SAT 2011 Competition: main competition (phase 1): solvers results per benchmarks

Result page for benchmark
application/kullmann/AES/Benchmarks/
32/aes_32_2_keyfind_1.cnf

Jump to solvers results

General information on the benchmark

Nameapplication/kullmann/AES/Benchmarks/
32/aes_32_2_keyfind_1.cnf
MD5SUMc192a897c1414e3cc7eb965289993edd
Bench CategoryAPPLICATION (applications instances)
Best result obtained on this benchmarkSAT
Best CPU time to get the best result obtained on this benchmark0.32295
Satisfiable
(Un)Satisfiability was proved
Number of variables504
Number of clauses1840
Sum of the clauses size5744
Maximum clause length5
Minimum clause length1
Number of clauses of size 172
Number of clauses of size 280
Number of clauses of size 31280
Number of clauses of size 4368
Number of clauses of size 540
Number of clauses of size over 50

Results of the different solvers on this benchmark

Solver NameTraceIDAnswerCPU timeWall clock time
minisat hack reference: minisat 2.2.0 (complete)3362583SAT 0.32295 0.324923
RestartSAT A75 (complete)3290203SAT 0.500923 0.501618
Lingeling 587f (fixed) (complete)3371934SAT 0.573912 0.574794
Lingeling 587 [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290220SAT 0.639902 0.640714
minisat hack: LR_GL_NOSHR 2011-03-02 (complete)3350086SAT 0.815875 0.815725
minisat hack: cir_minisat 2011-03-02 (complete)3348586SAT 0.971852 0.974584
minisat hack: MiniSAT 2.2.0-agile-26 (complete)3318078SAT 1.24381 1.24389
SAT09 reference solver:precosat 236 (complete)3308974SAT 1.26881 1.26992
Plingeling 587f (fixed) (complete)3371334SAT 2.28365 0.596324
Plingeling 587 [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290219SAT 2.33864 0.622757
minisat hack: contrasat 2011-03-02 (complete)3350386SAT 2.70259 2.70775
ppfolio seq (complete)3290227SAT 2.90156 2.90233
SAT09 reference solver: ManySAT 1.1 aimd 1/2009-03-20 (complete)3362283SAT 3.3085 0.837954
borg-sat 11.03.02-seq-industrial (fixed) (complete)3377934SAT 3.32649 3.79249
ppfolio par (complete)3290226SAT 3.40748 0.959511
RestartSAT B95 (complete)3290202SAT 3.57446 3.57436
jMiniSat 2011 (complete)3290236SAT 3.90741 3.53336
QuteRSat 2011-03-01 [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290221SAT 4.02139 4.02234
CryptoMiniSat Strange-Night-2-mt [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290208SAT 4.23235 1.06374
CryptoMiniSat Strange-Night-2-mt (fixed) (complete)3367134SAT 4.23635 1.07003
borg-sat 11.03.02-seq-industrial (fixed, 1200 s timeout) (complete)3484624SAT 4.39833 4.60108
riss Auto (complete)3290214SAT 4.5793 4.58375
riss 1.0 (complete)3290212SAT 4.71228 4.71352
clasp 2.0-R4092-indust (complete)3300113SAT 4.92525 4.92515
minisat hack: EBMiniSAT 2011-03-02 (incomplete)3349186SAT 4.95825 4.9601
synit_sat 2011-03-03 (complete)3290198SAT 5.09822 5.09778
claspmt 2.0-R4095-patched (fixed) (complete)3373434SAT 5.17621 1.30936
claspmt 2.0-R4095 [DEPRECATED] (complete)3299813SAT 5.45617 1.37515
CryptoMiniSat Strange-Night-1-st (fixed) (complete)3370734SAT 6.29404 6.29374
CryptoMiniSat Strange-Night-1-st [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290211SAT 6.30304 6.3042
minisat hack: LR_GL_SHR 2011-03-02 (complete)3349486SAT 6.67898 6.68312
minisat hack: cir_minisat 2011-05-13 (simp) (complete)3380334SAT 7.2329 7.23501
borg-sat 11.03.02-industrial [DEPRECATED] (complete)3317778SAT 8.5687 3.45191
