2019 XCSP3 competition: main track (CSP and COP, sequential and parallel solvers): solvers results per benchmarks

Result page for benchmark
GraphColoring/GraphColoring-m1-fixed/
GraphColoring-qwhopt-o33-h381-bal-1.xml

Jump to solvers results

General information on the benchmark

NameGraphColoring/GraphColoring-m1-fixed/
GraphColoring-qwhopt-o33-h381-bal-1.xml
MD5SUM2a724879a45d3456306f221189212969
Bench CategoryCOP (optimization problem)
Best result obtained on this benchmarkSAT TO
Best value of the objective obtained on this benchmark33
Best CPU time to get the best result obtained on this benchmark2519.82
Satisfiable
(Un)Satisfiability was proved
Number of variables1089
Number of constraints34849
Number of domains1
Minimum domain size1089
Maximum domain size1089
Distribution of domain sizes[{"size":1089,"count":1089}]
Minimum variable degree65
Maximum variable degree66
Distribution of variable degrees[{"degree":65,"count":381},{"degree":66,"count":708}]
Minimum constraint arity2
Maximum constraint arity708
Distribution of constraint arities[{"arity":2,"count":34848},{"arity":708,"count":1}]
Number of extensional constraints0
Number of intensional constraints34848
Distribution of constraint types[{"type":"intension","count":34848},{"type":"instantiation","count":1}]
Optimization problemYES
Type of objectivemin MAXIMUM

Results of the different solvers on this benchmark

Solver NameTraceIDAnswerobjective functionCPU timeWall clock time
cosoco 2.0 (complete)4408461SAT (TO)33 2519.82 2520.01
choco-solver 2019-09-24 (complete)4406281SAT (TO)33 2520.04 2509.81
cosoco 2.0 (complete)4397201SAT (TO)33 2520.05 2519.8
Concrete 3.12.2 (complete)4401181SAT (TO)33 2520.06 2487.54
Concrete 3.12.2 (complete)4396301SAT (TO)33 2520.07 2484.63
AbsCon 2019-07-23 (complete)4391021SAT (TO)33 2520.08 2511.42
cosoco 2 (complete)4389921SAT (TO)33 2520.09 2520
Concrete 3.10 (complete)4387001SAT (TO)33 2520.12 2487.43
Concrete 3.12.3 (complete)4402981SAT (TO)33 2520.17 2487.11
choco-solver 2019-09-20 (complete)4403881SAT (TO)33 2520.2 635.359
choco-solver 2019-06-14 (complete)4393421SAT (TO)33 2520.42 635.209
choco-solver 2019-09-16 (complete)4399381SAT (TO)33 2520.57 635.191
choco-solver 2019-09-20 parallel (complete)4404781SAT (TO)33 20008.4 2520.15
choco-solver 2019-06-14 parallel (complete)4394021SAT (TO)33 20018.7 2520.11
choco-solver 2019-09-24 parallel (complete)4407181SAT (TO)33 20023.7 2520.12
choco-solver 2019-09-16 parallel (complete)4399981SAT (TO)33 20033.3 2520.12
cosoco 2.0 parallel (complete)4409741SAT (TO)33 20066.9 2520.03
cosoco 2.O parallel (complete)4398481SAT (TO)33 20067.5 2520.03
PicatSAT 2019-09-12 (complete)4395401? (TO) 2519.98 2520.01

Additionnal information

This section presents information obtained from the best job displayed in the list (i.e. solvers whose names are not hidden).

