PB'26 competition: search progress per solver
Quality of the solution as a function of time for solver OR-Tools CP-SAT (16 cores)
2026-05-18
(complete)
1
2
3
4
5
6
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f3-DataDisplay_1_order6.seq-B-2-1-irEDCBA.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f37-AC_TotalLoss.seq-B-2-1-irabcde.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f32-AC_DoubleLoss.seq-A-3-combined-abcdeir.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f44-DC_ESS.seq-B-2-combined-irabcde.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB16/DEC-LIN/quimper/SyncCodes/
d-equals-n_k/normalized-compression32_18.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB16/DEC-LIN/quimper/SyncCodes/
d-equals-n_k/normalized-compression64_26.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB16/DEC-LIN/quimper/SyncCodes/
d-equals-n_k/normalized-compression64_23.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB16/DEC-LIN/quimper/SyncCodes/
d-equals-n_k/normalized-compression32_15.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/DEC-LIN/nordstrom/MIPLIB01/
dec/miplib3/normalized-stein27.0.s.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/DEC-LIN/nordstrom/CombinatorialBenchmarksPBsolvers/
php-missinghole/normalized-php_missinghole_450_449.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/DEC-LIN/nordstrom/CombinatorialBenchmarksPBsolvers/
php-missinghole-random/normalized-php_missinghole_random_390_389.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/DEC-LIN/nordstrom/CombinatorialBenchmarksPBsolvers/domset/
domset_large_fixedcols_final/normalized-domset-hexgrid-fixedcols_04_036.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/DEC-LIN/nordstrom/
CombinatorialBenchmarksPBsolvers/domset/domset-fixedrows-r08-tiling/normalized-domset-hexgrid_08_052.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/DEC-LIN/nordstrom/CombinatorialBenchmarksPBsolvers/domset/
domset-fixedrows-r06_shuffle/normalized-domset-hexgrid_06_064.shuf-3.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=10-t=10.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=11-t=4.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=8-t=2.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=10-t=2.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=11-t=8.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=13-t=7.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=10-t=7.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=14-t=2.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/KNAP/
subset_sum/normalized-knapPI_6_2000_1000_4_-39215.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/KNAP/uncorrelated/
normalized-knapPI_1_10000_10000_4_-11456508.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
linear/normalized-evencolouring_opt_linear_random6regular_nvert_041.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
linear/normalized-evencolouring_opt_linear_random6regular_nvert_081.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
linear/normalized-evencolouring_opt_linear_random6regular_nvert_801.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
linear/normalized-evencolouring_opt_linear_random6regular_nvert_061.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_901.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_951.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_851.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_251.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
comppebvc/normalized-comppebvc_opt_120.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
comppebvc/normalized-comppebvc_opt_200.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
comppebvc/normalized-comppebvc_opt_195.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid/
normalized-composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid_height18_pigeons17_holes16.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid/
normalized-composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid_height22_pigeons21_holes20.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_4layers_maxall_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_4layers_maxall_lastlayerdecr1_size_22.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_4layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_4layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1_size_05.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_4layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdiv2/
normalized-injcomp_opt_4layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdiv2_size_65.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_3layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_3layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1_size_75.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_3layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_3layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1_size_95.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_3layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_3layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1_size_04.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_3layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_3layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1_size_05.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_3layers_maxall_lastlayerdiv2/
normalized-injcomp_opt_3layers_maxall_lastlayerdiv2_size_20.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
dominating_set/normalized-dominating_set_hexgrid_opt_r8_c50.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
dominating_set/normalized-dominating_set_hexgrid_opt_r8_c10.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
dominating_set/normalized-dominating_set_hexgrid_opt_r8_c90.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
dominating_set/normalized-dominating_set_hexgrid_opt_r10_c90.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
