PB'12 competition: satisfaction and optimization track: results by benchmark

Results by benchmark for category no optimisation, small integers, linear constraints (DEC-SMALLINT-LIN), subcategory Handmade, subsubcategory Traveling Salesperson Problem

This page displays the results of the different solvers for each benchmark for category no optimisation, small integers, linear constraints (DEC-SMALLINT-LIN), subcategory Handmade, subsubcategory Traveling Salesperson Problem

REMINDER

Keep in mind that the 'Best result' columns only provide the best result given by one of the solvers. This 'Best result' may be wrong in case of an UNSATISFIABLE or OPTIMUM FOUND answer (because there's no efficient way to check these answers).

Description of a cell contents:

Cell example	Meaning
Answer	Solver result
f=...	value of the objective function for the model reported by the solver
TT=...	Total Time (TT): this is the CPU time (in seconds) used by the solver until termination. This time is only meaningful for complete solvers because incomplete solvers will always run until they time out

Remember that CPU time and wall clock time are two very different notions. The CPU time represents the time during which the instructions of the solver were executed by the processor. The wall clock time represents how much time ellapsed on the clock. For a same event, the CPU time may be either smaller or greater than the wall clock time depending on the number of threads of execution and the number of processors.

Meaning of some abbreviations:

Abbreviation	Meaning
f=...	Value of the objective function
TO	Time Out
MO	Mem. Out (out of memory)

Meaning of the different colors:

Color	Meaning
text	the solver cannot handle this instance
text	the solver gave no answer
text	the solver could give an answer (SAT)
text	the solver gave a definitive answer (OPTIMUM FOUND or UNSAT)
text	the solver performed better than the other ones on that instance (complete solvers point of view)
text	the solver performed better than the other ones on that instance (incomplete solvers point of view)
text	the solver was ended by a signal or other problem
text	the solver gave an incomplete answer
text	the solver gave a wrong answer

For better readability, you may choose to hide some solvers:
bsolo 3.2 (complete)
clasp 2.0.6-R5325 (dec) (complete)
npSolver 1.0 (complete)
npSolver 1.0 (fixed) (complete)
npSolver inc (complete)
npSolver inc (fixed) (complete)
npSolver inc-topDown (complete)
npSolver inc-topDown (fixed) (complete)
npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (complete)
npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed) (complete)
PB07: bsolo 3.0.17 (complete)
PB07: minisat+ 1.14 (complete)
PB07: PB-clasp 2007-04-10 (complete)
PB07: Pueblo 1.4 (incomplete)
PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution 2007-03-23 (complete)
PB09: bsolo 3.1 (complete)
PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution 2.1.1 (complete)
PB09: SCIPspx SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009) (complete)
PB10: borg-pb 10.05.30 (complete)
PB10: pb_cplex 2010-06-29 (complete)
PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP 2.2.0 2010-05-31 (complete)
PB10: SCIPspx SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver (complete)
PB11: borg pb-dec-11.04.03 (complete)
PB11: Sat4j Res//CP 2.3.0 (complete)
PB11: SCIP spx E_2 2011-06-10 (fixed) (complete)
PB12: minisatp 1.0-2-g022594c (complete)
pb2sat 2012-05-19 (complete)
pb2satCp2 2012-05-19 (complete)
PBPASSolver-CARD.DP 2012-05-28 (complete)
PBPASSolver-CARD.SN 2012-05-28 (complete)
pwbo 2.0 (complete)
pwbo 2.02 (complete)
SAT 4j PB RES // CP 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)
Sat 4j PB Resolution 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)
SAT4J PB specific settings 2.3.2 snapshot (complete)
SCIP spx SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)
SCIP spx E SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)
SCIP spx standard SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed (complete)
toysat 2012-05-17 (complete)
toysat 2012-06-01 (complete)
wbo 1.7 (complete)
wbo 1.72 (complete)

Bench name	Best results on this instance	bsolo 3.2 (complete)	clasp 2.0.6-R5325 (dec) (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc (complete)	npSolver inc (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed) (complete)	PB07: bsolo 3.0.17 (complete)	PB07: minisat+ 1.14 (complete)	PB07: PB-clasp 2007-04-10 (complete)	PB07: Pueblo 1.4 (incomplete)	PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution 2007-03-23 (complete)	PB09: bsolo 3.1 (complete)	PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution 2.1.1 (complete)	PB09: SCIPspx SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009) (complete)	PB10: borg-pb 10.05.30 (complete)	PB10: pb_cplex 2010-06-29 (complete)	PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP 2.2.0 2010-05-31 (complete)	PB10: SCIPspx SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver (complete)	