PB'12 competition: satisfaction and optimization track: results by benchmark

Results by benchmark for category optimisation, small integers, linear constraints (OPT-SMALLINT-LIN), subcategory Handmade, subsubcategory Routing

This page displays the results of the different solvers for each benchmark for category optimisation, small integers, linear constraints (OPT-SMALLINT-LIN), subcategory Handmade, subsubcategory Routing

REMINDER

Keep in mind that the 'Best result' columns only provide the best result given by one of the solvers. This 'Best result' may be wrong in case of an UNSATISFIABLE or OPTIMUM FOUND answer (because there's no efficient way to check these answers).

Description of a cell contents:

Cell example	Meaning
Answer	Solver result
f=...	value of the objective function for the model reported by the solver
TT=...	Total Time (TT): this is the CPU time (in seconds) used by the solver until termination. This time is only meaningful for complete solvers because incomplete solvers will always run until they time out

Remember that CPU time and wall clock time are two very different notions. The CPU time represents the time during which the instructions of the solver were executed by the processor. The wall clock time represents how much time ellapsed on the clock. For a same event, the CPU time may be either smaller or greater than the wall clock time depending on the number of threads of execution and the number of processors.

Meaning of some abbreviations:

Abbreviation	Meaning
f=...	Value of the objective function
TO	Time Out
MO	Mem. Out (out of memory)

Meaning of the different colors:

Color	Meaning
text	the solver cannot handle this instance
text	the solver gave no answer
text	the solver could give an answer (SAT)
text	the solver gave a definitive answer (OPTIMUM FOUND or UNSAT)
text	the solver performed better than the other ones on that instance (complete solvers point of view)
text	the solver performed better than the other ones on that instance (incomplete solvers point of view)
text	the solver was ended by a signal or other problem
text	the solver gave an incomplete answer
text	the solver gave a wrong answer

For better readability, you may choose to hide some solvers:
bsolo 3.2 (complete)
clasp 2.0.6-R5325 (opt) (complete)
npSolver 1.0 (complete)
npSolver 1.0 (fixed) (complete)
npSolver inc (complete)
npSolver inc (fixed) (complete)
npSolver inc-topDown (complete)
npSolver inc-topDown (fixed) (complete)
npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (complete)
npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed) (complete)
PB07: bsolo 3.0.17 (complete)
PB07: minisat+ 1.14 (complete)
PB07: PB-clasp 2007-04-10 (complete)
PB07: Pueblo 1.4 (incomplete)
PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution 2007-03-23 (complete)
PB09: bsolo 3.1 (complete)
PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution 2.1.1 (complete)
PB09: SCIPspx SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009) (complete)
PB10: pb_cplex 2010-06-29 (complete)
PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP 2.2.0 2010-05-31 (complete)
PB10: SCIPspx SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver (complete)
PB11: Sat4j Res//CP 2.3.0 (complete)
PB11: SCIP spx E_2 2011-06-10 (fixed) (complete)
PB12: minisatp 1.0-2-g022594c (complete)
pb2sat 2012-05-19 (complete)
pb2satCp2 2012-05-19 (complete)
pwbo 2.0 (complete)
pwbo 2.02 (complete)
SAT 4j PB RES // CP 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)
Sat 4j PB Resolution 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)
SAT4J PB specific settings 2.3.2 snapshot (complete)
