MAX-CSP 2008 Competition: results by benchmark

Results by benchmark for category binary constraints in extension (2-ARY-EXT)

This page displays the results of the different solvers for each benchmark for category binary constraints in extension (2-ARY-EXT)

REMINDER

Keep in mind that the 'Best result' columns only provide the best result given by one of the solvers. This 'Best result' may be wrong in case of an UNSATISFIABLE or OPTIMUM FOUND answer (because there's no efficient way to check these answers).

Description of a cell contents:

Cell exampleMeaning
AnswerSolver result
f=...value of the objective function for the model reported by the solver
TT=...Total Time (TT): this is the CPU time (in seconds) used by the solver until termination. This time is only meaningful for complete solvers because incomplete solvers will always run until they time out
T1=...Time to get the best model (T1): this is the wall clock time (in seconds) ellapsed when the solver found its best model. This time is obtained from the 'o lines'. It is useful to compare both complete and incomplete solvers. It doesn't take into account the time to prove optimality of the solution.
Remember that CPU time and wall clock time are two very different notions. The CPU time represents the time during which the instructions of the solver were executed by the processor. The wall clock time represents how much time ellapsed on the clock. For a same event, the CPU time may be either smaller or greater than the wall clock time depending on the number of threads of execution and the number of processors.

Meaning of some abbreviations:

AbbreviationMeaning
f=...Value of the objective function
TOTime Out
MOMem. Out (out of memory)

Meaning of the different colors:

ColorMeaning
textthe solver cannot handle this instance
textthe solver gave no answer
textthe solver could give an answer (SAT)
textthe solver gave a definitive answer (OPTIMUM FOUND or UNSAT)
textthe solver performed better than the other ones on that instance
textthe solver was ended by a signal
textthe solver gave an incomplete answer
textthe solver was disqualified in the category
textthe solver gave a wrong answer

For better readability, you may choose to hide some solvers:
AbsconMax 112 pc-d
AbsconMax 112 pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30
Sugar v1.13+minisat
Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc
toulbar2 2008-06-27
toulbar2/BTD 2008-06-27

M6?idev=16&idbench=60757">csp/QCP-10/? (MO)

TT=25.145

f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (T25745">MSA<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MOPT11r> f=2
8r> f=2<)<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
i72cp-1d> <50722o0.09

119.6dd">MOPT<119.16ev=16&idbench=60757">csp/QCP-10/OPTIMUM494ench.phpv=16&idjob=1108460">? (MO)

TT=25.145

MOPT<6.TO)
f=3TO)
f=2
TT=3br>TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=0.85
MOPT1=16
TT=1ben3)
f=2
TT=3br>TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1642.59
T1=0.8>i72cp-1d> <50722o0.09

f600.29
T1=0.87
TT=1600.29
T1=0.87
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=15.27
T1=14.88
MSAT1600.29
T1=0.87
f600.29
T1=0.87
OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
? (MO)

TT=21.97

MSAT1ven">MOPTf=3T129TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<13job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT<5idev=16>TT=.9dbench
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">T1=12.25
<05ss="even" width=31idjob=11615T13 (TOPTT1=0.75
722job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT94.4 (MO>TT=.94="bench.php?idev=16&idbench=60759">csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml <21job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT<337>MSAT (T2S9?idev=16&idbench=60723">csp/marc/ MSAT1ven">MOPT<2.8
T">M6?089
MSAT1ven">MOPT98TT=3600br>TT7=9f=2
TT=3600.04

f=2f=2
TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT<8Sbr>TT=PT<2o3T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

<18

049job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT9TT=9 (TOPT<3766 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">T1=12.25
034ss="even" width=31idjob=11601iTO)
f=1757">MSA )
f=2
TT=3600.04

041ss="even" width=31idjob=11607<8ev=1">M1.94="benc)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MObr>TT5>MSAT (T&780T169TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT1ven">MOP621ob6=159>f=1.7414340">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61/a>
MSAT1ven">MOPT97T02MSAT (T1TT1r>TT=0">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61/a>
66516="even" width=31idjob=11607<85MSAT (T1TT68 (TO)<2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
297job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MO3561.21f=2
TT=8 (TO)934.04
M12.29OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61/a>
14818job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MO3P=1TT=3600br>TT78 (TO)goo918

14826job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT7375T (TOPT<2.589 14793job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT66S92f=2
TT75.983 1478616b=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT<4T1r>TT=PT<4.69OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61goo918

14802ss="even" width=31idjob=11571.6br>f=2
TT=3600.04

<>
14809job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT92163f=2f=)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
14753job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT<3.32br>T=163T169f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">T1=12.25
14722job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT95?2
T=1621T5996
T1=20.64
14745job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT98T341108php16T44 (TO)<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">T1=12.25
1466616b=1108754">MSAT1ven">MO2695S15=2 14673job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOP618
TT=f="32.679T1=12.25
14705ss="even" width=31idjob=11569.27f=2
2.269 normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml 14737ss="even" width=31&idjob=1108721f=2
27T44 (TO) normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml 15098job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOP581.4
T=16&.069 15102ef="trace.php?ih=300 ><27djob7">MSphp2624.391108)
f=2T1=15.77
15105job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT97T96=159>f=1o4? (MOAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T1=20.64
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml 15065job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT57.47br>T=16&.04659.9Ta.9TIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.6118

normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml 15073job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOP761T96=159>f=2T1r>TT=0">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61idth=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT1ven">MObr>TT11 (TO>TT=0">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61idth=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT=1659.96
T1=20.64
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml 15081job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT95S62br>T=16&.86659.9TT1=20.64
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml 14225ss="even" width=31idjob=11604.br>TT=PT<10T6UM
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml 14233job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT99o7
T=1610.6896
T1=20.64
14442ss="even" width=31idjob=11575o91f=2T1=12.25
14498job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOP578.48=159>f=1o769T1=12.25
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml 14473job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT84o351108php16T12 (TO) 14478ef="trace.php?ih=300 ><888T341108php771.8296
T1=20.64
14490ss="even" width=31idjob=11588n71f=2
8 (TO)csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml 14489job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT86o5>MSAT (T8(TO)
T1=12.25
14426job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOP567T2r>TT==16&.179csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml 14425job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT97T15=2
14417job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT84o73br>T=16&514
Tr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
14422ef="trace.php?ih=300 ><2607461br>T=16&48.86 (TO)> 14433job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT74T52f=2
2.5
Tr>r>T1=12.25
14p?ideb=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT82.1
T=1610.989 14401job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOPT79.8T (T (T49.38M
2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
14p96ef="trace.php?ih=300 ><1907n16=159>f=548.99f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">T1=20.64
14378job=1108754">MSAT1ven">MOP573.47br>T=167.179 <>
TT=3600.04

15252ef="trace.php?ih=300 ><975o746=159>f=246.1196
h.php?ide5
<>
TT=3600.04

25345ss="even" width=310&idjob=PS1P.62MSAT (T3.66>TT=0"T1=20.64
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.13+minisat-inc
toulbar2
2008-06-27
toulbar2/BTD
2008-06-27
csp/BH-4-13/
normalized-BlackHole-4-13-e-0_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=2
TT=3600.03

MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1619.71
T1=2.99
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1573.87
T1=3.25
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.03

MSAT (TO)
f=6
TT=3600.06

MSAT (MO)
f=120
TT=134.53
T1=123.41
? (MO)

TT=58.318

? (TO)

TT=3600.01

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

csp/BH-4-13/
normalized-BlackHole-4-13-e-1_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1626.71
T1=32.58
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1610.54
T1=36.15
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=6
TT=3600.05

MSAT (MO)
f=209
TT=150.82
T1=138.82
? (MO)

TT=60.898

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

csp/BH-4-13/
normalized-BlackHole-4-13-e-2_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=3
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=10
TT=1594.42
T1=17.31
MSAT (TO)
f=10
TT=1626.61
T1=17.21
MSAT (TO)
f=3
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=5
TT=3600.05

MSAT (MO)
f=122
TT=138.96
T1=126.91
? (MO)

TT=59.935

? (TO)

TT=3600.03

? (TO)

TT=3600.05

csp/BH-4-13/
normalized-BlackHole-4-13-e-3_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=7
TT=1620.34
T1=34.15
MSAT (TO)
f=7
TT=1600.47
T1=30.74
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=6
TT=3600.04

MSAT (MO)
f=308
TT=137.304
T1=126.09
? (MO)

TT=60.104

? (TO)

TT=3600.1

? (TO)

TT=3600.07

csp/BH-4-13/
normalized-BlackHole-4-13-m-0_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=2
TT=3600.1

MSAT (TO)
f=8
TT=1619.33
T1=4.73
MSAT (TO)
f=8
TT=1595.75
T1=4.74
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.1

MSAT (TO)
f=4
TT=3600.08

MSAT (MO)
f=128
TT=159.68
T1=146.89
? (MO)

TT=57.817

? (TO)

TT=3600.02

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

csp/BH-4-13/
normalized-BlackHole-4-13-m-1_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=5
TT=1626.62
T1=39.79
MSAT (TO)
f=5
TT=1594.55
T1=36.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=4
TT=3600.08

MSAT (MO)
f=130
TT=134.02
T1=122.64
? (MO)

TT=63.018

? (TO)

TT=3600.08

? (TO)

TT=3600.02

csp/BH-4-13/
normalized-BlackHole-4-13-m-2_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=2
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=7
TT=1600.96
T1=7.24
MSAT (TO)
f=7
TT=1589.81
T1=8.03
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=5
TT=3600.04

MSAT (MO)
f=126
TT=137.34
T1=125.96
? (MO)

TT=64.927

? (TO)

TT=3600.1

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

csp/BH-4-4/
normalized-BlackHole-4-4-e-0_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1.617
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1581.05
T1=0.76
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1582.65
T1=0.97
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.06

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=6.199
T1=5.61
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=359.681
T1=359.38
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1.617
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=6.398
T1=6.33
csp/BH-4-4/
normalized-BlackHole-4-4-e-1_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1.492
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1571.12
T1=1.37
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1586.45
T1=1.38
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=41.085
T1=40.48
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=234.917
T1=234.74
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1.492
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=6.365
T1=6.32
csp/BH-4-4/
normalized-BlackHole-4-4-e-2_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1.601
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1685.08
T1=0.68
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1585.39
T1=0.64
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.01

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=430.832
T1=430.32
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1120.16
T1=1119.91
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1.601
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=6.962
T1=6.87
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.13+minisat-inc
toulbar2
2008-06-27
toulbar2/BTD
2008-06-27
csp/BH-4-4/
normalized-BlackHole-4-4-e-3_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1.591
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1563.14
T1=0.96
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1321.58
T1=1.15
CHECKS=103874000
NODES=35651
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=29.123
T1=28.6
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=107.458
T1=105.86
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1.591
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=6.36
T1=6.24
csp/BH-4-4/
normalized-BlackHole-4-4-e-4_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1.64
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=2153.75
T1=1.27
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1589.29
T1=1.26
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.04

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=260.555
T1=260.03
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=131.038
T1=127.16
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1.64
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=6.458
T1=6.42
csp/BH-4-4/
normalized-BlackHole-4-4-e-5_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1.495
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1580.23
T1=1.05
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1217.09
T1=1.07
CHECKS=143927000
NODES=93724
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.03

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.01

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=76.941
T1=76.46
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=2.926
T1=2.55
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1.495
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=5.921
T1=5.8
csp/BH-4-4/
normalized-BlackHole-4-4-e-6_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1.6
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1595.31
T1=1.68
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1588.82
T1=1.84
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.06

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=90.787
T1=90.24
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=160.742
T1=158.19
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1.6
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=6.373
T1=6.34
csp/BH-4-4/
normalized-BlackHole-4-4-e-7_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1.614
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1578.34
T1=0.66
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1055.33
T1=0.67
CHECKS=102669000
NODES=50575
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=83.487
T1=83.14
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=923.397
T1=923.02
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1.614
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=6.428
T1=6.33
csp/BH-4-4/
normalized-BlackHole-4-4-e-8_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1.513
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1591.56
T1=0.68
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1515.29
T1=0.64
CHECKS=88138700
NODES=48044
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.07

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=36.222
T1=35.71
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=3.341
T1=2.93
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1.513
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=5.973
T1=5.87
csp/BH-4-4/
normalized-BlackHole-4-4-e-9_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1.623
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=2558.13
T1=0.82
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1578.05
T1=0.74
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.1

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.07

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=72.313
T1=71.81
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=896.799
T1=896.28
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1.623
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=6.342
T1=6.31
csp/BH-4-7/
normalized-BlackHole-4-7-e-0_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=1
TT=1599.14
T1=9.82
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1606.37
T1=22.79
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1599.14
T1=24.63
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.02

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600
T1=35.67
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.16
T1=9.82
? (TO)

TT=3600.06

? (TO)

TT=3600.09

csp/BH-4-7/
normalized-BlackHole-4-7-e-4_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=3054.09
T1=12.32
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1596.33
T1=18.86
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1588.52
T1=18.22
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.08
T1=83.88
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=3054.09
T1=12.32
? (TO)

TT=3600.03

? (TO)

TT=3600.13

csp/BH-4-7/
normalized-BlackHole-4-7-e-7_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=980.632
T1=2.28
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1593.12
T1=2.37
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1583.97
T1=2.28
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.01

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=980.632
T1=39.89
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.21
T1=11.11
? (TO)

TT=3600.05

? (TO)

TT=3600.05

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.13+minisat-inc
toulbar2
2008-06-27
toulbar2/BTD
2008-06-27
csp/BH-4-7/
normalized-BlackHole-4-7-e-8_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=1
TT=1601.91
T1=7.37
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1601.91
T1=7.39
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1602.79
T1=7.37
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.03

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.06
T1=34.09
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.14
T1=9.27
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.09

csp/BH-4-7/
normalized-BlackHole-4-7-e-9_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=1
TT=1585.31
T1=7.36
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1596.8
T1=7.36
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1585.31
T1=7.61
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.06