PB11: borg pb-dec-11.04.03 (complete)	PB11: Sat4j Res//CP 2.3.0 (complete)	PB11: SCIP spx E_2 2011-06-10 (fixed) (complete)	PB12: minisatp 1.0-2-g022594c (complete)	pb2sat 2012-05-19 (complete)	pb2satCp2 2012-05-19 (complete)	PBPASSolver-CARD.DP 2012-05-28 (complete)	PBPASSolver-CARD.SN 2012-05-28 (complete)	pwbo 2.0 (complete)	pwbo 2.02 (complete)	SAT 4j PB RES // CP 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	Sat 4j PB Resolution 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	SAT4J PB specific settings 2.3.2 snapshot (complete)	SCIP spx SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx E SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx standard SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed (complete)	toysat 2012-05-17 (complete)	toysat 2012-06-01 (complete)	wbo 1.7 (complete)	wbo 1.72 (complete)
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900544484.opb	UNSAT TT=1.65	UNSAT TT=535.463	UNSAT TT=2.292	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=1.781	? (problem) TT=0.015	UNSAT TT=1.66	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=1.65	? (problem) TT=0.017	UNSAT TT=1.67	UNSAT TT=608.5	UNSAT TT=26.862	UNSAT TT=18.109	UNSAT TT=100.168	UNSAT TT=21.241	UNSAT TT=385.323	UNSAT TT=5.782	UNSAT TT=494.692	UNSAT TT=10.648	UNSAT TT=518.517	UNSAT TT=157.758	UNSAT TT=387.537	UNSAT TT=11.401	UNSAT TT=85.611	UNSAT TT=252.059	UNSAT TT=23.193	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.016	? (TO) TT=1800.06	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=86.76	UNSAT TT=57.783	UNSAT TT=31.068	UNSAT TT=17.98	UNSAT TT=16.253	UNSAT TT=247.054	UNSAT TT=220.299	UNSAT TT=223.446	UNSAT TT=17.443	UNSAT TT=16.982	UNSAT TT=57.09	UNSAT TT=54.77
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900546076.opb	UNSAT TT=0.614	UNSAT TT=384.849	UNSAT TT=0.614	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=6.796	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=6.67	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=6.67	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=6.57	UNSAT TT=652.963	UNSAT TT=3.641	UNSAT TT=4.169	UNSAT TT=45.346	UNSAT TT=1.715	UNSAT TT=378.958	UNSAT TT=2.465	UNSAT TT=239.396	UNSAT TT=5.232	UNSAT TT=403.06	UNSAT TT=12.493	UNSAT TT=171.449	UNSAT TT=3.623	UNSAT TT=39.457	UNSAT TT=54.999	UNSAT TT=2.657	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=6.038	UNSAT TT=1.71	UNSAT TT=8.674	UNSAT TT=4.02	UNSAT TT=4.772	UNSAT TT=161.766	UNSAT TT=155.23	UNSAT TT=72.711	UNSAT TT=21.834	UNSAT TT=21.342	UNSAT TT=1.699	UNSAT TT=1.759
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900547416.opb	SAT TT=0.07 T1=0.07	SAT TT=13.969 T1=13.97	SAT TT=0.07 T1=0.07	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=2.117 T1=2.11	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=2.112 T1=2.11	? (problem) TT=0.016	SAT TT=2.163 T1=2.16	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=2.206 T1=2.2	SAT TT=12.637 T1=12.64	SAT TT=16.576 T1=16.57	SAT TT=1.816 T1=1.8	SAT TT=3.32 T1=3.43	SAT TT=2.854 T1=2.14	SAT TT=5.773 T1=5.77	SAT TT=3.195 T1=2.54	SAT TT=21.921 T1=21.92	SAT TT=1.118 T1=2.3	SAT TT=1.651 T1=0.82	SAT TT=4.702 T1=2.31	SAT TT=16.26 T1=16.26	SAT TT=0.711 T1=0.82	SAT TT=9.642 T1=4.33	SAT TT=17.264 T1=17.26	SAT TT=11.694 T1=11.69	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (TO) TT=1800.12	SAT TT=1628.06 T1=1628.46	SAT TT=0.298 T1=0.29	SAT TT=0.237 T1=0.23	SAT TT=5.565 T1=1.83	SAT TT=7.302 T1=5.92	SAT TT=1.504 T1=0.92	SAT TT=14.721 T1=14.71	SAT TT=14.694 T1=14.69	SAT TT=15.396 T1=15.39	SAT TT=19.531 T1=19.53	SAT TT=19.422 T1=19.43	SAT TT=0.237 T1=0.23	SAT TT=0.238 T1=0.23
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900550006.opb	UNSAT TT=3.654	UNSAT TT=1265.24	UNSAT TT=3.654	? (problem) TT=0.015	UNSAT TT=4.036	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=3.97	? (problem) TT=0.017	UNSAT TT=4.16	? (problem) TT=0.015	UNSAT TT=3.96	UNSAT TT=1191.33	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=77.942	UNSAT TT=445.504	UNSAT TT=276.542	UNSAT TT=1118.67	UNSAT TT=78.76	UNSAT TT=640.163	UNSAT TT=49.128	? (TO) TT=1800.28	? (TO) TT=1801.2	UNSAT TT=1047.13	UNSAT TT=28.705	UNSAT TT=1760.78	UNSAT TT=777.195	? (TO) TT=1800.03	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=699.48	UNSAT TT=327.992	UNSAT TT=178.425	UNSAT TT=61.06	UNSAT TT=116.72	UNSAT TT=559.268	UNSAT TT=683.418	UNSAT TT=578.598	UNSAT TT=53.541	UNSAT TT=52.852	UNSAT TT=311.32	UNSAT TT=306.133
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900551864.opb	UNSAT TT=0.896	UNSAT TT=395.006	UNSAT TT=0.896	? (problem) TT=0.015	UNSAT TT=2.263	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=2.18	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=2.18	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=2.17	UNSAT TT=546.765	UNSAT TT=90.636	UNSAT TT=12.49	UNSAT TT=72.696	UNSAT TT=3.084	UNSAT TT=702.373	UNSAT TT=3.273	UNSAT TT=334.659	UNSAT TT=5.347	UNSAT TT=1034.4	UNSAT TT=33.359	UNSAT TT=374.732	UNSAT TT=4.223	UNSAT TT=20.973	UNSAT TT=152.478	UNSAT TT=47.507	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=29.37	UNSAT TT=24.813	UNSAT TT=13.634	UNSAT TT=7.444	UNSAT TT=11.753	UNSAT TT=210.54	UNSAT TT=168.751	UNSAT TT=182.691	UNSAT TT=14.44	UNSAT TT=14.178	UNSAT TT=23.266	UNSAT TT=23.886
