SAT 2009 Competition: main competition (phase 1): solvers results per benchmarks

Result page for benchmark
CRAFTED/parity-games/
instance_n4_i4_pp.cnf

Jump to solvers results

General information on the benchmark

NameCRAFTED/parity-games/
instance_n4_i4_pp.cnf
MD5SUMd35b54498d8d9672e60bf7e3ce33352b
Bench CategoryCRAFTED (crafted instances)
Best result obtained on this benchmarkSAT
Best CPU time to get the best result obtained on this benchmark0.022995
Satisfiable
(Un)Satisfiability was proved
Number of variables1572
Number of clauses9007
Sum of the clauses size28496
Maximum clause length12
Minimum clause length2
Number of clauses of size 10
Number of clauses of size 22356
Number of clauses of size 33596
Number of clauses of size 42300
Number of clauses of size 5752
Number of clauses of size over 53

Results of the different solvers on this benchmark

Solver NameTraceIDAnswerCPU timeWall clock time
SApperloT hrp (complete)1736501SAT 0.022995 0.0236681
picosat 913 (complete)1736497SAT 0.024995 0.0250319
MiniSat 2.1 (Sat-race'08 Edition) (complete)1736533SAT 0.038993 0.038903
SApperloT base (complete)1736500SAT 0.039993 0.039576
MXC 2009-03-10 (complete)1736495SAT 0.043993 0.0437421
clasp 1.2.0-SAT09-32 (complete)1736499SAT 0.051992 0.054044
glucose 1.0 (complete)1736494SAT 0.062989 0.0639079
Rsat 2009-03-22 (complete)1736532SAT 0.063989 0.0653599
MiniSAT 09z 2009-03-22 (complete)1834158SAT 0.065989 0.0670421
SAT07 reference solver: minisat SAT 2007 (complete)1613306SAT 0.079987 0.0796351
SATzilla2009_I 2009-03-22 (complete)1736517SAT 0.080986 0.0820069
VARSAT-crafted 2009-03-22 (complete)1736525SAT 0.081986 0.0820021
CircUs 2009-03-23 (complete)1736531SAT 0.084986 0.085708
VARSAT-industrial 2009-03-22 (complete)1736526SAT 0.085986 0.086154
ManySAT 1.1 aimd 0/2009-03-20 (complete)1736504SAT 0.089985 0.0785659
ManySAT 1.1 aimd 1/2009-03-20 (complete)1736505SAT 0.089985 0.078555
minisat_cumr p-2009-03-18 (complete)1834157SAT 0.092984 0.0956201
ManySAT 1.1 aimd 2/2009-03-20 (complete)1736506SAT 0.099984 0.083498
precosat 236 (complete)1736498SAT 0.099984 0.101172
LySAT i/2009-03-20 (complete)1736502SAT 0.101983 0.104222
CSat 2009-03-22 (complete)1736508SAT 0.101983 0.102253
kw 2009-03-20 (complete)1736492SAT 0.101983 0.103011
LySAT c/2009-03-20 (complete)1736503SAT 0.103983 0.106316
satake 2009-03-22 (complete)1736540SAT 0.104983 0.0662791
HydraSAT-Flat 2009-03-22-Flat (complete)1736510SAT 0.120981 0.121241
HydraSAT-Multi 2009-03-22-Multi (complete)1736509SAT 0.131979 0.132498
HydraSAT 2009-03-22-Base (complete)1736511SAT 0.134979 0.139784
IUT_BMB_SAT 1.0 (complete)1736514SAT 0.160975 0.406025
VARSAT-random 2009-03-22 (complete)1736527SAT 0.200969 0.201131
SAT07 reference solver: March KS 2007-02-08 (complete)1613308SAT 0.378941 0.379578
MoRsat 2009-03-03 (complete)1736493SAT 0.723889 0.723699
SAT4J CORE 2.1 RC1 (complete)1736491SAT 0.993848 0.685141
SATzilla2009_C 2009-03-22 (complete)1736516SAT 1.40679 1.40791
SAT07 reference solver: SATzilla CRAFTED (complete)1613307SAT 1.41078 1.41161
march_nn nn (complete)1736513SAT 2.50762 2.50901
march_hi hi (complete)1736512SAT 2.74358 2.74404
tts tts-5-0 (complete)1736496SAT 9.36258 9.36571
iPAWS 2009-03-22 (incomplete)1736507SAT 23.3444 23.3506
SATzilla2009_R 2009-03-22 (complete)1736515SAT 30.0824 30.0957
ttsth-5-0 2009-03-19 (complete)1736536SAT 33.9348 17.1611
slstc 1.0 (incomplete)1736528SAT 293.667 293.775
NCVWr 2009-03-22 (incomplete)1736519SAT 365.777 365.874
TNM 2009-03-22 (incomplete)1736520? (TO) 1200.03 1200.51
hybridGM3 3 (incomplete)1736522? (TO) 1200.04 1200.41
gnovelty+2-H 2009-03-22 (incomplete)1736534? (TO) 1200.05 1200.41
gnovelty+2 2009-03-22 (incomplete)1736535? (TO) 1200.05 1200.51
hybridGM7 7 (incomplete)1736523? (TO) 1200.06 1200.41
adaptg2wsat2009++ 2009-03-23 (incomplete)1736530? (TO) 1200.08 1200.51
adaptg2wsat2009 2009-03-23 (incomplete)1736529? (TO) 1200.09 1200.41
Hybrid2 2009-03-22 (incomplete)1736518? (TO) 1200.09 1200.41
gnovelty+ 2009-03-22 (incomplete)1736524? (TO) 1200.1 1200.42
hybridGM 1 (incomplete)1736521? (TO) 1200.11 1200.61
gNovelty+-T 2009-03-22 (incomplete)1736537? (TO) 1200.2 601.63
gNovelty+-V.2-T-H 2009-03-22 (incomplete)1736538Signal 3.9484 2.04826
gNovelty+-V.2-T 2009-03-22 (incomplete)1736539Signal 109.618 55.0002