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.1

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.02
T1=32.1
MSAT (TO)
f=3
TT=3600.22
T1=11.75
? (TO)

TT=3600.08

? (TO)

TT=3600.08

csp/BH-4-7/
normalized-BlackHole-4-7-h-1_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=1
TT=1599.14
T1=5.61
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1599.14
T1=5.61
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1601.42
T1=6
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.01

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.01

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05
T1=31.56
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.21
T1=10.68
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

csp/BH-4-7/
normalized-BlackHole-4-7-h-3_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=927.684
T1=10.3
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1603.7
T1=17.91
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1988.28
T1=16.57
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.07

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.01

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=927.684
T1=51.69
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.24
T1=10.3
? (TO)

TT=3600.03

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

csp/BH-4-7/
normalized-BlackHole-4-7-h-5_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=1438.56
T1=7.22
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1592.11
T1=7.31
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1607.47
T1=7.22
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.03

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1438.56
T1=263.95
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.21
T1=11.51
? (TO)

TT=3600.06

? (TO)

TT=3600.07

csp/BH-4-7/
normalized-BlackHole-4-7-h-8_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=1
TT=1616.98
T1=9.57
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1616.98
T1=9.57
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1923.43
T1=10.11
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.1

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.02
T1=32.22
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.19
T1=11.07
? (TO)

TT=3600.1

? (TO)

TT=3600.07

csp/BH-4-7/
normalized-BlackHole-4-7-h-9_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=1
TT=1590.63
T1=9.56
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1611.19
T1=26.07
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1590.63
T1=28.24
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.03

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.09
T1=57.38
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.15
T1=9.56
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.11

csp/coloring/
normalized-dsjc-125-1-4-ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=19
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=20
TT=1587.46
T1=1.68
MSAT (TO)
f=20
TT=1591.59
T1=1.86
MSAT (TO)
f=19
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=20
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=58
TT=3600
T1=44.83
MSAT (TO)
f=79
TT=3600.16
T1=3.94
? (TO)

TT=3600.09

? (TO)
f=65
TT=3600.05
T1=2336.42
csp/coloring/
normalized-geom-30a-4-ext.xml
MOPT
f=4
TT=0.323
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=4
TT=1626.04
T1=0.47
OPTIMUM
f=4
TT=164.607
T1=0.48
CHECKS=8843890
NODES=66412
MSAT (TO)
f=4
TT=3600.01

MSAT (TO)
f=4
TT=3600.04

OPTIMUM
f=4
TT=1.562
T1=1.04
OPTIMUM
f=4
TT=1.4
T1=1.05
OPTIMUM
f=4
TT=0.323
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=4
TT=0.101
T1=0.01
csp/coloring/
normalized-geom-40-2-ext.xml
MOPT
f=22
TT=0.03
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=22
TT=1637.14
T1=0.48
OPTIMUM
f=22
TT=1387.6
T1=0.57
CHECKS=102778000
NODES=1073070
MSAT (TO)
f=22
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=22
TT=3600

OPTIMUM
f=22
TT=396.059
T1=40.14
OPTIMUM
f=22
TT=780.585
T1=231.93
OPTIMUM
f=22
TT=0.03
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=22
TT=0.031
T1=0
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.13+minisat-inc
toulbar2
2008-06-27
toulbar2/BTD
2008-06-27
csp/coloring/
normalized-geom-40-3-ext.xml
MOPT
f=7
TT=0.141
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=7
TT=1622.75
T1=0.57
OPTIMUM
f=7
TT=1462.57
T1=0.66
CHECKS=98633000
NODES=896136
MSAT (TO)
f=7
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=7
TT=3600.04

OPTIMUM
f=7
TT=1.861
T1=1.12
OPTIMUM
f=7
TT=1.777
T1=0.98
OPTIMUM
f=7
TT=0.141
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=7
TT=0.049
T1=0
csp/coloring/
normalized-geom-40-4-ext.xml
MOPT
f=3
TT=0.216
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=3
TT=1643.7
T1=0.45
OPTIMUM
f=3
TT=78.315
T1=0.47
CHECKS=3448160
NODES=38800
MSAT (TO)
f=3
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=3
TT=3600.06

OPTIMUM
f=3
TT=1.585
T1=1.43
OPTIMUM
f=3
TT=1.32
T1=1.14
OPTIMUM
f=3
TT=0.216
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=3
TT=0.055
T1=0
csp/coloring/
normalized-le-450-5a-3-ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=900
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=952
TT=1671.41
T1=42.18
MSAT (TO)
f=952
TT=1680.67
T1=44.65
MSAT (TO)
f=902
TT=3600.07

MSAT (TO)
f=900
TT=3600.09

? (MO)

TT=98.11

? (MO)

TT=94.794

? (TO)

TT=3600.05

? (TO)
f=2638
TT=3600.12
T1=2936.68
csp/coloring/
normalized-le-450-5a-4-ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=392
TT=3600.03

MSAT (TO)
f=444
TT=1643.36
T1=27.56
MSAT (TO)
f=444
TT=1660.65
T1=26.68
MSAT (TO)
f=392
TT=3600.03

MSAT (TO)
f=394
TT=3600.08

? (MO)

TT=89.986

? (MO)

TT=98.836

? (TO)

TT=3600.09

? (TO)
f=2270
TT=3600.05
T1=3053.43
csp/coloring/
normalized-myciel-5g-4-ext.xml
MOPT
f=4
TT=16.654
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=4
TT=1617.37
T1=0.52
MSAT (TO)
f=4
TT=1591.87
T1=0.58
MSAT (TO)
f=4
TT=3600

MSAT (TO)
f=4
TT=3600.02

OPTIMUM
f=4
TT=278.105
T1=277.9
OPTIMUM
f=4
TT=1582.37
T1=1582.18
OPTIMUM
f=4
TT=16.654
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=4
TT=18.012
T1=0.02
csp/coloring/
normalized-myciel-5g-5-ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=59.362
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1625.63
T1=0.57
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=1599.61
T1=0.47
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.05

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=59.362
T1=2.36
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=302.625
T1=2.03
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=102.087
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=94.761
T1=0.04
csp/coloring/
normalized-queens-5-5-4-ext.xml
MOPT
f=12
TT=47.571
T1=0.09
MSAT (TO)
f=12
TT=1593.6
T1=0.46
MSAT (TO)
f=12
TT=1597.37
T1=0.58
MSAT (TO)
f=12
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=12
TT=3600.02

MSAT (TO)
f=19
TT=3600.13
T1=1.35
MSAT (TO)
f=19
TT=3600.08
T1=1.8
OPTIMUM
f=12
TT=47.571
T1=0.09
OPTIMUM
f=12
TT=59.298
T1=2.24
csp/composed-25-1-25/
normalized-composed-25-1-25-3_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.104
T1=0.07
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1598.97
T1=0.58
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1583.98
T1=0.77
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3.059
T1=2.96
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.565
T1=2.35
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.104
T1=0.07
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.666
T1=0.16
csp/composed-25-1-25/
normalized-composed-25-1-25-6_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.135
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1578.39
T1=1.04
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=113.73
T1=1.05
CHECKS=4946260
NODES=5051
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.01

