| Name | application/leberre/ 2dimensionalstrippacking/E04F15.cnf |
| MD5SUM | 2f0f06d695c1977edc3fba0ba8753984 |
| Bench Category | APPLICATION (applications instances) |
| Best result obtained on this benchmark | UNSAT |
| Best CPU time to get the best result obtained on this benchmark | 496.525 |
| Satisfiable | |
| (Un)Satisfiability was proved | |
| Number of variables | 4740 |
| Number of clauses | 37893 |
| Sum of the clauses size | 149173 |
| Maximum clause length | 28 |
| Minimum clause length | 1 |
| Number of clauses of size 1 | 12 |
| Number of clauses of size 2 | 12041 |
| Number of clauses of size 3 | 8998 |
| Number of clauses of size 4 | 3795 |
| Number of clauses of size 5 | 5970 |
| Number of clauses of size over 5 | 7077 |
| Solver Name | TraceID | Answer | CPU time | Wall clock time |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MUSer 2011-02-10 (complete) | 3493735 | UNSAT | 496.525 | 496.512 |
| MoUsSaka 2011-03-26 (complete) | 3495755 | UNSAT | 869.833 | 869.794 |
| Haifa-MUC 2011-04-07 (complete) | 3494555 | ? (MO) | 1173.93 | 1173.94 |
| Haifa-MUC 2011-04-07 (complete) | 3494255 | ? (MO) | 1199.36 | 1199.33 |
| OptimuS p100_source (complete) | 3495155 | ? (TO) | 1800.03 | 1800.02 |
| OptimuS x100_source (complete) | 3495455 | ? (TO) | 1800.05 | 1800.01 |
| MiniUnsat2 2011-02-22 (complete) | 3493737 | ? (TO) | 1800.05 | 1800.01 |
| Haifa-MUC-A 2011-04-07 (complete) | 3493955 | ? (TO) | 1800.06 | 1800.21 |
| OptimuS a100_source (complete) | 3494855 | ? (TO) | 1800.07 | 1800.01 |
| PicoMUS 941 (complete) | 3493738 | No Cert. | 1800.06 | 1800.02 |
| SAT4J MUS 2.3.0-SNAPSHOT 2011-02-06 (complete) | 3493736 | No Cert. | 1800.14 | 1798.34 |
This section presents information obtained from the best job displayed in the list (i.e. solvers whose names are not hidden).
Solution found:12728 15894 3421 20446 10734 37064 2273 8970 3477 16590 1824 20430 10718 37048 3875 2257 9836 8954 3461 10269 1808 12696 164 20414 9820 15399 10253 1792 148 20398 10686 2225 9804 1776 10237 20382 10670 2209 9788 10221 1760 2193 9772 15600 16482 1744 10205 100 4221 2177 9756 1728 10189 84 2161 9740 15461 1712 10173 16869 68 2145 1696 3011 2129 9708 1680 10141 15848 9259 2113 9692 15662 16188 1664 9243 20 2979 2097 1648 9227 4 2963 2081 9660 1632 9211 11408 15693 2947 2065 16575 9644 16219 1616 9195 11392 2931 2049 9628 2482 15384 9179 11376 2915 2033 9612 11809 2466 11360 2899 2017 9596 11793 10911 2450 12456 2883 10462 2001 210 10895 12440 10446 1985 9564 2418 11312 10430 9548 2402 9099 12408 12178 11296 1953 11729 16498 2386 9083 12162 12392 11280 1937 10398 11713 2370 12146 9067 11264 10382 1921 11697 37876 2354 9933 16003 9051 15647 12130 10366 37860 2338 9917 9035 12114 1889 10350 11665 10783 2322 9901 13213 12098 15864 10334 1873 12761 15678 10767 2306 9003 1857 10318 20463 10751 2290 8987 11184 10302 1841 12729 20447 3422 37065 2274 11168 10286 16591 1825 12713 20431 37049 10719 2258 9837 8955 1809 20415 10703 9821 15400 3446 10254 1793 