objective function: 33
Solution found:
<instantiation type='solution' cost='33'> <list>x[0] x[1000] x[1001] x[1002] x[1003] x[1004] x[1005] x[1006] x[1007] x[1008] x[1009] x[100]
x[1010] x[1011] x[1012] x[1013] x[1014] x[1015] x[1016] x[1017] x[1018] x[1019] x[101] x[1020] x[1021] x[1022] x[1023] x[1024] x[1025]
x[1026] x[1027] x[1028] x[1029] x[102] x[1030] x[1031] x[1032] x[1033] x[1034] x[1035] x[1036] x[1037] x[1038] x[1039] x[103] x[1040]
x[1041] x[1042] x[1043] x[1044] x[1045] x[1046] x[1047] x[1048] x[1049] x[104] x[1050] x[1051] x[1052] x[1053] x[1054] x[1055] x[1056]
x[1057] x[1058] x[1059] x[105] x[1060] x[1061] x[1062] x[1063] x[1064] x[1065] x[1066] x[1067] x[1068] x[1069] x[106] x[1070] x[1071]
x[1072] x[1073] x[1074] x[1075] x[1076] x[1077] x[1078] x[1079] x[107] x[1080] x[1081] x[1082] x[1083] x[1084] x[1085] x[1086] x[1087]
x[1088] x[108] x[109] x[10] x[110] x[111] x[112] x[113] x[114] x[115] x[116] x[117] x[118] x[119] x[11] x[120] x[121] x[122] x[123] x[124]
x[125] x[126] x[127] x[128] x[129] x[12] x[130] x[131] x[132] x[133] x[134] x[135] x[136] x[137] x[138] x[139] x[13] x[140] x[141] x[142]
x[143] x[144] x[145] x[146] x[147] x[148] x[149] x[14] x[150] x[151] x[152] x[153] x[154] x[155] x[156] x[157] x[158] x[159] x[15] x[160]
x[161] x[162] x[163] x[164] x[165] x[166] x[167] x[168] x[169] x[16] x[170] x[171] x[172] x[173] x[174] x[175] x[176] x[177] x[178] x[179]
x[17] x[180] x[181] x[182] x[183] x[184] x[185] x[186] x[187] x[188] x[189] x[18] x[190] x[191] x[192] x[193] x[194] x[195] x[196] x[197]
x[198] x[199] x[19] x[1] x[200] x[201] x[202] x[203] x[204] x[205] x[206] x[207] x[208] x[209] x[20] x[210] x[211] x[212] x[213] x[214]
x[215] x[216] x[217] x[218] x[219] x[21] x[220] x[221] x[222] x[223] x[224] x[225] x[226] x[227] x[228] x[229] x[22] x[230] x[231] x[232]
x[233] x[234] x[235] x[236] x[237] x[238] x[239] x[23] x[240] x[241] x[242] x[243] x[244] x[245] x[246] x[247] x[248] x[249] x[24] x[250]
x[251] x[252] x[253] x[254] x[255] x[256] x[257] x[258] x[259] x[25] x[260] x[261] x[262] x[263] x[264] x[265] x[266] x[267] x[268] x[269]
x[26] x[270] x[271] x[272] x[273] x[274] x[275] x[276] x[277] x[278] x[279] x[27] x[280] x[281] x[282] x[283] x[284] x[285] x[286] x[287]
x[288] x[289] x[28] x[290] x[291] x[292] x[293] x[294] x[295] x[296] x[297] x[298] x[299] x[29] x[2] x[300] x[301] x[302] x[303] x[304]
x[305] x[306] x[307] x[308] x[309] x[30] x[310] x[311] x[312] x[313] x[314] x[315] x[316] x[317] x[318] x[319] x[31] x[320] x[321] x[322]
x[323] x[324] x[325] x[326] x[327] x[328] x[329] x[32] x[330] x[331] x[332] x[333] x[334] x[335] x[336] x[337] x[338] x[339] x[33] x[340]