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900552423.opb	UNSAT TT=0.081	UNSAT TT=234.759	UNSAT TT=0.337	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=0.518	? (problem) TT=0.016	UNSAT TT=0.081	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=0.084	? (problem) TT=0.015	UNSAT TT=0.083	UNSAT TT=293.613	UNSAT TT=5.226	UNSAT TT=0.724	UNSAT TT=10.102	UNSAT TT=1.484	UNSAT TT=171.149	UNSAT TT=1.503	UNSAT TT=34.754	UNSAT TT=1.075	UNSAT TT=548.82	UNSAT TT=5.322	UNSAT TT=138.114	UNSAT TT=1.238	UNSAT TT=4.874	UNSAT TT=53.714	UNSAT TT=4.839	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.04	UNSAT TT=2.56	UNSAT TT=2.968	UNSAT TT=7.722	UNSAT TT=3.284	UNSAT TT=1.605	UNSAT TT=92.847	UNSAT TT=89.424	UNSAT TT=38.189	UNSAT TT=1.397	UNSAT TT=1.378	UNSAT TT=2.839	UNSAT TT=2.848
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900552735.opb	UNSAT TT=3.964	UNSAT TT=693.065	UNSAT TT=3.964	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=4.645	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=4.57	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=4.89	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=4.56	UNSAT TT=855.302	UNSAT TT=31.059	UNSAT TT=41.932	UNSAT TT=103.069	UNSAT TT=264.94	UNSAT TT=822.241	UNSAT TT=11.422	UNSAT TT=293.901	UNSAT TT=10.064	UNSAT TT=1168.83	UNSAT TT=839.727	UNSAT TT=373.432	UNSAT TT=20.033	UNSAT TT=805.763	UNSAT TT=177.363	UNSAT TT=25.473	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=66.46	UNSAT TT=66.953	UNSAT TT=51.526	UNSAT TT=21.82	UNSAT TT=36.786	UNSAT TT=226.244	UNSAT TT=208.576	UNSAT TT=236.612	UNSAT TT=14.202	UNSAT TT=14.43	UNSAT TT=62.88	UNSAT TT=63.66
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900553812.opb	UNSAT TT=0.093	UNSAT TT=697.243	UNSAT TT=0.966	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=0.457	? (problem) TT=0.015	UNSAT TT=0.096	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=0.096	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=0.093	UNSAT TT=611.818	UNSAT TT=22.038	UNSAT TT=9.22	UNSAT TT=43.223	UNSAT TT=18.731	UNSAT TT=444.08	UNSAT TT=3.484	UNSAT TT=319.172	UNSAT TT=8.817	UNSAT TT=314.85	UNSAT TT=735.731	UNSAT TT=237.783	UNSAT TT=10.735	UNSAT TT=29.532	UNSAT TT=229.821	UNSAT TT=17.591	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (problem) TT=0.016	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.14	UNSAT TT=56.08	UNSAT TT=63.413	UNSAT TT=20.562	UNSAT TT=10.432	UNSAT TT=8.454	UNSAT TT=130.485	UNSAT TT=127.225	UNSAT TT=157.68	UNSAT TT=7.115	UNSAT TT=7.007	UNSAT TT=63.332	UNSAT TT=61.77
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900554072.opb	UNSAT TT=1.07	UNSAT TT=385.194	UNSAT TT=1.143	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=1.177	? (problem) TT=0.016	UNSAT TT=1.08	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=1.07	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=1.17	UNSAT TT=727.567	UNSAT TT=42.666	UNSAT TT=18.385	UNSAT TT=119.713	UNSAT TT=4.284	UNSAT TT=491.078	UNSAT TT=3.523	UNSAT TT=528.174	UNSAT TT=7.532	UNSAT TT=781.4	UNSAT TT=712.276	UNSAT TT=369.576	UNSAT TT=10.934	UNSAT TT=669.502	UNSAT TT=126.715	UNSAT TT=9.984	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.011	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=142.73	UNSAT TT=123.952	UNSAT TT=81.443	UNSAT TT=20.662	UNSAT TT=33.089	UNSAT TT=185.689	UNSAT TT=197.25	UNSAT TT=196.748	UNSAT TT=10.859	UNSAT TT=10.846	UNSAT TT=124.215	UNSAT TT=129.51
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900554154.opb	SAT TT=0.188 T1=0.19	SAT TT=1.801 T1=1.8	SAT TT=0.188 T1=0.19	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=2.075 T1=2.07	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=2.071 T1=2.07	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=2.07 T1=2.06	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=2.197 T1=2.19	SAT TT=0.263 T1=0.26	SAT TT=0.446 T1=0.44	SAT TT=1.5 T1=1.51	SAT TT=3.704 T1=3.78	SAT TT=3.334 T1=2.59	SAT TT=3.274 T1=3.27	SAT TT=1.036 T1=0.5	SAT TT=7.462 T1=7.45	SAT TT=1.038 T1=1.13	SAT TT=2.144 T1=1.16	SAT TT=3.083 T1=1.31	SAT TT=12.049 T1=12.04	SAT TT=0.79 T1=0.88	SAT TT=7.734 T1=3.37	SAT TT=11.908 T1=11.9	SAT TT=0.285 T1=0.28	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=74.885 T1=75.07	SAT TT=977.946 T1=978.23	SAT TT=0.488 T1=0.49	SAT TT=1.997 T1=1.99	SAT TT=11.172 T1=4.83	SAT TT=12.442 T1=11.05	SAT TT=1.172 T1=0.63	SAT TT=11.091 T1=11.08	SAT TT=11.665 T1=11.66	SAT TT=11.118 T1=11.1	SAT TT=12.985 T1=12.98	SAT TT=12.634 T1=12.64	SAT TT=1.888 T1=1.88	SAT TT=1.888 T1=2.04