SArTagnan 2011-05-15 (fixed) (complete)3386278SAT 8.66568 2.18432
glucose 2 (complete)3290230SAT 9.58654 9.58644
MPhaseSAT_M 2011-02-16 (complete)3290193SAT 9.77251 9.77293
kw 2011-02-28 (complete)3290235SAT 10.9433 10.9453
CryptoMiniSat Strange-Night-1-mt [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290210SAT 11.0593 2.77113
CryptoMiniSat Strange-Night-1-mt (fixed) (complete)3369534SAT 11.0773 2.78549
riss Auto (1200 s timeout) (complete)3472959SAT 11.3113 11.3134
EBGlucose 1.0 (incomplete)3290231SAT 11.6922 11.6929
glueminisat 2.2.5 (complete)3290229SAT 11.8292 11.8295
CryptoMiniSat TechDemo-Alpha-st (complete)3290207SAT 12.5591 12.5702
QuteRSat 2011-05-12 (fixed) (complete)3377034SAT 13.07 13.0758
CryptoMiniSat Strange-Night2-st [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290209SAT 13.9579 13.9576
CryptoMiniSat Strange-Night2-st (fixed) (complete)3368334SAT 14.0799 14.0811
rcl 2011-04-01 (complete)3290223SAT 14.6648 14.6673
minisat hack: minisat_psm 2011-04-01 (complete)3348886SAT 14.9677 14.9718
SApperloT2010 2011-05-15 (fixed) (complete)3380034SAT 15.5796 15.5808
borg-sat 11.03.02-par-industrial (fixed) (complete)3378834SAT 16.6035 4.83699
Satisfiability Solver Selector 2011-03-18 (complete)3290228SAT 17.53 17.6418
priss Auto (complete)3290216SAT 17.5973 4.44076
riss Exp (complete)3290213SAT 23.9744 23.9741
MPhaseSAT 2011-02-15 (complete)3290191SAT 25.8391 25.8397
SAT09 reference solver:LySAT i/2009-03-20 (complete)3308976SAT 27.4428 27.4434
UmSat 2011-05-12 (fixed) (complete)3379434SAT 28.1827 28.1868
SApperloT2010 2011-03-04 [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290232SAT 28.2958 14.2067
PicoSAT 941 (complete)3290218SAT 29.0716 29.0723
priss UP (complete)3290215SAT 33.5609 18.8043
priss 1.0 (complete)3290217SAT 34.9217 8.75179
minisat hack: LR_NOGL_NOSHR 2011-03-02 (complete)3349786SAT 35.7346 35.7394
march_rw 2011-03-02 (complete)3290194SAT 43.1364 43.1351
SAT4J core 2.3.0 SNAPSHOT 2011-02-06 (complete)3290225SAT 44.1853 44.1204
Satisfiability Solver Selector 2011-03-18 (1200 s timeout) (complete)3449728SAT 53.9308 54.3543
CryptoMiniSat TechDemo-Alpha-mt (complete)3290206SAT 58.4001 14.7845
SAT09 reference solver:glucose 1.0 (complete)3308975SAT 63.7603 63.7641
Sol 2011-04-04 (complete)3290222SAT 67.4407 67.1813
sathys 2011-04-01 (complete)3290224SAT 68.3296 68.3343
SApperloT 2011-03-23 (complete)3290234SAT 177.706 177.703
MPhaseSAT64 2011-05-14 (fixed) (complete)3375834SAT 715.085 715.069
MPhaseSAT64 2011-03-03 [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290192SAT 943.697 943.688
sattime2011 2011-03-02 (incomplete)3290195? (TO) 1300 1300.01
sattime 2011-03-02 (incomplete)3290196? (TO) 1300.03 1300.01
Black Hole SAT 2011-03-08 (complete)3290205? (TO) 1300.04 1300.01
shortsattime+ 2011-03-02 (incomplete)3290200? (TO) 1300.04 1300.01
shortsattime2011 2011-03-02 (incomplete)3290197? (TO) 1300.05 1300.01
sattime+ 2011-03-02 (incomplete)3290201? (TO) 1300.05 1300.01
adaptg2wsat2011 2011-03-02 (incomplete)3290199? (TO) 1300.07 1300.01
STRUCTure 0.1 (hbr=2) (complete)3312158? (TO) 4800.22 1207.63
STRUCTure 0.1 (complete)3313358? (TO) 4800.28 1207.73
UmSat 2011-02-25 [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290204Signal 0.010997 0.011677
SArTagnan 2011-03-24 [DEPRECATED] (complete)3290233Wrong Cert. 28.2667 7.08136