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.833
T1=2.62
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.618
T1=2.43
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.135
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.596
T1=0.16
csp/composed-25-1-25/
normalized-composed-25-1-25-8_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.226
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1592.23
T1=1.09
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=465.236
T1=1.27
CHECKS=26031300
NODES=25456
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.02

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.976
T1=2.67
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.589
T1=2.4
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.226
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.392
T1=0.16
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.13+minisat-inc
toulbar2
2008-06-27
toulbar2/BTD
2008-06-27
csp/composed-25-1-2/
normalized-composed-25-1-2-6_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.06
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1592.21
T1=0.78
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1575.46
T1=0.67
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.07

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.71
T1=2.53
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.434
T1=2.22
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.06
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.186
T1=0
csp/composed-25-1-2/
normalized-composed-25-1-2-7_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.505
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1594.43
T1=0.67
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1585.65
T1=0.58
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.01

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.03

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3.142
T1=2.96
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.396
T1=2.22
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.505
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.202
T1=0.12
csp/composed-25-1-2/
normalized-composed-25-1-2-8_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.095
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1602.83
T1=0.77
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=2595.91
T1=0.68
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.767
T1=2.68
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.35
T1=2.17
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.095
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.181
T1=0
csp/composed-25-1-40/
normalized-composed-25-1-40-0_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=0.038
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=31.171
T1=0.78
CHECKS=5775
NODES=8
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=31.366
T1=0.61
CHECKS=24178
NODES=34
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=3.446
T1=3.18
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=2.685
T1=2.52
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=0.038
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=0.238
T1=0.17
csp/composed-25-1-40/
normalized-composed-25-1-40-4_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.131
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1576.96
T1=0.57
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=352.249
T1=0.58
CHECKS=21894200
NODES=21315
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.07

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3.333
T1=3.07
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.996
T1=2.76
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.131
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.802
T1=0.16
csp/composed-25-1-40/
normalized-composed-25-1-40-5_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.259
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1578.24
T1=0.67
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=210.925
T1=0.78
CHECKS=10154300
NODES=8042
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3.062
T1=2.8
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.483
T1=2.29
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.259
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.463
T1=0.15
csp/composed-25-1-80/
normalized-composed-25-1-80-2_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.144
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1717.95
T1=0.63
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=380.714
T1=0.75
CHECKS=21144400
NODES=18160
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.07

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3.413
T1=3.12
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.702
T1=2.54
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.144
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.503
T1=0.19
csp/composed-25-1-80/
normalized-composed-25-1-80-8_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.112
T1=0.01
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1574.42
T1=1.57
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=75.785
T1=1.78
CHECKS=2451750
NODES=2112
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.03

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3.843
T1=3.53
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.82
T1=2.61
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.112
T1=0.01
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.371
T1=0.18
csp/composed-25-1-80/
normalized-composed-25-1-80-9_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.252
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1585.98
T1=0.67
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=81.365
T1=0.66
CHECKS=2717830
NODES=1860
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.01

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3.42
T1=3.12
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.876
T1=2.76
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.252
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.511
T1=0.18
csp/composed-75-1-25/
normalized-composed-75-1-25-4_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=1.129
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1593.82
T1=0.88
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=78.849
T1=0.87
CHECKS=3018500
NODES=1415
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.02

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=7.657
T1=6.75
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=4.12
T1=3.87
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=1.129
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=6.258
T1=5.02
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.13+minisat-inc
toulbar2
2008-06-27
toulbar2/BTD
2008-06-27
csp/composed-75-1-25/
normalized-composed-75-1-25-6_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=2.038
T1=0.76
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1578.78
T1=0.76
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1564.06
T1=0.94
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.06

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=8.402
T1=7.44
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=4.758
T1=4.49
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.038
T1=1.48
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=4.879
T1=4.12
csp/composed-75-1-25/
normalized-composed-75-1-25-9_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.273
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1598.17
T1=0.87
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1595.33
T1=0.79
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.07

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=8.208
T1=7.37
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=4.126
T1=3.88
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.273
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2.004
T1=1.76
csp/composed-75-1-2/
normalized-composed-75-1-2-0_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=5.138
T1=1.16
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1591.78
T1=1.21
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1579.58
T1=1.16
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.1

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=9.324
T1=8.53
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=5.138
T1=4.86
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=9.019
T1=8.71
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=237.031
T1=236.93
csp/composed-75-1-2/
normalized-composed-75-1-2-2_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.405
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1596.88
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=260.565
T1=0.78
CHECKS=18354200
NODES=12203
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.03

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.03

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=8.816
T1=7.97
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=4.442
T1=4.19
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.405
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.872
T1=0.4
csp/composed-75-1-2/
normalized-composed-75-1-2-7_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=0.33
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=31.194
T1=0.79
CHECKS=4657
NODES=11
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=32.886
T1=0.88
CHECKS=85460
NODES=65
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.07

OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=9.618
T1=8.99
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=4.727
T1=4.47
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=0.33
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=0.56
T1=0.4
csp/composed-75-1-40/
normalized-composed-75-1-40-2_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.34
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1588.08
T1=0.76
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=123.857
T1=0.87
CHECKS=6019520
NODES=3204
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.02

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=9.846
T1=9.11
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=4.878
T1=4.48
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.34
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.989
T1=0.4
csp/composed-75-1-40/
normalized-composed-75-1-40-5_ext.xml
MOPT
f=3
TT=5.686
T1=0.76
MSAT (TO)
f=3
TT=1582.73
T1=0.78
OPTIMUM
f=3
TT=207.638
T1=0.76
CHECKS=10732800
NODES=4274
MSAT (TO)
f=3
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=3
TT=3600.08

OPTIMUM
f=3
TT=10.511
T1=10.29
OPTIMUM
f=3
TT=5.686
T1=5.44
OPTIMUM
f=3
TT=17.591
T1=14.96
OPTIMUM
f=3
TT=9.828
T1=8.7
csp/composed-75-1-40/
normalized-composed-75-1-40-9_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.47
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1578.71
T1=1.08
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1569.48
T1=0.98
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=9.721
T1=8.99
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=5.383
T1=5.21
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.47
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=1.705
T1=1.45
csp/composed-75-1-80/
normalized-composed-75-1-80-1_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.177
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=2360.6
T1=0.76
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=642.28
T1=0.98
CHECKS=39392600
NODES=17921
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.1

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.08

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=10.381
T1=9.47
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=5.24
T1=4.91
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.177
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.845
T1=0.42
csp/composed-75-1-80/
normalized-composed-75-1-80-8_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.115
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1597.23
T1=0.78
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=153.634
T1=0.78
CHECKS=7357580
NODES=3133
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.02

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.03

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=11.615
T1=10.64
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=5.705
T1=5.28
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.115
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.776
T1=0.45
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.13+minisat-inc
toulbar2
2008-06-27
toulbar2/BTD
2008-06-27
csp/composed-75-1-80/
normalized-composed-75-1-80-9_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=0.295
T1=0
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=2209.35
T1=0.77
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=2006.77
T1=0.78
CHECKS=216281000
NODES=120318
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.08

