PB'12 competition: satisfaction and optimization track: results by benchmark

Results by benchmark for category no optimisation, small integers, linear constraints (DEC-SMALLINT-LIN), subcategory Handmade, subsubcategory Pigeon Hole

This page displays the results of the different solvers for each benchmark for category no optimisation, small integers, linear constraints (DEC-SMALLINT-LIN), subcategory Handmade, subsubcategory Pigeon Hole

REMINDER

Keep in mind that the 'Best result' columns only provide the best result given by one of the solvers. This 'Best result' may be wrong in case of an UNSATISFIABLE or OPTIMUM FOUND answer (because there's no efficient way to check these answers).

Description of a cell contents:

Cell exampleMeaning
AnswerSolver result
f=...value of the objective function for the model reported by the solver
TT=...Total Time (TT): this is the CPU time (in seconds) used by the solver until termination. This time is only meaningful for complete solvers because incomplete solvers will always run until they time out
Remember that CPU time and wall clock time are two very different notions. The CPU time represents the time during which the instructions of the solver were executed by the processor. The wall clock time represents how much time ellapsed on the clock. For a same event, the CPU time may be either smaller or greater than the wall clock time depending on the number of threads of execution and the number of processors.

Meaning of some abbreviations:

AbbreviationMeaning
f=...Value of the objective function
TOTime Out
MOMem. Out (out of memory)

Meaning of the different colors:

ColorMeaning
textthe solver cannot handle this instance
textthe solver gave no answer
textthe solver could give an answer (SAT)
textthe solver gave a definitive answer (OPTIMUM FOUND or UNSAT)
textthe solver performed better than the other ones on that instance (complete solvers point of view)
textthe solver performed better than the other ones on that instance (incomplete solvers point of view)
textthe solver was ended by a signal or other problem
textthe solver gave an incomplete answer
textthe solver gave a wrong answer

For better readability, you may choose to hide some solvers:
bsolo 3.2 (complete)
clasp 2.0.6-R5325 (dec) (complete)
npSolver 1.0 (complete)
npSolver 1.0 (fixed) (complete)
npSolver inc (complete)
npSolver inc (fixed) (complete)
npSolver inc-topDown (complete)
npSolver inc-topDown (fixed) (complete)
npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (complete)
npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed) (complete)
PB07: bsolo 3.0.17 (complete)
PB07: minisat+ 1.14 (complete)
PB07: PB-clasp 2007-04-10 (complete)
PB07: Pueblo 1.4 (incomplete)
PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution 2007-03-23 (complete)
PB09: bsolo 3.1 (complete)
PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution 2.1.1 (complete)
PB09: SCIPspx SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009) (complete)
PB10: borg-pb 10.05.30 (complete)
PB10: pb_cplex 2010-06-29 (complete)
PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP 2.2.0 2010-05-31 (complete)
PB10: SCIPspx SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver (complete)
PB11: borg pb-dec-11.04.03 (complete)
PB11: Sat4j Res//CP 2.3.0 (complete)
PB11: SCIP spx E_2 2011-06-10 (fixed) (complete)
PB12: minisatp 1.0-2-g022594c (complete)
pb2sat 2012-05-19 (complete)
pb2satCp2 2012-05-19 (complete)
PBPASSolver-CARD.DP 2012-05-28 (complete)
PBPASSolver-CARD.SN 2012-05-28 (complete)
pwbo 2.0 (complete)
pwbo 2.02 (complete)
SAT 4j PB RES // CP 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)
Sat 4j PB Resolution 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)
SAT4J PB specific settings 2.3.2 snapshot (complete)
SCIP spx SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)
SCIP spx E SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)
SCIP spx standard SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed (complete)
toysat 2012-05-17 (complete)
toysat 2012-06-01 (complete)
wbo 1.7 (complete)
wbo 1.72 (complete)

