MAX-CSP 2008 Competition: results by benchmark

Results by benchmark for category n-ary constraints in intension (N-ARY-INT)

This page displays the results of the different solvers for each benchmark for category n-ary constraints in intension (N-ARY-INT)

REMINDER

Keep in mind that the 'Best result' columns only provide the best result given by one of the solvers. This 'Best result' may be wrong in case of an UNSATISFIABLE or OPTIMUM FOUND answer (because there's no efficient way to check these answers).

Description of a cell contents:

Cell example	Meaning
Answer	Solver result
f=...	value of the objective function for the model reported by the solver
TT=...	Total Time (TT): this is the CPU time (in seconds) used by the solver until termination. This time is only meaningful for complete solvers because incomplete solvers will always run until they time out
T1=...	Time to get the best model (T1): this is the wall clock time (in seconds) ellapsed when the solver found its best model. This time is obtained from the 'o lines'. It is useful to compare both complete and incomplete solvers. It doesn't take into account the time to prove optimality of the solution.

Remember that CPU time and wall clock time are two very different notions. The CPU time represents the time during which the instructions of the solver were executed by the processor. The wall clock time represents how much time ellapsed on the clock. For a same event, the CPU time may be either smaller or greater than the wall clock time depending on the number of threads of execution and the number of processors.

Meaning of some abbreviations:

Abbreviation	Meaning
f=...	Value of the objective function
TO	Time Out
MO	Mem. Out (out of memory)

Meaning of the different colors:

Color	Meaning
text	the solver cannot handle this instance
text	the solver gave no answer
text	the solver could give an answer (SAT)
text	the solver gave a definitive answer (OPTIMUM FOUND or UNSAT)
text	the solver performed better than the other ones on that instance
text	the solver was ended by a signal
text	the solver gave an incomplete answer
text	the solver was disqualified in the category
text	the solver gave a wrong answer

For better readability, you may choose to hide some solvers:
AbsconMax 112 pc-d
AbsconMax 112 pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30
Sugar v1.13+minisat
Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc

Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/bmc/ normalized-bmc-ibm-07-08.xml	MSAT TO f=2 TT=3600.08	? TT=465.348	? TT=440.593	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=123 TT=3600.02	? TT=514.729	? TT=509.37
csp/bmc/ normalized-bmc-ibm-07-16.xml	MSAT TO f=16 TT=3600.09	? TT=1323.81	? TT=1300.47	MSAT (TO) f=16 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=116 TT=3600.07	? TT=534.6	? TT=538.343
csp/chessboardColoration/ normalized-cc-12-12-2.xml	MSAT TO f=324 TT=3600.03 T1=25.87	MSAT (TO) f=324 TT=3600.15 T1=26.31	MSAT (TO) f=324 TT=3600.15 T1=25.87	MSAT (TO) f=324 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=326 TT=3600.06	? (MO) TT=59.771	? (MO) TT=58.01
csp/chessboardColoration/ normalized-cc-15-15-2.xml	MSAT TO f=945 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=956 TT=3600.12 T1=64.86	MSAT (TO) f=956 TT=3600.17 T1=63.67	MSAT (TO) f=950 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=945 TT=3600.06	? TT=180.523	? TT=181.771
csp/chessboardColoration/ normalized-cc-20-20-2.xml	MSAT TO f=3426 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=3518 TT=3600.37 T1=20.09	MSAT (TO) f=3518 TT=3600.31 T1=19.88	MSAT (TO) f=3464 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=3426 TT=3600.06	? TT=416.362	? TT=394.729
csp/chessboardColoration/ normalized-cc-5-5-2.xml	MOPT f=2 TT=3.473 T1=0.65	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=35.128 T1=0.65 CHECKS=2196670 NODES=41776	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=36.112 T1=0.88 CHECKS=1931990 NODES=32758	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.07	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.03	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=3.473 T1=3.32	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=3.522 T1=3.36
csp/chessboardColoration/ normalized-cc-6-6-2.xml	MOPT f=6 TT=1370.42 T1=0.81	OPTIMUM f=6 TT=1436.93 T1=0.81 CHECKS=827750000 NODES=7834780	OPTIMUM f=6 TT=1370.42 T1=0.87 CHECKS=608246000 NODES=6646180	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.07 T1=2.79	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.05 T1=1415.75
csp/chessboardColoration/ normalized-cc-7-7-2.xml	MSAT TO f=21 TT=3600.02 T1=0.97	MSAT (TO) f=21 TT=3600.11 T1=0.99	MSAT (TO) f=21 TT=3600.05 T1=0.97	MSAT (TO) f=21 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=21 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=22 TT=3600.07 T1=20.8	MSAT (TO) f=25 TT=3600.11 T1=3.8
csp/chessboardColoration/ normalized-cc-8-8-2.xml	MSAT TO f=40 TT=3600 T1=1.19	MSAT (TO) f=40 TT=3600.11 T1=1.19	MSAT (TO) f=40 TT=3600.05 T1=1.28	MSAT (TO) f=40 TT=3600.07	MSAT (TO) f=40 TT=3600	MSAT (TO) f=64 TT=3600.06 T1=12.22	MSAT (TO) f=64 TT=3600.15 T1=10.03
csp/chessboardColoration/ normalized-cc-9-9-2.xml	MSAT TO f=80 TT=3600.05 T1=1.58	MSAT (TO) f=80 TT=3600.16 T1=1.66	MSAT (TO) f=80 TT=3600.09 T1=1.58	MSAT (TO) f=80 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=80 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=92 TT=3600.09 T1=44.55	MSAT (TO) f=92 TT=3600.17 T1=88.79
Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-10-3-fair.xml		? TT=5.129	? TT=4.997	? (TO) TT=15.07	? (TO) TT=14.98	? TT=142.722	? TT=142.236
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-10-4-fair.xml		? TT=4.079	? TT=4.341	? (TO) TT=20.88	? (TO) TT=23.19	? TT=144.915	? TT=138.697
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-1-3-fair.xml		? TT=3469.03	? TT=3471.1	? (TO) TT=134.11	? (TO) TT=137.63	? (MO) TT=111.033	? (MO) TT=112.94
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-3-7-fair.xml		? TT=4.037	? TT=3.79	? (TO) TT=10.41	? (TO) TT=10.21	? TT=142.863	? TT=143.744
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-4-3-fair.xml		? TT=3.893	? TT=5.186	? (TO) TT=8.05	? (TO) TT=8.15	? TT=164.614	? TT=157.665
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-4-5-fair.xml		? TT=4.098	? TT=3.792	? (TO) TT=9.87	? (TO) TT=10.25	? TT=143.337	? TT=138.135
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-4-7-fair.xml		? TT=3.79	? TT=3.809	? (TO) TT=13.17	? (TO) TT=13.71	? TT=141.307	? TT=141.053
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-5-7-fair.xml		? TT=4.05	? TT=3.872	? (TO) TT=18.41	? (TO) TT=16.28	? TT=143.94	? TT=134.202
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-6-4-fair.xml		? TT=3.866	? TT=3.868	? (TO) TT=11	? (TO) TT=10.92	? TT=134.623	? TT=144.436
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-6-5-fair.xml		? TT=4.072	? TT=4.167	? (TO) TT=14.35	? (TO) TT=15	? TT=145.527	? TT=141.014
Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-6-7-fair.xml		? TT=4.079	? TT=3.979	? (TO) TT=22.95	? (TO) TT=23.06	? TT=145.03	? TT=140.21
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-7-3-fair.xml		? TT=3.869	? TT=3.893	? (TO) TT=10.05	? (TO) TT=9.15	? TT=145.464	? TT=143.589
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-7-4-fair.xml		? TT=5.239	? TT=5.144	? (TO) TT=14.01	? (TO) TT=13.59	? TT=142.51	? TT=144.78
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-8-3-fair.xml		? TT=3.833	? TT=3.877	? (TO) TT=11.77	? (TO) TT=11.88	? TT=140.14	? TT=136.949