x[341] x[342] x[343] x[344] x[345] x[346] x[347] x[348] x[349] x[34] x[350] x[351] x[352] x[353] x[354] x[355] x[356] x[357] x[358] x[359]
x[35] x[360] x[361] x[362] x[363] x[364] x[365] x[366] x[367] x[368] x[369] x[36] x[370] x[371] x[372] x[373] x[374] x[375] x[376] x[377]
x[378] x[379] x[37] x[380] x[381] x[382] x[383] x[384] x[385] x[386] x[387] x[388] x[389] x[38] x[390] x[391] x[392] x[393] x[394] x[395]
x[396] x[397] x[398] x[399] x[39] x[3] x[400] x[401] x[402] x[403] x[404] x[405] x[406] x[407] x[408] x[409] x[40] x[410] x[411] x[412]
x[413] x[414] x[415] x[416] x[417] x[418] x[419] x[41] x[420] x[421] x[422] x[423] x[424] x[425] x[426] x[427] x[428] x[429] x[42] x[430]
x[431] x[432] x[433] x[434] x[435] x[436] x[437] x[438] x[439] x[43] x[440] x[441] x[442] x[443] x[444] x[445] x[446] x[447] x[448] x[449]
x[44] x[450] x[451] x[452] x[453] x[454] x[455] x[456] x[457] x[458] x[459] x[45] x[460] x[461] x[462] x[463] x[464] x[465] x[466] x[467]
x[468] x[469] x[46] x[470] x[471] x[472] x[473] x[474] x[475] x[476] x[477] x[478] x[479] x[47] x[480] x[481] x[482] x[483] x[484] x[485]
x[486] x[487] x[488] x[489] x[48] x[490] x[491] x[492] x[493] x[494] x[495] x[496] x[497] x[498] x[499] x[49] x[4] x[500] x[501] x[502]
x[503] x[504] x[505] x[506] x[507] x[508] x[509] x[50] x[510] x[511] x[512] x[513] x[514] x[515] x[516] x[517] x[518] x[519] x[51] x[520]
x[521] x[522] x[523] x[524] x[525] x[526] x[527] x[528] x[529] x[52] x[530] x[531] x[532] x[533] x[534] x[535] x[536] x[537] x[538] x[539]
x[53] x[540] x[541] x[542] x[543] x[544] x[545] x[546] x[547] x[548] x[549] x[54] x[550] x[551] x[552] x[553] x[554] x[555] x[556] x[557]
x[558] x[559] x[55] x[560] x[561] x[562] x[563] x[564] x[565] x[566] x[567] x[568] x[569] x[56] x[570] x[571] x[572] x[573] x[574] x[575]
x[576] x[577] x[578] x[579] x[57] x[580] x[581] x[582] x[583] x[584] x[585] x[586] x[587] x[588] x[589] x[58] x[590] x[591] x[592] x[593]
x[594] x[595] x[596] x[597] x[598] x[599] x[59] x[5] x[600] x[601] x[602] x[603] x[604] x[605] x[606] x[607] x[608] x[609] x[60] x[610]
x[611] x[612] x[613] x[614] x[615] x[616] x[617] x[618] x[619] x[61] x[620] x[621] x[622] x[623] x[624] x[625] x[626] x[627] x[628] x[629]
x[62] x[630] x[631] x[632] x[633] x[634] x[635] x[636] x[637] x[638] x[639] x[63] x[640] x[641] x[642] x[643] x[644] x[645] x[646] x[647]
x[648] x[649] x[64] x[650] x[651] x[652] x[653] x[654] x[655] x[656] x[657] x[658] x[659] x[65] x[660] x[661] x[662] x[663] x[664] x[665]
x[666] x[667] x[668] x[669] x[66] x[670] x[671] x[672] x[673] x[674] x[675] x[676] x[677] x[678] x[679] x[67] x[680] x[681] x[682] x[683]
x[684] x[685] x[686] x[687] x[688] x[689] x[68] x[690] x[691] x[692] x[693] x[694] x[695] x[696] x[697] x[698] x[699] x[69] x[6] x[700]
