MAX-CSP 2008 Competition: solvers results per benchmarks

Result page for benchmark
csp/fapp/fapp34/
normalized-fapp34-0750-0.xml

Jump to solvers results

General information on the benchmark

Namecsp/fapp/fapp34/
normalized-fapp34-0750-0.xml
MD5SUM701805f3dd433f8e5a195a0325c2f865
Bench Category2-ARY-INT (binary constraints in intension)
Best result obtained on this benchmarkMSAT TO
Best Number of falsified constraints36
Best CPU time to get the best result obtained on this benchmark3600.03
Satisfiable
(Un)Satisfiability was proved
Number of variables750
Number of constraints8639
Maximum constraint arity2
Maximum domain size998
Number of constraints which are defined in extension0
Number of constraints which are defined in intension8639
Global constraints used (with number of constraints)

Results of the different solvers on this benchmark

Solver NameTraceIDAnswerNumber of falsified constraintsCPU timeWall clock time
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-301112789MSAT (TO)36 3600.03 3632.22
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-301112790MSAT (TO)77 3600.06 3614.82
Sugar v1.13+minisat1112794? 336.024 342.761
Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc1112793? 357.176 363.214
AbsconMax 112 pc-w1112791? 499.027 503.931
AbsconMax 112 pc-d1112792? 503.924 506.678

Additionnal information

This section presents information obtained from the best job displayed in the list (i.e. solvers whose names are not hidden).