SCIP spx SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)
SCIP spx E SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)
SCIP spx standard SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed (complete)
toysat 2012-05-17 (complete)
toysat 2012-06-01 (complete)
wbo 1.7 (complete)
wbo 1.72 (complete)

Bench name	Best results on this instance	bsolo 3.2 (complete)	clasp 2.0.6-R5325 (opt) (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc (complete)	npSolver inc (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed) (complete)	PB07: bsolo 3.0.17 (complete)	PB07: minisat+ 1.14 (complete)	PB07: PB-clasp 2007-04-10 (complete)	PB07: Pueblo 1.4 (incomplete)	PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution 2007-03-23 (complete)	PB09: bsolo 3.1 (complete)	PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution 2.1.1 (complete)	PB09: SCIPspx SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009) (complete)	PB10: pb_cplex 2010-06-29 (complete)	PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP 2.2.0 2010-05-31 (complete)	PB10: SCIPspx SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver (complete)	PB11: Sat4j Res//CP 2.3.0 (complete)	PB11: SCIP spx E_2 2011-06-10 (fixed) (complete)	PB12: minisatp 1.0-2-g022594c (complete)	pb2sat 2012-05-19 (complete)	pb2satCp2 2012-05-19 (complete)	pwbo 2.0 (complete)	pwbo 2.02 (complete)	SAT 4j PB RES // CP 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	Sat 4j PB Resolution 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	SAT4J PB specific settings 2.3.2 snapshot (complete)	SCIP spx SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx E SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx standard SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed (complete)	toysat 2012-05-17 (complete)	toysat 2012-06-01 (complete)	wbo 1.7 (complete)	wbo 1.72 (complete)
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s3-3-3-1pb.opb	OPT f=36 TT=0.003 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.01 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.006 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.146 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.156 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.109 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.105 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.056 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.055 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.059 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.059 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.019 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.09 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.074 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.009 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.483 T1=0.25	OPT f=36 TT=0.009 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.573 T1=0.22	OPT f=36 TT=0.037 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.019 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.875 T1=1.2	OPT f=36 TT=0.033 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.833 T1=0.71	OPT f=36 TT=0.04 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.049 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.109 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.043 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.003 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.004 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.802 T1=0.73	OPT f=36 TT=0.495 T1=0.25	OPT f=36 TT=0.575 T1=0.29	OPT f=36 TT=0.044 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.049 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.042 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.047 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.042 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.003 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.003 T1=0.01