Bench name	Best results	bsolo 3.2 (complete)	clasp 2.0.6-R5325 (dec) (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc (complete)	npSolver inc (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed) (complete)	PB07: bsolo 3.0.17 (complete)	PB07: minisat+ 1.14 (complete)	PB07: PB-clasp 2007-04-10 (complete)	PB07: Pueblo 1.4 (incomplete)	PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution 2007-03-23 (complete)	PB09: bsolo 3.1 (complete)	PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution 2.1.1 (complete)	PB09: SCIPspx SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009) (complete)	PB10: borg-pb 10.05.30 (complete)	PB10: pb_cplex 2010-06-29 (complete)	PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP 2.2.0 2010-05-31 (complete)	PB10: SCIPspx SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver (complete)	PB11: borg pb-dec-11.04.03 (complete)	PB11: Sat4j Res//CP 2.3.0 (complete)	PB11: SCIP spx E_2 2011-06-10 (fixed) (complete)	PB12: minisatp 1.0-2-g022594c (complete)	pb2sat 2012-05-19 (complete)	pb2satCp2 2012-05-19 (complete)	PBPASSolver-CARD.DP 2012-05-28 (complete)	PBPASSolver-CARD.SN 2012-05-28 (complete)	pwbo 2.0 (complete)	pwbo 2.02 (complete)	SAT 4j PB RES // CP 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	Sat 4j PB Resolution 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	SAT4J PB specific settings 2.3.2 snapshot (complete)	SCIP spx SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx E SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx standard SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed (complete)	toysat 2012-05-17 (complete)	toysat 2012-06-01 (complete)	wbo 1.7 (complete)	wbo 1.72 (complete)
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900554389.opb	SAT TT=0.041 T1=0.04	SAT TT=1.777 T1=1.77	SAT TT=0.041 T1=0.04	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=3.552 T1=3.55	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=3.536 T1=3.53	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=3.541 T1=3.55	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=3.508 T1=3.5	SAT TT=2.198 T1=2.19	SAT TT=7.264 T1=7.26	SAT TT=0.172 T1=0.15	SAT TT=0.085 T1=0.2	SAT TT=1.314 T1=0.63	SAT TT=0.152 T1=0.15	SAT TT=0.814 T1=0.39	SAT TT=7.861 T1=7.85	SAT TT=0.785 T1=0.93	SAT TT=0.899 T1=0.68	SAT TT=2.463 T1=1.31	SAT TT=12.386 T1=12.38	SAT TT=0.786 T1=0.87	SAT TT=4.323 T1=1.81	SAT TT=17.723 T1=17.72	SAT TT=10.692 T1=5.4	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=55.771 T1=55.85	SAT TT=9.432 T1=9.41	SAT TT=0.057 T1=0.05	SAT TT=0.168 T1=0.28	SAT TT=1.664 T1=0.82	SAT TT=1.426 T1=0.92	SAT TT=0.714 T1=0.36	SAT TT=3.953 T1=3.94	SAT TT=3.674 T1=3.66	SAT TT=5.434 T1=5.42	SAT TT=6.126 T1=6.12	SAT TT=6.158 T1=6.15	SAT TT=0.168 T1=0.15	SAT TT=0.177 T1=0.17
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900556231.opb	UNSAT TT=1.863	UNSAT TT=1012.53	UNSAT TT=1.863	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=25.714	? (problem) TT=0.012	UNSAT TT=25.66	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=25.04	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=25.27	UNSAT TT=1199.69	UNSAT TT=213.946	UNSAT TT=19.016	UNSAT TT=234.666	UNSAT TT=50.01	UNSAT TT=973.835	UNSAT TT=12.241	UNSAT TT=342.129	UNSAT TT=35.761	UNSAT TT=1075.94	UNSAT TT=889.618	UNSAT TT=669.024	UNSAT TT=19.573	UNSAT TT=901.95	UNSAT TT=316.723	UNSAT TT=152.033	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (problem) TT=0.017	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=224.29	UNSAT TT=204.003	UNSAT TT=90.319	UNSAT TT=37.549	UNSAT TT=46.598	UNSAT TT=344.306	UNSAT TT=429.534	UNSAT TT=256.47	UNSAT TT=32.808	UNSAT TT=31.967	UNSAT TT=197.76	UNSAT TT=185.689
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900559365.opb	SAT TT=0.348 T1=0.34	SAT TT=2.61 T1=2.61	SAT TT=0.689 T1=0.68	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=1.221 T1=1.21	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=1.209 T1=1.21	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=1.211 T1=1.21	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=1.209 T1=1.2	SAT TT=18.204 T1=18.21	SAT TT=4.259 T1=4.25	SAT TT=0.734 T1=0.72	SAT TT=8.162 T1=8.16	SAT TT=1.464 T1=0.76	SAT TT=5.874 T1=5.87	SAT TT=1.424 T1=0.83	SAT TT=52.008 T1=52.01	SAT TT=1.197 T1=2.24	SAT TT=21.098 T1=7.56	SAT TT=4.854 T1=2.31	SAT TT=52.021 T1=52.03	SAT TT=0.695 T1=0.78	SAT TT=4.183 T1=1.83	SAT TT=7.25 T1=7.24	SAT TT=3.139 T1=3.14	? (problem) TT=0.018	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=179.137 T1=179.41	SAT TT=169.656 T1=169.9	SAT TT=2.008 T1=2.01	SAT TT=0.35 T1=0.34	SAT TT=31.539 T1=15.41	SAT TT=5.514 T1=4.39	SAT TT=1.225 T1=0.69	SAT TT=15.544 T1=15.54	SAT TT=16.164 T1=16.16	SAT TT=16.043 T1=16.03	SAT TT=1.544 T1=1.54	SAT TT=1.518 T1=1.51	SAT TT=0.348 T1=0.34	SAT TT=0.348 T1=0.34
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900561288.opb	UNSAT TT=57.031	? TT=1798	UNSAT TT=60.643	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=87.186	? (problem) TT=0.011	UNSAT TT=85.95	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=84.65	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=84.94	UNSAT TT=1793.15	? (TO) TT=1800.03	UNSAT TT=131.663	UNSAT TT=394.962	UNSAT TT=1451.86	UNSAT TT=932.074	UNSAT TT=175.35	UNSAT TT=668.539	UNSAT TT=207.743	UNSAT TT=1156.44	? (TO) TT=1801.06	UNSAT TT=913.964	UNSAT TT=57.031	? (TO) TT=1800.01	UNSAT TT=774.925	? (TO) TT=1800.11	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.13	UNSAT TT=714.51	UNSAT TT=821.878	UNSAT TT=297.23	UNSAT TT=115.43	UNSAT TT=251.276	UNSAT TT=657.12	UNSAT TT=634.688	UNSAT TT=557.576	UNSAT TT=106.299	UNSAT TT=106.23	UNSAT TT=815.093	UNSAT TT=929.81