20399 2226 3788 10238 1777 20383 10671 2210 9789 1761 10222 2194 9773 15601 16483 10206 1745 15771 4222 2178 10190 1729 4207 2162 9741 15462 4140 16344 1713 10174 9292 2146 9725 1697 3012 2130 1681 9260 2114 9693 15663 1665 10126 16189 9244 2098 9677 1649 9228 2964 2082 9661 15880 1633 9212 11409 15694 2948 16576 2066 16220 9645 1617 9196 11393 2932 2050 9629 11826 2483 9180 2916 2034 11810 11361 2900 2018 9597 11794 2451 11345 2884 10463 2002 9581 15416 10896 12441 1986 10447 2419 9116 12425 11313 1970 10431 9549 2403 12409 9100 11297 10415 1954 9533 11730 16499 2387 15787 12393 12163 1938 11714 37893 2371 12147 12377 9068 11265 10383 1922 15478 11698 2355 16004 9934 12131 15648 9052 11249 10367 37861 2339 9918 9036 12115 1890 10351 10784 2323 9902 9020 12099 10335 1874 12762 10768 2307 13198 10319 1858 12746 20464 10752 2291 8988 3367 1842 10303 15896 20448 10736 37066 2275 8972 11169 1826 10287 12714 182 20432 3407 37050 2259 37781 9838 3463 10271 1810 12698 20416 10704 9822 3447 1794 20400 10688 2227 9806 1778 10239 134 20384 1606 2211 9790 10223 1762 118 2195 9774 15602 1746 102 2179 36239 9758 10191 1730 2163 15463 10175 1714 3313 2147 15803 9726 1698 10159 54 3013 2131 9710 1682 9261 38 2997 2115 16376 15664 1666 16190 9245 15834 22 2099 9678 1650 9229 6 2965 2083 9662 1634 9213 15695 2949 2067 16577 16221 9646 1618 9197 11394 2933 2051 9630 9181 11378 2917 2035 9614 11811 2901 2019 11795 10913 2452 11346 2885 10464 2003 9582 3229 12442 11330 10448 1987 9566 196 2420 12426 9117 11314 1971 2404 9101 12180 15448 11298 10416 16500 11731 2388 15788 12164 12394 11282 16314 10400 1939 11715 2372 12148 9069 1923 10384 11699 37878 2356 16005 9053 12132 15649 11250 1907 10368 11683 2340 9919 12116 10352 1891 10785 2324 9903 9021 1875 10336 15680 10769 2308 9005 15850 10320 1859 12747 20465 10753 2292 13183 3628 9871 3368 11186 10304 1843 12731 20449 10737 2276 8973 3353 16593 1827 15881 20433 10721 2260 9839 8957 11154 10272 1811 12699 20417 3392 2244 9823 10256 1795 10689 2228 9807 15386 1779 10240 20385 10673 1607 2212 9791 10224 1763 2196 15603 9775 10208 1747 2180 9759 1731 10192 9310 2164 9743 15464 1715 10176 2148 15804 16330 1699 3014 2132 9711 1683 9262 2998 2116 9695 15665 1667 16191 15835 9246 2100 1651 9230 2966 2084 9663 3314 1635 11411 2950 15696 2068 16578 9647 1619 9198 2934 2052 9631 9182 11379 2918 2036 9615 11812 11363 2902 2020 9599 11796 10914 2453 2886 2004 10465 10898 12443 11331 10449 1988 15402 9567 2421 12427 9118 11315 10433 1972 9551 2405 12411 9102 11299 11732 2389 15789 9086 12165 12395 16315 1940 10401 11716 2373 12149 9070 3230 11267 10385 1924 11700 37879 2357 9936 16006 9054 15650 1908 10369 2341 9920 12117 9038 10353 11668 2325 10786 32556 13216 9904 12101 10337 1876 10770 2309 9006 15851 1860 10321 20466 10754 2293 8990 11187 1844 10305 12732 20450 37068 2277 3354 11171 10289 16594 1828 12716 20434 3409 15882 10722 2261 9840 8958 1812 168 20418 3393 10706 2245 9824 10257 1796 12684 152 20402 2229 9808 15387 