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-9-2-fair.xml		? TT=3.934	? TT=3.759	? (TO) TT=8.66	? (TO) TT=10.21	? TT=144.328	? TT=143.959
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-9-4-fair.xml		? TT=3.932	? TT=3.972	? (TO) TT=19.02	? (TO) TT=18.87	? TT=145.638	? TT=144.662
csp/fischer/ normalized-fischer-9-6-fair.xml		? TT=4.499	? TT=4.469	? (TO) TT=39.69	? (TO) TT=37.75	? TT=144.676	? TT=136.22
csp/golombRulerArity3/ normalized-ruler-17-7-a3.xml	MOPT f=4 TT=509.547 T1=12.18	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=1609.41 T1=13.45	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=1635.34 T1=12.18	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.04	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.04	OPTIMUM f=4 TT=558.362 T1=558.18	OPTIMUM f=4 TT=509.547 T1=509.31
csp/golombRulerArity3/ normalized-ruler-25-8-a3.xml	MSAT TO f=4 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=1612.25 T1=1.07	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=1612.65 T1=0.99	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=8 TT=3600.06 T1=15.26	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.15 T1=950.98
csp/golombRulerArity3/ normalized-ruler-34-9-a3.xml	MSAT TO f=5 TT=3600.04	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=1651.28 T1=47.83	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=3600.19 T1=47.14	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.04	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=3600.07	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.03 T1=42.05	MSAT (TO) f=8 TT=3600.1 T1=12.66
Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/golombRulerArity3/ normalized-ruler-44-10-a3.xml	MSAT TO f=7 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=16 TT=1618.56 T1=22.59	MSAT (TO) f=16 TT=1686.13 T1=24.38	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.07	MSAT (TO) f=12 TT=3600.04 T1=49.82	MSAT (TO) f=8 TT=3600.12 T1=2298.9
csp/golombRulerArity3/ normalized-ruler-55-11-a3.xml	MSAT TO f=10 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=22 TT=1639.35 T1=2.78	MSAT (TO) f=22 TT=1664.95 T1=2.86	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=13 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=11 TT=3600.03 T1=604.35	MSAT (TO) f=18 TT=3600.18 T1=45.41
csp/golombRulerArity3/ normalized-ruler-67-12-a3.xml	MSAT TO f=14 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=18 TT=1643.07 T1=32.96	MSAT (TO) f=18 TT=1717.68 T1=30.48	MSAT (TO) f=14 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=18 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=18 TT=3600.15 T1=236.37	MSAT (TO) f=18 TT=3600.25 T1=89.63
csp/golombRulerArity3/ normalized-ruler-70-12-a3.xml	MSAT TO f=12 TT=3600.02 T1=2449.68	MSAT (TO) f=18 TT=1649.2 T1=14.42	MSAT (TO) f=18 TT=1780.05 T1=14.43	MSAT (TO) f=12 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=19 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=15 TT=3600.04 T1=713.13	MSAT (TO) f=12 TT=3600.16 T1=2449.68
csp/golombRulerArity3/ normalized-ruler-70-13-a3.xml	MSAT TO f=20 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=35 TT=1636.79 T1=6.12	MSAT (TO) f=35 TT=3600.21 T1=6.11	MSAT (TO) f=20 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=29 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=68 TT=3600.16 T1=181.08	MSAT (TO) f=73 TT=3600.27 T1=45.2
csp/golombRulerArity4/ normalized-ruler-17-7-a4.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=4.38 T1=0.88	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=35.719 T1=0.88 CHECKS=1522680 NODES=685	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=36.049 T1=0.88 CHECKS=1450640 NODES=1076	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.07	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=8.283 T1=6.74	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=4.38 T1=3.4
csp/golombRulerArity4/ normalized-ruler-25-8-a4.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=49.373 T1=1.69	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=99.693 T1=1.97 CHECKS=29180700 NODES=6624	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=94.235 T1=1.69 CHECKS=24144500 NODES=12055	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.05	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=51.314 T1=24.94	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=49.373 T1=19.57
csp/golombRulerArity4/ normalized-ruler-34-9-a4.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=415.382 T1=17.23	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=940.248 T1=17.23 CHECKS=441224000 NODES=57372	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=415.382 T1=17.32 CHECKS=146505000 NODES=35447	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.04	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=462.626 T1=147.46	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=490.947 T1=61.93
csp/golombRulerArity4/ normalized-ruler-44-10-a4.xml	MSAT TO f=1 TT=3600.07 T1=784.05	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=2334.41 T1=7.03	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=2291.2 T1=7.12	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.07	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.17 T1=1405.2	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.28 T1=784.05