Additionnal information

This section presents information obtained from the best job displayed in the list (i.e. solvers whose names are not hidden).

Solution found:
1 -2 -3 -4 -5 6 7 8 9 -10 11 12 13 14 15 16 -17 18 19 20 21 22 -23 24 -25 26 -27 28 -29 -30 31 -32 33 -34 35 36 37 -38 -39 40 -41 -42 43 44
45 -46 47 48 -49 -50 -51 -52 53 54 -55 -56 57 58 -59 -60 -61 -62 -63 -64 65 -66 -67 -68 -69 70 71 -72 -73 -74 -75 76 77 -78 79 -80 81 -82
-83 84 -85 -86 -87 -88 89 90 -91 -92 93 -94 -95 -96 -97 -98 -99 -100 101 102 -103 -104 105 106 107 -108 109 -110 111 112 -113 -114 -115 116
117 118 -119 120 -121 -122 -123 -124 125 126 -127 -128 129 -130 -131 132 -133 -134 135 -136 -137 -138 139 140 141 -142 -143 144 145 -146 147
148 149 -150 151 -152 -153 154 155 156 157 -158 159 -160 -161 -162 163 -164 -165 -166 167 168 169 -170 171 -172 -173 174 175 176 -177 178
179 -180 -181 182 -183 184 185 186 187 -188 189 -190 -191 -192 193 -194 195 196 197 -198 199 -200 -201 202 203 204 -205 206 -207 208 -209
-210 -211 -212 -213 -214 215 -216 -217 -218 -219 -220 -221 222 -223 -224 -225 226 227 -228 -229 230 -231 -232 233 -234 -235 -236 237 -238
-239 -240 241 -242 -243 -244 -245 -246 -247 -248 -249 -250 -251 -252 -253 254 -255 -256 -257 -258 259 -260 261 -262 -263 -264 -265 266 267
-268 -269 -270 -271 -272 -273 -274 275 -276 -277 -278 -279 280 -281 282 -283 284 -285 286 -287 -288 -289 290 -291 -292 -293 294 295 -296
-297 -298 299 -300 -301 302 303 304 -305 306 -307 -308 309 310 -311 312 -313 314 -315 -316 317 -318 -319 -320 321 322 323 -324 -325 326 327
-328 -329 330 -331 -332 -333 -334 335 336 337 338 -339 -340 -341 -342 -343 -344 -345 346 347 -348 349 350 351 352 353 -354 355 356 357 358
-359 -360 -361 -362 -363 364 -365 -366 367 -368 -369 -370 371 -372 -373 -374 375 -376 377 -378 379 380 381 -382 -383 -384 -385 386 -387 -388
389 -390 -391 392 393 394 -395 -396 -397 398 399 -400 -401 -402 -403 -404 405 406 407 408 -409 -410 -411 412 -413 -414 -415 -416 -417 418
-419 -420 -421 -422 -423 424 -425 426 -427 428 429 -430 -431 -432 -433 -434 435 436 -437 438 -439 -440 441 442 443 444 445 446 -447 448 449
-450 -451 -452 -453 -454 -455 -456 -457 458 459 460 -461 -462 463 464 -465 466 467 -468 -469 -470 -471 -472 -473 -474 475 -476 -477 478 479
480 481 482 483 -484 -485 -486 -487 -488 -489 490 -491 492 493 -494 495 -496 -497 -498 -499 -500 501 502 -503 -504 -505 506 507 -508 -509
-510 511 -512 -513 514 -515 516 -517 518 -519 -520 521 -522 523 524 -525 526 -527 -528 529 -530 -531 -532 533 534 -535 536 -537 538 539 540
-541 -542 -543 -544 -545 -546 -547 -548 -549 550 551 552 -553 -554 555 -556 -557 558 559 -560 -561 -562 -563 -564 -565 566 -567 -568 569 570
