CSP 2006 Competition (second round): results by benchmark

Results by benchmark for category binary constraints in extension (2-ARY-EXT), subcategory random problems

This page displays the results of the different solvers for each benchmark for category binary constraints in extension (2-ARY-EXT), subcategory random problems

REMINDER

Keep in mind that the 'Best result' columns only provide the best result given by one of the solvers. This 'Best result' may be wrong in case of an UNSATISFIABLE or OPTIMUM FOUND answer (because there's no efficient way to check these answers).

Description of a cell contents:

Cell example	Meaning
Answer	Solver result
TT=...	Total Time (TT): this is the CPU time (in seconds) used by the solver until termination. This time is only meaningful for complete solvers because incomplete solvers will always run until they time out

Remember that CPU time and wall clock time are two very different notions. The CPU time represents the time during which the instructions of the solver were executed by the processor. The wall clock time represents how much time ellapsed on the clock. For a same event, the CPU time may be either smaller or greater than the wall clock time depending on the number of threads of execution and the number of processors.

Meaning of some abbreviations:

Abbreviation	Meaning
TO	Time Out
MO	Mem. Out (out of memory)

Meaning of the different colors:

Color	Meaning
text	the solver cannot handle this instance
text	the solver gave no answer
text	the solver gave a definitive answer (SAT or UNSAT)
text	the solver performed better than the other ones on that instance
text	the solver was ended by a signal
text	the solver gave an incomplete answer
text	the solver was disqualified in the category
text	the solver gave a wrong answer

For better readability, you may choose to hide some solvers:
Abscon 109 ESAC
Abscon 109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13
buggy_2_5 2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3
Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21
galac 1
galacJ beta 1
Mistral 2006-12-04
rjw-solver 2006-12-09
rjw-solver 2007-01-21
sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3
sugar 0.40
Tramontane 2006-12-04
VALCSP 3.0
VALCSP 3.1

Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
frb/frb30-15/ frb30-15-1-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.078	SAT TT=0.928 CHECKS=309860 NODES=295	SAT TT=0.933 CHECKS=288213 NODES=317	SAT TT=0.27	SAT TT=0.445	SAT TT=0.449	SAT TT=1.692 NODES=1826	SAT TT=2.695 NODES=3790	SAT TT=3.094 CHECKS=65028 NODES=4506	SAT TT=5.817	SAT TT=16.177 CHECKS=9766001 NODES=7062	SAT TT=16.782 CHECKS=10878841 NODES=8223	SAT TT=4.134 CHECKS=2690117 NODES=1655	SAT TT=4.298	SAT TT=5.825	SAT TT=0.427	SAT TT=1.274 CHECKS=804338 NODES=575	SAT TT=1.268 CHECKS=804338 NODES=575	SAT TT=13.373	SAT TT=12.272	SAT TT=21.709	SAT TT=0.801	SAT TT=0.078 CHECKS=866747 NODES=237	SAT TT=0.077 CHECKS=866747 NODES=237
frb/frb30-15/ frb30-15-2-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.118	SAT TT=1.121 CHECKS=1143185 NODES=1125	SAT TT=1.529 CHECKS=3841897 NODES=3863	SAT TT=1.587	SAT TT=1.386	SAT TT=1.416	SAT TT=1.279 NODES=1028	SAT TT=3.783 NODES=5244	SAT TT=4.218 CHECKS=70377 NODES=6365	SAT TT=9.82	SAT TT=12.244 CHECKS=7274012 NODES=5043	SAT TT=13.152 CHECKS=8281447 NODES=5869	SAT TT=25.24 CHECKS=17379175 NODES=11191	SAT TT=15.029	SAT TT=8.606	SAT TT=1.992	SAT TT=15.415 CHECKS=10677586 NODES=7071	SAT TT=16.404 CHECKS=10677586 NODES=7071	SAT TT=15.709	SAT TT=14.885	SAT TT=36.66	SAT TT=0.118	SAT TT=0.385 CHECKS=10748100 NODES=2661	SAT TT=0.384 CHECKS=10748100 NODES=2661
frb/frb30-15/ frb30-15-3-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.272	SAT TT=1.555 CHECKS=3766806 NODES=3560	SAT TT=1.627 CHECKS=3934074 NODES=3737	SAT TT=1.276	SAT TT=0.939	SAT TT=0.937	SAT TT=4.678 NODES=7182	SAT TT=2.334 NODES=2737	SAT TT=2.31 CHECKS=68639 NODES=2937	SAT TT=0.864	SAT TT=11.563 CHECKS=6804349 NODES=4786	SAT TT=17.433 CHECKS=11291119 NODES=7273	SAT TT=10.618 CHECKS=7328158 NODES=4250	SAT TT=2.382	SAT TT=4.061	SAT TT=0.272	SAT TT=13.142 CHECKS=8574413 NODES=5387	SAT TT=12.35 CHECKS=8574413 NODES=5387	SAT TT=4.863	SAT TT=4.965	SAT TT=4.37	SAT TT=0.326	SAT TT=0.289 CHECKS=7649740 NODES=1692	SAT TT=0.267 CHECKS=7649740 NODES=1692
frb/frb30-15/ frb30-15-4-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.133	SAT TT=0.888 CHECKS=380993 NODES=397	SAT TT=0.9 CHECKS=140091 NODES=180	SAT TT=0.584	SAT TT=1.392	SAT TT=1.388	SAT TT=2.734 NODES=3475	SAT TT=3.509 NODES=4704	SAT TT=2.885 CHECKS=68657 NODES=4028	SAT TT=0.585	SAT TT=20.268 CHECKS=13236520 NODES=8891	SAT TT=21.321 CHECKS=13229662 NODES=9126	SAT TT=11.756 CHECKS=7912750 NODES=5021	SAT TT=2.387	SAT TT=3.087	SAT TT=1.119	SAT TT=4.827 CHECKS=3301308 NODES=2106	SAT TT=5.324 CHECKS=3301308 NODES=2106	SAT TT=2.674	SAT TT=2.983	SAT TT=13.52	SAT TT=1.076	SAT TT=0.133 CHECKS=2670640 NODES=618	SAT TT=0.135 CHECKS=2670640 NODES=618
frb/frb30-15/ frb30-15-5-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.171	SAT TT=0.966 CHECKS=745925 NODES=704	SAT TT=0.921 CHECKS=234846 NODES=271	SAT TT=0.602	SAT TT=1.625	SAT TT=1.626	SAT TT=0.818 NODES=360	SAT TT=1.848 NODES=1752	SAT TT=1.695 CHECKS=68617 NODES=1828	SAT TT=0.881	SAT TT=19.764 CHECKS=12151779 NODES=8451	SAT TT=11.292 CHECKS=7097865 NODES=4695	SAT TT=32.008 CHECKS=22294226 NODES=12881	SAT TT=2.392	SAT TT=2.689	SAT TT=0.345	SAT TT=6.098 CHECKS=4102863 NODES=2475	SAT TT=6.125 CHECKS=4102863 NODES=2475	SAT TT=4.422	SAT TT=4.438	SAT TT=6.31	SAT TT=0.328	SAT TT=0.171 CHECKS=3974620 NODES=886	SAT TT=0.172 CHECKS=3974620 NODES=886
frb/frb35-17/ frb35-17-1-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.754	SAT TT=3.614 CHECKS=17504113 NODES=13393	SAT TT=4.231 CHECKS=21099255 NODES=15974	SAT TT=2.733	SAT TT=2.378	SAT TT=2.368	SAT TT=23.543 NODES=29879	SAT TT=8.004 NODES=9882	SAT TT=8.468 CHECKS=106566 NODES=11399	SAT TT=70.469	SAT TT=63.453 CHECKS=33955353 NODES=17627	SAT TT=69.188 CHECKS=36663307 NODES=18479	SAT TT=107.572 CHECKS=64379955 NODES=29898	SAT TT=18.422	SAT TT=4.778	SAT TT=4.102	SAT TT=96.336 CHECKS=58908095 NODES=26027	SAT TT=104.451 CHECKS=58908095 NODES=26027	SAT TT=17.821	SAT TT=17.344	SAT TT=46.242	SAT TT=2.854	SAT TT=1.754 CHECKS=58823800 NODES=9427	SAT TT=1.804 CHECKS=58823800 NODES=9427
frb/frb35-17/ frb35-17-2-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.854	SAT TT=2.189 CHECKS=7316156 NODES=6224	SAT TT=3.942 CHECKS=20454408 NODES=16810	SAT TT=1.854	SAT TT=4.309	SAT TT=4.566	SAT TT=0.933 NODES=341	SAT TT=14.165 NODES=17673	SAT TT=11.881 CHECKS=106291 NODES=17494	SAT TT=32.052	SAT TT=151.854 CHECKS=88177463 NODES=48370	SAT TT=155.126 CHECKS=91734995 NODES=50441	SAT TT=112.498 CHECKS=71755080 NODES=39218	SAT TT=93.984	SAT TT=106.658	SAT TT=4.004	SAT TT=172.285 CHECKS=97220993 NODES=52116	SAT TT=163.518 CHECKS=97220993 NODES=52116	SAT TT=794.608	SAT TT=828.731	SAT TT=223.84	SAT TT=15.18	SAT TT=3.152 CHECKS=97709200 NODES=19902	SAT TT=2.871 CHECKS=97709200 NODES=19902
frb/frb35-17/ frb35-17-3-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.921	SAT TT=1.156 CHECKS=1190544 NODES=1071	SAT TT=1.071 CHECKS=851704 NODES=778	SAT TT=4.42	SAT TT=5.761	SAT TT=5.589	SAT TT=6.115 NODES=7178	SAT TT=2.616 NODES=2638	SAT TT=4.495 CHECKS=110751 NODES=5789	SAT TT=94.209	SAT TT=56.818 CHECKS=29095602 NODES=16856	SAT TT=54.994 CHECKS=28054817 NODES=16784	SAT TT=118.731 CHECKS=69998785 NODES=39851	SAT TT=41.618	SAT TT=46.317	SAT TT=2.037	SAT TT=49.004 CHECKS=25158956 NODES=15093	SAT TT=49.579 CHECKS=25158956 NODES=15093	SAT TT=47.247	SAT TT=48.187	SAT TT=56.777	SAT TT=6.344	SAT TT=0.921 CHECKS=26201400 NODES=6050	SAT TT=0.849 CHECKS=26201400 NODES=6050
frb/frb35-17/ frb35-17-4-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.257	SAT TT=2.773 CHECKS=11429769 NODES=8435	SAT TT=3.28 CHECKS=16629386 NODES=12231	SAT TT=0.816	SAT TT=3.392	SAT TT=3.628	SAT TT=7.377 NODES=8580	SAT TT=8.22 NODES=8708	SAT TT=6.662 CHECKS=106730 NODES=8761	SAT TT=51.286	SAT TT=63.144 CHECKS=35788478 NODES=16865	SAT TT=65.493 CHECKS=38876400 NODES=18409	SAT TT=109.949 CHECKS=71599445 NODES=30608	SAT TT=25.476	SAT TT=21.133	SAT TT=2.71	SAT TT=52.546 CHECKS=32845717 NODES=15001	SAT TT=57.304 CHECKS=32845717 NODES=15001	SAT TT=19.052	SAT TT=19.393	SAT TT=87.39	SAT TT=0.257	SAT TT=1.041 CHECKS=31853600 NODES=5252	SAT TT=1.034 CHECKS=31853600 NODES=5252
frb/frb35-17/ frb35-17-5-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.199	SAT TT=4.748 CHECKS=25866598 NODES=20580	SAT TT=1.91 CHECKS=5750420 NODES=4765	SAT TT=4.654	SAT TT=6.178	SAT TT=6.497	SAT TT=1.502 NODES=1187	SAT TT=28.437 NODES=39860	SAT TT=28.558 CHECKS=112198 NODES=41146	SAT TT=0.199	SAT TT=36.358 CHECKS=16924969 NODES=9736	SAT TT=23.525 CHECKS=10296335 NODES=5856	SAT TT=368.15 CHECKS=192346777 NODES=102811	SAT TT=130.991	SAT TT=53.038	SAT TT=10.976	SAT TT=232.35 CHECKS=121537886 NODES=65468	SAT TT=247.564 CHECKS=121537886 NODES=65468	SAT TT=204.618	SAT TT=214.984	SAT TT=99.17	SAT TT=14.005	SAT TT=3.481 CHECKS=117395000 NODES=24025	SAT TT=3.68 CHECKS=117395000 NODES=24025
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
frb/frb40-19/ frb40-19-1-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.54	SAT TT=1.54 CHECKS=3289620 NODES=2368	SAT TT=7.485 CHECKS=45290482 NODES=31521	SAT TT=25.756	SAT TT=5.075	SAT TT=4.993	SAT TT=7.346 NODES=7182	SAT TT=41.925 NODES=44804	SAT TT=40.104 CHECKS=165924 NODES=46854	SAT TT=624.146	SAT TT=297.047 CHECKS=174492325 NODES=70318	SAT TT=290.509 CHECKS=172464266 NODES=69465	SAT TT=478.011 CHECKS=307377910 NODES=122098	SAT TT=4.2	SAT TT=182.765	SAT TT=24.511	SAT TT=385.977 CHECKS=221834622 NODES=87539	SAT TT=392.903 CHECKS=221834622 NODES=87539	SAT TT=235.742	SAT TT=242.277	SAT TT=376.289	SAT TT=21.514	SAT TT=6.443 CHECKS=214740000 NODES=33575	SAT TT=6.404 CHECKS=214740000 NODES=33575
frb/frb40-19/ frb40-19-2-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.457	SAT TT=1.891 CHECKS=6120720 NODES=4565	SAT TT=1.457 CHECKS=2766955 NODES=2114	SAT TT=94.347	SAT TT=3.583	SAT TT=3.704	SAT TT=0.757 NODES=101	SAT TT=74.232 NODES=86634	SAT TT=76.883 CHECKS=167439 NODES=100434	SAT TT=588.544	SAT TT=174.599 CHECKS=105049557 NODES=44569	SAT TT=264.477 CHECKS=153398933 NODES=62784	SAT TT=994.755 CHECKS=623213649 NODES=259129	SAT TT=360.164	SAT TT=89.818	SAT TT=5.272	SAT TT=175.111 CHECKS=108168270 NODES=45476	SAT TT=179.992 CHECKS=108168270 NODES=45476	SAT TT=476.788	SAT TT=483.793	SAT TT=754.26	SAT TT=35.67	SAT TT=3.053 CHECKS=104303000 NODES=17633	SAT TT=3.189 CHECKS=104303000 NODES=17633
frb/frb40-19/ frb40-19-3-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=8.8	SAT TT=39.155 CHECKS=245438948 NODES=187091	SAT TT=17.24 CHECKS=112293829 NODES=84531	SAT TT=91.494	SAT TT=37.03	SAT TT=34.873	SAT TT=18.36 NODES=21438	SAT TT=325.524 NODES=389684	SAT TT=278.752 CHECKS=155726 NODES=397215	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=763.742 CHECKS=430803903 NODES=207981	SAT TT=736.933 CHECKS=425502742 NODES=205395	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=109.305	SAT TT=1491.72 CHECKS=850466417 NODES=407210	SAT TT=1532.3 CHECKS=850466417 NODES=407210	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=8.8	SAT TT=22.783 CHECKS=784834000 NODES=151379	SAT TT=24.397 CHECKS=784834000 NODES=151379
frb/frb40-19/ frb40-19-4-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.489	SAT TT=10.25 CHECKS=60547397 NODES=42902	SAT TT=47.548 CHECKS=330176782 NODES=230902	SAT TT=29.396	SAT TT=19.9	SAT TT=20.156	SAT TT=36.741 NODES=38669	SAT TT=187.249 NODES=219465	SAT TT=133.333 CHECKS=167593 NODES=174501	SAT TT=142.334	SAT TT=920.74 CHECKS=521239312 NODES=239426	SAT TT=1091.39 CHECKS=533080633 NODES=243750	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=1214.92	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=31.875	SAT TT=268.996 CHECKS=142863544 NODES=65140	SAT TT=256.702 CHECKS=142863544 NODES=65140	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.19	SAT TT=735.004	SAT TT=97.079	SAT TT=4.489 CHECKS=143350000 NODES=25098	SAT TT=4.484 CHECKS=143350000 NODES=25098
frb/frb40-19/ frb40-19-5-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=10.227	SAT TT=80.426 CHECKS=504378609 NODES=372979	SAT TT=82.37 CHECKS=556059266 NODES=414712	SAT TT=150.636	SAT TT=52.095	SAT TT=55.554	SAT TT=249.995 NODES=277916	SAT TT=208.683 NODES=260214	SAT TT=216.063 CHECKS=169535 NODES=290893	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=603.749 CHECKS=332382758 NODES=166295	SAT TT=976.508 CHECKS=517078704 NODES=264205	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=153.607	SAT TT=611.718 CHECKS=328890840 NODES=164178	SAT TT=638.835 CHECKS=328890840 NODES=164178	SAT TT=390.347	SAT TT=400.568	SAT TT=918.327	SAT TT=114.051	SAT TT=10.227 CHECKS=318887000 NODES=63997	SAT TT=10.106 CHECKS=318887000 NODES=63997
frb/frb45-21/ frb45-21-1-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=6.926	SAT TT=90.771 CHECKS=613789147 NODES=390951	SAT TT=30.029 CHECKS=190963189 NODES=123139	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=7.047	SAT TT=6.926	SAT TT=119.578 NODES=106885	SAT TT=1393.71 NODES=1472831	SAT TT=1187.49 CHECKS=249710 NODES=1319976	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.6	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=280.78 CHECKS=8951050000 NODES=1511880	SAT TT=273.113 CHECKS=8951050000 NODES=1511880
frb/frb45-21/ frb45-21-2-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=73.112	SAT TT=107.296 CHECKS=715802997 NODES=460419	SAT TT=73.112 CHECKS=516828091 NODES=331977	SAT TT=648.942	SAT TT=106.615	SAT TT=112.671	SAT TT=665.011 NODES=626636	SAT TT=590.981 NODES=562281	SAT TT=537.287 CHECKS=238171 NODES=618218	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=94.575	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=492.791	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.15	SAT TT=74.621	SAT TT=568.448	SAT TT=96.424 CHECKS=3100950000 NODES=529944	SAT TT=94.947 CHECKS=3100950000 NODES=529944
frb/frb45-21/ frb45-21-3-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=54.041	SAT TT=156.933 CHECKS=1112593646 NODES=720577	SAT TT=209.573 CHECKS=1399072869 NODES=908052	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=265.815	SAT TT=249.34	? (TO) TT=1800	SAT TT=897.975 NODES=936248	SAT TT=359.629 CHECKS=229486 NODES=418272	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=475.168	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=1265.82	SAT TT=54.041 CHECKS=1721410000 NODES=303672	SAT TT=52.553 CHECKS=1721410000 NODES=303672
frb/frb45-21/ frb45-21-4-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.285	SAT TT=2.285 CHECKS=9091424 NODES=5634	SAT TT=11.088 CHECKS=68240323 NODES=42274	SAT TT=252.78	SAT TT=218.68	SAT TT=211.423	SAT TT=7.559 NODES=6105	SAT TT=1204.04 NODES=1175832	SAT TT=1571.12 CHECKS=237917 NODES=1743529	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=490.251	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=543.944	SAT TT=77.579 CHECKS=2516490000 NODES=417652	SAT TT=77.607 CHECKS=2516490000 NODES=417652
frb/frb45-21/ frb45-21-5-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=56.871	SAT TT=404.202 CHECKS=2854025528 NODES=1787259	SAT TT=526.109 CHECKS=3684603661 NODES=2299428	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=245.086	SAT TT=231.393	SAT TT=1219.26 NODES=1160819	SAT TT=110.882 NODES=110323	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=1596.87	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=267.515	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=56.871	SAT TT=60.028	SAT TT=941.31	SAT TT=549.168	SAT TT=118.556 CHECKS=3923610000 NODES=608646	SAT TT=118.555 CHECKS=3923610000 NODES=608646
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
frb/frb50-23/ frb50-23-1-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=508.324	SAT TT=508.324 CHECKS=3446439207 NODES=1997854	SAT TT=760.972 CHECKS=5620777249 NODES=3240075	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=638.572 CHECKS=20942400000 NODES=3101720	SAT TT=626.566 CHECKS=20942400000 NODES=3101720
frb/frb50-23/ frb50-23-2-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09
frb/frb50-23/ frb50-23-3-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=582.261	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=622.836	SAT TT=582.261	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11
frb/frb50-23/ frb50-23-4-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=36.044	SAT TT=73.287 CHECKS=536947976 NODES=311555	SAT TT=154.219 CHECKS=1073175800 NODES=614186	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=553.798	SAT TT=517.815	SAT TT=1398.08 NODES=1049129	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=198.487	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=36.044 CHECKS=1160710000 NODES=192864	SAT TT=36.039 CHECKS=1160710000 NODES=192864
frb/frb50-23/ frb50-23-5-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=328.129	SAT TT=1546.18 CHECKS=10685475368 NODES=6040065	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=1337.59	SAT TT=1256.38	SAT TT=171.155 NODES=129022	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=328.129 CHECKS=10880900000 NODES=1607660	SAT TT=318.859 CHECKS=10880900000 NODES=1607660
frb/frb53-24/ frb53-24-1-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07
frb/frb53-24/ frb53-24-2-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06
frb/frb53-24/ frb53-24-3-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.22	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.01
frb/frb53-24/ frb53-24-4-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=73.891	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=73.891 CHECKS=509726407 NODES=262196	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=182.06 NODES=126936	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=1063.8	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=454.243 CHECKS=15829500000 NODES=2005400	SAT TT=436.845 CHECKS=15829500000 NODES=2005400
frb/frb53-24/ frb53-24-5-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
frb/frb56-25/ frb56-25-1-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11
frb/frb56-25/ frb56-25-2-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07
frb/frb56-25/ frb56-25-3-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04
frb/frb56-25/ frb56-25-4-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1
frb/frb56-25/ frb56-25-5-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02
frb/frb59-26/ frb59-26-1-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07
frb/frb59-26/ frb59-26-2-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.02
frb/frb59-26/ frb59-26-3-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1
frb/frb59-26/ frb59-26-4-mgd_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1
frb/frb59-26/ frb59-26-5-mgd_ext.xml	SAT TT=413.883	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=413.883 CHECKS=2438873030 NODES=1166077	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.22	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
marc/ large-80-sat_ext.xml	SAT TT=13.394	SAT TT=14.931 CHECKS=32216 NODES=0	SAT TT=13.394 CHECKS=29056 NODES=80	? (conv) TT=0.017	SAT TT=42.608	SAT TT=44.631	SAT TT=44.777 NODES=0	SAT TT=43.95 NODES=80	SAT TT=43.555 CHECKS=6320 NODES=80	? (MO) TT=8.617	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.031	? (TO) TT=0.027	? (problem) TT=109.535	SAT TT=17.884	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.034	SAT TT=46.406	SAT TT=46.041	? TT=422.52	SAT TT=16.009	SAT TT=321.874 CHECKS=120426 NODES=80	SAT TT=299.168 CHECKS=120426 NODES=80
marc/ large-80-unsat_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=11.802	UNSAT TT=12.116 CHECKS=1176214 NODES=0	UNSAT TT=11.802 CHECKS=1078209 NODES=79	? (conv) TT=0.017	UNSAT TT=32.972	UNSAT TT=32.898	UNSAT TT=44.509 NODES=79	UNSAT TT=47.657 NODES=63	UNSAT TT=50.306 CHECKS=20217680 NODES=66	? (MO) TT=6.137	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.032	UNSAT TT=1201.21	? (problem) TT=153.86	UNSAT TT=13.91	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=0.034	UNSAT TT=45.485	UNSAT TT=40.359	? TT=380.301	UNSAT TT=13.927	UNSAT TT=254.863 CHECKS=1392220 NODES=0	UNSAT TT=246.242 CHECKS=1392220 NODES=0
marc/ large-84-sat_ext.xml	SAT TT=15.726	SAT TT=15.726 CHECKS=46863 NODES=0	SAT TT=17.41 CHECKS=43377 NODES=84	? (conv) TT=0.017	SAT TT=51.814	SAT TT=52.188	SAT TT=52.752 NODES=0	SAT TT=52.801 NODES=84	SAT TT=58.359 CHECKS=6972 NODES=84	? (MO) TT=5.592	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=193.956	? (problem) TT=186.422	SAT TT=21.389	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=54.631	SAT TT=55.909	? TT=42.409	SAT TT=20.018	SAT TT=421.716 CHECKS=120553 NODES=84	SAT TT=433.801 CHECKS=120553 NODES=84
marc/ large-84-unsat_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=13.844	UNSAT TT=13.844 CHECKS=1407276 NODES=0	UNSAT TT=14.249 CHECKS=1271279 NODES=83	? (conv) TT=0.018	UNSAT TT=37.641	UNSAT TT=39.556	UNSAT TT=55.122 NODES=84	UNSAT TT=59.573 NODES=67	UNSAT TT=55.069 CHECKS=24590244 NODES=62	? (MO) TT=6.58	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.038	? (problem) TT=121.576	? (problem) TT=120.558	UNSAT TT=18.192	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.033	UNSAT TT=50.251	UNSAT TT=48.507	? TT=406.518	UNSAT TT=16.077	UNSAT TT=328.207 CHECKS=1612530 NODES=0	UNSAT TT=344.073 CHECKS=1612530 NODES=0
marc/ large-88-sat_ext.xml	SAT TT=18.772	SAT TT=20.441 CHECKS=36616 NODES=0	SAT TT=18.772 CHECKS=32788 NODES=88	? (conv) TT=0.017	SAT TT=65.523	SAT TT=65.277	? TT=333.067	? TT=310.926	? TT=307.157	? (MO) TT=6.578	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=297.525	? (problem) TT=293.562	SAT TT=25.826	? (problem) TT=0.038	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=69.749	SAT TT=65.84	? TT=36.54	SAT TT=25.072	SAT TT=571.475 CHECKS=151260 NODES=88	SAT TT=544.715 CHECKS=151260 NODES=88
marc/ large-88-unsat_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=16.382	UNSAT TT=16.382 CHECKS=1645295 NODES=0	UNSAT TT=16.432 CHECKS=1440713 NODES=86	? (conv) TT=0.018	UNSAT TT=47.698	UNSAT TT=48.17	UNSAT TT=97.827 NODES=90	UNSAT TT=110.393 NODES=65	UNSAT TT=127.905 CHECKS=29636376 NODES=65	? (MO) TT=7.207	? (problem) TT=0.038	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (problem) TT=143.944	? (problem) TT=135.866	UNSAT TT=21.55	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=0.036	UNSAT TT=62.673	UNSAT TT=57.558	? TT=1185.08	UNSAT TT=20.234	UNSAT TT=442.489 CHECKS=1854940 NODES=0	UNSAT TT=432.622 CHECKS=1854940 NODES=0
marc/ large-92-sat_ext.xml	SAT TT=22.359	SAT TT=22.359 CHECKS=47353 NODES=0	SAT TT=22.374 CHECKS=43167 NODES=92	? (conv) TT=0.017	SAT TT=64.137	SAT TT=66.806	? TT=295.347	? TT=262.385	? TT=298.095	? (MO) TT=6.964	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=277.651	? (problem) TT=277.531	SAT TT=29.325	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (problem) TT=0.036	SAT TT=77.395	SAT TT=75.243	? TT=52.873	SAT TT=29.637	SAT TT=722.096 CHECKS=154582 NODES=92	SAT TT=713.33 CHECKS=154582 NODES=92
marc/ large-92-unsat_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=17.856	UNSAT TT=17.856 CHECKS=1918859 NODES=0	UNSAT TT=18.064 CHECKS=1705351 NODES=91	? (conv) TT=0.019	UNSAT TT=53.635	UNSAT TT=54.95	? TT=382.528	? TT=442.404	? TT=426.781	? (MO) TT=7.226	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=312.389	? (problem) TT=350.259	UNSAT TT=24.725	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.034	UNSAT TT=65.889	UNSAT TT=69.314	? TT=37.84	UNSAT TT=23.848	UNSAT TT=595.023 CHECKS=2120440 NODES=0	UNSAT TT=554.758 CHECKS=2120440 NODES=0
marc/ large-96-sat_ext.xml	SAT TT=27.436	SAT TT=27.436 CHECKS=55143 NODES=0	SAT TT=27.81 CHECKS=50583 NODES=96	? (conv) TT=0.019	SAT TT=79.646	SAT TT=76.214	? TT=221.385	? TT=224.552	? TT=257.978	? (MO) TT=7.175	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=369.383	? (problem) TT=381.216	SAT TT=35.594	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.033	SAT TT=88.633	SAT TT=91.999	? TT=46.11	SAT TT=35.535	SAT TT=925.562 CHECKS=159433 NODES=96	SAT TT=989.084 CHECKS=159433 NODES=96
marc/ large-96-unsat_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=22.151	UNSAT TT=22.151 CHECKS=2219519 NODES=0	UNSAT TT=22.819 CHECKS=1912760 NODES=94	? (conv) TT=0.019	UNSAT TT=64.663	UNSAT TT=67.204	? TT=297.215	? TT=283.75	? TT=276.517	? (MO) TT=8.085	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=285.655	? (problem) TT=311.484	UNSAT TT=29.909	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.038	UNSAT TT=99.355	UNSAT TT=97.961	? TT=39.73	UNSAT TT=27.667	UNSAT TT=727.499 CHECKS=2410260 NODES=0	UNSAT TT=727.12 CHECKS=2410260 NODES=0
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-23/ rand-23-23-253-131-46021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=24.86	UNSAT TT=101.002 CHECKS=664471318 NODES=506059	UNSAT TT=105.137 CHECKS=707975132 NODES=537791	UNSAT TT=48.463	UNSAT TT=40.859	UNSAT TT=41.603	UNSAT TT=662.654 NODES=629730	UNSAT TT=261.509 NODES=401280	UNSAT TT=228.345 CHECKS=209198 NODES=397776	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=1458.47 CHECKS=783778269 NODES=552805	UNSAT TT=1558.06 CHECKS=770203342 NODES=545218	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=116.395	UNSAT TT=1604.72 CHECKS=752115205 NODES=533236	UNSAT TT=1610.04 CHECKS=752115205 NODES=533236	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=137.153	UNSAT TT=24.86 CHECKS=762123000 NODES=191607	UNSAT TT=23.17 CHECKS=762123000 NODES=191607
random/rand-2-23/ rand-23-23-253-131-47021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=24.431	UNSAT TT=97.097 CHECKS=651546326 NODES=490572	UNSAT TT=95.632 CHECKS=632766949 NODES=478159	UNSAT TT=45.859	UNSAT TT=40.556	UNSAT TT=39.117	UNSAT TT=630.337 NODES=591855	UNSAT TT=277.41 NODES=398958	UNSAT TT=246.685 CHECKS=204096 NODES=393683	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=1450.59 CHECKS=740232637 NODES=518607	UNSAT TT=1643.8 CHECKS=771846134 NODES=539918	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=110.491	UNSAT TT=1488.32 CHECKS=732374599 NODES=513952	UNSAT TT=1477.53 CHECKS=732374599 NODES=513952	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=130.764	UNSAT TT=24.431 CHECKS=749117000 NODES=186106	UNSAT TT=22.656 CHECKS=749117000 NODES=186106
random/rand-2-23/ rand-23-23-253-131-48021_ext.xml	SAT TT=15.971	SAT TT=62.843 CHECKS=417178844 NODES=317237	SAT TT=88.269 CHECKS=557724450 NODES=419676	SAT TT=32.011	SAT TT=15.971	SAT TT=16.017	SAT TT=330.758 NODES=337319	SAT TT=62.109 NODES=92496	SAT TT=56.24 CHECKS=203158 NODES=89596	SAT TT=22.864	SAT TT=303.081 CHECKS=170619178 NODES=118253	SAT TT=103.994 CHECKS=52292305 NODES=35746	SAT TT=773.27 CHECKS=403071536 NODES=285868	SAT TT=430.967	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=50.311	SAT TT=1084.6 CHECKS=537004351 NODES=375449	SAT TT=1088.33 CHECKS=537004351 NODES=375449	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=32.602	SAT TT=18.199 CHECKS=550598000 NODES=135896	SAT TT=17.861 CHECKS=550598000 NODES=135896
random/rand-2-23/ rand-23-23-253-131-49021_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.012	SAT TT=2.012 CHECKS=7376944 NODES=5844	SAT TT=35.277 CHECKS=227992844 NODES=175674	SAT TT=4.1	SAT TT=6.628	SAT TT=6.837	SAT TT=163.233 NODES=168270	SAT TT=238.787 NODES=371808	SAT TT=163.754 CHECKS=204274 NODES=255511	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=92.559 CHECKS=48851059 NODES=34630	SAT TT=986.929 CHECKS=483035909 NODES=338128	SAT TT=769.925 CHECKS=402740569 NODES=279205	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=32.985	SAT TT=115.183 CHECKS=57104512 NODES=40921	SAT TT=114.945 CHECKS=57104512 NODES=40921	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=35.401	SAT TT=2.072 CHECKS=59176900 NODES=14990	SAT TT=1.926 CHECKS=59176900 NODES=14990
random/rand-2-23/ rand-23-23-253-131-50021_ext.xml	SAT TT=13.803	SAT TT=90.851 CHECKS=634978159 NODES=492025	SAT TT=59.985 CHECKS=420917965 NODES=332321	SAT TT=50.227	SAT TT=36.818	SAT TT=38.488	SAT TT=14.419 NODES=14338	SAT TT=17.2 NODES=26910	SAT TT=13.803 CHECKS=202050 NODES=20739	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=795.443 CHECKS=400415914 NODES=288685	SAT TT=850.255 CHECKS=426303961 NODES=305648	SAT TT=538.779 CHECKS=288001702 NODES=208248	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=50.642	SAT TT=1727.25 CHECKS=791265385 NODES=569138	SAT TT=1627.84 CHECKS=791265385 NODES=569138	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=31.294	SAT TT=24.266 CHECKS=798235000 NODES=204563	SAT TT=25.997 CHECKS=798235000 NODES=204563
random/rand-2-23/ rand-23-23-253-131-51021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=26.646	UNSAT TT=101.899 CHECKS=686602124 NODES=524337	UNSAT TT=108.77 CHECKS=715213835 NODES=546328	UNSAT TT=52.065	UNSAT TT=41.885	UNSAT TT=44.604	UNSAT TT=617.738 NODES=630633	UNSAT TT=281.706 NODES=418143	UNSAT TT=248.503 CHECKS=203736 NODES=412710	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=1530.77 CHECKS=796112620 NODES=567648	UNSAT TT=1613.71 CHECKS=802076646 NODES=569445	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=112.245	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	UNSAT TT=138.204	UNSAT TT=26.646 CHECKS=835359000 NODES=210810	UNSAT TT=25.281 CHECKS=835359000 NODES=210810
random/rand-2-23/ rand-23-23-253-131-52021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=24.169	UNSAT TT=92.282 CHECKS=628559294 NODES=472758	UNSAT TT=99.401 CHECKS=687208692 NODES=515969	UNSAT TT=47.007	UNSAT TT=40.466	UNSAT TT=41.304	UNSAT TT=497.506 NODES=526802	UNSAT TT=243.746 NODES=396159	UNSAT TT=222.123 CHECKS=206941 NODES=381106	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=1420.05 CHECKS=723442419 NODES=507295	UNSAT TT=1553.47 CHECKS=725586468 NODES=510671	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=105.687	UNSAT TT=1493.36 CHECKS=725821946 NODES=509970	UNSAT TT=1474.54 CHECKS=725821946 NODES=509970	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=135.046	UNSAT TT=24.169 CHECKS=735585000 NODES=182201	UNSAT TT=23.951 CHECKS=735585000 NODES=182201
random/rand-2-23/ rand-23-23-253-131-53021_ext.xml	SAT TT=14.128	SAT TT=51.192 CHECKS=358011256 NODES=273402	SAT TT=83.25 CHECKS=564800774 NODES=427559	SAT TT=27.249	SAT TT=34.371	SAT TT=34.512	SAT TT=269.533 NODES=248405	SAT TT=137.675 NODES=223174	SAT TT=146.531 CHECKS=203928 NODES=251716	SAT TT=598.792	SAT TT=574.748 CHECKS=290298776 NODES=202185	SAT TT=1156.35 CHECKS=573112693 NODES=397335	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=14.609	SAT TT=907.845 CHECKS=422330190 NODES=295488	SAT TT=917.335 CHECKS=422330190 NODES=295488	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.15	SAT TT=1659.26	SAT TT=70.637	SAT TT=14.128 CHECKS=430194000 NODES=105854	SAT TT=13.958 CHECKS=430194000 NODES=105854
random/rand-2-23/ rand-23-23-253-131-54021_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.645	SAT TT=14.622 CHECKS=95977087 NODES=76067	SAT TT=12.394 CHECKS=75607897 NODES=59480	SAT TT=32.047	SAT TT=9.433	SAT TT=9.474	SAT TT=31.708 NODES=30573	SAT TT=237.083 NODES=373220	SAT TT=242.81 CHECKS=204930 NODES=390260	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=80.247 CHECKS=43085631 NODES=30594	SAT TT=385.739 CHECKS=187410818 NODES=132151	SAT TT=2.567 CHECKS=1512597 NODES=858	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=4.645	SAT TT=1000.48 CHECKS=489122706 NODES=345569	SAT TT=1064.56 CHECKS=489122706 NODES=345569	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800	SAT TT=34.367	SAT TT=15.447 CHECKS=499759000 NODES=124701	SAT TT=16.24 CHECKS=499759000 NODES=124701
random/rand-2-23/ rand-23-23-253-131-55021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=25.031	UNSAT TT=95.266 CHECKS=680900187 NODES=519269	UNSAT TT=100.11 CHECKS=704845115 NODES=534420	UNSAT TT=47.959	UNSAT TT=39.328	UNSAT TT=38.816	UNSAT TT=617.721 NODES=592933	UNSAT TT=248.638 NODES=381123	UNSAT TT=244.892 CHECKS=211873 NODES=385783	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=1493.47 CHECKS=791280626 NODES=560604	UNSAT TT=1623.63 CHECKS=759043314 NODES=539070	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	UNSAT TT=119.694	UNSAT TT=1521.39 CHECKS=741708310 NODES=526836	UNSAT TT=1626.33 CHECKS=741708310 NODES=526836	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=145.561	UNSAT TT=25.031 CHECKS=762712000 NODES=191299	UNSAT TT=24.787 CHECKS=762712000 NODES=191299
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-24/ rand-24-24-276-139-48021_ext.xml	SAT TT=9.908	SAT TT=213.073 CHECKS=1414666342 NODES=1016839	SAT TT=147.566 CHECKS=974819716 NODES=705542	SAT TT=18.262	SAT TT=34.788	SAT TT=32.662	SAT TT=704.814 NODES=678317	SAT TT=471.958 NODES=689898	SAT TT=530.69 CHECKS=243248 NODES=788131	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=883.398 CHECKS=386701364 NODES=256299	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=64.614	SAT TT=599.416 CHECKS=293501519 NODES=192693	SAT TT=570.573 CHECKS=293501519 NODES=192693	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=13.383	SAT TT=9.908 CHECKS=300621000 NODES=70002	SAT TT=9.27 CHECKS=300621000 NODES=70002
random/rand-2-24/ rand-24-24-276-139-49021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=56.069	UNSAT TT=228.635 CHECKS=1553737166 NODES=1098163	UNSAT TT=232.767 CHECKS=1555666554 NODES=1101906	UNSAT TT=103.935	UNSAT TT=91.04	UNSAT TT=90.827	UNSAT TT=1406.77 NODES=1236388	UNSAT TT=539.554 NODES=795674	UNSAT TT=535.154 CHECKS=246004 NODES=802102	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800	UNSAT TT=254.807	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=272.434	UNSAT TT=56.069 CHECKS=1711640000 NODES=402360	UNSAT TT=52.279 CHECKS=1711640000 NODES=402360
random/rand-2-24/ rand-24-24-276-139-50021_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.304	SAT TT=147.2 CHECKS=788976565 NODES=574096	SAT TT=138.649 CHECKS=925440958 NODES=668604	SAT TT=12.336	SAT TT=2.304	SAT TT=2.399	SAT TT=325.252 NODES=317447	SAT TT=477.258 NODES=679748	SAT TT=554.595 CHECKS=246233 NODES=830152	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=186.62 CHECKS=72612342 NODES=46609	SAT TT=227.789 CHECKS=80165499 NODES=53126	SAT TT=1288.21 CHECKS=603386892 NODES=397894	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=39.669	SAT TT=451.905 CHECKS=188252699 NODES=127703	SAT TT=378.4 CHECKS=188252699 NODES=127703	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=164.954	SAT TT=4.678 CHECKS=131220000 NODES=31689	SAT TT=4.485 CHECKS=131220000 NODES=31689
random/rand-2-24/ rand-24-24-276-139-51021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=60.286	UNSAT TT=236.257 CHECKS=1584006012 NODES=1128656	UNSAT TT=218.831 CHECKS=1582522674 NODES=1127737	UNSAT TT=106.13	UNSAT TT=91.377	UNSAT TT=86.446	UNSAT TT=1477.08 NODES=1295837	UNSAT TT=589.085 NODES=866918	UNSAT TT=531.282 CHECKS=244532 NODES=853372	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=270.003	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=287.232	UNSAT TT=60.286 CHECKS=1847260000 NODES=435549	UNSAT TT=59.555 CHECKS=1847260000 NODES=435549
random/rand-2-24/ rand-24-24-276-139-52021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=55.477	UNSAT TT=215.91 CHECKS=1555434220 NODES=1109595	UNSAT TT=243.456 CHECKS=1637246566 NODES=1166907	UNSAT TT=110.884	UNSAT TT=93.512	UNSAT TT=89.107	UNSAT TT=1455.17 NODES=1321050	UNSAT TT=588.149 NODES=850642	UNSAT TT=573.365 CHECKS=251214 NODES=855829	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.01	UNSAT TT=277.791	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=268.842	UNSAT TT=55.477 CHECKS=1807570000 NODES=427576	UNSAT TT=58.64 CHECKS=1807570000 NODES=427576
random/rand-2-24/ rand-24-24-276-139-53021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=59.617	UNSAT TT=242.033 CHECKS=1706551088 NODES=1229334	UNSAT TT=221.61 CHECKS=1599232375 NODES=1147915	UNSAT TT=115.464	UNSAT TT=93.693	UNSAT TT=100.069	UNSAT TT=1504.72 NODES=1348259	UNSAT TT=602.223 NODES=889719	UNSAT TT=533.233 CHECKS=245276 NODES=864550	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=273.994	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=325.582	UNSAT TT=59.617 CHECKS=1832500000 NODES=440219	UNSAT TT=59.522 CHECKS=1832500000 NODES=440219
random/rand-2-24/ rand-24-24-276-139-54021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=56.377	UNSAT TT=242.176 CHECKS=1602549192 NODES=1143657	UNSAT TT=228.278 CHECKS=1528489291 NODES=1094528	UNSAT TT=114.651	UNSAT TT=93.738	UNSAT TT=88.136	UNSAT TT=1525.12 NODES=1369953	UNSAT TT=546.593 NODES=854078	UNSAT TT=562.965 CHECKS=244564 NODES=855354	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=259.649	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=307.728	UNSAT TT=56.377 CHECKS=1864660000 NODES=446788	UNSAT TT=56.492 CHECKS=1864660000 NODES=446788
random/rand-2-24/ rand-24-24-276-139-55021_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.168	SAT TT=1.168 CHECKS=1801574 NODES=1377	SAT TT=1.954 CHECKS=6494220 NODES=4962	SAT TT=31.511	SAT TT=12.801	SAT TT=13.668	SAT TT=5.673 NODES=5011	SAT TT=598.072 NODES=881853	SAT TT=555.653 CHECKS=244557 NODES=894244	SAT TT=861.434	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=26.81	SAT TT=944.038 CHECKS=497258443 NODES=335849	SAT TT=1033.16 CHECKS=497258443 NODES=335849	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=279.269	SAT TT=17.253 CHECKS=522694000 NODES=125417	SAT TT=16.075 CHECKS=522694000 NODES=125417
random/rand-2-24/ rand-24-24-276-139-56021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=58.767	UNSAT TT=232.713 CHECKS=1597679929 NODES=1137974	UNSAT TT=238.808 CHECKS=1640788103 NODES=1166772	UNSAT TT=111.903	UNSAT TT=87.561	UNSAT TT=93.535	UNSAT TT=1494.96 NODES=1329646	UNSAT TT=600.625 NODES=879635	UNSAT TT=556.736 CHECKS=244918 NODES=834324	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	UNSAT TT=285.133	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=320.923	UNSAT TT=58.767 CHECKS=1795260000 NODES=430122	UNSAT TT=54.499 CHECKS=1795260000 NODES=430122
random/rand-2-24/ rand-24-24-276-139-57021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=53.806	UNSAT TT=216.885 CHECKS=1565934214 NODES=1107913	UNSAT TT=245.325 CHECKS=1644791796 NODES=1161685	UNSAT TT=100.9	UNSAT TT=90.272	UNSAT TT=90.523	UNSAT TT=1145.88 NODES=1110887	UNSAT TT=559.062 NODES=864254	UNSAT TT=517.587 CHECKS=250644 NODES=812349	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=262.678	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=313.764	UNSAT TT=53.806 CHECKS=1755300000 NODES=412537	UNSAT TT=56.885 CHECKS=1755300000 NODES=412537
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-25/ rand-25-25-300-147-50021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=134.869	UNSAT TT=503.625 CHECKS=3369245681 NODES=2272965	UNSAT TT=513.121 CHECKS=3489842688 NODES=2353737	UNSAT TT=236.594	UNSAT TT=218.673	UNSAT TT=220.804	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=1250.64 NODES=1829749	UNSAT TT=1313.81 CHECKS=295364 NODES=1850502	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=615.269	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=690.646	UNSAT TT=134.869 CHECKS=4135990000 NODES=936880	UNSAT TT=128.117 CHECKS=4135990000 NODES=936880
random/rand-2-25/ rand-25-25-300-147-51021_ext.xml	SAT TT=11.738	SAT TT=370.913 CHECKS=2450727471 NODES=1658752	SAT TT=212.61 CHECKS=1427027943 NODES=979062	SAT TT=21.968	SAT TT=76.246	SAT TT=71.552	SAT TT=13.306 NODES=11101	SAT TT=1115.34 NODES=1534296	SAT TT=824.628 CHECKS=288993 NODES=1217820	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=976.171 CHECKS=420259026 NODES=261908	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=276.226	SAT TT=879.005 CHECKS=339377582 NODES=216425	SAT TT=813.193 CHECKS=339377582 NODES=216425	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=370.066	SAT TT=11.738 CHECKS=350432000 NODES=79886	SAT TT=11.601 CHECKS=350432000 NODES=79886
random/rand-2-25/ rand-25-25-300-147-52021_ext.xml	SAT TT=32.93	SAT TT=534.098 CHECKS=3542492925 NODES=2400357	SAT TT=304.569 CHECKS=2123431907 NODES=1458249	SAT TT=63.364	SAT TT=58.12	SAT TT=58.216	SAT TT=906.96 NODES=798587	SAT TT=259.793 NODES=350085	SAT TT=424.325 CHECKS=291232 NODES=578671	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=275.489	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=575.814	SAT TT=32.93 CHECKS=991567000 NODES=229629	SAT TT=31.573 CHECKS=991567000 NODES=229629
random/rand-2-25/ rand-25-25-300-147-53021_ext.xml	SAT TT=13.229	SAT TT=51.094 CHECKS=328038770 NODES=230193	SAT TT=122.715 CHECKS=813162621 NODES=561762	SAT TT=134.075	SAT TT=13.229	SAT TT=13.521	SAT TT=470.625 NODES=418261	SAT TT=1059.12 NODES=1454007	SAT TT=1115.31 CHECKS=294140 NODES=1663115	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=83.62 CHECKS=35121091 NODES=21260	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=332.012	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=213.847	SAT TT=76.16 CHECKS=2318470000 NODES=521246	SAT TT=75.451 CHECKS=2318470000 NODES=521246
random/rand-2-25/ rand-25-25-300-147-54021_ext.xml	SAT TT=25.548	SAT TT=34.208 CHECKS=234412254 NODES=166444	SAT TT=40.121 CHECKS=260618020 NODES=183809	SAT TT=55.617	SAT TT=44.876	SAT TT=45.259	SAT TT=1120.61 NODES=947597	SAT TT=644.336 NODES=825593	SAT TT=428.961 CHECKS=289785 NODES=597286	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=813.695 CHECKS=339668462 NODES=212704	SAT TT=865.474 CHECKS=340952580 NODES=214285	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=44.002	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=345.737	SAT TT=25.548 CHECKS=822572000 NODES=186666	SAT TT=25.118 CHECKS=822572000 NODES=186666
random/rand-2-25/ rand-25-25-300-147-55021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=132.125	UNSAT TT=533.618 CHECKS=3581421535 NODES=2409979	UNSAT TT=532.17 CHECKS=3579809423 NODES=2398009	UNSAT TT=253.898	UNSAT TT=224.316	UNSAT TT=220.62	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=1420.21 NODES=1866654	UNSAT TT=1298.41 CHECKS=291463 NODES=1860874	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=612.121	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=758.363	UNSAT TT=132.125 CHECKS=4005370000 NODES=899287	UNSAT TT=122.287 CHECKS=4005370000 NODES=899287
random/rand-2-25/ rand-25-25-300-147-56021_ext.xml	SAT TT=42.811	SAT TT=273.819 CHECKS=1898482255 NODES=1300295	SAT TT=73.191 CHECKS=474116338 NODES=332703	SAT TT=253.635	SAT TT=42.811	SAT TT=43.132	SAT TT=454.81 NODES=379895	SAT TT=1134.34 NODES=1513963	SAT TT=181.954 CHECKS=287781 NODES=243339	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=657.716	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=250.784	SAT TT=141.659 CHECKS=4358630000 NODES=992077	SAT TT=135.087 CHECKS=4358630000 NODES=992077
random/rand-2-25/ rand-25-25-300-147-57021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=132.712	UNSAT TT=521.111 CHECKS=3766952057 NODES=2515566	UNSAT TT=527.374 CHECKS=3802175966 NODES=2544776	UNSAT TT=256.91	UNSAT TT=211.906	UNSAT TT=217.122	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=1285.51 NODES=1742687	UNSAT TT=1227.19 CHECKS=292338 NODES=1830165	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=569.468	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=730.282	UNSAT TT=132.712 CHECKS=4056660000 NODES=907895	UNSAT TT=122.593 CHECKS=4056660000 NODES=907895
random/rand-2-25/ rand-25-25-300-147-58021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=138.007	UNSAT TT=554.894 CHECKS=3638906372 NODES=2448692	UNSAT TT=539.853 CHECKS=3635581339 NODES=2444140	UNSAT TT=257.88	UNSAT TT=219.473	UNSAT TT=216.984	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=1435.11 NODES=1943210	UNSAT TT=1337.12 CHECKS=296244 NODES=1928130	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=619.047	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=712.433	UNSAT TT=138.007 CHECKS=4212780000 NODES=952782	UNSAT TT=128.484 CHECKS=4212780000 NODES=952782
random/rand-2-25/ rand-25-25-300-147-59021_ext.xml	SAT TT=67.126	SAT TT=144.139 CHECKS=1004797476 NODES=694039	SAT TT=107.003 CHECKS=749377810 NODES=520363	SAT TT=122.062	SAT TT=83.757	SAT TT=84.501	SAT TT=15.637 NODES=13432	SAT TT=924.12 NODES=1332557	SAT TT=892.97 CHECKS=292979 NODES=1305477	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=553.122	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.51	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=655.159	SAT TT=67.126 CHECKS=2032330000 NODES=457598	SAT TT=66.411 CHECKS=2032330000 NODES=457598
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-26/ rand-26-26-325-155-52021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=337.775	UNSAT TT=1355.64 CHECKS=9005733151 NODES=5782824	UNSAT TT=1277.39 CHECKS=8721566284 NODES=5614387	UNSAT TT=601.029	UNSAT TT=509	UNSAT TT=508.457	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=1468.95	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=1787.2	UNSAT TT=337.775 CHECKS=10202400000 NODES=2240380	UNSAT TT=318.67 CHECKS=10202400000 NODES=2240380
random/rand-2-26/ rand-26-26-325-155-53021_ext.xml	SAT TT=35.019	SAT TT=35.019 CHECKS=242178619 NODES=160905	SAT TT=201.072 CHECKS=1331169532 NODES=870893	SAT TT=215.028	SAT TT=223.228	SAT TT=209.42	SAT TT=1151.46 NODES=913408	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=47.089	SAT TT=1770.66 CHECKS=760876079 NODES=459137	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=856.709	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=1023.08	SAT TT=114.818 CHECKS=3467430000 NODES=753142	SAT TT=106.314 CHECKS=3467430000 NODES=753142
random/rand-2-26/ rand-26-26-325-155-54021_ext.xml	SAT TT=40.429	SAT TT=155.928 CHECKS=1022061274 NODES=684119	SAT TT=187.911 CHECKS=1307777023 NODES=870280	SAT TT=224.366	SAT TT=307.981	SAT TT=319.846	SAT TT=785.129 NODES=638090	SAT TT=1421.02 NODES=1921018	SAT TT=1279.6 CHECKS=342766 NODES=1786561	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=86.666	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800	SAT TT=40.429	SAT TT=126.88 CHECKS=3802980000 NODES=836956	SAT TT=116.686 CHECKS=3802980000 NODES=836956
random/rand-2-26/ rand-26-26-325-155-55021_ext.xml	SAT TT=35.281	SAT TT=157.415 CHECKS=1050111013 NODES=690303	SAT TT=35.281 CHECKS=244412805 NODES=161930	SAT TT=553.75	SAT TT=156.317	SAT TT=166.251	SAT TT=1396.49 NODES=1144180	SAT TT=772.139 NODES=1067168	SAT TT=576.246 CHECKS=339958 NODES=750873	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=1265.5	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=247.01	SAT TT=309.434 CHECKS=9399700000 NODES=2044320	SAT TT=294.735 CHECKS=9399700000 NODES=2044320
random/rand-2-26/ rand-26-26-325-155-56021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=345.71	UNSAT TT=1318.13 CHECKS=9425637831 NODES=6019711	UNSAT TT=1463.95 CHECKS=9645085718 NODES=6189826	UNSAT TT=653.046	UNSAT TT=554.257	UNSAT TT=554.953	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=1414.49	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=345.71 CHECKS=10472300000 NODES=2286260	UNSAT TT=319.91 CHECKS=10472300000 NODES=2286260
random/rand-2-26/ rand-26-26-325-155-57021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=338.633	UNSAT TT=1269.45 CHECKS=8768564687 NODES=5649761	UNSAT TT=1341.12 CHECKS=9150990544 NODES=5902241	UNSAT TT=649.235	UNSAT TT=542.476	UNSAT TT=529.958	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=1447.45	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=1714.26	UNSAT TT=338.633 CHECKS=10526000000 NODES=2316910	UNSAT TT=321.916 CHECKS=10526000000 NODES=2316910
random/rand-2-26/ rand-26-26-325-155-58021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=318.764	UNSAT TT=1291.88 CHECKS=9176264909 NODES=5884568	UNSAT TT=1231.94 CHECKS=8836686153 NODES=5681952	UNSAT TT=646.577	UNSAT TT=513.034	UNSAT TT=510.448	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=1580.02	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.01	UNSAT TT=1785.85	UNSAT TT=318.764 CHECKS=10339900000 NODES=2274760	UNSAT TT=320.299 CHECKS=10339900000 NODES=2274760
random/rand-2-26/ rand-26-26-325-155-59021_ext.xml	SAT TT=112.163	SAT TT=466.973 CHECKS=3323605609 NODES=2180140	SAT TT=492.535 CHECKS=3523297774 NODES=2302238	SAT TT=221.994	SAT TT=516.639	SAT TT=517.463	SAT TT=1586.28 NODES=1229305	SAT TT=629.324 NODES=762811	SAT TT=1010.52 CHECKS=342182 NODES=845046	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=892.549	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=826.791	SAT TT=112.163 CHECKS=3634670000 NODES=793981	SAT TT=119.794 CHECKS=3634670000 NODES=793981
random/rand-2-26/ rand-26-26-325-155-60021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=318.1	UNSAT TT=1337.4 CHECKS=8587703125 NODES=5479114	UNSAT TT=1289.82 CHECKS=8612838268 NODES=5498578	UNSAT TT=579.042	UNSAT TT=503.852	UNSAT TT=503.558	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=1381.28	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=1772.32	UNSAT TT=318.1 CHECKS=9708500000 NODES=2106620	UNSAT TT=316.283 CHECKS=9708500000 NODES=2106620
random/rand-2-26/ rand-26-26-325-155-61021_ext.xml	SAT TT=81.645	SAT TT=130.956 CHECKS=912492751 NODES=600102	SAT TT=81.645 CHECKS=532901111 NODES=353596	SAT TT=517.495	SAT TT=128.827	SAT TT=134.844	SAT TT=1378.39 NODES=1061274	SAT TT=1648.12 NODES=2047478	SAT TT=1251.35 CHECKS=341031 NODES=1133978	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=141.79	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=1179.38	SAT TT=259.427 CHECKS=8265280000 NODES=1812420	SAT TT=266.796 CHECKS=8265280000 NODES=1812420
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-27/ rand-27-27-351-163-54021_ext.xml	SAT TT=220.171	SAT TT=1362.94 CHECKS=6747430171 NODES=4248045	SAT TT=740.603 CHECKS=3698357799 NODES=2338116	SAT TT=548.281	SAT TT=220.171	SAT TT=235.041	SAT TT=996.524 NODES=734923	SAT TT=1342.42 NODES=1628535	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=723.889	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=1459.41	SAT TT=292.322 CHECKS=9328710000 NODES=1974470	SAT TT=296.105 CHECKS=9328710000 NODES=1974470
random/rand-2-27/ rand-27-27-351-163-55021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=779.576	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=1259.52	UNSAT TT=1177.97	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=779.576 CHECKS=23455500000 NODES=4881500	UNSAT TT=767.924 CHECKS=23455500000 NODES=4881500
random/rand-2-27/ rand-27-27-351-163-56021_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.147	SAT TT=4.147 CHECKS=15272227 NODES=10030	SAT TT=1110.46 CHECKS=5579664320 NODES=3488801	SAT TT=255.986	SAT TT=198.668	SAT TT=186.17	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=744.986 CHECKS=249273441 NODES=139470	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=370.182	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=145.221 CHECKS=4367660000 NODES=899596	SAT TT=133.627 CHECKS=4367660000 NODES=899596
random/rand-2-27/ rand-27-27-351-163-57021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=780.343	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	UNSAT TT=1313.11	UNSAT TT=1224.99	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=780.343 CHECKS=25314900000 NODES=5370120	UNSAT TT=832.437 CHECKS=25314900000 NODES=5370120
random/rand-2-27/ rand-27-27-351-163-58021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=822.211	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=1295.62	UNSAT TT=1297.44	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=822.211 CHECKS=25772500000 NODES=5399300	UNSAT TT=843.672 CHECKS=25772500000 NODES=5399300