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
bsolo
3.2
(complete)
clasp
2.0.6-R5325 (dec)
(complete)
npSolver
1.0
(complete)
npSolver
1.0 (fixed)
(complete)
npSolver
inc
(complete)
npSolver
inc (fixed)
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topDown
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topDown (fixed)
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topdown-quickBound
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed)
(complete)
PB07: bsolo
3.0.17
(complete)
PB07: minisat+
1.14
(complete)
PB07: PB-clasp
2007-04-10
(complete)
PB07: Pueblo
1.4
(incomplete)
PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution
2007-03-23
(complete)
PB09: bsolo
3.1
(complete)
PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution
2.1.1
(complete)
PB09: SCIPspx
SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009)
(complete)
PB10: borg-pb
10.05.30
(complete)
PB10: pb_cplex
2010-06-29
(complete)
PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP
2.2.0 2010-05-31
(complete)
PB10: SCIPspx
SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver
(complete)
PB11: borg
pb-dec-11.04.03
(complete)
PB11: Sat4j Res//CP
2.3.0
(complete)
PB11: SCIP spx E_2
2011-06-10 (fixed)
(complete)
PB12: minisatp
1.0-2-g022594c
(complete)
pb2sat
2012-05-19
(complete)
pb2satCp2
2012-05-19
(complete)
PBPASSolver-CARD.DP
2012-05-28
(complete)
PBPASSolver-CARD.SN
2012-05-28
(complete)
pwbo
2.0
(complete)
pwbo
2.02
(complete)
SAT 4j PB RES // CP
2.3.2 Snapshot
(complete)
Sat 4j PB Resolution
2.3.2 Snapshot
(complete)
SAT4J PB specific settings
2.3.2 snapshot
(complete)
SCIP spx
SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed
(complete)
SCIP spx E
SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed
(complete)
SCIP spx standard
SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed
(complete)
toysat
2012-05-17
(complete)
toysat
2012-06-01
(complete)
wbo
1.7
(complete)
wbo
1.72
(complete)
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-101-100.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.19

UNSAT
TT=253.101

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.046

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (problem)
TT=0.046

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (problem)
TT=0.044

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (problem)
TT=0.039

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

Signal
TT=1009.69

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

?
TT=437.804

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=537.18

UNSAT
TT=16.457

? (TO)
TT=1800.78

UNSAT
TT=0.228

UNSAT
TT=594.366

UNSAT
TT=0.342

UNSAT
TT=16.691

UNSAT
TT=0.19

UNSAT
TT=1.358

UNSAT
TT=17.483

UNSAT
TT=0.227

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (problem)
TT=0.038

? (problem)
TT=0.039

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.44

?
TT=1799.56

UNSAT
TT=18.491

? (TO)
TT=1800.47

? (TO)
TT=1800.4

UNSAT
TT=0.313

UNSAT
TT=0.283

UNSAT
TT=0.399

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

?
TT=1799.44

?
TT=1799.47

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-105-100.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.194

UNSAT
TT=3.768

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.048

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.038

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (problem)
TT=0.045

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

Signal
TT=1290.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

?
TT=321.188

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=428.87

UNSAT
TT=3.104

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.244

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.357

UNSAT
TT=1.792

UNSAT
TT=0.194

UNSAT
TT=1.386

UNSAT
TT=1.653

UNSAT
TT=0.244

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (problem)
TT=0.039

? (problem)
TT=0.047

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

?
TT=1799.84

?
TT=1799.51

UNSAT
TT=1.663

? (TO)
TT=1800.37

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.53

UNSAT
TT=0.48

UNSAT
TT=0.628

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

?
TT=1799.82

?
TT=1799.57

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-11-10.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.003

UNSAT
TT=0.003

UNSAT
TT=157.37

? (problem)
TT=0.003

UNSAT
TT=1.433

? (problem)
TT=0.001

UNSAT
TT=1.37

? (problem)
TT=0.003

UNSAT
TT=1.37

? (problem)
TT=0.002

UNSAT
TT=1.37

UNSAT
TT=179.867

UNSAT
TT=29.823

UNSAT
TT=70.38

UNSAT
TT=0.003

UNSAT
TT=226.519

UNSAT
TT=0.003

UNSAT
TT=56.03

UNSAT
TT=0.012

UNSAT
TT=182.899

UNSAT
TT=0.006

UNSAT
TT=0.243

UNSAT
TT=0.017

UNSAT
TT=0.473

UNSAT
TT=0.254

UNSAT
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=20.202

? (problem)
TT=0.003

? (problem)
TT=0.003

UNSAT
TT=11.388

UNSAT
TT=2.252

UNSAT
TT=304.807

UNSAT
TT=327.278

UNSAT
TT=0.264

UNSAT
TT=992.5

UNSAT
TT=23.39

UNSAT
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=0.022

UNSAT
TT=578.336

UNSAT
TT=587.653

UNSAT
TT=295.34

UNSAT
TT=312.72

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-15-10.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.002