Additionnal information

This section presents information obtained from the best job displayed in the list (i.e. solvers whose names are not hidden).

Solution found:
-1 2 -3 4 5 6 7 8 9 -10 11 12 13 -14 -15 16 17 18 -19 -20 21 -22 23 24 25 -26 -27 -28 -29 30 -31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 -39 -40 -41 -42 -43
-44 -45 46 47 48 -49 -50 -51 -52 53 54 -55 56 -57 -58 -59 60 61 62 -63 -64 -65 66 -67 68 69 -70 -71 -72 73 74 -75 -76 77 -78 79 80 81 82 83
-84 85 -86 87 -88 89 90 91 92 -93 94 95 -96 97 -98 99 -100 -101 -102 103 104 105 -106 107 108 109 110 111 -112 113 114 -115 -116 -117 118
119 -120 121 -122 -123 124 125 -126 -127 128 129 130 131 132 133 -134 135 -136 -137 138 -139 -140 -141 -142 143 -144 -145 -146 -147 148 149
150 151 152 -153 -154 -155 -156 -157 158 -159 -160 161 162 -163 164 -165 166 167 168 169 170 -171 172 -173 -174 -175 -176 177 178 -179 180
181 182 -183 184 185 186 -187 -188 -189 -190 -191 192 -193 194 -195 -196 -197 198 -199 -200 201 -202 -203 204 -205 206 -207 -208 -209 210
-211 -212 213 -214 -215 216 217 -218 -219 -220 221 -222 -223 -224 -225 -226 -227 228 229 230 -231 -232 -233 234 -235 236 237 238 239 240 241
-242 243 -244 -245 -246 247 248 -249 250 251 252 253 254 255 -256 257 -258 -259 -260 -261 262 -263 264 -265 -266 267 -268 269 -270 -271 -272
273 -274 275 276 -277 -278 279 -280 -281 282 283 -284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 -293 -294 295 296 297 -298 299 -300 301 -302 303 304
305 -306 307 308 -309 310 -311 -312 -313 -314 315 316 -317 318 319 -320 -321 322 323 -324 -325 326 -327 328 -329 330 -331 -332 333 334 335
-336 -337 -338 339 -340 341 342 -343 -344 345 346 -347 348 349 -350 351 -352 -353 -354 355 -356 357 358 -359 360 361 -362 -363 364 -365 -366
367 -368 369 370 -371 -372 -373 -374 375 -376 377 378 -379 -380 -381 382 -383 384 385 386 387 388 -389 -390 -391 -392 393 394 -395 -396 -397
398 399 400 -401 -402 403 404 405 406 -407 408 409 410 -411 412 -413 414 -415 -416 -417 -418 -419 -420 421 422 -423 424 -425 -426 -427 -428
-429 -430 431 -432 433 -434 -435 436 437 -438 439 440 441 442 443 -444 -445 446 447 448 -449 450 -451 -452 -453 454 455 -456 457 -458 -459
460 -461 462 -463 464 465 466 -467 -468 469 -470 -471 472 473 -474 -475 -476 -477 478 -479 -480 -481 -482 -483 484 -485 -486 487 -488 -489
-490 491 492 493 -494 495 496 497 -498 499 500 -501 -502 503 504 0