10241 1780 20386 10674 1608 2213 9792 1764 10225 2197 9776 15604 15774 1748 10209 2181 10193 1732 88 3047 2165 9744 15991 1716 10177 72 3031 2149 9728 15805 16331 1700 56 3015 2133 1684 2999 2117 9696 15666 1668 16192 9247 15836 24 16362 2101 9680 1652 9231 8 2967 2085 9664 1636 9215 11412 2951 15697 16579 2069 16223 9648 1620 9199 11396 2935 2053 9632 9183 11380 2919 2037 11813 11364 2903 2021 9600 11797 2454 11348 2887 10466 2005 9584 10899 2438 12444 10450 1989 10883 9119 12428 11316 10434 1973 9552 2406 11300 10418 1957 15976 9536 11733 2390 15790 9087 12396 12166 16316 1941 11717 2374 12150 12380 9071 11268 10386 11701 2358 12134 9055 15651 11252 10370 1909 37864 2342 9921 9039 12118 10354 10787 2326 9905 12102 9023 10338 1877 12765 11653 15682 2310 10771 13201 9889 15852 10322 1861 12749 20467 10755 2294 8991 32557 1845 10306 20451 10739 2278 8975 3355 11172 1829 10290 12717 20435 15883 37784 2262 9841 10274 1813 12701 20419 10707 2246 9825 1797 20403 10691 2230 9809 15388 1781 10242 20387 2214 9793 10226 1765 10659 2198 9777 15605 1749 2182 9761 1733 10194 3048 2166 10178 1717 15992 3032 2150 9729 15806 15450 16332 1701 16858 9280 2134 9713 1685 3000 2118 15667 1669 16193 9248 15837 2984 15481 16363 2102 9681 1653 9232 2968 2086 9665 1637 9216 2952 15698 16580 2070 9649 1621 9200 11397 2936 2054 9633 9184 11381 2920 2038 9617 11814 2904 2022 11798 10916 2455 11349 2888 10467 2006 9585 2439 10451 1990 15404 10884 2423 12429 9120 11317 1974 10435 2407 9104 12183 12413 11301 1958 10419 9537 11734 2391 15791 12167 12397 9088 15435 11285 16317 10403 11718 2375 12381 12151 9072 11702 2359 16008 9056 12135 15652 11253 10371 1910 11686 37865 2343 9922 12119 10355 10788 37849 2327 9906 9024 12103 10339 1878 10772 2311 9008 15853 10323 1862 12750 10756 2295 13186 11189 10307 1846 12734 20452 10740 2279 8976 1830 186 20436 15884 37054 10724 37785 2263 9842 8960 11157 1814 10275 12702 32558 170 20420 2247 9826 4088 10259 1798 20404 10692 2231 9810 15389 1782 10243 138 10676 2215 9794 10227 1766 122 2199 9778 15606 16488 10211 15776 1750 106 3065 2183 9762 1734 10195 3049 2167 9746 1718 10179 2151 15807 15451 16333 10163 1702 16859 2135 9714 1686 10147 42 3001 2119 9698 15668 1670 16194 9249 15838 26 2985 16364 2103 1654 9233 10 2969 2087 9666 1638 15699 2953 2071 16581 9650 16225 1622 9201 11398 2937 2055 9634 9185 2921 2039 9618 11815 11366 2905 2023 9602 11799 10917 2456 2889 10468 2007 11783 10901 2440 12446 11334 10452 1991 9570 200 2424 12430 11318 10436 1975 9554 2408 12414 9105 11302 1959 11735 16504 2392 15792 9089 12168 12398 15436 11286 16318 10404 11719 2376 12152 9073 11270 10388 1927 11703 2360 9057 15653 1911 10372 37866 2344 9923 9041 12120 1895 10356 11671 37850 10789 2328 9907 12104 10340 15684 10773 2312 15854 9009 1863 10324 20469 10757 2296 8993 10308 1847 12735 20453 2280 9859 11174 10292 1831 12719 15885 20437 10725 37055 2264 9843 8961 1815 20421 10709 37039 2248 9827 10260 1799 15576 12687 20405 2232 9811 15390 10244 1783 