UNSAT
TT=0.004

UNSAT
TT=144.79

? (problem)
TT=0.002

UNSAT
TT=2.262

? (problem)
TT=0.002

UNSAT
TT=2.18

? (problem)
TT=0.002

UNSAT
TT=2.18

? (problem)
TT=0.003

UNSAT
TT=2.17

UNSAT
TT=379.212

UNSAT
TT=57.463

UNSAT
TT=67.216

UNSAT
TT=0.002

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.003

UNSAT
TT=1641.86

UNSAT
TT=0.014

UNSAT
TT=186.876

UNSAT
TT=0.008

UNSAT
TT=0.214

UNSAT
TT=0.017

UNSAT
TT=0.482

UNSAT
TT=0.225

UNSAT
TT=0.017

UNSAT
TT=50.724

? (problem)
TT=0.002

? (problem)
TT=0.004

UNSAT
TT=26.403

UNSAT
TT=14.396

UNSAT
TT=856.4

UNSAT
TT=948.58

UNSAT
TT=0.186

UNSAT
TT=1379.24

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.02

UNSAT
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=0.024

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=846.12

UNSAT
TT=826.22

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-21-20.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.005

UNSAT
TT=0.015

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (problem)
TT=0.004

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=0.005

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=0.004

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=0.002

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

UNSAT
TT=0.005

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.013

? (TO)
TT=1800.71

UNSAT
TT=0.016

UNSAT
TT=592.227

UNSAT
TT=0.011

UNSAT
TT=0.447

UNSAT
TT=0.02

UNSAT
TT=0.469

UNSAT
TT=0.446

UNSAT
TT=0.021

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.004

? (problem)
TT=0.004

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

?
TT=1799.62

?
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.443

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.025

UNSAT
TT=0.024

UNSAT
TT=0.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=1799.7

?
TT=1800.03

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-25-20.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.008

UNSAT
TT=0.017

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.004

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (problem)
TT=0.004

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.004

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=0.003

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=27.351

UNSAT
TT=0.008

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.015

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=690.231

UNSAT
TT=0.013

UNSAT
TT=0.282

UNSAT
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=0.458

UNSAT
TT=0.314

UNSAT
TT=0.022

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.003

? (problem)
TT=0.003

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

?
TT=1799.92

?
TT=1799.89

UNSAT
TT=0.334

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.37

UNSAT
TT=0.025

UNSAT
TT=0.024

UNSAT
TT=0.031

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

?
TT=1799.63

?
TT=1799.63

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-31-30.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=0.052

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.007

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (problem)
TT=0.007

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (problem)
TT=0.004

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (problem)
TT=0.008

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.019

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.042

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.024

UNSAT
TT=591.991

UNSAT
TT=0.022

UNSAT
TT=1.093

UNSAT
TT=0.025

UNSAT
TT=0.503

UNSAT
TT=0.973

UNSAT
TT=0.029

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=0.005

? (problem)
TT=0.004

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=1799.61

?
TT=1799.66

UNSAT
TT=1.013

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.034

UNSAT
TT=0.034

UNSAT
TT=0.044

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

?
TT=1799.63

?
TT=1799.66

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-35-30.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.023

UNSAT
TT=0.059

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (problem)
TT=0.007

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (problem)
TT=0.005

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (problem)
TT=0.006

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (problem)
TT=0.004

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=0.027

? (TO)
TT=1800.47

UNSAT
TT=0.051

? (TO)
TT=1800.54

UNSAT
TT=0.028

UNSAT
TT=590.901

UNSAT
TT=0.023

UNSAT
TT=0.515

UNSAT
TT=0.03

UNSAT
TT=0.52

UNSAT
TT=0.513

UNSAT
TT=0.034

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.006

? (problem)
TT=0.006

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

?
TT=1799.96

?
TT=1799.63

UNSAT
TT=0.525

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.53

UNSAT
TT=0.037

UNSAT
TT=0.036

UNSAT
TT=0.047

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

?
TT=1799.63

?
TT=1799.96

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-41-40.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.037

