CSP 2009 Competition: solvers results per benchmarks

Result page for benchmark
csp/nengfa/
normalized-sudoku368.xml

Jump to solvers results

General information on the benchmark

Namecsp/nengfa/
normalized-sudoku368.xml
MD5SUM1929fd47e53207e47f93784218fb3b97
Bench CategoryAlldiff (alldiff)
Best result obtained on this benchmarkSAT
Best CPU time to get the best result obtained on this benchmark0.229964
Satisfiable
(Un)Satisfiability was proved
Number of variables1309
Number of constraints75
Maximum constraint arity25
Maximum domain size11
Number of constraints which are defined in extension0
Number of constraints which are defined in intension0
Global constraints used (with number of constraints)alldifferent(75)

Results of the different solvers on this benchmark

Solver NameTraceIDAnswerCPU timeWall clock time
Mistral 1.545 (complete)2078905SAT 0.229964 0.237338
Choco2.1.1b 2009-07-16 (complete)2116409SAT 1.2938 1.32666
Choco2.1.1 2009-06-10 (complete)2078901SAT 1.40479 1.44592
SAT4J CSP 2.1.1 (complete)2078896SAT 2.5926 2.66234
Abscon 112v4 AC (complete)2096995SAT 2.87256 2.92495
Sugar v1.14.6+minisat (complete)2078903SAT 3.78043 3.84161
Sugar v1.14.6+picosat (complete)2078902SAT 4.33734 4.46758
Concrete 2009-07-14 (complete)2078899SAT 8.30874 8.40873
bpsolver 09 (complete)2078906SAT 9.31458 9.42529
Abscon 112v4 ESAC (complete)2096996SAT 16.4885 16.7243
Concrete DC 2009-07-14 (complete)2078900SAT 31.4252 31.4126

Additionnal information

This section presents information obtained from the best job displayed in the list (i.e. solvers whose names are not hidden).