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900561389.opb	SAT TT=0.188 T1=0.18	SAT TT=0.188 T1=0.18	SAT TT=0.224 T1=0.22	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=10.705 T1=10.71	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=10.697 T1=10.69	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=10.599 T1=10.6	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=10.563 T1=10.57	SAT TT=7.998 T1=8	SAT TT=11.477 T1=11.48	SAT TT=2.287 T1=2.27	SAT TT=1.853 T1=1.94	SAT TT=2.384 T1=1.63	SAT TT=12.954 T1=12.95	SAT TT=5.683 T1=5	SAT TT=3.087 T1=3.08	SAT TT=0.678 T1=0.82	SAT TT=87.909 T1=32.13	SAT TT=4.013 T1=2.31	SAT TT=27.631 T1=27.64	SAT TT=0.912 T1=1	SAT TT=4.538 T1=1.82	SAT TT=20.175 T1=20.17	SAT TT=8.504 T1=8.5	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=475.384 T1=475.38	SAT TT=1161.1 T1=1161.24	SAT TT=0.587 T1=0.58	SAT TT=0.308 T1=0.31	SAT TT=6.643 T1=2.38	SAT TT=10.133 T1=8.63	SAT TT=1.595 T1=1.01	SAT TT=3.518 T1=3.5	SAT TT=3.422 T1=3.41	SAT TT=12.013 T1=12.01	SAT TT=6.103 T1=6.1	SAT TT=6.064 T1=6.06	SAT TT=0.307 T1=0.3	SAT TT=0.309 T1=0.3
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900565527.opb	SAT TT=0.008 T1=0.01	SAT TT=1.33 T1=1.33	SAT TT=0.596 T1=0.59	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=0.976 T1=0.97	? (problem) TT=0.017	SAT TT=0.975 T1=0.97	? (problem) TT=0.012	SAT TT=0.964 T1=0.96	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=0.965 T1=0.96	SAT TT=5.915 T1=5.91	SAT TT=0.89 T1=0.89	SAT TT=0.906 T1=0.88	SAT TT=2.061 T1=2.06	SAT TT=1.455 T1=0.72	SAT TT=10.679 T1=10.68	SAT TT=1.454 T1=0.84	SAT TT=17.06 T1=17.05	SAT TT=0.944 T1=1.05	SAT TT=122.69 T1=43.94	SAT TT=10.431 T1=5.3	SAT TT=33.535 T1=33.54	SAT TT=0.715 T1=0.79	SAT TT=6.333 T1=2.83	SAT TT=19.68 T1=9.89	SAT TT=0.615 T1=0.61	? (problem) TT=0.011	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=91.337 T1=91.42	SAT TT=512.858 T1=512.94	SAT TT=0.939 T1=0.93	SAT TT=0.008 T1=0.01	SAT TT=11.072 T1=4.81	SAT TT=5.072 T1=3.65	SAT TT=1.434 T1=0.85	SAT TT=10.119 T1=10.11	SAT TT=10.091 T1=10.08	SAT TT=12.442 T1=12.43	SAT TT=49.943 T1=49.95	SAT TT=48.573 T1=48.59	SAT TT=0.008 T1=0.01	SAT TT=0.008 T1=0.01
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900565534.opb	UNSAT TT=1.621	UNSAT TT=1077.3	UNSAT TT=1.621	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=1.967	? (problem) TT=0.016	UNSAT TT=1.87	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=1.94	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=2.08	UNSAT TT=1055.6	UNSAT TT=144.139	UNSAT TT=36.522	UNSAT TT=189.435	UNSAT TT=13.242	UNSAT TT=1054.65	UNSAT TT=6.324	UNSAT TT=624.774	UNSAT TT=32.012	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=1359.57	UNSAT TT=522.137	UNSAT TT=21.636	UNSAT TT=1342.39	UNSAT TT=336.141	UNSAT TT=69.427	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (TO) TT=1800.02	? (TO) TT=1800.08	UNSAT TT=309.18	UNSAT TT=290.377	UNSAT TT=21.96	UNSAT TT=67.246	UNSAT TT=131.064	UNSAT TT=224.51	UNSAT TT=285.201	UNSAT TT=410.632	UNSAT TT=18.219	UNSAT TT=18.274	UNSAT TT=289.799	UNSAT TT=286.18
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900566263.opb	SAT TT=0.02 T1=0.02	SAT TT=1.057 T1=1.05	SAT TT=0.02 T1=0.02	? (problem) TT=0.017	SAT TT=0.312 T1=0.31	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=0.308 T1=0.3	? (problem) TT=0.012	SAT TT=0.303 T1=0.57	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=0.304 T1=0.43	SAT TT=0.274 T1=0.27	SAT TT=0.402 T1=0.4	SAT TT=0.217 T1=0.2	SAT TT=4.157 T1=4.25	SAT TT=1.214 T1=0.55	SAT TT=3.937 T1=3.93	SAT TT=1.134 T1=0.61	SAT TT=3.253 T1=3.24	SAT TT=0.956 T1=2.02	SAT TT=1.447 T1=0.81	SAT TT=2.304 T1=1.32	SAT TT=3.054 T1=3.04	SAT TT=0.522 T1=0.61	SAT TT=1.396 T1=0.85	SAT TT=5.275 T1=5.26	SAT TT=0.263 T1=0.26	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=49.345 T1=49.54	SAT TT=8.333 T1=8.31	SAT TT=0.117 T1=0.11	SAT TT=0.108 T1=0.09	SAT TT=13.024 T1=5.86	SAT TT=4.743 T1=3.22	SAT TT=0.884 T1=0.44	SAT TT=3.413 T1=3.4	SAT TT=3.611 T1=3.6	SAT TT=12.616 T1=12.61	SAT TT=13.598 T1=13.6	SAT TT=13.673 T1=13.68	SAT TT=0.108 T1=0.09	SAT TT=0.119 T1=0.11
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900568186.opb	UNSAT TT=0.09	UNSAT TT=361.413	UNSAT TT=1.122	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=0.469	? (problem) TT=0.017	UNSAT TT=0.096	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=0.091	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=0.09	UNSAT TT=629.52	UNSAT TT=205.525	UNSAT TT=10.455	UNSAT TT=72.979	UNSAT TT=2.533	UNSAT TT=478.462	UNSAT TT=2.174	UNSAT TT=189.984	UNSAT TT=8.163	UNSAT TT=554.6	UNSAT TT=52.044	UNSAT TT=216.946	UNSAT TT=7.695	UNSAT TT=32.829	UNSAT TT=140.477	UNSAT TT=127.915	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.015	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.02	UNSAT TT=26.174	UNSAT TT=52.68	UNSAT TT=18.931	UNSAT TT=10.162	UNSAT TT=16.981	UNSAT TT=123.893	UNSAT TT=122.507	UNSAT TT=127.083	UNSAT TT=20.201	UNSAT TT=20.07	UNSAT TT=49.854	UNSAT TT=50.29