x[701] x[702] x[703] x[704] x[705] x[706] x[707] x[708] x[709] x[70] x[710] x[711] x[712] x[713] x[714] x[715] x[716] x[717] x[718] x[719]
x[71] x[720] x[721] x[722] x[723] x[724] x[725] x[726] x[727] x[728] x[729] x[72] x[730] x[731] x[732] x[733] x[734] x[735] x[736] x[737]
x[738] x[739] x[73] x[740] x[741] x[742] x[743] x[744] x[745] x[746] x[747] x[748] x[749] x[74] x[750] x[751] x[752] x[753] x[754] x[755]
x[756] x[757] x[758] x[759] x[75] x[760] x[761] x[762] x[763] x[764] x[765] x[766] x[767] x[768] x[769] x[76] x[770] x[771] x[772] x[773]
x[774] x[775] x[776] x[777] x[778] x[779] x[77] x[780] x[781] x[782] x[783] x[784] x[785] x[786] x[787] x[788] x[789] x[78] x[790] x[791]
x[792] x[793] x[794] x[795] x[796] x[797] x[798] x[799] x[79] x[7] x[800] x[801] x[802] x[803] x[804] x[805] x[806] x[807] x[808] x[809]
x[80] x[810] x[811] x[812] x[813] x[814] x[815] x[816] x[817] x[818] x[819] x[81] x[820] x[821] x[822] x[823] x[824] x[825] x[826] x[827]
x[828] x[829] x[82] x[830] x[831] x[832] x[833] x[834] x[835] x[836] x[837] x[838] x[839] x[83] x[840] x[841] x[842] x[843] x[844] x[845]
x[846] x[847] x[848] x[849] x[84] x[850] x[851] x[852] x[853] x[854] x[855] x[856] x[857] x[858] x[859] x[85] x[860] x[861] x[862] x[863]
x[864] x[865] x[866] x[867] x[868] x[869] x[86] x[870] x[871] x[872] x[873] x[874] x[875] x[876] x[877] x[878] x[879] x[87] x[880] x[881]
x[882] x[883] x[884] x[885] x[886] x[887] x[888] x[889] x[88] x[890] x[891] x[892] x[893] x[894] x[895] x[896] x[897] x[898] x[899] x[89]
x[8] x[900] x[901] x[902] x[903] x[904] x[905] x[906] x[907] x[908] x[909] x[90] x[910] x[911] x[912] x[913] x[914] x[915] x[916] x[917]
x[918] x[919] x[91] x[920] x[921] x[922] x[923] x[924] x[925] x[926] x[927] x[928] x[929] x[92] x[930] x[931] x[932] x[933] x[934] x[935]
x[936] x[937] x[938] x[939] x[93] x[940] x[941] x[942] x[943] x[944] x[945] x[946] x[947] x[948] x[949] x[94] x[950] x[951] x[952] x[953]
x[954] x[955] x[956] x[957] x[958] x[959] x[95] x[960] x[961] x[962] x[963] x[964] x[965] x[966] x[967] x[968] x[969] x[96] x[970] x[971]
x[972] x[973] x[974] x[975] x[976] x[977] x[978] x[979] x[97] x[980] x[981] x[982] x[983] x[984] x[985] x[986] x[987] x[988] x[989] x[98]
x[990] x[991] x[992] x[993] x[994] x[995] x[996] x[997] x[998] x[999] x[99] x[9] </list> <values>11 8 28 17 27 33 29 5 11 30 9 15 15 18 12
22 13 23 16 31 19 32 8 3 6 7 9 1 16 33 8 21 28 13 6 25 0 2 22 31 13 4 11 26 26 17 18 10 14 19 3 32 7 15 30 2 5 27 24 29 20 12 16 30 4 9 31
13 20 27 26 22 3 14 11 8 25 16 5 28 10 24 12 18 23 33 7 2 3 1 32 17 21 31 15 6 19 29 27 30 12 19 23 4 14 5 24 32 33 7 9 14 1 22 29 18 10 28