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s3-3-3-2pb.opb	OPT f=36 TT=0.005 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.01 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.005 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.154 T1=0.06	OPT f=36 TT=0.168 T1=0.06	OPT f=36 TT=0.12 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.107 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.072 T1=0.06	OPT f=36 TT=0.063 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.071 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.066 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.017 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.102 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.074 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.013 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.574 T1=0.25	OPT f=36 TT=0.009 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.606 T1=0.27	OPT f=36 TT=0.042 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.022 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.994 T1=1.2	OPT f=36 TT=0.035 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.864 T1=0.72	OPT f=36 TT=0.046 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.049 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.121 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.048 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.044 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.044 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.834 T1=0.73	OPT f=36 TT=0.624 T1=0.31	OPT f=36 TT=0.633 T1=0.31	OPT f=36 TT=0.054 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.052 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.049 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.061 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.061 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.023 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.024 T1=0.01
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s3-3-3-3pb.opb	OPT f=36 TT=0.004 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.009 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.015 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.156 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.173 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.125 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.122 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.058 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.067 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.062 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.064 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.018 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.13 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.07 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.009 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.635 T1=0.29	OPT f=36 TT=0.009 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.645 T1=0.3	OPT f=36 TT=0.039 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.021 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=1.274 T1=1.21	OPT f=36 TT=0.036 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.963 T1=0.74	OPT f=36 TT=0.046 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.072 T1=0.07	OPT f=36 TT=0.135 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.053 