random/rand-2-27/ rand-27-27-351-163-59021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=836.584	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=1240.91	UNSAT TT=1245.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=836.584 CHECKS=25515300000 NODES=5374010	UNSAT TT=840.682 CHECKS=25515300000 NODES=5374010
random/rand-2-27/ rand-27-27-351-163-60021_ext.xml	SAT TT=221.806	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=1603.86 CHECKS=8251906671 NODES=5089835	SAT TT=659.718	SAT TT=388.992	SAT TT=364.013	SAT TT=395.976 NODES=306178	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800	SAT TT=1626.67	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=221.806	SAT TT=341.455 CHECKS=10373900000 NODES=2145620	SAT TT=341.431 CHECKS=10373900000 NODES=2145620
random/rand-2-27/ rand-27-27-351-163-61021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=873.694	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=1412.67	UNSAT TT=1324.01	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=873.694 CHECKS=26575700000 NODES=5698190	UNSAT TT=838.505 CHECKS=26575700000 NODES=5698190
random/rand-2-27/ rand-27-27-351-163-62021_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=809.946	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=1249.41	UNSAT TT=1211.58	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=809.946 CHECKS=24664900000 NODES=5147560	UNSAT TT=807.041 CHECKS=24664900000 NODES=5147560
random/rand-2-27/ rand-27-27-351-163-63021_ext.xml	SAT TT=135.415	SAT TT=135.415 CHECKS=636103776 NODES=401804	SAT TT=834.703 CHECKS=4157663730 NODES=2599948	SAT TT=450.96	SAT TT=576.406	SAT TT=539.844	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=1444.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=224.173 CHECKS=6807330000 NODES=1420480	SAT TT=223.698 CHECKS=6807330000 NODES=1420480
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-11_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.072	SAT TT=1.431 CHECKS=2841278 NODES=3075	SAT TT=0.935 CHECKS=310153 NODES=393	SAT TT=1.637	SAT TT=0.445	SAT TT=0.445	SAT TT=0.811 NODES=425	SAT TT=4.124 NODES=6042	SAT TT=2.086 CHECKS=75537 NODES=2677	SAT TT=1.689	SAT TT=10.78 CHECKS=5648841 NODES=4482	SAT TT=11.038 CHECKS=5540558 NODES=4508	SAT TT=4.322 CHECKS=2749226 NODES=1723	SAT TT=12.452	SAT TT=5.25	SAT TT=0.094	SAT TT=0.923 CHECKS=499791 NODES=400	SAT TT=0.926 CHECKS=499791 NODES=400	SAT TT=2.463	SAT TT=2.617	SAT TT=5.064	SAT TT=0.129	SAT TT=0.072 CHECKS=622349 NODES=219	SAT TT=0.069 CHECKS=622349 NODES=219
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-13_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.149	SAT TT=0.951 CHECKS=745600 NODES=789	SAT TT=1.183 CHECKS=1777229 NODES=1860	SAT TT=0.423	SAT TT=1.455	SAT TT=1.441	SAT TT=0.678 NODES=218	SAT TT=1.797 NODES=2016	SAT TT=1.631 CHECKS=67798 NODES=2040	SAT TT=2.612	SAT TT=12.13 CHECKS=7710959 NODES=5493	SAT TT=13.995 CHECKS=9290837 NODES=6752	SAT TT=6.166 CHECKS=4449254 NODES=2789	SAT TT=3.789	SAT TT=3.524	SAT TT=0.727	SAT TT=5.171 CHECKS=3676892 NODES=2466	SAT TT=5.503 CHECKS=3676892 NODES=2466	SAT TT=2.765	SAT TT=3.437	SAT TT=12.49	SAT TT=0.472	SAT TT=0.149 CHECKS=3771040 NODES=929	SAT TT=0.163 CHECKS=3771040 NODES=929
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-15_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.103	SAT TT=0.964 CHECKS=626148 NODES=720	SAT TT=0.829 CHECKS=123717 NODES=162	SAT TT=0.603	SAT TT=1.359	SAT TT=1.305	SAT TT=0.779 NODES=351	SAT TT=1.202 NODES=1137	SAT TT=1.042 CHECKS=73064 NODES=782	SAT TT=0.521	SAT TT=0.135 CHECKS=30815 NODES=34	SAT TT=13.573 CHECKS=7318263 NODES=5767	SAT TT=0.949 CHECKS=635103 NODES=389	SAT TT=2.296	SAT TT=1.874	SAT TT=0.72	SAT TT=4.151 CHECKS=2391312 NODES=1816	SAT TT=4.137 CHECKS=2391312 NODES=1816	SAT TT=4.524	SAT TT=4.503	SAT TT=4.89	SAT TT=1.408	SAT TT=0.103 CHECKS=1704310 NODES=534	SAT TT=0.105 CHECKS=1704310 NODES=534
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.259	SAT TT=0.92 CHECKS=512804 NODES=572	SAT TT=0.925 CHECKS=453793 NODES=528	SAT TT=1.19	SAT TT=0.659	SAT TT=0.684	SAT TT=3.57 NODES=5344	SAT TT=3.078 NODES=4177	SAT TT=2.695 CHECKS=73587 NODES=3895	SAT TT=0.842	SAT TT=6.786 CHECKS=4194565 NODES=3130	SAT TT=7.142 CHECKS=3919045 NODES=3094	SAT TT=2.539 CHECKS=1724291 NODES=1102	SAT TT=4.541	SAT TT=3.562	SAT TT=0.259	SAT TT=16.619 CHECKS=10697755 NODES=7116	SAT TT=16.974 CHECKS=10697755 NODES=7116	SAT TT=3.533	SAT TT=3.367	SAT TT=13.45	SAT TT=0.71	SAT TT=0.366 CHECKS=10533200 NODES=2668	SAT TT=0.367 CHECKS=10533200 NODES=2668
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-19_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.076	SAT TT=0.952 CHECKS=564037 NODES=596	SAT TT=1.48 CHECKS=2898095 NODES=3122	SAT TT=0.213	SAT TT=1.447	SAT TT=1.398	SAT TT=0.91 NODES=600	SAT TT=1.745 NODES=2193	SAT TT=1.33 CHECKS=72466 NODES=1452	SAT TT=1.396	SAT TT=10.244 CHECKS=5552853 NODES=4470	SAT TT=31.698 CHECKS=18990546 NODES=14375	SAT TT=6.558 CHECKS=4114533 NODES=2915	SAT TT=11.389	SAT TT=21.84	SAT TT=1.348	SAT TT=1.041 CHECKS=556303 NODES=458	SAT TT=1.044 CHECKS=556303 NODES=458	SAT TT=12.686	SAT TT=12.581	SAT TT=15.65	SAT TT=1.2	SAT TT=0.076 CHECKS=772874 NODES=238	SAT TT=0.076 CHECKS=772874 NODES=238
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.352	SAT TT=0.871 CHECKS=123032 NODES=130	SAT TT=1.023 CHECKS=779386 NODES=922	SAT TT=1.044	SAT TT=1.264	SAT TT=1.336	SAT TT=0.81 NODES=432	SAT TT=2.029 NODES=2443	SAT TT=3.604 CHECKS=71161 NODES=5751	SAT TT=1.312	SAT TT=14.142 CHECKS=8805984 NODES=6765	SAT TT=18.446 CHECKS=11762844 NODES=9033	SAT TT=52.858 CHECKS=35399030 NODES=25893	SAT TT=5.793	SAT TT=5.065	SAT TT=1.842	SAT TT=13.704 CHECKS=9295265 NODES=6703	SAT TT=14.707 CHECKS=9295265 NODES=6703	SAT TT=3.068	SAT TT=2.888	SAT TT=19.402	SAT TT=0.956	SAT TT=0.352 CHECKS=9829220 NODES=2754	SAT TT=0.331 CHECKS=9829220 NODES=2754
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.352	SAT TT=1.008 CHECKS=913570 NODES=1027	SAT TT=1.16 CHECKS=1445104 NODES=1632	SAT TT=1.093	SAT TT=0.352	SAT TT=0.357	SAT TT=1.537 NODES=1868	SAT TT=1.076 NODES=955	SAT TT=0.653 CHECKS=70733 NODES=94	SAT TT=0.436	SAT TT=33.453 CHECKS=21660007 NODES=17174	SAT TT=0.252 CHECKS=95401 NODES=96	SAT TT=15.944 CHECKS=10175931 NODES=8198	SAT TT=2.782	SAT TT=4.118	SAT TT=1.714	SAT TT=24.847 CHECKS=15453151 NODES=12385	SAT TT=24.981 CHECKS=15453151 NODES=12385	SAT TT=2.651	SAT TT=2.85	SAT TT=28.797	SAT TT=3.385	SAT TT=0.562 CHECKS=16131500 NODES=4861	SAT TT=0.564 CHECKS=16131500 NODES=4861
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-25_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.113	SAT TT=0.855 CHECKS=336912 NODES=334	SAT TT=0.859 CHECKS=76063 NODES=103	SAT TT=1.191	SAT TT=0.461	SAT TT=0.443	SAT TT=0.787 NODES=366	SAT TT=2.909 NODES=3994	SAT TT=4.196 CHECKS=71824 NODES=6603	SAT TT=1.01	SAT TT=31.798 CHECKS=19528863 NODES=13963	SAT TT=30.206 CHECKS=18278494 NODES=13060	SAT TT=23.422 CHECKS=15853932 NODES=10618	SAT TT=10.482	SAT TT=12.887	SAT TT=0.616	SAT TT=3.174 CHECKS=2015068 NODES=1321	SAT TT=3.259 CHECKS=2015068 NODES=1321	SAT TT=17.926	SAT TT=17.691	SAT TT=13.414	SAT TT=1.649	SAT TT=0.113 CHECKS=2069700 NODES=465	SAT TT=0.108 CHECKS=2069700 NODES=465
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-27_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.079	SAT TT=1.235 CHECKS=1877612 NODES=2049	SAT TT=1.413 CHECKS=2853975 NODES=3208	SAT TT=0.28	SAT TT=1.005	SAT TT=1.046	SAT TT=3.486 NODES=5117	SAT TT=1.93 NODES=2516	SAT TT=2.726 CHECKS=70796 NODES=4176	SAT TT=2.888	SAT TT=11.07 CHECKS=6567478 NODES=5098	SAT TT=8.171 CHECKS=4792992 NODES=3756	SAT TT=7.26 CHECKS=5234720 NODES=3757	SAT TT=4.071	SAT TT=4.214	SAT TT=0.927	SAT TT=1.743 CHECKS=1128697 NODES=815	SAT TT=1.783 CHECKS=1128697 NODES=815	SAT TT=6.639	SAT TT=6.99	SAT TT=9.07	SAT TT=0.987	SAT TT=0.079 CHECKS=917823 NODES=271	SAT TT=0.079 CHECKS=917823 NODES=271
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-29_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.34	SAT TT=0.834 CHECKS=112135 NODES=107	SAT TT=0.858 CHECKS=226572 NODES=271	SAT TT=1.651	SAT TT=1.317	SAT TT=1.318	SAT TT=1.698 NODES=1967	SAT TT=4.003 NODES=5604	SAT TT=4.737 CHECKS=75681 NODES=8022	SAT TT=7.631	SAT TT=33.732 CHECKS=19890246 NODES=14334	SAT TT=30.572 CHECKS=17791424 NODES=12929	SAT TT=49.825 CHECKS=31955219 NODES=21658	SAT TT=4.832	SAT TT=2.226	SAT TT=1.074	SAT TT=14.577 CHECKS=8657962 NODES=6271	SAT TT=14.628 CHECKS=8657962 NODES=6271	SAT TT=4.811	SAT TT=4.721	SAT TT=7.36	SAT TT=1.114	SAT TT=0.34 CHECKS=9316810 NODES=2385	SAT TT=0.339 CHECKS=9316810 NODES=2385
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-31_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.478	SAT TT=1.929 CHECKS=6358664 NODES=6414	SAT TT=1.934 CHECKS=5580524 NODES=5792	SAT TT=2.095	SAT TT=0.578	SAT TT=0.592	SAT TT=5.238 NODES=7827	SAT TT=4.863 NODES=7351	SAT TT=3.89 CHECKS=72927 NODES=6323	SAT TT=0.704	SAT TT=33.976 CHECKS=20987507 NODES=14631	SAT TT=34.733 CHECKS=21090609 NODES=14759	SAT TT=2.738 CHECKS=1978317 NODES=1214	SAT TT=4.915	SAT TT=7.144	SAT TT=2.352	SAT TT=23.549 CHECKS=15075392 NODES=9926	SAT TT=23.593 CHECKS=15075392 NODES=9926	SAT TT=7.074	SAT TT=7.432	SAT TT=30.587	SAT TT=2.412	SAT TT=0.478 CHECKS=15265500 NODES=3855	SAT TT=0.515 CHECKS=15265500 NODES=3855
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-33_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.099	SAT TT=0.939 CHECKS=469541 NODES=518	SAT TT=1.047 CHECKS=892847 NODES=1048	SAT TT=0.875	SAT TT=1.106	SAT TT=1.151	SAT TT=0.627 NODES=150	SAT TT=3.217 NODES=4589	SAT TT=4.225 CHECKS=75455 NODES=7228	SAT TT=4.76	SAT TT=17.019 CHECKS=9154875 NODES=7178	SAT TT=16.655 CHECKS=9611396 NODES=7501	SAT TT=50.155 CHECKS=31000053 NODES=23916	SAT TT=2.861	SAT TT=2.939	SAT TT=0.099	SAT TT=1.47 CHECKS=776535 NODES=643	SAT TT=1.365 CHECKS=776535 NODES=643	SAT TT=3.4	SAT TT=3.546	SAT TT=49.619	SAT TT=0.749	SAT TT=0.151 CHECKS=3076190 NODES=939	SAT TT=0.147 CHECKS=3076190 NODES=939
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-35_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.156	SAT TT=1.083 CHECKS=1264217 NODES=1327	SAT TT=1.286 CHECKS=2258259 NODES=2475	SAT TT=0.583	SAT TT=0.5	SAT TT=0.501	SAT TT=0.992 NODES=675	SAT TT=1.746 NODES=1937	SAT TT=1.379 CHECKS=75500 NODES=1380	SAT TT=3.736	SAT TT=11.083 CHECKS=6648262 NODES=4719	SAT TT=11.833 CHECKS=6625405 NODES=4861	SAT TT=8.567 CHECKS=5608398 NODES=3640	SAT TT=9.139	SAT TT=9.201	SAT TT=0.288	SAT TT=5.147 CHECKS=3321090 NODES=2590	SAT TT=5.563 CHECKS=3321090 NODES=2590	SAT TT=3.134	SAT TT=3.408	SAT TT=35.07	SAT TT=1.378	SAT TT=0.156 CHECKS=3312560 NODES=1081	SAT TT=0.158 CHECKS=3312560 NODES=1081
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-37_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.094	SAT TT=0.847 CHECKS=71848 NODES=70	SAT TT=0.885 CHECKS=142499 NODES=169	SAT TT=0.388	SAT TT=0.57	SAT TT=0.565	SAT TT=0.682 NODES=180	SAT TT=0.666 NODES=170	SAT TT=0.676 CHECKS=74016 NODES=172	SAT TT=1.169	SAT TT=8.881 CHECKS=5059041 NODES=3440	SAT TT=14.844 CHECKS=8832483 NODES=6050	SAT TT=5.663 CHECKS=3855082 NODES=2133	SAT TT=2.24	SAT TT=2.126	SAT TT=0.228	SAT TT=1.419 CHECKS=895113 NODES=546	SAT TT=1.4 CHECKS=895113 NODES=546	SAT TT=2.348	SAT TT=2.43	SAT TT=8.92	SAT TT=0.205	SAT TT=0.094 CHECKS=1607390 NODES=379	SAT TT=0.093 CHECKS=1607390 NODES=379
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-39_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.219	SAT TT=0.939 CHECKS=493776 NODES=575	SAT TT=0.885 CHECKS=271662 NODES=353	SAT TT=0.787	SAT TT=1.293	SAT TT=1.228	SAT TT=1.315 NODES=1290	SAT TT=3.218 NODES=4689	SAT TT=2.913 CHECKS=72379 NODES=4196	SAT TT=2.562	SAT TT=17.304 CHECKS=9647520 NODES=7812	SAT TT=13.223 CHECKS=7864688 NODES=6312	SAT TT=6.528 CHECKS=4268016 NODES=3044	SAT TT=2.283	SAT TT=3.676	SAT TT=1.524	SAT TT=9.098 CHECKS=5277030 NODES=3949	SAT TT=8.559 CHECKS=5277030 NODES=3949	SAT TT=5.082	SAT TT=5.049	SAT TT=12.57	SAT TT=0.226	SAT TT=0.219 CHECKS=5349580 NODES=1475	SAT TT=0.218 CHECKS=5349580 NODES=1475
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-41_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.558	SAT TT=2.053 CHECKS=6855917 NODES=7484	SAT TT=1.674 CHECKS=4300902 NODES=4889	SAT TT=2.718	SAT TT=1.673	SAT TT=1.675	SAT TT=3.122 NODES=4929	SAT TT=6.016 NODES=9647	SAT TT=5.015 CHECKS=75797 NODES=8481	SAT TT=2.377	SAT TT=39.673 CHECKS=24519788 NODES=19025	SAT TT=34.997 CHECKS=20517486 NODES=16401	SAT TT=18.004 CHECKS=12693343 NODES=8563	SAT TT=3.644	SAT TT=23.541	SAT TT=1.101	SAT TT=25.815 CHECKS=16000225 NODES=12880	SAT TT=24.442 CHECKS=16000225 NODES=12880	SAT TT=2.692	SAT TT=2.853	SAT TT=7.14	SAT TT=1.292	SAT TT=0.558 CHECKS=16024600 NODES=5278	SAT TT=0.553 CHECKS=16024600 NODES=5278
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-43_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.12	SAT TT=1.058 CHECKS=1004291 NODES=1144	SAT TT=0.955 CHECKS=715941 NODES=849	SAT TT=0.906	SAT TT=1.482	SAT TT=1.41	SAT TT=3.088 NODES=4502	SAT TT=2.567 NODES=3339	SAT TT=3.69 CHECKS=74680 NODES=6007	SAT TT=7.211	SAT TT=9.217 CHECKS=4992405 NODES=3863	SAT TT=6.556 CHECKS=3558679 NODES=2713	SAT TT=22.471 CHECKS=14756786 NODES=9685	SAT TT=2.138	SAT TT=5.338	SAT TT=0.21	SAT TT=2.698 CHECKS=1565067 NODES=1085	SAT TT=2.719 CHECKS=1565067 NODES=1085	SAT TT=6.782	SAT TT=7.067	SAT TT=32.955	SAT TT=0.559	SAT TT=0.12 CHECKS=2240630 NODES=616	SAT TT=0.119 CHECKS=2240630 NODES=616
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-45_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.167	SAT TT=1.035 CHECKS=639653 NODES=699	SAT TT=0.806 CHECKS=50956 NODES=78	SAT TT=0.374	SAT TT=1.57	SAT TT=1.598	SAT TT=0.579 NODES=74	SAT TT=1.974 NODES=2134	SAT TT=2.917 CHECKS=75643 NODES=4215	SAT TT=1.667	SAT TT=9.502 CHECKS=5262920 NODES=3831	SAT TT=11.966 CHECKS=6985705 NODES=5140	SAT TT=2.468 CHECKS=1572628 NODES=1004	SAT TT=2.468	SAT TT=2.514	SAT TT=0.942	SAT TT=5.922 CHECKS=3732745 NODES=2488	SAT TT=6.362 CHECKS=3732745 NODES=2488	SAT TT=3.1	SAT TT=3.287	SAT TT=11.676	SAT TT=1.067	SAT TT=0.167 CHECKS=3849680 NODES=986	SAT TT=0.156 CHECKS=3849680 NODES=986
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-47_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.074	SAT TT=4.023 CHECKS=18959307 NODES=21314	SAT TT=4.867 CHECKS=22996408 NODES=25783	SAT TT=2.574	SAT TT=3.029	SAT TT=3.064	SAT TT=1.473 NODES=1442	SAT TT=2.949 NODES=4390	SAT TT=8.819 CHECKS=74456 NODES=16074	SAT TT=40.513	SAT TT=16.155 CHECKS=9133400 NODES=7138	SAT TT=34.425 CHECKS=19617427 NODES=15524	SAT TT=8.377 CHECKS=5291080 NODES=4062	SAT TT=22.3	SAT TT=3.365	SAT TT=0.089	SAT TT=1.711 CHECKS=979706 NODES=836	SAT TT=1.701 CHECKS=979706 NODES=836	SAT TT=10.599	SAT TT=10.427	SAT TT=15.65	SAT TT=1.186	SAT TT=0.074 CHECKS=778679 NODES=241	SAT TT=0.074 CHECKS=778679 NODES=241
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-49_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.145	SAT TT=1.678 CHECKS=4441565 NODES=4865	SAT TT=0.884 CHECKS=288271 NODES=400	SAT TT=0.453	SAT TT=0.642	SAT TT=0.618	SAT TT=1.538 NODES=1700	SAT TT=1.931 NODES=2436	SAT TT=3.668 CHECKS=73351 NODES=5585	SAT TT=15.166	SAT TT=10.997 CHECKS=6299400 NODES=4651	SAT TT=15.483 CHECKS=8939462 NODES=6443	SAT TT=6.48 CHECKS=4454551 NODES=2856	SAT TT=2.694	SAT TT=1.794	SAT TT=1.036	SAT TT=4.965 CHECKS=2926882 NODES=2172	SAT TT=4.927 CHECKS=2926882 NODES=2172	SAT TT=7.998	SAT TT=7.647	SAT TT=13.42	SAT TT=1.643	SAT TT=0.145 CHECKS=3273850 NODES=915	SAT TT=0.143 CHECKS=3273850 NODES=915
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-11_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.759	UNSAT TT=3.534 CHECKS=16258870 NODES=16629	UNSAT TT=3.439 CHECKS=15536082 NODES=15809	UNSAT TT=4.847	UNSAT TT=2.42	UNSAT TT=2.316	UNSAT TT=17.279 NODES=28867	UNSAT TT=6.213 NODES=9425	UNSAT TT=7.344 CHECKS=75790 NODES=10704	UNSAT TT=25.335	UNSAT TT=49.733 CHECKS=29843897 NODES=21529	UNSAT TT=47.533 CHECKS=26411088 NODES=19545	UNSAT TT=165.625 CHECKS=102836791 NODES=70733	UNSAT TT=24.143	UNSAT TT=23.87	UNSAT TT=2.926	UNSAT TT=39.876 CHECKS=22916740 NODES=17155	UNSAT TT=37.542 CHECKS=22916740 NODES=17155	UNSAT TT=40.575	UNSAT TT=39.304	UNSAT TT=21.47	UNSAT TT=3.715	UNSAT TT=0.759 CHECKS=22317100 NODES=6385	UNSAT TT=0.698 CHECKS=22317100 NODES=6385
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-13_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.329	UNSAT TT=1.587 CHECKS=3480076 NODES=3537	UNSAT TT=1.451 CHECKS=3406934 NODES=3519	UNSAT TT=0.726	UNSAT TT=1.832	UNSAT TT=1.831	UNSAT TT=3.832 NODES=5155	UNSAT TT=2.183 NODES=2460	UNSAT TT=1.838 CHECKS=68160 NODES=2441	UNSAT TT=4.098	UNSAT TT=13.25 CHECKS=8373775 NODES=5665	UNSAT TT=12.269 CHECKS=8319493 NODES=5640	UNSAT TT=32.22 CHECKS=23839402 NODES=14612	UNSAT TT=3.965	UNSAT TT=3.897	UNSAT TT=0.77	UNSAT TT=10.516 CHECKS=7552988 NODES=4521	UNSAT TT=11.062 CHECKS=7552988 NODES=4521	UNSAT TT=6.276	UNSAT TT=6.526	UNSAT TT=10.78	UNSAT TT=1.225	UNSAT TT=0.329 CHECKS=9291930 NODES=2032	UNSAT TT=0.325 CHECKS=9291930 NODES=2032
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-15_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.774	UNSAT TT=2.754 CHECKS=9728920 NODES=10336	UNSAT TT=3.149 CHECKS=13003965 NODES=14001	UNSAT TT=7.946	UNSAT TT=2.241	UNSAT TT=2.29	UNSAT TT=12.426 NODES=18611	UNSAT TT=4.112 NODES=6585	UNSAT TT=3.98 CHECKS=73607 NODES=6643	UNSAT TT=13.516	UNSAT TT=34.283 CHECKS=21223350 NODES=15526	UNSAT TT=26.465 CHECKS=16602311 NODES=12069	UNSAT TT=143.164 CHECKS=89821435 NODES=66256	UNSAT TT=7.541	UNSAT TT=12.849	UNSAT TT=2.04	UNSAT TT=40.819 CHECKS=25637495 NODES=18689	UNSAT TT=40.83 CHECKS=25637495 NODES=18689	UNSAT TT=22.169	UNSAT TT=24.511	UNSAT TT=20.167	UNSAT TT=2.563	UNSAT TT=0.774 CHECKS=22745000 NODES=6382	UNSAT TT=0.774 CHECKS=22745000 NODES=6382
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.147	SAT TT=0.847 CHECKS=40841 NODES=30	SAT TT=0.83 CHECKS=6830 NODES=30	SAT TT=0.886	SAT TT=1.4	SAT TT=1.511	SAT TT=0.587 NODES=36	SAT TT=2.145 NODES=2679	SAT TT=1.908 CHECKS=74171 NODES=2351	SAT TT=0.835	SAT TT=16.617 CHECKS=10553181 NODES=7443	SAT TT=13.918 CHECKS=8824497 NODES=6265	SAT TT=8.87 CHECKS=6035475 NODES=3656	SAT TT=2.619	SAT TT=2.285	SAT TT=0.725	SAT TT=5.921 CHECKS=3730967 NODES=2185	SAT TT=5.297 CHECKS=3730967 NODES=2185	SAT TT=3.418	SAT TT=3.466	SAT TT=5.51	SAT TT=0.525	SAT TT=0.147 CHECKS=3604930 NODES=850	SAT TT=0.144 CHECKS=3604930 NODES=850
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-19_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.553	UNSAT TT=3.224 CHECKS=13141010 NODES=13147	UNSAT TT=3.188 CHECKS=12993716 NODES=12862	UNSAT TT=2.888	UNSAT TT=2.178	UNSAT TT=2.095	UNSAT TT=9.302 NODES=15110	UNSAT TT=5.234 NODES=8339	UNSAT TT=5.483 CHECKS=74109 NODES=9421	UNSAT TT=16.972	UNSAT TT=33.729 CHECKS=21064362 NODES=15411	UNSAT TT=31.186 CHECKS=17941774 NODES=13096	UNSAT TT=154.349 CHECKS=94265209 NODES=66849	UNSAT TT=16.573	UNSAT TT=21.012	UNSAT TT=2.449	UNSAT TT=25.365 CHECKS=16525500 NODES=12063	UNSAT TT=25.75 CHECKS=16525500 NODES=12063	UNSAT TT=32.651	UNSAT TT=30.915	UNSAT TT=26.379	UNSAT TT=3.017	UNSAT TT=0.553 CHECKS=17082100 NODES=4721	UNSAT TT=0.584 CHECKS=17082100 NODES=4721
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-1_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.138	SAT TT=2.811 CHECKS=10465335 NODES=10150	SAT TT=1.52 CHECKS=2531551 NODES=2586	SAT TT=0.138	SAT TT=1.966	SAT TT=2.019	SAT TT=1.778 NODES=1811	SAT TT=1.757 NODES=1723	SAT TT=1.552 CHECKS=73004 NODES=1748	SAT TT=6.209	SAT TT=12.959 CHECKS=7105473 NODES=5289	SAT TT=6.712 CHECKS=3599070 NODES=2744	SAT TT=0.884 CHECKS=573510 NODES=347	SAT TT=7.649	SAT TT=6.324	SAT TT=0.308	SAT TT=8.41 CHECKS=5246466 NODES=3398	SAT TT=8.753 CHECKS=5246466 NODES=3398	SAT TT=2.005	SAT TT=2.179	SAT TT=7.98	SAT TT=1.06	SAT TT=0.24 CHECKS=6129640 NODES=1532	SAT TT=0.236 CHECKS=6129640 NODES=1532
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.258	SAT TT=2.874 CHECKS=11171868 NODES=11955	SAT TT=2.804 CHECKS=9918371 NODES=10556	SAT TT=1.849	SAT TT=1.354	SAT TT=1.356	SAT TT=8.142 NODES=12803	SAT TT=2.801 NODES=3913	SAT TT=2.356 CHECKS=71792 NODES=3470	SAT TT=0.363	SAT TT=27.496 CHECKS=16710972 NODES=12367	SAT TT=15.724 CHECKS=9343913 NODES=6970	SAT TT=13.815 CHECKS=9469052 NODES=6544	SAT TT=5.025	SAT TT=3.183	SAT TT=1.687	SAT TT=9.417 CHECKS=6350453 NODES=4530	SAT TT=9.981 CHECKS=6350453 NODES=4530	SAT TT=6.052	SAT TT=5.946	SAT TT=8.27	SAT TT=1.119	SAT TT=0.258 CHECKS=6734850 NODES=1847	SAT TT=0.238 CHECKS=6734850 NODES=1847
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.601	SAT TT=2.284 CHECKS=7865426 NODES=8739	SAT TT=1.52 CHECKS=3510381 NODES=3936	SAT TT=2.846	SAT TT=2.66	SAT TT=2.552	SAT TT=1.7 NODES=2038	SAT TT=3.247 NODES=5055	SAT TT=4.025 CHECKS=71836 NODES=7007	SAT TT=9.589	SAT TT=33.55 CHECKS=21850820 NODES=16847	SAT TT=29.855 CHECKS=18071260 NODES=13974	SAT TT=126.462 CHECKS=85090582 NODES=64139	SAT TT=3.573	SAT TT=3.226	SAT TT=1.481	SAT TT=25.591 CHECKS=17100936 NODES=12967	SAT TT=27.504 CHECKS=17100936 NODES=12967	SAT TT=38.092	SAT TT=37.972	SAT TT=31.14	SAT TT=2.025	SAT TT=0.601 CHECKS=18300900 NODES=5239	SAT TT=0.628 CHECKS=18300900 NODES=5239
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-25_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.227	SAT TT=3.53 CHECKS=15506812 NODES=15902	SAT TT=3.338 CHECKS=14924311 NODES=15285	SAT TT=0.227	SAT TT=1.555	SAT TT=1.645	SAT TT=13.935 NODES=24011	SAT TT=5.035 NODES=7984	SAT TT=5.616 CHECKS=71848 NODES=9157	SAT TT=8.863	SAT TT=37.902 CHECKS=23943475 NODES=17515	SAT TT=33.988 CHECKS=22446039 NODES=16293	SAT TT=5.943 CHECKS=3967591 NODES=2741	SAT TT=2.76	SAT TT=4.307	SAT TT=2.227	SAT TT=10.212 CHECKS=6263334 NODES=4400	SAT TT=9.523 CHECKS=6263334 NODES=4400	SAT TT=41.656	SAT TT=39.824	SAT TT=18.23	SAT TT=2.881	SAT TT=0.261 CHECKS=6635540 NODES=1679	SAT TT=0.256 CHECKS=6635540 NODES=1679
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-27_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.384	UNSAT TT=2.367 CHECKS=7949885 NODES=7793	UNSAT TT=2.235 CHECKS=7853456 NODES=7842	UNSAT TT=1.205	UNSAT TT=1.969	UNSAT TT=1.867	UNSAT TT=5.661 NODES=8856	UNSAT TT=4.073 NODES=5387	UNSAT TT=4.289 CHECKS=71514 NODES=5771	UNSAT TT=7.354	UNSAT TT=22.887 CHECKS=15183999 NODES=10246	UNSAT TT=22.475 CHECKS=14184758 NODES=9390	UNSAT TT=73.415 CHECKS=49656080 NODES=31473	UNSAT TT=8.319	UNSAT TT=10.137	UNSAT TT=1.398	UNSAT TT=15.797 CHECKS=11091239 NODES=7029	UNSAT TT=15.365 CHECKS=11091239 NODES=7029	UNSAT TT=14.932	UNSAT TT=15.114	UNSAT TT=23.389	UNSAT TT=2.204	UNSAT TT=0.384 CHECKS=11157200 NODES=2706	UNSAT TT=0.391 CHECKS=11157200 NODES=2706
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-29_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.81	UNSAT TT=3.008 CHECKS=13228831 NODES=13785	UNSAT TT=3.301 CHECKS=13663201 NODES=13999	UNSAT TT=2.256	UNSAT TT=2.436	UNSAT TT=2.417	UNSAT TT=12.055 NODES=18799	UNSAT TT=5.006 NODES=7671	UNSAT TT=5.283 CHECKS=75906 NODES=8359	UNSAT TT=23.94	UNSAT TT=33.555 CHECKS=19075279 NODES=13891	UNSAT TT=34.805 CHECKS=20667405 NODES=14882	UNSAT TT=165.614 CHECKS=101491435 NODES=70615	UNSAT TT=11.294	UNSAT TT=14.91	UNSAT TT=2.114	UNSAT TT=40.072 CHECKS=23774878 NODES=17349	UNSAT TT=37.82 CHECKS=23774878 NODES=17349	UNSAT TT=27.449	UNSAT TT=25.308	UNSAT TT=42.84	UNSAT TT=2.727	UNSAT TT=0.81 CHECKS=23467700 NODES=6542	UNSAT TT=0.802 CHECKS=23467700 NODES=6542
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-31_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.696	UNSAT TT=3.309 CHECKS=14364986 NODES=14210	UNSAT TT=3.204 CHECKS=13191923 NODES=13191	UNSAT TT=2.72	UNSAT TT=2.411	UNSAT TT=2.42	UNSAT TT=10.813 NODES=18094	UNSAT TT=5.129 NODES=8229	UNSAT TT=5.083 CHECKS=72582 NODES=8256	UNSAT TT=16.045	UNSAT TT=39.834 CHECKS=26381723 NODES=18108	UNSAT TT=42.748 CHECKS=26517711 NODES=18110	UNSAT TT=159.246 CHECKS=104934568 NODES=69767	UNSAT TT=13.647	UNSAT TT=29.179	UNSAT TT=2.368	UNSAT TT=30.248 CHECKS=20232038 NODES=13297	UNSAT TT=30.915 CHECKS=20232038 NODES=13297	UNSAT TT=55.874	UNSAT TT=62.521	UNSAT TT=27.553	UNSAT TT=3.503	UNSAT TT=0.696 CHECKS=21309700 NODES=5193	UNSAT TT=0.696 CHECKS=21309700 NODES=5193
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-33_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.753	UNSAT TT=6.245 CHECKS=29681778 NODES=32086	UNSAT TT=5.74 CHECKS=29985566 NODES=32206	UNSAT TT=10.253	UNSAT TT=3.034	UNSAT TT=2.995	UNSAT TT=25.413 NODES=41021	UNSAT TT=11.007 NODES=19472	UNSAT TT=12.132 CHECKS=76293 NODES=22204	UNSAT TT=80.13	UNSAT TT=76.271 CHECKS=44187747 NODES=34221	UNSAT TT=63.825 CHECKS=38242003 NODES=29675	UNSAT TT=263.749 CHECKS=162135746 NODES=122990	UNSAT TT=55.177	UNSAT TT=112.157	UNSAT TT=4.489	UNSAT TT=98.234 CHECKS=60212837 NODES=45254	UNSAT TT=102.292 CHECKS=60212837 NODES=45254	UNSAT TT=479.48	UNSAT TT=406.321	UNSAT TT=110.644	UNSAT TT=6.231	UNSAT TT=1.753 CHECKS=57260500 NODES=16553	UNSAT TT=1.855 CHECKS=57260500 NODES=16553
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-35_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.531	UNSAT TT=3.315 CHECKS=14377123 NODES=15101	UNSAT TT=3.173 CHECKS=11819072 NODES=12690	UNSAT TT=1.864	UNSAT TT=2.237	UNSAT TT=2.384	UNSAT TT=11.247 NODES=17635	UNSAT TT=5.522 NODES=8823	UNSAT TT=4.332 CHECKS=75586 NODES=6904	UNSAT TT=14.954	UNSAT TT=27.32 CHECKS=17373166 NODES=13055	UNSAT TT=29.469 CHECKS=18335833 NODES=13580	UNSAT TT=155.504 CHECKS=103306822 NODES=73100	UNSAT TT=11.577	UNSAT TT=12.347	UNSAT TT=1.934	UNSAT TT=25.659 CHECKS=15498160 NODES=11503	UNSAT TT=25.765 CHECKS=15498160 NODES=11503	UNSAT TT=19.894	UNSAT TT=20.175	UNSAT TT=27.06	UNSAT TT=3.27	UNSAT TT=0.531 CHECKS=14997400 NODES=4627	UNSAT TT=0.521 CHECKS=14997400 NODES=4627
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-37_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.146	SAT TT=1.054 CHECKS=537886 NODES=518	SAT TT=1.106 CHECKS=1087037 NODES=1132	SAT TT=0.829	SAT TT=0.385	SAT TT=0.403	SAT TT=1.659 NODES=1535	SAT TT=1.012 NODES=651	SAT TT=1.358 CHECKS=77085 NODES=1232	SAT TT=0.152	SAT TT=12.332 CHECKS=7239841 NODES=4423	SAT TT=12.811 CHECKS=7327654 NODES=4529	SAT TT=0.67 CHECKS=444429 NODES=244	SAT TT=2.705	SAT TT=2.3	SAT TT=0.178	SAT TT=5.78 CHECKS=3618654 NODES=2044	SAT TT=5.717 CHECKS=3618654 NODES=2044	SAT TT=2.53	SAT TT=2.729	SAT TT=5.68	SAT TT=0.441	SAT TT=0.146 CHECKS=3778420 NODES=925	SAT TT=0.156 CHECKS=3778420 NODES=925
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-39_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.179	SAT TT=1.033 CHECKS=942633 NODES=1050	SAT TT=0.976 CHECKS=465788 NODES=543	SAT TT=0.279	SAT TT=1.213	SAT TT=1.284	SAT TT=0.781 NODES=358	SAT TT=2.571 NODES=3341	SAT TT=1.703 CHECKS=72168 NODES=1961	SAT TT=1.13	SAT TT=7.668 CHECKS=4451565 NODES=3520	SAT TT=11.289 CHECKS=6053743 NODES=4861	SAT TT=10.453 CHECKS=7002328 NODES=4957	SAT TT=7.722	SAT TT=5.313	SAT TT=0.53	SAT TT=7.155 CHECKS=4365638 NODES=3401	SAT TT=7.533 CHECKS=4365638 NODES=3401	SAT TT=8.623	SAT TT=8.538	SAT TT=17.12	SAT TT=0.464	SAT TT=0.179 CHECKS=4269700 NODES=1259	SAT TT=0.189 CHECKS=4269700 NODES=1259
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-3_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.593	UNSAT TT=2.184 CHECKS=8159027 NODES=7856	UNSAT TT=2.27 CHECKS=8948501 NODES=8464	UNSAT TT=1.445	UNSAT TT=2.03	UNSAT TT=1.956	UNSAT TT=8.033 NODES=12938	UNSAT TT=3.236 NODES=4415	UNSAT TT=3.281 CHECKS=73298 NODES=4737	UNSAT TT=8.971	UNSAT TT=26.077 CHECKS=16827139 NODES=11115	UNSAT TT=25.113 CHECKS=15050780 NODES=10254	UNSAT TT=75.704 CHECKS=50058856 NODES=31116	UNSAT TT=6.075	UNSAT TT=7.573	UNSAT TT=1.422	UNSAT TT=28.723 CHECKS=17893102 NODES=10890	UNSAT TT=28.86 CHECKS=17893102 NODES=10890	UNSAT TT=13.976	UNSAT TT=13.935	UNSAT TT=18.758	UNSAT TT=2.066	UNSAT TT=0.593 CHECKS=17375500 NODES=3873	UNSAT TT=0.578 CHECKS=17375500 NODES=3873
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-41_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.159	SAT TT=1.619 CHECKS=3316416 NODES=3839	SAT TT=1.669 CHECKS=4498336 NODES=5037	SAT TT=0.922	SAT TT=1.842	SAT TT=1.779	SAT TT=3.461 NODES=5338	SAT TT=4.128 NODES=6447	SAT TT=1.6 CHECKS=73798 NODES=1832	SAT TT=27.167	SAT TT=16.221 CHECKS=9668351 NODES=7552	SAT TT=13.96 CHECKS=8230510 NODES=6512	SAT TT=9.697 CHECKS=6566420 NODES=4367	SAT TT=3.921	SAT TT=7.881	SAT TT=0.159	SAT TT=7.94 CHECKS=4797790 NODES=4017	SAT TT=7.579 CHECKS=4797790 NODES=4017	SAT TT=6.611	SAT TT=6.708	SAT TT=29.16	SAT TT=0.528	SAT TT=0.225 CHECKS=5613970 NODES=1828	SAT TT=0.227 CHECKS=5613970 NODES=1828
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-43_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.172	SAT TT=1.531 CHECKS=2892489 NODES=3140	SAT TT=1.332 CHECKS=2194296 NODES=2424	SAT TT=0.371	SAT TT=0.817	SAT TT=0.853	SAT TT=5.949 NODES=9268	SAT TT=4.256 NODES=6426	SAT TT=1.222 CHECKS=73383 NODES=1170	SAT TT=3.298	SAT TT=15.271 CHECKS=9001641 NODES=6608	SAT TT=20.422 CHECKS=11919935 NODES=8824	SAT TT=19.876 CHECKS=13083743 NODES=8929	SAT TT=2.684	SAT TT=5.831	SAT TT=0.225	SAT TT=5.682 CHECKS=3318644 NODES=2292	SAT TT=5.614 CHECKS=3318644 NODES=2292	SAT TT=15.56	SAT TT=16.494	SAT TT=56.17	SAT TT=2.777	SAT TT=0.172 CHECKS=3835540 NODES=1126	SAT TT=0.169 CHECKS=3835540 NODES=1126
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-45_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.134	SAT TT=0.962 CHECKS=525364 NODES=519	SAT TT=1.783 CHECKS=4659959 NODES=4669	SAT TT=0.134	SAT TT=0.304	SAT TT=0.284	SAT TT=1.109 NODES=885	SAT TT=2.348 NODES=2799	SAT TT=2.401 CHECKS=74872 NODES=3319	SAT TT=1.839	SAT TT=9.765 CHECKS=5277735 NODES=3991	SAT TT=13.015 CHECKS=7056134 NODES=5291	SAT TT=4.591 CHECKS=2949669 NODES=1859	SAT TT=2.38	SAT TT=2.048	SAT TT=0.328	SAT TT=6.326 CHECKS=3748300 NODES=2415	SAT TT=5.95 CHECKS=3748300 NODES=2415	SAT TT=2.555	SAT TT=2.342	SAT TT=5.64	SAT TT=0.739	SAT TT=0.183 CHECKS=4312020 NODES=1117	SAT TT=0.182 CHECKS=4312020 NODES=1117
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-47_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.56	SAT TT=1.399 CHECKS=2545447 NODES=3091	SAT TT=1.001 CHECKS=808247 NODES=978	SAT TT=2.494	SAT TT=1.399	SAT TT=1.437	SAT TT=4.692 NODES=6932	SAT TT=12.885 NODES=21992	SAT TT=13.161 CHECKS=75921 NODES=25598	SAT TT=68.799	SAT TT=34.212 CHECKS=19381661 NODES=15480	SAT TT=32.393 CHECKS=18552091 NODES=15024	SAT TT=85.906 CHECKS=56361321 NODES=44193	SAT TT=36.421	SAT TT=57.267	SAT TT=3.453	SAT TT=25.477 CHECKS=14874461 NODES=11957	SAT TT=25.42 CHECKS=14874461 NODES=11957	SAT TT=233.684	SAT TT=282.395	SAT TT=64.452	SAT TT=2.152	SAT TT=0.56 CHECKS=15448200 NODES=4544	SAT TT=0.547 CHECKS=15448200 NODES=4544
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-49_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.782	UNSAT TT=3.169 CHECKS=12364826 NODES=13588	UNSAT TT=2.988 CHECKS=12340121 NODES=13680	UNSAT TT=3.221	UNSAT TT=2.377	UNSAT TT=2.445	UNSAT TT=11.433 NODES=19783	UNSAT TT=6.337 NODES=10425	UNSAT TT=6.128 CHECKS=74595 NODES=10109	UNSAT TT=37.719	UNSAT TT=34.146 CHECKS=22022611 NODES=16856	UNSAT TT=39.779 CHECKS=25403189 NODES=19143	UNSAT TT=156.592 CHECKS=98842321 NODES=70049	UNSAT TT=13.299	UNSAT TT=20.686	UNSAT TT=2.528	UNSAT TT=41.965 CHECKS=25734743 NODES=18186	UNSAT TT=39.625 CHECKS=25734743 NODES=18186	UNSAT TT=39.505	UNSAT TT=40.194	UNSAT TT=36.896	UNSAT TT=3.287	UNSAT TT=0.782 CHECKS=25032000 NODES=6803	UNSAT TT=0.824 CHECKS=25032000 NODES=6803
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-6_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=0.374	UNSAT TT=2.29 CHECKS=8473202 NODES=8066	UNSAT TT=1.977 CHECKS=6944704 NODES=6742	UNSAT TT=1.882	UNSAT TT=1.926	UNSAT TT=1.944	UNSAT TT=7.445 NODES=12067	UNSAT TT=3.269 NODES=4671	UNSAT TT=3.307 CHECKS=73918 NODES=4672	UNSAT TT=10.661	UNSAT TT=20.237 CHECKS=12893614 NODES=8602	UNSAT TT=24.954 CHECKS=14716061 NODES=9802	UNSAT TT=76.498 CHECKS=50685076 NODES=31838	UNSAT TT=5.849	UNSAT TT=6.286	UNSAT TT=1.183	UNSAT TT=16.731 CHECKS=10637402 NODES=6888	UNSAT TT=16.356 CHECKS=10637402 NODES=6888	UNSAT TT=10.63	UNSAT TT=10.828	UNSAT TT=27.89	UNSAT TT=1.925	UNSAT TT=0.374 CHECKS=10859900 NODES=2569	UNSAT TT=0.348 CHECKS=10859900 NODES=2569
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-7_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.287	SAT TT=0.936 CHECKS=445864 NODES=522	SAT TT=1.017 CHECKS=938178 NODES=1114	SAT TT=3.851	SAT TT=1.169	SAT TT=1.248	SAT TT=8.537 NODES=14344	SAT TT=3.357 NODES=5200	SAT TT=5.027 CHECKS=74705 NODES=8490	SAT TT=10.017	SAT TT=24.964 CHECKS=14399873 NODES=10872	SAT TT=22.842 CHECKS=13031493 NODES=9838	SAT TT=67.165 CHECKS=43855691 NODES=30752	SAT TT=2.738	SAT TT=19.542	SAT TT=3.081	SAT TT=14.606 CHECKS=8702283 NODES=6506	SAT TT=14.718 CHECKS=8702283 NODES=6506	SAT TT=25.357	SAT TT=26.223	SAT TT=24.68	SAT TT=0.379	SAT TT=0.287 CHECKS=8100750 NODES=2328	SAT TT=0.302 CHECKS=8100750 NODES=2328
random/rand-2-30-15/ rand-2-30-15-306-230-9_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.362	SAT TT=3.495 CHECKS=13772609 NODES=14941	SAT TT=2.669 CHECKS=9843265 NODES=10633	SAT TT=1.937	SAT TT=0.551	SAT TT=0.55	SAT TT=5.14 NODES=8248	SAT TT=2.517 NODES=3665	SAT TT=2.423 CHECKS=74442 NODES=3597	SAT TT=1.444	SAT TT=34.058 CHECKS=20098911 NODES=15646	SAT TT=19.893 CHECKS=11109027 NODES=8932	SAT TT=71.23 CHECKS=43410012 NODES=32544	SAT TT=14.597	SAT TT=15.135	SAT TT=2.374	SAT TT=16.578 CHECKS=9328057 NODES=7247	SAT TT=15.538 CHECKS=9328057 NODES=7247	SAT TT=8.656	SAT TT=8.231	SAT TT=18.38	SAT TT=0.511	SAT TT=0.362 CHECKS=9438690 NODES=2792	SAT TT=0.358 CHECKS=9438690 NODES=2792
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-11_ext.xml	SAT TT=27.015	SAT TT=94.297 CHECKS=632576895 NODES=468967	SAT TT=95.601 CHECKS=595486628 NODES=442486	SAT TT=229.294	SAT TT=93.046	SAT TT=93.644	SAT TT=356.376 NODES=399936	SAT TT=630.898 NODES=731588	SAT TT=582.66 CHECKS=178308 NODES=759561	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=36.374	SAT TT=1739.27 CHECKS=907812872 NODES=439424	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.58	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=77.419	SAT TT=27.015 CHECKS=860978000 NODES=165328	SAT TT=26.65 CHECKS=860978000 NODES=165328
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-13_ext.xml	SAT TT=14.202	SAT TT=24.496 CHECKS=148307866 NODES=104766	SAT TT=21.238 CHECKS=132053360 NODES=93178	SAT TT=17.821	SAT TT=23.091	SAT TT=21.727	SAT TT=100.951 NODES=103775	SAT TT=137.96 NODES=150406	SAT TT=88.695 CHECKS=181902 NODES=116061	SAT TT=295.536	SAT TT=1005.36 CHECKS=479970648 NODES=208179	SAT TT=196.937 CHECKS=94758785 NODES=43629	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=657.812	SAT TT=355.438	SAT TT=23.702	SAT TT=975.627 CHECKS=475546485 NODES=205534	SAT TT=944.553 CHECKS=475546485 NODES=205534	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=989.201	SAT TT=23.686	SAT TT=14.202 CHECKS=474743000 NODES=80749	SAT TT=14.167 CHECKS=474743000 NODES=80749
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-15_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.784	SAT TT=5.869 CHECKS=35061907 NODES=23125	SAT TT=5.16 CHECKS=26835900 NODES=18560	SAT TT=31.893	SAT TT=7.347	SAT TT=6.934	SAT TT=46.475 NODES=49389	SAT TT=60.363 NODES=61731	SAT TT=69.348 CHECKS=173525 NODES=85254	SAT TT=16.488	SAT TT=48.654 CHECKS=24427842 NODES=11161	SAT TT=327.545 CHECKS=177446096 NODES=69027	SAT TT=720.412 CHECKS=413310865 NODES=164307	SAT TT=36.582	SAT TT=240.26	SAT TT=1.309	SAT TT=30.052 CHECKS=15479465 NODES=6895	SAT TT=31.133 CHECKS=15479465 NODES=6895	SAT TT=167.526	SAT TT=173.9	SAT TT=56.04	SAT TT=32.195	SAT TT=0.784 CHECKS=21750900 NODES=4008	SAT TT=0.789 CHECKS=21750900 NODES=4008
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=54.076	SAT TT=201.918 CHECKS=1257764808 NODES=946712	SAT TT=110.58 CHECKS=674932527 NODES=514357	SAT TT=105.833	SAT TT=56.234	SAT TT=58.951	SAT TT=896.822 NODES=960526	SAT TT=596.921 NODES=731173	SAT TT=383.181 CHECKS=182553 NODES=523952	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=1249.83 CHECKS=639273039 NODES=310067	SAT TT=1077.22 CHECKS=634878398 NODES=299468	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=74.249	SAT TT=128.949	SAT TT=217.431	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=63.811	SAT TT=54.076 CHECKS=1900790000 NODES=361813	SAT TT=57.218 CHECKS=1900790000 NODES=361813
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-19_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.178	SAT TT=2.178 CHECKS=7056188 NODES=5287	SAT TT=21.875 CHECKS=131514524 NODES=95762	SAT TT=92.348	SAT TT=49.357	SAT TT=49.43	SAT TT=7.926 NODES=7729	SAT TT=87.772 NODES=98963	SAT TT=192.966 CHECKS=176138 NODES=244667	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=1703.4 CHECKS=895684442 NODES=431970	SAT TT=215.433 CHECKS=112101828 NODES=52960	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=81.538	SAT TT=803.683 CHECKS=392194544 NODES=190374	SAT TT=862.692 CHECKS=392194544 NODES=190374	SAT TT=1748.77	SAT TT=1743.61	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=147.588	SAT TT=10.518 CHECKS=361704000 NODES=69367	SAT TT=11.297 CHECKS=361704000 NODES=69367
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=14.49	SAT TT=100.628 CHECKS=663544064 NODES=519584	SAT TT=17.87 CHECKS=113430019 NODES=89261	SAT TT=812.279	SAT TT=14.49	SAT TT=14.525	SAT TT=958.493 NODES=1108244	SAT TT=304.161 NODES=380791	SAT TT=286.887 CHECKS=173817 NODES=404932	SAT TT=873.626	SAT TT=13.361 CHECKS=6319346 NODES=3172	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=1398.08 CHECKS=716979709 NODES=367616	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=214.178	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=124.962	SAT TT=33.752 CHECKS=1146170000 NODES=248856	SAT TT=33.5 CHECKS=1146170000 NODES=248856
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.6	SAT TT=25.403 CHECKS=164297085 NODES=121499	SAT TT=69.528 CHECKS=437537601 NODES=318058	SAT TT=122.248	SAT TT=23.588	SAT TT=23.482	SAT TT=189.303 NODES=203318	SAT TT=284.308 NODES=305576	SAT TT=243.527 CHECKS=174408 NODES=298073	SAT TT=1531.79	SAT TT=1454.99 CHECKS=701754633 NODES=330394	SAT TT=1534.58 CHECKS=694248313 NODES=328771	SAT TT=640.494 CHECKS=324715908 NODES=158860	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=6.838	SAT TT=291.656 CHECKS=134292168 NODES=65800	SAT TT=297.697 CHECKS=134292168 NODES=65800	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=1760.86	SAT TT=95.568	SAT TT=2.6 CHECKS=79148100 NODES=16401	SAT TT=2.586 CHECKS=79148100 NODES=16401
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-25_ext.xml	SAT TT=10.229	SAT TT=10.229 CHECKS=56099442 NODES=42650	SAT TT=10.614 CHECKS=65171841 NODES=48978	SAT TT=116.234	SAT TT=52.739	SAT TT=56.157	SAT TT=70.496 NODES=74384	SAT TT=35.633 NODES=41956	SAT TT=41.468 CHECKS=177846 NODES=53855	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=636.362 CHECKS=310160422 NODES=151914	SAT TT=689.156 CHECKS=306864687 NODES=150298	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=924.713	SAT TT=722.864	SAT TT=87.77	SAT TT=1015.58 CHECKS=493646543 NODES=241084	SAT TT=1078.03 CHECKS=493646543 NODES=241084	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.54	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=81.922	SAT TT=13.237 CHECKS=417602000 NODES=84067	SAT TT=13.062 CHECKS=417602000 NODES=84067
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-27_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.37	SAT TT=20.006 CHECKS=122097872 NODES=87055	SAT TT=17.276 CHECKS=110535120 NODES=78296	SAT TT=153.233	SAT TT=4.595	SAT TT=4.37	SAT TT=101.957 NODES=107713	SAT TT=201.136 NODES=237074	SAT TT=186.522 CHECKS=180255 NODES=242547	SAT TT=1130.92	SAT TT=1054.03 CHECKS=516671374 NODES=251005	SAT TT=1110.47 CHECKS=530691235 NODES=257664	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=414.52	SAT TT=72.043	SAT TT=1410.45 CHECKS=733462980 NODES=355617	SAT TT=1391.94 CHECKS=733462980 NODES=355617	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=991.733	SAT TT=84.53	SAT TT=22.087 CHECKS=756417000 NODES=143029	SAT TT=21.998 CHECKS=756417000 NODES=143029
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-29_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.648	SAT TT=4.648 CHECKS=22837804 NODES=16752	SAT TT=23.825 CHECKS=146818252 NODES=104867	SAT TT=134.106	SAT TT=19.633	SAT TT=19.525	SAT TT=319.075 NODES=345860	SAT TT=123.84 NODES=146427	SAT TT=177.427 CHECKS=173905 NODES=158251	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=214.611 CHECKS=112379526 NODES=49693	SAT TT=210.626 CHECKS=113555002 NODES=50461	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=340.067	SAT TT=422.093	SAT TT=55.849	SAT TT=1087.26 CHECKS=524230273 NODES=226084	SAT TT=1092.55 CHECKS=524230273 NODES=226084	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=245.61	SAT TT=87.568	SAT TT=14.766 CHECKS=498492000 NODES=85800	SAT TT=14.77 CHECKS=498492000 NODES=85800
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-31_ext.xml	SAT TT=6.609	SAT TT=26.81 CHECKS=170595974 NODES=128962	SAT TT=44.024 CHECKS=272927342 NODES=207071	SAT TT=12.068	SAT TT=50.823	SAT TT=47.29	SAT TT=168.091 NODES=188096	SAT TT=40.837 NODES=50245	SAT TT=89.87 CHECKS=171075 NODES=87460	SAT TT=45.715	SAT TT=210.728 CHECKS=113584204 NODES=56579	SAT TT=214.663 CHECKS=111200538 NODES=55870	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=1349.89	SAT TT=21.299	SAT TT=424.152 CHECKS=224851374 NODES=109209	SAT TT=447.269 CHECKS=224851374 NODES=109209	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=63.32	SAT TT=6.609 CHECKS=213435000 NODES=41723	SAT TT=6.215 CHECKS=213435000 NODES=41723
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-33_ext.xml	SAT TT=32.448	SAT TT=378.594 CHECKS=2362099420 NODES=1832823	SAT TT=365.688 CHECKS=2422920425 NODES=1885246	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=34.205	SAT TT=32.448	SAT TT=386.11 NODES=442530	SAT TT=159.147 NODES=201044	SAT TT=937.265 CHECKS=172465 NODES=1246157	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=1068.45 CHECKS=540632987 NODES=282072	SAT TT=352.191 CHECKS=172565826 NODES=87182	SAT TT=1755.12 CHECKS=851958019 NODES=449887	SAT TT=315.202	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=339.049	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=59.426	SAT TT=70.357 CHECKS=2253600000 NODES=464246	SAT TT=70.394 CHECKS=2253600000 NODES=464246
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-35_ext.xml	SAT TT=54.136	SAT TT=173.057 CHECKS=1046911372 NODES=823526	SAT TT=99.705 CHECKS=664135759 NODES=524674	SAT TT=871.5	SAT TT=78.687	SAT TT=80.051	SAT TT=182.182 NODES=199070	SAT TT=119.945 NODES=140362	SAT TT=374.201 CHECKS=178929 NODES=480198	SAT TT=1258.72	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=92.23	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.15	SAT TT=518.634	SAT TT=84.441	SAT TT=54.136 CHECKS=1712780000 NODES=370694	SAT TT=49.781 CHECKS=1712780000 NODES=370694
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-37_ext.xml	SAT TT=19.31	SAT TT=54.15 CHECKS=347123494 NODES=270266	SAT TT=19.31 CHECKS=120915614 NODES=96348	SAT TT=302.998	SAT TT=31.424	SAT TT=30.803	SAT TT=46.135 NODES=51937	SAT TT=462.564 NODES=533253	SAT TT=348.647 CHECKS=174851 NODES=454076	SAT TT=1629.71	SAT TT=376.995 CHECKS=180830798 NODES=90370	SAT TT=462.334 CHECKS=218439990 NODES=109229	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=88.252	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=234.705	SAT TT=45.003 CHECKS=1414080000 NODES=295463	SAT TT=44.409 CHECKS=1414080000 NODES=295463
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-39_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.586	SAT TT=1.586 CHECKS=3409965 NODES=2333	SAT TT=2.419 CHECKS=10039213 NODES=6850	SAT TT=32.53	SAT TT=14.767	SAT TT=14.888	SAT TT=2.773 NODES=1998	SAT TT=106.938 NODES=114073	SAT TT=90.682 CHECKS=187594 NODES=102868	SAT TT=657.009	SAT TT=747.752 CHECKS=350594310 NODES=145836	SAT TT=573.452 CHECKS=352693768 NODES=147451	SAT TT=842.56 CHECKS=395452977 NODES=158210	SAT TT=134.218	SAT TT=2.689	SAT TT=54.165	SAT TT=566.256 CHECKS=350225127 NODES=145855	SAT TT=623.524 CHECKS=350225127 NODES=145855	SAT TT=1263.35	SAT TT=1235.53	SAT TT=98.88	SAT TT=28.749	SAT TT=9.552 CHECKS=343045000 NODES=59457	SAT TT=10.098 CHECKS=343045000 NODES=59457
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-41_ext.xml	SAT TT=15.795	SAT TT=55.424 CHECKS=371184799 NODES=256959	SAT TT=20.139 CHECKS=123478444 NODES=86265	SAT TT=139.515	SAT TT=16.838	SAT TT=15.795	SAT TT=106.182 NODES=115503	SAT TT=71.479 NODES=75840	SAT TT=75.596 CHECKS=177303 NODES=90708	SAT TT=156.049	SAT TT=1041.77 CHECKS=531633881 NODES=245577	SAT TT=1114.54 CHECKS=526888559 NODES=243135	SAT TT=90.265 CHECKS=50576236 NODES=22088	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=516.923	SAT TT=87.165	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=476.484	SAT TT=486.243	SAT TT=1504.64	SAT TT=39.617	SAT TT=28.495 CHECKS=938038000 NODES=181325	SAT TT=26.552 CHECKS=938038000 NODES=181325
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-43_ext.xml	SAT TT=30.719	SAT TT=83.82 CHECKS=516143492 NODES=388035	SAT TT=149.906 CHECKS=947595102 NODES=706391	SAT TT=751.356	SAT TT=92.342	SAT TT=98.313	SAT TT=738.252 NODES=826284	SAT TT=725.716 NODES=861344	SAT TT=774.159 CHECKS=178114 NODES=1057394	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=314.243	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=327.405	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.75	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=136.456	SAT TT=30.719 CHECKS=1061480000 NODES=213606	SAT TT=30.628 CHECKS=1061480000 NODES=213606
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-45_ext.xml	SAT TT=5.683	SAT TT=35.137 CHECKS=224234327 NODES=167770	SAT TT=5.683 CHECKS=32164042 NODES=23489	SAT TT=181.154	SAT TT=27.098	SAT TT=26.95	SAT TT=97.103 NODES=101399	SAT TT=167.283 NODES=196291	SAT TT=167.111 CHECKS=182777 NODES=214928	SAT TT=117.694	SAT TT=1109.34 CHECKS=515568738 NODES=261045	SAT TT=130.036 CHECKS=52001369 NODES=27519	SAT TT=105.371 CHECKS=51756179 NODES=23642	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=180.231	SAT TT=944.769 CHECKS=488566949 NODES=231852	SAT TT=1008.49 CHECKS=488566949 NODES=231852	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=40.055	SAT TT=9.889 CHECKS=314312000 NODES=60931	SAT TT=9.825 CHECKS=314312000 NODES=60931
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-47_ext.xml	SAT TT=62.002	SAT TT=229.165 CHECKS=1489822477 NODES=1104163	SAT TT=243.374 CHECKS=1525088587 NODES=1125784	SAT TT=266.534	SAT TT=86.02	SAT TT=85.516	SAT TT=40.527 NODES=42505	SAT TT=404.985 NODES=518026	SAT TT=533.183 CHECKS=184569 NODES=728103	SAT TT=1082.24	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=101.145	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=565.913	SAT TT=62.002 CHECKS=1996370000 NODES=405974	SAT TT=59.298 CHECKS=1996370000 NODES=405974
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-49_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.332	SAT TT=19.912 CHECKS=125401063 NODES=96225	SAT TT=14.209 CHECKS=80162547 NODES=62783	SAT TT=7.859	SAT TT=48.838	SAT TT=52.02	SAT TT=707.28 NODES=821055	SAT TT=503 NODES=646976	SAT TT=445.596 CHECKS=186663 NODES=610044	SAT TT=729.785	SAT TT=148.556 CHECKS=64301622 NODES=35429	SAT TT=159.328 CHECKS=62652487 NODES=34511	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=2.989	SAT TT=106.196 CHECKS=57933582 NODES=32619	SAT TT=123.454 CHECKS=57933582 NODES=32619	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=1660.63	SAT TT=71.004	SAT TT=2.332 CHECKS=68445000 NODES=15655	SAT TT=2.3 CHECKS=68445000 NODES=15655
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-11_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=81.693	UNSAT TT=270.083 CHECKS=1685665617 NODES=1238090	UNSAT TT=279.873 CHECKS=1881116508 NODES=1371491	UNSAT TT=468.471	UNSAT TT=146.502	UNSAT TT=156.821	UNSAT TT=1513.46 NODES=1777853	UNSAT TT=631.972 NODES=781142	UNSAT TT=742.628 CHECKS=176678 NODES=975243	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.01	UNSAT TT=325.558	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.84	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=442.87	UNSAT TT=81.693 CHECKS=2808250000 NODES=556541	UNSAT TT=81.737 CHECKS=2808250000 NODES=556541
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-13_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=22.895	UNSAT TT=76.95 CHECKS=496232509 NODES=335360	UNSAT TT=68.696 CHECKS=478900487 NODES=327656	UNSAT TT=125.841	UNSAT TT=44.819	UNSAT TT=42.058	UNSAT TT=426.336 NODES=426101	UNSAT TT=192.304 NODES=213015	UNSAT TT=185.432 CHECKS=183600 NODES=220916	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=1442.9 CHECKS=713251144 NODES=327878	UNSAT TT=1332.56 CHECKS=714682686 NODES=328301	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=94.725	UNSAT TT=1656.94 CHECKS=847682884 NODES=367115	UNSAT TT=1615.41 CHECKS=847682884 NODES=367115	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=125.078	UNSAT TT=22.895 CHECKS=808893000 NODES=138520	UNSAT TT=24.051 CHECKS=808893000 NODES=138520