20389 10677 2216 32559 9795 1767 10228 2200 9779 15607 10212 1751 2184 9763 10196 1735 4089 2168 9747 1719 10180 9298 3034 2152 9731 15808 15452 16334 1703 10164 16860 2136 1687 3002 2120 9699 15669 1671 16195 9250 15839 2986 16365 2104 9683 1655 9234 2970 2088 9667 1639 9218 16056 11415 15700 2954 2072 16582 9651 1623 9202 11399 2938 2056 9635 9186 2922 4103 2040 11816 11367 2906 2024 9603 11800 11351 2890 2008 9587 11784 10902 2441 15592 12447 10453 1992 15406 10886 9122 12431 11319 10437 1976 3209 9555 2409 9106 11303 10421 9539 11736 2393 15793 9090 12399 15437 12169 16319 1944 11720 16489 2377 9074 12153 12383 11271 10389 1928 11704 2361 12137 15654 9058 11255 10373 1912 15468 37867 2345 15994 9924 9042 12121 1896 10357 10790 37851 2329 9908 9026 12105 10341 12768 11656 10774 2313 13204 15855 10325 1864 12752 20470 10758 2297 8994 1848 10309 20454 10742 2281 8978 11175 1832 10293 12720 15886 20438 37056 2265 9844 11159 10277 1816 12704 20422 10710 37040 2249 9828 3453 1800 156 20406 10694 2233 9812 15391 1784 10245 140 20390 2217 9796 10229 1768 20374 10662 2201 9780 15608 1752 15778 2185 9764 32560 16474 1736 10197 92 2169 10181 1720 76 2153 9732 15809 15453 16335 1704 16861 60 2137 9716 1688 3003 2121 15670 16196 1672 9251 15840 28 2987 16366 2105 9684 4090 1656 9235 12 2971 2089 9668 1640 15701 2955 2073 9652 1624 9203 11400 2939 2057 9636 4172 9187 11384 2923 2041 9620 11817 2907 2025 11801 10919 11352 2891 10470 2009 9588 2442 10454 1993 10887 12432 9123 11320 1977 10438 2410 9107 12186 12416 11304 10422 9540 15624 2394 15794 15438 12170 12400 11288 16320 1945 10406 11721 16490 2378 12384 12154 9075 1929 11705 2362 9059 12138 12368 4186 15655 11256 10374 1913 11689 37868 2346 3188 15995 9925 12122 9043 10358 1897 10791 37852 2330 9909 12106 9027 1881 10342 15686 10775 2314 9893 15856 9011 10326 1865 12753 20471 10759 2298 9877 13189 11192 10310 1849 12737 20455 10743 2282 8979 1833 15887 20439 10727 37057 2266 9845 8963 11160 3470 10278 1817 12705 20423 37041 2250 9829 3454 10262 1801 12689 20407 10695 2234 9813 15392 1785 10246 20391 10679 2218 9797 10230 1769 20375 2202 9781 1753 10214 2186 9765 16475 1737 10198 2170 9749 1721 10182 15640 2154 15810 15454 16336 1705 10166 32561 16862 2138 9717 1689 3004 2122 9701 1673 15841 9252 2988 16367 2106 1657 9236 2972 2090 1641 15702 2956 2074 16584 9653 1625 9204 2940 2058 9637 9188 11385 2924 2042 9621 11818 11369 2908 2026 9605 11802 10920 2892 10471 2010 11786 10904 2443 12449 11337 10455 1994 15408 9573 12433 3271 11321 10439 1978 9557 1609 4173 2411 9108 11305 35317 2395 15795 9092 12401 15439 12171 11289 16321 10407 1946 16491 11722 2379 12155 9076 11273 10391 1930 11706 2363 9060 15656 1914 10375 15470 37869 9926 15996 9044 12123 10359 1898 4105 11674 37853 9910 12107 10343 1882 10776 2315 9894 15857 9012 1866 10327 33860 10760 2299 8996 11193 1850 10311 12738 20456 2283 11177 10295 1834 16600 12722 190 15888 20440 10728 37058 2267 9846 8964 1818 174 20424 3399 37042 10712 2251 