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.043 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.043 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=1.254 T1=0.72	OPT f=36 TT=0.625 T1=0.31	OPT f=36 TT=0.646 T1=0.24	OPT f=36 TT=0.041 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.046 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.051 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.117 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.116 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.023 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.004 T1=0.01
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s3-3-3-4pb.opb	OPT f=36 TT=0.003 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.009 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.017 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.18 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.17 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.137 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.113 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.061 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.065 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.064 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.061 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.019 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.105 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.073 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.011 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.634 T1=0.2	OPT f=36 TT=0.008 T1=0	OPT f=36 TT=0.664 T1=0.23	OPT f=36 TT=0.038 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.02 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=1.385 T1=1.21	OPT f=36 TT=0.031 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=1.234 T1=0.72	OPT f=36 TT=0.042 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.057 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=0.148 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.053 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.004 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.003 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=1.225 T1=0.72	OPT f=36 TT=0.604 T1=0.21	OPT f=36 TT=0.613 T1=0.21	OPT f=36 TT=0.04 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.05 T1=0.04	OPT f=36 TT=0.045 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.121 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.121 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.004 T1=0.01	OPT f=36 TT=0.004 T1=0.01
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s3-3-3-5pb.opb	OPT f=34 TT=0.003 T1=0	OPT f=34 TT=0.014 T1=0.01	OPT f=34 TT=0.02 T1=0	OPT f=34 TT=0.2 T1=0.04	OPT f=34 TT=0.178 T1=0.05	OPT f=34 TT=0.158 T1=0.04	OPT f=34 TT=0.138 T1=0.04	OPT f=34 TT=0.074 T1=0.04	OPT f=34 TT=0.071 T1=0.04	OPT f=34 TT=0.072 T1=0.04	OPT f=34 TT=0.07 T1=0.04	OPT f=34 TT=0.02 T1=0.02	OPT f=34 TT=0.177 T1=0.01	OPT f=34 TT=0.125 T1=0.07	OPT f=34 TT=0.036 T1=0	OPT f=34 TT=0.614 T1=0.21	OPT f=34 TT=0.014 T1=0.01	OPT f=34 TT=0.664 T1=0.21	OPT f=34 TT=0.038 T1=0.03	OPT f=34 TT=0.019 T1=0.02	OPT f=34 TT=1.334 T1=1.19	OPT f=34 TT=0.035 T1=0.03	OPT f=34 TT=1.243 T1=0.72	OPT f=34 TT=0.043 T1=0.03	OPT f=34 TT=0.106 T1=0.1	OPT f=34 TT=0.147 T1=0.01	OPT f=34 TT=0.058 T1=0.02	OPT f=34 TT=0.003 T1=0.01	OPT f=34 TT=0.023 T1=0.01	OPT f=34 TT=1.314 T1=0.71	OPT f=34 TT=0.644 T1=0.2	OPT f=34 TT=0.664 T1=0.29	OPT f=34 TT=0.04 T1=0.03	OPT f=34 TT=0.04 T1=0.03	OPT f=34 TT=0.048 T1=0.04	OPT f=34 TT=0.203 T1=0.02	OPT f=34 TT=0.19 T1=0.02	OPT f=34 TT=0.004 T1=0.01	OPT f=34 TT=0.003 T1=0.01