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-15_ext.xml	SAT TT=3.797	SAT TT=8.913 CHECKS=57623674 NODES=37451	SAT TT=3.797 CHECKS=20669527 NODES=13830	SAT TT=3.856	SAT TT=15.891	SAT TT=14.978	SAT TT=32.018 NODES=36122	SAT TT=113.948 NODES=112881	SAT TT=56.679 CHECKS=173502 NODES=72663	SAT TT=1042.09	SAT TT=799.431 CHECKS=433541560 NODES=179998	SAT TT=97.596 CHECKS=52078924 NODES=22356	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=794.276	SAT TT=1449.75	SAT TT=37.593	SAT TT=838.558 CHECKS=428013040 NODES=176915	SAT TT=852.867 CHECKS=428013040 NODES=176915	SAT TT=306.696	SAT TT=305.067	SAT TT=21.49	SAT TT=40.589	SAT TT=12.534 CHECKS=431137000 NODES=69090	SAT TT=12.574 CHECKS=431137000 NODES=69090
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=8.208	SAT TT=69.543 CHECKS=427618641 NODES=320664	SAT TT=8.208 CHECKS=46275172 NODES=35157	SAT TT=236.888	SAT TT=29.439	SAT TT=29.639	SAT TT=258.228 NODES=270509	SAT TT=357.897 NODES=442204	SAT TT=198.387 CHECKS=184082 NODES=266369	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=921.745 CHECKS=462731028 NODES=215642	SAT TT=863.329 CHECKS=459093816 NODES=213705	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=116.145	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800	SAT TT=188.5	SAT TT=32.909 CHECKS=1118070000 NODES=191018	SAT TT=32.744 CHECKS=1118070000 NODES=191018
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-19_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=36.32	UNSAT TT=123.621 CHECKS=786503385 NODES=549961	UNSAT TT=119.529 CHECKS=814838312 NODES=568065	UNSAT TT=288.395	UNSAT TT=69.012	UNSAT TT=65.007	UNSAT TT=746.12 NODES=802852	UNSAT TT=314.714 NODES=339170	UNSAT TT=294.684 CHECKS=176541 NODES=369896	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=148.721	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=178.104	UNSAT TT=36.32 CHECKS=1154330000 NODES=217269	UNSAT TT=35.785 CHECKS=1154330000 NODES=217269
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-1_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=28.147	UNSAT TT=82.964 CHECKS=567557577 NODES=396626	UNSAT TT=82.202 CHECKS=576195353 NODES=400431	UNSAT TT=279.047	UNSAT TT=62.043	UNSAT TT=58.596	UNSAT TT=945.114 NODES=782576	UNSAT TT=243.85 NODES=254956	UNSAT TT=232.395 CHECKS=182445 NODES=279233	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=0.028	UNSAT TT=109.378	UNSAT TT=1752.85 CHECKS=1017313398 NODES=459653	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.63	? (TO) TT=1800.19	UNSAT TT=1766.73	UNSAT TT=157.836	UNSAT TT=28.147 CHECKS=935683000 NODES=169049	UNSAT TT=27.911 CHECKS=935683000 NODES=169049
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=37.253	SAT TT=97.913 CHECKS=586900352 NODES=462706	SAT TT=38.511 CHECKS=228326931 NODES=183575	SAT TT=521.055	SAT TT=127.277	SAT TT=119.245	SAT TT=190.05 NODES=214539	SAT TT=254.095 NODES=311267	SAT TT=452.494 CHECKS=172366 NODES=647046	SAT TT=1386.83	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=124.397	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=208.437	SAT TT=37.253 CHECKS=1176600000 NODES=260347	SAT TT=36.823 CHECKS=1176600000 NODES=260347
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=10.098	SAT TT=13.521 CHECKS=77208957 NODES=55339	SAT TT=34.425 CHECKS=231377112 NODES=164016	SAT TT=69.653	SAT TT=10.098	SAT TT=10.211	SAT TT=486.363 NODES=554770	SAT TT=139.548 NODES=156544	SAT TT=223.99 CHECKS=173569 NODES=267086	SAT TT=169.81	SAT TT=994.601 CHECKS=508363988 NODES=233891	SAT TT=1079.09 CHECKS=508459251 NODES=233765	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=572.472	SAT TT=492.971	SAT TT=113.932	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=386.896	SAT TT=399.648	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=55.856	SAT TT=31.058 CHECKS=1025080000 NODES=180961	SAT TT=30.912 CHECKS=1025080000 NODES=180961
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-25_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=41.501	UNSAT TT=138.093 CHECKS=862691004 NODES=608392	UNSAT TT=148.017 CHECKS=955109046 NODES=672649	UNSAT TT=336.913	UNSAT TT=80.468	UNSAT TT=75.098	UNSAT TT=772.02 NODES=836781	UNSAT TT=367.812 NODES=391501	UNSAT TT=319.053 CHECKS=177335 NODES=419233	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=175.851	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.5	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=189.761	UNSAT TT=41.501 CHECKS=1345170000 NODES=256676	UNSAT TT=41.31 CHECKS=1345170000 NODES=256676
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-27_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=21.91	UNSAT TT=61.421 CHECKS=407838029 NODES=275956	UNSAT TT=64.59 CHECKS=411636816 NODES=278904	UNSAT TT=217.826	UNSAT TT=41.647	UNSAT TT=42.61	UNSAT TT=489.99 NODES=512479	UNSAT TT=182.672 NODES=205523	UNSAT TT=167.008 CHECKS=178073 NODES=208942	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=1337.33 CHECKS=652715125 NODES=306327	UNSAT TT=1418.6 CHECKS=643522927 NODES=302785	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=87.158	UNSAT TT=1451 CHECKS=682268266 NODES=319523	UNSAT TT=1453.81 CHECKS=682268266 NODES=319523	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=112.858	UNSAT TT=21.91 CHECKS=701594000 NODES=127171	UNSAT TT=21.803 CHECKS=701594000 NODES=127171
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-29_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=15.692	UNSAT TT=43.531 CHECKS=297493035 NODES=201833	UNSAT TT=45.497 CHECKS=291636592 NODES=198540	UNSAT TT=133.185	UNSAT TT=27.082	UNSAT TT=26.759	UNSAT TT=314.241 NODES=363530	UNSAT TT=125.056 NODES=128720	UNSAT TT=114.151 CHECKS=172659 NODES=135750	UNSAT TT=1396.1	UNSAT TT=891.893 CHECKS=504794105 NODES=212056	UNSAT TT=951.397 CHECKS=505533456 NODES=212573	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=943.167	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=60.046	UNSAT TT=1107.17 CHECKS=532357648 NODES=223350	UNSAT TT=1017.58 CHECKS=532357648 NODES=223350	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=1795.09	UNSAT TT=69.755	UNSAT TT=15.692 CHECKS=523276000 NODES=85303	UNSAT TT=15.194 CHECKS=523276000 NODES=85303
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-31_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.864	SAT TT=31.186 CHECKS=188205637 NODES=139656	SAT TT=46.413 CHECKS=303858548 NODES=227582	SAT TT=0.864	SAT TT=35.076	SAT TT=37.541	SAT TT=342.688 NODES=399133	SAT TT=82.835 NODES=94103	SAT TT=83.158 CHECKS=170429 NODES=104753	SAT TT=1712.27	SAT TT=155.488 CHECKS=83673616 NODES=40575	SAT TT=97.783 CHECKS=51711810 NODES=24856	SAT TT=780.933 CHECKS=423755191 NODES=208830	SAT TT=255.063	SAT TT=1252.33	SAT TT=31.509	SAT TT=722.98 CHECKS=348897154 NODES=161018	SAT TT=701.861 CHECKS=348897154 NODES=161018	? (TO) TT=1800.52	? (TO) TT=1800.71	SAT TT=1521.77	SAT TT=14.819	SAT TT=10.878 CHECKS=350977000 NODES=64255	SAT TT=10.672 CHECKS=350977000 NODES=64255
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-33_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=148.225	UNSAT TT=411.682 CHECKS=2728993272 NODES=2086270	UNSAT TT=434.814 CHECKS=2745934907 NODES=2112798	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=239.68	UNSAT TT=239.954	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=1200.07 NODES=1373535	UNSAT TT=1049.68 CHECKS=173665 NODES=1479267	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=589.85	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=625.842	UNSAT TT=148.225 CHECKS=4775300000 NODES=977797	UNSAT TT=142.043 CHECKS=4775300000 NODES=977797
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-35_ext.xml	SAT TT=23.531	SAT TT=139.722 CHECKS=926278292 NODES=722375	SAT TT=45.968 CHECKS=278468133 NODES=223323	SAT TT=674.271	SAT TT=61.268	SAT TT=61.82	SAT TT=75.425 NODES=86512	SAT TT=523.503 NODES=643599	SAT TT=416.858 CHECKS=179542 NODES=544623	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=1418.63 CHECKS=726829844 NODES=375000	SAT TT=1490.41 CHECKS=735768305 NODES=377590	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=223.699	SAT TT=1297.46 CHECKS=710894124 NODES=367578	SAT TT=1383.33 CHECKS=710894124 NODES=367578	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=305.502	SAT TT=23.531 CHECKS=750935000 NODES=162605	SAT TT=23.487 CHECKS=750935000 NODES=162605
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-37_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=83.27	UNSAT TT=314.332 CHECKS=1946987218 NODES=1461042	UNSAT TT=305.646 CHECKS=1911952266 NODES=1438524	UNSAT TT=655.245	UNSAT TT=142.696	UNSAT TT=134.679	UNSAT TT=1781.1 NODES=1970053	UNSAT TT=719.859 NODES=877191	UNSAT TT=742.296 CHECKS=175653 NODES=1039034	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.01	UNSAT TT=392.74	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=400.837	UNSAT TT=83.27 CHECKS=2634620000 NODES=557397	UNSAT TT=82.772 CHECKS=2634620000 NODES=557397
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-39_ext.xml	SAT TT=8.716	SAT TT=24.166 CHECKS=163130678 NODES=106270	SAT TT=21.799 CHECKS=150204849 NODES=99005	SAT TT=25.203	SAT TT=16.879	SAT TT=16.869	SAT TT=40.969 NODES=42095	SAT TT=15.725 NODES=14849	SAT TT=12.819 CHECKS=185255 NODES=13572	SAT TT=105.557	SAT TT=583.598 CHECKS=287466952 NODES=117891	SAT TT=607.888 CHECKS=337553096 NODES=133906	SAT TT=1637.17 CHECKS=838881795 NODES=326870	SAT TT=165.254	SAT TT=360.82	SAT TT=8.716	SAT TT=579.285 CHECKS=336691626 NODES=133587	SAT TT=604.317 CHECKS=336691626 NODES=133587	SAT TT=1538.76	SAT TT=1549.73	SAT TT=152.56	SAT TT=25.93	SAT TT=10.073 CHECKS=350749000 NODES=54653	SAT TT=10.161 CHECKS=350749000 NODES=54653
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-3_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=44.238	UNSAT TT=156.658 CHECKS=1048557079 NODES=701425	UNSAT TT=129.111 CHECKS=901722206 NODES=610489	UNSAT TT=284.374	UNSAT TT=66.02	UNSAT TT=62.049	UNSAT TT=772.224 NODES=853018	UNSAT TT=383.986 NODES=430576	UNSAT TT=343.912 CHECKS=178995 NODES=424908	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=204.468	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=267.436	UNSAT TT=44.238 CHECKS=1501180000 NODES=246778	UNSAT TT=42.557 CHECKS=1501180000 NODES=246778
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-41_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=30.718	UNSAT TT=100.378 CHECKS=689206796 NODES=465240	UNSAT TT=124.494 CHECKS=806582929 NODES=538273	UNSAT TT=367.574	UNSAT TT=53.151	UNSAT TT=51.011	UNSAT TT=571.261 NODES=606464	UNSAT TT=237.48 NODES=282828	UNSAT TT=235.671 CHECKS=177571 NODES=289170	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.01	UNSAT TT=143.665	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=173.194	UNSAT TT=30.718 CHECKS=1010840000 NODES=186342	UNSAT TT=30.578 CHECKS=1010840000 NODES=186342
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-43_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=90.651	UNSAT TT=311.807 CHECKS=2101744036 NODES=1535269	UNSAT TT=355.111 CHECKS=2327609636 NODES=1692213	UNSAT TT=747.571	UNSAT TT=162.007	UNSAT TT=174.427	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=869.937 NODES=1106615	UNSAT TT=818.918 CHECKS=178982 NODES=1050528	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=367.294	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.66	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=457.526	UNSAT TT=90.651 CHECKS=2939110000 NODES=601618	UNSAT TT=90.312 CHECKS=2939110000 NODES=601618
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-45_ext.xml	SAT TT=13.724	SAT TT=64.193 CHECKS=403162453 NODES=299827	SAT TT=71.926 CHECKS=444370623 NODES=326786	SAT TT=265.996	SAT TT=50.837	SAT TT=51.734	SAT TT=214.741 NODES=225103	SAT TT=605.269 NODES=675236	SAT TT=209.139 CHECKS=183745 NODES=280278	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=441.298 CHECKS=215549476 NODES=106849	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=163.129	SAT TT=1055.75 CHECKS=501138605 NODES=239090	SAT TT=973.572 CHECKS=501138605 NODES=239090	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.55	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=332.152	SAT TT=13.724 CHECKS=459736000 NODES=88601	SAT TT=14.549 CHECKS=459736000 NODES=88601
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-47_ext.xml	SAT TT=24.838	SAT TT=53.883 CHECKS=322891431 NODES=242639	SAT TT=38.669 CHECKS=255575389 NODES=192514	SAT TT=579.109	SAT TT=26.269	SAT TT=24.838	SAT TT=105.585 NODES=113146	SAT TT=604.666 NODES=712171	SAT TT=533.44 CHECKS=182780 NODES=717625	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=137.71	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=1321.41	SAT TT=1268.87	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=359.746	SAT TT=36.782 CHECKS=1204100000 NODES=228533	SAT TT=34.813 CHECKS=1204100000 NODES=228533
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-49_ext.xml	SAT TT=40.087	SAT TT=228.26 CHECKS=1434466780 NODES=1086944	SAT TT=212.71 CHECKS=1421763725 NODES=1078878	SAT TT=165.045	SAT TT=174.428	SAT TT=163.144	SAT TT=348.484 NODES=378181	SAT TT=46.041 NODES=52100	SAT TT=45.889 CHECKS=182408 NODES=56456	SAT TT=563.63	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=1139.2 CHECKS=511102299 NODES=272997	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=106.324	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.56	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=307.824	SAT TT=40.087 CHECKS=1232450000 NODES=286929	SAT TT=38.881 CHECKS=1232450000 NODES=286929
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-5_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=66.415	UNSAT TT=251.427 CHECKS=1540686439 NODES=1117687	UNSAT TT=225.652 CHECKS=1521246115 NODES=1096362	UNSAT TT=360.918	UNSAT TT=117.294	UNSAT TT=121.773	UNSAT TT=1201.18 NODES=1384785	UNSAT TT=600.315 NODES=741963	UNSAT TT=580.665 CHECKS=175887 NODES=813812	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=237.446	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.56	? (TO) TT=1800.02	UNSAT TT=343.162	UNSAT TT=66.415 CHECKS=2134640000 NODES=437659	UNSAT TT=65.721 CHECKS=2134640000 NODES=437659
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-7_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=101.315	UNSAT TT=403.932 CHECKS=2477981985 NODES=1937455	UNSAT TT=379.2 CHECKS=2454505480 NODES=1914574	UNSAT TT=588.845	UNSAT TT=237.011	UNSAT TT=222.366	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=951.525 NODES=1182920	UNSAT TT=990.828 CHECKS=173582 NODES=1306306	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=387.366	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=488.675	UNSAT TT=101.315 CHECKS=3302030000 NODES=718151	UNSAT TT=103.239 CHECKS=3302030000 NODES=718151
random/rand-2-40-19/ rand-2-40-19-443-230-9_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=63.954	UNSAT TT=181.347 CHECKS=1226164643 NODES=882161	UNSAT TT=193.667 CHECKS=1225260478 NODES=880664	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=112.201	UNSAT TT=109.439	UNSAT TT=1170.99 NODES=1234992	UNSAT TT=433.668 NODES=515134	UNSAT TT=416.641 CHECKS=179142 NODES=544089	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=194.905	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.65	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=268.674	UNSAT TT=63.954 CHECKS=2092670000 NODES=386609	UNSAT TT=63.122 CHECKS=2092670000 NODES=386609
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-11_ext.xml	SAT TT=222.955	SAT TT=222.955 CHECKS=1559117243 NODES=940192	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-13_ext.xml	SAT TT=639.645	? (TO) TT=1800.15	SAT TT=1325.75 CHECKS=8485695134 NODES=5394062	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=639.645	SAT TT=683.312	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=1579.39 CHECKS=50658100000 NODES=9588380	SAT TT=1506.02 CHECKS=50658100000 NODES=9588380
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-15_ext.xml	SAT TT=468.835	? (TO) TT=1800.17	SAT TT=468.835 CHECKS=3054840526 NODES=1922021	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=698.148 CHECKS=21951700000 NODES=4043510	SAT TT=642.672 CHECKS=21951700000 NODES=4043510
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=408.058	SAT TT=1326.16 CHECKS=9305168526 NODES=5952688	SAT TT=1559.1 CHECKS=10861441116 NODES=6942988	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=428.389	SAT TT=408.058	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=1701.03	SAT TT=594.221 CHECKS=18742500000 NODES=3222370	SAT TT=581.475 CHECKS=18742500000 NODES=3222370
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-19_ext.xml	SAT TT=522.947	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=643.891	SAT TT=689.236	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=1421.71	SAT TT=1407.12	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=732.859	SAT TT=522.947 CHECKS=16273500000 NODES=2965810	SAT TT=474.57 CHECKS=16273500000 NODES=2965810
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=845.181	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.15	SAT TT=920.403	SAT TT=845.181	SAT TT=899.016	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=1358.34 CHECKS=47828100000 NODES=7135380	SAT TT=1437.53 CHECKS=47828100000 NODES=7135380
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.536	SAT TT=2.536 CHECKS=10153281 NODES=6554	SAT TT=295.195 CHECKS=1946467607 NODES=1204962	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=75.128	SAT TT=80.119	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=1007.19 CHECKS=32313800000 NODES=5422250	SAT TT=992.237 CHECKS=32313800000 NODES=5422250
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-25_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-27_ext.xml	SAT TT=511.767	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=511.767	SAT TT=513.529	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.58	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-29_ext.xml	SAT TT=1166.76	SAT TT=1579.7 CHECKS=10057451549 NODES=6238367	SAT TT=1166.76 CHECKS=8187481087 NODES=5076299	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=1349.48	SAT TT=1283.3	SAT TT=245.123 NODES=197541	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=1189.59 CHECKS=39723200000 NODES=7508550	SAT TT=1267.74 CHECKS=39723200000 NODES=7508550
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-31_ext.xml	SAT TT=196.206	SAT TT=196.206 CHECKS=1399949621 NODES=822579	SAT TT=679.658 CHECKS=4608631011 NODES=2731527	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=1159.57	SAT TT=1241.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=983.361	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.56	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=212.36 CHECKS=7094220000 NODES=1139870	SAT TT=213.087 CHECKS=7094220000 NODES=1139870
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-33_ext.xml	SAT TT=389.804	SAT TT=1382.22 CHECKS=9960552631 NODES=5888388	SAT TT=389.804 CHECKS=2595711036 NODES=1537471	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=442.397	SAT TT=472.105	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=783.735 CHECKS=25323400000 NODES=4161090	SAT TT=747.266 CHECKS=25323400000 NODES=4161090
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-35_ext.xml	SAT TT=330.783	SAT TT=743.444 CHECKS=4905020155 NODES=2979562	SAT TT=330.783 CHECKS=2359597418 NODES=1402022	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=795.741	SAT TT=799.707	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.56	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-37_ext.xml	SAT TT=477.599	SAT TT=477.599 CHECKS=3260384086 NODES=1997401	SAT TT=676.876 CHECKS=4739119516 NODES=2900247	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.55	? (TO) TT=1800.64	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-39_ext.xml	SAT TT=114.517	SAT TT=114.517 CHECKS=745514391 NODES=442915	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=1369.4	SAT TT=1462.65	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=1496.78 NODES=1373334	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=1531.35	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=299.484 CHECKS=10259500000 NODES=1702660	SAT TT=297.376 CHECKS=10259500000 NODES=1702660
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-41_ext.xml	SAT TT=167.635	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=394.314 CHECKS=2593680866 NODES=1611602	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=1622.51	SAT TT=1690.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=809.899	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.58	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=167.635 CHECKS=5552370000 NODES=1108730	SAT TT=165.706 CHECKS=5552370000 NODES=1108730
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-43_ext.xml	SAT TT=222.449	SAT TT=242.28 CHECKS=1588213368 NODES=934085	SAT TT=222.449 CHECKS=1565728893 NODES=935186	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.62	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-45_ext.xml	SAT TT=68.775	SAT TT=841.733 CHECKS=5451351129 NODES=3260742	SAT TT=396.648 CHECKS=2806955628 NODES=1719545	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=68.775	SAT TT=69.62	SAT TT=1614.73 NODES=1410930	SAT TT=1384.77 NODES=1261422	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=1442.89	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=277.52 CHECKS=9348540000 NODES=1599140	SAT TT=285.587 CHECKS=9348540000 NODES=1599140
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-47_ext.xml	SAT TT=76.456	SAT TT=76.456 CHECKS=473734824 NODES=320167	SAT TT=300.986 CHECKS=1938949376 NODES=1270628	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=1664.49	SAT TT=1535.82	SAT TT=929.374 NODES=792611	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-49_ext.xml	SAT TT=489.567	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.15	SAT TT=1565.74	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=489.567 CHECKS=363609 NODES=460289	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-10_ext.xml	SAT TT=376.074	SAT TT=1445.31 CHECKS=9817823554 NODES=6522095	SAT TT=902.971 CHECKS=4541294022 NODES=2954073	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=377.407	SAT TT=376.074	SAT TT=768.686 NODES=699439	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=880.949	SAT TT=624.102 CHECKS=21030800000 NODES=4054740	SAT TT=657.977 CHECKS=21030800000 NODES=4054740
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-11_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.64	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-12_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.06
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-13_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.47	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-14_ext.xml	SAT TT=1044.05	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=1044.05 CHECKS=34979400000 NODES=6160800	SAT TT=1099.29 CHECKS=34979400000 NODES=6160800
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-15_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-16_ext.xml	SAT TT=354.635	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=354.635	SAT TT=381.497	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=1135.12 CHECKS=37577000000 NODES=6149130	SAT TT=1085.44 CHECKS=37577000000 NODES=6149130
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=1073.51	SAT TT=1073.51 CHECKS=7489081724 NODES=4527913	SAT TT=1792.66 CHECKS=11790234745 NODES=7131750	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=1147.16	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=1600.64 CHECKS=52112800000 NODES=8761670	SAT TT=1536.11 CHECKS=52112800000 NODES=8761670
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-18_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-19_ext.xml	SAT TT=255.586	? (TO) TT=1800.14	SAT TT=255.586 CHECKS=1756254328 NODES=1087419	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.6	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=1045.81 CHECKS=33497900000 NODES=5754670	SAT TT=1034.49 CHECKS=33497900000 NODES=5754670
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-1_ext.xml	SAT TT=1776.7	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=1776.7	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-20_ext.xml	SAT TT=192.44	SAT TT=420.005 CHECKS=3038737884 NODES=1803886	SAT TT=887.073 CHECKS=5997688607 NODES=3605977	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=192.44	SAT TT=206.815	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=359.465 CHECKS=11923900000 NODES=1955720	SAT TT=332.88 CHECKS=11923900000 NODES=1955720
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=1298.57	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=1607.24	SAT TT=1712.83	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=1298.57 CHECKS=45344000000 NODES=6922360	SAT TT=1372.75 CHECKS=45344000000 NODES=6922360
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-22_ext.xml	SAT TT=141.697	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=869.883	SAT TT=873.925	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=1145.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=141.697 CHECKS=4459680000 NODES=831752	SAT TT=139.912 CHECKS=4459680000 NODES=831752
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=129.765	SAT TT=490.513 CHECKS=3489519939 NODES=2119569	SAT TT=500.604 CHECKS=3347495509 NODES=2061144	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=242.441	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.61	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=129.765 CHECKS=4435940000 NODES=739299	SAT TT=135.842 CHECKS=4435940000 NODES=739299
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-24_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-25_ext.xml	SAT TT=1077.61	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=1459.45 NODES=1401411	SAT TT=1077.61 CHECKS=363670 NODES=1089385	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-26_ext.xml	SAT TT=1737.96	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=1737.96	SAT TT=1738.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-27_ext.xml	SAT TT=714.584	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=714.584 CHECKS=23577000000 NODES=4691380	SAT TT=755.227 CHECKS=23577000000 NODES=4691380
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-28_ext.xml	SAT TT=34.22	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=34.228	SAT TT=34.22	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-29_ext.xml	SAT TT=70.963	SAT TT=70.963 CHECKS=475381175 NODES=303283	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=131.825	SAT TT=123.127	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=732.517	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.59	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=167.191 CHECKS=5745780000 NODES=1009170	SAT TT=178.638 CHECKS=5745780000 NODES=1009170
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-2_ext.xml	SAT TT=385.944	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=932.626	SAT TT=930.794	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=385.944 CHECKS=12851600000 NODES=1887140	SAT TT=363.75 CHECKS=12851600000 NODES=1887140
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-30_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-31_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.56	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-32_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.09
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-33_ext.xml	SAT TT=1304.16	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=1383.4 CHECKS=9867902868 NODES=5849897	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=1304.16 CHECKS=42190700000 NODES=6958390	SAT TT=1291.26 CHECKS=42190700000 NODES=6958390
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-34_ext.xml	SAT TT=195.182	SAT TT=1732.17 CHECKS=11129118467 NODES=7112610	SAT TT=195.182 CHECKS=1335280719 NODES=866976	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=370.541	SAT TT=369.994	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-35_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-36_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.11
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-37_ext.xml	SAT TT=74.297	SAT TT=777.829 CHECKS=5406844162 NODES=3283954	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=79.189	SAT TT=74.297	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.22	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-38_ext.xml	SAT TT=1481.2	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=1481.2 CHECKS=47642200000 NODES=7960070	SAT TT=1422.51 CHECKS=47642200000 NODES=7960070
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-39_ext.xml	SAT TT=362.121	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=1528.42 CHECKS=10776208870 NODES=6658242	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=1341.08	SAT TT=1333.3	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=362.121 CHECKS=11597200000 NODES=2093800	SAT TT=338.374 CHECKS=11597200000 NODES=2093800
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-3_ext.xml	SAT TT=240.868	SAT TT=240.868 CHECKS=1558019976 NODES=981761	SAT TT=1207.57 CHECKS=5413295919 NODES=3415515	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=299.217	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-40_ext.xml	SAT TT=1513.18	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=1513.18 CHECKS=52388900000 NODES=8957720	SAT TT=1520.03 CHECKS=52388900000 NODES=8957720
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-41_ext.xml	SAT TT=529.552	SAT TT=1492.67 CHECKS=10269984948 NODES=6546448	SAT TT=807.094 CHECKS=5537901306 NODES=3548020	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.61	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=529.552 CHECKS=16779700000 NODES=3114270	SAT TT=519.167 CHECKS=16779700000 NODES=3114270
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-42_ext.xml	SAT TT=681.298	SAT TT=1201.87 CHECKS=7967714328 NODES=4825502	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=681.298	SAT TT=726.381	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-43_ext.xml	SAT TT=35.285	SAT TT=1277.44 CHECKS=8755088250 NODES=5369590	SAT TT=614.942 CHECKS=4328373748 NODES=2622267	SAT TT=619.823	SAT TT=53.224	SAT TT=53.247	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=1200.22	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.3	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=35.285 CHECKS=1121080000 NODES=189192	SAT TT=35.119 CHECKS=1121080000 NODES=189192
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-44_ext.xml	SAT TT=224.611	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=341.596	SAT TT=224.611	SAT TT=225.98	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-45_ext.xml	SAT TT=22.815	SAT TT=22.815 CHECKS=142857244 NODES=92726	SAT TT=974.66 CHECKS=6862462120 NODES=4182508	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=1104.62	SAT TT=1104.16	SAT TT=398.418 NODES=326339	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.56	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=1171.98 CHECKS=40011700000 NODES=6805440	SAT TT=1179.48 CHECKS=40011700000 NODES=6805440
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-46_ext.xml	SAT TT=874.67	? (TO) TT=1800.14	SAT TT=1544.08 CHECKS=10862142214 NODES=7019298	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=1268.48	SAT TT=1267.66	SAT TT=177.753 NODES=143363	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=874.67 CHECKS=27898200000 NODES=5002010	SAT TT=865.1 CHECKS=27898200000 NODES=5002010
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-47_ext.xml	SAT TT=1009.15	SAT TT=1009.15 CHECKS=6811257930 NODES=4594407	SAT TT=1622.36 CHECKS=11023246404 NODES=7210102	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-48_ext.xml	SAT TT=211.765	SAT TT=1683.76 CHECKS=12035354105 NODES=6311691	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=938.187	SAT TT=875.73	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.22	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=211.765 CHECKS=7206030000 NODES=1001880	SAT TT=196.47 CHECKS=7206030000 NODES=1001880
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-49_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.55	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-4_ext.xml	SAT TT=419.269	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.62	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=419.269 CHECKS=13582700000 NODES=2231500	SAT TT=400.893 CHECKS=13582700000 NODES=2231500
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-50_ext.xml	SAT TT=184.732	SAT TT=463.493 CHECKS=3061502354 NODES=1852654	SAT TT=560.31 CHECKS=3986034545 NODES=2439144	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=185.669	SAT TT=184.732	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=1765.91 CHECKS=60918900000 NODES=11207900
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-5_ext.xml	SAT TT=491.785	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=515.356	SAT TT=514.814	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=998.511	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=491.785 CHECKS=16336500000 NODES=2845680	SAT TT=509.203 CHECKS=16336500000 NODES=2845680
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-6_ext.xml		? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-7_ext.xml	SAT TT=243.616	SAT TT=243.616 CHECKS=1746638556 NODES=1023904	SAT TT=375.128 CHECKS=2665429111 NODES=1538331	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.01	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-8_ext.xml	SAT TT=726.759	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=774.14	SAT TT=776.536	? (TO) TT=1800	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=1471.29	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.6	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=1399.63	SAT TT=726.759 CHECKS=23003500000 NODES=4297810	SAT TT=723.637 CHECKS=23003500000 NODES=4297810
random/rand-2-50-23/ rand-2-50-23-587-230-9_ext.xml	SAT TT=740.976	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=740.976 CHECKS=25652400000 NODES=4588030	SAT TT=751.938 CHECKS=25652400000 NODES=4588030
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-0_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.337	SAT TT=4.399 CHECKS=10132138 NODES=15308	SAT TT=3.355 CHECKS=7738981 NODES=11832	SAT TT=13.45	SAT TT=2.451	SAT TT=2.337	SAT TT=20.014 NODES=16237	SAT TT=14.868 NODES=13960	SAT TT=9.992 CHECKS=86818 NODES=10961	SAT TT=12.706	SAT TT=202.438 CHECKS=93768929 NODES=60130	SAT TT=175.37 CHECKS=84153643 NODES=53992	SAT TT=179.329 CHECKS=86669367 NODES=58484	SAT TT=4.027	SAT TT=8.353	SAT TT=12.857	SAT TT=186.315 CHECKS=91046842 NODES=61478	SAT TT=184.568 CHECKS=91046842 NODES=61478	SAT TT=142.102	SAT TT=139.892	SAT TT=16.64	SAT TT=3.736	SAT TT=2.958 CHECKS=92195900 NODES=31384	SAT TT=2.915 CHECKS=92195900 NODES=31384
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-11_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.401	SAT TT=2.802 CHECKS=5096327 NODES=7666	SAT TT=1.401 CHECKS=834443 NODES=1408	SAT TT=9.05	SAT TT=1.957	SAT TT=1.935	SAT TT=11.499 NODES=8407	SAT TT=29.182 NODES=29791	SAT TT=18.439 CHECKS=87567 NODES=20704	SAT TT=8.585	SAT TT=172.516 CHECKS=78368752 NODES=48439	SAT TT=208.103 CHECKS=93746797 NODES=58080	SAT TT=114.072 CHECKS=55760938 NODES=35371	SAT TT=4.59	SAT TT=2.72	SAT TT=2.953	SAT TT=198.138 CHECKS=95953597 NODES=62735	SAT TT=194.513 CHECKS=95953597 NODES=62735	SAT TT=61.161	SAT TT=62.562	SAT TT=1.72	SAT TT=3.095	SAT TT=3.04 CHECKS=93606700 NODES=31656	SAT TT=2.894 CHECKS=93606700 NODES=31656
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-13_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.391	UNSAT TT=13.06 CHECKS=36869981 NODES=51875	UNSAT TT=13.475 CHECKS=39493712 NODES=55718	UNSAT TT=10.809	UNSAT TT=11.606	UNSAT TT=11.704	UNSAT TT=94.197 NODES=72656	UNSAT TT=35.986 NODES=35701	UNSAT TT=28.326 CHECKS=86389 NODES=30291	UNSAT TT=23.259	UNSAT TT=216.246 CHECKS=105047266 NODES=61708	UNSAT TT=219.897 CHECKS=103564291 NODES=62523	UNSAT TT=801.284 CHECKS=399337321 NODES=245253	UNSAT TT=47.431	UNSAT TT=250.057	UNSAT TT=13.09	UNSAT TT=215.159 CHECKS=104516503 NODES=64231	UNSAT TT=214.114 CHECKS=104516503 NODES=64231	UNSAT TT=499.185	UNSAT TT=495.912	UNSAT TT=23.65	UNSAT TT=18.94	UNSAT TT=3.391 CHECKS=108681000 NODES=33887	UNSAT TT=3.383 CHECKS=108681000 NODES=33887
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-15_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.389	SAT TT=10.885 CHECKS=33539559 NODES=49829	SAT TT=10.408 CHECKS=29564154 NODES=43830	SAT TT=3.736	SAT TT=6.1	SAT TT=5.72	SAT TT=4.436 NODES=2897	SAT TT=26.061 NODES=27702	SAT TT=25.259 CHECKS=87911 NODES=26567	SAT TT=20.012	SAT TT=251.472 CHECKS=117902134 NODES=76637	SAT TT=253.526 CHECKS=116760459 NODES=75174	SAT TT=390.802 CHECKS=191190811 NODES=122688	SAT TT=4.675	SAT TT=136.516	SAT TT=11.245	SAT TT=85.563 CHECKS=37904289 NODES=24601	SAT TT=82.956 CHECKS=37904289 NODES=24601	SAT TT=23.773	SAT TT=22.088	SAT TT=6.69	SAT TT=4.199	SAT TT=1.389 CHECKS=42583900 NODES=14197	SAT TT=1.273 CHECKS=42583900 NODES=14197
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-17_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.169	UNSAT TT=21.417 CHECKS=63340371 NODES=93125	UNSAT TT=20.914 CHECKS=67498836 NODES=99716	UNSAT TT=16.421	UNSAT TT=14.364	UNSAT TT=14.926	UNSAT TT=139.749 NODES=107247	UNSAT TT=55.536 NODES=53680	UNSAT TT=53.588 CHECKS=87187 NODES=60927	UNSAT TT=48.779	UNSAT TT=323.528 CHECKS=149539320 NODES=94589	UNSAT TT=306.428 CHECKS=142295520 NODES=91012	UNSAT TT=1290.75 CHECKS=624424576 NODES=410197	UNSAT TT=112.78	UNSAT TT=527.517	UNSAT TT=19.444	UNSAT TT=333.81 CHECKS=149385247 NODES=97850	UNSAT TT=336.718 CHECKS=149385247 NODES=97850	UNSAT TT=1412.11	UNSAT TT=1440.3	UNSAT TT=48.35	UNSAT TT=23.501	UNSAT TT=5.169 CHECKS=161310000 NODES=53745	UNSAT TT=5.087 CHECKS=161310000 NODES=53745
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-19_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.376	SAT TT=11.231 CHECKS=31735358 NODES=45098	SAT TT=10.929 CHECKS=31512046 NODES=45168	SAT TT=7.801	SAT TT=6.257	SAT TT=6.456	SAT TT=46.684 NODES=38575	SAT TT=13.699 NODES=12348	SAT TT=26.154 CHECKS=87082 NODES=29996	SAT TT=12.128	? (conv) TT=0	? (conv) TT=0	? (conv) TT=0	SAT TT=33.222	SAT TT=61.958	SAT TT=4.841	? (conv) TT=0	? (conv) TT=0	SAT TT=34.432	SAT TT=33.455	SAT TT=20.48	SAT TT=4.511	SAT TT=2.376 CHECKS=75128200 NODES=23413	SAT TT=2.319 CHECKS=75128200 NODES=23413
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-1_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.421	UNSAT TT=18.123 CHECKS=52499096 NODES=75603	UNSAT TT=16.165 CHECKS=47521739 NODES=69133	UNSAT TT=11.13	UNSAT TT=11.179	UNSAT TT=11.856	UNSAT TT=95.62 NODES=72352	UNSAT TT=44.496 NODES=41890	UNSAT TT=35.938 CHECKS=88719 NODES=41082	UNSAT TT=30.185	UNSAT TT=304.897 CHECKS=141902522 NODES=85567	UNSAT TT=268.047 CHECKS=128855353 NODES=78072	UNSAT TT=1108.18 CHECKS=510360248 NODES=317762	UNSAT TT=56.697	UNSAT TT=302.761	UNSAT TT=12.194	UNSAT TT=220.75 CHECKS=101191665 NODES=63158	UNSAT TT=211.933 CHECKS=101191665 NODES=63158	UNSAT TT=994.845	UNSAT TT=951.538	UNSAT TT=25.58	UNSAT TT=19.641	UNSAT TT=3.421 CHECKS=108994000 NODES=34510	UNSAT TT=3.423 CHECKS=108994000 NODES=34510
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-21_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.628	UNSAT TT=22.426 CHECKS=66653428 NODES=99137	UNSAT TT=21.17 CHECKS=66078961 NODES=97939	UNSAT TT=16.198	UNSAT TT=12.696	UNSAT TT=12.992	UNSAT TT=117.251 NODES=93687	UNSAT TT=45.315 NODES=48719	UNSAT TT=42.51 CHECKS=88980 NODES=48295	UNSAT TT=35.131	UNSAT TT=277.856 CHECKS=136038223 NODES=88666	UNSAT TT=321.918 CHECKS=150188985 NODES=98664	UNSAT TT=1282.16 CHECKS=638406850 NODES=428442	UNSAT TT=134.898	UNSAT TT=324.474	UNSAT TT=19.545	UNSAT TT=301.004 CHECKS=139600114 NODES=92899	UNSAT TT=306.327 CHECKS=139600114 NODES=92899	UNSAT TT=1593.49	UNSAT TT=1564.39	UNSAT TT=38.3	UNSAT TT=27.629	UNSAT TT=4.628 CHECKS=145034000 NODES=50246	UNSAT TT=4.584 CHECKS=145034000 NODES=50246
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.304	SAT TT=2.195 CHECKS=3547239 NODES=5436	SAT TT=1.509 CHECKS=1299788 NODES=2081	SAT TT=4.285	SAT TT=1.927	SAT TT=2.042	SAT TT=8.672 NODES=6933	SAT TT=8.847 NODES=8600	SAT TT=22.566 CHECKS=87740 NODES=23931	SAT TT=5.225	SAT TT=95.539 CHECKS=42978332 NODES=26940	SAT TT=114.024 CHECKS=53334477 NODES=32779	SAT TT=115.487 CHECKS=48739278 NODES=31981	SAT TT=26.775	SAT TT=15.47	SAT TT=6.135	SAT TT=88.53 CHECKS=39465715 NODES=26999	SAT TT=80.87 CHECKS=39465715 NODES=26999	SAT TT=35.228	SAT TT=36.506	SAT TT=2.454	SAT TT=15.351	SAT TT=1.304 CHECKS=39834300 NODES=13930	SAT TT=1.266 CHECKS=39834300 NODES=13930
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-25_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.051	SAT TT=1.074 CHECKS=345661 NODES=581	SAT TT=3.143 CHECKS=6989290 NODES=11255	SAT TT=3.41	SAT TT=2.034	SAT TT=1.966	SAT TT=8.797 NODES=6752	SAT TT=20.994 NODES=22217	SAT TT=28.408 CHECKS=87561 NODES=33219	SAT TT=16.287	SAT TT=72.442 CHECKS=32279174 NODES=21273	SAT TT=94.978 CHECKS=45537424 NODES=28489	SAT TT=250.864 CHECKS=122415925 NODES=82111	SAT TT=15.065	SAT TT=146.004	SAT TT=2.406	SAT TT=64.198 CHECKS=29636955 NODES=20691	SAT TT=64.813 CHECKS=29636955 NODES=20691	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=7.31	SAT TT=2.425	SAT TT=1.051 CHECKS=34147100 NODES=12308	SAT TT=1.115 CHECKS=34147100 NODES=12308
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-27_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.909	SAT TT=2.392 CHECKS=4214489 NODES=6339	SAT TT=3.648 CHECKS=7933180 NODES=12024	SAT TT=3.568	SAT TT=3.954	SAT TT=4.178	SAT TT=26.395 NODES=19867	SAT TT=43.687 NODES=42142	SAT TT=11.846 CHECKS=86573 NODES=12456	SAT TT=14.075	SAT TT=219.156 CHECKS=100651974 NODES=63753	SAT TT=225.978 CHECKS=100964306 NODES=64360	SAT TT=351.521 CHECKS=167768085 NODES=107658	SAT TT=4.989	SAT TT=100.429	SAT TT=11.947	SAT TT=61.142 CHECKS=26158827 NODES=16653	SAT TT=58.894 CHECKS=26158827 NODES=16653	SAT TT=204.928	SAT TT=215.655	SAT TT=17.24	SAT TT=9.996	SAT TT=0.909 CHECKS=29913800 NODES=9452	SAT TT=0.896 CHECKS=29913800 NODES=9452
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-29_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.545	SAT TT=2.315 CHECKS=3628391 NODES=5834	SAT TT=20.229 CHECKS=65634322 NODES=99959	SAT TT=9.3	SAT TT=1.61	SAT TT=1.545	SAT TT=138.517 NODES=114539	SAT TT=13.749 NODES=13611	SAT TT=59.238 CHECKS=87596 NODES=66888	SAT TT=2.763	SAT TT=116.095 CHECKS=53547256 NODES=33576	SAT TT=62.742 CHECKS=29416991 NODES=19057	SAT TT=283.311 CHECKS=131533741 NODES=89962	SAT TT=16.574	SAT TT=220.963	SAT TT=13.337	SAT TT=208.355 CHECKS=95657776 NODES=64279	SAT TT=207.007 CHECKS=95657776 NODES=64279	SAT TT=507.808	SAT TT=521.455	SAT TT=43.39	SAT TT=25.024	SAT TT=3.075 CHECKS=97842000 NODES=33601	SAT TT=3.101 CHECKS=97842000 NODES=33601
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-31_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.288	UNSAT TT=20.003 CHECKS=59739575 NODES=86693	UNSAT TT=20.944 CHECKS=63877756 NODES=93064	UNSAT TT=13.948	UNSAT TT=15.103	UNSAT TT=14.167	UNSAT TT=110.122 NODES=95226	UNSAT TT=58.29 NODES=55442	UNSAT TT=49.713 CHECKS=88476 NODES=57411	UNSAT TT=47.229	UNSAT TT=282.846 CHECKS=139395566 NODES=88428	UNSAT TT=302.085 CHECKS=137179445 NODES=88760	UNSAT TT=1334.21 CHECKS=644459458 NODES=420187	UNSAT TT=102.51	UNSAT TT=642.271	UNSAT TT=18.408	UNSAT TT=261.484 CHECKS=120986216 NODES=78339	UNSAT TT=265.387 CHECKS=120986216 NODES=78339	UNSAT TT=1409.16	UNSAT TT=1516.1	UNSAT TT=37.304	UNSAT TT=27.198	UNSAT TT=4.288 CHECKS=133938000 NODES=44847	UNSAT TT=4.231 CHECKS=133938000 NODES=44847
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-33_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.061	UNSAT TT=16.848 CHECKS=52326554 NODES=75557	UNSAT TT=14.054 CHECKS=44393897 NODES=63450	UNSAT TT=13.228	UNSAT TT=14.745	UNSAT TT=13.805	UNSAT TT=94.474 NODES=72456	UNSAT TT=43.43 NODES=47434	UNSAT TT=40.191 CHECKS=87843 NODES=46023	UNSAT TT=38.063	UNSAT TT=245.619 CHECKS=113567110 NODES=71131	UNSAT TT=272.278 CHECKS=130543859 NODES=81803	UNSAT TT=1008.23 CHECKS=504529510 NODES=320318	UNSAT TT=90.521	UNSAT TT=541.867	UNSAT TT=15.095	UNSAT TT=248.133 CHECKS=120547663 NODES=76018	UNSAT TT=255.85 CHECKS=120547663 NODES=76018	UNSAT TT=948.977	UNSAT TT=931.579	UNSAT TT=26.57	UNSAT TT=20.951	UNSAT TT=4.061 CHECKS=129729000 NODES=41935	UNSAT TT=4.17 CHECKS=129729000 NODES=41935
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-35_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.929	UNSAT TT=13.516 CHECKS=42058294 NODES=59580	UNSAT TT=13.058 CHECKS=37651974 NODES=52938	UNSAT TT=12.724	UNSAT TT=10.497	UNSAT TT=10.704	UNSAT TT=65.382 NODES=49641	UNSAT TT=37.276 NODES=34951	UNSAT TT=34.397 CHECKS=88978 NODES=36342	UNSAT TT=27.329	UNSAT TT=264.126 CHECKS=119463866 NODES=69660	UNSAT TT=264.602 CHECKS=118499016 NODES=68969	UNSAT TT=1102.17 CHECKS=512564990 NODES=309825	UNSAT TT=61.306	UNSAT TT=246.177	UNSAT TT=14.202	UNSAT TT=261.095 CHECKS=127482250 NODES=76683	UNSAT TT=271.909 CHECKS=127482250 NODES=76683	UNSAT TT=680.094	UNSAT TT=670.615	UNSAT TT=35.53	UNSAT TT=18.594	UNSAT TT=3.929 CHECKS=126236000 NODES=38338	UNSAT TT=3.889 CHECKS=126236000 NODES=38338
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-37_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.653	UNSAT TT=15.601 CHECKS=49429947 NODES=70766	UNSAT TT=15.363 CHECKS=46050328 NODES=66237	UNSAT TT=11.662	UNSAT TT=12.867	UNSAT TT=12.99	UNSAT TT=95.758 NODES=71157	UNSAT TT=33.791 NODES=37500	UNSAT TT=34.571 CHECKS=87504 NODES=40057	UNSAT TT=26.739	UNSAT TT=260.723 CHECKS=118036312 NODES=73403	UNSAT TT=268.771 CHECKS=121156710 NODES=75182	UNSAT TT=1042.79 CHECKS=499037204 NODES=322235	UNSAT TT=51.887	UNSAT TT=239.629	UNSAT TT=15.181	UNSAT TT=221.663 CHECKS=106919541 NODES=67965	UNSAT TT=220.588 CHECKS=106919541 NODES=67965	UNSAT TT=1126.18	UNSAT TT=1098.54	UNSAT TT=21.299	UNSAT TT=26.177	UNSAT TT=3.653 CHECKS=114855000 NODES=37649	UNSAT TT=3.638 CHECKS=114855000 NODES=37649
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-39_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.12	SAT TT=1.993 CHECKS=3129801 NODES=4908	SAT TT=10.479 CHECKS=31324011 NODES=47691	SAT TT=4.381	SAT TT=3.96	SAT TT=4.061	SAT TT=17.464 NODES=13570	SAT TT=39.346 NODES=38444	SAT TT=37.845 CHECKS=89308 NODES=42900	SAT TT=23.082	SAT TT=246.937 CHECKS=111543827 NODES=71590	SAT TT=246.946 CHECKS=117517241 NODES=75357	SAT TT=180.539 CHECKS=90535247 NODES=59693	SAT TT=4.984	SAT TT=6.704	SAT TT=7.816	SAT TT=69.29 CHECKS=32159491 NODES=20947	SAT TT=74.43 CHECKS=32159491 NODES=20947	SAT TT=484.276	SAT TT=515.953	SAT TT=24.87	SAT TT=12.8	SAT TT=1.12 CHECKS=34192900 NODES=11386	SAT TT=1.088 CHECKS=34192900 NODES=11386
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-3_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.772	UNSAT TT=18.057 CHECKS=53559010 NODES=76874	UNSAT TT=16.325 CHECKS=48891083 NODES=70017	UNSAT TT=10.731	UNSAT TT=14.966	UNSAT TT=15.067	UNSAT TT=92.465 NODES=77162	UNSAT TT=38.995 NODES=43252	UNSAT TT=36.575 CHECKS=87805 NODES=40042	UNSAT TT=28.307	UNSAT TT=274.402 CHECKS=129838667 NODES=79258	UNSAT TT=259.881 CHECKS=118817260 NODES=72598	UNSAT TT=1043.61 CHECKS=505188367 NODES=318700	UNSAT TT=80.791	UNSAT TT=246.753	UNSAT TT=14.054	UNSAT TT=256.065 CHECKS=116603426 NODES=72764	UNSAT TT=259.807 CHECKS=116603426 NODES=72764	UNSAT TT=832.106	UNSAT TT=877.963	UNSAT TT=29.433	UNSAT TT=25.556	UNSAT TT=3.772 CHECKS=119856000 NODES=38002	UNSAT TT=3.771 CHECKS=119856000 NODES=38002
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-41_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.09	SAT TT=15.839 CHECKS=48721571 NODES=76158	SAT TT=4.098 CHECKS=9467261 NODES=15311	SAT TT=0.459	SAT TT=11.07	SAT TT=11.683	SAT TT=12.431 NODES=9941	SAT TT=11.816 NODES=12861	SAT TT=51.167 CHECKS=86911 NODES=60740	SAT TT=17.314	SAT TT=41.278 CHECKS=18591548 NODES=11185	SAT TT=32.444 CHECKS=13939623 NODES=8525	SAT TT=63.881 CHECKS=30760609 NODES=21262	SAT TT=11.329	SAT TT=195.168	SAT TT=0.366	SAT TT=8.419 CHECKS=3349760 NODES=2555	SAT TT=8.648 CHECKS=3349760 NODES=2555	SAT TT=510.104	SAT TT=509.927	SAT TT=18.896	SAT TT=1.396	SAT TT=0.09 CHECKS=1790540 NODES=735	SAT TT=0.085 CHECKS=1790540 NODES=735
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-43_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.158	UNSAT TT=14.065 CHECKS=40967030 NODES=57139	UNSAT TT=11.813 CHECKS=36876805 NODES=51584	UNSAT TT=9.214	UNSAT TT=10.344	UNSAT TT=10.067	UNSAT TT=84.181 NODES=68519	UNSAT TT=30.604 NODES=32879	UNSAT TT=29.141 CHECKS=87059 NODES=30661	UNSAT TT=23.907	UNSAT TT=226.006 CHECKS=110008884 NODES=64714	UNSAT TT=251.407 CHECKS=121596328 NODES=70881	UNSAT TT=802.657 CHECKS=393527408 NODES=236905	UNSAT TT=47.357	UNSAT TT=214.15	UNSAT TT=12.351	UNSAT TT=195.29 CHECKS=92476506 NODES=55798	UNSAT TT=202.702 CHECKS=92476506 NODES=55798	UNSAT TT=625.375	UNSAT TT=633.476	UNSAT TT=28.05	UNSAT TT=16.758	UNSAT TT=3.158 CHECKS=100466000 NODES=30640	UNSAT TT=3.127 CHECKS=100466000 NODES=30640
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-45_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.48	SAT TT=9.145 CHECKS=27022481 NODES=41041	SAT TT=11.888 CHECKS=34432932 NODES=51927	SAT TT=13.674	SAT TT=5.794	SAT TT=6.159	SAT TT=82.946 NODES=65050	SAT TT=35.722 NODES=37630	SAT TT=30.298 CHECKS=87935 NODES=33151	SAT TT=32.82	SAT TT=153.22 CHECKS=75210888 NODES=48590	SAT TT=168.688 CHECKS=80157313 NODES=51060	SAT TT=242.591 CHECKS=116684821 NODES=77691	SAT TT=17.78	SAT TT=40.5	SAT TT=17.924	SAT TT=297.453 CHECKS=134862115 NODES=90685	SAT TT=281.231 CHECKS=134862115 NODES=90685	SAT TT=62.183	SAT TT=62.809	SAT TT=20.58	SAT TT=14.823	SAT TT=4.48 CHECKS=141895000 NODES=48660	SAT TT=4.484 CHECKS=141895000 NODES=48660