571 572 -573 574 575 -576 577 -578 579 -580 581 -582 -583 -584 -585 586 587 588 589 -590 591 592 593 -594 -595 -596 -597 -598 -599 600 601
-602 -603 -604 -605 -606 -607 -608 -609 -610 -611 -612 -613 614 -615 -616 -617 618 -619 -620 621 -622 623 624 -625 626 -627 628 -629 -630
631 632 -633 -634 635 -636 637 -638 -639 -640 641 -642 -643 -644 645 646 647 648 -649 -650 651 -652 653 654 -655 -656 -657 -658 659 -660 661
-662 -663 -664 -665 -666 667 -668 -669 -670 -671 -672 -673 -674 675 676 -677 -678 -679 -680 681 682 -683 -684 685 686 -687 688 689 -690 691
-692 -693 -694 695 696 -697 698 -699 700 -701 702 703 704 705 706 -707 -708 709 710 -711 712 713 714 715 716 -717 718 719 720 -721 -722 723
724 -725 -726 -727 -728 -729 730 -731 -732 -733 734 -735 -736 -737 -738 -739 740 741 742 -743 -744 -745 746 -747 -748 749 750 751 752 -753
-754 -755 -756 -757 -758 -759 -760 761 -762 763 764 765 -766 767 768 769 -770 771 -772 -773 774 775 -776 -777 -778 -779 -780 -781 -782 -783
-784 -785 -786 -787 788 789 790 791 -792 -793 794 -795 796 797 -798 799 -800 -801 802 -803 -804 -805 -806 -807 -808 -809 -810 -811 812 -813
814 -815 -816 817 -818 819 -820 821 -822 -823 -824 825 -826 827 -828 829 830 -831 -832 -833 -834 835 -836 837 -838 -839 840 -841 842 -843
-844 -845 -846 -847 -848 -849 -850 -851 852 -853 -854 855 -856 -857 858 -859 -860 861 -862 -863 -864 865 -866 867 -868 -869 -870 871 -872
873 874 -875 876 877 878 -879 880 881 -882 883 884 885 886 -887 -888 -889 -890 -891 -892 893 894 895 -896 -897 898 -899 -900 -901 -902 -903
-904 -905 -906 -907 -908 -909 -910 -911 -912 913 -914 915 -916 -917 -918 -919 -920 -921 -922 -923 -924 925 -926 -927 928 929 -930 -931 -932
-933 -934 -935 -936 -937 -938 -939 -940 941 -942 -943 -944 -945 946 -947 -948 -949 950 -951 -952 -953 954 -955 956 -957 958 959 -960 -961
962 -963 -964 -965 -966 -967 968 -969 -970 -971 -972 -973 -974 -975 -976 977 -978 -979 -980 -981 -982 -983 -984 -985 -986 -987 -988 -989 990
-991 -992 -993 -994 -995 -996 -997 -998 -999 -1000 -1001 -1002 -1003 -1004 1005 -1006 -1007 -1008 -1009 -1010 -1011 1012 1013 -1014 -1015
-1016 -1017 1018 -1019 -1020 1021 -1022 -1023 -1024 -1025 1026 -1027 -1028 -1029 -1030 -1031 -1032 -1033 -1034 -1035 -1036 -1037 -1038 1039
-1040 -1041 -1042 -1043 -1044 -1045 -1046 -1047 -1048 -1049 -1050 -1051 -1052 -1053 -1054 -1055 -1056 -1057 1058 -1059 -1060 -1061 1062 1063
-1064 1065 -1066 1067 -1068 1069 1070 -1071 1072 1073 1074 1075 -1076 -1077 1078 -1079 -1080 -1081 -1082 -1083 -1084 -1085 -1086 -1087 -1088
-1089 -1090 1091 1092 1093 -1094 -1095 -1096 -1097 1098 1099 1100 1101 -1102 -1103 1104 -1105 -1106 -1107 1108 1109 1110 -1111 -1112 -1113