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s4-4-3-10pb.opb	OPT f=70 TT=0.078 T1=0.04	OPT f=70 TT=0.078 T1=0.07	OPT f=70 TT=0.203 T1=0.1	OPT f=70 TT=1.523 T1=1.21	OPT f=70 TT=1.406 T1=1.29	OPT f=70 TT=1.44 T1=1.15	OPT f=70 TT=1.271 T1=1	OPT f=70 TT=0.58 T1=0.27	OPT f=70 TT=0.629 T1=0.37	OPT f=70 TT=0.58 T1=0.27	OPT f=70 TT=0.645 T1=0.38	OPT f=70 TT=0.416 T1=0.41	OPT f=70 TT=3.884 T1=2.9	OPT f=70 TT=0.982 T1=0.4	OPT f=70 TT=0.206 T1=0.04	OPT f=70 TT=1.517 T1=0.63	OPT f=70 TT=0.077 T1=0.07	OPT f=70 TT=1.625 T1=0.71	OPT f=70 TT=0.102 T1=0.09	OPT f=70 TT=0.148 T1=0.14	OPT f=70 TT=3.823 T1=2.31	OPT f=70 TT=0.088 T1=0.08	OPT f=70 TT=3.094 T1=1.32	OPT f=70 TT=0.11 T1=0.1	OPT f=70 TT=2.59 T1=2.6	OPT f=70 TT=1.986 T1=1.77	OPT f=70 TT=0.531 T1=0.2	OPT f=70 TT=0.169 T1=0.08	OPT f=70 TT=0.169 T1=0.08	OPT f=70 TT=3.043 T1=1.32	OPT f=70 TT=1.524 T1=0.64	OPT f=70 TT=1.604 T1=0.72	OPT f=70 TT=0.374 T1=0.36	OPT f=70 TT=0.386 T1=0.37	OPT f=70 TT=0.243 T1=0.23	OPT f=70 TT=2.474 T1=0.7	OPT f=70 TT=2.475 T1=0.7	OPT f=70 TT=0.09 T1=0.08	OPT f=70 TT=0.09 T1=0.08
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s4-4-3-1pb.opb	OPT f=62 TT=0.068 T1=0.06	OPT f=62 TT=0.153 T1=0.14	OPT f=62 TT=324.629 T1=2.14	OPT f=62 TT=8.919 T1=3.73	OPT f=62 TT=7.052 T1=4.28	OPT f=62 TT=9.429 T1=3.94	OPT f=62 TT=6.99 T1=4.2	OPT f=62 TT=3.062 T1=2.7	OPT f=62 TT=4.325 T1=1.56	OPT f=62 TT=3.034 T1=2.66	OPT f=62 TT=4.578 T1=1.76	OPT f=62 TT=0.237 T1=0.23	OPT f=62 TT=24.167 T1=22.24	SAT (TO) f=62 TT=1802.1 T1=20.43	OPT f=62 TT=10.403 T1=2.24	OPT f=62 TT=225.733 T1=5.26	OPT f=62 TT=0.145 T1=0.14	OPT f=62 TT=1024.88 T1=5.7	OPT f=62 TT=0.382 T1=0.37	OPT f=62 TT=0.108 T1=0.1	OPT f=62 TT=1096.49 T1=15.31	OPT f=62 TT=0.103 T1=0.09	OPT f=62 TT=892.736 T1=5.34	OPT f=62 TT=0.108 T1=0.09	OPT f=62 TT=10.954 T1=10.95	OPT f=62 TT=10.14 T1=2.25	OPT f=62 TT=4.215 T1=1.76	OPT f=62 TT=0.128 T1=0.06	OPT f=62 TT=0.127 T1=0.06	OPT f=62 TT=632.552 T1=33.65	OPT f=62 TT=197.725 T1=1.35	OPT f=62 TT=233.528 T1=3.07	OPT f=62 TT=0.989 T1=0.97	OPT f=62 TT=1.059 T1=1.04	OPT f=62 TT=0.897 T1=0.88	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	OPT f=62 TT=0.067 T1=0.06	OPT f=62 TT=0.068 T1=0.06
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s4-4-3-2pb.opb	OPT f=64 TT=0.066 T1=0.06	OPT f=64 TT=136.795 T1=60.88	OPT f=64 TT=27.091 T1=7.17	OPT f=64 TT=6.776 T1=6.77	OPT f=64 TT=7.075 T1=5.41	OPT f=64 TT=6.627 T1=6.62	OPT f=64 TT=6.94 T1=5.27	OPT f=64 TT=6.827 T1=5.84	OPT f=64 TT=5.067 T1=3.4	OPT f=64 TT=6.51 T1=5.53	OPT f=64 TT=5.203 T1=3.49	OPT f=64 TT=271.14 T1=39.54	OPT f=64 TT=63.878 T1=62.52	OPT f=64 TT=387.758 T1=58.3	OPT f=64 TT=26.86 T1=3.52	OPT f=64 TT=338.45 T1=103.35	OPT f=64 TT=156.172 T1=141.15	OPT f=64 TT=158.21 T1=32.94	OPT f=64 TT=0.336 T1=0.32	OPT f=64 TT=0.126 T1=0.12	OPT f=64 TT=155.382 T1=28.42	OPT f=64 TT=1.077 T1=1.06	OPT f=64 TT=171.539 T1=34.12	OPT f=64 TT=0.692 T1=0.67	OPT f=64 TT=16.218 T1=16.22	OPT f=64 TT=9.159 T1=9.15	OPT f=64 TT=11.867 T1=9.44	OPT f=64 TT=0.128 T1=0.06	OPT f=64 TT=0.127 T1=0.06	OPT f=64 TT=133.895 T1=13.95	OPT f=64 TT=43.456 T1=6.09	OPT f=64 TT=63.443 T1=17.82	OPT f=64 TT=0.535 T1=0.52	OPT f=64 TT=0.636 T1=0.62	OPT f=64 TT=0.467 T1=0.45	OPT f=64 TT=677.882 T1=41.78	OPT f=64 TT=682.207 T1=42.9	OPT f=64 TT=0.067 T1=0.06	OPT f=64 TT=0.066 T1=0.06