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-47_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.933	UNSAT TT=16.056 CHECKS=47087819 NODES=67896	UNSAT TT=14.222 CHECKS=44751461 NODES=64841	UNSAT TT=11.509	UNSAT TT=10.198	UNSAT TT=10.739	UNSAT TT=89.587 NODES=75003	UNSAT TT=40.847 NODES=42266	UNSAT TT=38.579 CHECKS=88733 NODES=41080	UNSAT TT=38.936	UNSAT TT=230.934 CHECKS=108489982 NODES=68347	UNSAT TT=250.776 CHECKS=122993559 NODES=76274	UNSAT TT=1065.88 CHECKS=493953522 NODES=313138	UNSAT TT=99.26	UNSAT TT=342.791	UNSAT TT=16.937	UNSAT TT=243.215 CHECKS=117884958 NODES=74207	UNSAT TT=238.911 CHECKS=117884958 NODES=74207	UNSAT TT=1065.37	UNSAT TT=1136.74	UNSAT TT=26.2	UNSAT TT=22.103	UNSAT TT=3.933 CHECKS=125565000 NODES=40306	UNSAT TT=3.955 CHECKS=125565000 NODES=40306
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-49_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.553	UNSAT TT=18.522 CHECKS=54333846 NODES=76315	UNSAT TT=16.035 CHECKS=51510094 NODES=72840	UNSAT TT=14.393	UNSAT TT=12.553	UNSAT TT=11.867	UNSAT TT=96.797 NODES=73275	UNSAT TT=36.947 NODES=34449	UNSAT TT=33.817 CHECKS=87778 NODES=35501	UNSAT TT=31.696	UNSAT TT=270.107 CHECKS=124099309 NODES=74225	UNSAT TT=256.927 CHECKS=123013831 NODES=73845	UNSAT TT=1037.69 CHECKS=516222002 NODES=318552	UNSAT TT=49.963	UNSAT TT=340.368	UNSAT TT=16.706	UNSAT TT=285.329 CHECKS=136263442 NODES=84576	UNSAT TT=298.951 CHECKS=136263442 NODES=84576	UNSAT TT=1154.87	UNSAT TT=1134.02	UNSAT TT=26.398	UNSAT TT=19.323	UNSAT TT=4.553 CHECKS=142904000 NODES=44475	UNSAT TT=4.467 CHECKS=142904000 NODES=44475
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-51_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.478	UNSAT TT=15 CHECKS=46929260 NODES=68109	UNSAT TT=15.553 CHECKS=49713897 NODES=71645	UNSAT TT=13.578	UNSAT TT=14.705	UNSAT TT=15.515	UNSAT TT=107.281 NODES=83351	UNSAT TT=36.326 NODES=39960	UNSAT TT=39.502 CHECKS=87388 NODES=45399	UNSAT TT=39.228	UNSAT TT=239.861 CHECKS=112540896 NODES=71367	UNSAT TT=250.932 CHECKS=117284606 NODES=74603	UNSAT TT=1295.79 CHECKS=610811624 NODES=393713	UNSAT TT=73.842	UNSAT TT=353.616	UNSAT TT=18.521	UNSAT TT=293.258 CHECKS=134212124 NODES=86994	UNSAT TT=289.809 CHECKS=134212124 NODES=86994	UNSAT TT=789.437	UNSAT TT=802.056	UNSAT TT=30.86	UNSAT TT=23.295	UNSAT TT=4.478 CHECKS=140409000 NODES=46881	UNSAT TT=4.128 CHECKS=140409000 NODES=46881
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-53_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.044	UNSAT TT=14.006 CHECKS=40042669 NODES=56993	UNSAT TT=12.976 CHECKS=37935454 NODES=54452	UNSAT TT=11.902	UNSAT TT=12.708	UNSAT TT=12.701	UNSAT TT=100.524 NODES=80964	UNSAT TT=31.283 NODES=32189	UNSAT TT=37.162 CHECKS=87567 NODES=40854	UNSAT TT=40.656	UNSAT TT=247.756 CHECKS=114359307 NODES=69222	UNSAT TT=224.954 CHECKS=106529934 NODES=65146	UNSAT TT=1118.85 CHECKS=513885226 NODES=320048	UNSAT TT=79.637	UNSAT TT=265.643	UNSAT TT=16.887	UNSAT TT=256.788 CHECKS=122114495 NODES=75095	UNSAT TT=259.497 CHECKS=122114495 NODES=75095	UNSAT TT=1019.69	UNSAT TT=935.176	UNSAT TT=34.01	UNSAT TT=21.282	UNSAT TT=4.044 CHECKS=128563000 NODES=39795	UNSAT TT=3.975 CHECKS=128563000 NODES=39795
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-55_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.679	UNSAT TT=19.772 CHECKS=64239231 NODES=93012	UNSAT TT=18.658 CHECKS=58982436 NODES=85046	UNSAT TT=11.85	UNSAT TT=14.543	UNSAT TT=14.056	UNSAT TT=109.205 NODES=92172	UNSAT TT=44.681 NODES=41535	UNSAT TT=38.773 CHECKS=89147 NODES=44612	UNSAT TT=43.319	UNSAT TT=293.624 CHECKS=140026039 NODES=86930	UNSAT TT=287.277 CHECKS=139536023 NODES=86730	UNSAT TT=1389.59 CHECKS=629173058 NODES=401891	UNSAT TT=69.73	UNSAT TT=319.55	UNSAT TT=15.252	UNSAT TT=239.559 CHECKS=114519974 NODES=72787	UNSAT TT=245.594 CHECKS=114519974 NODES=72787	UNSAT TT=1303.55	UNSAT TT=1348.91	UNSAT TT=36.71	UNSAT TT=22.905	UNSAT TT=3.679 CHECKS=122438000 NODES=40232	UNSAT TT=3.868 CHECKS=122438000 NODES=40232
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-57_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.628	UNSAT TT=12.183 CHECKS=36617876 NODES=49533	UNSAT TT=8.963 CHECKS=27067175 NODES=37003	UNSAT TT=7.231	UNSAT TT=8.35	UNSAT TT=8.049	UNSAT TT=60.841 NODES=48785	UNSAT TT=23.967 NODES=24799	UNSAT TT=24.486 CHECKS=87873 NODES=27567	UNSAT TT=28.892	UNSAT TT=196.058 CHECKS=88924520 NODES=49685	UNSAT TT=184.307 CHECKS=88590197 NODES=49216	UNSAT TT=803.294 CHECKS=395598715 NODES=226819	UNSAT TT=34.227	UNSAT TT=168.619	UNSAT TT=9.49	UNSAT TT=160.114 CHECKS=78376272 NODES=44440	UNSAT TT=164.704 CHECKS=78376272 NODES=44440	UNSAT TT=462.623	UNSAT TT=477.01	UNSAT TT=18.77	UNSAT TT=13.21	UNSAT TT=2.628 CHECKS=83938600 NODES=23571	UNSAT TT=2.616 CHECKS=83938600 NODES=23571
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-59_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.322	SAT TT=8.468 CHECKS=22878648 NODES=33266	SAT TT=5.216 CHECKS=12995433 NODES=18931	SAT TT=3.782	SAT TT=7.92	SAT TT=8.293	SAT TT=5.766 NODES=4000	SAT TT=20.574 NODES=22189	SAT TT=26.243 CHECKS=87346 NODES=27226	SAT TT=9.142	SAT TT=118.267 CHECKS=52935296 NODES=31665	SAT TT=121.47 CHECKS=55788023 NODES=33159	SAT TT=26.753 CHECKS=12247518 NODES=7503	SAT TT=26.542	SAT TT=18.029	SAT TT=12.24	SAT TT=81.106 CHECKS=39152965 NODES=24543	SAT TT=83.773 CHECKS=39152965 NODES=24543	SAT TT=51.503	SAT TT=55.831	SAT TT=16.73	SAT TT=5.888	SAT TT=1.322 CHECKS=40366900 NODES=12766	SAT TT=1.287 CHECKS=40366900 NODES=12766
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-5_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.326	SAT TT=1.006 CHECKS=30607 NODES=44	SAT TT=0.885 CHECKS=8507 NODES=44	SAT TT=1.086	SAT TT=2.12	SAT TT=2.003	SAT TT=2.381 NODES=1294	SAT TT=23.784 NODES=21895	SAT TT=9.091 CHECKS=87720 NODES=9021	SAT TT=3.449	SAT TT=43.782 CHECKS=18634895 NODES=10054	SAT TT=118.033 CHECKS=52380922 NODES=31610	SAT TT=194.038 CHECKS=97348846 NODES=60544	SAT TT=9.66	SAT TT=27.584	SAT TT=1.881	SAT TT=20.566 CHECKS=8995275 NODES=5652	SAT TT=22.584 CHECKS=8995275 NODES=5652	SAT TT=18.029	SAT TT=20.03	SAT TT=13.5	SAT TT=0.326	SAT TT=0.334 CHECKS=9534270 NODES=2983	SAT TT=0.331 CHECKS=9534270 NODES=2983
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-61_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.138	SAT TT=1.004 CHECKS=136553 NODES=226	SAT TT=1.001 CHECKS=148496 NODES=276	SAT TT=6.022	SAT TT=1.729	SAT TT=1.613	SAT TT=0.978 NODES=280	SAT TT=29.916 NODES=33893	SAT TT=34.999 CHECKS=87576 NODES=38101	SAT TT=0.138	SAT TT=181.172 CHECKS=79741678 NODES=50426	SAT TT=113.165 CHECKS=50729200 NODES=32085	SAT TT=355.848 CHECKS=163977260 NODES=107038	SAT TT=45.503	SAT TT=9.364	SAT TT=5.738	SAT TT=133.066 CHECKS=58626345 NODES=37741	SAT TT=118.01 CHECKS=58626345 NODES=37741	SAT TT=9.669	SAT TT=10.296	SAT TT=8.52	SAT TT=3.885	SAT TT=2.01 CHECKS=63575600 NODES=20535	SAT TT=2.003 CHECKS=63575600 NODES=20535
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-63_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.779	SAT TT=4.622 CHECKS=10640088 NODES=16450	SAT TT=3.403 CHECKS=7974334 NODES=12271	SAT TT=8.106	SAT TT=7.523	SAT TT=7.114	SAT TT=41.558 NODES=32347	SAT TT=42.829 NODES=46071	SAT TT=33.506 CHECKS=88999 NODES=37479	SAT TT=1.779	SAT TT=188.985 CHECKS=86075933 NODES=55166	SAT TT=197.811 CHECKS=88669237 NODES=57343	SAT TT=337.3 CHECKS=159074722 NODES=105237	SAT TT=2.632	SAT TT=314.675	SAT TT=22.669	SAT TT=154.806 CHECKS=72617076 NODES=47165	SAT TT=147.596 CHECKS=72617076 NODES=47165	SAT TT=33.417	SAT TT=32.264	SAT TT=8.98	SAT TT=13.879	SAT TT=2.512 CHECKS=77746200 NODES=25735	SAT TT=2.422 CHECKS=77746200 NODES=25735
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-65_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.572	UNSAT TT=19.502 CHECKS=61884814 NODES=90720	UNSAT TT=20.091 CHECKS=64839331 NODES=94851	UNSAT TT=17.429	UNSAT TT=15.054	UNSAT TT=15.077	UNSAT TT=138.938 NODES=112944	UNSAT TT=58.622 NODES=55274	UNSAT TT=45.854 CHECKS=88562 NODES=52138	UNSAT TT=49.629	UNSAT TT=318.204 CHECKS=147282426 NODES=94092	UNSAT TT=326.363 CHECKS=148940174 NODES=95652	UNSAT TT=1302.22 CHECKS=640027323 NODES=414596	UNSAT TT=119.787	UNSAT TT=623.636	UNSAT TT=21.107	UNSAT TT=329.407 CHECKS=165243468 NODES=106389	UNSAT TT=336.498 CHECKS=165243468 NODES=106389	? (TO) TT=1800.51	? (TO) TT=1800.45	UNSAT TT=41.976	UNSAT TT=25.024	UNSAT TT=5.572 CHECKS=177984000 NODES=58946	UNSAT TT=5.233 CHECKS=177984000 NODES=58946
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-67_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.429	SAT TT=0.967 CHECKS=111750 NODES=179	SAT TT=1.121 CHECKS=520848 NODES=931	SAT TT=5.338	SAT TT=0.429	SAT TT=0.433	SAT TT=1.142 NODES=518	SAT TT=12.576 NODES=13757	SAT TT=14.969 CHECKS=87648 NODES=15499	SAT TT=2.078	SAT TT=76.794 CHECKS=36361774 NODES=22196	SAT TT=46.802 CHECKS=19945750 NODES=11135	SAT TT=39.092 CHECKS=18518201 NODES=11689	SAT TT=4.899	SAT TT=37.28	SAT TT=3.533	SAT TT=131.536 CHECKS=58832319 NODES=37776	SAT TT=139.178 CHECKS=58832319 NODES=37776	SAT TT=11.52	SAT TT=10.957	SAT TT=3.2	SAT TT=4.004	SAT TT=1.909 CHECKS=59719600 NODES=19522	SAT TT=1.91 CHECKS=59719600 NODES=19522
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-69_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.421	UNSAT TT=16.949 CHECKS=49455817 NODES=70676	UNSAT TT=18.161 CHECKS=57642070 NODES=83162	UNSAT TT=13.073	UNSAT TT=12.594	UNSAT TT=11.772	UNSAT TT=98.929 NODES=81675	UNSAT TT=44.735 NODES=41421	UNSAT TT=38.499 CHECKS=87707 NODES=44267	UNSAT TT=36.502	UNSAT TT=248.909 CHECKS=123180882 NODES=75812	UNSAT TT=281.105 CHECKS=128996823 NODES=79143	UNSAT TT=1091.39 CHECKS=517988986 NODES=325114	UNSAT TT=79.393	UNSAT TT=382.472	UNSAT TT=15.095	UNSAT TT=281.732 CHECKS=135697674 NODES=84499	UNSAT TT=282.57 CHECKS=135697674 NODES=84499	UNSAT TT=1331.27	UNSAT TT=1325.03	UNSAT TT=40.604	UNSAT TT=24.967	UNSAT TT=4.421 CHECKS=140475000 NODES=44887	UNSAT TT=4.42 CHECKS=140475000 NODES=44887
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-71_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.456	SAT TT=7.019 CHECKS=18538714 NODES=27155	SAT TT=6.788 CHECKS=17844142 NODES=26390	SAT TT=4.496	SAT TT=8.501	SAT TT=8.092	SAT TT=29.709 NODES=23315	SAT TT=30.49 NODES=30570	SAT TT=26.886 CHECKS=87804 NODES=29082	SAT TT=16.457	SAT TT=119.067 CHECKS=55268469 NODES=33470	SAT TT=92.11 CHECKS=41316126 NODES=24585	SAT TT=101.92 CHECKS=48269510 NODES=28946	SAT TT=34.774	SAT TT=33.894	SAT TT=4.005	SAT TT=94.585 CHECKS=43490391 NODES=27354	SAT TT=94.151 CHECKS=43490391 NODES=27354	SAT TT=28.275	SAT TT=27.982	SAT TT=12.714	SAT TT=14.192	SAT TT=1.456 CHECKS=45746600 NODES=14823	SAT TT=1.466 CHECKS=45746600 NODES=14823
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-73_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.554	UNSAT TT=22.151 CHECKS=66378667 NODES=96464	UNSAT TT=20.744 CHECKS=62444179 NODES=90908	UNSAT TT=13.845	UNSAT TT=15.648	UNSAT TT=15.585	UNSAT TT=143.863 NODES=109183	UNSAT TT=56.829 NODES=53657	UNSAT TT=47.75 CHECKS=88111 NODES=55050	UNSAT TT=52.723	UNSAT TT=348.623 CHECKS=159819036 NODES=102601	UNSAT TT=376.894 CHECKS=171081189 NODES=109365	UNSAT TT=1363.53 CHECKS=637910528 NODES=419961	UNSAT TT=78.749	UNSAT TT=815.802	UNSAT TT=19.192	UNSAT TT=288.912 CHECKS=132084743 NODES=87614	UNSAT TT=282.49 CHECKS=132084743 NODES=87614	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=39.85	UNSAT TT=31.383	UNSAT TT=4.554 CHECKS=142668000 NODES=48345	UNSAT TT=4.528 CHECKS=142668000 NODES=48345
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-75_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.68	SAT TT=1.79 CHECKS=2503459 NODES=3982	SAT TT=1.197 CHECKS=335184 NODES=599	SAT TT=2.013	SAT TT=1.676	SAT TT=1.687	SAT TT=29.47 NODES=23466	SAT TT=11.336 NODES=11809	SAT TT=14.54 CHECKS=88117 NODES=16106	SAT TT=5.086	SAT TT=46.007 CHECKS=19747513 NODES=10900	SAT TT=67.135 CHECKS=28749582 NODES=16267	SAT TT=6.812 CHECKS=2843134 NODES=1654	SAT TT=10.618	SAT TT=9.979	SAT TT=2.028	SAT TT=42.087 CHECKS=18745124 NODES=12137	SAT TT=39.199 CHECKS=18745124 NODES=12137	SAT TT=20.406	SAT TT=19.44	SAT TT=2.19	SAT TT=3.74	SAT TT=0.68 CHECKS=20299700 NODES=6717	SAT TT=0.673 CHECKS=20299700 NODES=6717
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-77_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.976	SAT TT=1.021 CHECKS=234543 NODES=394	SAT TT=0.976 CHECKS=111708 NODES=205	SAT TT=5.646	SAT TT=5.709	SAT TT=5.407	SAT TT=2.387 NODES=1402	SAT TT=4.678 NODES=4263	SAT TT=4.6 CHECKS=85987 NODES=4327	SAT TT=5.939	SAT TT=88.755 CHECKS=40153379 NODES=25394	SAT TT=158.885 CHECKS=72949958 NODES=45670	SAT TT=38.715 CHECKS=18540719 NODES=12375	SAT TT=12.733	SAT TT=41.688	SAT TT=1.763	SAT TT=105.282 CHECKS=47775131 NODES=31917	SAT TT=108.807 CHECKS=47775131 NODES=31917	SAT TT=5.651	SAT TT=6.036	SAT TT=3.25	SAT TT=1.119	SAT TT=1.651 CHECKS=51669200 NODES=17645	SAT TT=1.648 CHECKS=51669200 NODES=17645
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-79_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.159	UNSAT TT=20.509 CHECKS=62714728 NODES=93104	UNSAT TT=18.537 CHECKS=59649688 NODES=88099	UNSAT TT=12.808	UNSAT TT=15.227	UNSAT TT=14.331	UNSAT TT=96.905 NODES=84189	UNSAT TT=44.089 NODES=45565	UNSAT TT=43.207 CHECKS=87435 NODES=47351	UNSAT TT=41.816	UNSAT TT=269.391 CHECKS=122501594 NODES=79048	UNSAT TT=279.871 CHECKS=127105628 NODES=81709	UNSAT TT=1366.57 CHECKS=630492197 NODES=415063	UNSAT TT=96.24	UNSAT TT=428.038	UNSAT TT=16.077	UNSAT TT=277.353 CHECKS=125209595 NODES=82715	UNSAT TT=257.368 CHECKS=125209595 NODES=82715	UNSAT TT=1338.17	UNSAT TT=1381.14	UNSAT TT=29.088	UNSAT TT=24.176	UNSAT TT=4.159 CHECKS=129102000 NODES=43346	UNSAT TT=4.066 CHECKS=129102000 NODES=43346
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-7_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.989	SAT TT=1.005 CHECKS=143303 NODES=225	SAT TT=1.055 CHECKS=158982 NODES=295	SAT TT=2.258	SAT TT=9.214	SAT TT=9.428	SAT TT=1.982 NODES=961	SAT TT=24.745 NODES=25409	SAT TT=22.071 CHECKS=87662 NODES=24482	SAT TT=5.929	SAT TT=112.529 CHECKS=49290625 NODES=28983	SAT TT=91.779 CHECKS=40329746 NODES=24066	SAT TT=84.464 CHECKS=42362893 NODES=25602	SAT TT=16.476	SAT TT=22.87	SAT TT=9.61	SAT TT=66.203 CHECKS=29338666 NODES=18098	SAT TT=66.402 CHECKS=29338666 NODES=18098	SAT TT=34.997	SAT TT=37.784	SAT TT=10.384	SAT TT=5.826	SAT TT=0.989 CHECKS=32646900 NODES=10430	SAT TT=1.043 CHECKS=32646900 NODES=10430
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.1/ rand-2-40-8-753-100-9_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.172	UNSAT TT=14.978 CHECKS=43032439 NODES=61962	UNSAT TT=16.489 CHECKS=49561999 NODES=71499	UNSAT TT=14.378	UNSAT TT=11.217	UNSAT TT=11.842	UNSAT TT=75.004 NODES=62914	UNSAT TT=31.345 NODES=32153	UNSAT TT=28.394 CHECKS=87381 NODES=31734	UNSAT TT=31.473	UNSAT TT=291.356 CHECKS=132119131 NODES=80579	UNSAT TT=262.091 CHECKS=120966417 NODES=74118	UNSAT TT=1046.39 CHECKS=506238953 NODES=313856	UNSAT TT=68.895	UNSAT TT=235.735	UNSAT TT=12.816	UNSAT TT=267.083 CHECKS=124387458 NODES=78832	UNSAT TT=255.134 CHECKS=124387458 NODES=78832	UNSAT TT=622.556	UNSAT TT=596.026	UNSAT TT=24.32	UNSAT TT=21.547	UNSAT TT=4.172 CHECKS=129946000 NODES=41798	UNSAT TT=4.069 CHECKS=129946000 NODES=41798
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-11_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.883	UNSAT TT=18.724 CHECKS=85002721 NODES=94340	UNSAT TT=20.029 CHECKS=90492051 NODES=100119	UNSAT TT=13.642	UNSAT TT=11.346	UNSAT TT=12.057	UNSAT TT=96.411 NODES=124449	UNSAT TT=47.578 NODES=64081	UNSAT TT=44.713 CHECKS=82256 NODES=63573	UNSAT TT=93.629	UNSAT TT=314.948 CHECKS=152306784 NODES=106322	UNSAT TT=317.311 CHECKS=150747281 NODES=105189	UNSAT TT=1531.94 CHECKS=722846137 NODES=497110	UNSAT TT=163.272	UNSAT TT=555.635	UNSAT TT=18.119	UNSAT TT=275.54 CHECKS=140106507 NODES=98201	UNSAT TT=271.735 CHECKS=140106507 NODES=98201	UNSAT TT=1457.94	UNSAT TT=1414.66	UNSAT TT=61.13	UNSAT TT=27.308	UNSAT TT=4.883 CHECKS=150237000 NODES=47887	UNSAT TT=4.879 CHECKS=150237000 NODES=47887
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-13_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.857	UNSAT TT=26.381 CHECKS=118299738 NODES=139620	UNSAT TT=21.595 CHECKS=95688881 NODES=114625	UNSAT TT=23.619	UNSAT TT=14.574	UNSAT TT=14.271	UNSAT TT=128.895 NODES=165248	UNSAT TT=61.508 NODES=83763	UNSAT TT=54.509 CHECKS=80966 NODES=82779	UNSAT TT=165.871	UNSAT TT=438.926 CHECKS=209318830 NODES=155741	UNSAT TT=358.122 CHECKS=177687747 NODES=133138	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=402.157	UNSAT TT=657.051	UNSAT TT=22.436	UNSAT TT=377.656 CHECKS=190920001 NODES=141398	UNSAT TT=373.31 CHECKS=190920001 NODES=141398	UNSAT TT=1584.1	UNSAT TT=1647.8	UNSAT TT=77.74	UNSAT TT=38.425	UNSAT TT=5.857 CHECKS=177731000 NODES=61668	UNSAT TT=5.804 CHECKS=177731000 NODES=61668
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-15_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.78	SAT TT=2.227 CHECKS=5558368 NODES=6930	SAT TT=8.348 CHECKS=36192020 NODES=44785	SAT TT=5.966	SAT TT=9.909	SAT TT=10.278	SAT TT=16.986 NODES=21430	SAT TT=56.733 NODES=83856	SAT TT=56.171 CHECKS=82630 NODES=84982	SAT TT=113.545	SAT TT=145.908 CHECKS=68785901 NODES=49607	SAT TT=134.471 CHECKS=62759925 NODES=45228	SAT TT=288.27 CHECKS=141332705 NODES=102657	SAT TT=6.154	SAT TT=779.164	SAT TT=26.614	SAT TT=110.669 CHECKS=55688989 NODES=40984	SAT TT=110.247 CHECKS=55688989 NODES=40984	SAT TT=955.296	SAT TT=974.468	SAT TT=78.488	SAT TT=34.523	SAT TT=1.78 CHECKS=52887200 NODES=17929	SAT TT=1.762 CHECKS=52887200 NODES=17929
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.433	SAT TT=2.995 CHECKS=9442209 NODES=11503	SAT TT=12.259 CHECKS=57025230 NODES=67784	SAT TT=0.433	SAT TT=3.775	SAT TT=4.018	SAT TT=43.47 NODES=59645	SAT TT=11.392 NODES=15375	SAT TT=10.89 CHECKS=81288 NODES=15273	SAT TT=112.419	SAT TT=42.884 CHECKS=21404670 NODES=15450	SAT TT=23.315 CHECKS=11049274 NODES=7553	SAT TT=844.186 CHECKS=413391507 NODES=296153	SAT TT=65.359	SAT TT=185.946	SAT TT=0.73	SAT TT=8.941 CHECKS=4592674 NODES=3414	SAT TT=8.924 CHECKS=4592674 NODES=3414	SAT TT=93.193	SAT TT=96.432	SAT TT=10.49	SAT TT=27.433	SAT TT=0.591 CHECKS=16897800 NODES=5764	SAT TT=0.585 CHECKS=16897800 NODES=5764
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-19_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.355	UNSAT TT=15.42 CHECKS=74856158 NODES=78955	UNSAT TT=15.757 CHECKS=71066726 NODES=75176	UNSAT TT=8.478	UNSAT TT=9.961	UNSAT TT=9.729	UNSAT TT=62.357 NODES=84183	UNSAT TT=32.071 NODES=43085	UNSAT TT=32.265 CHECKS=81961 NODES=43583	UNSAT TT=81.04	UNSAT TT=268.454 CHECKS=126609746 NODES=82007	UNSAT TT=258.993 CHECKS=122844273 NODES=80085	UNSAT TT=1211.55 CHECKS=589162317 NODES=384065	UNSAT TT=125.641	UNSAT TT=346.71	UNSAT TT=13.281	UNSAT TT=216.31 CHECKS=104251866 NODES=69497	UNSAT TT=217.862 CHECKS=104251866 NODES=69497	UNSAT TT=908.828	UNSAT TT=936.231	UNSAT TT=50.092	UNSAT TT=16.406	UNSAT TT=3.355 CHECKS=104449000 NODES=30848	UNSAT TT=3.381 CHECKS=104449000 NODES=30848
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-1_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.837	UNSAT TT=15.312 CHECKS=67055664 NODES=73735	UNSAT TT=13.831 CHECKS=61283040 NODES=67840	UNSAT TT=10.86	UNSAT TT=11.036	UNSAT TT=11.16	UNSAT TT=64.948 NODES=79221	UNSAT TT=31.417 NODES=43148	UNSAT TT=32.523 CHECKS=80515 NODES=43733	UNSAT TT=73.916	UNSAT TT=208.232 CHECKS=107955859 NODES=71780	UNSAT TT=229.248 CHECKS=108079234 NODES=71904	UNSAT TT=1193.6 CHECKS=586385485 NODES=382435	UNSAT TT=101.232	UNSAT TT=230.06	UNSAT TT=15.391	UNSAT TT=230.443 CHECKS=116494192 NODES=76829	UNSAT TT=243.746 CHECKS=116494192 NODES=76829	UNSAT TT=596.907	UNSAT TT=569.828	UNSAT TT=35.479	UNSAT TT=23.523	UNSAT TT=3.837 CHECKS=120192000 NODES=35364	UNSAT TT=3.868 CHECKS=120192000 NODES=35364
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.386	SAT TT=4.299 CHECKS=15883831 NODES=19970	SAT TT=4.548 CHECKS=15696716 NODES=20109	SAT TT=1.441	SAT TT=2.135	SAT TT=2.278	SAT TT=14.066 NODES=17862	SAT TT=31.493 NODES=46088	SAT TT=33.247 CHECKS=81232 NODES=50012	SAT TT=0.386	SAT TT=219.509 CHECKS=103435152 NODES=80144	SAT TT=208.897 CHECKS=97484901 NODES=76562	SAT TT=698.897 CHECKS=356722734 NODES=272847	SAT TT=62.707	SAT TT=632.374	SAT TT=0.87	SAT TT=29.816 CHECKS=13953083 NODES=11205	SAT TT=29.635 CHECKS=13953083 NODES=11205	SAT TT=490.991	SAT TT=487.752	SAT TT=2.733	SAT TT=1.808	SAT TT=0.528 CHECKS=14865800 NODES=5348	SAT TT=0.525 CHECKS=14865800 NODES=5348
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.391	SAT TT=3.397 CHECKS=10868740 NODES=13347	SAT TT=1.337 CHECKS=1480419 NODES=1892	SAT TT=0.953	SAT TT=3.211	SAT TT=3.413	SAT TT=10.501 NODES=13052	SAT TT=22.233 NODES=30796	SAT TT=45.356 CHECKS=81017 NODES=66851	SAT TT=13.904	SAT TT=43.6 CHECKS=21171401 NODES=16344	SAT TT=59.117 CHECKS=27064644 NODES=20464	SAT TT=92.854 CHECKS=45835265 NODES=33637	SAT TT=3.852	SAT TT=5.668	SAT TT=1.363	SAT TT=20.83 CHECKS=9954770 NODES=7927	SAT TT=20.967 CHECKS=9954770 NODES=7927	SAT TT=216.737	SAT TT=212.967	SAT TT=53.36	SAT TT=8.239	SAT TT=0.391 CHECKS=11427300 NODES=4282	SAT TT=0.415 CHECKS=11427300 NODES=4282
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-25_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.076	UNSAT TT=22.048 CHECKS=98139088 NODES=111832	UNSAT TT=23.991 CHECKS=116552605 NODES=132635	UNSAT TT=14.653	UNSAT TT=11.931	UNSAT TT=11.899	UNSAT TT=105.121 NODES=130479	UNSAT TT=48.489 NODES=69213	UNSAT TT=53.755 CHECKS=81068 NODES=73314	UNSAT TT=141.615	UNSAT TT=327.166 CHECKS=169594711 NODES=120606	UNSAT TT=386.094 CHECKS=180696611 NODES=127464	UNSAT TT=1711.29 CHECKS=914865504 NODES=640080	UNSAT TT=170.286	UNSAT TT=656.156	UNSAT TT=21.541	UNSAT TT=349.038 CHECKS=165213616 NODES=118191	UNSAT TT=333.405 CHECKS=165213616 NODES=118191	UNSAT TT=1753.78	UNSAT TT=1685.57	UNSAT TT=79.1	UNSAT TT=31.44	UNSAT TT=5.076 CHECKS=163380000 NODES=52293	UNSAT TT=5.306 CHECKS=163380000 NODES=52293
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-27_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.886	SAT TT=1.518 CHECKS=2468984 NODES=2907	SAT TT=0.888 CHECKS=197786 NODES=269	SAT TT=4.792	SAT TT=1.687	SAT TT=1.703	SAT TT=2.023 NODES=1856	SAT TT=2.906 NODES=2981	SAT TT=8.015 CHECKS=80941 NODES=9872	SAT TT=11.27	SAT TT=78.356 CHECKS=38147700 NODES=25063	SAT TT=82.116 CHECKS=38142616 NODES=25082	SAT TT=71.954 CHECKS=35076245 NODES=23223	SAT TT=15.569	SAT TT=16.92	SAT TT=6.73	SAT TT=92.188 CHECKS=42814146 NODES=30235	SAT TT=85.246 CHECKS=42814146 NODES=30235	SAT TT=23.733	SAT TT=22.094	SAT TT=2.38	SAT TT=0.886	SAT TT=1.034 CHECKS=30888100 NODES=9332	SAT TT=1.034 CHECKS=30888100 NODES=9332
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-29_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=6.293	UNSAT TT=25.847 CHECKS=116912029 NODES=136384	UNSAT TT=25.532 CHECKS=122949712 NODES=142602	UNSAT TT=17.836	UNSAT TT=13.616	UNSAT TT=12.805	UNSAT TT=145.293 NODES=186727	UNSAT TT=55.86 NODES=80779	UNSAT TT=55.677 CHECKS=81149 NODES=82616	UNSAT TT=157.403	UNSAT TT=402.302 CHECKS=209983675 NODES=148949	UNSAT TT=391.933 CHECKS=201398853 NODES=144891	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=195.403	UNSAT TT=695.57	UNSAT TT=22.844	UNSAT TT=414.756 CHECKS=197148766 NODES=142828	UNSAT TT=399.145 CHECKS=197148766 NODES=142828	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=84.821	UNSAT TT=31.651	UNSAT TT=6.293 CHECKS=190138000 NODES=64330	UNSAT TT=6.209 CHECKS=190138000 NODES=64330
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-31_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.594	SAT TT=9.548 CHECKS=38958195 NODES=48559	SAT TT=2.497 CHECKS=6634443 NODES=8612	SAT TT=1.594	SAT TT=7.973	SAT TT=8.545	SAT TT=18.438 NODES=23690	SAT TT=21.602 NODES=28944	SAT TT=31.015 CHECKS=80946 NODES=42649	SAT TT=24.469	SAT TT=68.794 CHECKS=35291044 NODES=27185	SAT TT=79.729 CHECKS=39122266 NODES=29481	SAT TT=79.573 CHECKS=39097007 NODES=28892	SAT TT=17.281	SAT TT=28.483	SAT TT=7.741	SAT TT=36.939 CHECKS=17165586 NODES=12976	SAT TT=37.317 CHECKS=17165586 NODES=12976	SAT TT=248.898	SAT TT=238.748	SAT TT=78.35	SAT TT=12.076	SAT TT=1.944 CHECKS=57649100 NODES=20925	SAT TT=1.945 CHECKS=57649100 NODES=20925
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-33_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.182	SAT TT=1.182 CHECKS=958727 NODES=1281	SAT TT=1.718 CHECKS=3759819 NODES=4644	SAT TT=3.468	SAT TT=3.098	SAT TT=3.08	SAT TT=32.04 NODES=40769	SAT TT=25.454 NODES=36753	SAT TT=22.136 CHECKS=80935 NODES=30902	SAT TT=127.567	SAT TT=82.463 CHECKS=38828328 NODES=27941	SAT TT=108.425 CHECKS=48639430 NODES=37262	SAT TT=151.639 CHECKS=75678803 NODES=56666	SAT TT=51.132	SAT TT=181.879	SAT TT=4.07	SAT TT=74.73 CHECKS=35124937 NODES=28007	SAT TT=75.593 CHECKS=35124937 NODES=28007	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=34.315	SAT TT=8.384	SAT TT=1.22 CHECKS=35724200 NODES=12947	SAT TT=1.136 CHECKS=35724200 NODES=12947
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-35_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.912	SAT TT=2.345 CHECKS=5908051 NODES=7496	SAT TT=1.912 CHECKS=4595157 NODES=5792	SAT TT=7.181	SAT TT=5.351	SAT TT=5.398	SAT TT=10.632 NODES=14078	SAT TT=36.957 NODES=57153	SAT TT=71.238 CHECKS=82451 NODES=104685	SAT TT=140.308	SAT TT=432.106 CHECKS=220382994 NODES=166044	SAT TT=143.765 CHECKS=66209043 NODES=48697	SAT TT=805.339 CHECKS=380805971 NODES=284159	SAT TT=327.171	SAT TT=1002.68	SAT TT=10.744	SAT TT=161.28 CHECKS=73688891 NODES=57016	SAT TT=147.786 CHECKS=73688891 NODES=57016	SAT TT=90.951	SAT TT=92.715	SAT TT=144.04	SAT TT=23.923	SAT TT=2.99 CHECKS=89861500 NODES=30672	SAT TT=2.981 CHECKS=89861500 NODES=30672
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-37_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=6.638	UNSAT TT=27.826 CHECKS=125183192 NODES=145941	UNSAT TT=25.436 CHECKS=113011273 NODES=133319	UNSAT TT=27.667	UNSAT TT=15.079	UNSAT TT=15.127	UNSAT TT=113.282 NODES=154556	UNSAT TT=67.902 NODES=90956	UNSAT TT=63.028 CHECKS=80862 NODES=95145	UNSAT TT=163.277	UNSAT TT=366.812 CHECKS=180013041 NODES=132399	UNSAT TT=348.899 CHECKS=176029929 NODES=129896	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=278.981	UNSAT TT=879.314	UNSAT TT=24.506	UNSAT TT=430.846 CHECKS=203634517 NODES=148146	UNSAT TT=405.774 CHECKS=203634517 NODES=148146	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=76.07	UNSAT TT=30.712	UNSAT TT=6.638 CHECKS=204800000 NODES=68718	UNSAT TT=6.682 CHECKS=204800000 NODES=68718
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-39_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=6.687	UNSAT TT=29.431 CHECKS=131525064 NODES=153353	UNSAT TT=28.099 CHECKS=126645932 NODES=147623	UNSAT TT=19.346	UNSAT TT=17.432	UNSAT TT=17.356	UNSAT TT=147.624 NODES=186882	UNSAT TT=53.356 NODES=77566	UNSAT TT=56.391 CHECKS=82004 NODES=82439	UNSAT TT=177.103	UNSAT TT=448.095 CHECKS=211895455 NODES=156726	UNSAT TT=425.736 CHECKS=211308786 NODES=156258	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=286.211	UNSAT TT=844.687	UNSAT TT=25.449	UNSAT TT=412.984 CHECKS=206892825 NODES=153810	UNSAT TT=426.695 CHECKS=206892825 NODES=153810	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.14	UNSAT TT=76.933	UNSAT TT=40.902	UNSAT TT=6.687 CHECKS=203180000 NODES=68757	UNSAT TT=6.667 CHECKS=203180000 NODES=68757
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-3_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.378	UNSAT TT=15.529 CHECKS=73376228 NODES=84279	UNSAT TT=16.469 CHECKS=72740185 NODES=83423	UNSAT TT=14.095	UNSAT TT=10.502	UNSAT TT=9.86	UNSAT TT=84.874 NODES=107424	UNSAT TT=40.544 NODES=61989	UNSAT TT=44.615 CHECKS=80402 NODES=61176	UNSAT TT=72.473	UNSAT TT=283.225 CHECKS=142289183 NODES=101549	UNSAT TT=274.737 CHECKS=136527556 NODES=96306	UNSAT TT=1537.25 CHECKS=698976873 NODES=498345	UNSAT TT=113.37	UNSAT TT=346.789	UNSAT TT=17.202	UNSAT TT=276.813 CHECKS=135781514 NODES=96921	UNSAT TT=274.236 CHECKS=135781514 NODES=96921	UNSAT TT=790.827	UNSAT TT=773.511	UNSAT TT=46.05	UNSAT TT=26.078	UNSAT TT=4.378 CHECKS=133138000 NODES=43297	UNSAT TT=4.342 CHECKS=133138000 NODES=43297
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-41_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.677	UNSAT TT=17.886 CHECKS=86051241 NODES=94931	UNSAT TT=20.992 CHECKS=96555340 NODES=105048	UNSAT TT=16.453	UNSAT TT=10.522	UNSAT TT=10.475	UNSAT TT=92.142 NODES=128275	UNSAT TT=42.152 NODES=63369	UNSAT TT=48.585 CHECKS=81832 NODES=70496	UNSAT TT=96.367	UNSAT TT=288.044 CHECKS=150421048 NODES=101017	UNSAT TT=283.477 CHECKS=144599868 NODES=96569	UNSAT TT=1549.43 CHECKS=720730847 NODES=489668	UNSAT TT=112.615	UNSAT TT=509.704	UNSAT TT=20.028	UNSAT TT=283.35 CHECKS=143365376 NODES=97133	UNSAT TT=287.11 CHECKS=143365376 NODES=97133	UNSAT TT=1260.9	UNSAT TT=1315.06	UNSAT TT=50.47	UNSAT TT=27.883	UNSAT TT=4.677 CHECKS=143788000 NODES=44319	UNSAT TT=4.595 CHECKS=143788000 NODES=44319
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-43_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.817	SAT TT=6.655 CHECKS=26229040 NODES=30989	SAT TT=0.817 CHECKS=13463 NODES=44	SAT TT=4.83	SAT TT=3.948	SAT TT=4.005	SAT TT=0.648 NODES=70	SAT TT=31.573 NODES=44382	SAT TT=44.281 CHECKS=81581 NODES=62196	SAT TT=66.03	SAT TT=226.424 CHECKS=109670889 NODES=78414	SAT TT=221.438 CHECKS=105433466 NODES=75745	SAT TT=953.177 CHECKS=484912187 NODES=347149	SAT TT=7.187	SAT TT=115.616	SAT TT=4.937	SAT TT=127.762 CHECKS=60931144 NODES=45614	SAT TT=127.269 CHECKS=60931144 NODES=45614	SAT TT=11.762	SAT TT=11.901	SAT TT=18.7	SAT TT=5.74	SAT TT=2.077 CHECKS=62213100 NODES=21913	SAT TT=2.075 CHECKS=62213100 NODES=21913
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-45_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.46	UNSAT TT=13.432 CHECKS=64342223 NODES=68681	UNSAT TT=14.374 CHECKS=63094242 NODES=67875	UNSAT TT=12.526	UNSAT TT=8.521	UNSAT TT=8.241	UNSAT TT=66.188 NODES=82874	UNSAT TT=31.1 NODES=42706	UNSAT TT=33.257 CHECKS=81958 NODES=46354	UNSAT TT=95.317	UNSAT TT=255.809 CHECKS=120851990 NODES=79036	UNSAT TT=242.157 CHECKS=118587487 NODES=77355	UNSAT TT=1162.72 CHECKS=570590246 NODES=374687	UNSAT TT=83.083	UNSAT TT=329.422	UNSAT TT=14.037	UNSAT TT=221.132 CHECKS=107841718 NODES=72854	UNSAT TT=229.061 CHECKS=107841718 NODES=72854	UNSAT TT=921.549	UNSAT TT=887.599	UNSAT TT=63.443	UNSAT TT=19.677	UNSAT TT=3.46 CHECKS=106392000 NODES=31350	UNSAT TT=3.388 CHECKS=106392000 NODES=31350
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-47_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.628	UNSAT TT=19.717 CHECKS=87307138 NODES=98768	UNSAT TT=18.573 CHECKS=87809517 NODES=98693	UNSAT TT=11.73	UNSAT TT=10.458	UNSAT TT=10.466	UNSAT TT=95.62 NODES=120391	UNSAT TT=42.956 NODES=61134	UNSAT TT=38.716 CHECKS=82796 NODES=57269	UNSAT TT=79.915	UNSAT TT=291.111 CHECKS=150669110 NODES=103245	UNSAT TT=297.874 CHECKS=148898531 NODES=101902	UNSAT TT=1438.03 CHECKS=709361143 NODES=491275	UNSAT TT=158.406	UNSAT TT=402.046	UNSAT TT=22.692	UNSAT TT=290.889 CHECKS=139532326 NODES=98746	UNSAT TT=292.53 CHECKS=139532326 NODES=98746	UNSAT TT=1062.74	UNSAT TT=1109.7	UNSAT TT=50.49	UNSAT TT=26.879	UNSAT TT=4.628 CHECKS=143346000 NODES=45300	UNSAT TT=4.62 CHECKS=143346000 NODES=45300
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-49_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.081	SAT TT=3.137 CHECKS=10842254 NODES=13120	SAT TT=2.265 CHECKS=5405356 NODES=6741	SAT TT=0.357	SAT TT=5.611	SAT TT=5.67	SAT TT=2.555 NODES=2655	SAT TT=43.409 NODES=60930	SAT TT=42.562 CHECKS=81794 NODES=58876	SAT TT=119.476	SAT TT=33.754 CHECKS=14962845 NODES=10188	SAT TT=47.756 CHECKS=21054615 NODES=15220	SAT TT=0.366 CHECKS=141003 NODES=123	SAT TT=78.777	SAT TT=27.48	SAT TT=0.081	SAT TT=0.375 CHECKS=141003 NODES=123	SAT TT=0.374 CHECKS=141003 NODES=123	SAT TT=22.946	SAT TT=23.645	SAT TT=6.959	SAT TT=3.365	SAT TT=0.503 CHECKS=14113800 NODES=5103	SAT TT=0.509 CHECKS=14113800 NODES=5103
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-51_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.22	SAT TT=3.447 CHECKS=11963223 NODES=13896	SAT TT=2.22 CHECKS=6232929 NODES=7239	SAT TT=9.24	SAT TT=6.391	SAT TT=6.326	SAT TT=11.357 NODES=13657	SAT TT=28.055 NODES=42264	SAT TT=7.415 CHECKS=80555 NODES=9235	SAT TT=121.136	SAT TT=286.387 CHECKS=145358175 NODES=99992	SAT TT=290.311 CHECKS=146073437 NODES=101203	SAT TT=333.263 CHECKS=176529161 NODES=119410	SAT TT=23.01	SAT TT=380.221	SAT TT=4.082	SAT TT=210.074 CHECKS=99975075 NODES=69175	SAT TT=207.831 CHECKS=99975075 NODES=69175	SAT TT=1165.68	SAT TT=1160.26	SAT TT=21.643	SAT TT=11.934	SAT TT=3.285 CHECKS=101245000 NODES=31050	SAT TT=3.289 CHECKS=101245000 NODES=31050
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-53_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.567	SAT TT=5.109 CHECKS=18525061 NODES=22656	SAT TT=7.565 CHECKS=31233335 NODES=38360	SAT TT=14.276	SAT TT=13.487	SAT TT=12.676	SAT TT=17.462 NODES=21928	SAT TT=51.821 NODES=80282	SAT TT=41.112 CHECKS=81764 NODES=60303	SAT TT=81.21	SAT TT=315.667 CHECKS=162503426 NODES=121289	SAT TT=106.102 CHECKS=48657958 NODES=37356	SAT TT=988.11 CHECKS=464504444 NODES=347235	SAT TT=164.193	SAT TT=486.797	SAT TT=19.787	SAT TT=306.954 CHECKS=146683287 NODES=109974	SAT TT=286.357 CHECKS=146683287 NODES=109974	SAT TT=14.067	SAT TT=13.975	SAT TT=21.023	SAT TT=19.956	SAT TT=4.567 CHECKS=138156000 NODES=48102	SAT TT=4.534 CHECKS=138156000 NODES=48102
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-55_ext.xml	SAT TT=3.223	SAT TT=8.856 CHECKS=40107791 NODES=44888	SAT TT=9.973 CHECKS=45310853 NODES=50563	SAT TT=9.04	SAT TT=6.018	SAT TT=5.685	SAT TT=31.985 NODES=39909	SAT TT=22.673 NODES=28648	SAT TT=23.179 CHECKS=80976 NODES=31130	SAT TT=73.557	SAT TT=209.954 CHECKS=102492280 NODES=67505	SAT TT=217.876 CHECKS=102815320 NODES=68162	SAT TT=2.928 CHECKS=1527755 NODES=931	SAT TT=37.576	SAT TT=97.17	SAT TT=10.28	SAT TT=200.777 CHECKS=96092043 NODES=64069	SAT TT=202.772 CHECKS=96092043 NODES=64069	SAT TT=83.699	SAT TT=80.229	SAT TT=6.02	SAT TT=15.346	SAT TT=3.223 CHECKS=98006800 NODES=29468	SAT TT=3.16 CHECKS=98006800 NODES=29468
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-57_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.449	SAT TT=18.615 CHECKS=83206082 NODES=100428	SAT TT=15.654 CHECKS=71992196 NODES=85757	SAT TT=1.094	SAT TT=4.084	SAT TT=3.826	SAT TT=59.044 NODES=82262	SAT TT=69.121 NODES=104588	SAT TT=17.026 CHECKS=80879 NODES=23230	SAT TT=11.717	SAT TT=300.724 CHECKS=146075396 NODES=111556	SAT TT=287.56 CHECKS=142040000 NODES=109728	SAT TT=196.52 CHECKS=102373340 NODES=77445	SAT TT=13.148	SAT TT=82.967	SAT TT=2.256	SAT TT=20.866 CHECKS=10361205 NODES=7978	SAT TT=20.754 CHECKS=10361205 NODES=7978	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.15	SAT TT=45.115	SAT TT=6.62	SAT TT=0.449 CHECKS=12514000 NODES=4230	SAT TT=0.447 CHECKS=12514000 NODES=4230
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-59_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.839	SAT TT=5.231 CHECKS=20945818 NODES=25725	SAT TT=1.477 CHECKS=2446611 NODES=3061	SAT TT=5.141	SAT TT=15.819	SAT TT=15.825	SAT TT=24.294 NODES=31192	SAT TT=74.485 NODES=111453	SAT TT=70.614 CHECKS=81435 NODES=107898	SAT TT=212.987	SAT TT=167.973 CHECKS=78906419 NODES=62744	SAT TT=160.8 CHECKS=79535648 NODES=62999	SAT TT=267.869 CHECKS=139302472 NODES=108322	SAT TT=12.261	SAT TT=142.386	SAT TT=16.339	SAT TT=122.117 CHECKS=56598179 NODES=44591	SAT TT=113.131 CHECKS=56598179 NODES=44591	SAT TT=798.868	SAT TT=770.02	SAT TT=34.009	SAT TT=40.799	SAT TT=0.839 CHECKS=24367100 NODES=8532	SAT TT=0.831 CHECKS=24367100 NODES=8532
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-5_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.716	UNSAT TT=27.083 CHECKS=121807645 NODES=135602	UNSAT TT=24.072 CHECKS=108724630 NODES=121293	UNSAT TT=15.174	UNSAT TT=12.394	UNSAT TT=12.415	UNSAT TT=122.434 NODES=163910	UNSAT TT=48.955 NODES=69844	UNSAT TT=54.621 CHECKS=80929 NODES=75318	UNSAT TT=175.184	UNSAT TT=337.289 CHECKS=173000510 NODES=122118	UNSAT TT=363.117 CHECKS=179425860 NODES=127408	UNSAT TT=1767.08 CHECKS=891136337 NODES=624511	UNSAT TT=343.92	UNSAT TT=866.227	UNSAT TT=22.181	UNSAT TT=360.469 CHECKS=179601835 NODES=130125	UNSAT TT=361.903 CHECKS=179601835 NODES=130125	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=91.397	UNSAT TT=31.473	UNSAT TT=5.716 CHECKS=175555000 NODES=57903	UNSAT TT=5.766 CHECKS=175555000 NODES=57903
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-61_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.513	SAT TT=1.547 CHECKS=2614362 NODES=3139	SAT TT=1.513 CHECKS=2525014 NODES=2963	SAT TT=13.763	SAT TT=5.565	SAT TT=5.944	SAT TT=1.706 NODES=1429	SAT TT=13.713 NODES=18830	SAT TT=21.453 CHECKS=81476 NODES=28694	SAT TT=35.68	SAT TT=283.452 CHECKS=144392592 NODES=105310	SAT TT=182.395 CHECKS=90976250 NODES=66678	SAT TT=106.822 CHECKS=51367741 NODES=36878	SAT TT=68.673	SAT TT=2.546	SAT TT=7.612	SAT TT=302.813 CHECKS=139190367 NODES=102091	SAT TT=299.151 CHECKS=139190367 NODES=102091	SAT TT=444.13	SAT TT=430.002	SAT TT=9.622	SAT TT=19.055	SAT TT=4.525 CHECKS=137326000 NODES=46175	SAT TT=4.164 CHECKS=137326000 NODES=46175
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-63_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.194	SAT TT=1.671 CHECKS=2901084 NODES=3508	SAT TT=1.56 CHECKS=3026777 NODES=3868	SAT TT=3.725	SAT TT=5.464	SAT TT=5.833	SAT TT=4.588 NODES=5204	SAT TT=16.783 NODES=23316	SAT TT=25.921 CHECKS=83292 NODES=35492	SAT TT=19.242	SAT TT=95.84 CHECKS=46954196 NODES=35373	SAT TT=101.057 CHECKS=46271768 NODES=34660	SAT TT=101.856 CHECKS=52893842 NODES=37922	SAT TT=3.584	SAT TT=20.355	SAT TT=3.676	SAT TT=77.266 CHECKS=38814014 NODES=30016	SAT TT=79.855 CHECKS=38814014 NODES=30016	SAT TT=2.937	SAT TT=3.914	SAT TT=22.82	SAT TT=1.194	SAT TT=1.385 CHECKS=40704100 NODES=14359	SAT TT=1.403 CHECKS=40704100 NODES=14359
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-65_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.083	SAT TT=2.192 CHECKS=5819640 NODES=6371	SAT TT=1.083 CHECKS=1022222 NODES=1187	SAT TT=7.076	SAT TT=3.069	SAT TT=3.081	SAT TT=0.732 NODES=183	SAT TT=12.854 NODES=15768	SAT TT=12.303 CHECKS=81801 NODES=16010	SAT TT=4.249	SAT TT=174.529 CHECKS=89879592 NODES=57008	SAT TT=164.88 CHECKS=79219947 NODES=51161	SAT TT=146.13 CHECKS=71135763 NODES=45464	SAT TT=7.296	SAT TT=12.592	SAT TT=5.121	SAT TT=160.607 CHECKS=75017415 NODES=49309	SAT TT=152.268 CHECKS=75017415 NODES=49309	SAT TT=252.985	SAT TT=248.24	SAT TT=2.71	SAT TT=2.599	SAT TT=2.422 CHECKS=75438600 NODES=22064	SAT TT=2.418 CHECKS=75438600 NODES=22064
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-67_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.314	UNSAT TT=20.639 CHECKS=91621141 NODES=102102	UNSAT TT=18.132 CHECKS=81501286 NODES=91689	UNSAT TT=11.801	UNSAT TT=10.039	UNSAT TT=10.8	UNSAT TT=84.938 NODES=106003	UNSAT TT=41.901 NODES=58040	UNSAT TT=41.091 CHECKS=82343 NODES=59834	UNSAT TT=85.735	UNSAT TT=293.732 CHECKS=142890504 NODES=99449	UNSAT TT=307.578 CHECKS=147666835 NODES=100724	UNSAT TT=1470.69 CHECKS=705124913 NODES=492325	UNSAT TT=119.035	UNSAT TT=323.416	UNSAT TT=17.51	UNSAT TT=276.345 CHECKS=129653942 NODES=91041	UNSAT TT=273.761 CHECKS=129653942 NODES=91041	UNSAT TT=737.369	UNSAT TT=741.645	UNSAT TT=38.91	UNSAT TT=24.894	UNSAT TT=4.314 CHECKS=133009000 NODES=42500	UNSAT TT=4.323 CHECKS=133009000 NODES=42500
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-69_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.582	UNSAT TT=16.936 CHECKS=74528669 NODES=84737	UNSAT TT=16.081 CHECKS=75470312 NODES=85199	UNSAT TT=16.672	UNSAT TT=9.526	UNSAT TT=9.229	UNSAT TT=81.43 NODES=103509	UNSAT TT=41.545 NODES=54589	UNSAT TT=42.659 CHECKS=81557 NODES=57310	UNSAT TT=75.387	UNSAT TT=261.432 CHECKS=136232526 NODES=93430	UNSAT TT=241.039 CHECKS=123646227 NODES=85217	UNSAT TT=1136.19 CHECKS=562302181 NODES=386304	UNSAT TT=86.408	UNSAT TT=290.548	UNSAT TT=17.2	UNSAT TT=271.63 CHECKS=139755052 NODES=96183	UNSAT TT=295.081 CHECKS=139755052 NODES=96183	UNSAT TT=694.916	UNSAT TT=739.273	UNSAT TT=32.296	UNSAT TT=20.486	UNSAT TT=4.582 CHECKS=140982000 NODES=43541	UNSAT TT=4.515 CHECKS=140982000 NODES=43541
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-71_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.899	SAT TT=2.899 CHECKS=8989444 NODES=11092	SAT TT=2.996 CHECKS=9321336 NODES=11591	SAT TT=13.359	SAT TT=11.843	SAT TT=11.878	SAT TT=5.689 NODES=6823	SAT TT=71.421 NODES=103586	SAT TT=71.395 CHECKS=80531 NODES=100584	SAT TT=164.71	SAT TT=84.806 CHECKS=42524800 NODES=31502	SAT TT=262.744 CHECKS=126295456 NODES=94722	SAT TT=280.689 CHECKS=145863283 NODES=107453	SAT TT=22.272	SAT TT=719.809	SAT TT=22.841	SAT TT=265.732 CHECKS=132017246 NODES=96104	SAT TT=272.339 CHECKS=132017246 NODES=96104	SAT TT=1455.01	SAT TT=1441.94	SAT TT=7.139	SAT TT=27.172	SAT TT=4.433 CHECKS=134221000 NODES=44840	SAT TT=4.18 CHECKS=134221000 NODES=44840
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-73_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.541	SAT TT=1.899 CHECKS=4279575 NODES=5115	SAT TT=4.837 CHECKS=17664528 NODES=20845	SAT TT=1.563	SAT TT=3.845	SAT TT=3.707	SAT TT=0.834 NODES=383	SAT TT=19.211 NODES=26969	SAT TT=29.473 CHECKS=81478 NODES=40294	SAT TT=75.397	SAT TT=36.821 CHECKS=17803018 NODES=13346	SAT TT=67.785 CHECKS=33057447 NODES=25889	SAT TT=12.624 CHECKS=6482505 NODES=4344	SAT TT=19.419	SAT TT=23.715	SAT TT=5.639	SAT TT=30.432 CHECKS=14321407 NODES=11098	SAT TT=30.958 CHECKS=14321407 NODES=11098	SAT TT=57.845	SAT TT=55.202	SAT TT=11.28	SAT TT=0.991	SAT TT=0.541 CHECKS=15027100 NODES=5322	SAT TT=0.55 CHECKS=15027100 NODES=5322
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-75_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=7.832	UNSAT TT=36.02 CHECKS=162296271 NODES=187182	UNSAT TT=32.137 CHECKS=152362748 NODES=174589	UNSAT TT=26.248	UNSAT TT=18.375	UNSAT TT=18.371	UNSAT TT=160.575 NODES=209808	UNSAT TT=78.631 NODES=114158	UNSAT TT=76.791 CHECKS=81693 NODES=111330	UNSAT TT=276.905	UNSAT TT=468.62 CHECKS=240638733 NODES=175701	UNSAT TT=542.489 CHECKS=261793378 NODES=191944	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=440.094	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=29.096	UNSAT TT=492.086 CHECKS=236128468 NODES=174491	UNSAT TT=468.077 CHECKS=236128468 NODES=174491	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.14	UNSAT TT=137.45	UNSAT TT=42.573	UNSAT TT=7.832 CHECKS=238828000 NODES=81314	UNSAT TT=7.813 CHECKS=238828000 NODES=81314
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-77_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.333	SAT TT=19.759 CHECKS=93883464 NODES=115299	SAT TT=15.287 CHECKS=65767447 NODES=81849	SAT TT=19.511	SAT TT=2.333	SAT TT=2.336	SAT TT=22.779 NODES=29196	SAT TT=72.577 NODES=107515	SAT TT=73.677 CHECKS=80537 NODES=110462	SAT TT=77.289	SAT TT=332.772 CHECKS=158452510 NODES=120325	SAT TT=322.6 CHECKS=162008924 NODES=122231	SAT TT=127.08 CHECKS=66920228 NODES=48883	SAT TT=149.33	SAT TT=28.45	SAT TT=19.83	SAT TT=364.802 CHECKS=170760172 NODES=129913	SAT TT=342.835 CHECKS=170760172 NODES=129913	SAT TT=977.427	SAT TT=929.327	SAT TT=76.906	SAT TT=21.519	SAT TT=5.988 CHECKS=180906000 NODES=63570	SAT TT=5.558 CHECKS=180906000 NODES=63570
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-79_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=7.062	UNSAT TT=34.884 CHECKS=159616219 NODES=186592	UNSAT TT=33.251 CHECKS=150132253 NODES=177028	UNSAT TT=22.448	UNSAT TT=16.935	UNSAT TT=17.518	UNSAT TT=151.472 NODES=204755	UNSAT TT=67.771 NODES=100238	UNSAT TT=69.467 CHECKS=81777 NODES=103763	UNSAT TT=223.018	UNSAT TT=562.404 CHECKS=261468692 NODES=195405	UNSAT TT=512.556 CHECKS=252588799 NODES=187303	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=373.525	UNSAT TT=1612.8	UNSAT TT=30.018	UNSAT TT=481.835 CHECKS=231641261 NODES=172148	UNSAT TT=485.717 CHECKS=231641261 NODES=172148	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=137.965	UNSAT TT=53.303	UNSAT TT=7.062 CHECKS=230942000 NODES=78714	UNSAT TT=7.571 CHECKS=230942000 NODES=78714
tightness/tightness0.2/ rand-2-40-11-414-200-9_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.712	UNSAT TT=15.847 CHECKS=75317379 NODES=81457	UNSAT TT=14.671 CHECKS=69964731 NODES=76011	UNSAT TT=11.365	UNSAT TT=10.256	UNSAT TT=10.867	UNSAT TT=71.153 NODES=88733	UNSAT TT=35.021 NODES=48416	UNSAT TT=36.163 CHECKS=81281 NODES=49255	UNSAT TT=91.442	UNSAT TT=286.405 CHECKS=139025841 NODES=90138	UNSAT TT=247.063 CHECKS=120195280 NODES=78201	UNSAT TT=1183.69 CHECKS=591710280 NODES=384704	UNSAT TT=92.595	UNSAT TT=429.799	UNSAT TT=14.445	UNSAT TT=234.626 CHECKS=117951460 NODES=76879	UNSAT TT=242.765 CHECKS=117951460 NODES=76879	UNSAT TT=944.709	UNSAT TT=905.585	UNSAT TT=47.112	UNSAT TT=21.541	UNSAT TT=3.712 CHECKS=115022000 NODES=34065	UNSAT TT=3.693 CHECKS=115022000 NODES=34065
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-11_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=6.946	UNSAT TT=27.252 CHECKS=160852327 NODES=146873	UNSAT TT=21.451 CHECKS=135504299 NODES=126122	UNSAT TT=24.333	UNSAT TT=12.022	UNSAT TT=12.039	UNSAT TT=142.584 NODES=248661	UNSAT TT=69.344 NODES=99052	UNSAT TT=58.491 CHECKS=84016 NODES=95705	UNSAT TT=234.304	UNSAT TT=421.732 CHECKS=241666017 NODES=145160	UNSAT TT=438.066 CHECKS=255462888 NODES=150930	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=507.921	UNSAT TT=1586.21	UNSAT TT=31.193	UNSAT TT=395.942 CHECKS=226243890 NODES=138921	UNSAT TT=403.096 CHECKS=226243890 NODES=138921	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.16	UNSAT TT=232.835	UNSAT TT=34.959	UNSAT TT=6.946 CHECKS=216659000 NODES=54213	UNSAT TT=6.919 CHECKS=216659000 NODES=54213
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-13_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.381	SAT TT=5.79 CHECKS=28235117 NODES=28009	SAT TT=4.572 CHECKS=21424870 NODES=21229	SAT TT=11.237	SAT TT=5.531	SAT TT=5.533	SAT TT=52.553 NODES=97107	SAT TT=26.79 NODES=40743	SAT TT=26.748 CHECKS=83924 NODES=43889	SAT TT=24.907	SAT TT=168.086 CHECKS=106154529 NODES=67033	SAT TT=133.881 CHECKS=77738703 NODES=49462	SAT TT=709.797 CHECKS=435909577 NODES=273543	SAT TT=51.316	SAT TT=124.982	SAT TT=7.427	SAT TT=132.109 CHECKS=77117190 NODES=49692	SAT TT=134.063 CHECKS=77117190 NODES=49692	SAT TT=656.81	SAT TT=668.543	SAT TT=61.46	SAT TT=9.647	SAT TT=2.381 CHECKS=70853200 NODES=19603	SAT TT=2.374 CHECKS=70853200 NODES=19603
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-15_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.113	UNSAT TT=12.266 CHECKS=73056952 NODES=61235	UNSAT TT=11.463 CHECKS=67455990 NODES=57496	UNSAT TT=8.148	UNSAT TT=7.131	UNSAT TT=7.186	UNSAT TT=46.591 NODES=79383	UNSAT TT=21.551 NODES=32274	UNSAT TT=22.273 CHECKS=84284 NODES=34597	UNSAT TT=60.333	UNSAT TT=182.606 CHECKS=107362490 NODES=58985	UNSAT TT=163.11 CHECKS=102973912 NODES=56483	UNSAT TT=974.879 CHECKS=614284535 NODES=327531	UNSAT TT=195.949	UNSAT TT=280.438	UNSAT TT=11.973	UNSAT TT=173.48 CHECKS=102718090 NODES=55071	UNSAT TT=173.235 CHECKS=102718090 NODES=55071	UNSAT TT=569.162	UNSAT TT=608.94	UNSAT TT=72.35	UNSAT TT=13.442	UNSAT TT=3.113 CHECKS=95955500 NODES=20628	UNSAT TT=3.067 CHECKS=95955500 NODES=20628
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.696	SAT TT=9.989 CHECKS=58934910 NODES=55547	SAT TT=10.032 CHECKS=57588062 NODES=53774	SAT TT=5.29	SAT TT=5.008	SAT TT=4.746	SAT TT=5.598 NODES=8774	SAT TT=18.29 NODES=25126	SAT TT=11.128 CHECKS=84625 NODES=16790	SAT TT=8.454	SAT TT=122.843 CHECKS=72540341 NODES=43931	SAT TT=115.866 CHECKS=72059517 NODES=43513	SAT TT=282.745 CHECKS=184055872 NODES=108533	SAT TT=42.692	SAT TT=57.472	SAT TT=10.262	SAT TT=119.892 CHECKS=72359290 NODES=42230	SAT TT=113.776 CHECKS=72359290 NODES=42230	SAT TT=629.966	SAT TT=623.751	SAT TT=35.324	SAT TT=6.767	SAT TT=1.696 CHECKS=51384900 NODES=12417	SAT TT=1.677 CHECKS=51384900 NODES=12417
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-19_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.179	UNSAT TT=8.929 CHECKS=50541702 NODES=44098	UNSAT TT=8.303 CHECKS=49077152 NODES=42749	UNSAT TT=9.071	UNSAT TT=5.792	UNSAT TT=5.746	UNSAT TT=31.283 NODES=52288	UNSAT TT=17.053 NODES=24541	UNSAT TT=20.306 CHECKS=86041 NODES=30555	UNSAT TT=38.837	UNSAT TT=128.323 CHECKS=81837042 NODES=45454	UNSAT TT=125.537 CHECKS=76783399 NODES=43763	UNSAT TT=630.392 CHECKS=377574926 NODES=206112	UNSAT TT=86.636	UNSAT TT=142.157	UNSAT TT=9.823	UNSAT TT=136.874 CHECKS=80183218 NODES=43798	UNSAT TT=131.914 CHECKS=80183218 NODES=43798	UNSAT TT=271.131	UNSAT TT=276.149	UNSAT TT=56.21	UNSAT TT=11.368	UNSAT TT=2.179 CHECKS=72397100 NODES=16990	UNSAT TT=2.331 CHECKS=72397100 NODES=16990
