CSP 2009 Competition: solvers results per benchmarks

Result page for benchmark
csp/fapp/fapp32/
normalized-fapp32-0550-6.xml

Jump to solvers results

General information on the benchmark

Namecsp/fapp/fapp32/
normalized-fapp32-0550-6.xml
MD5SUM35433b7323a58295c09c0516097c5775
Bench Category2-ARY-INT (binary constraints in intension)
Best result obtained on this benchmarkSAT
Best CPU time to get the best result obtained on this benchmark33.8249
Satisfiable
(Un)Satisfiability was proved
Number of variables550
Number of constraints9461
Maximum constraint arity2
Maximum domain size998
Number of constraints which are defined in extension0
Number of constraints which are defined in intension9461
Global constraints used (with number of constraints)

Results of the different solvers on this benchmark

Solver NameTraceIDAnswerCPU timeWall clock time
Abscon 112v4 AC (complete)2097865SAT 33.8249 34.0479
Abscon 112v4 ESAC (complete)2097866SAT 35.1727 35.5357
Concrete 2009-07-14 (complete)2083684SAT 333.35 336.54
SAT4J CSP 2.1.1 (complete)2083681? 0.601908 0.688388
Concrete DC 2009-07-14 (complete)2083685? 363.218 366.682
bpsolver 09 (complete)2083691? (exit code) 64.9861 65.2504
Sugar v1.14.6+minisat (complete)2083688? (MO) 370.273 375.544
Sugar v1.14.6+picosat (complete)2083687? (MO) 588.85 598.591
Mistral 1.545 (complete)2083690? (TO) 1800.03 1808.01
pcs-restart 0.3.2 (complete)2083683? (TO) 1800.06 1800.63
pcs 0.3.2 (complete)2083682? (TO) 1800.09 1802.13
Choco2.1.1b 2009-07-16 (complete)2116844? (TO) 1800.13 1800.83
Choco2.1.1 2009-06-10 (complete)2083686? (TO) 1800.13 1801.29

Additionnal information

This section presents information obtained from the best job displayed in the list (i.e. solvers whose names are not hidden).

Solution found:
-3780 2452 2148 -3452 3948 -2808 3468 -2804 -2832 -2224 -2820 3160 -4100 2580 -2848 -2224 3808 -3324 -3692 -2620 -2892 3572 -3976 2168 -3400
3224 -4028 2984 -3832 2208 -4084 -2844 3376 2788 -3432 -2172 -3036 3180 2732 -2660 3808 -2968 -2772 -4060 -2172 2828 3644 -2228 3448 -2268
-4100 2616 3884 -2112 2744 2808 3664 4060 3756 -3400 2880 2932 3812 -3920 -3040 -2472 3392 2848 -2512 -2432 -2620 -2660 2472 -2264 -2188
-2452 -2780 -2676 2956 2132 3656 3220 2440 -2152 -2268 -2288 -3768 -2708 -3328 2108 -3400 -3872 3084 -2660 -2180 -3360 3068 -2472 3096 -2884
-2964 -2884 -2432 -2780 3916 -3936 -2660 -4088 -2152 -3996 3476 3740 -2844 -2224 4020 2144 3028 -3892 -2276 -3400 -3360 2816 2148 4060 -3432
3756 -2660 -2660 -2844 2132 -3872 3032 2172 -2112 2108 2856 -3400 -2240 -2300 -2624 3592 -2884 -2224 2764 -2620 -2224 -3776 3948 -4040 -4044
-2632 -2660 2140 -2176 2764 3984 2808 2780 3652 -3908 -2636 -3716 2936 2164 -3064 -2172 -3400 2260 2932 3468 -4036 3584 3644 -2664 -2772
-3360 -3360 -3768 3468 -2764 -3736 -2160 2744 -2836 -2424 2660 3824 -3908 3184 -3360 4060 -2804 3224 -2620 -2856 -2884 3200 3508 -3360 2140
3884 -2844 -2844 -4100 -2264 2572 -3284 2124 -2844 2744 2832 -3284 2580 -2264 -3612 -3288 2872 2492 -2200 -2148 -3816 -4044 -2308 -4096
-2264 2228 -3508 3924 3100 -4028 -3260 -3544 3280 2132 -4060 -2620 -2184 3140 2208 3488 2992 2996 -3684 3684 -2844 3096 -3324 -2884 -3972
2764 -3716 -3852 3436 3696 3808 -2184 -2480 -2176 3280 -2868 -3400 -2620 2648 -3360 3072 -2128 -2620 3896 2940 3808 3376 -2108 -3360 3632
-3324 2708 -3136 -2432 -3284 2520 -3416 -2788 -2884 -2512 2260 -2884 2108 -2268 -3508 2420 -3832 -3400 -4100 3372 -4060 -2480 -4076 2136
4092 3876 2852 -2820 2376 -2268 -2820 3136 4048 -3360 3980 -2844 -3080 -2652 3284 -4100 2996 -2268 4080 -2160 2520 -3400 -2620 3900 2996
2956 2496 -3328 2688 -3848 -2228 -3400 3136 2172 2980 3208 -3360 -2656 2896 -2748 -2412 -2188 -3360 -2792 2384 2996 -3544 -2804 -2308 -2620
3584 2784 -2228 3024 -2188 -2264 3288 -2248 4068 -2244 -2264 -2884 -3284 -3936 -3400 -3320 -3780 -2168 -2312 -2884 3436 -3848 3936 -2664
-2268 2804 -3124 2200 -2224 2164 2608 2704 -2148 2668 -2264 -3400 3684 3324 3984 -3400 -2840 -3932 3496 3028 -2148 -2264 -2224 -3400 2732
-2228 -2120 3492 3240 2784 -3328 4044 -3324 4024 -2416 2132 2612 -2660 3140 -2540 3836 -2228 -3864 -2844 -3400 4024 -3864 3412 -2224 -2272
3696 -3856 -2300 -2748 2168 -2748 2904 -3288 3180 3096 -3360 3120 -2876 -3360 2472 -2844 2132 -2848 -3476 3000 3024 4052 2248 3068 3824
-2916 -3360 2764 3900 -4060 4020 -2832 -3704 -2120 2648 -2804 -2268 -2816 -3360 3336 -3036 2228 2816 -2264 -3184 3940 -3400 2972 -4004 3816
2144 3860 -2540 -2620 -2268 -2264 -4096 4056 -2224 -2268 3168 -3820 3332 -2884 3452 -2688 -2264 -4100 -2160 -3852 -2472 3032 -2624 -2648
-2380 -2876 -2872 2592 2608 3140 -2284 3796 -2148 4068 -3360 3980 -4036 4020 2480 -2884 3632 -2236 -2844 2944 2924 -3996 2972 -2648 2208
-2856 3896 -2764 -2660 4056 3924 -2224 -3360 -2612 3456 2136 -3400 4036 2124 3008 -2148 -2456 -3400 3392 2804 -3360 -4004 3644 3144 3592
-2224 3880 -2180 3184