UNSAT
TT=0.147

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (problem)
TT=0.008

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.008

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.008

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.057

? (TO)
TT=1800.53

UNSAT
TT=0.115

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.037

UNSAT
TT=591.757

UNSAT
TT=0.037

UNSAT
TT=1.454

UNSAT
TT=0.039

UNSAT
TT=0.553

UNSAT
TT=1.403

UNSAT
TT=0.041

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.008

? (problem)
TT=0.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=1799.55

?
TT=1799.54

UNSAT
TT=1.385

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.047

UNSAT
TT=0.05

UNSAT
TT=0.061

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=1799.88

?
TT=1799.52

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-45-40.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.039

UNSAT
TT=0.207

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (problem)
TT=0.011

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (problem)
TT=0.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (problem)
TT=0.011

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.007

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.067

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.151

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.04

UNSAT
TT=609.345

UNSAT
TT=0.042

UNSAT
TT=0.674

UNSAT
TT=0.039

UNSAT
TT=0.519

UNSAT
TT=0.894

UNSAT
TT=0.043

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.008

? (problem)
TT=0.011

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=1799.56

?
TT=1799.54

UNSAT
TT=0.635

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.65

UNSAT
TT=0.052

UNSAT
TT=0.05

UNSAT
TT=0.067

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

?
TT=1799.56

?
TT=1799.56

Bench nameBest resultsbsolo
3.2
(complete)
clasp
2.0.6-R5325 (dec)
(complete)
npSolver
1.0
(complete)
npSolver
1.0 (fixed)
(complete)
npSolver
inc
(complete)
npSolver
inc (fixed)
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topDown
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topDown (fixed)
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topdown-quickBound
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed)
(complete)
PB07: bsolo
3.0.17
(complete)
PB07: minisat+
1.14
(complete)
PB07: PB-clasp
2007-04-10
(complete)
PB07: Pueblo
1.4
(incomplete)
PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution
2007-03-23
(complete)
PB09: bsolo
3.1
(complete)
PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution
2.1.1
(complete)
PB09: SCIPspx
SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009)
(complete)
PB10: borg-pb
10.05.30
(complete)
PB10: pb_cplex
2010-06-29
(complete)
PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP
2.2.0 2010-05-31
(complete)
PB10: SCIPspx
SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver
(complete)
PB11: borg
pb-dec-11.04.03
(complete)
PB11: Sat4j Res//CP
2.3.0
(complete)
PB11: SCIP spx E_2
2011-06-10 (fixed)
(complete)
PB12: minisatp
1.0-2-g022594c
(complete)
pb2sat
2012-05-19
(complete)
pb2satCp2
2012-05-19
(complete)
PBPASSolver-CARD.DP
2012-05-28
(complete)
PBPASSolver-CARD.SN
2012-05-28
(complete)
pwbo
2.0
(complete)
pwbo
2.02
(complete)
SAT 4j PB RES // CP
2.3.2 Snapshot
(complete)
Sat 4j PB Resolution
2.3.2 Snapshot
(complete)
SAT4J PB specific settings
2.3.2 snapshot
(complete)
SCIP spx
SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed
(complete)
SCIP spx E
SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed
(complete)
SCIP spx standard
SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed
(complete)
toysat
2012-05-17
(complete)
toysat
2012-06-01
(complete)
wbo
1.7
(complete)
wbo
1.72
(complete)
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-51-50.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.05

UNSAT
TT=0.375

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (problem)
TT=0.012

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.014

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.013

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (problem)
TT=0.014

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.129

? (TO)
TT=1800

UNSAT
TT=0.292

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.051

UNSAT
TT=589.715

UNSAT
TT=0.062

UNSAT
TT=2.103

UNSAT
TT=0.05

UNSAT
TT=0.576

UNSAT
TT=2.004

UNSAT
TT=0.052

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (problem)
TT=0.011

? (problem)
TT=0.012

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

?
TT=1799.8

?
TT=1799.52

UNSAT
TT=2.134

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.07

UNSAT
TT=0.065

UNSAT
TT=0.089

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

?
TT=1799.6

?
TT=1799.91

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-55-50.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.05