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-1_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.642	UNSAT TT=19.217 CHECKS=122733201 NODES=111135	UNSAT TT=19.55 CHECKS=117283556 NODES=106448	UNSAT TT=13.614	UNSAT TT=10.459	UNSAT TT=10.575	UNSAT TT=84.402 NODES=148416	UNSAT TT=35.389 NODES=55631	UNSAT TT=43.903 CHECKS=84086 NODES=71577	UNSAT TT=167.327	UNSAT TT=261.761 CHECKS=154389699 NODES=93301	UNSAT TT=244.034 CHECKS=151735380 NODES=91155	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=322.732	UNSAT TT=734.524	UNSAT TT=19.377	UNSAT TT=256.766 CHECKS=150184559 NODES=90110	UNSAT TT=259.756 CHECKS=150184559 NODES=90110	UNSAT TT=1650.18	UNSAT TT=1727.94	UNSAT TT=183.426	UNSAT TT=24.259	UNSAT TT=4.642 CHECKS=145248000 NODES=36181	UNSAT TT=4.668 CHECKS=145248000 NODES=36181
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.429	SAT TT=1.429 CHECKS=2604645 NODES=2768	SAT TT=14.23 CHECKS=79790470 NODES=80884	SAT TT=9.853	SAT TT=7.715	SAT TT=7.683	SAT TT=3.432 NODES=5169	SAT TT=5.989 NODES=8064	SAT TT=5.407 CHECKS=84094 NODES=7858	SAT TT=15.414	SAT TT=194.849 CHECKS=115859628 NODES=75258	SAT TT=47.224 CHECKS=25260201 NODES=17726	SAT TT=87.633 CHECKS=55112137 NODES=35232	SAT TT=247.845	SAT TT=884.435	SAT TT=3.035	SAT TT=187.07 CHECKS=108858199 NODES=71076	SAT TT=194.935 CHECKS=108858199 NODES=71076	SAT TT=128.918	SAT TT=134.514	SAT TT=267.91	SAT TT=9.982	SAT TT=3.288 CHECKS=98961900 NODES=27858	SAT TT=3.279 CHECKS=98961900 NODES=27858
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.235	SAT TT=7.067 CHECKS=40292803 NODES=38555	SAT TT=3.065 CHECKS=12214221 NODES=11920	SAT TT=19.675	SAT TT=2.235	SAT TT=2.31	SAT TT=19.438 NODES=34355	SAT TT=44.32 NODES=65257	SAT TT=35.945 CHECKS=84807 NODES=60686	SAT TT=31.287	SAT TT=224.423 CHECKS=138329832 NODES=86322	SAT TT=298.42 CHECKS=180287227 NODES=113091	SAT TT=263.165 CHECKS=160660831 NODES=96056	SAT TT=308.718	SAT TT=1020.84	SAT TT=2.814	SAT TT=305.077 CHECKS=177960369 NODES=111399	SAT TT=297.874 CHECKS=177960369 NODES=111399	SAT TT=1181.53	SAT TT=1195.03	SAT TT=13.275	SAT TT=10.887	SAT TT=4.762 CHECKS=143946000 NODES=38156	SAT TT=4.44 CHECKS=143946000 NODES=38156
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-25_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.579	SAT TT=14.703 CHECKS=83081944 NODES=80638	SAT TT=16.135 CHECKS=91510265 NODES=89592	SAT TT=4.129	SAT TT=6.371	SAT TT=6.331	SAT TT=104.157 NODES=192894	SAT TT=46.28 NODES=67943	SAT TT=8.465 CHECKS=83507 NODES=13813	SAT TT=215.028	SAT TT=82.426 CHECKS=46526554 NODES=30341	SAT TT=56.756 CHECKS=33759086 NODES=21723	SAT TT=526.397 CHECKS=308344415 NODES=183674	SAT TT=201.076	SAT TT=18.849	SAT TT=5.65	SAT TT=58.109 CHECKS=34931060 NODES=22511	SAT TT=61.907 CHECKS=34931060 NODES=22511	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=10.563	SAT TT=29.222	SAT TT=1.579 CHECKS=47027200 NODES=12052	SAT TT=1.577 CHECKS=47027200 NODES=12052
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-27_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=7.083	UNSAT TT=26.73 CHECKS=171430117 NODES=159018	UNSAT TT=25.192 CHECKS=158575657 NODES=150438	UNSAT TT=35.214	UNSAT TT=16.957	UNSAT TT=18.037	UNSAT TT=140.326 NODES=255887	UNSAT TT=74.394 NODES=115856	UNSAT TT=59.681 CHECKS=84190 NODES=99692	UNSAT TT=191.905	UNSAT TT=419.635 CHECKS=236996912 NODES=147773	UNSAT TT=411.559 CHECKS=234976019 NODES=148026	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=521.592	UNSAT TT=1628.59	UNSAT TT=28.178	UNSAT TT=426.985 CHECKS=252616345 NODES=159213	UNSAT TT=453.944 CHECKS=252616345 NODES=159213	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.14	UNSAT TT=187.99	UNSAT TT=38.854	UNSAT TT=7.083 CHECKS=230350000 NODES=61063	UNSAT TT=7.446 CHECKS=230350000 NODES=61063
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-29_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=8.587	UNSAT TT=27.739 CHECKS=161648013 NODES=152902	UNSAT TT=26.285 CHECKS=166698711 NODES=159057	UNSAT TT=31.903	UNSAT TT=14.263	UNSAT TT=14.328	UNSAT TT=146.123 NODES=255783	UNSAT TT=61.313 NODES=92239	UNSAT TT=57.036 CHECKS=85138 NODES=99523	UNSAT TT=360.169	UNSAT TT=429.564 CHECKS=255481042 NODES=162611	UNSAT TT=455.965 CHECKS=257403638 NODES=163661	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=684.026	? (TO) TT=1800.01	UNSAT TT=27.329	UNSAT TT=481.167 CHECKS=287515729 NODES=177671	UNSAT TT=484.175 CHECKS=287515729 NODES=177671	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=347.29	UNSAT TT=34.757	UNSAT TT=8.587 CHECKS=267568000 NODES=68771	UNSAT TT=8.558 CHECKS=267568000 NODES=68771
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-31_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.211	SAT TT=12.296 CHECKS=73601046 NODES=72624	SAT TT=17.272 CHECKS=103981357 NODES=100790	SAT TT=2.273	SAT TT=6.722	SAT TT=6.775	SAT TT=30.54 NODES=51691	SAT TT=33.76 NODES=49004	SAT TT=26.881 CHECKS=84249 NODES=46021	SAT TT=12.099	SAT TT=71.333 CHECKS=39528918 NODES=26129	SAT TT=70.736 CHECKS=38140818 NODES=25037	SAT TT=254.739 CHECKS=151211558 NODES=96714	SAT TT=292.294	SAT TT=197.27	SAT TT=6.876	SAT TT=58.087 CHECKS=34101486 NODES=22724	SAT TT=60.245 CHECKS=34101486 NODES=22724	SAT TT=75.784	SAT TT=80.331	SAT TT=56.97	SAT TT=1.9	SAT TT=1.211 CHECKS=34847100 NODES=9223	SAT TT=1.2 CHECKS=34847100 NODES=9223
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-33_ext.xml	SAT TT=3.108	SAT TT=3.108 CHECKS=14628327 NODES=12801	SAT TT=4.273 CHECKS=21750918 NODES=18948	SAT TT=17.761	SAT TT=7.598	SAT TT=7.614	SAT TT=5.466 NODES=9061	SAT TT=36.091 NODES=50534	SAT TT=22.539 CHECKS=84112 NODES=37441	SAT TT=4.54	SAT TT=148.057 CHECKS=93874629 NODES=52009	SAT TT=164.177 CHECKS=95627623 NODES=53407	SAT TT=373.454 CHECKS=232554547 NODES=127030	SAT TT=134.15	SAT TT=411.913	SAT TT=10.668	SAT TT=244.578 CHECKS=153611221 NODES=84456	SAT TT=245.433 CHECKS=153611221 NODES=84456	SAT TT=231.057	SAT TT=235.459	SAT TT=88.769	SAT TT=14.221	SAT TT=4.679 CHECKS=147493000 NODES=31713	SAT TT=4.642 CHECKS=147493000 NODES=31713
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-35_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=8.16	UNSAT TT=34.752 CHECKS=205959991 NODES=204639	UNSAT TT=31.344 CHECKS=197620738 NODES=194739	UNSAT TT=28.668	UNSAT TT=18.146	UNSAT TT=17.823	UNSAT TT=134.2 NODES=238492	UNSAT TT=79.41 NODES=119819	UNSAT TT=75.991 CHECKS=83997 NODES=135373	UNSAT TT=259.754	UNSAT TT=505.379 CHECKS=281947167 NODES=188047	UNSAT TT=499.618 CHECKS=287198530 NODES=191403	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=836.531	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=35.347	UNSAT TT=512.288 CHECKS=285783371 NODES=189283	UNSAT TT=485.273 CHECKS=285783371 NODES=189283	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.15	UNSAT TT=341.66	UNSAT TT=34.234	UNSAT TT=8.16 CHECKS=247166000 NODES=71808	UNSAT TT=8.009 CHECKS=247166000 NODES=71808
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-37_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.214	SAT TT=8.146 CHECKS=44447735 NODES=46576	SAT TT=20.846 CHECKS=120402922 NODES=124502	SAT TT=4.535	SAT TT=2.789	SAT TT=2.763	SAT TT=22.599 NODES=39783	SAT TT=28.325 NODES=44451	SAT TT=29.859 CHECKS=84106 NODES=54693	SAT TT=79.544	SAT TT=85.12 CHECKS=49164378 NODES=34213	SAT TT=89.792 CHECKS=48705460 NODES=34479	SAT TT=398.289 CHECKS=233934435 NODES=163686	SAT TT=197.145	SAT TT=41.22	SAT TT=53.793	SAT TT=90.891 CHECKS=48895852 NODES=34321	SAT TT=89.862 CHECKS=48895852 NODES=34321	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=445.58	SAT TT=17.743	SAT TT=1.214 CHECKS=36380400 NODES=10556	SAT TT=1.294 CHECKS=36380400 NODES=10556
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-39_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.31	SAT TT=10.953 CHECKS=63813052 NODES=56738	SAT TT=11.778 CHECKS=66304872 NODES=58640	SAT TT=0.754	SAT TT=5.496	SAT TT=5.442	SAT TT=29.795 NODES=49680	SAT TT=28.165 NODES=41388	SAT TT=10.395 CHECKS=84211 NODES=16168	SAT TT=46.22	SAT TT=19.17 CHECKS=10588328 NODES=6432	SAT TT=138.652 CHECKS=84603508 NODES=50765	SAT TT=42.197 CHECKS=25394832 NODES=14156	SAT TT=256.746	SAT TT=169.301	SAT TT=10.309	SAT TT=11.537 CHECKS=7069691 NODES=4378	SAT TT=11.554 CHECKS=7069691 NODES=4378	SAT TT=492.863	? (MO) TT=2.425	SAT TT=36.685	SAT TT=11.848	SAT TT=0.31 CHECKS=7127400 NODES=1797	SAT TT=0.285 CHECKS=7127400 NODES=1797
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-3_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.623	UNSAT TT=12.962 CHECKS=82262037 NODES=69222	UNSAT TT=12.716 CHECKS=79805920 NODES=67135	UNSAT TT=22.658	UNSAT TT=7.377	UNSAT TT=7.276	UNSAT TT=62.257 NODES=109589	UNSAT TT=31.294 NODES=42763	UNSAT TT=24.917 CHECKS=84633 NODES=39197	UNSAT TT=84.26	UNSAT TT=204.194 CHECKS=128709827 NODES=69076	UNSAT TT=210.606 CHECKS=131470260 NODES=71148	UNSAT TT=1231.8 CHECKS=767004353 NODES=416622	UNSAT TT=205.849	UNSAT TT=363.038	UNSAT TT=17.129	UNSAT TT=239.011 CHECKS=148377836 NODES=81283	UNSAT TT=239.303 CHECKS=148377836 NODES=81283	UNSAT TT=900.054	UNSAT TT=897.1	UNSAT TT=101.395	UNSAT TT=20.92	UNSAT TT=4.623 CHECKS=145661000 NODES=30796	UNSAT TT=4.363 CHECKS=145661000 NODES=30796
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-41_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.667	UNSAT TT=10.915 CHECKS=61884574 NODES=52710	UNSAT TT=9.113 CHECKS=53775521 NODES=45638	UNSAT TT=16.943	UNSAT TT=5.827	UNSAT TT=5.823	UNSAT TT=45.4 NODES=74635	UNSAT TT=22.266 NODES=28680	UNSAT TT=19.413 CHECKS=83899 NODES=31286	UNSAT TT=46.564	UNSAT TT=127.914 CHECKS=79921665 NODES=45202	UNSAT TT=170.839 CHECKS=99008246 NODES=56093	UNSAT TT=813.925 CHECKS=476950988 NODES=268551	UNSAT TT=90.69	UNSAT TT=191.191	UNSAT TT=9.443	UNSAT TT=155.607 CHECKS=88112186 NODES=50971	UNSAT TT=154.351 CHECKS=88112186 NODES=50971	UNSAT TT=395.347	UNSAT TT=391.909	UNSAT TT=46.494	UNSAT TT=13.373	UNSAT TT=2.667 CHECKS=83050600 NODES=18762	UNSAT TT=2.711 CHECKS=83050600 NODES=18762
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-43_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=14.014	UNSAT TT=44.24 CHECKS=260890880 NODES=249479	UNSAT TT=40.269 CHECKS=245048453 NODES=233196	UNSAT TT=67.307	UNSAT TT=19.471	UNSAT TT=19.571	UNSAT TT=208.949 NODES=366731	UNSAT TT=95.608 NODES=150779	UNSAT TT=84.732 CHECKS=84221 NODES=151575	UNSAT TT=409.706	UNSAT TT=668.598 CHECKS=378554580 NODES=237895	UNSAT TT=676.459 CHECKS=393983647 NODES=246878	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=839.529	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=52.875	UNSAT TT=864.754 CHECKS=472512394 NODES=299482	UNSAT TT=826.538 CHECKS=472512394 NODES=299482	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.19	UNSAT TT=667.455	UNSAT TT=56.289	UNSAT TT=14.014 CHECKS=432852000 NODES=112585	UNSAT TT=14.011 CHECKS=432852000 NODES=112585
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-45_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.042	UNSAT TT=4.428 CHECKS=22409664 NODES=16878	UNSAT TT=4.784 CHECKS=25038357 NODES=18931	UNSAT TT=2.573	UNSAT TT=3.706	UNSAT TT=3.85	UNSAT TT=13.206 NODES=20710	UNSAT TT=10.55 NODES=12803	UNSAT TT=8.202 CHECKS=84427 NODES=11161	UNSAT TT=15.852	UNSAT TT=59.206 CHECKS=37112271 NODES=18853	UNSAT TT=58.905 CHECKS=36627864 NODES=18631	UNSAT TT=364.911 CHECKS=235353012 NODES=110118	UNSAT TT=42.259	UNSAT TT=42.369	UNSAT TT=4.956	UNSAT TT=54.045 CHECKS=32397751 NODES=15812	UNSAT TT=53.784 CHECKS=32397751 NODES=15812	UNSAT TT=66.088	UNSAT TT=65.422	UNSAT TT=19.06	UNSAT TT=5.243	UNSAT TT=1.042 CHECKS=31441900 NODES=5867	UNSAT TT=0.957 CHECKS=31441900 NODES=5867
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-47_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=6.131	UNSAT TT=21.612 CHECKS=137583819 NODES=125625	UNSAT TT=23.603 CHECKS=139173223 NODES=126740	UNSAT TT=19.955	UNSAT TT=14.285	UNSAT TT=14.518	UNSAT TT=104.727 NODES=195227	UNSAT TT=54.113 NODES=76498	UNSAT TT=51.004 CHECKS=84430 NODES=85000	UNSAT TT=199.546	UNSAT TT=357.868 CHECKS=207676580 NODES=124218	UNSAT TT=347.035 CHECKS=210930120 NODES=126459	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=557.663	UNSAT TT=1377.31	UNSAT TT=26.906	UNSAT TT=336 CHECKS=206416998 NODES=121793	UNSAT TT=363.058 CHECKS=206416998 NODES=121793	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.19	UNSAT TT=212.57	UNSAT TT=36.102	UNSAT TT=6.131 CHECKS=193985000 NODES=45682	UNSAT TT=5.902 CHECKS=193985000 NODES=45682
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-49_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.099	UNSAT TT=17.408 CHECKS=99460850 NODES=89442	UNSAT TT=17.317 CHECKS=102340197 NODES=91593	UNSAT TT=23.755	UNSAT TT=9.646	UNSAT TT=9.65	UNSAT TT=71.703 NODES=130953	UNSAT TT=42.956 NODES=62555	UNSAT TT=39.775 CHECKS=83461 NODES=65791	UNSAT TT=176.526	UNSAT TT=252.923 CHECKS=149133631 NODES=85573	UNSAT TT=239.81 CHECKS=148101812 NODES=85484	UNSAT TT=1301.45 CHECKS=796689518 NODES=462237	UNSAT TT=409.278	UNSAT TT=828.29	UNSAT TT=17.685	UNSAT TT=262.692 CHECKS=158857746 NODES=95096	UNSAT TT=270.567 CHECKS=158857746 NODES=95096	UNSAT TT=1743.43	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=133.48	UNSAT TT=23.429	UNSAT TT=5.099 CHECKS=155883000 NODES=37516	UNSAT TT=5.06 CHECKS=155883000 NODES=37516
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-51_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.929	SAT TT=2.45 CHECKS=8367908 NODES=8213	SAT TT=8.808 CHECKS=52605281 NODES=49775	SAT TT=11.106	SAT TT=6.506	SAT TT=6.593	SAT TT=34.88 NODES=61741	SAT TT=37.119 NODES=58661	SAT TT=37.548 CHECKS=85232 NODES=63518	SAT TT=12.653	SAT TT=126.252 CHECKS=73818571 NODES=45949	SAT TT=132.044 CHECKS=75783769 NODES=46898	SAT TT=399.083 CHECKS=255852334 NODES=155068	SAT TT=30.326	SAT TT=484.603	SAT TT=5.582	SAT TT=107.581 CHECKS=67240380 NODES=40683	SAT TT=112.603 CHECKS=67240380 NODES=40683	SAT TT=81.537	SAT TT=85.238	SAT TT=47.43	SAT TT=1.929	SAT TT=2.316 CHECKS=69439900 NODES=17274	SAT TT=2.283 CHECKS=69439900 NODES=17274
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-53_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=11.997	UNSAT TT=47.708 CHECKS=285944284 NODES=279529	UNSAT TT=45.519 CHECKS=273214839 NODES=267258	UNSAT TT=47.535	UNSAT TT=23.005	UNSAT TT=22.952	UNSAT TT=216.765 NODES=402200	UNSAT TT=106.394 NODES=158045	UNSAT TT=97.74 CHECKS=84273 NODES=172295	UNSAT TT=462.227	UNSAT TT=745.092 CHECKS=445480297 NODES=292895	UNSAT TT=705.777 CHECKS=407048501 NODES=267669	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=1247.01	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=50.408	UNSAT TT=830.969 CHECKS=443585220 NODES=290534	UNSAT TT=820.861 CHECKS=443585220 NODES=290534	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=477.74	UNSAT TT=69.448	UNSAT TT=11.997 CHECKS=369551000 NODES=102746	UNSAT TT=11.747 CHECKS=369551000 NODES=102746
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-55_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.051	UNSAT TT=15.743 CHECKS=90835422 NODES=85125	UNSAT TT=15.485 CHECKS=93372206 NODES=87383	UNSAT TT=19.467	UNSAT TT=10.295	UNSAT TT=10.252	UNSAT TT=71.973 NODES=122934	UNSAT TT=40.971 NODES=58614	UNSAT TT=32.54 CHECKS=84911 NODES=57059	UNSAT TT=124.998	UNSAT TT=270.47 CHECKS=168916650 NODES=101953	UNSAT TT=291.004 CHECKS=169211778 NODES=102590	UNSAT TT=1656.85 CHECKS=955435057 NODES=574724	UNSAT TT=255.564	UNSAT TT=857.112	UNSAT TT=18.693	UNSAT TT=280.92 CHECKS=170810216 NODES=102581	UNSAT TT=295.892 CHECKS=170810216 NODES=102581	UNSAT TT=1280.64	UNSAT TT=1321.17	UNSAT TT=123.78	UNSAT TT=21.186	UNSAT TT=5.051 CHECKS=153851000 NODES=38361	UNSAT TT=4.95 CHECKS=153851000 NODES=38361
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-57_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.447	SAT TT=7.645 CHECKS=41531974 NODES=37795	SAT TT=6.504 CHECKS=34749821 NODES=31400	SAT TT=9.896	SAT TT=6.173	SAT TT=6.258	SAT TT=27.895 NODES=48623	SAT TT=14.456 NODES=20926	SAT TT=14.659 CHECKS=84518 NODES=23811	SAT TT=10.853	SAT TT=133.84 CHECKS=77894605 NODES=45119	SAT TT=62.099 CHECKS=34914923 NODES=19920	SAT TT=45.428 CHECKS=28398698 NODES=14855	SAT TT=97.706	SAT TT=25.061	SAT TT=10.206	SAT TT=134.404 CHECKS=79489637 NODES=45369	SAT TT=126.748 CHECKS=79489637 NODES=45369	SAT TT=130.311	SAT TT=131.699	SAT TT=69.63	SAT TT=10.111	SAT TT=2.447 CHECKS=74104400 NODES=17062	SAT TT=2.41 CHECKS=74104400 NODES=17062
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-59_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.523	UNSAT TT=12.288 CHECKS=69475855 NODES=65086	UNSAT TT=11.35 CHECKS=64713444 NODES=60774	UNSAT TT=13.989	UNSAT TT=7.119	UNSAT TT=7.174	UNSAT TT=44.296 NODES=74547	UNSAT TT=27.741 NODES=41534	UNSAT TT=25.173 CHECKS=84754 NODES=39884	UNSAT TT=55.066	UNSAT TT=166.612 CHECKS=106183332 NODES=62087	UNSAT TT=168.135 CHECKS=106991286 NODES=62521	UNSAT TT=805.084 CHECKS=500667862 NODES=285311	UNSAT TT=160.012	UNSAT TT=239.344	UNSAT TT=13.341	UNSAT TT=193.961 CHECKS=114631752 NODES=67811	UNSAT TT=194.764 CHECKS=114631752 NODES=67811	UNSAT TT=489.954	UNSAT TT=506.746	UNSAT TT=58.769	UNSAT TT=14.53	UNSAT TT=3.523 CHECKS=111092000 NODES=27631	UNSAT TT=3.524 CHECKS=111092000 NODES=27631
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-5_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.144	SAT TT=4.988 CHECKS=24220285 NODES=23468	SAT TT=3.8 CHECKS=18646208 NODES=18109	SAT TT=18.624	SAT TT=2.223	SAT TT=2.144	SAT TT=5.232 NODES=8238	SAT TT=22.273 NODES=32017	SAT TT=19.63 CHECKS=85350 NODES=33654	SAT TT=36.811	SAT TT=269.258 CHECKS=158022035 NODES=94689	SAT TT=171 CHECKS=102215145 NODES=63012	SAT TT=186.243 CHECKS=113500126 NODES=66161	SAT TT=83.81	SAT TT=38.844	SAT TT=15.217	SAT TT=269.861 CHECKS=156553978 NODES=93204	SAT TT=272.397 CHECKS=156553978 NODES=93204	SAT TT=441.502	SAT TT=461.672	SAT TT=44.921	SAT TT=16.191	SAT TT=4.455 CHECKS=138900000 NODES=34921	SAT TT=4.48 CHECKS=138900000 NODES=34921
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-61_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.802	UNSAT TT=8.283 CHECKS=44943090 NODES=37844	UNSAT TT=6.891 CHECKS=37628363 NODES=32082	UNSAT TT=7.971	UNSAT TT=5.678	UNSAT TT=5.737	UNSAT TT=27.646 NODES=45653	UNSAT TT=15.953 NODES=20986	UNSAT TT=14.521 CHECKS=84805 NODES=22095	UNSAT TT=31.349	UNSAT TT=111.677 CHECKS=62733678 NODES=35446	UNSAT TT=100.809 CHECKS=58572722 NODES=33845	UNSAT TT=445.818 CHECKS=273226443 NODES=152232	UNSAT TT=108.464	UNSAT TT=155.515	UNSAT TT=7.659	UNSAT TT=97.684 CHECKS=56266553 NODES=32007	UNSAT TT=98.831 CHECKS=56266553 NODES=32007	UNSAT TT=290.672	UNSAT TT=294.3	UNSAT TT=48.212	UNSAT TT=8.752	UNSAT TT=1.802 CHECKS=53162600 NODES=12218	UNSAT TT=1.657 CHECKS=53162600 NODES=12218
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-63_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=6.925	UNSAT TT=22.477 CHECKS=141491859 NODES=133626	UNSAT TT=24.11 CHECKS=141178097 NODES=132705	UNSAT TT=20.763	UNSAT TT=15.629	UNSAT TT=15.545	UNSAT TT=154.145 NODES=283713	UNSAT TT=60.495 NODES=93358	UNSAT TT=53.715 CHECKS=84076 NODES=93593	UNSAT TT=269.058	UNSAT TT=468.852 CHECKS=264292069 NODES=161152	UNSAT TT=453.395 CHECKS=259688359 NODES=158334	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=507.033	UNSAT TT=1721.65	UNSAT TT=25.739	UNSAT TT=421.592 CHECKS=236327334 NODES=145437	UNSAT TT=394.311 CHECKS=236327334 NODES=145437	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=276.55	UNSAT TT=31.382	UNSAT TT=6.925 CHECKS=211406000 NODES=53924	UNSAT TT=6.367 CHECKS=211406000 NODES=53924
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-65_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.209	UNSAT TT=14.361 CHECKS=82171880 NODES=73327	UNSAT TT=14.042 CHECKS=81579079 NODES=73070	UNSAT TT=19.035	UNSAT TT=8.803	UNSAT TT=8.838	UNSAT TT=81.331 NODES=144002	UNSAT TT=36.023 NODES=49596	UNSAT TT=34.99 CHECKS=84208 NODES=55598	UNSAT TT=130.021	UNSAT TT=249.029 CHECKS=139133283 NODES=83256	UNSAT TT=237.705 CHECKS=141755591 NODES=84845	UNSAT TT=1280.33 CHECKS=746543419 NODES=448646	UNSAT TT=304.176	UNSAT TT=710.106	UNSAT TT=14.413	UNSAT TT=247.791 CHECKS=140207449 NODES=83068	UNSAT TT=245.898 CHECKS=140207449 NODES=83068	UNSAT TT=1598.35	UNSAT TT=1573.16	UNSAT TT=149.38	UNSAT TT=21.988	UNSAT TT=4.209 CHECKS=130924000 NODES=31158	UNSAT TT=4.206 CHECKS=130924000 NODES=31158
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-67_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.878	SAT TT=1.07 CHECKS=1083062 NODES=971	SAT TT=0.878 CHECKS=266270 NODES=257	SAT TT=8.883	SAT TT=3.218	SAT TT=3.4	SAT TT=22.97 NODES=40964	SAT TT=12.665 NODES=16891	SAT TT=15.143 CHECKS=84190 NODES=24562	SAT TT=49.69	SAT TT=46.545 CHECKS=27262914 NODES=16223	SAT TT=45.862 CHECKS=26778323 NODES=15241	SAT TT=112.396 CHECKS=71571915 NODES=38904	SAT TT=43.43	SAT TT=52.27	SAT TT=7.021	SAT TT=163.138 CHECKS=95749846 NODES=54415	SAT TT=164.586 CHECKS=95749846 NODES=54415	SAT TT=30.285	SAT TT=30.395	SAT TT=57.03	SAT TT=1.133	SAT TT=2.591 CHECKS=80238500 NODES=19572	SAT TT=2.568 CHECKS=80238500 NODES=19572
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-69_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.283	SAT TT=1.686 CHECKS=4134325 NODES=3514	SAT TT=4.338 CHECKS=21251383 NODES=17319	SAT TT=0.661	SAT TT=3.42	SAT TT=3.221	SAT TT=4.825 NODES=7225	SAT TT=2.289 NODES=2164	SAT TT=6.427 CHECKS=84410 NODES=8690	SAT TT=2.611	SAT TT=28.137 CHECKS=16696950 NODES=9337	SAT TT=21.44 CHECKS=11860708 NODES=6661	SAT TT=174.126 CHECKS=111403145 NODES=53870	SAT TT=6.643	SAT TT=2.926	SAT TT=1.428	SAT TT=14.764 CHECKS=8585910 NODES=4401	SAT TT=13.793 CHECKS=8585910 NODES=4401	SAT TT=4.849	SAT TT=4.907	SAT TT=6.39	SAT TT=4.119	SAT TT=0.283 CHECKS=6748910 NODES=1393	SAT TT=0.282 CHECKS=6748910 NODES=1393
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-71_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.377	UNSAT TT=12.32 CHECKS=71338589 NODES=61099	UNSAT TT=11.916 CHECKS=70561795 NODES=59837	UNSAT TT=14.771	UNSAT TT=6.995	UNSAT TT=7.111	UNSAT TT=82.801 NODES=137797	UNSAT TT=28.331 NODES=37792	UNSAT TT=25.747 CHECKS=84599 NODES=41096	UNSAT TT=73.392	UNSAT TT=184.723 CHECKS=118598558 NODES=65464	UNSAT TT=195.793 CHECKS=119346999 NODES=65624	UNSAT TT=1054.12 CHECKS=664677450 NODES=345909	UNSAT TT=207.083	UNSAT TT=387.496	UNSAT TT=12.245	UNSAT TT=177.777 CHECKS=112611637 NODES=61787	UNSAT TT=189.835 CHECKS=112611637 NODES=61787	UNSAT TT=716.182	UNSAT TT=775.249	UNSAT TT=62.22	UNSAT TT=15.906	UNSAT TT=3.377 CHECKS=106103000 NODES=22963	UNSAT TT=3.439 CHECKS=106103000 NODES=22963
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-73_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.322	SAT TT=1.766 CHECKS=4464997 NODES=4264	SAT TT=0.843 CHECKS=80992 NODES=99	SAT TT=0.322	SAT TT=2.313	SAT TT=2.303	SAT TT=2.384 NODES=2927	SAT TT=54.79 NODES=81082	SAT TT=29.78 CHECKS=85532 NODES=52164	SAT TT=181.286	SAT TT=59.153 CHECKS=33212448 NODES=21166	SAT TT=25.765 CHECKS=13773022 NODES=8643	SAT TT=10.949 CHECKS=7125271 NODES=3888	SAT TT=201.535	SAT TT=816.465	SAT TT=0.356	SAT TT=2.36 CHECKS=1269651 NODES=790	SAT TT=2.187 CHECKS=1269651 NODES=790	SAT TT=229.076	SAT TT=224.987	SAT TT=186.642	SAT TT=25.482	SAT TT=0.347 CHECKS=8375630 NODES=2124	SAT TT=0.343 CHECKS=8375630 NODES=2124
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-75_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.569	SAT TT=19.926 CHECKS=120654096 NODES=119208	SAT TT=15.549 CHECKS=88492439 NODES=87578	SAT TT=14.714	SAT TT=9.515	SAT TT=9.974	SAT TT=46.647 NODES=81894	SAT TT=12.264 NODES=17257	SAT TT=28.715 CHECKS=84479 NODES=48155	SAT TT=70.653	SAT TT=236.33 CHECKS=138548660 NODES=94175	SAT TT=236.213 CHECKS=138963352 NODES=94329	SAT TT=90.076 CHECKS=53032326 NODES=34187	SAT TT=45.572	SAT TT=1251.96	SAT TT=6.836	SAT TT=264.937 CHECKS=145161266 NODES=96379	SAT TT=244.626 CHECKS=145161266 NODES=96379	SAT TT=1259.18	SAT TT=1330.23	SAT TT=29.42	SAT TT=37.946	SAT TT=4.569 CHECKS=136991000 NODES=37699	SAT TT=4.523 CHECKS=136991000 NODES=37699
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-77_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.972	SAT TT=1.578 CHECKS=3882496 NODES=3778	SAT TT=1.185 CHECKS=1590872 NODES=1533	SAT TT=4.634	SAT TT=2.109	SAT TT=2.161	SAT TT=3.917 NODES=6453	SAT TT=35.443 NODES=53956	SAT TT=25.338 CHECKS=84733 NODES=40392	SAT TT=22.75	SAT TT=44.082 CHECKS=26325963 NODES=16465	SAT TT=61.691 CHECKS=34590539 NODES=21597	SAT TT=18.373 CHECKS=12063244 NODES=7552	SAT TT=155.642	SAT TT=159.384	SAT TT=5.043	SAT TT=54.163 CHECKS=32567563 NODES=20035	SAT TT=55.467 CHECKS=32567563 NODES=20035	SAT TT=156.444	SAT TT=164.678	SAT TT=61.945	SAT TT=18.425	SAT TT=0.972 CHECKS=28937500 NODES=7758	SAT TT=0.993 CHECKS=28937500 NODES=7758
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-79_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=8.964	UNSAT TT=28.796 CHECKS=183072623 NODES=178776	UNSAT TT=32.585 CHECKS=207265454 NODES=200880	UNSAT TT=30.742	UNSAT TT=17.128	UNSAT TT=17.136	UNSAT TT=197.782 NODES=363109	UNSAT TT=81.654 NODES=123896	UNSAT TT=78.01 CHECKS=84130 NODES=136056	UNSAT TT=393.833	UNSAT TT=545.764 CHECKS=326718135 NODES=211044	UNSAT TT=573.783 CHECKS=332041171 NODES=214104	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=1342.01	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=37.8	UNSAT TT=604.061 CHECKS=322189863 NODES=207719	UNSAT TT=552.834 CHECKS=322189863 NODES=207719	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=412.83	UNSAT TT=49.48	UNSAT TT=8.964 CHECKS=291466000 NODES=76689	UNSAT TT=8.818 CHECKS=291466000 NODES=76689
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-7_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=7.546	UNSAT TT=30.092 CHECKS=186700981 NODES=178289	UNSAT TT=26.827 CHECKS=160829351 NODES=154842	UNSAT TT=38.042	UNSAT TT=17.707	UNSAT TT=16.699	UNSAT TT=124.003 NODES=220482	UNSAT TT=73.595 NODES=107722	UNSAT TT=64.498 CHECKS=84824 NODES=113460	UNSAT TT=248.151	UNSAT TT=418.265 CHECKS=246932204 NODES=163661	UNSAT TT=442.757 CHECKS=247533113 NODES=164470	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=809.926	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=27.373	UNSAT TT=456.364 CHECKS=248579987 NODES=164689	UNSAT TT=443.255 CHECKS=248579987 NODES=164689	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.15	UNSAT TT=283	UNSAT TT=40.016	UNSAT TT=7.546 CHECKS=229096000 NODES=62105	UNSAT TT=7.008 CHECKS=229096000 NODES=62105
tightness/tightness0.35/ rand-2-40-16-250-350-9_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.314	SAT TT=3.448 CHECKS=16811114 NODES=15136	SAT TT=4.7 CHECKS=24408909 NODES=21204	SAT TT=0.864	SAT TT=3.482	SAT TT=3.328	SAT TT=7.012 NODES=11231	SAT TT=11.2 NODES=14469	SAT TT=6.456 CHECKS=86109 NODES=8760	SAT TT=0.314	SAT TT=56.737 CHECKS=34981696 NODES=19833	SAT TT=64.022 CHECKS=37093568 NODES=21274	SAT TT=31.974 CHECKS=19633936 NODES=10763	SAT TT=3.206	SAT TT=13.873	SAT TT=3.774	SAT TT=22.939 CHECKS=13501649 NODES=7476	SAT TT=22.781 CHECKS=13501649 NODES=7476	SAT TT=55.057	SAT TT=53.874	SAT TT=11.72	SAT TT=5.406	SAT TT=0.484 CHECKS=13270100 NODES=3001	SAT TT=0.477 CHECKS=13270100 NODES=3001
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-11_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=7.155	UNSAT TT=15.55 CHECKS=113730956 NODES=78939	UNSAT TT=14.181 CHECKS=112186401 NODES=78528	UNSAT TT=386.543	UNSAT TT=9.095	UNSAT TT=9.127	UNSAT TT=91.414 NODES=172648	UNSAT TT=38.963 NODES=44527	UNSAT TT=30.6 CHECKS=113506 NODES=47845	UNSAT TT=1112.33	UNSAT TT=291.298 CHECKS=211539074 NODES=80882	UNSAT TT=0 CHECKS=216116089 NODES=82227	UNSAT TT=1162.84 CHECKS=967599382 NODES=338690	UNSAT TT=307.559	UNSAT TT=622.193	UNSAT TT=26.718	UNSAT TT=438.065 CHECKS=309001571 NODES=112438	UNSAT TT=431.654 CHECKS=309001571 NODES=112438	UNSAT TT=965.533	UNSAT TT=978.67	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=28.079	UNSAT TT=7.155 CHECKS=268253000 NODES=34081	UNSAT TT=7.591 CHECKS=268253000 NODES=34081
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-13_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.074	SAT TT=18.665 CHECKS=144256178 NODES=102580	SAT TT=15.703 CHECKS=120544464 NODES=86095	SAT TT=357.596	SAT TT=9.757	SAT TT=9.926	SAT TT=7.503 NODES=11393	SAT TT=24.794 NODES=30250	SAT TT=39.155 CHECKS=114976 NODES=64825	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=385.185 CHECKS=262609354 NODES=99766	SAT TT=155.487 CHECKS=103004052 NODES=40264	SAT TT=839.048 CHECKS=613014200 NODES=227700	SAT TT=678.467	SAT TT=47.891	SAT TT=14.681	SAT TT=103.482 CHECKS=69181025 NODES=26213	SAT TT=97.752 CHECKS=69181025 NODES=26213	SAT TT=1135.39	SAT TT=1039.69	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=17.126	SAT TT=2.074 CHECKS=63899700 NODES=8830	SAT TT=1.922 CHECKS=63899700 NODES=8830
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-15_ext.xml	SAT TT=3.515	SAT TT=3.515 CHECKS=20545475 NODES=14732	SAT TT=11.268 CHECKS=81676898 NODES=58147	SAT TT=291.949	SAT TT=12.633	SAT TT=12.598	SAT TT=147.102 NODES=258598	SAT TT=18.414 NODES=21783	SAT TT=25.67 CHECKS=113325 NODES=40954	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=263.392 CHECKS=192593756 NODES=74790	SAT TT=291.241 CHECKS=195500624 NODES=76218	SAT TT=467.562 CHECKS=387949051 NODES=139381	SAT TT=163.181	SAT TT=1778.63	SAT TT=27.783	SAT TT=261.394 CHECKS=187793035 NODES=71395	SAT TT=279.784 CHECKS=187793035 NODES=71395	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.16	SAT TT=34.541	SAT TT=4.702 CHECKS=157646000 NODES=23022	SAT TT=4.329 CHECKS=157646000 NODES=23022
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.526	SAT TT=3.668 CHECKS=21366144 NODES=17294	SAT TT=2.87 CHECKS=14995363 NODES=12218	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=3.57	SAT TT=3.608	SAT TT=4.429 NODES=6290	SAT TT=61.984 NODES=75103	SAT TT=51.634 CHECKS=113650 NODES=90981	SAT TT=992.907	SAT TT=77.311 CHECKS=48870607 NODES=20303	SAT TT=39.993 CHECKS=27961581 NODES=11695	SAT TT=178.339 CHECKS=126334112 NODES=53065	SAT TT=425.854	SAT TT=22.149	SAT TT=3.435	SAT TT=56.278 CHECKS=45997011 NODES=17793	SAT TT=70.841 CHECKS=45997011 NODES=17793	SAT TT=459.15	SAT TT=429.414	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=11.93	SAT TT=1.526 CHECKS=47641900 NODES=6976	SAT TT=1.579 CHECKS=47641900 NODES=6976
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-19_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.709	SAT TT=1.09 CHECKS=1707055 NODES=1154	SAT TT=2.57 CHECKS=11891329 NODES=7903	SAT TT=130.075	SAT TT=1.914	SAT TT=1.953	SAT TT=2.878 NODES=3409	SAT TT=2.046 NODES=1356	SAT TT=2.059 CHECKS=114159 NODES=1894	SAT TT=12.827	SAT TT=24.839 CHECKS=19951693 NODES=7068	SAT TT=22.655 CHECKS=15303936 NODES=6134	SAT TT=25.123 CHECKS=20990987 NODES=6189	SAT TT=31.372	SAT TT=4.157	SAT TT=3.057	SAT TT=25.696 CHECKS=20484729 NODES=6335	SAT TT=26.197 CHECKS=20484729 NODES=6335	SAT TT=16.174	SAT TT=16.172	SAT TT=1148.95	SAT TT=0.859	SAT TT=0.709 CHECKS=16823400 NODES=2190	SAT TT=0.703 CHECKS=16823400 NODES=2190
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-1_ext.xml	SAT TT=5.584	SAT TT=5.584 CHECKS=33626628 NODES=25762	SAT TT=16.68 CHECKS=118134691 NODES=89072	SAT TT=455.414	SAT TT=6.309	SAT TT=6.31	SAT TT=8.304 NODES=13941	SAT TT=6.524 NODES=6719	SAT TT=8.457 CHECKS=114535 NODES=12218	SAT TT=288.407	SAT TT=99.329 CHECKS=65481156 NODES=26131	SAT TT=286.986 CHECKS=194376176 NODES=76407	SAT TT=11.436 CHECKS=8370770 NODES=2722	SAT TT=209.687	SAT TT=45.855	SAT TT=31.297	SAT TT=393.429 CHECKS=257954400 NODES=104314	SAT TT=379.33 CHECKS=257954400 NODES=104314	SAT TT=36.522	SAT TT=34.615	? (TO) TT=1800.14	SAT TT=7.937	SAT TT=7.357 CHECKS=247088000 NODES=33420	SAT TT=7.292 CHECKS=247088000 NODES=33420
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=3.434	SAT TT=3.434 CHECKS=18011314 NODES=16131	SAT TT=3.633 CHECKS=20172002 NODES=17980	SAT TT=1568.82	SAT TT=4.509	SAT TT=4.469	SAT TT=53.737 NODES=96491	SAT TT=153.727 NODES=226088	SAT TT=127.108 CHECKS=115117 NODES=241734	SAT TT=969.109	SAT TT=218.491 CHECKS=137832798 NODES=69433	SAT TT=786.499 CHECKS=565976024 NODES=279985	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=1060.96	SAT TT=1090.51	SAT TT=78.839	SAT TT=875.901 CHECKS=563551001 NODES=279888	SAT TT=785.03 CHECKS=563551001 NODES=279888	SAT TT=1446.01	SAT TT=1438.98	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=80.056	SAT TT=13.198 CHECKS=423631000 NODES=83252	SAT TT=12.41 CHECKS=423631000 NODES=83252
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.65	SAT TT=12.931 CHECKS=82286081 NODES=75916	SAT TT=20.819 CHECKS=150450496 NODES=132600	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=11.483	SAT TT=10.988	SAT TT=6.292 NODES=10076	SAT TT=14.251 NODES=19365	SAT TT=10.55 CHECKS=113535 NODES=17361	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=28.8 CHECKS=16756721 NODES=9072	SAT TT=56.256 CHECKS=34409669 NODES=19317	SAT TT=27.615 CHECKS=18025352 NODES=8105	SAT TT=82.053	SAT TT=96.516	SAT TT=1.592	SAT TT=20.056 CHECKS=11083521 NODES=6264	SAT TT=19.223 CHECKS=11083521 NODES=6264	SAT TT=112.256	SAT TT=109.988	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=6.126	SAT TT=0.65 CHECKS=11769500 NODES=2657	SAT TT=0.651 CHECKS=11769500 NODES=2657
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-25_ext.xml	SAT TT=3.03	SAT TT=36.224 CHECKS=262688603 NODES=199452	SAT TT=3.047 CHECKS=16583477 NODES=12952	SAT TT=197.791	SAT TT=5.78	SAT TT=5.432	SAT TT=144.592 NODES=250758	SAT TT=83.317 NODES=113250	SAT TT=51.752 CHECKS=113864 NODES=93720	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=574.669 CHECKS=424243362 NODES=178510	SAT TT=156.48 CHECKS=106111961 NODES=49166	SAT TT=837.208 CHECKS=576815614 NODES=240755	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=31.576	SAT TT=21.435	SAT TT=147.904 CHECKS=100845936 NODES=45802	SAT TT=149.63 CHECKS=100845936 NODES=45802	SAT TT=130.072	SAT TT=142.915	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=34.116	SAT TT=3.03 CHECKS=101404000 NODES=17187	SAT TT=3.234 CHECKS=101404000 NODES=17187
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-27_ext.xml	SAT TT=7.25	SAT TT=7.25 CHECKS=45878860 NODES=34275	SAT TT=9.556 CHECKS=65312198 NODES=47368	SAT TT=536.471	SAT TT=9.148	SAT TT=8.711	SAT TT=168.97 NODES=303626	SAT TT=89.529 NODES=112741	SAT TT=62.387 CHECKS=113462 NODES=101771	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=923.929 CHECKS=594786797 NODES=252946	SAT TT=886.627 CHECKS=598924281 NODES=254388	SAT TT=559.473 CHECKS=376721533 NODES=145163	SAT TT=1413.22	SAT TT=45.12	SAT TT=12.989	SAT TT=805.105 CHECKS=580475073 NODES=244252	SAT TT=813.203 CHECKS=580475073 NODES=244252	SAT TT=66.677	SAT TT=69.016	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=33.811	SAT TT=15.497 CHECKS=517640000 NODES=82989	SAT TT=15.295 CHECKS=517640000 NODES=82989
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-29_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=10.542	UNSAT TT=30.125 CHECKS=216737041 NODES=151389	UNSAT TT=28.103 CHECKS=216856785 NODES=151207	UNSAT TT=889.596	UNSAT TT=14.98	UNSAT TT=15.939	UNSAT TT=221.032 NODES=378821	UNSAT TT=91.009 NODES=116222	UNSAT TT=69.395 CHECKS=114600 NODES=118887	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=677.244 CHECKS=428734079 NODES=177513	UNSAT TT=641.482 CHECKS=421768155 NODES=168073	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=991.637	? (TO) TT=1800.02	UNSAT TT=56.509	UNSAT TT=676.283 CHECKS=411755710 NODES=162879	UNSAT TT=643.626 CHECKS=411755710 NODES=162879	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=67.255	UNSAT TT=10.542 CHECKS=355981000 NODES=49365	UNSAT TT=9.843 CHECKS=355981000 NODES=49365
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-31_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.264	SAT TT=8.168 CHECKS=55840171 NODES=43591	SAT TT=26.415 CHECKS=187430057 NODES=144631	SAT TT=181.681	SAT TT=7.708	SAT TT=7.741	SAT TT=145.258 NODES=246713	SAT TT=48.221 NODES=63424	SAT TT=37.76 CHECKS=114935 NODES=61799	? (TO) TT=1800.16	SAT TT=250.902 CHECKS=150759120 NODES=68532	SAT TT=236.987 CHECKS=155511945 NODES=70302	SAT TT=1103.93 CHECKS=888211766 NODES=387943	SAT TT=370.984	SAT TT=1679.45	SAT TT=30.9	SAT TT=230.116 CHECKS=149991645 NODES=67503	SAT TT=212.599 CHECKS=149991645 NODES=67503	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=65.534	SAT TT=4.264 CHECKS=132367000 NODES=22003	SAT TT=3.943 CHECKS=132367000 NODES=22003
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-33_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=6.194	UNSAT TT=16.262 CHECKS=116730332 NODES=79007	UNSAT TT=15.826 CHECKS=123879979 NODES=83782	? (TO) TT=1800.02	UNSAT TT=8.929	UNSAT TT=8.978	UNSAT TT=94.406 NODES=157065	UNSAT TT=41.411 NODES=50341	UNSAT TT=40.113 CHECKS=113590 NODES=61278	? (TO) TT=1800.14	UNSAT TT=352.634 CHECKS=235877433 NODES=92045	UNSAT TT=338.801 CHECKS=245151223 NODES=91784	UNSAT TT=1563.83 CHECKS=1390127432 NODES=505295	UNSAT TT=444.332	UNSAT TT=951.259	UNSAT TT=31.932	UNSAT TT=289.569 CHECKS=214445354 NODES=79300	UNSAT TT=285.986 CHECKS=214445354 NODES=79300	? (TO) TT=1800.61	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=42.104	UNSAT TT=6.194 CHECKS=214966000 NODES=26627	UNSAT TT=6.141 CHECKS=214966000 NODES=26627
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-35_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.877	SAT TT=7.84 CHECKS=50721212 NODES=41008	SAT TT=12.388 CHECKS=83921137 NODES=67344	SAT TT=13.377	SAT TT=1.877	SAT TT=1.878	SAT TT=2.327 NODES=2573	SAT TT=16.082 NODES=18081	SAT TT=10.19 CHECKS=113984 NODES=16059	SAT TT=1197.19	SAT TT=145.98 CHECKS=101393169 NODES=41679	SAT TT=133.047 CHECKS=98228985 NODES=39532	SAT TT=333.356 CHECKS=260796634 NODES=102334	SAT TT=348.041	SAT TT=25.163	SAT TT=7.396	SAT TT=137.25 CHECKS=96428719 NODES=38129	SAT TT=130.157 CHECKS=96428719 NODES=38129	SAT TT=14.877	SAT TT=14.976	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=3.828	SAT TT=2.749 CHECKS=90159800 NODES=16726	SAT TT=2.757 CHECKS=90159800 NODES=16726
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-37_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=23.395	UNSAT TT=60.406 CHECKS=437131741 NODES=341181	UNSAT TT=58.995 CHECKS=431794356 NODES=339054	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=28.822	UNSAT TT=27.158	UNSAT TT=432.679 NODES=839734	UNSAT TT=173.832 NODES=241037	UNSAT TT=135.729 CHECKS=113761 NODES=247758	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=1132.96 CHECKS=887053877 NODES=390564	UNSAT TT=1255.85 CHECKS=892816262 NODES=393298	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=121.982	UNSAT TT=1159.3 CHECKS=882422354 NODES=387295	UNSAT TT=1153.46 CHECKS=882422354 NODES=387295	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=146.403	UNSAT TT=23.395 CHECKS=807045000 NODES=127976	UNSAT TT=23.303 CHECKS=807045000 NODES=127976
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-39_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.362	SAT TT=2.525 CHECKS=12235669 NODES=8525	SAT TT=1.717 CHECKS=5292650 NODES=3843	SAT TT=53.492	SAT TT=4.492	SAT TT=4.776	SAT TT=12.183 NODES=19251	SAT TT=9.379 NODES=9575	SAT TT=8.746 CHECKS=114501 NODES=11748	SAT TT=71.557	SAT TT=15.954 CHECKS=9420702 NODES=4580	SAT TT=16.837 CHECKS=9525258 NODES=4617	SAT TT=85.63 CHECKS=64591056 NODES=23752	SAT TT=25.407	SAT TT=109.73	SAT TT=0.717	SAT TT=5.251 CHECKS=3362377 NODES=1399	SAT TT=5.426 CHECKS=3362377 NODES=1399	SAT TT=28.338	SAT TT=27.89	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=11.666	SAT TT=0.362 CHECKS=2807810 NODES=465	SAT TT=0.334 CHECKS=2807810 NODES=465
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-3_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.388	UNSAT TT=3.424 CHECKS=19863309 NODES=11227	UNSAT TT=3.011 CHECKS=18767712 NODES=10456	UNSAT TT=248.801	UNSAT TT=4.994	UNSAT TT=5.161	UNSAT TT=18.284 NODES=26882	UNSAT TT=8.968 NODES=8497	UNSAT TT=7.935 CHECKS=115336 NODES=10214	UNSAT TT=198.639	UNSAT TT=57.281 CHECKS=46804167 NODES=14279	UNSAT TT=61.85 CHECKS=49448280 NODES=15679	UNSAT TT=263.42 CHECKS=225741937 NODES=61189	UNSAT TT=129.616	UNSAT TT=106.743	UNSAT TT=4.763	UNSAT TT=57.88 CHECKS=44559939 NODES=12508	UNSAT TT=53.939 CHECKS=44559939 NODES=12508	UNSAT TT=140.213	UNSAT TT=134.16	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=6.062	UNSAT TT=1.388 CHECKS=43170100 NODES=4020	UNSAT TT=1.313 CHECKS=43170100 NODES=4020
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-41_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=8.463	UNSAT TT=16.918 CHECKS=122084905 NODES=80555	UNSAT TT=16.092 CHECKS=125001341 NODES=82711	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=9.52	UNSAT TT=9.565	UNSAT TT=111.016 NODES=173984	UNSAT TT=50.757 NODES=59030	UNSAT TT=38.928 CHECKS=114561 NODES=61200	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=400.792 CHECKS=256355330 NODES=96081	UNSAT TT=410.155 CHECKS=257894932 NODES=97437	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=746.501	UNSAT TT=1172.53	UNSAT TT=28.288	UNSAT TT=456.095 CHECKS=314489578 NODES=118309	UNSAT TT=476.446 CHECKS=314489578 NODES=118309	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=34.774	UNSAT TT=8.463 CHECKS=294932000 NODES=36589	UNSAT TT=8.398 CHECKS=294932000 NODES=36589
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-43_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=11.113	UNSAT TT=25.143 CHECKS=193344143 NODES=153475	UNSAT TT=25.259 CHECKS=192572600 NODES=152761	UNSAT TT=734.514	UNSAT TT=15.321	UNSAT TT=14.991	UNSAT TT=180.098 NODES=329148	UNSAT TT=73.683 NODES=102684	UNSAT TT=65.869 CHECKS=114404 NODES=111087	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=536.063 CHECKS=441553387 NODES=183145	UNSAT TT=539.357 CHECKS=442886751 NODES=183782	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=1290.27	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=53.539	UNSAT TT=554.262 CHECKS=435856308 NODES=180444	UNSAT TT=489.052 CHECKS=435856308 NODES=180444	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=62.358	UNSAT TT=11.113 CHECKS=382119000 NODES=64479	UNSAT TT=10.265 CHECKS=382119000 NODES=64479
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-45_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.011	UNSAT TT=10.282 CHECKS=71731746 NODES=47252	UNSAT TT=9.748 CHECKS=67043715 NODES=44588	UNSAT TT=300.014	UNSAT TT=7.141	UNSAT TT=7.181	UNSAT TT=55.103 NODES=90006	UNSAT TT=28.829 NODES=33211	UNSAT TT=22.222 CHECKS=114015 NODES=33535	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=213.418 CHECKS=143727319 NODES=51568	UNSAT TT=216.113 CHECKS=145041855 NODES=52378	UNSAT TT=1026.61 CHECKS=700514440 NODES=243512	UNSAT TT=372.607	UNSAT TT=561.321	UNSAT TT=17.687	UNSAT TT=211.904 CHECKS=143021045 NODES=51092	UNSAT TT=196.913 CHECKS=143021045 NODES=51092	UNSAT TT=1373.59	UNSAT TT=1357.82	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=22.834	UNSAT TT=4.011 CHECKS=132626000 NODES=16694	UNSAT TT=3.942 CHECKS=132626000 NODES=16694
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-47_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.601	UNSAT TT=11.283 CHECKS=79065709 NODES=51311	UNSAT TT=10.178 CHECKS=75144446 NODES=48807	UNSAT TT=692.49	UNSAT TT=7.788	UNSAT TT=7.73	UNSAT TT=70.917 NODES=112443	UNSAT TT=29.751 NODES=33145	UNSAT TT=22.615 CHECKS=114449 NODES=33138	UNSAT TT=628.155	UNSAT TT=190.615 CHECKS=137346707 NODES=49554	UNSAT TT=194.268 CHECKS=140351644 NODES=51170	UNSAT TT=896.93 CHECKS=700182627 NODES=246375	UNSAT TT=196.123	UNSAT TT=417.726	UNSAT TT=21.908	UNSAT TT=257.915 CHECKS=171846504 NODES=61249	UNSAT TT=244.891 CHECKS=171846504 NODES=61249	UNSAT TT=617.097	UNSAT TT=645.338	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=23.27	UNSAT TT=4.601 CHECKS=155259000 NODES=19005	UNSAT TT=4.534 CHECKS=155259000 NODES=19005
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-49_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.651	SAT TT=17.474 CHECKS=131478861 NODES=105253	SAT TT=18.317 CHECKS=130741047 NODES=104586	SAT TT=186.27	SAT TT=12.521	SAT TT=11.906	SAT TT=124.156 NODES=224387	SAT TT=14.257 NODES=19582	SAT TT=11.531 CHECKS=113408 NODES=19933	SAT TT=1677.28	SAT TT=32.723 CHECKS=20108227 NODES=9501	SAT TT=34.196 CHECKS=20011663 NODES=9903	SAT TT=312.634 CHECKS=220240904 NODES=97330	SAT TT=388.406	SAT TT=466.411	SAT TT=16.319	SAT TT=19.28 CHECKS=12238851 NODES=5464	SAT TT=18.813 CHECKS=12238851 NODES=5464	SAT TT=17.554	SAT TT=16.894	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=29.927	SAT TT=0.651 CHECKS=14113800 NODES=2521	SAT TT=0.638 CHECKS=14113800 NODES=2521
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-51_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.272	SAT TT=7.55 CHECKS=52238763 NODES=43073	SAT TT=1.272 CHECKS=2057113 NODES=1666	SAT TT=291.703	SAT TT=4.477	SAT TT=4.704	SAT TT=101.912 NODES=197535	SAT TT=84.853 NODES=125183	SAT TT=78.193 CHECKS=113933 NODES=139018	SAT TT=495.92	SAT TT=538.803 CHECKS=424405691 NODES=200608	SAT TT=577.164 CHECKS=441809053 NODES=208066	SAT TT=591.364 CHECKS=411696134 NODES=183410	SAT TT=672.473	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=13.937	SAT TT=79.489 CHECKS=53364550 NODES=25302	SAT TT=79.027 CHECKS=53364550 NODES=25302	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.16	SAT TT=28.803	SAT TT=1.849 CHECKS=54219500 NODES=10342	SAT TT=1.853 CHECKS=54219500 NODES=10342
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-53_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=12.787	UNSAT TT=37.926 CHECKS=275117787 NODES=220885	UNSAT TT=34.023 CHECKS=263340181 NODES=214428	UNSAT TT=766.689	UNSAT TT=18.929	UNSAT TT=18.691	UNSAT TT=208.654 NODES=358198	UNSAT TT=129.389 NODES=163933	UNSAT TT=85.657 CHECKS=113082 NODES=152505	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=646.1 CHECKS=537502951 NODES=232610	UNSAT TT=659.227 CHECKS=530157309 NODES=230894	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=1094.56	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=77.628	UNSAT TT=614.837 CHECKS=535064104 NODES=217725	UNSAT TT=661.392 CHECKS=535064104 NODES=217725	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=92.186	UNSAT TT=12.787 CHECKS=443840000 NODES=77100	UNSAT TT=12.555 CHECKS=443840000 NODES=77100
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-55_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.218	SAT TT=8.305 CHECKS=58062084 NODES=44047	SAT TT=4.717 CHECKS=28009779 NODES=20927	SAT TT=576.623	SAT TT=4.327	SAT TT=4.557	SAT TT=59.117 NODES=101458	SAT TT=14.124 NODES=18085	SAT TT=12.578 CHECKS=113735 NODES=20196	SAT TT=83.652	SAT TT=437.341 CHECKS=295428665 NODES=121162	SAT TT=405.522 CHECKS=297276567 NODES=122098	SAT TT=1123.01 CHECKS=777403083 NODES=309903	SAT TT=222.182	SAT TT=120.942	SAT TT=7.304	SAT TT=434.805 CHECKS=292664361 NODES=119252	SAT TT=390.774 CHECKS=292664361 NODES=119252	SAT TT=4.812	SAT TT=4.76	? (TO) TT=1800.15	SAT TT=4.218	SAT TT=7.692 CHECKS=260052000 NODES=42053	SAT TT=7.573 CHECKS=260052000 NODES=42053
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-57_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.929	UNSAT TT=11.604 CHECKS=79975288 NODES=52330	UNSAT TT=11.094 CHECKS=83848818 NODES=54368	UNSAT TT=236.185	UNSAT TT=8.206	UNSAT TT=8.182	UNSAT TT=72.08 NODES=113846	UNSAT TT=35.021 NODES=40151	UNSAT TT=27.831 CHECKS=115016 NODES=44171	UNSAT TT=1309.61	UNSAT TT=219.179 CHECKS=138223826 NODES=51308	UNSAT TT=214.09 CHECKS=137812483 NODES=51475	UNSAT TT=1254.51 CHECKS=849091233 NODES=309716	UNSAT TT=277.186	UNSAT TT=324.364	UNSAT TT=21.273	UNSAT TT=256.942 CHECKS=181410035 NODES=65746	UNSAT TT=262.207 CHECKS=181410035 NODES=65746	UNSAT TT=547.542	UNSAT TT=538.062	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=24.844	UNSAT TT=4.929 CHECKS=163708000 NODES=22260	UNSAT TT=4.867 CHECKS=163708000 NODES=22260
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-59_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.388	UNSAT TT=9.067 CHECKS=63835488 NODES=42620	UNSAT TT=8.37 CHECKS=63277783 NODES=42162	UNSAT TT=210.981	UNSAT TT=6.206	UNSAT TT=6.473	UNSAT TT=42.068 NODES=67689	UNSAT TT=22.429 NODES=24784	UNSAT TT=18.729 CHECKS=115140 NODES=27748	UNSAT TT=1030.75	UNSAT TT=168.777 CHECKS=117348011 NODES=43211	UNSAT TT=166.623 CHECKS=118744733 NODES=43122	UNSAT TT=737.611 CHECKS=563722557 NODES=194083	UNSAT TT=271.414	UNSAT TT=299.853	UNSAT TT=17.891	UNSAT TT=157.497 CHECKS=116372105 NODES=40889	UNSAT TT=154.461 CHECKS=116372105 NODES=40889	UNSAT TT=428.109	UNSAT TT=440.134	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=23.231	UNSAT TT=3.388 CHECKS=114511000 NODES=14977	UNSAT TT=3.378 CHECKS=114511000 NODES=14977
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-5_ext.xml	SAT TT=10.966	SAT TT=19.75 CHECKS=137138630 NODES=122012	SAT TT=14.924 CHECKS=96691116 NODES=85097	SAT TT=722.76	SAT TT=12.224	SAT TT=12.479	SAT TT=5.165 NODES=8444	SAT TT=139.422 NODES=204326	SAT TT=127.576 CHECKS=113946 NODES=240046	SAT TT=791.87	SAT TT=753.51 CHECKS=459728314 NODES=232222	SAT TT=604.068 CHECKS=430271065 NODES=219407	SAT TT=47.55 CHECKS=30182527 NODES=16547	SAT TT=710.553	SAT TT=17.85	SAT TT=79.076	SAT TT=756.469 CHECKS=485222297 NODES=245560	SAT TT=710.644 CHECKS=485222297 NODES=245560	SAT TT=1105.33	SAT TT=1066.42	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=133.192	SAT TT=10.966 CHECKS=352186000 NODES=73999	SAT TT=10.358 CHECKS=352186000 NODES=73999
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-61_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=9.167	UNSAT TT=27.172 CHECKS=207196019 NODES=155815	UNSAT TT=26.622 CHECKS=190111187 NODES=146189	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=14.619	UNSAT TT=14.421	UNSAT TT=148.046 NODES=278397	UNSAT TT=64.227 NODES=87694	UNSAT TT=69.822 CHECKS=115438 NODES=118216	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=472.472 CHECKS=336513732 NODES=145700	UNSAT TT=485.521 CHECKS=336062710 NODES=145326	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=724.388	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=43.679	UNSAT TT=543.721 CHECKS=352503891 NODES=162404	UNSAT TT=516.13 CHECKS=352503891 NODES=162404	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.16	UNSAT TT=61.673	UNSAT TT=9.167 CHECKS=299614000 NODES=52486	UNSAT TT=8.402 CHECKS=299614000 NODES=52486