-1114 -1115 -1116 -1117 1118 -1119 -1120 -1121 1122 1123 -1124 -1125 -1126 -1127 -1128 -1129 -1130 -1131 -1132 -1133 -1134 -1135 -1136 -1137
-1138 -1139 -1140 -1141 -1142 -1143 1144 -1145 -1146 -1147 -1148 -1149 -1150 -1151 -1152 -1153 -1154 1155 -1156 -1157 -1158 -1159 1160 -1161
1162 -1163 -1164 -1165 -1166 -1167 -1168 -1169 1170 1171 1172 1173 1174 -1175 1176 -1177 -1178 -1179 -1180 1181 1182 1183 -1184 -1185 -1186
-1187 -1188 -1189 -1190 -1191 -1192 -1193 1194 -1195 1196 -1197 -1198 1199 -1200 1201 -1202 -1203 -1204 -1205 -1206 1207 1208 -1209 -1210
1211 -1212 -1213 -1214 -1215 -1216 -1217 1218 -1219 -1220 -1221 -1222 -1223 -1224 -1225 -1226 1227 -1228 -1229 -1230 -1231 -1232 -1233 1234
-1235 -1236 -1237 -1238 -1239 -1240 -1241 -1242 -1243 -1244 -1245 -1246 -1247 -1248 -1249 -1250 -1251 -1252 -1253 -1254 1255 1256 -1257
-1258 -1259 -1260 -1261 -1262 1263 -1264 -1265 -1266 1267 -1268 1269 1270 1271 -1272 -1273 -1274 1275 1276 1277 1278 1279 -1280 -1281 -1282
-1283 -1284 -1285 1286 -1287 -1288 -1289 -1290 -1291 -1292 -1293 -1294 -1295 1296 1297 -1298 1299 -1300 -1301 -1302 -1303 -1304 -1305 -1306
-1307 -1308 1309 1310 -1311 -1312 1313 1314 -1315 1316 -1317 -1318 -1319 -1320 -1321 -1322 -1323 -1324 -1325 -1326 -1327 -1328 -1329 -1330
-1331 1332 1333 1334 -1335 -1336 -1337 -1338 -1339 -1340 -1341 -1342 -1343 -1344 -1345 -1346 -1347 -1348 1349 -1350 -1351 -1352 1353 -1354
-1355 -1356 -1357 -1358 -1359 -1360 -1361 -1362 -1363 -1364 -1365 -1366 -1367 -1368 -1369 -1370 -1371 -1372 -1373 -1374 -1375 -1376 -1377
1378 1379 1380 -1381 -1382 1383 1384 -1385 -1386 1387 -1388 -1389 -1390 -1391 1392 1393 1394 1395 -1396 1397 1398 1399 -1400 -1401 -1402
-1403 -1404 -1405 -1406 -1407 -1408 1409 1410 1411 1412 -1413 1414 1415 1416 -1417 -1418 -1419 -1420 -1421 -1422 -1423 -1424 -1425 -1426
-1427 -1428 -1429 -1430 -1431 -1432 -1433 -1434 -1435 -1436 1437 -1438 -1439 1440 -1441 -1442 -1443 -1444 -1445 -1446 -1447 -1448 -1449
-1450 1451 1452 1453 1454 1455 -1456 1457 -1458 1459 -1460 1461 1462 1463 1464 1465 -1466 -1467 -1468 -1469 -1470 1471 1472 1473 1474 1475
-1476 -1477 -1478 -1479 1480 1481 1482 1483 1484 1485 -1486 1487 -1488 -1489 1490 1491 1492 1493 1494 1495 -1496 -1497 -1498 1499 -1500 1501
1502 1503 1504 1505 -1506 -1507 -1508 1509 -1510 1511 1512 1513 1514 1515 -1516 -1517 1518 -1519 -1520 1521 1522 1523 1524 1525 -1526 -1527
1528 -1529 -1530 1531 1532 1533 1534 1535 -1536 1537 -1538 -1539 1540 1541 1542 1543 1544 1545 -1546 -1547 1548 1549 -1550 1551 1552 1553
1554 1555 -1556 -1557 1558 -1559 1560 1561 1562 1563 1564 1565 -1566 1567 -1568 1569 1570 1571 1572  0