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900574974.opb	SAT TT=0.019 T1=0.01	SAT TT=5.479 T1=5.48	SAT TT=0.019 T1=0.01	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=1.328 T1=1.36	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=1.32 T1=1.31	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=1.334 T1=1.33	? (problem) TT=0.012	SAT TT=1.378 T1=1.37	SAT TT=0.163 T1=0.16	SAT TT=1.978 T1=1.97	SAT TT=0.383 T1=0.37	SAT TT=1.173 T1=1.17	SAT TT=1.844 T1=1.1	SAT TT=3.54 T1=3.53	SAT TT=0.753 T1=0.39	SAT TT=3.742 T1=3.73	SAT TT=0.695 T1=0.81	SAT TT=1.681 T1=0.94	SAT TT=3.863 T1=1.3	SAT TT=14.125 T1=14.12	SAT TT=0.537 T1=0.64	SAT TT=4.104 T1=1.83	SAT TT=3.747 T1=3.74	SAT TT=1.431 T1=1.43	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (problem) TT=0.016	SAT TT=10.452 T1=10.51	SAT TT=65.004 T1=65.17	SAT TT=0.228 T1=0.22	SAT TT=0.229 T1=0.22	SAT TT=5.723 T1=2.31	SAT TT=4.343 T1=3.06	SAT TT=0.923 T1=0.45	SAT TT=3.266 T1=3.25	SAT TT=3.263 T1=3.25	SAT TT=7.104 T1=7.09	SAT TT=5.338 T1=5.33	SAT TT=5.206 T1=5.21	SAT TT=0.208 T1=0.2	SAT TT=0.211 T1=0.21
Bench name	Best results	bsolo 3.2 (complete)	clasp 2.0.6-R5325 (dec) (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc (complete)	npSolver inc (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed) (complete)	PB07: bsolo 3.0.17 (complete)	PB07: minisat+ 1.14 (complete)	PB07: PB-clasp 2007-04-10 (complete)	PB07: Pueblo 1.4 (incomplete)	PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution 2007-03-23 (complete)	PB09: bsolo 3.1 (complete)	PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution 2.1.1 (complete)	PB09: SCIPspx SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009) (complete)	PB10: borg-pb 10.05.30 (complete)	PB10: pb_cplex 2010-06-29 (complete)	PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP 2.2.0 2010-05-31 (complete)	PB10: SCIPspx SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver (complete)	PB11: borg pb-dec-11.04.03 (complete)	PB11: Sat4j Res//CP 2.3.0 (complete)	PB11: SCIP spx E_2 2011-06-10 (fixed) (complete)	PB12: minisatp 1.0-2-g022594c (complete)	pb2sat 2012-05-19 (complete)	pb2satCp2 2012-05-19 (complete)	PBPASSolver-CARD.DP 2012-05-28 (complete)	PBPASSolver-CARD.SN 2012-05-28 (complete)	pwbo 2.0 (complete)	pwbo 2.02 (complete)	SAT 4j PB RES // CP 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	Sat 4j PB Resolution 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	SAT4J PB specific settings 2.3.2 snapshot (complete)	SCIP spx SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx E SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx standard SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed (complete)	toysat 2012-05-17 (complete)	toysat 2012-06-01 (complete)	wbo 1.7 (complete)	wbo 1.72 (complete)
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900576918.opb	SAT TT=0.048 T1=0.04	SAT TT=0.738 T1=0.73	SAT TT=0.116 T1=0.11	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=2.369 T1=2.37	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=2.36 T1=2.36	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=2.377 T1=2.39	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=2.529 T1=2.52	SAT TT=9.906 T1=9.91	SAT TT=3.07 T1=3.07	SAT TT=0.134 T1=0.11	SAT TT=0.398 T1=0.4	SAT TT=1.264 T1=0.59	SAT TT=0.689 T1=0.68	SAT TT=1.074 T1=0.53	SAT TT=7.339 T1=7.33	SAT TT=0.724 T1=0.84	SAT TT=0.74 T1=0.53	SAT TT=5.253 T1=2.34	SAT TT=12.149 T1=12.15	SAT TT=0.63 T1=0.73	SAT TT=1.775 T1=0.83	SAT TT=5.386 T1=5.37	SAT TT=2.113 T1=2.11	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=40.178 T1=40.2	SAT TT=60.121 T1=60.18	SAT TT=0.058 T1=0.05	SAT TT=0.057 T1=0.05	SAT TT=5.925 T1=2.32	SAT TT=4.624 T1=3.41	SAT TT=1.203 T1=0.67	SAT TT=1.958 T1=1.95	SAT TT=1.971 T1=1.95	SAT TT=17.54 T1=17.53	SAT TT=7.303 T1=7.31	SAT TT=7.27 T1=7.27	SAT TT=0.048 T1=0.04	SAT TT=0.048 T1=0.04
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900576927.opb	UNSAT TT=2.88	UNSAT TT=1342.3	UNSAT TT=2.88	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=43.743	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=43.06	? (problem) TT=0.012	UNSAT TT=43.36	? (problem) TT=0.012	UNSAT TT=43.75	UNSAT TT=1244.24	UNSAT TT=396.689	UNSAT TT=71.195	UNSAT TT=214.481	UNSAT TT=140.362	UNSAT TT=1626.63	UNSAT TT=79.36	UNSAT TT=359.572	UNSAT TT=49.301	UNSAT TT=1332.9	? (TO) TT=1800.11	UNSAT TT=1232.05	UNSAT TT=41.597	UNSAT TT=1752.88	UNSAT TT=629.968	UNSAT TT=367.553	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (TO) TT=1800.05	? (TO) TT=1800.1	UNSAT TT=261.22	UNSAT TT=318.105	UNSAT TT=174.99	UNSAT TT=65.223	UNSAT TT=121.816	UNSAT TT=862.969	UNSAT TT=728.662	UNSAT TT=554.527	UNSAT TT=79.649	UNSAT TT=78.292	UNSAT TT=312.661	UNSAT TT=321.17