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-63_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.447	SAT TT=2.447 CHECKS=9923126 NODES=7885	SAT TT=7.481 CHECKS=47184739 NODES=35458	SAT TT=231.696	SAT TT=9.799	SAT TT=10.38	SAT TT=85.926 NODES=144391	SAT TT=51.69 NODES=63197	SAT TT=39.439 CHECKS=114293 NODES=66722	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=518.595 CHECKS=360280013 NODES=152769	SAT TT=529.712 CHECKS=352715661 NODES=150166	SAT TT=1002.65 CHECKS=797517025 NODES=320246	SAT TT=275.763	SAT TT=864.036	SAT TT=42.146	SAT TT=391.432 CHECKS=261956564 NODES=107802	SAT TT=346.343 CHECKS=261956564 NODES=107802	SAT TT=373.07	SAT TT=386.317	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=59.049	SAT TT=7.277 CHECKS=245465000 NODES=39608	SAT TT=7.239 CHECKS=245465000 NODES=39608
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-65_ext.xml	SAT TT=3.885	SAT TT=11.475 CHECKS=80702431 NODES=59625	SAT TT=22.272 CHECKS=161078957 NODES=118607	SAT TT=338.483	SAT TT=3.926	SAT TT=3.885	SAT TT=30.572 NODES=54100	SAT TT=116.921 NODES=159319	SAT TT=96.509 CHECKS=113862 NODES=165813	SAT TT=1142.65	SAT TT=73.727 CHECKS=48563951 NODES=21724	SAT TT=569.54 CHECKS=385773348 NODES=156171	SAT TT=243.59 CHECKS=167025703 NODES=68030	SAT TT=345.594	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=20.899	SAT TT=580.776 CHECKS=382404454 NODES=153173	SAT TT=546.015 CHECKS=382404454 NODES=153173	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=27.922	SAT TT=10.104 CHECKS=350668000 NODES=53706	SAT TT=10.177 CHECKS=350668000 NODES=53706
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-67_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=7.984	UNSAT TT=23.78 CHECKS=185396294 NODES=131173	UNSAT TT=23.936 CHECKS=187142838 NODES=132082	UNSAT TT=594.055	UNSAT TT=14.551	UNSAT TT=14.501	UNSAT TT=127.891 NODES=214879	UNSAT TT=64.193 NODES=78057	UNSAT TT=60.38 CHECKS=113298 NODES=96248	? (TO) TT=1800.14	UNSAT TT=444.659 CHECKS=286017802 NODES=115787	UNSAT TT=452.658 CHECKS=295310520 NODES=119744	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=563.903	UNSAT TT=1148.44	UNSAT TT=44.104	UNSAT TT=466.434 CHECKS=296227534 NODES=120259	UNSAT TT=417.437 CHECKS=296227534 NODES=120259	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=49.801	UNSAT TT=7.984 CHECKS=265440000 NODES=42639	UNSAT TT=7.865 CHECKS=265440000 NODES=42639
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-69_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.017	SAT TT=5.488 CHECKS=35628131 NODES=26649	SAT TT=6.793 CHECKS=46876711 NODES=34984	SAT TT=235.577	SAT TT=9.902	SAT TT=9.813	SAT TT=12.956 NODES=21048	SAT TT=24.979 NODES=31448	SAT TT=24.458 CHECKS=113712 NODES=40344	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=248.102 CHECKS=158618960 NODES=66473	SAT TT=236.664 CHECKS=159443497 NODES=66808	SAT TT=659.542 CHECKS=422236863 NODES=167593	SAT TT=533.408	SAT TT=47.672	SAT TT=21.417	SAT TT=235.737 CHECKS=151584611 NODES=63238	SAT TT=228.672 CHECKS=151584611 NODES=63238	SAT TT=1065.27	SAT TT=1069.94	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=18.831	SAT TT=4.017 CHECKS=129584000 NODES=20764	SAT TT=3.939 CHECKS=129584000 NODES=20764
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-71_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.395	SAT TT=4.217 CHECKS=26539875 NODES=19106	SAT TT=4.284 CHECKS=26544693 NODES=19060	SAT TT=37.242	SAT TT=4.114	SAT TT=4.342	SAT TT=39.679 NODES=67220	SAT TT=17.248 NODES=21855	SAT TT=10.982 CHECKS=113752 NODES=16248	SAT TT=82.616	SAT TT=14.409 CHECKS=9246118 NODES=4545	SAT TT=150.666 CHECKS=101166948 NODES=44373	SAT TT=176.322 CHECKS=120074481 NODES=49399	SAT TT=32.059	SAT TT=434.722	SAT TT=1.395	SAT TT=8.551 CHECKS=5229010 NODES=2488	SAT TT=8.738 CHECKS=5229010 NODES=2488	SAT TT=15.277	SAT TT=15.77	SAT TT=1711.52	SAT TT=39.924	SAT TT=0.395 CHECKS=4572690 NODES=790	SAT TT=0.409 CHECKS=4572690 NODES=790
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-73_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.611	SAT TT=1.611 CHECKS=4836640 NODES=3554	SAT TT=1.618 CHECKS=5152832 NODES=3753	SAT TT=672.19	SAT TT=6.13	SAT TT=6.159	SAT TT=3.875 NODES=6232	SAT TT=44.387 NODES=58265	SAT TT=51.951 CHECKS=114158 NODES=81812	SAT TT=685.687	SAT TT=484.384 CHECKS=297685887 NODES=126736	SAT TT=438.49 CHECKS=302867605 NODES=127600	SAT TT=1250.05 CHECKS=1011457298 NODES=403803	SAT TT=369.389	SAT TT=90.901	SAT TT=33.944	SAT TT=455.782 CHECKS=283687482 NODES=119010	SAT TT=441.874 CHECKS=283687482 NODES=119010	SAT TT=503.835	SAT TT=529.21	? (TO) TT=1800.14	SAT TT=39.802	SAT TT=7.272 CHECKS=240001000 NODES=40355	SAT TT=6.854 CHECKS=240001000 NODES=40355
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-75_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.945	SAT TT=7.439 CHECKS=52479750 NODES=37857	SAT TT=10.335 CHECKS=76907057 NODES=54411	SAT TT=516.202	SAT TT=4.629	SAT TT=4.339	SAT TT=18.044 NODES=28877	SAT TT=54.672 NODES=67368	SAT TT=47.269 CHECKS=113853 NODES=74825	SAT TT=1085.82	SAT TT=309.117 CHECKS=195642028 NODES=78317	SAT TT=295.689 CHECKS=198790213 NODES=80325	SAT TT=407.431 CHECKS=294944699 NODES=111863	SAT TT=21.435	SAT TT=790.267	SAT TT=14.144	SAT TT=163.851 CHECKS=106078394 NODES=40976	SAT TT=161.899 CHECKS=106078394 NODES=40976	? (TO) TT=1800.15	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=22.124	SAT TT=2.945 CHECKS=92854100 NODES=12858	SAT TT=2.894 CHECKS=92854100 NODES=12858
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-77_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=8.546	UNSAT TT=20.926 CHECKS=155025262 NODES=110059	UNSAT TT=20.105 CHECKS=159859105 NODES=113845	UNSAT TT=743.669	UNSAT TT=12.542	UNSAT TT=12.634	UNSAT TT=140.201 NODES=251046	UNSAT TT=62.355 NODES=77360	UNSAT TT=52.298 CHECKS=115042 NODES=89462	? (TO) TT=1800.15	UNSAT TT=440.61 CHECKS=355049376 NODES=130185	UNSAT TT=470.667 CHECKS=362563603 NODES=139500	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=756.141	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=38.875	UNSAT TT=477.524 CHECKS=352500784 NODES=135688	UNSAT TT=483.716 CHECKS=352500784 NODES=135688	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=46.695	UNSAT TT=8.546 CHECKS=317585000 NODES=44812	UNSAT TT=8.911 CHECKS=317585000 NODES=44812
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-79_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.852	SAT TT=20.514 CHECKS=153638184 NODES=124105	SAT TT=20.226 CHECKS=142215636 NODES=115389	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=5.171	SAT TT=5.538	SAT TT=134.857 NODES=233233	SAT TT=43.564 NODES=58298	SAT TT=61.639 CHECKS=113171 NODES=102863	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=327.912 CHECKS=240141931 NODES=109954	SAT TT=868.062 CHECKS=654646323 NODES=290841	SAT TT=153.952 CHECKS=125526705 NODES=53180	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=1.033	SAT TT=40.589 CHECKS=26633062 NODES=10880	SAT TT=37.888 CHECKS=26633062 NODES=10880	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=1.251	SAT TT=0.852 CHECKS=20213100 NODES=3275	SAT TT=0.791 CHECKS=20213100 NODES=3275
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-7_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.814	SAT TT=9.928 CHECKS=68066710 NODES=50019	SAT TT=1.814 CHECKS=6202499 NODES=4478	SAT TT=187.482	SAT TT=3.461	SAT TT=3.725	SAT TT=40.325 NODES=75653	SAT TT=27.788 NODES=35954	SAT TT=24.29 CHECKS=114589 NODES=38559	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=166.602 CHECKS=112661880 NODES=45005	SAT TT=171.035 CHECKS=115719318 NODES=46601	SAT TT=152.152 CHECKS=106418916 NODES=39914	SAT TT=21.89	SAT TT=346.367	SAT TT=4.721	SAT TT=173.004 CHECKS=119427513 NODES=48054	SAT TT=180.521 CHECKS=119427513 NODES=48054	SAT TT=351.164	SAT TT=337.446	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=9.104	SAT TT=3.423 CHECKS=112652000 NODES=17001	SAT TT=3.485 CHECKS=112652000 NODES=17001
tightness/tightness0.5/ rand-2-40-25-180-500-9_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.019	SAT TT=4.189 CHECKS=25613935 NODES=19129	SAT TT=10.766 CHECKS=80109142 NODES=59920	SAT TT=391.445	SAT TT=3.934	SAT TT=3.865	SAT TT=61.259 NODES=106613	SAT TT=5.995 NODES=6420	SAT TT=17.444 CHECKS=114428 NODES=27755	SAT TT=183.074	SAT TT=242.246 CHECKS=174608598 NODES=68328	SAT TT=230.972 CHECKS=173436638 NODES=67841	SAT TT=116.666 CHECKS=88599532 NODES=33288	SAT TT=181.026	SAT TT=235.302	SAT TT=2.497	SAT TT=45.352 CHECKS=31914981 NODES=11535	SAT TT=43.426 CHECKS=31914981 NODES=11535	SAT TT=176.69	SAT TT=180.154	SAT TT=1066.13	SAT TT=3.575	SAT TT=1.019 CHECKS=29187500 NODES=3817	SAT TT=1.088 CHECKS=29187500 NODES=3817
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-11_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.903	SAT TT=2.538 CHECKS=14297811 NODES=7290	SAT TT=2.328 CHECKS=14093394 NODES=7185	SAT TT=171.659	SAT TT=7.234	SAT TT=6.855	SAT TT=12.498 NODES=16866	SAT TT=15.119 NODES=11734	SAT TT=4.418 CHECKS=154755 NODES=4999	SAT TT=1045.86	SAT TT=24.741 CHECKS=24002233 NODES=5660	SAT TT=30.349 CHECKS=27788179 NODES=7474	SAT TT=432.621 CHECKS=574340394 NODES=101161	SAT TT=26.895	SAT TT=22.265	SAT TT=13.256	SAT TT=20.848 CHECKS=22249003 NODES=4436	SAT TT=22.205 CHECKS=22249003 NODES=4436	SAT TT=30.131	SAT TT=29.494	? (TO) TT=1800.96	SAT TT=13.736	SAT TT=0.903 CHECKS=20858100 NODES=1377	SAT TT=0.945 CHECKS=20858100 NODES=1377
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-13_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=6.073	UNSAT TT=8.578 CHECKS=69667265 NODES=36431	UNSAT TT=7.311 CHECKS=62924169 NODES=33312	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=8.93	UNSAT TT=9.439	UNSAT TT=55.895 NODES=83422	UNSAT TT=31.102 NODES=25223	UNSAT TT=18.293 CHECKS=154037 NODES=26611	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=145.726 CHECKS=177601502 NODES=37902	UNSAT TT=146.057 CHECKS=166306607 NODES=36152	UNSAT TT=877.733 CHECKS=1112265011 NODES=230957	UNSAT TT=265.777	UNSAT TT=209.479	UNSAT TT=20.821	UNSAT TT=235.999 CHECKS=286746824 NODES=56494	UNSAT TT=233.365 CHECKS=286746824 NODES=56494	UNSAT TT=392.685	UNSAT TT=379.48	? (TO) TT=1800.51	UNSAT TT=21.557	UNSAT TT=6.073 CHECKS=263747000 NODES=19963	UNSAT TT=6.11 CHECKS=262302000 NODES=19664
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-15_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.098	UNSAT TT=7.661 CHECKS=60943647 NODES=32175	UNSAT TT=7.448 CHECKS=60642964 NODES=31876	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=10.279	UNSAT TT=9.728	UNSAT TT=42.18 NODES=63985	UNSAT TT=22.148 NODES=18624	UNSAT TT=16.567 CHECKS=154186 NODES=21974	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=138.747 CHECKS=166685098 NODES=37566	UNSAT TT=146.995 CHECKS=165521745 NODES=36332	UNSAT TT=771.137 CHECKS=948275465 NODES=183031	UNSAT TT=218.523	UNSAT TT=221.404	UNSAT TT=15.419	UNSAT TT=146.533 CHECKS=166034046 NODES=33545	UNSAT TT=130.109 CHECKS=166034046 NODES=33545	UNSAT TT=744.11	UNSAT TT=731.963	? (TO) TT=1800.97	UNSAT TT=17.092	UNSAT TT=4.098 CHECKS=163977000 NODES=13483	UNSAT TT=4.075 CHECKS=163977000 NODES=13483
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.145	SAT TT=5.059 CHECKS=34127806 NODES=21089	SAT TT=4.145 CHECKS=30445437 NODES=18972	SAT TT=676.246	SAT TT=6.104	SAT TT=6.199	SAT TT=13.474 NODES=19992	SAT TT=14.87 NODES=12482	SAT TT=9.771 CHECKS=153733 NODES=13544	SAT TT=699.923	SAT TT=28.11 CHECKS=26074375 NODES=7915	SAT TT=31.907 CHECKS=32821665 NODES=9417	SAT TT=166.611 CHECKS=214314101 NODES=46296	SAT TT=514.464	SAT TT=4.771	SAT TT=24.343	SAT TT=233.597 CHECKS=282502579 NODES=50160	SAT TT=222.005 CHECKS=282502579 NODES=50160	SAT TT=67.677	SAT TT=70.994	? (TO) TT=1800.95	SAT TT=20.857	SAT TT=6.039 CHECKS=256831000 NODES=15797	SAT TT=5.613 CHECKS=256831000 NODES=15797
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-19_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.055	SAT TT=1.055 CHECKS=1036522 NODES=761	SAT TT=1.888 CHECKS=6807058 NODES=5071	SAT TT=344.833	SAT TT=6.009	SAT TT=6.451	SAT TT=4.565 NODES=6784	SAT TT=2.27 NODES=1305	SAT TT=3.834 CHECKS=152510 NODES=4923	SAT TT=909.521	SAT TT=114.337 CHECKS=121738320 NODES=37347	SAT TT=123.606 CHECKS=119488101 NODES=37113	SAT TT=260.442 CHECKS=285998134 NODES=81836	SAT TT=1152.89	SAT TT=92.528	SAT TT=24.289	SAT TT=120.578 CHECKS=127135122 NODES=35644	SAT TT=119.864 CHECKS=127135122 NODES=35644	SAT TT=22.705	SAT TT=23.908	? (TO) TT=1801.01	SAT TT=16.668	SAT TT=2.509 CHECKS=84777600 NODES=12335	SAT TT=2.599 CHECKS=84777600 NODES=12335
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-1_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.326	SAT TT=8.68 CHECKS=68704923 NODES=36930	SAT TT=6.385 CHECKS=49266588 NODES=27208	SAT TT=67.464	SAT TT=7.107	SAT TT=6.776	SAT TT=20.884 NODES=27507	SAT TT=18.518 NODES=14654	SAT TT=10.969 CHECKS=152223 NODES=15416	SAT TT=845.561	SAT TT=52.977 CHECKS=48729041 NODES=11814	SAT TT=79.442 CHECKS=87490728 NODES=20041	SAT TT=88.849 CHECKS=97272051 NODES=20753	SAT TT=6.79	SAT TT=85.119	SAT TT=8.876	SAT TT=43.137 CHECKS=38178211 NODES=8453	SAT TT=42.16 CHECKS=38178211 NODES=8453	SAT TT=9.517	SAT TT=9.09	? (TO) TT=1801.02	SAT TT=9.154	SAT TT=1.326 CHECKS=39752300 NODES=3079	SAT TT=1.407 CHECKS=39752300 NODES=3079
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.907	SAT TT=22.33 CHECKS=197968679 NODES=132886	SAT TT=25.024 CHECKS=208692708 NODES=139871	SAT TT=291.378	SAT TT=10.852	SAT TT=10.877	SAT TT=159.65 NODES=239341	SAT TT=16.982 NODES=17647	SAT TT=12.052 CHECKS=153201 NODES=18497	? (TO) TT=1800.16	SAT TT=223.149 CHECKS=226178938 NODES=63113	SAT TT=239.14 CHECKS=247617069 NODES=69127	SAT TT=345.514 CHECKS=381362809 NODES=108476	SAT TT=47.307	SAT TT=111.629	SAT TT=8.81	SAT TT=98.709 CHECKS=105247794 NODES=29321	SAT TT=93.213 CHECKS=105247794 NODES=29321	SAT TT=54.394	SAT TT=64.268	? (TO) TT=1801.03	SAT TT=20.839	SAT TT=2.907 CHECKS=99791300 NODES=10495	SAT TT=2.881 CHECKS=99791300 NODES=10495
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-23_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=13.086	UNSAT TT=33.933 CHECKS=325473646 NODES=167734	UNSAT TT=35.048 CHECKS=310522329 NODES=158756	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=18.401	UNSAT TT=19.317	UNSAT TT=226.935 NODES=359130	UNSAT TT=114.554 NODES=125500	UNSAT TT=80.434 CHECKS=152358 NODES=131862	? (TO) TT=1800.14	UNSAT TT=662.82 CHECKS=731400411 NODES=164233	UNSAT TT=640.484 CHECKS=719241660 NODES=160374	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=1737.31	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=97.933	UNSAT TT=695.71 CHECKS=721812392 NODES=160602	UNSAT TT=646.276 CHECKS=721812392 NODES=160602	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.99	UNSAT TT=109.708	UNSAT TT=13.086 CHECKS=542782000 NODES=41160	UNSAT TT=13.132 CHECKS=542782000 NODES=41160
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-25_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.95	UNSAT TT=4.676 CHECKS=35272682 NODES=15319	UNSAT TT=5.096 CHECKS=38877392 NODES=16778	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=16.25	UNSAT TT=15.373	UNSAT TT=28.434 NODES=37370	UNSAT TT=14.434 NODES=11085	UNSAT TT=9.893 CHECKS=154012 NODES=11448	UNSAT TT=1455.68	UNSAT TT=87.999 CHECKS=104485822 NODES=18716	UNSAT TT=107.188 CHECKS=106752673 NODES=20338	UNSAT TT=494.494 CHECKS=553136732 NODES=95441	UNSAT TT=181.638	UNSAT TT=45.228	UNSAT TT=11.413	UNSAT TT=126.421 CHECKS=116290084 NODES=20543	UNSAT TT=125.49 CHECKS=116290084 NODES=20543	UNSAT TT=108.398	UNSAT TT=106.533	? (TO) TT=1801	UNSAT TT=12.554	UNSAT TT=2.95 CHECKS=110590000 NODES=5574	UNSAT TT=2.756 CHECKS=110590000 NODES=5574
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-27_ext.xml	SAT TT=8.106	SAT TT=12.51 CHECKS=103564816 NODES=56391	SAT TT=19.74 CHECKS=170419608 NODES=90551	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=8.61	SAT TT=8.521	SAT TT=96.942 NODES=149810	SAT TT=42.218 NODES=35764	SAT TT=30.395 CHECKS=152846 NODES=45636	SAT TT=1725.72	SAT TT=409.148 CHECKS=461978994 NODES=99388	SAT TT=72.37 CHECKS=66687602 NODES=14805	SAT TT=283.779 CHECKS=296400405 NODES=61609	SAT TT=795.774	SAT TT=53.031	SAT TT=20.364	SAT TT=414.171 CHECKS=470799457 NODES=99628	SAT TT=426.511 CHECKS=470799457 NODES=99628	SAT TT=1440.57	SAT TT=1438.78	? (TO) TT=1800.99	SAT TT=24.398	SAT TT=8.106 CHECKS=338783000 NODES=28266	SAT TT=8.019 CHECKS=338783000 NODES=28266
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-29_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=13.621	UNSAT TT=27.86 CHECKS=259045782 NODES=139440	UNSAT TT=30.559 CHECKS=283249005 NODES=152173	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=18.627	UNSAT TT=18.989	UNSAT TT=169.587 NODES=256625	UNSAT TT=89.279 NODES=94130	UNSAT TT=61.217 CHECKS=152789 NODES=98932	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=603.539 CHECKS=608550529 NODES=140638	UNSAT TT=621.484 CHECKS=618196790 NODES=144006	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=64.341	UNSAT TT=568.586 CHECKS=617394855 NODES=140410	UNSAT TT=573.157 CHECKS=617394855 NODES=140410	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1801.03	UNSAT TT=75.884	UNSAT TT=13.621 CHECKS=569900000 NODES=43696	UNSAT TT=13.617 CHECKS=569900000 NODES=43696
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-31_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=16.796	UNSAT TT=25.789 CHECKS=213758673 NODES=128143	UNSAT TT=23.991 CHECKS=200917444 NODES=120299	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=16.796	UNSAT TT=16.933	UNSAT TT=217.847 NODES=331272	UNSAT TT=99.351 NODES=91605	UNSAT TT=51.203 CHECKS=152762 NODES=88059	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=498.967 CHECKS=560153306 NODES=138439	UNSAT TT=529.59 CHECKS=575717772 NODES=142237	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=1227.8	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=52.55	UNSAT TT=990.023 CHECKS=979625786 NODES=235626	UNSAT TT=915.818 CHECKS=979625786 NODES=235626	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.86	UNSAT TT=69.282	UNSAT TT=20.317 CHECKS=820483000 NODES=60564	UNSAT TT=20.102 CHECKS=820483000 NODES=60564
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-33_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.5	UNSAT TT=7.776 CHECKS=67032160 NODES=30226	UNSAT TT=6.888 CHECKS=60808136 NODES=28305	? (TO) TT=1800.02	UNSAT TT=10.361	UNSAT TT=9.761	UNSAT TT=58.57 NODES=83958	UNSAT TT=27.558 NODES=21439	UNSAT TT=17.604 CHECKS=153415 NODES=22873	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=175.608 CHECKS=188291549 NODES=33820	UNSAT TT=155.116 CHECKS=162667745 NODES=30391	UNSAT TT=855.79 CHECKS=929308061 NODES=167352	UNSAT TT=215.817	UNSAT TT=98.412	UNSAT TT=18.322	UNSAT TT=138.249 CHECKS=159803972 NODES=28924	UNSAT TT=128.66 CHECKS=159803972 NODES=28924	UNSAT TT=298.525	UNSAT TT=299.478	? (TO) TT=1800.95	UNSAT TT=22.297	UNSAT TT=3.5 CHECKS=147293000 NODES=8035	UNSAT TT=3.719 CHECKS=147293000 NODES=8035
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-35_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.827	SAT TT=6.134 CHECKS=50056424 NODES=22516	SAT TT=1.86 CHECKS=8142178 NODES=3904	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=8.71	SAT TT=8.352	SAT TT=5.188 NODES=5650	SAT TT=14.4 NODES=10180	SAT TT=5.325 CHECKS=153488 NODES=6179	SAT TT=34.039	SAT TT=44.892 CHECKS=44522601 NODES=9777	SAT TT=81.573 CHECKS=90027531 NODES=16336	SAT TT=156.699 CHECKS=171297808 NODES=27599	SAT TT=103.724	SAT TT=47.825	SAT TT=18.033	SAT TT=71.634 CHECKS=70466280 NODES=11967	SAT TT=61.223 CHECKS=70466280 NODES=11967	SAT TT=105.261	SAT TT=121.073	? (TO) TT=1801.02	SAT TT=20.641	SAT TT=1.827 CHECKS=63287900 NODES=3125	SAT TT=1.831 CHECKS=63287900 NODES=3125
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-37_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=9.194	UNSAT TT=15.926 CHECKS=132676416 NODES=78434	UNSAT TT=15.327 CHECKS=130974824 NODES=76634	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=14.779	UNSAT TT=14.459	UNSAT TT=150.628 NODES=217035	UNSAT TT=53.082 NODES=51229	UNSAT TT=33.78 CHECKS=156091 NODES=53983	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=316.734 CHECKS=332037472 NODES=89946	UNSAT TT=398.626 CHECKS=431083872 NODES=113107	UNSAT TT=1353 CHECKS=1605269676 NODES=388587	UNSAT TT=897.415	UNSAT TT=686.214	UNSAT TT=40.652	UNSAT TT=435.45 CHECKS=416060073 NODES=108753	UNSAT TT=392.34 CHECKS=416060073 NODES=108753	UNSAT TT=1761.79	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1801	UNSAT TT=41.319	UNSAT TT=9.194 CHECKS=364273000 NODES=28041	UNSAT TT=9.175 CHECKS=364273000 NODES=28041
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-39_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.89	UNSAT TT=4.992 CHECKS=38098172 NODES=15487	UNSAT TT=5.044 CHECKS=43370687 NODES=17292	UNSAT TT=104.381	UNSAT TT=11.078	UNSAT TT=10.564	UNSAT TT=18.934 NODES=24850	UNSAT TT=12.5 NODES=8477	UNSAT TT=9.735 CHECKS=153532 NODES=10844	UNSAT TT=794.001	UNSAT TT=77.508 CHECKS=76111790 NODES=14753	UNSAT TT=74.265 CHECKS=76002568 NODES=14001	UNSAT TT=503.466 CHECKS=607286739 NODES=95789	UNSAT TT=75.806	UNSAT TT=25.805	UNSAT TT=8.634	UNSAT TT=64.265 CHECKS=71815189 NODES=12136	UNSAT TT=66.188 CHECKS=71815189 NODES=12136	UNSAT TT=52.881	UNSAT TT=51.426	? (TO) TT=1801.13	UNSAT TT=10.101	UNSAT TT=1.89 CHECKS=63092000 NODES=3655	UNSAT TT=1.881 CHECKS=63092000 NODES=3655
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-3_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.38	UNSAT TT=2.91 CHECKS=19183832 NODES=7316	UNSAT TT=2.958 CHECKS=19808004 NODES=7567	UNSAT TT=405.953	UNSAT TT=11.019	UNSAT TT=11.559	UNSAT TT=12.333 NODES=16044	UNSAT TT=8.449 NODES=5350	UNSAT TT=6.314 CHECKS=156841 NODES=6287	UNSAT TT=421.425	UNSAT TT=49.897 CHECKS=50945827 NODES=8864	UNSAT TT=52.567 CHECKS=53591232 NODES=9874	UNSAT TT=359.602 CHECKS=394526429 NODES=53551	UNSAT TT=44.129	UNSAT TT=13.976	UNSAT TT=6.535	UNSAT TT=41.268 CHECKS=44934217 NODES=6495	UNSAT TT=41.936 CHECKS=44934217 NODES=6495	UNSAT TT=25.603	UNSAT TT=26.063	? (TO) TT=1800.97	UNSAT TT=7.393	UNSAT TT=1.38 CHECKS=40952600 NODES=1739	UNSAT TT=1.375 CHECKS=40952600 NODES=1739
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-41_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.979	SAT TT=3.643 CHECKS=27704561 NODES=12113	SAT TT=5.424 CHECKS=47243891 NODES=20545	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=8.861	SAT TT=8.48	SAT TT=2.326 NODES=2094	SAT TT=7.386 NODES=4867	SAT TT=7.781 CHECKS=152611 NODES=9562	SAT TT=102.502	SAT TT=99.02 CHECKS=93591309 NODES=18535	SAT TT=85.514 CHECKS=93254068 NODES=17915	SAT TT=103.521 CHECKS=101617414 NODES=16719	SAT TT=114.701	SAT TT=25.067	SAT TT=5.165	SAT TT=144.541 CHECKS=132833233 NODES=24658	SAT TT=135.174 CHECKS=132833233 NODES=24658	SAT TT=58.597	SAT TT=55.336	? (TO) TT=1801	SAT TT=6.367	SAT TT=2.979 CHECKS=118050000 NODES=6330	SAT TT=3.038 CHECKS=118050000 NODES=6330
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-43_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.043	SAT TT=1.098 CHECKS=1099488 NODES=718	SAT TT=1.043 CHECKS=1429061 NODES=980	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=16.368	SAT TT=17.495	SAT TT=17.406 NODES=26317	SAT TT=77.873 NODES=83252	SAT TT=56.174 CHECKS=154078 NODES=85226	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=442.308 CHECKS=484689245 NODES=111680	SAT TT=418.568 CHECKS=482261336 NODES=111542	SAT TT=126.169 CHECKS=151220335 NODES=31591	SAT TT=684.877	SAT TT=28.168	SAT TT=26.936	SAT TT=414.398 CHECKS=476378145 NODES=107881	SAT TT=397.417 CHECKS=476378145 NODES=107881	SAT TT=43.33	SAT TT=40.75	? (TO) TT=1800.96	SAT TT=33.982	SAT TT=8.753 CHECKS=391005000 NODES=38306	SAT TT=9.205 CHECKS=391005000 NODES=38306
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-45_ext.xml	SAT TT=3.466	SAT TT=3.627 CHECKS=23568185 NODES=13577	SAT TT=3.507 CHECKS=25054561 NODES=14157	SAT TT=563.464	SAT TT=7.449	SAT TT=7.261	SAT TT=11.078 NODES=16416	SAT TT=23.84 NODES=19797	SAT TT=15.389 CHECKS=155891 NODES=20686	SAT TT=834.695	SAT TT=37.599 CHECKS=37698826 NODES=9030	SAT TT=35.904 CHECKS=37770695 NODES=8791	SAT TT=411.368 CHECKS=490150035 NODES=105432	SAT TT=282.458	SAT TT=190.849	SAT TT=17.178	SAT TT=131.348 CHECKS=154696562 NODES=31950	SAT TT=130.804 CHECKS=154696562 NODES=31950	SAT TT=6.985	SAT TT=6.633	? (TO) TT=1800.44	SAT TT=20.667	SAT TT=3.466 CHECKS=129484000 NODES=10706	SAT TT=3.346 CHECKS=129484000 NODES=10706
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-47_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.628	SAT TT=10.232 CHECKS=84182470 NODES=43465	SAT TT=4.7 CHECKS=34303319 NODES=17948	SAT TT=141.79	SAT TT=3.609	SAT TT=3.621	SAT TT=67.24 NODES=99220	SAT TT=30.976 NODES=23944	SAT TT=23.793 CHECKS=153602 NODES=31523	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=25.57 CHECKS=21649864 NODES=5812	SAT TT=24.53 CHECKS=20983903 NODES=5712	SAT TT=91.364 CHECKS=104333373 NODES=20902	SAT TT=83.963	SAT TT=167.847	SAT TT=12.461	SAT TT=49.3 CHECKS=41881181 NODES=9332	SAT TT=41.409 CHECKS=41881181 NODES=9332	SAT TT=20.204	SAT TT=20.507	? (TO) TT=1800.96	SAT TT=6.556	SAT TT=1.628 CHECKS=48262900 NODES=3393	SAT TT=1.6 CHECKS=48262900 NODES=3393
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-49_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.696	SAT TT=2.957 CHECKS=17761313 NODES=10059	SAT TT=1.155 CHECKS=2145554 NODES=1254	SAT TT=327.175	SAT TT=0.696	SAT TT=0.728	SAT TT=0.995 NODES=135	SAT TT=3.825 NODES=2796	SAT TT=3.044 CHECKS=153332 NODES=3228	SAT TT=323.461	SAT TT=48.256 CHECKS=54826068 NODES=12366	SAT TT=63.616 CHECKS=70929073 NODES=17480	SAT TT=231.409 CHECKS=266319179 NODES=60143	SAT TT=23.261	SAT TT=19.376	SAT TT=4.485	SAT TT=26.446 CHECKS=26399111 NODES=5956	SAT TT=26.313 CHECKS=26399111 NODES=5956	SAT TT=72.926	SAT TT=72.887	? (TO) TT=1800.99	SAT TT=8.866	SAT TT=1.202 CHECKS=31610700 NODES=2346	SAT TT=1.182 CHECKS=31610700 NODES=2346
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-51_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.699	SAT TT=4.153 CHECKS=27211002 NODES=16264	SAT TT=3.41 CHECKS=23397826 NODES=13867	SAT TT=249.697	SAT TT=7.167	SAT TT=6.788	SAT TT=24.207 NODES=40506	SAT TT=19.914 NODES=18669	SAT TT=6.571 CHECKS=152452 NODES=9028	SAT TT=64.745	SAT TT=348.746 CHECKS=372404968 NODES=90191	SAT TT=120.526 CHECKS=129434926 NODES=31046	SAT TT=191.811 CHECKS=228568692 NODES=49650	SAT TT=70.133	SAT TT=38.586	SAT TT=8.59	SAT TT=40.302 CHECKS=43352837 NODES=9786	SAT TT=44.115 CHECKS=43352837 NODES=9786	SAT TT=4.723	SAT TT=4.655	? (TO) TT=1801.03	SAT TT=27.87	SAT TT=1.699 CHECKS=51848300 NODES=4406	SAT TT=1.679 CHECKS=51848300 NODES=4406
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-53_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.198	SAT TT=0.988 CHECKS=560133 NODES=330	SAT TT=1.744 CHECKS=7516617 NODES=4695	SAT TT=1.388	SAT TT=1.03	SAT TT=1.085	SAT TT=7.879 NODES=11565	SAT TT=10.239 NODES=9012	SAT TT=3.207 CHECKS=151973 NODES=3594	SAT TT=40.4	SAT TT=13.899 CHECKS=10420083 NODES=3687	SAT TT=12.849 CHECKS=10643690 NODES=3703	SAT TT=0.741 CHECKS=246396 NODES=86	SAT TT=185.511	SAT TT=15.699	SAT TT=0.198	SAT TT=0.668 CHECKS=246396 NODES=86	SAT TT=0.696 CHECKS=246396 NODES=86	SAT TT=18.033	SAT TT=19.78	? (TO) TT=1801.1	SAT TT=1.067	SAT TT=0.517 CHECKS=341461 NODES=78	SAT TT=0.525 CHECKS=341461 NODES=78
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-55_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.321	SAT TT=1.575 CHECKS=4605050 NODES=2759	SAT TT=1.321 CHECKS=3478018 NODES=2095	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=4.786	SAT TT=4.863	SAT TT=11.202 NODES=16419	SAT TT=44.657 NODES=41777	SAT TT=15.589 CHECKS=152623 NODES=21370	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=51.149 CHECKS=50104404 NODES=11330	SAT TT=131.994 CHECKS=137926166 NODES=33537	SAT TT=38.603 CHECKS=36858518 NODES=8699	SAT TT=5.148	SAT TT=157.86	SAT TT=13.884	SAT TT=140.002 CHECKS=142544229 NODES=31186	SAT TT=125.808 CHECKS=142544229 NODES=31186	SAT TT=191.548	SAT TT=189.26	? (TO) TT=1801.11	SAT TT=13.196	SAT TT=3.575 CHECKS=131458000 NODES=11354	SAT TT=3.531 CHECKS=131458000 NODES=11354
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-57_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.799	SAT TT=1.799 CHECKS=8248397 NODES=3978	SAT TT=1.867 CHECKS=7796469 NODES=3961	SAT TT=331.975	SAT TT=8.174	SAT TT=7.813	SAT TT=18.463 NODES=23710	SAT TT=8.62 NODES=5916	SAT TT=6.721 CHECKS=152313 NODES=7810	SAT TT=645.763	SAT TT=42.501 CHECKS=40171257 NODES=9068	SAT TT=137.24 CHECKS=133882762 NODES=24948	SAT TT=73.423 CHECKS=69256746 NODES=12666	SAT TT=59.851	SAT TT=4.161	SAT TT=2.058	SAT TT=130.212 CHECKS=111389969 NODES=21474	SAT TT=126.374 CHECKS=111389969 NODES=21474	SAT TT=5.21	SAT TT=5.44	? (TO) TT=1801.02	SAT TT=4.164	SAT TT=2.862 CHECKS=102708000 NODES=8121	SAT TT=2.866 CHECKS=102708000 NODES=8121
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-59_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.237	UNSAT TT=3.698 CHECKS=28928434 NODES=13100	UNSAT TT=3.948 CHECKS=30397122 NODES=13654	UNSAT TT=445.453	UNSAT TT=49.822	UNSAT TT=48.726	UNSAT TT=27.061 NODES=39111	UNSAT TT=12.112 NODES=8807	UNSAT TT=8.144 CHECKS=154979 NODES=9850	UNSAT TT=843.687	UNSAT TT=85.487 CHECKS=97276063 NODES=17636	UNSAT TT=103.068 CHECKS=108942647 NODES=18219	UNSAT TT=406.017 CHECKS=480746006 NODES=73404	UNSAT TT=99.644	UNSAT TT=64.292	UNSAT TT=10.03	UNSAT TT=81.558 CHECKS=90424861 NODES=13788	UNSAT TT=76.247 CHECKS=90424861 NODES=13788	UNSAT TT=97.715	UNSAT TT=95.735	? (TO) TT=1801.03	UNSAT TT=11.704	UNSAT TT=2.237 CHECKS=91213500 NODES=4644	UNSAT TT=2.356 CHECKS=91213500 NODES=4644
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-5_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.37	SAT TT=5.846 CHECKS=37644329 NODES=27321	SAT TT=4.595 CHECKS=28161098 NODES=20693	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=3.653	SAT TT=3.878	SAT TT=6.337 NODES=9237	SAT TT=107.264 NODES=128210	SAT TT=71.259 CHECKS=152974 NODES=125099	SAT TT=1136.09	SAT TT=81.023 CHECKS=82755658 NODES=25885	SAT TT=86.932 CHECKS=83034026 NODES=25705	SAT TT=711.712 CHECKS=750594524 NODES=232927	SAT TT=35.435	SAT TT=7.345	SAT TT=10.838	SAT TT=533.452 CHECKS=548996236 NODES=163436	SAT TT=546.147 CHECKS=548996236 NODES=163436	SAT TT=6.021	SAT TT=6.245	? (TO) TT=1800.95	SAT TT=0.37	SAT TT=12.214 CHECKS=471647000 NODES=51372	SAT TT=12.073 CHECKS=471647000 NODES=51372
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-61_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.04	SAT TT=1.413 CHECKS=4202424 NODES=2450	SAT TT=1.83 CHECKS=7982221 NODES=4480	SAT TT=357.139	SAT TT=6.964	SAT TT=7.053	SAT TT=16.776 NODES=24470	SAT TT=11.509 NODES=9264	SAT TT=7.712 CHECKS=152878 NODES=10079	SAT TT=919.535	SAT TT=32.676 CHECKS=28726675 NODES=7223	SAT TT=33.312 CHECKS=30816345 NODES=7638	SAT TT=75.67 CHECKS=82658952 NODES=16463	SAT TT=198.262	SAT TT=5.823	SAT TT=5.736	SAT TT=26.303 CHECKS=24448006 NODES=4741	SAT TT=25.444 CHECKS=24448006 NODES=4741	SAT TT=23.107	SAT TT=23.405	? (TO) TT=1801.02	SAT TT=3.904	SAT TT=1.04 CHECKS=23901700 NODES=1726	SAT TT=1.019 CHECKS=23901700 NODES=1726
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-63_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.225	SAT TT=1.225 CHECKS=1966578 NODES=1262	SAT TT=1.307 CHECKS=3078982 NODES=2004	SAT TT=296.304	SAT TT=6.238	SAT TT=6.657	SAT TT=4.473 NODES=5530	SAT TT=23.058 NODES=20187	SAT TT=13.203 CHECKS=153222 NODES=18418	? (TO) TT=1800.14	SAT TT=57.655 CHECKS=60439054 NODES=14148	SAT TT=65.194 CHECKS=60808177 NODES=14646	SAT TT=397.747 CHECKS=447888012 NODES=102160	SAT TT=261.36	SAT TT=124.318	SAT TT=15.848	SAT TT=141.137 CHECKS=118832293 NODES=26159	SAT TT=128.107 CHECKS=118832293 NODES=26159	SAT TT=25.687	SAT TT=27.647	? (TO) TT=1801.03	SAT TT=18.532	SAT TT=3.316 CHECKS=120894000 NODES=8533	SAT TT=3.328 CHECKS=120894000 NODES=8533
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-65_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=26.245	UNSAT TT=53.817 CHECKS=444702458 NODES=266419	UNSAT TT=49.722 CHECKS=448740023 NODES=270882	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=27.251	UNSAT TT=29.189	UNSAT TT=368.963 NODES=545444	UNSAT TT=188.753 NODES=193601	UNSAT TT=112.926 CHECKS=153073 NODES=191121	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=1228 CHECKS=1404257390 NODES=338577	UNSAT TT=1297.42 CHECKS=1411171313 NODES=338707	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.1	? (TO) TT=1800	UNSAT TT=114	UNSAT TT=1317.18 CHECKS=1430099190 NODES=342979	UNSAT TT=1244.12 CHECKS=1430099190 NODES=342979	? (TO) TT=1800.57	? (TO) TT=1800.59	? (TO) TT=1801	UNSAT TT=135.47	UNSAT TT=26.245 CHECKS=1174980000 NODES=116212	UNSAT TT=27.85 CHECKS=1174980000 NODES=116212
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-67_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.999	SAT TT=1.34 CHECKS=2535661 NODES=1520	SAT TT=0.999 CHECKS=659554 NODES=475	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=6.765	SAT TT=6.669	SAT TT=29.463 NODES=45572	SAT TT=64.634 NODES=61690	SAT TT=15.322 CHECKS=153556 NODES=23701	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=48.6 CHECKS=48393848 NODES=11949	SAT TT=49.147 CHECKS=51136493 NODES=12635	SAT TT=208.581 CHECKS=245677087 NODES=60213	SAT TT=1008.29	SAT TT=240.418	SAT TT=45.174	SAT TT=187.58 CHECKS=217788801 NODES=50517	SAT TT=197.734 CHECKS=217788801 NODES=50517	SAT TT=19.707	SAT TT=18.35	? (TO) TT=1800.99	SAT TT=6.704	SAT TT=5.687 CHECKS=221012000 NODES=19831	SAT TT=5.553 CHECKS=221012000 NODES=19831
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-69_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.205	SAT TT=8.578 CHECKS=66154069 NODES=34785	SAT TT=8.979 CHECKS=72233620 NODES=38030	SAT TT=353.785	SAT TT=9.036	SAT TT=9.677	SAT TT=18.389 NODES=26145	SAT TT=41.825 NODES=37499	SAT TT=38.774 CHECKS=152107 NODES=51517	SAT TT=1014.47	SAT TT=244.765 CHECKS=268655381 NODES=61965	SAT TT=252.054 CHECKS=277532662 NODES=63166	SAT TT=74.44 CHECKS=83314961 NODES=16012	SAT TT=312.277	SAT TT=34.078	SAT TT=6.125	SAT TT=245.715 CHECKS=275588322 NODES=61785	SAT TT=238.252 CHECKS=275588322 NODES=61785	SAT TT=96.172	SAT TT=92.268	? (TO) TT=1800.95	SAT TT=4.205	SAT TT=6.827 CHECKS=273211000 NODES=22311	SAT TT=6.748 CHECKS=273211000 NODES=22311
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-71_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.432	UNSAT TT=13.644 CHECKS=121363248 NODES=62595	UNSAT TT=13.164 CHECKS=112294226 NODES=57973	UNSAT TT=661.682	UNSAT TT=12.03	UNSAT TT=11.299	UNSAT TT=70.722 NODES=104530	UNSAT TT=39.972 NODES=38292	UNSAT TT=30.217 CHECKS=154572 NODES=43837	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=255.607 CHECKS=241413250 NODES=58519	UNSAT TT=220.515 CHECKS=240694318 NODES=58454	UNSAT TT=1506.17 CHECKS=1711380482 NODES=369294	UNSAT TT=649.546	UNSAT TT=263.688	UNSAT TT=27.419	UNSAT TT=220.614 CHECKS=238489508 NODES=57157	UNSAT TT=245.188 CHECKS=238489508 NODES=57157	UNSAT TT=628.275	UNSAT TT=617.604	? (TO) TT=1800.97	UNSAT TT=36.28	UNSAT TT=5.432 CHECKS=213068000 NODES=18606	UNSAT TT=5.385 CHECKS=213068000 NODES=18606
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-73_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.07	UNSAT TT=11.924 CHECKS=98047830 NODES=49271	UNSAT TT=11.619 CHECKS=98798411 NODES=49433	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=11.947	UNSAT TT=11.277	UNSAT TT=73.245 NODES=102101	UNSAT TT=35.43 NODES=31695	UNSAT TT=25.134 CHECKS=153792 NODES=35347	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=245.099 CHECKS=249547246 NODES=53425	UNSAT TT=234.223 CHECKS=248376702 NODES=52983	UNSAT TT=1063.33 CHECKS=1194815352 NODES=232252	UNSAT TT=494.802	UNSAT TT=117.366	UNSAT TT=24.693	UNSAT TT=233.472 CHECKS=246091293 NODES=51671	UNSAT TT=235.559 CHECKS=246091293 NODES=51671	UNSAT TT=346.56	UNSAT TT=417.714	? (TO) TT=1801.04	UNSAT TT=26.248	UNSAT TT=5.07 CHECKS=196552000 NODES=13732	UNSAT TT=5.147 CHECKS=196552000 NODES=13732
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-75_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=8.294	UNSAT TT=14.691 CHECKS=125700167 NODES=61526	UNSAT TT=14.916 CHECKS=128871114 NODES=62530	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=12.41	UNSAT TT=13.282	UNSAT TT=91.887 NODES=134120	UNSAT TT=45.66 NODES=37217	UNSAT TT=36.155 CHECKS=153750 NODES=47823	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=270.892 CHECKS=304903437 NODES=63234	UNSAT TT=264.959 CHECKS=302442356 NODES=60495	UNSAT TT=1172.64 CHECKS=1398836725 NODES=285189	UNSAT TT=653.677	UNSAT TT=239.612	UNSAT TT=50.929	UNSAT TT=423.187 CHECKS=406214869 NODES=86279	UNSAT TT=393.323 CHECKS=406214869 NODES=86279	UNSAT TT=1079.69	UNSAT TT=1060.97	? (TO) TT=1800.98	UNSAT TT=54.526	UNSAT TT=8.294 CHECKS=331703000 NODES=21579	UNSAT TT=7.605 CHECKS=331703000 NODES=21579
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-77_ext.xml	SAT TT=8.175	SAT TT=8.947 CHECKS=68471403 NODES=42614	SAT TT=8.175 CHECKS=68287855 NODES=41499	SAT TT=1145.64	SAT TT=14.798	SAT TT=14.134	SAT TT=61.638 NODES=101954	SAT TT=53.749 NODES=46618	SAT TT=31.486 CHECKS=153691 NODES=47022	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=148.647 CHECKS=160434315 NODES=40411	SAT TT=137.976 CHECKS=158761259 NODES=39492	SAT TT=686.693 CHECKS=802408170 NODES=185357	SAT TT=694.502	SAT TT=38.913	SAT TT=23.728	SAT TT=492.735 CHECKS=506634258 NODES=124531	SAT TT=447.032 CHECKS=506634258 NODES=124531	SAT TT=310.581	SAT TT=308.581	? (TO) TT=1800.94	SAT TT=27.014	SAT TT=12.11 CHECKS=496620000 NODES=43164	SAT TT=11.204 CHECKS=496620000 NODES=43164
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-79_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=12.835	UNSAT TT=18.52 CHECKS=169621610 NODES=88755	UNSAT TT=18.488 CHECKS=160077895 NODES=84276	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=13.218	UNSAT TT=12.835	UNSAT TT=215.592 NODES=329234	UNSAT TT=69.664 NODES=59817	UNSAT TT=41.543 CHECKS=154311 NODES=61023	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=533.427 CHECKS=531130038 NODES=124376	UNSAT TT=877.024 CHECKS=853560347 NODES=203390	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=970.011	UNSAT TT=881.149	UNSAT TT=60.648	UNSAT TT=890.085 CHECKS=845586287 NODES=200403	UNSAT TT=848.625 CHECKS=845586287 NODES=200403	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.17	? (TO) TT=1800.94	UNSAT TT=67.323	UNSAT TT=31.166 CHECKS=1237840000 NODES=91580	UNSAT TT=30.513 CHECKS=1237840000 NODES=91580
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-7_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.584	SAT TT=4.561 CHECKS=37009670 NODES=18280	SAT TT=3.556 CHECKS=25079265 NODES=12230	SAT TT=649.221	SAT TT=5.406	SAT TT=5.443	SAT TT=5.32 NODES=7267	SAT TT=25.835 NODES=19696	SAT TT=15.685 CHECKS=153402 NODES=20421	SAT TT=207.148	SAT TT=54.979 CHECKS=63535479 NODES=12467	SAT TT=60.955 CHECKS=63448603 NODES=12569	SAT TT=221.777 CHECKS=274973475 NODES=46851	SAT TT=118.047	SAT TT=7.585	SAT TT=2.024	SAT TT=51.225 CHECKS=59701963 NODES=10328	SAT TT=49.827 CHECKS=59701963 NODES=10328	SAT TT=25.306	SAT TT=26.397	? (TO) TT=1801.05	SAT TT=14.741	SAT TT=1.584 CHECKS=50383300 NODES=2664	SAT TT=1.473 CHECKS=50383300 NODES=2664
tightness/tightness0.65/ rand-2-40-40-135-650-9_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.82	SAT TT=3.754 CHECKS=24980567 NODES=15426	SAT TT=4.345 CHECKS=29710846 NODES=18412	SAT TT=37.553	SAT TT=7.178	SAT TT=7.291	SAT TT=30.296 NODES=41835	SAT TT=7.406 NODES=5525	SAT TT=9.278 CHECKS=153621 NODES=12086	? (TO) TT=1800.14	SAT TT=12.776 CHECKS=11089444 NODES=3174	SAT TT=16.333 CHECKS=13746234 NODES=4233	SAT TT=13.421 CHECKS=13655513 NODES=2884	SAT TT=9.777	SAT TT=25.771	SAT TT=2.046	SAT TT=17.369 CHECKS=13640747 NODES=4432	SAT TT=17.407 CHECKS=13640747 NODES=4432	SAT TT=26.127	SAT TT=27.97	? (TO) TT=1800.98	SAT TT=2.464	SAT TT=0.82 CHECKS=11863900 NODES=983	SAT TT=0.751 CHECKS=11863900 NODES=982
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-11_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.78	UNSAT TT=2.871 CHECKS=22544765 NODES=5756	UNSAT TT=2.78 CHECKS=23109824 NODES=5806	UNSAT TT=421.768	UNSAT TT=43.273	UNSAT TT=40.497	UNSAT TT=29.107 NODES=27313	UNSAT TT=13.563 NODES=3878	UNSAT TT=4.834 CHECKS=269026 NODES=4040	UNSAT TT=528.366	UNSAT TT=62.588 CHECKS=108988430 NODES=8197	UNSAT TT=72.822 CHECKS=115386161 NODES=8524	UNSAT TT=253.898 CHECKS=492033769 NODES=28502	UNSAT TT=59.376	UNSAT TT=54.304	UNSAT TT=7.302	UNSAT TT=74.574 CHECKS=126731138 NODES=7920	UNSAT TT=75.243 CHECKS=126731138 NODES=7920	UNSAT TT=72.066	UNSAT TT=71.27	? (TO) TT=1800.78	UNSAT TT=8.667	UNSAT TT=4.004 CHECKS=143544000 NODES=3237	UNSAT TT=3.953 CHECKS=143544000 NODES=3237
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-13_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.643	SAT TT=6.746 CHECKS=74418896 NODES=22988	SAT TT=6.895 CHECKS=78182514 NODES=24093	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=1.643	SAT TT=1.782	SAT TT=96.931 NODES=108947	SAT TT=16.284 NODES=6985	SAT TT=6.47 CHECKS=265783 NODES=7095	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=37.806 CHECKS=45956025 NODES=4962	SAT TT=107.375 CHECKS=151286543 NODES=17224	SAT TT=240.411 CHECKS=397133344 NODES=36487	? (TO) TT=1800.01	SAT TT=348.955	SAT TT=19.438	SAT TT=91.085 CHECKS=141845170 NODES=13468	SAT TT=97.266 CHECKS=141845170 NODES=13468	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.18	SAT TT=26.725	SAT TT=4.046 CHECKS=142376000 NODES=5753	SAT TT=3.597 CHECKS=115955000 NODES=4030
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-15_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.552	UNSAT TT=1.552 CHECKS=6707746 NODES=1438	UNSAT TT=1.581 CHECKS=8227450 NODES=1653	UNSAT TT=171.632	UNSAT TT=5.535	UNSAT TT=5.601	UNSAT TT=12.083 NODES=10388	UNSAT TT=5.721 NODES=1159	UNSAT TT=2.593 CHECKS=267722 NODES=1213	UNSAT TT=157.956	UNSAT TT=31.35 CHECKS=42447543 NODES=3876	UNSAT TT=40.757 CHECKS=52027149 NODES=5049	UNSAT TT=102.21 CHECKS=160351434 NODES=8725	UNSAT TT=10.684	UNSAT TT=9.17	UNSAT TT=3.006	UNSAT TT=15.906 CHECKS=24169738 NODES=1629	UNSAT TT=17.04 CHECKS=24169738 NODES=1629	UNSAT TT=9.372	UNSAT TT=9.794	? (TO) TT=1800.24	UNSAT TT=2.945	UNSAT TT=2.293 CHECKS=27343300 NODES=471	UNSAT TT=2.094 CHECKS=27343300 NODES=471
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.818	SAT TT=1.615 CHECKS=7961194 NODES=2131	SAT TT=1.422 CHECKS=5267396 NODES=1440	SAT TT=895.294	SAT TT=0.818	SAT TT=0.88	SAT TT=21.625 NODES=19718	SAT TT=12.059 NODES=4876	SAT TT=3.408 CHECKS=265588 NODES=2539	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=64.571 CHECKS=89326130 NODES=8473	SAT TT=76.614 CHECKS=93432076 NODES=9683	SAT TT=700.059 CHECKS=1205012136 NODES=91442	SAT TT=14.512	SAT TT=125.697	SAT TT=2.714	SAT TT=117.508 CHECKS=171276732 NODES=14357	SAT TT=120.175 CHECKS=171276732 NODES=14357	SAT TT=78.105	SAT TT=75.626	? (TO) TT=1800.22	SAT TT=7.091	SAT TT=3.902 CHECKS=144428000 NODES=4651	SAT TT=4.025 CHECKS=144428000 NODES=4651
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-19_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.324	SAT TT=16.32 CHECKS=169061146 NODES=71450	SAT TT=1.324 CHECKS=3479098 NODES=1564	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=5.07	SAT TT=5.117	SAT TT=20.004 NODES=22226	SAT TT=35.027 NODES=26596	SAT TT=50.535 CHECKS=266617 NODES=90705	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=79.551 CHECKS=110351654 NODES=16116	SAT TT=82.748 CHECKS=101060404 NODES=14492	SAT TT=96.982 CHECKS=122631918 NODES=20712	SAT TT=210.149	SAT TT=15.878	SAT TT=71.681	SAT TT=424.461 CHECKS=623234991 NODES=70954	SAT TT=408.043 CHECKS=623234991 NODES=70954	SAT TT=71.418	SAT TT=77.432	? (TO) TT=1800.88	SAT TT=6.879	SAT TT=9.493 CHECKS=451952000 NODES=20364	SAT TT=8.91 CHECKS=451952000 NODES=20364
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-1_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.24	SAT TT=2.363 CHECKS=18726470 NODES=4381	SAT TT=1.24 CHECKS=3467291 NODES=871	SAT TT=129.18	SAT TT=10.924	SAT TT=10.903	SAT TT=11.853 NODES=11885	SAT TT=14.846 NODES=5793	SAT TT=6.294 CHECKS=267204 NODES=5538	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=107.983 CHECKS=157524161 NODES=14077	SAT TT=93.579 CHECKS=147672121 NODES=12573	SAT TT=326.079 CHECKS=499110576 NODES=33494	SAT TT=185.198	SAT TT=19.05	SAT TT=8.286	SAT TT=89.951 CHECKS=131643064 NODES=10521	SAT TT=86.85 CHECKS=131643064 NODES=10521	SAT TT=27.305	SAT TT=27.737	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=2.537	SAT TT=3.978 CHECKS=132423000 NODES=3194	SAT TT=3.932 CHECKS=132423000 NODES=3193
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.126	SAT TT=1.145 CHECKS=982614 NODES=285	SAT TT=1.126 CHECKS=1540444 NODES=505	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=19.747	SAT TT=19.745	SAT TT=2.551 NODES=1485	SAT TT=9.206 NODES=2834	SAT TT=4.064 CHECKS=264535 NODES=3113	SAT TT=1434.7	SAT TT=115.547 CHECKS=220835346 NODES=18386	SAT TT=117.975 CHECKS=214023928 NODES=17824	SAT TT=47.927 CHECKS=91573455 NODES=6002	SAT TT=655.98	SAT TT=8.486	SAT TT=5.974	SAT TT=117.467 CHECKS=215801216 NODES=16233	SAT TT=121.014 CHECKS=215801216 NODES=16233	SAT TT=160.655	SAT TT=162.439	? (TO) TT=1800.22	SAT TT=3.769	SAT TT=4.716 CHECKS=198803000 NODES=7438	SAT TT=4.787 CHECKS=198803000 NODES=7437
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-23_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.25	SAT TT=3.993 CHECKS=42636621 NODES=9408	SAT TT=4.079 CHECKS=44069748 NODES=9772	SAT TT=171.834	SAT TT=1.25	SAT TT=1.316	SAT TT=17.725 NODES=16733	SAT TT=19.136 NODES=7090	SAT TT=6.849 CHECKS=270372 NODES=6045	SAT TT=1101.84	SAT TT=105.146 CHECKS=161597956 NODES=11825	SAT TT=99.514 CHECKS=165403240 NODES=11592	SAT TT=201.298 CHECKS=342843541 NODES=19593	SAT TT=179.447	SAT TT=15.823	SAT TT=11.389	SAT TT=96.475 CHECKS=161201305 NODES=9732	SAT TT=103.271 CHECKS=161201305 NODES=9732	SAT TT=206.36	SAT TT=210.443	? (TO) TT=1800.8	SAT TT=11.907	SAT TT=4.084 CHECKS=148418000 NODES=2345	SAT TT=4.093 CHECKS=148418000 NODES=2345
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-25_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.923	UNSAT TT=2.923 CHECKS=27721562 NODES=6786	UNSAT TT=3.143 CHECKS=28047385 NODES=7010	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=19.558	UNSAT TT=18.56	UNSAT TT=26.201 NODES=21002	UNSAT TT=10.827 NODES=3780	UNSAT TT=5.224 CHECKS=267514 NODES=4525	UNSAT TT=1100.9	UNSAT TT=78.683 CHECKS=104316836 NODES=8862	UNSAT TT=82.823 CHECKS=109539729 NODES=9800	UNSAT TT=280.47 CHECKS=426476504 NODES=32924	UNSAT TT=86.983	UNSAT TT=66.381	UNSAT TT=6.861	UNSAT TT=113.704 CHECKS=162664107 NODES=13357	UNSAT TT=122.084 CHECKS=162664107 NODES=13357	UNSAT TT=96.654	UNSAT TT=93.87	? (TO) TT=1800.82	UNSAT TT=8.813	UNSAT TT=5.047 CHECKS=193395000 NODES=2869	UNSAT TT=4.576 CHECKS=174191000 NODES=2060
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-27_ext.xml	SAT TT=3.081	SAT TT=5.187 CHECKS=49527423 NODES=16976	SAT TT=3.081 CHECKS=25015394 NODES=8686	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=39.174	SAT TT=37.97	SAT TT=96.706 NODES=110905	SAT TT=1429.88 NODES=922213	SAT TT=170.296 CHECKS=266317 NODES=260372	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=351.153	SAT TT=486.298	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.2	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.14	SAT TT=573.075	SAT TT=44.473 CHECKS=2432810000 NODES=100726	SAT TT=44.52 CHECKS=2427500000 NODES=100268
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-29_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.024	UNSAT TT=5.143 CHECKS=59328044 NODES=13681	UNSAT TT=5.024 CHECKS=55379944 NODES=12752	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=88.005	UNSAT TT=82.558	UNSAT TT=72.317 NODES=60265	UNSAT TT=28.669 NODES=10714	UNSAT TT=11.194 CHECKS=267515 NODES=10771	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=170.803 CHECKS=254255929 NODES=19853	UNSAT TT=156.115 CHECKS=234365562 NODES=18280	UNSAT TT=579.417 CHECKS=890657853 NODES=67134	UNSAT TT=182.187	UNSAT TT=115.045	UNSAT TT=20.609	UNSAT TT=152.948 CHECKS=225236427 NODES=16628	UNSAT TT=143.075 CHECKS=225236427 NODES=16628	UNSAT TT=186.806	UNSAT TT=182.134	? (TO) TT=1800.97	UNSAT TT=21.799	UNSAT TT=5.171 CHECKS=212435000 NODES=4119	UNSAT TT=4.896 CHECKS=203545000 NODES=3826
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-31_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.857	SAT TT=1.857 CHECKS=10733496 NODES=3469	SAT TT=2.55 CHECKS=18885555 NODES=6196	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=24.174	SAT TT=25.784	SAT TT=29.585 NODES=29257	SAT TT=5.798 NODES=2051	SAT TT=3.163 CHECKS=264096 NODES=2250	SAT TT=1154.04	SAT TT=263.71 CHECKS=393195168 NODES=43706	SAT TT=53.245 CHECKS=79741583 NODES=8686	SAT TT=244.584 CHECKS=345342554 NODES=32677	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=157.171	SAT TT=8.59	SAT TT=253.011 CHECKS=383641151 NODES=42671	SAT TT=272.892 CHECKS=383641151 NODES=42671	SAT TT=789.165	SAT TT=851.702	? (TO) TT=1800.44	SAT TT=8.6	SAT TT=92.032 CHECKS=5268310000 NODES=279889	SAT TT=7.685 CHECKS=360350000 NODES=18239