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=10.995
T1=10.09
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=6.054
T1=5.76
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=0.295
T1=0
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=1.14
T1=0.94
csp/ehi-85/
normalized-ehi-85-297-27_ext.xml
MOPT
f=9
TT=1044.36
T1=1043.7
MSAT (TO)
f=18
TT=1608.63
T1=10.87
MSAT (TO)
f=18
TT=1608.9
T1=10.04
MSAT (TO)
f=34
TT=3600.02

MSAT (TO)
f=204
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1044.36
T1=1043.7
? (MO)

TT=53.381

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

? (TO)
f=712
TT=3600.06
T1=2022.32
csp/ehi-85/
normalized-ehi-85-297-30_ext.xml
MOPT
f=9
TT=1087.57
T1=18.49
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1695.9
T1=18.66
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1637.86
T1=18.49
MSAT (TO)
f=45
TT=3600

MSAT (TO)
f=180
TT=3600.08

OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1087.57
T1=772.04
No Cert.

TT=72.781

? (TO)

TT=3600.05

? (TO)
f=343
TT=3600.12
T1=3262.12
csp/ehi-85/
normalized-ehi-85-297-55_ext.xml
MOPT
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=23.89
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1665.28
T1=23.89
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1637.41
T1=24.72
MSAT (TO)
f=36
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=159
TT=3600.08

OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
? (MO)

TT=53.489

? (TO)

TT=3600.02

? (TO)
f=633
TT=3600.07
T1=3576.75
csp/ehi-85/
normalized-ehi-85-297-78_ext.xml
MOPT
f=9
TT=895.122
T1=657.19
MSAT (TO)
f=27
TT=1616.49
T1=17.99
MSAT (TO)
f=10
TT=1651.96
T1=45.05
MSAT (TO)
f=18
TT=3600.1

MSAT (TO)
f=137
TT=3600.04

OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=895.122
T1=657.19
? (MO)

TT=63.447

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

? (TO)
f=677
TT=3600.03
T1=2656.32
csp/ehi-85/
normalized-ehi-85-297-96_ext.xml
MOPT
f=9
TT=869.078
T1=621.42
MSAT (TO)
f=25
TT=1613.38
T1=29.57
MSAT (TO)
f=25
TT=1633.39
T1=29.98
MSAT (TO)
f=43
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=139
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=869.078
T1=621.42
? (MO)

TT=55.767

? (TO)

TT=3600.03

? (TO)
f=460
TT=3600.05
T1=3253.85
csp/ehi-90/
normalized-ehi-90-315-51_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=9
TT=1639.43
T1=36.29
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1672.14
T1=40.39
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1639.43
T1=36.29
MSAT (TO)
f=27
TT=3600.06

MSAT (TO)
f=197
TT=3600.09

? (MO)

TT=61.335

? (MO)

TT=61.372

? (TO)

TT=3600.05

? (TO)
f=556
TT=3600.06
T1=2563.95
csp/ehi-90/
normalized-ehi-90-315-54_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=16
TT=1636.21
T1=36.75
MSAT (TO)
f=16
TT=1636.21
T1=36.75
MSAT (TO)
f=18
TT=1633.55
T1=7.96
MSAT (TO)
f=41
TT=3600

MSAT (TO)
f=177
TT=3600.06

? (MO)

TT=62.21

? (MO)

TT=58.368

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

? (TO)
f=819
TT=3600.1
T1=2753.09
csp/ehi-90/
normalized-ehi-90-315-65_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=18
TT=1617.4
T1=7.38
MSAT (TO)
f=18
TT=1735.22
T1=7.38
MSAT (TO)
f=18
TT=1617.4
T1=7.98
MSAT (TO)
f=34
TT=3600.06

MSAT (TO)
f=192
TT=3600.04

? (MO)

TT=62.852

? (MO)

TT=56.279

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

? (TO)
f=669
TT=3600.06
T1=2863.37
csp/ehi-90/
normalized-ehi-90-315-71_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=9
TT=1632.26
T1=22.11
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1669.36
T1=24.08
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1632.26
T1=22.11
MSAT (TO)
f=27
TT=3600.01

MSAT (TO)
f=146
TT=3600.06

? (MO)

TT=61.65

? (MO)

TT=55.981

? (TO)

TT=3600.05

? (TO)
f=655
TT=3600.12
T1=3429.94
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.13+minisat-inc
toulbar2
2008-06-27
toulbar2/BTD
2008-06-27
csp/ehi-90/
normalized-ehi-90-315-95_ext.xml
MOPT
f=9
TT=1111.24
T1=42.61
OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1111.24
T1=42.61
CHECKS=51962600
NODES=16325
MSAT (TO)
f=9
TT=1653.9
T1=43.19
MSAT (TO)
f=27
TT=3600.06

MSAT (TO)
f=177
TT=3600.02

? (MO)

TT=63.35

? (MO)

TT=57.685

? (TO)

TT=3600.09

? (TO)
f=512
TT=3600.05
T1=3312.23
csp/geom/
normalized-geo50-20-d4-75-94_ext.xml
MOPT
f=1
TT=2133.04
T1=1526.96
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1571.64
T1=2.07
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1595.71
T1=1.89
MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.06

MSAT (TO)
f=1
TT=3600.02

MSAT (TO)
f=3
TT=3600.05
T1=1483.28
MSAT (TO)
f=27
TT=3600.13
T1=3.85
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=2133.04
T1=1526.96
OPTIMUM
f=1
TT=1248.53
T1=688.42
csp/langford/
normalized-langford-3-11-ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=1928.92
T1=4.28
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1775.51
T1=14.62
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=14.54
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.01

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=1928.92
T1=7.13
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.19
T1=4.28
? (TO)

TT=3600.06

? (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.1
T1=18.28
csp/langford/
normalized-slangford-3-11-ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=3044.97
T1=4.28
MSAT (TO)
f=3
TT=1601.2
T1=2.43
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=2879.59
T1=2879.49
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.02

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3044.97
T1=7.59
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.2
T1=4.28
? (TO)

TT=3600.09

? (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.11
T1=14.52
csp/marc/
normalized-large-80-unsat_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=780
TT=1610.07
T1=1610.02
MSAT (TO)
f=781
TT=1638.57
T1=10.39
MSAT (TO)
f=780
TT=1610.07
T1=1610.02
MSAT (TO)
f=780
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=780
TT=3600.01

? (MO)

TT=19.918

? (MO)

TT=20.285

? (TO)

TT=3600.03

? (TO)
f=1564
TT=3600.08
T1=1870.83
csp/marc/
normalized-large-84-unsat_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=862
TT=1595.61
T1=11.61
MSAT (TO)
f=862
TT=1595.61
T1=12.25
MSAT (TO)
f=862
TT=1633.07
T1=11.61
MSAT (TO)
f=862
TT=3600

MSAT (TO)
f=862
TT=3600.04

? (MO)

TT=21.97

? (MO)