Solution found:
5 18 7 12 4 23 0 19 11 21 23 7 18 1 2 19 6 15 7 18 19 20 0 13 1 19 3 16 9 23 0 10 1 5 13 17 20 22 7 12 22 11 5 13 2 3 16 6 19 12 4 18 9 23
21 21 0 22 8 11 20 15 6 19 3 16 17 1 5 13 24 7 12 18 24 4 6 15 16 2 9 0 14 8 22 20 11 5 1 21 23 10 12 18 4 19 2 1 17 5 24 12 8 11 22 20 15 3
23 21 9 0 19 16 3 6 21 0 9 10 23 7 24 18 11 20 14 13 17 2 7 4 1 11 10 21 19 4 12 7 14 20 11 8 0 21 10 23 16 19 15 5 13 18 18 12 1 5 22 11 14
16 23 16 19 3 20 22 8 11 14 10 23 21 9 13 17 2 4 24 18 12 1 17 5 19 3 24 12 21 10 11 21 10 1 2 5 8 20 18 4 12 16 22 8 11 24 4 7 17 2 13 1 15
16 3 10 21 9 18 12 7 4 24 23 9 0 3 19 8 14 11 20 22 2 5 13 14 20 22 8 9 0 23 21 13 1 12 18 16 13 5 4 0 21 14 13 1 23 21 7 4 24 12 7 20 14 8
13 1 9 23 0 24 7 16 22 8 14 17 1 2 5 2 1 13 17 24 21 9 10 6 3 16 15 8 14 20 22 0 9 10 20 11 8 14 22 4 12 24 13 5 17 16 3 4 12 24 16 3 6 15
14 11 8 22 9 21 23 10 5 2 17 6 15 21 2 11 14 8 18 4 24 14 20 8 17 1 15 24 7 10 0 10 23 9 14 2 18 4 12 7 3 19 5 17 1 13 23 10 21 11 14 8 22
20 2 17 13 9 0 7 24 3 6 15 16 13 18 7 4 14 6 19 16 10 15 4 12 22 8 1 5 19 3 16 15 6 12 24 18 1 5 13 17 2 21 9 0 10 23 11 14 20 22 8 17 5 13
2 22 14 20 8 10 9 21 0 23 24 12 7 4 18 15 3 19 16 6 0 9 23 15 16 3 6 24 18 22 20 14 11 8 17 13 5 1 2 22 9 3 6 1 17 2 12 4 7 24 4 24 7 13 2
17 20 8 6 15 19 3 0 10 21 9 15 6 0 1 5 7 13 2 15 16 6 7 4 18 0 23 9 22 20 8 14 23 0 9 17 13 11 22 14 7 24 19 6 15 3 20 14 18 12 5 6 19 23 0
21 10 6 16 15 1 17 11 3 16 15 6 19 10 5 17 2 4 24 7 6 3 15 19 2 17 1 18 12 24 7 23 9 10 8 20 22 11 2 17 5 10 0 9 8 22 20 14 11 18 24 4 12 6
15 16 3 19 18 22 11 17 5 2 16 15 3 6 19 0 10 23 21 10 21 9 18 12 4 15 19 6 3 11 20 13 2 1 13 17 0 9 10 4 12 24 6 15 14 20 8 24 20 11 8 14 22
16 3 6 15 21 17 1 21 9 10 4 12 24 14 11 8 22 2 15 6 3 16 15 13 5 17 9 21 23 10 11 14 8 24 7 8 14 20 22 16 3 5 2 17 18 4 24 10 0 10 23 9 12 7
14 8 22 20 13 15 14 3 19 2 17 13 18 7 4 5 17 1 13 9 0 14 4 12 2 23 10 21 7 24 6 19 16 22 8 18 4 11 3 6 15 16 10 1 5 19 3 16 15 6 17 5 13 2 0
9 23 22 4 24 7 12 24 18 22 14 20 8 15 16 3 6 9 13 2 17 1 5 13 17 2 10 9 21 0 23 24 18 3 6 20 8 21 9 0 10 23 24 12 7 4 18 22 20 14 11 8 1 17
2 6 15 19 3 11 14 20 22 8 15 3 19 16 6 17 13 5 1 2 12 4 7 24 0 10 21 9 15 6 13 2 23 0 9 20 14 15 16 6 17 13 18 12 21 10 0 7 4 18 11 22 14 5
6 16 15 1 5 0 23 9 7 24 6 19 7 22 20 8 14 19 6 15 3 23 0 1 17 11 6 3 15 19 2 17 5 18 10 21 9 3 16 15 6 19 2 17 1 10 0 9 22 11 18 12 4 10 18
12 24 7 8 22 20 14 11 17 5 2 15 19 6 3 5 17 2 23 9 10 18 24 4 12 16 15 3 6 19 11 20 4 24 7 8 20 22 11 6 15 16 3 19 0 10 23 21 13 2 6 8 10 19
1 21 11 0 3 5 1 21 23 2 18 3 12 5 9 14 15 16 4 9 3 14 16 13 0 20 6 15 10 17 24 13 16 20 9 14 15 24 17 10 22 1 7 6 2 17 24 10 15 22 4 6 18 2
23 8 5 11 19 7 0 20 4 13 16 12 3 5 17 22 10 24 15 7 6 2 18 23 8 11 23 5 14 9 12 3 15 22 20 8 17 10 21 7 19 13 16 4 0 20 3 12 9 9 14 12 5 3 7
19 1 21 11 13 20 0 4 16 2 6 18 23 8 15 17 24 10 22 10 22 24 17 13 2 8 23 18 6 9 14 19 1 7 11 4 16 14 9 3 15 24 22 17 11 7 19 2 8 18 6 12 3
14 9 5 7 0 16 20 13 23 6 17 10 22 24 15 11 21 8 2 6 9 3 14 5 17 22 24 15 0 20 4 16 6 8 23 2 22 17 24 15 11 1 0 13 5 9 14 12 3 24 15 22 10 17
20 13 0 16 23 6 18 8 2 9 14 3 11 19 21 11 18 6 9 3 12 16 0 14 7 19 4 18 6 23 22 17 15 10 6 2 8 18 10 1 7 20 0 5 3 4 14 22 17 24 19 18 2 6 23
15 24 13 4 16 6 2 14 12 5 11 19 21 14 1 4 13 20 0 6 10 15 17 15 24 10 4 2 8 6 21 19 11 20 0 12 5 24 17 15 10 21 1 18 6 8 15 22 7 19 21 16 9
12 3 1 7 8 3 9 10 15 17 4 20 13