csp/golombRulerArity4/ normalized-ruler-55-11-a4.xml	MSAT TO f=1 TT=3600	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=2279.25 T1=6.64	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=2359.87 T1=6.05	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600	? (MO) TT=62.436	? (MO) TT=64.967
Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/lexHerald/ normalized-crossword-m1-lex-15-04.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=1983.58 T1=1584.93	MSAT (TO) f=11 TT=3600.08 T1=152.12	MSAT (TO) f=11 TT=3600.07 T1=165.16	MSAT (TO) f=8 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=42 TT=3600.03	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2453.22 T1=1866.93	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=1983.58 T1=1584.93
csp/nengfa/ normalized-block.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=32.103 T1=31.23	? TT=45.31	? TT=44.332	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=31 TT=3600.01	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=105.323 T1=94.72	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=32.103 T1=31.23
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-10-11.xml	MOPT f=2 TT=340.209 T1=1.33	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.12 T1=2.44	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.06 T1=2.66	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=15 TT=3600.03	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=409.95 T1=1.33	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=340.209 T1=51.19
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-10-15.xml	MOPT f=2 TT=3108.81 T1=48.29	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.1 T1=17.56	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.14 T1=48.29	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=18 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.09 T1=75.29	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=3108.81 T1=3108.6
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-15-16.xml	MSAT TO f=2 TT=3600.06 T1=1.7	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.08 T1=88	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.1 T1=84.84	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=28 TT=3600.07	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.09 T1=1.7	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.07 T1=1.99
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-15-20.xml	MSAT TO f=2 TT=3600.1 T1=2.05	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.08 T1=101.8	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.14 T1=160.02	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=29 TT=3600.04	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.1 T1=2.05	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.11 T1=1.57
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-20-21.xml	MSAT TO f=2 TT=3600.06 T1=2.59	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.11 T1=88.33	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.1 T1=249.84	MSAT (TO) f=19 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=39 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.06 T1=2.59	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.09 T1=2.5
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-20-30.xml	MSAT TO f=2 TT=3600.07 T1=3.05	MSAT (TO) f=40 TT=3600.13 T1=0.89	MSAT (TO) f=40 TT=3600.15 T1=1.08	MSAT (TO) f=39 TT=3600.01	? (TO) TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.07 T1=3.05	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.1 T1=54.18
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-30-31.xml	MSAT TO f=3 TT=3600 T1=10.38	MSAT (TO) f=60 TT=3600.07 T1=1.18	MSAT (TO) f=60 TT=3600.13 T1=1.16	MSAT (TO) f=59 TT=3600.07	? (TO) TT=3600.04	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600 T1=10.38	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.14 T1=4.13
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-30-35.xml	MSAT TO f=2 TT=3600.01 T1=14.12	MSAT (TO) f=60 TT=3600.12 T1=1.18	MSAT (TO) f=60 TT=3600.15 T1=1.28	? (TO) TT=3600.07	? (TO) TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.01 T1=14.12	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.12 T1=7.57
Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-30-40.xml	MSAT TO f=2 TT=3600.07 T1=4.61	MSAT (TO) f=60 TT=3600.09 T1=1.27	? f=60 TT=32.822 T1=1.08	? (TO) TT=3600.06	? (TO) TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.07 T1=4.61	MSAT (TO) f=8 TT=3600.15 T1=6.49
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-35-40.xml	MSAT TO f=2 TT=3600.12 T1=99.59	MSAT (TO) f=70 TT=3600.05 T1=1.17	? f=70 TT=33.413 T1=1.18	? (TO) TT=3600.01	? (TO) TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.08 T1=543.18	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.12 T1=99.59
csp/pseudo/chnl/ normalized-chnl-35-45.xml	MSAT TO f=3 TT=3600.08 T1=5.61	MSAT (TO) f=70 TT=3600.11 T1=1.36	? f=70 TT=33.907 T1=1.37	? (TO) TT=3600.04	? (TO) TT=3600.07	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.08 T1=5.61	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.15 T1=4.66
csp/pseudo/mpsReduced/ normalized-mps-red-bandm.xml		? TT=142.765	? TT=138.256	? (problem) TT=0.724	? (problem) TT=0.696	? TT=165.696	? TT=165.169