TT=22.38

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

? (TO)
f=1702
TT=3600.02
T1=651.76
csp/marc/
normalized-large-88-unsat_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=946
TT=1603.52
T1=13.58
MSAT (TO)
f=946
TT=1603.52
T1=13.58
MSAT (TO)
f=946
TT=1618.44
T1=14.79
MSAT (TO)
f=946
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=946
TT=3600.05

? (MO)

TT=25.145

? (MO)

TT=24.162

? (TO)

TT=3600.08

? (TO)
f=1903
TT=3600.07
T1=327.62
csp/marc/
normalized-large-92-unsat_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=1036
TT=1626.96
T1=15.8
MSAT (TO)
f=1036
TT=1629.07
T1=15.8
MSAT (TO)
f=1036
TT=1626.96
T1=17.35
MSAT (TO)
f=1036
TT=3600.1

MSAT (TO)
f=1036
TT=3600.06

? (MO)

TT=28.73

? (MO)

TT=27.99

? (TO)

TT=3600.1

? (TO)
f=2088
TT=3600.07
T1=285.04
csp/marc/
normalized-large-96-unsat_ext.xml
MSAT TO
f=1128
TT=1619.07
T1=20.1
MSAT (TO)
f=1128
TT=1659.96
T1=20.64
MSAT (TO)
f=1128
TT=1619.07
T1=20.1
MSAT (TO)
f=1128
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=1128
TT=3600.02

? (MO)

TT=30.89

? (MO)

TT=32.86

? (TO)

TT=3600.09

? (TO)
f=2259
TT=3600.08
T1=877.92
csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-10_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=5.983
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1584.69
T1=1.04
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.02

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.09

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=15.27
T1=14.88
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.13+minisat-inc
toulbar2
2008-06-27
toulbar2/BTD
2008-06-27
csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1600.29
T1=0.87
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.08

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=16.031
T1=15.77
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02
? (TO)

TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-12_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=0.75
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1629.96
T1=0.75
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=0.84
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.03

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=14.846
T1=14.44
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
? (TO)

TT=3600.1

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-13_ext.xml
MOPT
f=2
TT=6.243
T1=0.88
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1642.59
T1=0.88
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
i72cp-1d> <50722o0.09

OPTIMUM
f5M
f=2
TT=14.846
T1=14.44
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=14.8>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02
? (T4br>
TT=3600.07

MOP>? (MO)? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MOPT5616
TT=11">? (MO)

TTTT=1642.59
T1=0.88
MOPT<="even">MOPTT=5.983
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=0.84
MSbr>TT=3600.08


MSAT (T2? (MO)? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=0.84
MOPT<212.5AT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.02

MSAT (T656&idbench=61706">csp/ehi-90/
normaldth=100 class="goodresult">
? (MO)

TT=25.145

f=2
TT=14.8>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOPT1r> f=2<)? (TO)

TT=3600.04

TT=360T1r> f=2<)<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">MOPT>MS9?idev=16&id45">MSA<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
i72cp-1d> <50722o0.09

f=2
TT=3600.02

MSA >MOP71.9dbench=61706">csp/ehi-90/
normaldth=100 class="goodresult">
f=2
TT=14.88460">? (MO)

TT=25.145

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=16.03r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

MOPT<8 f=9? (TO)

TT=3600.04

csp/marc/
normalized-large-80-unsat_ext.xml
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

MSAT (TAT (9? (TO)

TT=3600.04

csp/marc/
normalized-large-80-unsat_ext.xml
MSAT (T64ob=11086&idbench=60757">csp/QCP-10/OPTIMUM
f5M
f=2
TT=14.846
T1=14.44

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

TT=1f=9
T16&idbench=60721">csp/marc/
normalized-large-80-unsat_ext.xml
MSA76.5dev=16&id76.TO)csp/ehi-90/
normaldth=100 class="goodresult">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=14.8>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

f=2
TT=1600.2T=1601.2
T1=2.43
f=942>TT=3600.046TT=3044.97
T1=4.28
T10.07.8
T16&idbench=60721">csp/marc/
normalized-large-80-unsat_ext.xml
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1600.29
T1=0.87
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1600.29
T1=0.87
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.1116&idjob=12?idev=16&idjob=110875<0008600.03

f=2
TT=1600.2T=1601.2
T1=2.43
? (M>f=377
T1=20.1
MSAT (TA4.1T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1600.29
T1=0.87
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=16.03r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

f=2TT=1600.2T=1601.2
T1=2.43
MOPTf=2
TT=3600.04

MOPT19.7idev=16&id8T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

MSAT78737">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
OPTIMUM
f5M
f=2
TT=14.846
T1=14.44

f=2TT=1600.2T=1601.2
T1=2.43
MSAT (T&9 fidev=16&idbench=60721">csp/marc/
normalized-large-80-unsat_ext.xml
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=862
TT=3600.04

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=14.8>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

f=2TT=1600.2T=1601.2
T1=2.43
MSA<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=780
TT=3600.09

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=16.031
T1=15.77
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=65.93

MSAT (TO) MSA<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">csp/marc/
normalized-large-96-unsat_ext.xml
MSAT1408449">MSAT (TO)
f=780
TT=1610.07
T1=1610.02
MSAT (TO)
f=1128
TT=3600.02

TT=1600.29
T1=0.87
f=2
TT=16.03r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

f=2TT=1600.2T=1601.2
T1=2.43
MSAT h=300 >MOPT<49> f=2
TT=1928.92
T1=4.28
MSAT h=300 >csp/marc/
normalized-large-96-unsat_ext.xml
TT=1659.96
T1=20.64
MSAT1408449">MSAT (SAT (TO)
f=862
TT=1633.07
T1=11.61
f=1128
TT=1619.07
T1=20.1
MSAT (TO)
f=1036
TT=3600.06

OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=16.031
T1=15.77
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=16.03r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
f=2 T1=3.85
f=2
TT=3600.05

T1=12.25
MSAT1408449">MSAT16&idjob=1108432">MSAT (TO)
f=1036
TT=3600.06

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98? (MO)>MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
? (MO)

TT=25.145

f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
csp/langford/
normalized-langford-3-11-ext.xmlMOPT<49>8 (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

TT753">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT1408449">MSAT (SAT (TO)
f=862
TT=1633.07
T1=11.61
<39ass?ce.php?idev=14.8108737">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3044.97
T1=7.59
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=65.93

MTT=1600.2T=1601.2
T1=2.43
MSAT18ven">MOPT34ob=1108PT<42 >csp/marc/ MSAT18ven">MOPT66MSAT=16&idbench=60723">csp/marc/
normalized-large-96-unsat_ext.xml
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
? (MO)

TT=19.918

f=2
TT=14.8>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT97T129
f=3T169TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT=1659.96
T1=20.64
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT4ven">MObr>TT=1659.0.088016
Tr>T1=20.64
f=2
TT=3600.05

f=579.7414340">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
MOPT<647 3">? (MO)

TT=22.38T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1.1416&idjrand-2-23idev=16&idjob=11rand-23-23-2530031-47021br>
TT=3600.07