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-33_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.462	SAT TT=1.551 CHECKS=5323136 NODES=1729	SAT TT=1.539 CHECKS=5619914 NODES=1938	SAT TT=64.183	SAT TT=16.251	SAT TT=15.34	SAT TT=6.398 NODES=5536	SAT TT=5.463 NODES=2145	SAT TT=3.451 CHECKS=265015 NODES=2973	SAT TT=1562.9	SAT TT=23.099 CHECKS=26880454 NODES=3524	SAT TT=2.488 CHECKS=1931007 NODES=329	SAT TT=29.169 CHECKS=40922682 NODES=3541	SAT TT=25.756	SAT TT=7.064	SAT TT=1.462	SAT TT=25.934 CHECKS=27025810 NODES=3167	SAT TT=23.814 CHECKS=27025810 NODES=3167	SAT TT=33.928	SAT TT=31.383	? (TO) TT=1800.14	SAT TT=13.213	SAT TT=2.267 CHECKS=35796800 NODES=1104	SAT TT=2.262 CHECKS=35796800 NODES=1104
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-35_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.983	UNSAT TT=1.983 CHECKS=14472755 NODES=2482	UNSAT TT=2.037 CHECKS=15589771 NODES=2698	UNSAT TT=91.785	UNSAT TT=4.814	UNSAT TT=5.186	UNSAT TT=12.65 NODES=10453	UNSAT TT=9.907 NODES=2519	UNSAT TT=3.511 CHECKS=270487 NODES=2290	UNSAT TT=447.602	UNSAT TT=53.204 CHECKS=87691715 NODES=6509	UNSAT TT=56.515 CHECKS=87723952 NODES=6366	UNSAT TT=170.373 CHECKS=292460400 NODES=13836	UNSAT TT=47.202	UNSAT TT=19.039	UNSAT TT=6.097	UNSAT TT=35.672 CHECKS=55119575 NODES=3455	UNSAT TT=35.338 CHECKS=55119575 NODES=3455	UNSAT TT=21.931	UNSAT TT=23.868	? (TO) TT=1801.01	UNSAT TT=6.364	UNSAT TT=2.806 CHECKS=63798200 NODES=1034	UNSAT TT=2.647 CHECKS=57379300 NODES=568
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-37_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.282	SAT TT=1.461 CHECKS=5173646 NODES=1773	SAT TT=1.282 CHECKS=3343326 NODES=1056	SAT TT=1099.3	SAT TT=18.989	SAT TT=19.539	SAT TT=82.863 NODES=86323	SAT TT=86.336 NODES=46126	SAT TT=54.985 CHECKS=265983 NODES=76987	SAT TT=127.346	? (TO) TT=1800.13	SAT TT=243.314 CHECKS=366016285 NODES=46841	SAT TT=1218.04 CHECKS=1940495251 NODES=183823	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.04	SAT TT=241.226	SAT TT=1037.9 CHECKS=1335941018 NODES=141492	SAT TT=986.65 CHECKS=1335941018 NODES=141492	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.16	? (TO) TT=1800.17	SAT TT=268.925	SAT TT=109.746 CHECKS=6415070000 NODES=212721	SAT TT=26.876 CHECKS=1548700000 NODES=46484
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-39_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.486	SAT TT=3.127 CHECKS=28090770 NODES=7465	SAT TT=3.383 CHECKS=29054839 NODES=7720	SAT TT=158.477	SAT TT=27.817	SAT TT=27.831	SAT TT=47.844 NODES=45783	SAT TT=32.92 NODES=15009	SAT TT=20.317 CHECKS=267733 NODES=23341	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=41.039 CHECKS=58159360 NODES=7340	SAT TT=42.894 CHECKS=56939824 NODES=7170	SAT TT=139.572 CHECKS=208966331 NODES=16646	SAT TT=469.813	SAT TT=74.956	SAT TT=6.871	SAT TT=27.707 CHECKS=38466401 NODES=3893	SAT TT=31.075 CHECKS=38466401 NODES=3893	SAT TT=6.938	SAT TT=7.175	? (TO) TT=1800.5	SAT TT=9.269	SAT TT=2.486 CHECKS=41054200 NODES=1405	SAT TT=2.477 CHECKS=41054200 NODES=1405
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-3_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.948	UNSAT TT=2.039 CHECKS=15946251 NODES=2668	UNSAT TT=1.948 CHECKS=12610500 NODES=2161	UNSAT TT=173.187	UNSAT TT=5.366	UNSAT TT=5.434	UNSAT TT=11.161 NODES=10085	UNSAT TT=6.1 NODES=1560	UNSAT TT=2.946 CHECKS=270597 NODES=1716	UNSAT TT=392.928	UNSAT TT=39.971 CHECKS=59315938 NODES=4042	UNSAT TT=41.453 CHECKS=60422046 NODES=4043	UNSAT TT=184.421 CHECKS=316263239 NODES=13339	UNSAT TT=25.471	UNSAT TT=10.028	UNSAT TT=4.938	UNSAT TT=27.107 CHECKS=41342454 NODES=1752	UNSAT TT=24.504 CHECKS=41342454 NODES=1752	UNSAT TT=12.104	UNSAT TT=12.402	? (TO) TT=1800.22	UNSAT TT=5.212	UNSAT TT=2.407 CHECKS=41218500 NODES=335	UNSAT TT=2.362 CHECKS=41218500 NODES=335
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-41_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.754	UNSAT TT=4.754 CHECKS=53597285 NODES=11131	UNSAT TT=5.188 CHECKS=57423528 NODES=12206	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=37.663	UNSAT TT=40.219	UNSAT TT=54.166 NODES=51588	UNSAT TT=23.964 NODES=8395	UNSAT TT=10.639 CHECKS=271440 NODES=9178	? (TO) TT=1800.14	UNSAT TT=179.617 CHECKS=308427828 NODES=20126	UNSAT TT=164.882 CHECKS=294300532 NODES=18531	UNSAT TT=601.688 CHECKS=1042538655 NODES=56405	UNSAT TT=100.486	UNSAT TT=107.339	UNSAT TT=22.695	UNSAT TT=277.855 CHECKS=419475295 NODES=28030	UNSAT TT=275.419 CHECKS=419475295 NODES=28030	UNSAT TT=120.935	UNSAT TT=116.969	? (TO) TT=1800.21	UNSAT TT=20.668	UNSAT TT=8.119 CHECKS=452984000 NODES=5096	UNSAT TT=7.934 CHECKS=452984000 NODES=5096
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-43_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.279	UNSAT TT=3.327 CHECKS=29461631 NODES=7403	UNSAT TT=3.279 CHECKS=30253735 NODES=7575	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=54.795	UNSAT TT=58.666	UNSAT TT=45.44 NODES=41034	UNSAT TT=18.89 NODES=5886	UNSAT TT=6.221 CHECKS=267368 NODES=5545	UNSAT TT=1510.83	UNSAT TT=124.473 CHECKS=202202855 NODES=16389	UNSAT TT=109.727 CHECKS=180159155 NODES=14367	UNSAT TT=585.657 CHECKS=1093299525 NODES=66964	UNSAT TT=129.018	UNSAT TT=84.464	UNSAT TT=9.595	UNSAT TT=126.413 CHECKS=180694053 NODES=13833	UNSAT TT=116.879 CHECKS=180694053 NODES=13833	UNSAT TT=104.471	UNSAT TT=124.53	? (TO) TT=1800.97	UNSAT TT=10.354	UNSAT TT=5.469 CHECKS=225752000 NODES=2478	UNSAT TT=5.14 CHECKS=225752000 NODES=2478
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-45_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.134	SAT TT=1.188 CHECKS=1674705 NODES=480	SAT TT=1.134 CHECKS=2421631 NODES=740	SAT TT=17.006	SAT TT=1.464	SAT TT=1.509	SAT TT=4.793 NODES=3282	SAT TT=11.163 NODES=3032	SAT TT=4.514 CHECKS=273230 NODES=3633	SAT TT=97.085	SAT TT=22.743 CHECKS=26638651 NODES=3027	SAT TT=30.355 CHECKS=38124889 NODES=4121	SAT TT=193.779 CHECKS=323229766 NODES=22500	SAT TT=24.893	SAT TT=8.258	SAT TT=7.76	SAT TT=10.446 CHECKS=15802167 NODES=991	SAT TT=9.374 CHECKS=15802167 NODES=991	SAT TT=11.028	SAT TT=12.303	? (TO) TT=1800.21	SAT TT=7.704	SAT TT=2.021 CHECKS=12741900 NODES=418	SAT TT=1.896 CHECKS=12741900 NODES=417
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-47_ext.xml	SAT TT=7.196	SAT TT=7.351 CHECKS=77702008 NODES=25195	SAT TT=7.862 CHECKS=90270247 NODES=29429	? (TO) TT=1800.02	SAT TT=10.61	SAT TT=10.2	SAT TT=8.18 NODES=6654	SAT TT=15.767 NODES=7453	SAT TT=7.196 CHECKS=265219 NODES=7880	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=155.663 CHECKS=226813876 NODES=23584	SAT TT=59.267 CHECKS=80905205 NODES=8603	SAT TT=621.211 CHECKS=954088618 NODES=96153	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=1359.88	SAT TT=29.855	SAT TT=399.243 CHECKS=512098632 NODES=55938	SAT TT=397.76 CHECKS=512098632 NODES=55938	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.22	SAT TT=33.299	SAT TT=10.024 CHECKS=481038000 NODES=18918	SAT TT=9.987 CHECKS=481038000 NODES=18918
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-49_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.589	SAT TT=8.179 CHECKS=87588882 NODES=30824	SAT TT=5.736 CHECKS=62665703 NODES=23510	SAT TT=6.548	SAT TT=1.239	SAT TT=1.282	SAT TT=63.626 NODES=71320	SAT TT=6.383 NODES=3344	SAT TT=3.251 CHECKS=264504 NODES=3355	SAT TT=19.87	SAT TT=23.85 CHECKS=33929080 NODES=5044	SAT TT=22.935 CHECKS=26629894 NODES=3668	SAT TT=16.283 CHECKS=23368143 NODES=2405	SAT TT=1349.97	SAT TT=135.574	SAT TT=0.589	SAT TT=2.987 CHECKS=3160791 NODES=476	SAT TT=3.033 CHECKS=3160791 NODES=476	SAT TT=5.119	SAT TT=5.304	? (TO) TT=1800.26	SAT TT=2.136	SAT TT=1.86 CHECKS=3062720 NODES=164	SAT TT=1.869 CHECKS=3062720 NODES=164
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-51_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.906	SAT TT=1.034 CHECKS=972385 NODES=299	SAT TT=2.439 CHECKS=16117835 NODES=5127	SAT TT=13.706	SAT TT=1.488	SAT TT=1.542	SAT TT=5.589 NODES=4765	SAT TT=24.7 NODES=12540	SAT TT=10.198 CHECKS=266072 NODES=10760	SAT TT=987.441	SAT TT=24.965 CHECKS=30640391 NODES=4666	SAT TT=31.945 CHECKS=40387261 NODES=5859	SAT TT=200.949 CHECKS=312949439 NODES=31108	SAT TT=133.944	SAT TT=49.351	SAT TT=1.541	SAT TT=7.691 CHECKS=8597555 NODES=1235	SAT TT=7.581 CHECKS=8597555 NODES=1235	SAT TT=101.637	SAT TT=104.389	? (TO) TT=1801.02	SAT TT=0.906	SAT TT=2.179 CHECKS=20450300 NODES=1244	SAT TT=2.119 CHECKS=20450300 NODES=1244
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-53_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.53	UNSAT TT=4.293 CHECKS=41589494 NODES=10453	UNSAT TT=3.53 CHECKS=35734160 NODES=9416	UNSAT TT=415.369	UNSAT TT=68.421	UNSAT TT=67.339	UNSAT TT=27.686 NODES=27585	UNSAT TT=14.538 NODES=5654	UNSAT TT=8.686 CHECKS=267248 NODES=8061	UNSAT TT=1214.9	UNSAT TT=83.747 CHECKS=138056951 NODES=12146	UNSAT TT=85.187 CHECKS=137735034 NODES=11925	UNSAT TT=395.765 CHECKS=684259364 NODES=45762	UNSAT TT=126.272	UNSAT TT=62.057	UNSAT TT=17.211	UNSAT TT=79.562 CHECKS=130453840 NODES=10564	UNSAT TT=79.775 CHECKS=130453840 NODES=10564	UNSAT TT=69.236	UNSAT TT=72.514	? (TO) TT=1800.31	UNSAT TT=18.459	UNSAT TT=4.106 CHECKS=145318000 NODES=3468	UNSAT TT=4.131 CHECKS=145262000 NODES=3469
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-55_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.648	SAT TT=2.339 CHECKS=15224800 NODES=4032	SAT TT=1.648 CHECKS=8202166 NODES=2344	SAT TT=13.31	SAT TT=5.877	SAT TT=5.603	SAT TT=7.305 NODES=6754	SAT TT=7.508 NODES=2555	SAT TT=2.202 CHECKS=265668 NODES=1214	SAT TT=68.809	SAT TT=22.42 CHECKS=27386241 NODES=3136	SAT TT=17.413 CHECKS=22887756 NODES=2889	SAT TT=27.736 CHECKS=42329969 NODES=3002	SAT TT=10.514	SAT TT=4.87	SAT TT=5.625	SAT TT=7.944 CHECKS=11089411 NODES=869	SAT TT=7.681 CHECKS=11089411 NODES=869	SAT TT=10.301	SAT TT=9.881	? (TO) TT=1800.81	SAT TT=3.404	SAT TT=1.99 CHECKS=10204600 NODES=287	SAT TT=1.971 CHECKS=10204600 NODES=287
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-57_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.459	SAT TT=4.459 CHECKS=43806485 NODES=12754	SAT TT=4.733 CHECKS=48032480 NODES=13035	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=20.931	SAT TT=22.46	SAT TT=32.867 NODES=30724	SAT TT=9.066 NODES=4138	SAT TT=6.991 CHECKS=265578 NODES=7327	SAT TT=47.301	SAT TT=535.69 CHECKS=705554400 NODES=83959	SAT TT=130.494 CHECKS=151602964 NODES=18420	SAT TT=880.422 CHECKS=1255560475 NODES=117701	SAT TT=347.08	SAT TT=76.052	SAT TT=24.881	SAT TT=531.442 CHECKS=659383236 NODES=78070	SAT TT=494.548 CHECKS=659383236 NODES=78070	SAT TT=152.101	SAT TT=155.479	? (TO) TT=1800.39	SAT TT=29.369	SAT TT=31.688 CHECKS=1482820000 NODES=66677	SAT TT=12.14 CHECKS=566275000 NODES=19261
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-59_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=7.86	UNSAT TT=10.918 CHECKS=136808556 NODES=32265	UNSAT TT=9.137 CHECKS=117497235 NODES=28220	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=146.634	UNSAT TT=150.916	UNSAT TT=75.583 NODES=66679	UNSAT TT=40.06 NODES=15889	UNSAT TT=23.256 CHECKS=266633 NODES=23183	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=261.185 CHECKS=414023420 NODES=26976	UNSAT TT=275.532 CHECKS=432996809 NODES=28240	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=1192.62	UNSAT TT=401.843	UNSAT TT=45.174	UNSAT TT=245.117 CHECKS=406084220 NODES=25204	UNSAT TT=240.048 CHECKS=406084220 NODES=25204	UNSAT TT=1002.35	UNSAT TT=1131.7	? (TO) TT=1800.86	UNSAT TT=42.553	UNSAT TT=7.86 CHECKS=364330000 NODES=8619	UNSAT TT=7.392 CHECKS=357674000 NODES=8540
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-5_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.673	SAT TT=4.014 CHECKS=36432225 NODES=13206	SAT TT=3.86 CHECKS=35918796 NODES=12917	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=4.236	SAT TT=4.343	SAT TT=1.894 NODES=287	SAT TT=5.373 NODES=3209	SAT TT=2.673 CHECKS=265616 NODES=2497	SAT TT=1186.54	SAT TT=30.77 CHECKS=39667670 NODES=5662	SAT TT=22.251 CHECKS=25125203 NODES=3453	SAT TT=98.254 CHECKS=128857626 NODES=18194	SAT TT=298.541	SAT TT=175.42	SAT TT=16.986	SAT TT=337.096 CHECKS=477747632 NODES=52948	SAT TT=327.239 CHECKS=477747632 NODES=52948	SAT TT=44.17	SAT TT=41.85	? (TO) TT=1801.02	SAT TT=9.514	SAT TT=14.227 CHECKS=757938000 NODES=19928	SAT TT=13.831 CHECKS=773459000 NODES=18127
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-61_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=11.762	UNSAT TT=12.234 CHECKS=149237774 NODES=32763	UNSAT TT=11.762 CHECKS=141854666 NODES=31184	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=73.897	UNSAT TT=78.314	UNSAT TT=159.084 NODES=156744	UNSAT TT=66.785 NODES=23295	UNSAT TT=27.201 CHECKS=267413 NODES=27150	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=277.457 CHECKS=413447266 NODES=38057	UNSAT TT=277.082 CHECKS=412427081 NODES=37511	UNSAT TT=1360.35 CHECKS=2159111841 NODES=158172	UNSAT TT=1404.03	UNSAT TT=486.68	UNSAT TT=44.111	UNSAT TT=687.673 CHECKS=812518641 NODES=78617	UNSAT TT=691.659 CHECKS=812518641 NODES=78617	UNSAT TT=1191.57	UNSAT TT=1242.15	? (TO) TT=1800.2	UNSAT TT=47.431	UNSAT TT=22.725 CHECKS=1185870000 NODES=23596	UNSAT TT=18.112 CHECKS=975866000 NODES=17403
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-63_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=28.618	UNSAT TT=28.772 CHECKS=393337313 NODES=93054	UNSAT TT=30.31 CHECKS=395704244 NODES=93693	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=35.844	UNSAT TT=33.715	UNSAT TT=480.451 NODES=465327	UNSAT TT=144.593 NODES=61966	UNSAT TT=69.71 CHECKS=266413 NODES=72705	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=811.484 CHECKS=1218330836 NODES=94384	UNSAT TT=735.159 CHECKS=1229504798 NODES=96103	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=110.748	UNSAT TT=950.427 CHECKS=1544368011 NODES=103876	UNSAT TT=883.497 CHECKS=1544368011 NODES=103876	? (TO) TT=1800.19	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.73	UNSAT TT=119.339	UNSAT TT=28.618 CHECKS=1614400000 NODES=40463	UNSAT TT=22.229 CHECKS=1259500000 NODES=29275
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-65_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.477	SAT TT=1.694 CHECKS=7609819 NODES=1903	SAT TT=1.477 CHECKS=5954190 NODES=1709	? (TO) TT=1800.07	SAT TT=6.186	SAT TT=6.177	SAT TT=49.396 NODES=47647	SAT TT=66.153 NODES=28534	SAT TT=4.445 CHECKS=264666 NODES=4247	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=387.024 CHECKS=679798165 NODES=57101	SAT TT=434.996 CHECKS=780532402 NODES=65130	SAT TT=220.501 CHECKS=378360105 NODES=27994	SAT TT=36.65	SAT TT=110.797	SAT TT=14.781	SAT TT=383.75 CHECKS=689258631 NODES=55920	SAT TT=401.596 CHECKS=689258631 NODES=55920	SAT TT=40.982	SAT TT=40.392	? (TO) TT=1800.15	SAT TT=17.001	SAT TT=11.113 CHECKS=604787000 NODES=23159	SAT TT=10.663 CHECKS=604787000 NODES=23159
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-67_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=10.394	UNSAT TT=10.394 CHECKS=125877566 NODES=37213	UNSAT TT=10.863 CHECKS=125244231 NODES=37441	UNSAT TT=1332.12	UNSAT TT=45.008	UNSAT TT=48.062	UNSAT TT=99.956 NODES=90481	UNSAT TT=63.413 NODES=30195	UNSAT TT=26.324 CHECKS=268840 NODES=31691	? (TO) TT=1800.16	UNSAT TT=456.954 CHECKS=649959668 NODES=57948	UNSAT TT=343.903 CHECKS=528942795 NODES=49542	UNSAT TT=1028.02 CHECKS=1654651838 NODES=164538	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=1687.47	UNSAT TT=46.705	UNSAT TT=1075.32 CHECKS=1539537745 NODES=118994	UNSAT TT=1026.68 CHECKS=1539537745 NODES=118994	? (TO) TT=1800.14	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.66	UNSAT TT=40.406	UNSAT TT=23.295 CHECKS=1293920000 NODES=26353	UNSAT TT=22.521 CHECKS=1267790000 NODES=24890
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-69_ext.xml	SAT TT=3.295	SAT TT=4.211 CHECKS=38719431 NODES=10514	SAT TT=3.295 CHECKS=30807100 NODES=8263	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=21.246	SAT TT=20.166	SAT TT=13.683 NODES=13025	SAT TT=47.992 NODES=23634	SAT TT=8.464 CHECKS=264145 NODES=9477	SAT TT=899.003	SAT TT=311.147 CHECKS=413816233 NODES=38144	SAT TT=301.295 CHECKS=411163981 NODES=38222	SAT TT=420.6 CHECKS=596438785 NODES=47657	SAT TT=383.077	SAT TT=142.385	SAT TT=68.191	SAT TT=296.469 CHECKS=401762677 NODES=36284	SAT TT=287.331 CHECKS=401762677 NODES=36284	SAT TT=307.587	SAT TT=294.626	? (TO) TT=1800.85	SAT TT=122.272	SAT TT=82.868 CHECKS=4932420000 NODES=152877	SAT TT=7.362 CHECKS=348236000 NODES=10714
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-71_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.123	UNSAT TT=3.19 CHECKS=28285845 NODES=6045	UNSAT TT=3.123 CHECKS=28099735 NODES=5748	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=51.044	UNSAT TT=50.873	UNSAT TT=26.631 NODES=22852	UNSAT TT=14.131 NODES=3735	UNSAT TT=4.887 CHECKS=268458 NODES=3917	UNSAT TT=461.265	UNSAT TT=89.445 CHECKS=119687650 NODES=9130	UNSAT TT=59.843 CHECKS=98892290 NODES=7016	UNSAT TT=243.915 CHECKS=411653138 NODES=25758	UNSAT TT=74.285	UNSAT TT=41.584	UNSAT TT=8.251	UNSAT TT=77.246 CHECKS=112010972 NODES=7426	UNSAT TT=75.995 CHECKS=112010972 NODES=7426	UNSAT TT=26.084	UNSAT TT=31.611	? (TO) TT=1800.28	UNSAT TT=10.152	UNSAT TT=23.437 CHECKS=1431370000 NODES=34581	UNSAT TT=3.377 CHECKS=98992200 NODES=2226
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-73_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.625	UNSAT TT=4.785 CHECKS=51457864 NODES=11164	UNSAT TT=4.625 CHECKS=51342047 NODES=11183	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=60.621	UNSAT TT=57.494	UNSAT TT=44.128 NODES=42215	UNSAT TT=27.244 NODES=9538	UNSAT TT=10.246 CHECKS=265702 NODES=9392	UNSAT TT=1358.06	UNSAT TT=136.582 CHECKS=227671992 NODES=16616	UNSAT TT=145.99 CHECKS=222633817 NODES=16286	UNSAT TT=656.676 CHECKS=1109825266 NODES=69388	UNSAT TT=100.938	UNSAT TT=89.059	UNSAT TT=18.21	UNSAT TT=137.661 CHECKS=196264573 NODES=13369	UNSAT TT=132.2 CHECKS=196264573 NODES=13369	UNSAT TT=148.731	UNSAT TT=158.774	? (TO) TT=1800.18	UNSAT TT=18.695	UNSAT TT=4.688 CHECKS=185092000 NODES=3422	UNSAT TT=4.598 CHECKS=185092000 NODES=3422
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-75_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.016	SAT TT=1.259 CHECKS=2754385 NODES=527	SAT TT=1.016 CHECKS=1182089 NODES=288	SAT TT=92.387	SAT TT=5.654	SAT TT=5.691	SAT TT=4.372 NODES=3234	SAT TT=4.485 NODES=933	SAT TT=1.568 CHECKS=264910 NODES=320	SAT TT=238.039	SAT TT=48.967 CHECKS=86588522 NODES=5555	SAT TT=47.051 CHECKS=81404492 NODES=5349	SAT TT=207.563 CHECKS=348152119 NODES=18207	SAT TT=23.451	SAT TT=15.864	SAT TT=7.805	SAT TT=40.338 CHECKS=73054876 NODES=3374	SAT TT=40.53 CHECKS=73054876 NODES=3374	SAT TT=5.071	SAT TT=5.126	? (TO) TT=1800.66	SAT TT=8.338	SAT TT=2.768 CHECKS=63410000 NODES=902	SAT TT=2.626 CHECKS=63410000 NODES=902
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-77_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.309	UNSAT TT=4.363 CHECKS=51917974 NODES=10354	UNSAT TT=4.309 CHECKS=52016326 NODES=10420	UNSAT TT=266.233	UNSAT TT=37.778	UNSAT TT=37.192	UNSAT TT=40.263 NODES=33415	UNSAT TT=18.411 NODES=6466	UNSAT TT=9.981 CHECKS=265922 NODES=8937	UNSAT TT=1656.47	UNSAT TT=124.195 CHECKS=166601282 NODES=14596	UNSAT TT=98.443 CHECKS=165167233 NODES=13843	UNSAT TT=469.964 CHECKS=839435595 NODES=53295	UNSAT TT=111.991	UNSAT TT=93.688	UNSAT TT=14.901	UNSAT TT=101.16 CHECKS=133043216 NODES=9314	UNSAT TT=91.521 CHECKS=133043216 NODES=9314	UNSAT TT=90.257	UNSAT TT=90.868	? (TO) TT=1800.17	UNSAT TT=12.444	UNSAT TT=4.367 CHECKS=148557000 NODES=3120	UNSAT TT=3.733 CHECKS=125208000 NODES=1808
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-79_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.921	UNSAT TT=4.597 CHECKS=46627459 NODES=10026	UNSAT TT=4.501 CHECKS=49534804 NODES=10939	UNSAT TT=316.263	UNSAT TT=37.387	UNSAT TT=37.337	UNSAT TT=33.209 NODES=24958	UNSAT TT=18.148 NODES=6559	UNSAT TT=10.092 CHECKS=268284 NODES=9392	UNSAT TT=1289.3	UNSAT TT=99.98 CHECKS=159597620 NODES=11365	UNSAT TT=107.572 CHECKS=173280015 NODES=12921	UNSAT TT=418.595 CHECKS=670046575 NODES=43311	UNSAT TT=195.229	UNSAT TT=97.734	UNSAT TT=17.133	UNSAT TT=95.642 CHECKS=146677884 NODES=9389	UNSAT TT=90.491 CHECKS=146677884 NODES=9389	UNSAT TT=117.123	UNSAT TT=125.256	? (TO) TT=1800.41	UNSAT TT=17.761	UNSAT TT=3.921 CHECKS=146551000 NODES=2826	UNSAT TT=4.289 CHECKS=146551000 NODES=2826
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-7_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.823	SAT TT=1.881 CHECKS=13222059 NODES=2727	SAT TT=2.081 CHECKS=14188602 NODES=2861	SAT TT=32.085	SAT TT=0.823	SAT TT=0.866	SAT TT=18.226 NODES=16143	SAT TT=4.072 NODES=876	SAT TT=2.002 CHECKS=265021 NODES=754	SAT TT=173.585	SAT TT=17.675 CHECKS=20667317 NODES=2518	SAT TT=27.225 CHECKS=37774495 NODES=3498	SAT TT=36.148 CHECKS=60299404 NODES=3373	SAT TT=17.52	SAT TT=15.094	SAT TT=1.055	SAT TT=3.244 CHECKS=3788452 NODES=253	SAT TT=2.937 CHECKS=3788452 NODES=253	SAT TT=20.186	SAT TT=19.982	? (TO) TT=1800.25	SAT TT=1.952	SAT TT=1.785 CHECKS=6727780 NODES=154	SAT TT=1.88 CHECKS=5066920 NODES=103
tightness/tightness0.8/ rand-2-40-80-103-800-9_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.498	SAT TT=8.613 CHECKS=101515936 NODES=23682	SAT TT=8.348 CHECKS=99275105 NODES=23337	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=5.277	SAT TT=5.154	SAT TT=92.632 NODES=80986	SAT TT=22.573 NODES=8878	SAT TT=22.53 CHECKS=269071 NODES=22676	SAT TT=272.006	SAT TT=236.756 CHECKS=360442115 NODES=28077	SAT TT=18.107 CHECKS=20898260 NODES=2566	SAT TT=890.314 CHECKS=1420487366 NODES=90339	SAT TT=408.037	SAT TT=440.845	SAT TT=6.759	SAT TT=401.02 CHECKS=602184951 NODES=46918	SAT TT=400.539 CHECKS=602184951 NODES=46918	SAT TT=33.982	SAT TT=35.123	? (TO) TT=1800.21	SAT TT=0.498	SAT TT=12.637 CHECKS=631061000 NODES=16069	SAT TT=11.304 CHECKS=591540000 NODES=14263
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-11_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.58	UNSAT TT=1.779 CHECKS=8858513 NODES=863	UNSAT TT=1.58 CHECKS=7866532 NODES=815	UNSAT TT=426.698	UNSAT TT=3.489	UNSAT TT=3.891	UNSAT TT=24.344 NODES=11491	UNSAT TT=12.129 NODES=682	UNSAT TT=3.158 CHECKS=543802 NODES=724	? (MO) TT=6.871	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.035	UNSAT TT=30.08	UNSAT TT=34.655	UNSAT TT=4.455	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.033	UNSAT TT=26.664	UNSAT TT=29.031	? (TO) TT=1800.7	UNSAT TT=4.385	UNSAT TT=17.858 CHECKS=350454000 NODES=1429	UNSAT TT=16.993 CHECKS=350057000 NODES=967
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-13_ext.xml	SAT TT=9.897	SAT TT=10.007 CHECKS=176365816 NODES=21816	SAT TT=10.623 CHECKS=180652561 NODES=22878	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=26.004	SAT TT=28.119	SAT TT=55.718 NODES=31118	SAT TT=59.204 NODES=9293	SAT TT=18.917 CHECKS=547861 NODES=12670	? (MO) TT=7.417	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=85.37	SAT TT=23.855	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (problem) TT=0.036	SAT TT=337.984	SAT TT=335.86	? (TO) TT=1800.23	SAT TT=9.897	SAT TT=111.47 CHECKS=5999410000 NODES=59343	SAT TT=15.654 CHECKS=322493000 NODES=3416
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-15_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.15	UNSAT TT=3.375 CHECKS=37210974 NODES=2796	UNSAT TT=3.15 CHECKS=36150788 NODES=2838	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=4.918	UNSAT TT=5.086	UNSAT TT=96.464 NODES=47484	UNSAT TT=27.768 NODES=2386	UNSAT TT=6.909 CHECKS=552153 NODES=2720	? (MO) TT=7.206	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.034	UNSAT TT=74.301	UNSAT TT=44.159	UNSAT TT=18.493	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (problem) TT=0.035	UNSAT TT=50.3	UNSAT TT=54.841	? (TO) TT=1800.97	UNSAT TT=18.743	UNSAT TT=15.235 CHECKS=269029000 NODES=799	UNSAT TT=14.651 CHECKS=269029000 NODES=799
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-17_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.461	SAT TT=1.461 CHECKS=4471567 NODES=461	SAT TT=1.772 CHECKS=10533057 NODES=1014	SAT TT=812.885	SAT TT=2.124	SAT TT=2.569	SAT TT=42.626 NODES=22670	SAT TT=64.847 NODES=10462	SAT TT=16.767 CHECKS=552306 NODES=10192	? (MO) TT=7.308	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=36.685	SAT TT=107.542	SAT TT=6.003	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=0.034	SAT TT=388.743	SAT TT=355.489	? (TO) TT=1801	SAT TT=10.155	SAT TT=14.949 CHECKS=281205000 NODES=2273	SAT TT=14.765 CHECKS=281205000 NODES=2271
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-19_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.86	SAT TT=1.86 CHECKS=9867209 NODES=1134	SAT TT=2.45 CHECKS=20441220 NODES=2691	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=8.245	SAT TT=8.633	SAT TT=18.701 NODES=10405	SAT TT=9.806 NODES=1752	SAT TT=3.947 CHECKS=547111 NODES=1714	? (MO) TT=6.974	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (conv) TT=0	SAT TT=145.761	SAT TT=292.343	SAT TT=4.514	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.034	SAT TT=1593.5	SAT TT=1584.54	? (TO) TT=1800.25	SAT TT=30.109	SAT TT=19.28 CHECKS=530445000 NODES=5392	SAT TT=10.537 CHECKS=57214800 NODES=484
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-1_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.944	SAT TT=3.042 CHECKS=33583924 NODES=2545	SAT TT=2.944 CHECKS=29554426 NODES=2288	SAT TT=42.973	SAT TT=3.114	SAT TT=3.481	SAT TT=9.636 NODES=3662	SAT TT=24.11 NODES=2047	SAT TT=3.005 CHECKS=545632 NODES=479	? (MO) TT=6.843	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (conv) TT=0	SAT TT=68.816	SAT TT=17.345	SAT TT=9.692	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.033	SAT TT=31.032	SAT TT=35.742	? (TO) TT=1800.15	SAT TT=11.767	SAT TT=10.907 CHECKS=32154600 NODES=195	SAT TT=10.465 CHECKS=32154600 NODES=193
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-21_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.593	SAT TT=1.159 CHECKS=596223 NODES=59	SAT TT=1.125 CHECKS=79068 NODES=50	SAT TT=23.913	SAT TT=1.839	SAT TT=2.287	SAT TT=1.918 NODES=50	SAT TT=2.358 NODES=91	SAT TT=2.253 CHECKS=544646 NODES=153	? (MO) TT=6.864	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=25.209	SAT TT=11.305	SAT TT=0.6	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (problem) TT=0.033	SAT TT=5.401	SAT TT=5.591	? (TO) TT=1800.45	SAT TT=0.593	SAT TT=10.319 CHECKS=4786340 NODES=123	SAT TT=10.363 CHECKS=4786340 NODES=122
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-23_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=15.756	UNSAT TT=15.756 CHECKS=272082831 NODES=25548	UNSAT TT=15.999 CHECKS=278248090 NODES=25747	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=134.319	UNSAT TT=134.353	UNSAT TT=196.491 NODES=109471	UNSAT TT=117.499 NODES=19867	UNSAT TT=33.328 CHECKS=551525 NODES=20340	? (MO) TT=7.206	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.035	UNSAT TT=1438.65	UNSAT TT=781.121	UNSAT TT=102.474	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (problem) TT=0.032	UNSAT TT=670.741	UNSAT TT=680.244	? (TO) TT=1800.71	UNSAT TT=105.171	UNSAT TT=25.666 CHECKS=873952000 NODES=3514	UNSAT TT=25.854 CHECKS=874254000 NODES=3517
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-25_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=1.887	UNSAT TT=1.962 CHECKS=13050996 NODES=799	UNSAT TT=1.887 CHECKS=12807196 NODES=838	UNSAT TT=75.771	UNSAT TT=2.163	UNSAT TT=2.358	UNSAT TT=22.529 NODES=7081	UNSAT TT=16.416 NODES=711	UNSAT TT=3.882 CHECKS=546083 NODES=959	? (MO) TT=6.666	? (conv) TT=0	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.036	UNSAT TT=28.139	UNSAT TT=21.768	UNSAT TT=6.996	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.034	UNSAT TT=17.435	UNSAT TT=18.191	? (TO) TT=1800.3	UNSAT TT=6.791	UNSAT TT=19.414 CHECKS=493948000 NODES=3665	UNSAT TT=11.38 CHECKS=67276200 NODES=141
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-27_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=231.646	UNSAT TT=231.646 CHECKS=4561260999 NODES=501532	UNSAT TT=280.36 CHECKS=4979444244 NODES=584200	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=271.289	UNSAT TT=270.529	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=1683.68 NODES=404216	UNSAT TT=572.031 CHECKS=549634 NODES=453322	? (MO) TT=7.244	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800	UNSAT TT=1699.91	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.23	? (TO) TT=1800.32	UNSAT TT=1781.44	UNSAT TT=515.583 CHECKS=27095300000 NODES=265306	UNSAT TT=308.752 CHECKS=16325700000 NODES=144305
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-29_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.149	UNSAT TT=3.149 CHECKS=34365915 NODES=2343	UNSAT TT=3.603 CHECKS=48765052 NODES=3565	? (TO) TT=1800.06	UNSAT TT=3.57	UNSAT TT=4.091	UNSAT TT=50.769 NODES=21625	UNSAT TT=23.511 NODES=2077	UNSAT TT=6.652 CHECKS=551486 NODES=2589	? (MO) TT=7.067	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.035	UNSAT TT=60.729	UNSAT TT=39.934	UNSAT TT=18.734	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.034	UNSAT TT=43.974	UNSAT TT=43.559	? (TO) TT=1800.22	UNSAT TT=18.281	UNSAT TT=14.397 CHECKS=268229000 NODES=484	UNSAT TT=14.412 CHECKS=268229000 NODES=484
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-31_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.183	SAT TT=1.201 CHECKS=954594 NODES=107	SAT TT=1.183 CHECKS=475340 NODES=100	SAT TT=272.32	SAT TT=2.228	SAT TT=2.518	SAT TT=2.24 NODES=70	SAT TT=3.188 NODES=193	SAT TT=2.116 CHECKS=543402 NODES=211	? (MO) TT=6.803	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.034	SAT TT=46.102	SAT TT=13.671	SAT TT=9.087	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.033	SAT TT=47.637	SAT TT=44.047	? (TO) TT=1800.25	SAT TT=4.323	SAT TT=17.862 CHECKS=491213000 NODES=5916	SAT TT=11.477 CHECKS=126743000 NODES=842
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-33_ext.xml	SAT TT=4.441	SAT TT=4.441 CHECKS=50480652 NODES=7670	SAT TT=15.787 CHECKS=232066922 NODES=32724	SAT TT=306.316	SAT TT=98.924	SAT TT=92.908	SAT TT=19.463 NODES=11065	SAT TT=26.395 NODES=6152	SAT TT=8.895 CHECKS=546666 NODES=6069	? (MO) TT=7.416	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=1283.56	SAT TT=116.659	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.036	SAT TT=41.644	SAT TT=42.815	? (TO) TT=1800.52	SAT TT=287.237	SAT TT=243.874 CHECKS=12277500000 NODES=198890	SAT TT=30.657 CHECKS=1218170000 NODES=15648
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-35_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.964	UNSAT TT=4.145 CHECKS=54590463 NODES=3897	UNSAT TT=3.964 CHECKS=55928697 NODES=4118	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=4.695	UNSAT TT=4.945	UNSAT TT=81.017 NODES=37529	UNSAT TT=38.756 NODES=3419	UNSAT TT=8.556 CHECKS=552080 NODES=3634	? (MO) TT=7.383	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.036	UNSAT TT=110.486	UNSAT TT=85.244	UNSAT TT=25.739	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (conv) TT=0	UNSAT TT=150.955	UNSAT TT=164.064	? (TO) TT=1800.98	UNSAT TT=24.788	? (TO) TT=1800.07	UNSAT TT=40.764 CHECKS=1707620000 NODES=6991
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-37_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.182	SAT TT=1.396 CHECKS=2628080 NODES=339	SAT TT=1.182 CHECKS=177662 NODES=53	SAT TT=59.823	SAT TT=2.077	SAT TT=2.349	SAT TT=3.423 NODES=810	SAT TT=16.536 NODES=1833	SAT TT=7.353 CHECKS=548241 NODES=3782	? (MO) TT=6.866	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (conv) TT=0	SAT TT=25.693	SAT TT=16.049	SAT TT=10.213	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.033	SAT TT=7.481	SAT TT=7.226	? (TO) TT=1800.21	SAT TT=5.9	SAT TT=16.934 CHECKS=371335000 NODES=12348	SAT TT=10.4 CHECKS=43533700 NODES=805
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-39_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=9.114	UNSAT TT=9.114 CHECKS=156098611 NODES=11062	UNSAT TT=9.42 CHECKS=151347153 NODES=10662	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=73.367	UNSAT TT=78.192	UNSAT TT=146.339 NODES=63451	UNSAT TT=89.779 NODES=9620	UNSAT TT=22.983 CHECKS=551023 NODES=9744	? (MO) TT=6.859	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.036	UNSAT TT=1778.86	UNSAT TT=200.662	UNSAT TT=73.07	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (conv) TT=0	UNSAT TT=236.76	UNSAT TT=250.202	? (TO) TT=1800.63	UNSAT TT=74.88	UNSAT TT=30.042 CHECKS=1182420000 NODES=7411	UNSAT TT=20.672 CHECKS=639690000 NODES=2738
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-3_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.6	UNSAT TT=2.6 CHECKS=29221992 NODES=2028	UNSAT TT=2.826 CHECKS=28868418 NODES=2134	? (TO) TT=1800.14	UNSAT TT=2.701	UNSAT TT=2.915	UNSAT TT=37.997 NODES=16359	UNSAT TT=21.527 NODES=1976	UNSAT TT=5.711 CHECKS=552367 NODES=2123	? (MO) TT=6.716	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (problem) TT=0.032	UNSAT TT=36.868	UNSAT TT=28.495	UNSAT TT=11.442	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.035	UNSAT TT=30.551	UNSAT TT=32.561	? (TO) TT=1800.77	UNSAT TT=11.57	UNSAT TT=11.878 CHECKS=128732000 NODES=303	UNSAT TT=12.037 CHECKS=128732000 NODES=303
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-41_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.754	UNSAT TT=4.982 CHECKS=75836831 NODES=5725	UNSAT TT=4.754 CHECKS=68807963 NODES=5076	UNSAT TT=772.817	UNSAT TT=5.523	UNSAT TT=5.971	UNSAT TT=83.56 NODES=38737	UNSAT TT=44.154 NODES=3848	UNSAT TT=10.431 CHECKS=553850 NODES=4610	? (MO) TT=7.306	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.033	UNSAT TT=300.755	UNSAT TT=79.446	UNSAT TT=34.653	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.035	UNSAT TT=102.372	UNSAT TT=109.009	? (TO) TT=1800.96	UNSAT TT=33.954	UNSAT TT=19.535 CHECKS=476344000 NODES=1517	UNSAT TT=18.929 CHECKS=454053000 NODES=928
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-43_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.089	UNSAT TT=2.089 CHECKS=16601157 NODES=1679	UNSAT TT=2.098 CHECKS=15304041 NODES=1677	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=5.492	UNSAT TT=5.876	UNSAT TT=72.547 NODES=35034	UNSAT TT=21.679 NODES=1269	UNSAT TT=4.321 CHECKS=548152 NODES=1249	? (MO) TT=6.848	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (conv) TT=0	UNSAT TT=106.741	UNSAT TT=62.15	UNSAT TT=9.678	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (problem) TT=0.033	UNSAT TT=57.627	UNSAT TT=58.464	? (TO) TT=1800.97	UNSAT TT=9.11	UNSAT TT=17.468 CHECKS=411665000 NODES=1106	UNSAT TT=17.332 CHECKS=390204000 NODES=782
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-45_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.329	UNSAT TT=2.617 CHECKS=22937681 NODES=1930	UNSAT TT=2.329 CHECKS=22476234 NODES=1929	UNSAT TT=94.73	UNSAT TT=2.877	UNSAT TT=3.309	UNSAT TT=30.36 NODES=13961	UNSAT TT=18.882 NODES=1330	UNSAT TT=4.154 CHECKS=554405 NODES=1342	? (MO) TT=7.422	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.035	UNSAT TT=42.457	UNSAT TT=20.24	UNSAT TT=12.589	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.033	UNSAT TT=15.478	UNSAT TT=14.98	? (TO) TT=1800.65	UNSAT TT=13.54	UNSAT TT=12.363 CHECKS=103823000 NODES=325	UNSAT TT=11.924 CHECKS=103823000 NODES=325
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-47_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.154	SAT TT=2.573 CHECKS=21389321 NODES=2788	SAT TT=3.506 CHECKS=35988552 NODES=5445	SAT TT=415.642	SAT TT=37.913	SAT TT=36.066	SAT TT=27.446 NODES=14719	SAT TT=5.059 NODES=655	SAT TT=2.154 CHECKS=544337 NODES=217	? (MO) TT=7.378	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (conv) TT=0	? (TO) TT=1800	SAT TT=82.698	SAT TT=12.55	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.033	SAT TT=41.839	SAT TT=43.847	? (TO) TT=1800.99	SAT TT=91.93	SAT TT=15.185 CHECKS=372413000 NODES=3627	SAT TT=15.633 CHECKS=375007000 NODES=3388
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-49_ext.xml	SAT TT=7.985	SAT TT=35.093 CHECKS=591618427 NODES=78727	SAT TT=10.664 CHECKS=173641728 NODES=22126	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=7.985	SAT TT=8.68	SAT TT=104.499 NODES=62253	SAT TT=76.798 NODES=17727	SAT TT=29.575 CHECKS=546693 NODES=23686	? (MO) TT=7.211	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (TO) TT=1800.03	SAT TT=186.382	SAT TT=88.537	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=73.96	SAT TT=72.194	? (TO) TT=1800.95	SAT TT=46.357	SAT TT=13.357 CHECKS=211525000 NODES=2673	SAT TT=13.49 CHECKS=211525000 NODES=2673
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-51_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.817	SAT TT=1.359 CHECKS=1718867 NODES=201	SAT TT=1.183 CHECKS=743271 NODES=126	SAT TT=55.059	SAT TT=2.552	SAT TT=3.097	SAT TT=3.19 NODES=972	SAT TT=5.055 NODES=456	SAT TT=2.723 CHECKS=545012 NODES=561	? (MO) TT=6.808	? (problem) TT=0.038	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.033	SAT TT=32.537	SAT TT=10.928	SAT TT=2.384	? (problem) TT=0.038	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=6.906	SAT TT=6.692	? (TO) TT=1800.79	SAT TT=0.817	SAT TT=11.264 CHECKS=55220600 NODES=511	SAT TT=11.139 CHECKS=55220600 NODES=511
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-53_ext.xml	SAT TT=28.061	SAT TT=28.968 CHECKS=512233863 NODES=52790	SAT TT=28.061 CHECKS=500410557 NODES=51721	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=582.003	SAT TT=591.64	SAT TT=249.494 NODES=129850	SAT TT=311.05 NODES=51617	SAT TT=78.929 CHECKS=546094 NODES=53349	? (MO) TT=6.824	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=190.555	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.034	SAT TT=757.652	SAT TT=756.12	? (TO) TT=1801.02	SAT TT=211.567	SAT TT=79.903 CHECKS=3043460000 NODES=24076	SAT TT=42.687 CHECKS=1581650000 NODES=8576
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-55_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.328	SAT TT=1.328 CHECKS=2616411 NODES=333	SAT TT=1.412 CHECKS=2943009 NODES=424	SAT TT=28.141	SAT TT=2	SAT TT=2.402	SAT TT=2.553 NODES=125	SAT TT=4.602 NODES=448	SAT TT=2.209 CHECKS=547027 NODES=260	? (MO) TT=7.076	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=39.74	SAT TT=9.733	SAT TT=2.566	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.033	SAT TT=6.492	SAT TT=6.45	? (TO) TT=1800.31	SAT TT=4.085	SAT TT=11.008 CHECKS=29559600 NODES=728	SAT TT=10.882 CHECKS=32770800 NODES=434
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-57_ext.xml	SAT TT=126.471	SAT TT=134.562 CHECKS=2280391773 NODES=290302	SAT TT=126.471 CHECKS=2222806410 NODES=284121	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=169.239	SAT TT=169.704	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=536.913 NODES=126972	SAT TT=191.528 CHECKS=548035 NODES=176316	? (MO) TT=7.4	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.1	SAT TT=654.564	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (TO) TT=1800.23	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.8	SAT TT=679.877	SAT TT=565.953 CHECKS=24855300000 NODES=513212	SAT TT=148.131 CHECKS=7368190000 NODES=88825
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-59_ext.xml	SAT TT=42.465	SAT TT=44.397 CHECKS=762493392 NODES=88991	SAT TT=47.433 CHECKS=831583971 NODES=95880	? (TO) TT=1800.11	SAT TT=118.97	SAT TT=127.596	SAT TT=549.614 NODES=291696	SAT TT=122.91 NODES=24205	SAT TT=42.465 CHECKS=551646 NODES=30281	? (MO) TT=7.073	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (TO) TT=1800.04	? (TO) TT=1800.08	SAT TT=345.281	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (TO) TT=1800.13	? (TO) TT=1800.18	? (TO) TT=1800.82	SAT TT=175.824	SAT TT=100.702 CHECKS=4819690000 NODES=31746	SAT TT=99.81 CHECKS=4932320000 NODES=29867
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-5_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.686	SAT TT=2.623 CHECKS=20493541 NODES=2446	SAT TT=2.343 CHECKS=16024216 NODES=1854	SAT TT=117.426	SAT TT=1.851	SAT TT=2.231	SAT TT=4.836 NODES=1813	SAT TT=7.556 NODES=1084	SAT TT=3.428 CHECKS=546341 NODES=1061	? (MO) TT=7.422	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.032	SAT TT=43.543	SAT TT=19.838	SAT TT=2.085	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=10.493	SAT TT=10.319	? (TO) TT=1801.01	SAT TT=0.686	SAT TT=10.135 CHECKS=22210000 NODES=160	SAT TT=10.676 CHECKS=22210000 NODES=159
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-61_ext.xml	SAT TT=0.778	SAT TT=1.29 CHECKS=1687169 NODES=207	SAT TT=1.328 CHECKS=1470565 NODES=268	SAT TT=29.919	SAT TT=2.114	SAT TT=2.392	SAT TT=12.048 NODES=6717	SAT TT=3.882 NODES=502	SAT TT=2.327 CHECKS=544637 NODES=365	? (MO) TT=7.415	? (problem) TT=0.032	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.033	SAT TT=27.06	SAT TT=14.755	SAT TT=1.241	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.034	SAT TT=7.77	SAT TT=8.261	? (TO) TT=1800.14	SAT TT=0.778	SAT TT=10.087 CHECKS=34532300 NODES=641	SAT TT=10.73 CHECKS=28237900 NODES=265
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-63_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=6.413	UNSAT TT=6.413 CHECKS=96436057 NODES=9249	UNSAT TT=6.645 CHECKS=98284204 NODES=9561	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=42.976	UNSAT TT=43.956	UNSAT TT=149.955 NODES=78618	UNSAT TT=65.637 NODES=7864	UNSAT TT=15.199 CHECKS=549127 NODES=8214	? (MO) TT=7.423	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=0.033	UNSAT TT=614.88	UNSAT TT=548.725	UNSAT TT=40.038	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.035	UNSAT TT=534.686	UNSAT TT=534.024	? (TO) TT=1800.31	UNSAT TT=42.522	UNSAT TT=25.033 CHECKS=824177000 NODES=5349	UNSAT TT=24.122 CHECKS=807790000 NODES=4570
Bench name	Best results on this instance	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-65_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=14.989	UNSAT TT=14.989 CHECKS=257564003 NODES=26270	UNSAT TT=15.626 CHECKS=267550826 NODES=27452	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=436.732	UNSAT TT=439.246	UNSAT TT=498.794 NODES=235943	UNSAT TT=194.969 NODES=20015	UNSAT TT=31.682 CHECKS=546750 NODES=19136	? (MO) TT=7.172	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=155.132	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (conv) TT=0	? (TO) TT=1800.21	? (TO) TT=1800.24	? (TO) TT=1800.15	UNSAT TT=160.182	UNSAT TT=106.533 CHECKS=5490340000 NODES=74498	UNSAT TT=60.757 CHECKS=3192740000 NODES=19551
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-67_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=5.025	UNSAT TT=5.025 CHECKS=72217408 NODES=5385	UNSAT TT=5.072 CHECKS=71773780 NODES=5413	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=5.713	UNSAT TT=5.886	UNSAT TT=100.047 NODES=43822	UNSAT TT=46.684 NODES=4987	UNSAT TT=11.063 CHECKS=551035 NODES=4736	? (MO) TT=7.384	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (conv) TT=0	UNSAT TT=218.704	UNSAT TT=105.708	UNSAT TT=30.872	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.032	UNSAT TT=81.199	UNSAT TT=90.426	? (TO) TT=1800.23	UNSAT TT=29.021	UNSAT TT=48.928 CHECKS=1731180000 NODES=10492	UNSAT TT=21.606 CHECKS=621746000 NODES=3077
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-69_ext.xml	SAT TT=1.362	SAT TT=1.362 CHECKS=1892926 NODES=196	SAT TT=1.611 CHECKS=7044392 NODES=793	SAT TT=513.769	SAT TT=2.645	SAT TT=3.177	SAT TT=2.337 NODES=90	SAT TT=4.952 NODES=419	SAT TT=2.541 CHECKS=545961 NODES=383	? (MO) TT=7.123	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=109.97	SAT TT=16.594	SAT TT=9.771	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.034	SAT TT=43.61	SAT TT=40.806	? (TO) TT=1800.28	SAT TT=9.823	SAT TT=14.044 CHECKS=206846000 NODES=1883	SAT TT=13.015 CHECKS=206846000 NODES=1881
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-71_ext.xml	SAT TT=22.201	SAT TT=22.201 CHECKS=361960228 NODES=34903	SAT TT=26.355 CHECKS=449393382 NODES=43501	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=113.322	SAT TT=106.873	SAT TT=67.99 NODES=35498	SAT TT=197.236 NODES=27736	SAT TT=26.714 CHECKS=546343 NODES=15873	? (MO) TT=7.403	? (problem) TT=0.039	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (TO) TT=1800.09	SAT TT=964.62	SAT TT=68.68	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=1130.42	SAT TT=1164.63	? (TO) TT=1800.7	SAT TT=81.765	SAT TT=1497.59 CHECKS=64147000000 NODES=1017040	SAT TT=54.704 CHECKS=2298230000 NODES=22215
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-73_ext.xml	SAT TT=2.689	SAT TT=2.876 CHECKS=27013788 NODES=2479	SAT TT=2.689 CHECKS=27999744 NODES=2662	? (TO) TT=1800.05	SAT TT=4.418	SAT TT=4.716	SAT TT=33.336 NODES=17006	SAT TT=74.163 NODES=9934	SAT TT=20.021 CHECKS=549325 NODES=10550	? (MO) TT=6.734	? (conv) TT=0	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.034	SAT TT=50.429	SAT TT=287.835	SAT TT=10.721	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.035	SAT TT=35.76	SAT TT=35.705	? (TO) TT=1801.13	SAT TT=10.653	SAT TT=16.112 CHECKS=392286000 NODES=2021	SAT TT=16.383 CHECKS=392286000 NODES=2019
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-75_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.949	UNSAT TT=4.884 CHECKS=66927373 NODES=4833	UNSAT TT=4.72 CHECKS=68811874 NODES=5025	UNSAT TT=229.286	UNSAT TT=3.949	UNSAT TT=4.518	UNSAT TT=40.839 NODES=17327	UNSAT TT=27.509 NODES=2551	UNSAT TT=9.231 CHECKS=551591 NODES=3999	? (MO) TT=6.811	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (conv) TT=0	UNSAT TT=119.318	UNSAT TT=31.525	UNSAT TT=20.537	? (problem) TT=0.039	? (problem) TT=0.035	UNSAT TT=32.644	UNSAT TT=36.267	? (TO) TT=1800.99	UNSAT TT=22.565	UNSAT TT=14.963 CHECKS=247747000 NODES=690	UNSAT TT=14.489 CHECKS=234533000 NODES=490
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-77_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.525	UNSAT TT=4.525 CHECKS=67955246 NODES=5776	UNSAT TT=4.769 CHECKS=68710517 NODES=5988	UNSAT TT=323.16	UNSAT TT=5.529	UNSAT TT=5.638	UNSAT TT=92.319 NODES=53803	UNSAT TT=32.936 NODES=3916	UNSAT TT=9.53 CHECKS=546830 NODES=4436	? (MO) TT=7.206	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.033	UNSAT TT=334.534	UNSAT TT=88.282	UNSAT TT=24.286	? (problem) TT=0.033	? (problem) TT=0.037	UNSAT TT=118.899	UNSAT TT=115.059	? (TO) TT=1800.37	UNSAT TT=23.785	UNSAT TT=21.477 CHECKS=549260000 NODES=1524	UNSAT TT=18.96 CHECKS=454966000 NODES=1024
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-79_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=4.383	UNSAT TT=5.829 CHECKS=86577128 NODES=5517	UNSAT TT=4.383 CHECKS=58904378 NODES=4212	UNSAT TT=158.003	UNSAT TT=4.579	UNSAT TT=4.742	UNSAT TT=46.089 NODES=20668	UNSAT TT=29.28 NODES=2961	UNSAT TT=13.077 CHECKS=550058 NODES=5127	? (MO) TT=7.112	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.036	UNSAT TT=71.751	UNSAT TT=57.438	UNSAT TT=25.925	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.034	UNSAT TT=34.289	UNSAT TT=37.358	? (TO) TT=1800.97	UNSAT TT=15.626	UNSAT TT=17.272 CHECKS=290692000 NODES=1897	UNSAT TT=15.478 CHECKS=234771000 NODES=758
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-7_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=2.426	UNSAT TT=2.426 CHECKS=24088264 NODES=2208	UNSAT TT=2.467 CHECKS=24121398 NODES=2302	UNSAT TT=1048.23	UNSAT TT=4.238	UNSAT TT=4.653	UNSAT TT=30.616 NODES=13416	UNSAT TT=17.038 NODES=1133	UNSAT TT=4.978 CHECKS=548078 NODES=1903	? (MO) TT=6.805	? (problem) TT=0.034	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.036	UNSAT TT=48.724	UNSAT TT=31.991	UNSAT TT=9.774	? (problem) TT=0.037	? (problem) TT=0.036	UNSAT TT=38.273	UNSAT TT=35.362	? (TO) TT=1800.78	UNSAT TT=10.362	UNSAT TT=13.612 CHECKS=159652000 NODES=646	UNSAT TT=12.955 CHECKS=163756000 NODES=492
tightness/tightness0.9/ rand-2-40-180-84-900-9_ext.xml	UNSAT TT=3.992	UNSAT TT=3.992 CHECKS=56532527 NODES=4625	UNSAT TT=4.402 CHECKS=57663370 NODES=4963	UNSAT TT=873.217	UNSAT TT=31.584	UNSAT TT=29.936	UNSAT TT=64.764 NODES=27697	UNSAT TT=37.731 NODES=4011	UNSAT TT=8.618 CHECKS=550692 NODES=3930	? (MO) TT=7.065	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.035	? (problem) TT=0.034	UNSAT TT=113.261	UNSAT TT=74.864	UNSAT TT=25.367	? (problem) TT=0.036	? (problem) TT=0.033	UNSAT TT=78.37	UNSAT TT=80.085	? (TO) TT=1800.16	UNSAT TT=25.654	UNSAT TT=33.687 CHECKS=1239140000 NODES=12870	UNSAT TT=15.847 CHECKS=315227000 NODES=1452

Some statistics...

	Abscon 109 ESAC	Abscon 109 AC	BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13	buggy_2_5 2007-01-08	buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08	CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19	CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16	CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3	Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21	Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22	Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21	galac 1	galacJ beta 1	Mistral 2006-12-04	rjw-solver 2006-12-09	rjw-solver 2007-01-21	sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3	SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3	sugar 0.40	Tramontane 2006-12-04	VALCSP 3.0	VALCSP 3.1
Number of times the solver is able to give the best known answer	474	477	367	488	489	0	0	430	268	0	0	0	333	323	456	0	0	305	302	199	445	490	0
Number of times the solver is the best solver from a complete solver point of view (i.e. best known answer and best TT time)	69	67	8	29	17	0	0	7	5	0	0	0	0	0	10	0	0	1	0	0	19	280	0