9830 8948 3455 10263 1802 12690 20408 2235 15393 9814 10247 1786 20392 10680 2219 9798 3306 1770 10231 126 20376 2203 9782 10215 1754 15780 110 2187 36247 15594 9766 10199 1738 2171 9750 1722 10183 2155 9734 15811 15455 16337 1706 10167 16863 2139 1690 46 2123 9702 15672 1674 10135 15842 9253 30 32562 2989 16368 2107 9686 1658 9237 14 2973 2091 1642 9221 11418 2957 2075 9654 1626 9205 11402 2941 2059 9638 1610 9189 11386 2925 2043 11819 9173 11370 2909 2027 9606 11803 11354 2893 2011 9590 11787 10905 2444 12450 10456 1995 204 10889 9125 12434 10440 1979 9558 2412 11306 10424 1963 9542 16152 2396 15796 3333 9093 12402 15440 12172 16322 1947 11723 16492 2380 9077 12386 12156 11274 10392 1931 35318 11707 2364 12140 9061 11258 10376 37870 2348 9927 15997 9045 12124 1899 10360 37854 2332 9911 12108 9029 1883 12771 11659 10777 2316 13207 9895 15858 10328 1867 12755 20473 10761 2300 8997 1851 10312 20457 10745 2284 8981 11178 1835 10296 12723 15889 20441 3416 37059 2268 11162 3472 10280 1819 12707 20425 3400 10713 37043 2252 9831 8949 1803 20409 10697 2236 9815 15394 1787 10248 20393 2220 9799 4188 10232 1771 20377 10665 2204 9783 1755 10216 2188 9767 15595 16477 1739 10200 2172 10184 1723 2156 15812 9735 15456 16338 1707 16864 9286 3022 2140 9719 1691 2124 1675 9254 15843 2990 2108 16369 9687 3160 1659 9238 2974 2092 9671 1643 9222 15704 2958 2076 32563 9655 1627 9206 11403 2942 2060 9639 1611 9190 11387 2926 2044 9623 11820 9174 2910 2028 11804 10922 2461 11355 2894 10473 2012 9591 11788 2445 11339 10457 1996 15410 10890 12435 9126 11323 1980 4053 10441 2413 9110 12419 11307 10425 9543 2397 15797 3334 12173 12403 9094 15441 16323 10409 1948 11724 16493 2381 12157 12387 9078 1932 11708 2365 9062 12141 12371 11259 10377 16184 15472 37871 2349 15998 9928 12125 9046 15642 11243 10361 1900 37855 9912 35319 9030 1884 10778 2317 9896 9014 15859 10329 1868 12756 20474 2301 10762 13192 11195 10313 1852 12740 20458 2285 10746 8982 1836 3295 192 20442 15890 10730 37060 2269 8966 11163 1820 10281 12708 20426 3401 37044 2253 9832 10265 1804 12692 160 20410 10698 2237 9816 15395 1788 10249 144 20394 10682 2221 9800 10233 1772 20378 2205 9784 10217 1756 15782 2189 9768 15596 16478 1740 10201 96 3055 2173 9752 1724 10185 3039 80 2157 15813 15457 16339 10169 1708 16865 64 3023 2141 9720 1692 10153 2125 9704 1676 16200 9255 15844 2991 16370 2109 15658 1660 9239 16 2975 2093 1644 9223 2959 2077 9656 1628 9207 11404 2943 15689 2061 9640 1612 9191 11388 2927 2045 32564 11372 2911 2029 9608 11805 10923 2462 2895 10474 2013 11789 10907 12452 11340 10458 1997 9576 206 11324 10442 1981 9560 2414 12420 9111 11308 2398 15798 9095 12404 12174 15442 11292 16324 10410 16494 11725 2382 12158 12388 9079 11276 10394 1933 11709 2366 9063 10378 11693 37872 2350 9929 15999 9047 12126 15643 11244 10362 1901 11677 37856 9913 12110 10346 1885 10779 2318 9897 16216 9015 15860 1869 10330 10763 2302 8999 4136 10314 1853 12741 20459 10747 2286 9865 11180 1837 10298 12725 20443 3418 15891 