? (MO>TT=.9dbenchf=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT1ven">MOPT95S8T (TO>f=3T24="bench.php?idev=16&idbench=60759">csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (T&.96
TTTT=1642.59
T1=0.88
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT13 (TOPT<972.6T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

? (MO>TT896"714340">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

TT1d45">MSA<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT1">MOPT<1129.57
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MO110875idev=15.8<78br> T5613414340">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
T1=20.1
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

? (TO)
f=2088
TT=3600.07
T1=285.04
T1=12.25
T1=12.25
f=3540r> f=2<)<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=193o1UM
TT838o814340">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
2f=2
724T24="bench.php?ide>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

M6?089? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT75.16ev=1">M6?2
Tr>T1=20.64
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT53">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MOPT<1701i6
Tr>T1=20.64
MOPT<1038o3T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

M323o3T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

<
T1=934.04
T1=20.1
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MOPT<5i> f=2
TT7=9? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT<5i> f=2
TT=br>Tr>T1=20.64
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT=1659.96
T1=20.64
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=121996
T1=20.64
MO11087129
f=e07766 (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

<="bestresultcomplete">
? (MO)

TT=19.918

MObr>TT1">MOPT<2266S9?idev=16&idbench>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOPT92
TT=PT<10.45)? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT95Sbr>TT=PT<11.5=9T1=20.64
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT53">MS (T2SAT (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

f=934T=6.314
T1=0.85
MSphp3109">? (MO)

TTr>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT98TTO)
f=2T (9f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT53">MS (T1258381AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT7ref="be&idjo1>MSAT (T954br>
<335837>MSAT (T672 2ch.php?idev=16&idbench=60707">csp/laTT=19.918

MObr>TT1r>TT=PT<1279T=5.983
T1=0.85>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOPT<6.T3 (TOPT<3766 (TO)MSAT1ven">MOPT<6.T3 (TOPT<3712="bench.php?idev=16&idbench=60759">csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSphp505.6T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

<>
? (MO)

TT=19.918

TT=PT<1904 3">? (MO)

TT=22.38T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MOPT96.1T (TOPT<11108437">? (TO)
f=2088
TT=3600.07
T1=285.04
MSAT1ven">MOPT96.1T (TOPT<1110843br>f=2
TT=3600.04

<>
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT=1659.96
T1=20.64
TT=PT<542 >6 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT71a href="bh66.16.314
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=16.031
T1=15.77
MObr>TT=1659.0.0183.45.983
T1=0.85>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOPT9216
TT=10.95td> )? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT9216
TT=10.9(9f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT57">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT1408449">MSAT (9MSAT (T95.7=br>Tr>T1=20.64
TT75T (TOPT<2909">4.314
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
MSphp1519d45">MSA<
f=2T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v167016&idjrand-2-24idev=16&idjob=11rand-24-24-2760039-57021br>
TT=3600.07

M1.94="benc=12.25
MSAT1ven">MOPT98T33">MS (T2S01="bench.php?idev=16&idbench=60759">csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
<3031.16ev=1">M=19.1114340">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
<3058.6br>f=2<>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOPT94T=1659.0.011T=5.983 T=16&id88 (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

MSAT1ven">MOPT94.=1659.0.011T=5.983 MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT53">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=f="bf48.6T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

<>
MSAT18(TO)
f=2
TT=f="b.96<04.314
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3044.97
T1=7.59

TT=3600.07

MOPT<7?2
T=16&.7414340"hp?idev=16&idjob=1108749">? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT<7?2
T=162.1T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

T1=12.25
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
M66T169TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2072T169TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
f5M
f=2
TT=14.846
T1=14.44
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOPTMSAT (T1TT1r>TT=0"hp?idev=16&idjob=1108749">? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT<331>MSAT (T11T=5.983 MSAT1ven">MObr>TT1">MOAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=355TT=3600f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MS>f=3539.6.314
T1=0.85
? (MO)

TT=19.918

MObr>TT1O)
f=540r97br>T1=20.1
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MOPT<7?1>MSAT (T1TT68 (TO)MSAT1ven">MOPT<7?1>MSAT (T11T56="bench.php?idev=16&idbench=60759">csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT=1659.96
T1=20.64
MSAT8&idjob=1108757">MSphp32677
T1=20.1
MObr>TT1r>TT=PT<1296T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04

TT>f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOP646T1r>TT=PT<25n319TT=3600.05

TT=PT<25n319f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT23 (TOPT<96f=2
TT=3600.04

T1=12.25
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT1408449">MSAT (8ev=1">M1049757">MSA
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=16.031
T1=15.77

TT=3600.07

MOPT<2.7=br>T">M6?73ev=16&f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT1ven">MOPT96.6br>
MSAT1ven">MOPT<2.7=br>T">M6?73ev=16&T1=12.25
T1=12.25
MSAT (9MSAT (T4.63br>T1=20.1
<
MSAT (9MSAT (T593.57
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
f5M
f=2
TT=14.846
T1=14.44
MObr>TT=1659.0.01500.45)f=2
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOPT<5.16ev=1">M9.65.983 MSAT1ven">MO2915.66ev=1">M9.7r>TT=0">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61/a>
MSAT1ven">MOPT<5i16ev=1">M9.65.983MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSphp1671.7=br>Tr>T1=20.64
MSAT7ven">MObr>TT1">MOPT<2738o569TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
MObr>TT1">MOPT<2855TT=3600f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MOP=14.24f=2
TT=8 (TO)
MSAT1ven">MOP=14.24f=2
TT=8 (TO)csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT= (TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T1=12.25
MSAT1408449">MSATob7">MSphp913.47nch.f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT1408449">MSATo129
f=3507767
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
1b=1114340">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61
T1=934.04
MOPT<2887.65)f=2
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOP223.s="odd">M12.29? (TO)

TT=3600.04

M12.465.61
T1=12.25
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT18(TO)
f=2MSA
MSAT (9MSAT (T3255.45.983
T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
? (MO)

TT=19.918

TT=0">OPTIMUMT1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v178116&idjrand-2-30-15idev=16&idjob=11rand-2-30-15-30br>30-19br>
TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

2f=2
TT79MSATCHECKS=14J 70083">MS NODES=72793">MS A
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT=1659.96
T1=20.64
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT=1659.96
T1=20.64

<22.361 (TOPT<14.7414340">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61goo918

<29.38
T">M=1T6UM
6o4? (MOAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1004.98
<21ob96=159>f=13.3=1108)
f=2
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02
30-29br>
TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04


3083">MS NODES=6441996T1=20.64
T1=20.64

<37.911">MOPT<33712="bench.php?idev=16&idbench=60759">goo918

<50.519MSAT (T44T5T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

<22.2<
T=1611.1996
T1=20.64

<20.281MSAT (T11T5996
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
30-31br>
TT=3600.07

TT78 (TO)csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
T1=20.64
T1=20.64

<51.7r>TT= (T42.7r>TT=0">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61goo918

<22.05r>TT=PT<13.6T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

4br> M6?071108)
f=2
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02
30-40br>
TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT (T4.63br>TCHECKS=143730083">MS NODES=640b? (MO A f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T1=20.64