dominating_set/normalized-dominating_set_hexgrid_opt_r6_c40.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_380.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_490.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_170.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_420.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
dominating_set/normalized-dominating_set_hexgrid_opt_r6_c60.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_block/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_block_nvert_50.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_block/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_block_nvert_17.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_block/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_block_nvert_18.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_block/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_block_nvert_78.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_inlv_nvert_54.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv_nvert_57.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv_nvert_90.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv_nvert_85.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv_nvert_45.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/vertex_cover/vertexcover_opt_grid_evenrowevencolsquare/
normalized-vertexcover_opt_grid_evenrowevencolsquare_dim_100.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/vertex_cover/
vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowoddcolsquare/normalized-vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowoddcolsquare_dim_121.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/vertex_cover/
vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowoddcolsquare/normalized-vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowoddcolsquare_dim_057.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/vertex_cover/
vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowoddcolsquare/normalized-vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowoddcolsquare_dim_033.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/vertex_cover/
vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowevencolsquare/normalized-vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowevencolsquare_dim_064.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/vertex_cover/
vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowevencolsquare/normalized-vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowevencolsquare_dim_090.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/vertex_cover/
vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowevencolsquare/normalized-vertexcover_opt_grid_oddrowevencolsquare_dim_080.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/vertex_cover/
vertexcover_opt_grid_evenrowoddcolsquare/normalized-vertexcover_opt_grid_evenrowoddcolsquare_dim_150.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/vertex_cover/
vertexcover_opt_grid_evenrowoddcolsquare/normalized-vertexcover_opt_grid_evenrowoddcolsquare_dim_064.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/comppebphp_pyrheight_equals_nholes/
normalized-comppebphp_opt_pyrheightequalsnholes_39.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/comppebphp_pyrheight_equals_nholes/
normalized-comppebphp_opt_pyrheightequalsnholes_38.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/comppebphp_pyrheight_equals_nholes/
normalized-comppebphp_opt_pyrheightequalsnholes_13.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/comppebphp_pyrheight_equals_nholes/
normalized-comppebphp_opt_pyrheightequalsnholes_55.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/comppebphp_pyrheight_equals_nholes/
normalized-comppebphp_opt_pyrheightequalsnholes_50.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/
MIPLIB01/opt/miplib3/normalized-nw04.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/MIPLIB01/
opt/miplib2017/normalized-supportcase22.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/MIPLIB01/
opt/miplib2017/normalized-neos-780889.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/
MIPLIB01/opt/miplib2017/normalized-scpn2.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/MIPLIB01/
opt/miplib2010/normalized-ex1010-pi.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/
MIPLIB01/opt/miplib2010/normalized-bab1.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/MIPLIB01/
opt/miplib2010/normalized-neos-506428.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/MIPLIB01/
opt/miplib2010/normalized-eilA101-2.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/
StableMatchings/SMTI/SMTI_PBO/SMTI_50000_5_0.75_7.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/
StableMatchings/SMTI/SMTI_PBO/SMTI_10000_3_0.95_7.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/
StableMatchings/SMTI/x1/Init-x1-i4_pp_95_merged.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/
StableMatchings/SMTI/x1/Init-x1-i6_pp_93_merged.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/
StableMatchings/SMTI/x1/Init-x1-i5_pp_97_merged.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/
StableMatchings/SMTI/x1/Init-x1-i8_pp_96_merged.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/
StableMatchings/SMTI/x1/Init-x1-i6_pp_88_merged.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/StableMatchings/
KidneyTransplantBenchmarks/normalized-KE_390_005.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/StableMatchings/
KidneyTransplantBenchmarks/normalized-KE_710_002.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/StableMatchings/
KidneyTransplantBenchmarks/normalized-KE_260_002.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/StableMatchings/
KidneyTransplantBenchmarks/normalized-KE_430_001.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/StableMatchings/
KidneyTransplantBenchmarks/normalized-Generated_notes_20140709_1000_0.01-000.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/StableMatchings/
KidneyTransplantBenchmarks/normalized-KE_430_008.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/pettersson/StableMatchings/
KidneyTransplantBenchmarks/normalized-KE_690_000.opb
Download the above graph
as a PDF file
1
2
3
4
5
6
1 2 3 4 5 6
1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6