Number of falsified constraints: 36
Solution found:
-2514 -2554 -3240 3312 3254 -3200 2556 -2500 -2990 2754 -2626 -2576 -2584 -2758 3034 -2616 3044 2562 3144 2616 -2584 -2562 -2562 -2518 -3044
2564 3272 3346 2616 -2616 2828 2758 2576 -2852 3142 -2494 -3102 3352 -3096 -3352 2784 -2798 2994 -3070 2788 2602 2990 2732 2576 -2788 -2518
3190 2892 3150 2602 3010 -2798 -2490 -2586 -2518 -2562 -2576 2818 2784 -2828 -2478 -3150 -2828 2558 3038 2918 -3230 2602 -2518 3294 -2584
3190 -3004 -2624 -3150 2758 2698 -3134 -2436 2828 2614 3352 3038 -3250 -2856 -2828 -2478 2688 2358 -2478 -2786 -3004 -3102 3056 2562 3336
2932 -3304 -3106 -3004 -3044 -3004 -2982 -3150 -2758 -2562 2548 2488 -2624 -3064 -3004 2828 2518 -3142 2478 -2400 3350 3194 3234 3038 3292
-2992 -2448 3044 -2602 -3102 -2558 3312 3148 -2602 -3150 2772 -3016 -2616 -3074 -2602 3168 3002 3120 -2700 2518 -2602 -2758 -2540 3344 -2478
3000 -3190 2758 -3008 2828 -2576 2584 -2478 -3010 2616 3148 -3150 -3148 3174 2562 2438 -2828 -2478 -2616 -3190 -3150 -2514 -2618 2396 2902
-3102 -2518 -2584 -2630 -2784 -2718 2728 -3150 2426 -3052 -2518 -2478 -2788 -3142 2478 -2576 3004 -2788 -2364 -3350 2626 2970 -2990 3150
3142 -2624 -3142 -2544 -3044 -2356 -2518 -3214 2678 -2950 3190 3326 2594 2534 3254 -2602 -2508 3190 -2798 2558 2828 -2942 -2788 -2678 2604
-2578 -2624 2396 -3150 -2478 2558 -3190 -3060 -2852 2934 -2798 2744 -2368 -2974 2820 -2826 -2828 2440 -2398 -3290 3290 -3142 -2562 -2616
-3224 -3142 -2518 -2368 -2478 2478 -2616 -3102 -2396 2408 -3004 2934 -2828 -3190 -2624 -2584 3278 -2562 -3310 -2374 -2788 -2602 -3352 -2788
2372 3056 -2518 2358 -3004 -3180 -2788 -2586 -2518 3044 -3146 3044 -3352 -2510 2918 3270 2850 2768 -3190 2728 3312 -3036 -2998 -2396 -2518
-3296 -3012 3102 2616 2828 3312 2394 -2624 3150 3002 3042 -3004 -3136 2624 -3182 -2558 -2584 -3190 3190 -2576 2984 -3234 3004 2412 3308
-2584 -3188 2360 2878 -3042 3350 2788 -2678 -3004 -2510 -2584 3312 2624 -3330 3172 3078 -2758 -2558 -2558 -3170 -3142 -3272 2740 -2370 2758
-2828 3348 2922 2758 2478 -2562 3142 -2396 -3150 -3190 -2976 -3142 -3194 -2356 -3102 -2624 -2584 -2798 -2616 -3004 3256 -2518 -2624 -2518
3334 -2398 2356 -2950 -2950 -3190 -2584 -2624 -2624 2576 3238 3352 2824 -3190 -2788 -2618 2798 2676 2834 -3298 2518 -2602 -2576 2402 -3176
3298 3136 -2584 3038 -2654 2576 -2828 2826 -3352 2718 -2356 -2616 -2708 -2798 -3044 2360 -2788 3044 -2540 -3244 -3150 3310 -3044 -2402 -2576
-2624 2562 -3004 -2624 3004 2518 2936 3128 -2562 3004 -2616 -2788 3302 -2558 2530 2548 2732 -3044 -2558 2788 2584 3150 2854 -2478 2360 3002
-2624 2944 2798 -2958 -2788 3150 2396 -3044 -2828 -3076 -2798 2576 3312 3190 2598 -3296 -2678 -3030 3130 -2578 -2448 2576 -2788 -2518 -3146
-2478 -2602 -2798 2584 2952 -2996 -3342 3190 -2518 -3344 2364 2932 -2576 -3210 -2624 -2562 -2576 -2798 2816 3020 2584 3082 -3150 -3150 3004
2890 2386 2486 2966 3336 -2718 2602 2828 2758 -2518 2758 -2508 3306 -3286 -3258 -2602 -3036 2356 2942 -2504 -2758 3184 -2798 2812 -3104
-2616 -3004 -2798 -3102 2952 3042 -3106 -3312 2716 -2584 -2396 -3004 -2828 2518 3190 -2758 2624 -2786 2396 -2758 -2518 3150 -3294 -3142
-2602 -2562 -3166 2526 3190 -2518 2398 -3352 -3004 -2788 2396 -2758 -2562 -2828 -3150 -2518 2408 -2448 2618 -2602 -2798 -2824 -2478 -2558
-3044 -2518 3142 -2558 -2518 -2558 -2516 2362 -2580 -2616 3080 -3044 -3130 -2602 2518 -2576 -2990 -2558 3216 -2436 3022 -2446 2396 -2518
-2616 -2518 -2518 -3142 -2562 -3150 -3304 -2626 3104 -3044 -2992 2478 2788 2882 -3062 2624 2780 -2788 -2558 -2478 2926 -2758 2518 2558 -2478
-2486 -2616 -3004 -2586 2356 -3102 2502 -2828 2576 2798 3200 -3102 2550 -2758 2356 2616 3240 -2788 -2518 2518 3286 2668 -3102 -3150 -2400
-2408 -2518 -2576 -2758 -2828 -2478 -2576 -3044 2602 -3304 -2576 3142 -2562 -2758 -2828 -3190 2970 -2576 -3170 -2624 2584 3204 -3044 2518
3078 3338 2866 -2788 -2400 -2746 -2602 3044 3212 -2798 -2616 -2576 -3102 3332 -2554 -3040 2954 2828 -2356 2794 2730 -2788 2770 -2602 -3190
-3042 -2616 -2798 -3188 2408 2798 -3030 2502 -2788 3246 2358 -3142 3256 -3102 3102 -2550 2590 2478 -2616 -2576 3016 -2478 -3190 -3078 -3188
-2616 -2404 -3044 -2794 -2828 -2518 -3344 -2562 -3348 3312 2894 -2404 2718 -2584 -2616 -2788 2894 -2562 -2798 -3308 2398 3190 2518 -2478
-2584 -2442 3140 -2578 -2518 -2478 -2478