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900577000.opb	SAT TT=0.007 T1=0.01	SAT TT=0.533 T1=0.53	SAT TT=0.063 T1=0.06	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=0.217 T1=0.21	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=0.211 T1=0.21	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=0.21 T1=0.58	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=0.208 T1=0.21	SAT TT=0.602 T1=0.61	SAT TT=6.307 T1=6.3	SAT TT=0.287 T1=0.27	SAT TT=0.355 T1=0.35	SAT TT=1.143 T1=0.51	SAT TT=4.523 T1=4.52	SAT TT=1.255 T1=0.69	SAT TT=12.354 T1=12.35	SAT TT=0.776 T1=0.89	SAT TT=2.031 T1=1	SAT TT=6.943 T1=3.32	SAT TT=8.71 T1=8.7	SAT TT=0.529 T1=0.59	SAT TT=1.633 T1=0.83	SAT TT=7.844 T1=7.83	SAT TT=4.661 T1=4.66	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=32.511 T1=32.46	SAT TT=242.207 T1=242.2	SAT TT=0.007 T1=0.01	SAT TT=0.348 T1=0.34	SAT TT=9.365 T1=3.82	SAT TT=4.154 T1=2.85	SAT TT=1.283 T1=0.71	SAT TT=9.97 T1=9.96	SAT TT=9.965 T1=9.95	SAT TT=12.031 T1=12.02	SAT TT=44.019 T1=44.03	SAT TT=44.018 T1=44.03	SAT TT=0.348 T1=0.34	SAT TT=0.348 T1=0.34
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900582300.opb	UNSAT TT=2.232	UNSAT TT=1017.05	UNSAT TT=2.232	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=10.383	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=10.16	? (problem) TT=0.015	UNSAT TT=10.26	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=10.26	UNSAT TT=1708.15	UNSAT TT=453.634	UNSAT TT=55.35	UNSAT TT=279.352	UNSAT TT=33.11	UNSAT TT=762.292	UNSAT TT=14.643	UNSAT TT=542.268	UNSAT TT=41.684	UNSAT TT=1547.95	UNSAT TT=1295.33	UNSAT TT=668.325	UNSAT TT=22.233	UNSAT TT=1261.18	UNSAT TT=435.355	UNSAT TT=547.158	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (problem) TT=0.016	? (TO) TT=1800.08	? (TO) TT=1800.12	UNSAT TT=426.55	UNSAT TT=241.74	UNSAT TT=96.499	UNSAT TT=50.936	UNSAT TT=94.63	UNSAT TT=498.86	UNSAT TT=437.577	UNSAT TT=356.222	UNSAT TT=56.577	UNSAT TT=56.987	UNSAT TT=226.556	UNSAT TT=231.9
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900582376.opb	SAT TT=0.048 T1=0.03	SAT TT=19.187 T1=19.19	SAT TT=0.378 T1=0.37	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=0.209 T1=0.21	? (problem) TT=0.012	SAT TT=0.209 T1=0.2	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=0.205 T1=0.2	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=0.203 T1=0.2	SAT TT=26.27 T1=26.27	SAT TT=6.973 T1=6.97	SAT TT=0.191 T1=0.18	SAT TT=2.798 T1=2.8	SAT TT=2.104 T1=1.33	SAT TT=11.662 T1=11.66	SAT TT=2.074 T1=1.41	SAT TT=34.801 T1=34.8	SAT TT=1.119 T1=2.08	SAT TT=142 T1=50.64	SAT TT=16.392 T1=8.3	SAT TT=21.358 T1=21.36	SAT TT=1 T1=1.08	SAT TT=8.742 T1=3.82	SAT TT=3.233 T1=3.22	SAT TT=5.142 T1=5.14	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (problem) TT=0.016	SAT TT=1635.62 T1=1636.09	SAT TT=11.231 T1=11.22	SAT TT=1.357 T1=1.36	SAT TT=0.05 T1=0.04	SAT TT=4.872 T1=1.85	SAT TT=1.483 T1=0.82	SAT TT=3.783 T1=3.17	SAT TT=10.351 T1=10.34	SAT TT=10.21 T1=10.2	SAT TT=10.16 T1=10.15	SAT TT=7.348 T1=7.35	SAT TT=7.334 T1=7.33	SAT TT=0.048 T1=0.03	SAT TT=0.048 T1=0.04
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900584106.opb	UNSAT TT=0.626	UNSAT TT=619.731	UNSAT TT=0.626	? (problem) TT=0.016	UNSAT TT=1.624	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=1.56	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=1.53	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=1.55	UNSAT TT=503.671	UNSAT TT=54.358	UNSAT TT=3.42	UNSAT TT=55.282	UNSAT TT=7.603	UNSAT TT=382.327	UNSAT TT=2.665	UNSAT TT=112.38	UNSAT TT=6.757	UNSAT TT=498.819	UNSAT TT=71.934	UNSAT TT=212.637	UNSAT TT=2.714	UNSAT TT=293.248	UNSAT TT=74.101	UNSAT TT=33.292	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (TO) TT=1800.09	? (TO) TT=1800.01	UNSAT TT=25.89	UNSAT TT=106.676	UNSAT TT=24.11	UNSAT TT=18.569	UNSAT TT=12.662	UNSAT TT=72.601	UNSAT TT=72.735	UNSAT TT=93.388	UNSAT TT=5.769	UNSAT TT=5.81	UNSAT TT=104.054	UNSAT TT=102.107
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900669299.opb	SAT TT=0.054 T1=0.05	SAT TT=9.367 T1=9.36	SAT TT=0.059 T1=0.05	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=0.973 T1=0.97	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=0.963 T1=0.96	? (problem) TT=0.013	SAT TT=0.97 T1=0.97	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=0.972 T1=0.97	SAT TT=3.124 T1=3.12	SAT TT=0.112 T1=0.11	SAT TT=0.225 T1=0.21	SAT TT=5.563 T1=5.56	SAT TT=1.203 T1=0.57	SAT TT=2.568 T1=2.56	SAT TT=1.235 T1=0.65	SAT TT=10.132 T1=10.12	SAT TT=0.766 T1=0.84	SAT TT=1.931 T1=0.86	SAT TT=6.553 T1=3.31	SAT TT=27.515 T1=27.52	SAT TT=0.524 T1=0.62	SAT TT=1.204 T1=0.83	SAT TT=3.958 T1=3.94	SAT TT=0.054 T1=0.05	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (problem) TT=0.012	SAT TT=1060.51 T1=531.6	SAT TT=34.012 T1=34.37	SAT TT=0.409 T1=0.4	SAT TT=0.58 T1=0.57	SAT TT=1.183 T1=0.83	SAT TT=3.761 T1=2.58	SAT TT=0.683 T1=0.35	SAT TT=10.691 T1=5.39	SAT TT=5.388 T1=5.37	SAT TT=12.487 T1=12.48	SAT TT=0.088 T1=0.08	SAT TT=0.086 T1=0.08	SAT TT=0.578 T1=0.57	SAT TT=0.579 T1=0.57