UNSAT
TT=3.358

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (problem)
TT=0.014

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.013

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (problem)
TT=0.013

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=0.013

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=0.226

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=2.92

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.058

UNSAT
TT=631.128

UNSAT
TT=0.067

UNSAT
TT=1.033

UNSAT
TT=0.05

UNSAT
TT=0.595

UNSAT
TT=1.055

UNSAT
TT=0.054

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=0.012

? (problem)
TT=0.014

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

?
TT=1799.51

?
TT=1799.43

UNSAT
TT=1.043

? (TO)
TT=1800.78

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.071

UNSAT
TT=0.068

UNSAT
TT=0.093

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

?
TT=1799.54

?
TT=1799.78

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-61-60.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.068

UNSAT
TT=0.499

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.016

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.015

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.016

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (problem)
TT=0.016

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.25

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.283

?
TT=1078.49

UNSAT
TT=0.375

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.077

UNSAT
TT=641.949

UNSAT
TT=0.098

UNSAT
TT=2.774

UNSAT
TT=0.068

UNSAT
TT=0.671

UNSAT
TT=2.715

UNSAT
TT=0.074

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.017

? (problem)
TT=0.016

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=1799.92

?
TT=1799.73

UNSAT
TT=2.87

? (TO)
TT=1800.81

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.097

UNSAT
TT=0.101

UNSAT
TT=0.125

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

?
TT=1799.94

?
TT=1799.72

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-65-60.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.07

UNSAT
TT=0.963

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.018

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (problem)
TT=0.016

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (problem)
TT=0.018

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (problem)
TT=0.014

? (TO)
TT=1807.55

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=1.131

?
TT=1221.17

UNSAT
TT=0.671

? (TO)
TT=1800

UNSAT
TT=0.08

UNSAT
TT=593.743

UNSAT
TT=0.103

UNSAT
TT=1.113

UNSAT
TT=0.07

UNSAT
TT=0.681

UNSAT
TT=1.183

UNSAT
TT=0.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=0.014

? (problem)
TT=0.017

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

?
TT=1799.55

?
TT=1799.44

UNSAT
TT=1.124

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.82

UNSAT
TT=0.099

UNSAT
TT=0.093

UNSAT
TT=0.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

?
TT=1799.44

?
TT=1799.52

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-71-70.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.093

UNSAT
TT=1.889

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (problem)
TT=0.023

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.022

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=54.024

?
TT=861.48

UNSAT
TT=0.754

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.105

UNSAT
TT=628.94

UNSAT
TT=0.145

UNSAT
TT=4.332

UNSAT
TT=0.093

UNSAT
TT=0.761

UNSAT
TT=4.543

UNSAT
TT=0.102

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (problem)
TT=0.02

? (problem)
TT=0.023

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=1799.55

?
TT=1799.56

UNSAT
TT=4.583

? (TO)
TT=1800.73

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.144

UNSAT
TT=0.137

UNSAT
TT=0.185

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

?
TT=1799.51

?
TT=1799.87

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-75-70.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.093

UNSAT
TT=4.752

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (problem)
TT=0.022

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (problem)
TT=0.021

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (problem)
TT=0.023

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (problem)
TT=0.019

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

Signal
TT=1707.45

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

?
TT=1320.25

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

?
TT=606.15

UNSAT
TT=3.818

? (TO)
TT=1800.74

UNSAT
TT=0.101

UNSAT
TT=599.518

UNSAT
TT=0.151

UNSAT
TT=1.595

UNSAT
TT=0.093

UNSAT
TT=0.758

UNSAT
TT=1.416

UNSAT
TT=0.104

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (problem)
TT=0.023

? (problem)
TT=0.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

?
TT=1799.95

?
TT=1799.9

UNSAT
TT=1.425

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.182

UNSAT
TT=0.175

UNSAT
TT=0.229

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

?
TT=1799.45

?
TT=1799.92

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-81-80.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.117

?
TT=1798.26

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (problem)
TT=0.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=0.027

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.026

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.026

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

Signal
TT=1112.81

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=514.597

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.127

UNSAT
TT=593.416

UNSAT
TT=0.202

UNSAT
TT=6.782

UNSAT
TT=0.117

UNSAT
TT=0.911

UNSAT
TT=7.155

UNSAT
TT=0.126

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.026

? (problem)
TT=0.023

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=1799.8

?
TT=1799.85

UNSAT
TT=7.065

? (TO)
TT=1800.95

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.2

UNSAT
TT=0.188

UNSAT
TT=0.253

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=1799.75

?
TT=1799.53

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-85-80.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.12