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s4-4-3-3pb.opb	OPT f=62 TT=0.066 T1=0.06	OPT f=62 TT=86.475 T1=74.7	OPT f=62 TT=23.894 T1=18.54	OPT f=62 TT=24.965 T1=4.9	OPT f=62 TT=7.777 T1=1.97	OPT f=62 TT=24.851 T1=5.09	OPT f=62 TT=7.671 T1=1.91	OPT f=62 TT=15.124 T1=8.99	OPT f=62 TT=9.22 T1=4.85	OPT f=62 TT=14.492 T1=8.61	OPT f=62 TT=9.359 T1=4.53	OPT f=62 TT=594.328 T1=37.51	OPT f=62 TT=66.859 T1=66.7	OPT f=62 TT=692.284 T1=55.38	OPT f=62 TT=12.991 T1=3.24	OPT f=62 TT=272.99 T1=177.21	OPT f=62 TT=957.988 T1=781.41	OPT f=62 TT=126.13 T1=26.96	OPT f=62 TT=0.217 T1=0.21	OPT f=62 TT=0.107 T1=0.11	OPT f=62 TT=257.884 T1=76.17	OPT f=62 TT=0.213 T1=0.2	OPT f=62 TT=172.818 T1=80.19	OPT f=62 TT=0.271 T1=0.26	OPT f=62 TT=42.575 T1=42.58	OPT f=62 TT=22.379 T1=6.44	OPT f=62 TT=25.25 T1=14.99	OPT f=62 TT=0.127 T1=0.08	OPT f=62 TT=0.128 T1=0.06	OPT f=62 TT=158.08 T1=46.92	OPT f=62 TT=60.084 T1=30.88	OPT f=62 TT=51.816 T1=26.98	OPT f=62 TT=0.263 T1=0.25	OPT f=62 TT=0.262 T1=0.25	OPT f=62 TT=0.162 T1=0.15	OPT f=62 TT=1215.32 T1=100.72	OPT f=62 TT=1226.94 T1=107.2	OPT f=62 TT=0.066 T1=0.06	OPT f=62 TT=0.066 T1=0.06
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s4-4-3-4pb.opb	OPT f=60 TT=0.067 T1=0.06	OPT f=60 TT=0.3 T1=0.29	OPT f=60 TT=226.774 T1=11.31	OPT f=60 TT=2.733 T1=2.43	OPT f=60 TT=2.712 T1=2.01	OPT f=60 TT=2.639 T1=2.42	OPT f=60 TT=2.568 T1=2.03	OPT f=60 TT=3.803 T1=3.44	OPT f=60 TT=2.957 T1=2.23	OPT f=60 TT=3.731 T1=3.48	OPT f=60 TT=2.81 T1=2.13	OPT f=60 TT=0.06 T1=0.06	OPT f=60 TT=31.444 T1=30.87	OPT f=60 TT=1602.99 T1=203.01	OPT f=60 TT=7.682 T1=3.59	OPT f=60 TT=310.09 T1=31.42	OPT f=60 TT=0.275 T1=0.27	OPT f=60 TT=1014.07 T1=48.45	OPT f=60 TT=0.609 T1=0.59	OPT f=60 TT=0.11 T1=0.1	OPT f=60 TT=324.945 T1=28.33	OPT f=60 TT=0.488 T1=0.47	OPT f=60 TT=780.52 T1=46.99	OPT f=60 TT=1.977 T1=1.97	OPT f=60 TT=15.456 T1=15.45	OPT f=60 TT=2.684 T1=1.31	OPT f=60 TT=4.362 T1=3.47	OPT f=60 TT=0.127 T1=0.06	OPT f=60 TT=0.128 T1=0.06	OPT f=60 TT=518.384 T1=33.93	OPT f=60 TT=164.4 T1=18.53	OPT f=60 TT=207.332 T1=26.93	OPT f=60 TT=0.104 T1=0.09	OPT f=60 TT=0.094 T1=0.08	OPT f=60 TT=0.102 T1=0.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	OPT f=60 TT=0.067 T1=0.06	OPT f=60 TT=0.067 T1=0.06
Bench name	Best results	bsolo 3.2 (complete)	clasp 2.0.6-R5325 (opt) (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc (complete)	npSolver inc (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed) (complete)	PB07: bsolo 3.0.17 (complete)	PB07: minisat+ 1.14 (complete)	PB07: PB-clasp 2007-04-10 (complete)	PB07: Pueblo 1.4 (incomplete)	PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution 2007-03-23 (complete)	PB09: bsolo 3.1 (complete)	PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution 2.1.1 (complete)	PB09: SCIPspx SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009) (complete)	PB10: pb_cplex 2010-06-29 (complete)	PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP 2.2.0 2010-05-31 (complete)	PB10: SCIPspx SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver (complete)	PB11: Sat4j Res//CP 2.3.0 (complete)	PB11: SCIP spx E_2 2011-06-10 (fixed) (complete)	PB12: minisatp 1.0-2-g022594c (complete)	pb2sat 2012-05-19 (complete)	pb2satCp2 2012-05-19 (complete)	pwbo 2.0 (complete)	pwbo 2.02 (complete)	SAT 4j PB RES // CP 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	Sat 4j PB Resolution 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	SAT4J PB specific settings 2.3.2 snapshot (complete)	SCIP spx SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx E SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx standard SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed (complete)	toysat 2012-05-17 (complete)	toysat 2012-06-01 (complete)	wbo 1.7 (complete)	wbo 1.72 (complete)