csp/pseudo/mpsReduced/ normalized-mps-red-blend.xml	MSAT TO f=44 TT=3600.1 T1=14.51	MSAT (TO) f=44 TT=3600.1 T1=14.51	MSAT (TO) f=44 TT=3600.14 T1=16.03	? (problem) TT=0.67	? (problem) TT=0.673	? TT=484.511	? TT=480.915
csp/pseudo/mpsReduced/ normalized-mps-red-egout.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=12.99 T1=12.77	MSAT (TO) f=30 TT=3600.17 T1=45.3	MSAT (TO) f=30 TT=3600.14 T1=45.26	MSAT (TO) f=32 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=38 TT=3600	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=18.015 T1=17.1	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=12.99 T1=12.77
csp/pseudo/mpsReduced/ normalized-mps-red-sample2.xml	MSAT TO f=14 TT=3600.08 T1=12.18	MSAT (TO) f=14 TT=3600.11 T1=12.18	MSAT (TO) f=14 TT=3600.08 T1=12.36	MSAT (TO) f=14 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=17 TT=3600.08	? (MO) TT=82.71	? (MO) TT=83.636
csp/pseudo/mpsReduced/ normalized-mps-red-share2b.xml	MSAT TO f=11 TT=3600.07	MSAT (TO) f=17 TT=3600.15 T1=17.13	MSAT (TO) f=17 TT=3600.15 T1=17.22	MSAT (TO) f=11 TT=3600.07	MSAT (TO) f=17 TT=3600.09	? (MO) TT=167.886	? (MO) TT=164.777
csp/pseudo/ primesDimacs/ normalized-bf-0432-007.xml	MSAT TO f=1 TT=3600.08 T1=6.74	? f=1 TT=70.397 T1=6.75	? f=1 TT=118.234 T1=6.74	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=20 TT=3600.05	? (MO) TT=68.99	? (MO) TT=70.485
csp/pseudo/ primesDimacs/ normalized-bf-1355-075.xml	MSAT f=1 TT=59.582 T1=11.94	MSAT f=1 TT=59.582 T1=12.36	MSAT f=1 TT=597.204 T1=11.94	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=73 TT=3600.08	? TT=205.974	? TT=208.869
Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/pseudo/ primesDimacs/ normalized-bf-1355-638.xml	MSAT f=1 TT=86.503 T1=13.6	? f=1 TT=904.547 T1=13.6	MSAT f=1 TT=86.503 T1=14.07	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=84 TT=3600.01	? TT=184.407	? TT=182.549
csp/pseudo/ primesDimacs/ normalized-bf-2670-001.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=467.509 T1=9.04	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.15 T1=9.04	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=467.509 T1=9.14 CHECKS=13127400 NODES=35854	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=36 TT=3600.06	? (MO) TT=75.31	? (MO) TT=72.904
csp/pseudo/ssa/ normalized-ssa-0432-003.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=13.067 T1=1.23	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.17 T1=1.56	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=706.469 T1=1.23 CHECKS=25342600 NODES=609224	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.02	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=58.648 T1=54.08	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=13.067 T1=12.68
csp/pseudo/ssa/ normalized-ssa-2670-130.xml	MSAT f=1 TT=1678.15 T1=6.04	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.07 T1=6.76	MSAT f=1 TT=1678.15 T1=6.04	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=40 TT=3600.07	? (MO) TT=73.51	? (MO) TT=66.111
csp/pseudo/ssa/ normalized-ssa-2670-141.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=46.438 T1=3.94	MSAT f=1 TT=1742.09 T1=3.94	MSAT f=1 TT=809.643 T1=4.06	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=30 TT=3600.03	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=702.816 T1=648.18	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=46.438 T1=45.94
csp/pseudo/ssa/ normalized-ssa-6288-047.xml		? TT=248.24	? TT=245.807	? (problem) TT=344.321 CHECKS=91320 NODES=0	? (problem) TT=345.784 CHECKS=92456 NODES=0	? TT=546.584	? TT=472.994
csp/pseudo/uclid/ normalized-22s-smv.xml	MSAT f=1 TT=371.596 T1=219.11	MSAT f=1 TT=371.596 T1=219.11	MSAT f=1 TT=1681.34 T1=240.77	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=29 TT=3600.04	? TT=175.341	? TT=178.165
csp/pseudo/uclid/ normalized-37s-smv.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=43.924 T1=7.83	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.12 T1=7.85	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=2108.21 T1=7.83	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.1	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.02	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=489.48 T1=449.94	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=43.924 T1=42.12
csp/pseudo/uclid/ normalized-43s-smv.xml	MSAT TO f=4 TT=3600.03	? f=1 TT=268.714 T1=180.51	? f=1 TT=1377.12 T1=168.77	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=27 TT=3600.09	? TT=185.693	? TT=260.85
csp/pseudo/uclid/ normalized-46s-smv.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=844.907 T1=16.2	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=2526.84 T1=17.02	? f=1 TT=140.785 T1=16.2	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.01	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=844.907 T1=776.98	No Cert. TT=52.755
Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/pseudo/uclid/ normalized-blast-floppy1-7.xml	MSAT TO f=51 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=80 TT=3600.2 T1=85.61	MSAT (TO) f=80 TT=3600.35 T1=90.95	MSAT (TO) f=51 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=70 TT=3600.1	? TT=157.444	? TT=171.465