25 11 12 0 6 21 17 10 9 3 30 24 11 7 23 23 33 29 26 25 1 2 18 12 28 31 17 16 20 17 27 21 5 6 8 15 19 25 14 13 32 0 22 23 12 2 8 32 3 19 4 20
15 30 31 5 24 21 28 7 26 29 13 9 33 7 10 17 1 0 31 25 27 16 6 3 11 14 18 30 31 15 8 19 4 7 28 22 8 32 2 16 3 19 25 18 15 24 21 26 14 0 27 20
5 9 11 23 5 6 29 12 33 13 10 28 1 4 16 5 17 33 1 25 12 9 30 6 0 23 10 29 3 30 32 28 11 21 22 18 24 26 15 31 13 7 20 8 33 14 21 2 27 28 4 33
3 9 16 24 11 22 31 17 13 32 18 7 24 2 10 1 25 6 21 20 0 10 14 27 29 0 19 26 30 23 8 12 5 31 32 10 4 1 7 4 22 26 3 27 21 23 33 14 22 17 1 9
30 20 19 25 13 11 6 29 24 5 0 12 15 29 18 16 28 8 9 27 28 29 18 1 30 2 5 11 8 18 17 12 3 15 20 16 6 14 25 32 2 31 13 0 7 33 26 21 22 23 19
28 4 9 10 0 14 12 19 2 32 23 23 17 10 18 1 21 28 5 30 31 15 25 4 26 3 22 6 11 33 24 27 9 8 8 25 7 20 16 13 24 23 11 16 20 2 14 12 0 4 17 19
33 9 20 32 29 31 1 13 29 27 6 8 28 5 18 16 3 22 10 2 26 21 15 7 30 29 11 10 17 32 28 23 8 2 24 20 27 19 13 9 1 12 7 14 19 4 30 6 7 16 18 25
15 21 26 3 33 0 5 26 22 31 32 21 25 26 31 3 6 33 9 28 13 29 0 4 10 16 8 9 23 32 15 5 11 22 24 17 30 7 20 27 13 18 2 12 1 14 13 22 23 21 20
31 27 9 15 11 4 1 25 10 2 0 6 33 17 12 30 24 16 28 26 29 3 19 5 31 14 18 5 27 33 8 32 3 26 4 18 0 30 6 5 27 2 28 22 15 10 16 33 21 10 7 12 8
31 25 17 30 1 9 29 19 13 23 20 11 14 32 14 24 14 17 0 11 6 24 19 7 21 27 22 15 8 32 20 9 27 25 1 29 12 28 4 3 23 16 2 18 5 12 13 24 10 31 33
26 7 3 31 20 11 10 22 18 30 28 14 5 32 29 27 8 19 15 6 33 0 22 24 12 9 2 13 25 16 3 23 17 21 26 1 4 6 33 7 22 1 28 15 27 17 0 8 24 10 18 5
17 14 2 32 11 9 21 12 3 4 25 15 31 26 1 29 13 16 20 30 23 19 21 21 6 32 22 3 17 12 30 29 25 1 24 31 19 28 23 33 16 10 13 1 0 26 14 15 20 4
11 8 0 7 5 27 9 18 2 19 24 30 10 22 29 32 5 13 25 13 26 6 27 0 12 11 18 20 17 15 7 2 5 21 33 4 28 17 3 33 14 1 9 23 31 16 25 33 9 27 18 29 5
10 21 7 12 4 20 15 19 19 22 3 18 2 1 13 0 23 32 6 12 14 28 31 24 17 16 26 30 11 8 4 5 15 12 19 0 1 31 23 33 11 7 26 21 6 25 20 22 3 32 27 30
16 29 13 10 16 14 2 9 28 17 7 13 24 4 26 27 13 1 5 14 24 9 11 32 6 31 21 2 12 16 29 19 0 18 26 17 23 32 7 8 28 22 30 4 11 14 15 25 10 3 33
17 29 14 6 21 23 25 3 18 26 9 28 24 7 30 0 22 4 2 16 20 11 33 15 27 8 10 3 12 1 32 22 31 19 13 23 5 11 8 24 25 12 15 29 13 0 23 9 1 29 22 3
7 6 17 27 2 14 21 32 31 31 19 8 4 33 30 10 28 18 26 20 20 12 18 7 29 23 13 14 10 30 21 20 15 20 17 33 31 8 0 27 6 28 9 19 16 2 4 26 11 9 25
1 32 6 22 24 5 3 22 13 26 15 10 31 32 33 14 5 32 18 4 30 24 27 23 28 19 21 0 29 2 8 16 12 20 3 24 11 7 9 6 25 17 28 15 19 21 30 31 16 7 9 1
18 14 5 6 11 2 26 13 22 4 8 10 17 24 12 30 25 23 32 20 0 33 2 29 28 27 25 15 2 25 20 14 0 4 21 24 1 10 6 16 </values> </instantiation>