10731 37061 2270 8967 1821 20427 10715 37045 2254 9833 8951 10266 1805 12693 20411 2238 9817 15396 10250 1789 20395 10683 2222 1773 10234 20379 2206 9785 10218 1757 2190 9769 15597 16479 10202 1741 2174 9753 1725 10186 9304 3040 2158 9737 15814 16696 15458 16340 1709 10170 16866 3024 2142 1693 2126 9705 1677 9256 15845 2992 16371 2110 9689 15659 1661 9240 2976 2094 1645 9224 11421 2960 2078 9657 16232 1629 9208 15690 2944 11405 2062 9641 2495 1613 9192 2928 11389 2046 9176 2912 2030 9609 11806 2463 11357 2896 2014 9593 11790 10908 12453 32565 2880 10459 1998 15412 10892 12437 10443 1982 9561 2415 9112 11309 10427 1966 9545 2399 9096 12175 12405 15443 16325 11726 16495 2383 9080 12159 12389 11277 10395 11710 2367 12143 9064 11261 10379 1918 11694 16712 15474 37873 2351 9930 16000 12127 9048 15644 1902 10363 37857 2335 9914 9032 12111 10347 1886 11662 10780 2319 13210 9898 15861 10331 1870 12758 20476 10764 2303 9000 4137 1854 10315 20460 10748 2287 8984 3363 11181 10299 1838 12726 15892 20444 37062 2271 11165 3475 10283 1822 12710 178 20428 10716 37046 37777 2255 9834 8952 1806 20412 10700 2239 9818 15397 1790 10251 20396 2223 9802 10235 1774 130 20380 10668 2207 9786 1758 10219 114 2191 9770 15598 16480 1742 10203 3250 4219 2175 10187 1726 3041 2159 9738 15459 16341 1710 10171 16867 3025 2143 9722 1694 3009 50 2127 1678 9257 15846 34 2111 16372 9690 15660 1662 9241 18 2977 2095 9674 1646 9225 2 2961 2079 9658 1630 9209 11406 15691 2945 2063 9642 16217 2496 1614 9193 11390 2929 2047 9626 11823 2480 9177 2913 2031 11807 10925 2464 11358 2897 10476 2015 9594 11791 11342 2881 10460 1999 9578 10893 12438 1983 10444 2416 12422 9113 11310 10428 32566 9546 2400 15800 12176 12406 15444 11294 16326 10412 11727 16496 2384 12390 9081 12160 11711 2368 9065 12144 12374 11262 10380 1919 37874 2352 16001 9931 12128 9049 15645 11246 10364 1903 37858 2336 9915 9033 12112 1887 10348 10781 2320 9899 15862 9017 10332 1871 12759 15676 20477 10765 2304 13195 9883 4138 10316 1855 12743 20461 10749 2288 8985 1839 15893 20445 37063 10733 2272 8969 11166 3476 16589 1823 10284 12711 20429 37047 3874 2256 9835 10268 1807 12695 2240 9819 15398 1791 20397 10685 2224 9803 10236 1775 20381 2208 9787 10220 1759 2192 3561 9771 15599 16481 1743 10204 4220 2176 9755 1727 10188 3042 2160 15816 15460 16342 10172 1711 16868 2144 9723 1695 9274 3010 2128 9707 1679 9258 15847 2112 15661 16187 1663 9242 2978 2096 9675 1647 9226 2962 2080 9659 1631 9210 15692 2946 2064 9643 1615 9194 11391 2930 2048 9627 2481 11375 2914 2032 9611 11808 10926 2465 2898 2016 11792 10910 12455 11343 2882 10461 2000 9579 12439 11327 10445 1984 9563 2417 12423 9114 11311 2401 9098 12177 15445 11295 1952 10413 16497 11728 2385 12161 9082 12391 11279 10397 11712 32567 3954 2369 9066 12145 1920 10381 15832 11696 15476 37875 2353 16002 9050 15646 12129 11247 10365 11680 37859 2337 9916 12113 10349 1888 10782 2321 9900 9018 10333 1872 10766 2305 9002 10317 1856 12744 20462 2289 3365 4124 11183 1840 10301 15368 0