csp/pseudo/uclid/ normalized-cache-ibm-q-unbounded-Icl2arity-ucl.xml		? TT=475.484	? TT=481.221	? (problem) TT=1178.57 CHECKS=133115 NODES=0	? (problem) TT=1147.57 CHECKS=139236 NODES=0	? TT=196.156	? TT=191.13
csp/pseudo/uclid/ normalized-elf-rf6.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=1.541 T1=0.68	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=32.364 T1=0.68 CHECKS=113783 NODES=4221	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=31.236 T1=0.78 CHECKS=7563 NODES=140	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.04	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.04	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=1.583 T1=1.4	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=1.541 T1=1.38
csp/pseudo/uclid/ normalized-elf-rf8.xml	MSAT TO f=2 TT=1857.62 T1=68.17	? f=2 TT=133.359 T1=71.64	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=1857.62 T1=68.17	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=25 TT=3600	? TT=171.441	? TT=175.749
csp/pseudo/uclid/ normalized-ooo-burch-dill-4-accl.xml	MSAT f=2 TT=126.304 T1=66.1	MSAT f=2 TT=126.304 T1=66.1	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=1906.86 T1=66.45	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.09	? TT=194.485	? TT=180.991
csp/pseudo/uclid/ normalized-ooo-tag10.xml	MSAT TO f=2 TT=3600.04	MSAT f=13 TT=231.978 T1=152.93	MSAT (TO) f=13 TT=2044.38 T1=151.4	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.04	MSAT (TO) f=30 TT=3600.08	? TT=242.813	? TT=229.5
csp/radar-8-24-3-2/ normalized-radar-8-24-3-2-18.xml	MOPT f=2 TT=1.92 T1=1.73	? TT=31.248	? TT=31.334	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.02	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=2.16 T1=1.95	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=1.92 T1=1.73
csp/radar-8-24-3-2/ normalized-radar-8-24-3-2-19.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.184 T1=2	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.14 T1=1.18	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.14 T1=268.37	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.09	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.603 T1=2.42	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.184 T1=2
csp/radar-8-24-3-2/ normalized-radar-8-24-3-2-1.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.283 T1=2.1	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=828.226 T1=825.55 CHECKS=415329000 NODES=12773	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=1133.59 T1=1129.85 CHECKS=773515000 NODES=58311	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.03	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.326 T1=2.14	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.283 T1=2.1
csp/radar-8-24-3-2/ normalized-radar-8-24-3-2-2.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=1.993 T1=1.92	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.06 T1=1.17	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=58.603 T1=46.68 CHECKS=20447400 NODES=723	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.08	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.168 T1=2	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=1.993 T1=1.92
Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/radar-8-24-3-2/ normalized-radar-8-24-3-2-32.xml	MOPT f=2 TT=1.913 T1=1.71	? TT=32.069	? TT=32.081	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.05	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=1.958 T1=1.77	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=1.913 T1=1.71
csp/radar-8-24-3-2/ normalized-radar-8-24-3-2-41.xml	MOPT f=2 TT=2.144 T1=1.18	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.09 T1=1.27	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=549.141 T1=1.18 CHECKS=349883000 NODES=118383	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.02	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=2.144 T1=1.95	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=2.455 T1=2.27
csp/radar-8-24-3-2/ normalized-radar-8-24-3-2-44.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.226 T1=2.03	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.05 T1=1.07	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.1 T1=1.06	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.02	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.272 T1=2.09	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.226 T1=2.03
csp/radar-8-24-3-2/ normalized-radar-8-24-3-2-47.xml	MOPT f=2 TT=2.067 T1=1.27	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.09 T1=1.36	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.09 T1=1.27	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.06	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=2.101 T1=1.91	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=2.067 T1=2.01
csp/radar-8-24-3-2/ normalized-radar-8-24-3-2-5.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.205 T1=2.03	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=61.536 T1=39.91 CHECKS=19120800 NODES=290	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=137.533 T1=49.61 CHECKS=68271100 NODES=2451	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.02	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.268 T1=2.07	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.205 T1=2.03
