This site gives some information based on the answers provided by the different solvers. Not all answers given by a solver can be checked efficiently. Therefore, some answers given by a solver may be wrong but this may be unnoticed by the evaluation environment.

Here are the checks made for each answer.

- SATISFIABLE answers:

The model provided by the solver is given to a verifier program which checks that all constraints are actually satisfied. These answers are the only ones that are guaranteed to be true. - UNSATISFIABLE answers:

The only check that is made is to verify that no other solver found a solution to this instance. An UNSATISFIABLE answer is not reliable. Some solvers may wrongly indicate UNSATISFIABLE but unless another solver finds a model, this will remain undetected. - OPTIMUM FOUND answers:

Beyond verifying the model and the value of the objective function, the only check that is made is to verify that no other solver found a better solution to this instance. An OPTIMUM FOUND answer is not reliable. Some solvers may wrongly indicate OPTIMUM FOUND but unless another solver finds a better model, this will remain undetected.

- Information about solvers (command line, supported categories,...)
- Information about selected instances (no solver result)

- CPU Ranking of solvers
- All solvers (tabular format, summary)
- All solvers (tabular format, detailed results)

- BTD
*2018.06.11_3*(complete) (list format) - BTD
*2018.07.27_3*(complete) (list format) - BTD_12
*2018-06-11_12*(complete) (list format) - BTD_12
*2018.07.27_12*(complete) (list format) - Choco-solver
*4.0.7 seq (493a269)*(complete) (list format) - Choco-solver
*4.0.7b seq (e747e1e)*(complete) (list format) - Concrete
*3.9.2*(complete) (list format) - Concrete
*3.9.2-SuperNG*(complete) (list format) - Concrete 3.8
*2018-06-13*(complete) (list format) - Concrete 3.8-SuperNG
*2018-06-13*(complete) (list format) - cosoco
*1.12*(complete) (list format) - macht
*2018.06.11*(complete) (list format) - macht
*2018.07.27*(complete) (list format) - Mistral-2.0
*2018-06-15*(complete) (list format) - Mistral-2.0
*2018-08-01*(complete) (list format) - OscaR - Conflict Ordering
*2018-07-02*(complete) (list format) - OscaR - Conflict Ordering
*2018-08-14*(complete) (list format) - OscaR - Conflict Ordering with restarts
*2018-07-02*(complete) (list format) - OscaR - Conflict Ordering with restarts
*2018-08-14*(complete) (list format) - OscaR - Conflict Ordering with restarts
*2018-08-17*(complete) (list format) - OscaR - Hybrid
*2018-07-02*(complete) (list format) - OscaR - Hybrid
*2018-08-14*(complete) (list format) - PicatSAT
*2018-06-15*(complete) (list format) - PicatSAT
*2018-08-02*(complete) (list format) - PicatSAT
*2018-08-14*(complete) (list format) - Sat4j-CSP
*2018-07-11*(complete) (list format) - scop
*both+MapleCOMSPS (2018-06-13)*(complete) (list format) - scop
*both+MapleCOMSPS (2018-07-31)*(complete) (list format) - scop
*order+MapleCOMSPS (2018-06-13)*(complete) (list format) - scop
*order+MapleCOMSPS (2018-07-31)*(complete) (list format)

- Number of instances solved in a given amount of time
- Number of instances solved within a given amount of memory
- Memory versus time for each solvers
- Evolution of the solution quality for solver BTD
*2018.06.11_3*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver BTD
*2018.07.27_3*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver BTD_12
*2018-06-11_12*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver BTD_12
*2018.07.27_12*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver Choco-solver
*4.0.7 seq (493a269)*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver Choco-solver
*4.0.7b seq (e747e1e)*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver Concrete
*3.9.2*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver Concrete
*3.9.2-SuperNG*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver Concrete 3.8
*2018-06-13*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver Concrete 3.8-SuperNG
*2018-06-13*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver Mistral-2.0
*2018-06-15*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver Mistral-2.0
*2018-08-01*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver OscaR - Conflict Ordering
*2018-07-02*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver OscaR - Conflict Ordering
*2018-08-14*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver OscaR - Conflict Ordering with restarts
*2018-07-02*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver OscaR - Conflict Ordering with restarts
*2018-08-14*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver OscaR - Conflict Ordering with restarts
*2018-08-17*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver OscaR - Hybrid
*2018-07-02*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver OscaR - Hybrid
*2018-08-14*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver PicatSAT
*2018-06-15*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver PicatSAT
*2018-08-02*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver PicatSAT
*2018-08-14*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver Sat4j-CSP
*2018-07-11*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver cosoco
*1.12*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver macht
*2018.06.11*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver macht
*2018.07.27*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver scop
*both+MapleCOMSPS (2018-06-13)*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver scop
*both+MapleCOMSPS (2018-07-31)*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver scop
*order+MapleCOMSPS (2018-06-13)*(complete) - Evolution of the solution quality for solver scop
*order+MapleCOMSPS (2018-07-31)*(complete)

- Graphical comparison of two solvers based on CPU time
- Graphical comparison of two solvers based on memory

- Results for category COP (optimization problem, 346 instances)
- Results for category CSP (decision problem, 236 instances)
- Results for all categories