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s4-4-3-5pb.opb	OPT f=60 TT=0.067 T1=0.06	OPT f=60 TT=12.054 T1=12.05	OPT f=60 TT=43.12 T1=29.16	OPT f=60 TT=2.677 T1=1.84	OPT f=60 TT=4.968 T1=2.57	OPT f=60 TT=2.606 T1=1.79	OPT f=60 TT=4.83 T1=2.46	OPT f=60 TT=5.413 T1=4.79	OPT f=60 TT=6.688 T1=4.22	OPT f=60 TT=5.442 T1=4.81	OPT f=60 TT=6.487 T1=4.13	OPT f=60 TT=1.258 T1=1.25	OPT f=60 TT=16.247 T1=15.87	OPT f=60 TT=1067.78 T1=466.11	OPT f=60 TT=30.996 T1=29.58	OPT f=60 TT=293.128 T1=149.75	OPT f=60 TT=39.531 T1=39.53	OPT f=60 TT=157.41 T1=71.52	OPT f=60 TT=0.161 T1=0.15	OPT f=60 TT=0.108 T1=0.1	OPT f=60 TT=256.335 T1=70.73	OPT f=60 TT=0.262 T1=0.25	OPT f=60 TT=208.763 T1=66.91	OPT f=60 TT=0.204 T1=0.19	OPT f=60 TT=13.821 T1=13.82	OPT f=60 TT=2.115 T1=0.64	OPT f=60 TT=5.43 T1=4.98	OPT f=60 TT=0.128 T1=0.06	OPT f=60 TT=0.128 T1=0.06	OPT f=60 TT=251.928 T1=73.6	OPT f=60 TT=50.195 T1=29.09	OPT f=60 TT=85.061 T1=61.9	OPT f=60 TT=0.224 T1=0.21	OPT f=60 TT=0.221 T1=0.2	OPT f=60 TT=0.127 T1=0.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	OPT f=60 TT=0.068 T1=0.06	OPT f=60 TT=0.067 T1=0.06
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s4-4-3-6pb.opb	OPT f=66 TT=0.067 T1=0.06	OPT f=66 TT=26.241 T1=5.44	OPT f=66 TT=5.982 T1=1.01	OPT f=66 TT=8.532 T1=6.67	OPT f=66 TT=3.822 T1=1.89	OPT f=66 TT=8.481 T1=6.61	OPT f=66 TT=3.725 T1=2.13	OPT f=66 TT=6.148 T1=4.82	OPT f=66 TT=1.496 T1=0.81	OPT f=66 TT=5.845 T1=4.55	OPT f=66 TT=1.504 T1=0.81	OPT f=66 TT=104.131 T1=9.97	OPT f=66 TT=7.582 T1=6	OPT f=66 TT=82.071 T1=11.49	OPT f=66 TT=2.552 T1=0.86	OPT f=66 TT=10.37 T1=3.48	OPT f=66 TT=38.779 T1=17.13	OPT f=66 TT=13.312 T1=2.87	OPT f=66 TT=0.172 T1=0.12	OPT f=66 TT=0.118 T1=0.12	OPT f=66 TT=25.729 T1=7.31	OPT f=66 TT=0.331 T1=0.13	OPT f=66 TT=24.291 T1=5.83	OPT f=66 TT=0.331 T1=0.32	OPT f=66 TT=5.098 T1=5.09	OPT f=66 TT=11.353 T1=10.42	OPT f=66 TT=3.44 T1=2.51	OPT f=66 TT=0.127 T1=0.06	OPT f=66 TT=0.127 T1=0.06	OPT f=66 TT=33.598 T1=2.8	OPT f=66 TT=11.221 T1=1.45	OPT f=66 TT=10.872 T1=2.02	OPT f=66 TT=0.34 T1=0.33	OPT f=66 TT=0.354 T1=0.34	OPT f=66 TT=0.208 T1=0.19	OPT f=66 TT=178.334 T1=21.32	OPT f=66 TT=178.533 T1=21.97	OPT f=66 TT=0.067 T1=0.06	OPT f=66 TT=0.067 T1=0.06
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s4-4-3-7pb.opb	OPT f=64 TT=0.068 T1=0.06	OPT f=64 TT=11.807 T1=7.94	OPT f=64 TT=3.539 T1=2.32	OPT f=64 TT=5.454 T1=4.36	OPT f=64 TT=4.303 T1=3.44	OPT f=64 TT=5.372 T1=4.28	OPT f=64 TT=4.165 T1=3.33	OPT f=64 TT=4.977 T1=4.01	OPT f=64 TT=2.165 T1=1.32	OPT f=64 TT=4.799 T1=3.71	OPT f=64 TT=2.158 T1=1.43	SAT (TO) f=64 TT=1800.11 T1=25.63	OPT f=64 TT=18.391 T1=17.9	OPT f=64 TT=51.921 T1=16.01	OPT f=64 TT=1.936 T1=0.83	OPT f=64 TT=6.413 T1=2.91	OPT f=64 TT=8.7 T1=5.1	OPT f=64 TT=6.762 T1=3.37	OPT f=64 TT=0.208 T1=0.2	OPT f=64 TT=0.103 T1=0.1	OPT f=64 TT=14.292 T1=6.32	OPT f=64 TT=0.258 T1=0.25	OPT f=64 TT=17.441 T1=8.35	OPT f=64 TT=0.245 T1=0.23	OPT f=64 TT=9.705 T1=9.7	OPT f=64 TT=3.089 T1=3.09	OPT f=64 TT=2.875 T1=2.14	OPT f=64 TT=0.128 T1=0.06	OPT f=64 TT=0.128 T1=0.06	OPT f=64 TT=18.307 T1=5.32	OPT f=64 TT=7.254 T1=2.2	OPT f=64 TT=7.343 T1=2.62	OPT f=64 TT=0.297 T1=0.28	OPT f=64 TT=0.294 T1=0.28	OPT f=64 TT=0.185 T1=0.17	OPT f=64 TT=198.387 T1=38.26	OPT f=64 TT=197.236 T1=37.79	OPT f=64 TT=0.068 T1=0.06	OPT f=64 TT=0.068 T1=0.06
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s4-4-3-8pb.opb	OPT f=36 TT=0.034 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=9.013 T1=9.01	OPT f=36 TT=206.285 T1=200.96	OPT f=36 TT=0.393 T1=0.28	OPT f=36 TT=0.445 T1=0.27	OPT f=36 TT=0.341 T1=0.23	OPT f=36 TT=0.355 T1=0.22	OPT f=36 TT=0.271 T1=0.21	OPT f=36 TT=0.939 T1=0.88	OPT f=36 TT=0.272 T1=0.21	OPT f=36 TT=0.932 T1=0.88	OPT f=36 TT=0.091 T1=0.09	OPT f=36 TT=2.548 T1=2.47	SAT (TO) f=36 TT=1802.11 T1=559.5	OPT f=36 TT=4.527 T1=3.83	OPT f=36 TT=221.73 T1=90.01	OPT f=36 TT=15.845 T1=15.84	OPT f=36 TT=713.826 T1=362.82	OPT f=36 TT=0.067 T1=0.06	OPT f=36 TT=0.054 