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900669309.opb	SAT TT=0.27 T1=0.26	SAT TT=105.81 T1=105.82	SAT TT=0.556 T1=0.55	? (problem) TT=0.012	SAT TT=5.234 T1=5.24	? (problem) TT=0.015	SAT TT=5.24 T1=5.24	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=5.531 T1=5.55	? (problem) TT=0.014	SAT TT=5.529 T1=5.52	SAT TT=61.535 T1=61.54	SAT TT=19.652 T1=19.65	SAT TT=6.674 T1=6.66	SAT TT=26.061 T1=26.06	SAT TT=1.653 T1=0.92	SAT TT=36.847 T1=36.85	SAT TT=2.075 T1=1.41	SAT TT=68.662 T1=68.67	SAT TT=0.809 T1=0.9	SAT TT=364.645 T1=109.04	SAT TT=15.433 T1=7.33	SAT TT=14.192 T1=14.18	SAT TT=3.885 T1=3.94	SAT TT=4.27 T1=1.85	SAT TT=38.492 T1=38.49	SAT TT=14.212 T1=14.21	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (TO) TT=1800.06	SAT TT=136 T1=136	SAT TT=0.27 T1=0.26	SAT TT=0.448 T1=0.44	SAT TT=25.068 T1=11.82	SAT TT=2.283 T1=1.46	SAT TT=3.263 T1=2.65	SAT TT=14.497 T1=14.49	SAT TT=14.421 T1=14.41	SAT TT=24.603 T1=24.59	SAT TT=42.719 T1=42.73	SAT TT=42.566 T1=42.57	SAT TT=0.448 T1=0.44	SAT TT=0.478 T1=0.48
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900670167.opb	UNSAT TT=1.428	UNSAT TT=979.046	UNSAT TT=1.428	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=7.896	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=7.87	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=7.75	? (problem) TT=0.013	UNSAT TT=7.77	UNSAT TT=684.6	UNSAT TT=16.717	UNSAT TT=16.027	UNSAT TT=146.246	UNSAT TT=5.663	UNSAT TT=1493.9	UNSAT TT=5.781	UNSAT TT=342.928	UNSAT TT=21.387	UNSAT TT=1146.14	UNSAT TT=636.508	UNSAT TT=393.52	UNSAT TT=13.126	UNSAT TT=500.66	UNSAT TT=225.449	UNSAT TT=12.606	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (problem) TT=0.014	? (TO) TT=1800.12	? (TO) TT=1800.09	UNSAT TT=75.76	UNSAT TT=89.599	UNSAT TT=26.7	UNSAT TT=16.791	UNSAT TT=19.361	UNSAT TT=189.071	UNSAT TT=205.328	UNSAT TT=128.022	UNSAT TT=18.012	UNSAT TT=18.439	UNSAT TT=94.256	UNSAT TT=88.167
normalized-PB06/SATUNSAT-SMALLINT/ submitted-PB06/namasivayam/tsp/ normalized-t3002.11tsp11.1900670675.opb	UNSAT TT=0.709	UNSAT TT=381.464	UNSAT TT=0.709	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=1.242	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=1.17	? (problem) TT=0.015	UNSAT TT=1.15	? (problem) TT=0.014	UNSAT TT=1.27	UNSAT TT=850.953	UNSAT TT=26.881	UNSAT TT=4.68	UNSAT TT=117.077	UNSAT TT=2.973	UNSAT TT=361.356	UNSAT TT=2.364	UNSAT TT=173.163	UNSAT TT=6.132	UNSAT TT=707.53	UNSAT TT=68.894	UNSAT TT=251.092	UNSAT TT=3.669	UNSAT TT=28.631	UNSAT TT=164.545	UNSAT TT=25.052	? (problem) TT=0.013	? (problem) TT=0.012	? (TO) TT=1800.07	? (TO) TT=1800.05	UNSAT TT=30.086	UNSAT TT=44.561	UNSAT TT=9.463	UNSAT TT=3.273	UNSAT TT=11.313	UNSAT TT=134.294	UNSAT TT=128.576	UNSAT TT=212.538	UNSAT TT=5.494	UNSAT TT=5.438	UNSAT TT=42.194	UNSAT TT=40.482

Statistics		bsolo 3.2 (complete)	clasp 2.0.6-R5325 (dec) (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (complete)	npSolver 1.0 (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc (complete)	npSolver inc (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (complete)	npSolver inc-topDown (fixed) (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (complete)	npSolver inc-topdown-quickBound (fixed) (complete)	PB07: bsolo 3.0.17 (complete)	PB07: minisat+ 1.14 (complete)	PB07: PB-clasp 2007-04-10 (complete)	PB07: Pueblo 1.4 (incomplete)	PB07: SAT4JPseudoResolution 2007-03-23 (complete)	PB09: bsolo 3.1 (complete)	PB09: SAT4J Pseudo Resolution 2.1.1 (complete)	PB09: SCIPspx SCIP 1.1.0.7 with SoPLEX 1.4.1(24.4.2009) (complete)	PB10: borg-pb 10.05.30 (complete)	PB10: pb_cplex 2010-06-29 (complete)	PB10: SAT4J PB RES // CP 2.2.0 2010-05-31 (complete)	PB10: SCIPspx SCIP 1.2.1.3 with SoPlex 1.4.2 (CVS Version 30.5.2010) as LP solver (complete)	PB11: borg pb-dec-11.04.03 (complete)	PB11: Sat4j Res//CP 2.3.0 (complete)	PB11: SCIP spx E_2 2011-06-10 (fixed) (complete)	PB12: minisatp 1.0-2-g022594c (complete)	pb2sat 2012-05-19 (complete)	pb2satCp2 2012-05-19 (complete)	PBPASSolver-CARD.DP 2012-05-28 (complete)	PBPASSolver-CARD.SN 2012-05-28 (complete)	pwbo 2.0 (complete)	pwbo 2.02 (complete)	SAT 4j PB RES // CP 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	Sat 4j PB Resolution 2.3.2 Snapshot (complete)	SAT4J PB specific settings 2.3.2 snapshot (complete)	SCIP spx SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx E SCIP 2.1.1.4. Exp with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 fixed (complete)	SCIP spx standard SCIP 2.1.1.4. with SoPlex 1.6.0.3 standard fixed (complete)	toysat 2012-05-17 (complete)	toysat 2012-06-01 (complete)	wbo 1.7 (complete)	wbo 1.72 (complete)
Number of times the solver is able to give the best known answer		29	30	0	30	0	30	0	30	0	30	30	28	30	30	30	0	30	30	30	28	27	30	30	29	30	28	0	0	11	13	30	30	30	30	30	30	30	30	0	30	30	30
Number of times the solver is the best solver from a complete solver point of view (i.e. best known answer and best TT time)		1	16	0	0	0	1	0	2	0	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	1	0	0	1	0	0	0	0	2	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	4	4