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-12.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.648 T1=2.39	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.11 T1=4.18	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.05 T1=4.46	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.01	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.726 T1=2.52	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.648 T1=2.39
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-26.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.489 T1=2.25	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.09 T1=4.15	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.09 T1=3.75	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.1	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.616 T1=2.41	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.489 T1=2.25
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-29.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.882 T1=2.72	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.14 T1=4.68	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.04 T1=4.67	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.06	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.882 T1=2.72	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=3.129 T1=2.86
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-2.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.524 T1=2.35	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.13 T1=2.56	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.13 T1=2.38	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.06	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.656 T1=2.43	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.524 T1=2.35
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-30.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.441 T1=2.31	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.09 T1=6.82	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.16 T1=6.72	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.06	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.653 T1=2.45	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.441 T1=2.31
Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-31.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.365 T1=2.17	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.12 T1=19.14	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.06 T1=18.65	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.02	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.578 T1=2.37	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.365 T1=2.17
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-34.xml	MOPT f=2 TT=2.481 T1=2.29	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.15 T1=7.65	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.13 T1=7.23	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.07	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=2.858 T1=2.65	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=2.481 T1=2.29
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-43.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.362 T1=2.26	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.11 T1=2.58	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.09 T1=673.46	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.09	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=3.014 T1=2.8	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.362 T1=2.26
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-47.xml	MOPT f=2 TT=2.214 T1=1.97	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.08 T1=4.94	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.08 T1=839.36	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.1	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=2.56 T1=2.31	OPTIMUM f=2 TT=2.214 T1=1.97
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-48.xml	MOPT f=3 TT=2.587 T1=2.37	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.14 T1=7.18	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.08 T1=7.96	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.07	OPTIMUM f=3 TT=2.837 T1=2.66	OPTIMUM f=3 TT=2.587 T1=2.37
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-49.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.63 T1=2.4	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.08 T1=2.36	MSAT (TO) f=6 TT=3600.08 T1=2.55	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.06	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.08	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.923 T1=2.68	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.63 T1=2.4
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-7.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.718 T1=2.52	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.12 T1=2.66	MSAT (TO) f=4 TT=3600.08 T1=2.56	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=2 TT=3600.06	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=3.061 T1=2.87	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.718 T1=2.52