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=152.732 T1=56.8	OPT f=36 TT=0.057 T1=0.05	OPT f=36 TT=144.123 T1=26.54	OPT f=36 TT=0.074 T1=0.06	OPT f=36 TT=1.585 T1=1.58	OPT f=36 TT=0.255 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.113 T1=0.03	OPT f=36 TT=0.066 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.066 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=159.122 T1=7.8	OPT f=36 TT=57.29 T1=18.15	OPT f=36 TT=107.298 T1=66.46	OPT f=36 TT=0.235 T1=0.22	OPT f=36 TT=0.192 T1=0.18	OPT f=36 TT=0.091 T1=0.08	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.035 T1=0.02	OPT f=36 TT=0.034 T1=0.02
normalized-PB06/OPT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB05/manquinho/routing/ normalized-s4-4-3-9pb.opb	OPT f=68 TT=0.15 T1=0.14	OPT f=68 TT=1.631 T1=1.61	OPT f=68 TT=1.828 T1=0.68	OPT f=68 TT=7.372 T1=5.96	OPT f=68 TT=5.447 T1=2.65	OPT f=68 TT=7.321 T1=5.97	OPT f=68 TT=5.131 T1=2.36	OPT f=68 TT=2.422 T1=1.63	OPT f=68 TT=3.985 T1=3.13	OPT f=68 TT=2.393 T1=1.6	OPT f=68 TT=3.909 T1=2.9	SAT (TO) f=68 TT=1800.1 T1=6.14	OPT f=68 TT=19.257 T1=13.4	OPT f=68 TT=25.644 T1=2.79	OPT f=68 TT=1.67 T1=0.46	OPT f=68 TT=7.543 T1=2.21	OPT f=68 TT=1.612 T1=1.59	OPT f=68 TT=5.292 T1=3.27	OPT f=68 TT=0.7 T1=0.69	OPT f=68 TT=0.15 T1=0.15	OPT f=68 TT=10.996 T1=4.35	OPT f=68 TT=0.421 T1=0.41	OPT f=68 TT=9.913 T1=2.33	OPT f=68 TT=0.264 T1=0.25	OPT f=68 TT=10.465 T1=10.46	OPT f=68 TT=13.321 T1=6.15	OPT f=68 TT=6.698 T1=3.22	OPT f=68 TT=0.58 T1=0.29	OPT f=68 TT=0.29 T1=0.14	OPT f=68 TT=12.352 T1=3.41	OPT f=68 TT=4.573 T1=2.42	OPT f=68 TT=4.353 T1=1.52	OPT f=68 TT=0.426 T1=0.41	OPT f=68 TT=0.4 T1=0.38	OPT f=68 TT=0.226 T1=0.21	OPT f=68 TT=67.86 T1=32.17	OPT f=68 TT=68.951 T1=33.15	OPT f=68 TT=0.398 T1=0.39	OPT f=68 TT=0.378 T1=0.37

Statistics		bsolo 3.2 (complete)	clasp 2.0.6-R5325 (opt) (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc (complete)	npSolver inc (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed) (complete)	PB07: bsolo 3.0.17 (complete)	PB07: minisat+ 1.14 (complete)	PB07: PB-clasp 2007-04-10 (complete)	PB07: Pueblo 1.4 (incomplete)	PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution 2007-03-23 (complete)	PB09: bsolo 3.1 (complete)	PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution 2.1.1 (complete)	PB09: SCIPspx SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009) (complete)	PB10: pb_cplex 2010-06-29 (complete)	PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP 2.2.0 2010-05-31 (complete)	PB10: SCIPspx SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver (complete)	PB11: Sat4j Res//CP 2.3.0 (complete)	PB11: SCIP spx E_2 2011-06-10 (fixed) (complete)	PB12: minisatp 1.0-2-g022594c (complete)	pb2sat 2012-05-19 (complete)	pb2satCp2 2012-05-19 (complete)	pwbo 2.0 (complete)	pwbo 2.02 (complete)	SAT 4j PB RES // CP 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	Sat 4j PB Resolution 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	SAT4J PB specific settings 2.3.2 snapshot (complete)	SCIP spx SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx E SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx standard SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed (complete)	toysat 2012-05-17 (complete)	toysat 2012-06-01 (complete)	wbo 1.7 (complete)	wbo 1.72 (complete)
Number of times the solver is able to give the best known answer		15	15	15	15	15	15	15	15	15	15	0	15	13	15	15	0	15	0	15	15	15	15	15	15	15	15	0	15	15	15	0	15	15	15	11	11	0	15
Number of times the solver is the best solver from a complete solver point of view (i.e. best known answer and best TT time)		1	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	11