PB'25 competition: search progress per solver

Quality of the solution as a function of time for solver OR-Tools CP-SAT 9.14 (complete)


1 2 3 4 5

PB24/normalized-PB12/OPT-LIN/graca/
normalized-ped3.G.recomb10-0.01-4.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB12/OPT-LIN/graca/
normalized-ped2.G.recomb1-0.01-5.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
EmployeeScheduling/normalized-aug5.5.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
EmployeeScheduling/normalized-sep5.5.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
EmployeeScheduling/normalized-oct6.5.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
EmployeeScheduling/normalized-may6.5.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
EmployeeScheduling/normalized-jul6.5.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
EmployeeScheduling/normalized-jun5.5.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
EmployeeScheduling/normalized-aug6.5.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
EmployeeScheduling/normalized-oct5.5.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
EmployeeScheduling/normalized-jun6.5.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/opb/normalized-faclay70.lin.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-sporttournament18.lin.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/
minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/opb/normalized-faclay75.lin.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-sporttournament26.lin.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-autocorr_bern60-15.lin.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-autocorr_bern60-45.lin.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-graphpart_2pm-0055-0055.lin.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-edgecross14-019.lin.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-graphpart_2pm-0088-0888.lin.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-graphpart_clique-40.lin.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/pbfvmc-formulae/
hw128/normalized-hw128-vm50p-opt.opb.negationfix.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/pbfvmc-formulae/
hw128/normalized-hw128-vm90p-opt.opb.negationfix.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/pbfvmc-formulae/
hw128/normalized-hw128-vm98p-opt.opb.negationfix.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/pbfvmc-formulae/
hw64/normalized-hw64-vm85p-opt.opb.negationfix.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/pbfvmc-formulae/
hw32/normalized-hw32-vm85p-opt.opb.negationfix.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/pbfvmc-formulae/
hw32/normalized-hw32-vm90p-opt.opb.negationfix.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/pbfvmc-formulae/
hw32/normalized-hw32-vm50p-opt.opb.negationfix.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-LIN/pbfvmc-formulae/
hw32/normalized-hw32-vm25p-opt.opb.negationfix.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-NLC/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-edgecross20-080.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-NLC/
minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/opb/normalized-faclay60.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-NLC/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-autocorr_bern45-23.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-NLC/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-sporttournament28.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-NLC/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-autocorr_bern30-08.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-NLC/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-edgecross10-070.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-NLC/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-edgecross14-176.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-NLC/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-graphpart_clique-40.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB15eval/OPT-NLC/minlplib2-pb-0.1.0/
opb/normalized-graphpart_3g-0344-0344.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f58-fob_fxl_loss.seq-A-3-1-irEDCBA.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f12-ACDoubleLoss.seq-B-3-combined-EDCBAir.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f4-DataDisplay_2_order9.seq-A-3-2-irabcde.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f17-DCdoubleLoss.seq-B-2-2-irEDCBA.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f50-DC_side2.seq-B-3-1-EDCBAir.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f47-DC_Side1.seq-B-2-2-irabcde.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f3-DataDisplay_1_order6.seq-B-2-2-irabcde.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f53-AC_FC1.seq-A-2-1-EDCBAir.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f37-AC_TotalLoss.seq-B-2-2-abcdeir.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB16/OPT-LIN/lion9-single-obj/
normalized-single-obj-f13-ACDoubleLoss.seq-B-2-2-irEDCBA.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=13-t=8.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=18-t=2.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=10-t=9.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=11-t=8.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=10-t=3.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=13-t=7.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=8-t=3.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=7-t=3.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/ihalainen/PBO-clique-coloring/
normalized-clique-coloring-max-clique-n=14-t=2.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/KNAP/strongly_correlated/
normalized-knapPI_3_5000_1000_4_-199683.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/KNAP/uncorrelated_span/
normalized-knapPI_11_1000_1000_5_-23276.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/KNAP/profit_ceiling/
normalized-knapPI_15_2000_1000_5_-50838.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/KNAP/multiple_strongly_correlated/
normalized-knapPI_14_10000_1000_2_-407357.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
linear/normalized-evencolouring_opt_linear_random6regular_nvert_071.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
linear/normalized-evencolouring_opt_linear_random6regular_nvert_101.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_031.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_091.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_111.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_401.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_501.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_451.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/evencolouring/
unit/normalized-evencolouring_opt_unit_random6regular_nvert_351.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
comppebvc/normalized-comppebvc_opt_75.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid/
normalized-composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid_height16_pigeons15_holes14.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid/
normalized-composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid_height37_pigeons36_holes35.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid/
normalized-composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid_height30_pigeons29_holes28.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid/
normalized-composed_pebbling_php_opt_pyramid_height13_pigeons12_holes11.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_4layers_maxall_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_4layers_maxall_lastlayerdecr1_size_26.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_4layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_4layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdecr1_size_30.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_4layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdiv2/
normalized-injcomp_opt_4layers_maxfirst_lastlayerdiv2_size_32.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_3layers_maxall_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_3layers_maxall_lastlayerdecr1_size_12.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_3layers_maxall_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_3layers_maxall_lastlayerdecr1_size_75.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/injcomp/injcomp_opt_3layers_maxall_lastlayerdecr1/
normalized-injcomp_opt_3layers_maxall_lastlayerdecr1_size_29.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
dominating_set/normalized-dominating_set_hexgrid_opt_r6_c80.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
dominating_set/normalized-dominating_set_hexgrid_opt_r6_c50.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_550.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_380.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_430.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_400.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_290.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_160.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/dominating_set/
hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5/normalized-domset_opt_hexgrid_nrowsdiv30add5_ncols_390.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/
dominating_set/normalized-dominating_set_hexgrid_opt_r6_c60.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_block/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_block_nvert_47.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_block/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_block_nvert_90.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_block/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_block_nvert_12.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_inlv_nvert_87.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_inlv_nvert_69.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_inlv_nvert_18.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_6-partite_inlv_nvert_84.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv_nvert_50.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file
PB24/normalized-PB24/OPT-LIN/nordstrom/CoreGuidedPB/maxcut/maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv/
normalized-maxcut_opt_complete_5-partite_inlv_nvert_20.opb


Download the above graph as a PDF file / as an EPS file

1 2 3 4 5