csp/radar-9-28-4-2/ normalized-radar-9-28-4-2-9.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.574 T1=2.38	MSAT (TO) f=8 TT=3600.05 T1=1.97	MSAT (TO) f=8 TT=3600.07 T1=1.96	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.04	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.718 T1=2.46	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.574 T1=2.38
csp/ramsey3/ normalized-ramsey-17-3.xml	MSAT TO f=5 TT=3600.03 T1=2.98	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.03 T1=3.34	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.1 T1=2.98	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.04	MSAT (TO) f=5 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=16 TT=3600.09 T1=432.36	MSAT (TO) f=20 TT=3600.13 T1=21.87
csp/ramsey3/ normalized-ramsey-18-3.xml	MSAT TO f=10 TT=3600.03 T1=8.21	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.08 T1=8.21	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.03 T1=8.38	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.09	MSAT (TO) f=11 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=44 TT=3600.07 T1=10.67	MSAT (TO) f=26 TT=3600.1 T1=27.42
Bench name	Best results on this instance	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
csp/ramsey3/ normalized-ramsey-20-3.xml	MSAT TO f=20 TT=3600 T1=15.05	MSAT (TO) f=20 TT=3600.11 T1=15.28	MSAT (TO) f=20 TT=3600.08 T1=15.05	MSAT (TO) f=20 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=20 TT=3600	MSAT (TO) f=50 TT=3600.02 T1=29.4	MSAT (TO) f=56 TT=3600.13 T1=36.25
csp/ramsey3/ normalized-ramsey-25-3.xml	MSAT TO f=50 TT=3600.02 T1=7.79	MSAT (TO) f=50 TT=3600.09 T1=7.9	MSAT (TO) f=50 TT=3600.12 T1=7.79	MSAT (TO) f=50 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=50 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=177 TT=3600.2 T1=44.38	MSAT (TO) f=198 TT=3600.3 T1=45.43
csp/schurrLemma/ normalized-lemma-100-9-mod.xml	MSAT TO f=374 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=380 TT=3600.13 T1=49.44	MSAT (TO) f=380 TT=3600.14 T1=51.34	MSAT (TO) f=374 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=407 TT=3600.03	? (TO) TT=3600.13	MSAT (TO) f=937 TT=3600.28 T1=528.01
csp/schurrLemma/ normalized-lemma-12-9-mod.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=1.515 T1=0.5	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=85.742 T1=0.5 CHECKS=52863600 NODES=638649	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=89.755 T1=0.58 CHECKS=53552100 NODES=444970	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.07	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=1.6 T1=0.84	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=1.515 T1=0.82
csp/schurrLemma/ normalized-lemma-15-9-mod.xml	MOPT f=3 TT=926.785 T1=0.63	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.08 T1=0.63	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.08 T1=0.68	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=3 TT=3600.05	OPTIMUM f=3 TT=926.785 T1=1.61	OPTIMUM f=3 TT=997.631 T1=12.78
csp/schurrLemma/ normalized-lemma-20-9-mod.xml	MSAT TO f=7 TT=3600.01 T1=0.68	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=3600.07 T1=0.68	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=3600.08 T1=0.69	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=3600.01	MSAT (TO) f=7 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=10 TT=3600.12 T1=94.06	MSAT (TO) f=11 TT=3600.09 T1=14.39
csp/schurrLemma/ normalized-lemma-24-3.xml	MOPT f=1 TT=2.377 T1=0.68	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=34.715 T1=0.68 CHECKS=1696700 NODES=21491	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=32.305 T1=0.68 CHECKS=708842 NODES=10494	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.03	MSAT (TO) f=1 TT=3600.07	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.405 T1=1.92	OPTIMUM f=1 TT=2.377 T1=1.75
csp/schurrLemma/ normalized-lemma-30-9-mod.xml	MSAT TO f=21 TT=3600.04 T1=17.47	MSAT (TO) f=21 TT=3600.09 T1=17.47	MSAT (TO) f=21 TT=3600.11 T1=18.69	MSAT (TO) f=21 TT=3600.04	MSAT (TO) f=21 TT=3600.05	MSAT (TO) f=44 TT=3600.05 T1=2.17	MSAT (TO) f=40 TT=3600.16 T1=3.82
csp/schurrLemma/ normalized-lemma-50-9-mod.xml	MSAT TO f=76 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=80 TT=3600.16 T1=21.34	MSAT (TO) f=80 TT=3600.09 T1=20.69	MSAT (TO) f=76 TT=3600.08	MSAT (TO) f=78 TT=3600.02	MSAT (TO) f=149 TT=3600.01 T1=47.96	MSAT (TO) f=219 TT=3600.12 T1=2.92

Some statistics...

	AbsconMax 112 pc-d	AbsconMax 112 pc-w	Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30	Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30	Sugar v1.13+minisat	Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
Number of times the solver is able to give the best known answer	28	35	31	12	48	43
Number of times the solver is able to give the best known answer from an incomplete solver point of view (i.e. without considering optimality proof)	39	45	68	25	49	44
Number of times the solver is the best solver from a complete solver point of view (i.e. best known answer and best TT time)	17	21	29	12	14	38
Number of times the solver is the best solver from an incomplete solver point of view (i.e. best known answer and best T1 time)	18	18	0	0	10	25