UNSAT
TT=1.274

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.028

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.026

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (problem)
TT=0.027

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

Signal
TT=851.54

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

?
TT=8.319

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=460.283

UNSAT
TT=1.046

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.134

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.21

UNSAT
TT=1.674

UNSAT
TT=0.12

UNSAT
TT=0.925

UNSAT
TT=1.545

UNSAT
TT=0.123

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=0.025

? (problem)
TT=0.027

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

?
TT=1799.53

?
TT=1799.55

UNSAT
TT=1.567

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.79

UNSAT
TT=0.169

UNSAT
TT=0.158

UNSAT
TT=0.228

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=1799.54

?
TT=1799.44

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-91-90.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.16

UNSAT
TT=2.994

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.036

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.035

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

Signal
TT=917.405

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

?
TT=479.48

UNSAT
TT=2.393

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.178

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.265

UNSAT
TT=11.071

UNSAT
TT=0.16

UNSAT
TT=1.072

UNSAT
TT=11.411

UNSAT
TT=0.188

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.029

? (problem)
TT=0.032

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

?
TT=1799.54

?
TT=1799.83

UNSAT
TT=11.694

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.258

UNSAT
TT=0.239

UNSAT
TT=0.331

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

?
TT=1799.59

?
TT=1799.55

normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/
submitted-PB06/roussel/
normalized-pigeon-cardinality-95-90.opb
UNSAT
TT=0.157

UNSAT
TT=2.274

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.037

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (problem)
TT=0.03

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (problem)
TT=0.037

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

Signal
TT=1651.41

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=545.97

UNSAT
TT=1.698

? (TO)
TT=1800.26

UNSAT
TT=0.206

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.276

UNSAT
TT=1.704

UNSAT
TT=0.157

UNSAT
TT=1.122

UNSAT
TT=1.683

UNSAT
TT=0.176

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (problem)
TT=0.032

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

?
TT=1799.5

?
TT=1799.88

UNSAT
TT=1.656

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.38

UNSAT
TT=0.242

UNSAT
TT=0.223

UNSAT
TT=0.317

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

?
TT=1799.9

?
TT=1799.83




Statisticsbsolo
3.2
(complete)
clasp
2.0.6-R5325 (dec)
(complete)
npSolver
1.0
(complete)
npSolver
1.0 (fixed)
(complete)
npSolver
inc
(complete)
npSolver
inc (fixed)
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topDown
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topDown (fixed)
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topdown-quickBound
(complete)
npSolver
inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed)
(complete)
PB07: bsolo
3.0.17
(complete)
PB07: minisat+
1.14
(complete)
PB07: PB-clasp
2007-04-10
(complete)
PB07: Pueblo
1.4
(incomplete)
PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution
2007-03-23
(complete)
PB09: bsolo
3.1
(complete)
PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution
2.1.1
(complete)
PB09: SCIPspx
SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009)
(complete)
PB10: borg-pb
10.05.30
(complete)
PB10: pb_cplex
2010-06-29
(complete)
PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP
2.2.0 2010-05-31
(complete)
PB10: SCIPspx
SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver
(complete)
PB11: borg
pb-dec-11.04.03
(complete)
PB11: Sat4j Res//CP
2.3.0
(complete)
PB11: SCIP spx E_2
2011-06-10 (fixed)
(complete)
PB12: minisatp
1.0-2-g022594c
(complete)
pb2sat
2012-05-19
(complete)
pb2satCp2
2012-05-19
(complete)
PBPASSolver-CARD.DP
2012-05-28
(complete)
PBPASSolver-CARD.SN
2012-05-28
(complete)
pwbo
2.0
(complete)
pwbo
2.02
(complete)
SAT 4j PB RES // CP
2.3.2 Snapshot
(complete)
Sat 4j PB Resolution
2.3.2 Snapshot
(complete)
SAT4J PB specific settings
2.3.2 snapshot
(complete)
SCIP spx
SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed
(complete)
SCIP spx E
SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed
(complete)
SCIP spx standard
SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed
(complete)
toysat
2012-05-17
(complete)
toysat
2012-06-01
(complete)
wbo
1.7
(complete)
wbo
1.72
(complete)
Number of times the solver is able to give the best known answer19202020202222131022016202020202020200222220212020200122
Number of times the solver is the best solver from a complete solver point of view
(i.e. best known answer and best TT time)
0000000000000500010201200100000000000000000