<57.4U29
f=38.2896
T1=20.64

<97.423 (TOPT<87">2f=2<)
f=2
TT=3600.04

<36.621f=2
25.465.61
T1=12.25

<35.81a href="b4.8696
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
30-49br>
TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT97T8f=2T1=20.64
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT1">MOAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo918

<28.65idev=>TT=1r> f=2<)<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo918

<28.881MSAT (T17?089
<34br0a href="bf.391108)
f=2
f=2
TT=6.314
T1=6.02
30-6br>
TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT9214
T=16&.58 (TO)csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
<21o731MSAT (T19T23 (TO)<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
<9.9> f=230-11br>
TT=3600.07

MObr>TT= (TO)
f=0.64
MSAT (TO)T=16&.47
f=)
f=2
TT=1606.46
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
17016
TT=11o3T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MObr>TT= (TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT53">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT508449">MSAT (8ev=1">M633T23 (TO)<
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT10ven">MObr>TT15 (TOPT<34331>MSAT
T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=3044.97
T1=7.59
M3359.7r>TT=0">OPTIMUMT1=6.02
30-19br>
TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT91.4UMcsp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<2558.7
T=161534b7896
T1=20.64
MSATo129
f=117?65.983M2601i9>
M28=1T6296
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
30-24br>
TT=3600.07

M=1T5996
p?idev=16&idbench=60759">csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
MSAT1ven">MOPT95S2
T">M=1T669f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2TT=979T169f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=1772.3T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.05

M607<81 OPTIMUMT1=6.02
30-25br>
TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT7914
T=16&7.7 (TO)csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
<2861.391108php1399.72="bench.php?ide5
MSAT33ven">MObr>TT53">MS (T2SA>MSAT
T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
f=2
TT=16.031
T1=15.77
f=3510TT=3600f=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v176216&idjrand-2-40-19idev=16&idjob=11rand-2-40-19-443r>30-28br>
TT=3600.07

csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T1=12.25
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT53">MS (T28<6.T3 (TO
T1=12.25
T1=20.1
<
<2245MSAT
T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
<27=1T3a href="bh53T=9 (TOTO)
f=2T1=6.02
30-29br>
TT=3600.07

MSAT2ven">MOPT79146=159>f=2o369f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT2ven">MOPT62o3=159>f=2o33 (TO
T1=12.25
T1=12.25
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo918

<3591ob6=159>f=3239.8T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo918

<2596163f=2T1=20.1
<
2f=2
962 (TO)T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
<925S15=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
30-30br>
TT=3600.07

MOPT91o54=159>f=32.679? (TO)MSAT1ven">MOPT91.54=159>f=32.86 (TO)csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT56">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2<<29
f=3197T6UM
MObr>TT1r>TT=PT<2.57
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=16.031
T1=15.77
30-32br>
TT=3600.07

csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
T1=20.64
T1=20.64
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT11 (TOPT<1472.6896
T1=20.64
246TT1r>TT=0">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61/a>
<2881.21f=2
1559o3T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

<>
<2998.16ev=1">M18>3T73="bench.php?ider>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
30-41br>
TT=3600.07

MOPT99oT3 (TOPT<14.899TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
16<04.314
T1=0.85
MSAT1ven">MOPT99oT3 (TOPT<14.899f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT755=2
MSAT2ref="be&idjob6=159>f=1247<81 f=2
TT=16.031
T1=15.77
30-43br>
TT=3600.07

MOPT92.21f=2
27T44 (TO)TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
MSAT1ven">MOPT92121f=2
27T7r>TT=0">OPTIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61/a>
T1=12.25
T1=12.25
MSAT508449">MSAT (8ev=1">M2601i>MSAT
T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
OPTIMUM
4
f=2
TT=16.031
T1=15.77
MObr>TT=9MSAT (T561T669f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSphp1756659.9TIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61/a>
MSphp17229 MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T1=12.25
MObr>TT=9MSAT (T3197T79AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT141108php184.86 (TO)csp/QCP-10br>normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
<350216
TT=13413.58 (TO)T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT97T51f=2csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml

MSAT (T1T03.6T (TO)
f=2
TT=3600.04

<654.2br>TT=f="571.8296
T1=20.64

<1012 (8ev=1">M908.181108)
f=2T1=15.77
MSAT (T1297T769f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT<3.57">MSphp3SA>MSAT
T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85MSAT1ven">MOPT96.T3 (TOPT<3.96br>T1=20.1
<
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T1=12.25

f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo918

<87016
TT=1805.7UM
<540r52UM <481.21>MSAT (T408.82 (TO)T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOPT9216=159>f=1o92 (TO)TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
MSAT2ven">MOPT9216=159>f=1o92 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT2ven">MOP7=1T52=159>f=1o97 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT=9MSAT (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT=4MSAT (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT=4MSATPT<2347ob5">MSA<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT508449">MSAT 11 (TOPT<967T99MSAT
T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
? (MO)

TT=19.918

MOPT<232516
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1812ef&idjtightnessid1idev=16&idjob=11rand-2-40-8-753-5.7-82br>
TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MO1648T45br>T=16&.04659.9Ta.9TIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61/a>
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">T1=12.25

T=16&7527229 MSAT (9MSAT (T4T51f=2<> <1056.98br>T=16930.1996
T1=20.64

f=1275.87 (TO)T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT9275>MSAT (T2.1996
T1=20.64

goo918

<2149.31MSAT (T2089T669f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
<29214
T=16&89T95.983
<436.76
TT=1326.179f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT98T01br>T=16&.86659.9TT1=20.64
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
<585.395br>T=16553.179f=2goo918

<19067229T)<
f=2goo918

<2246.48f=2
2150o97 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
<2462T8696M=373.2br>T0">OPTIMUMT1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOP601ibr>TT=f="11.391108)
f=2T1=15.77
T1=12.25
T1=20.64
<648.7<6=2
<2439.2896M=353.219
<2367.7
T=162282.72="bench.php?ide5
<2418146=159>f=2342o81 f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT99o829
f=11.br>TT=)
f=2T1=15.77
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T1=12.25
MObr>TT=9MSAT (T3248T75.983 <610.6T6=2f=2goo918

<724.2696a8.6896
T1=20.64

<932.10a href="8=1T=9 (TOTO)
f=2T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT (TO)MSphp5o92 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T1=12.25
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT=1659.96
T1=20.64
<186T861br>T=16&34.899f=2goo918

<207<814 (TOPT<147b7896
T1=20.64

<364.587">MSphp308142="bench.php?ide5
<716.13a href="656T12="bench.php?ider>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
MSAT1ven">MOPT80T99MSATphp1728(TO)
T1=12.25
T1=12.25
T1=12.25

<549.51r>TT=PT<425164.314
T1=0.85
<498T343f=2T1=12.25

<871.716ev=1">M<34.219 <993.213 (TOPT<851724 (TOTO)
f=2T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

f=1o78(TO)
T1=12.25
T1=20.64
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT53">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo918

<353.471f=2
251.6896
T1=20.64
<278.166=159>f=8216
Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo918

<486o919MSAT (T356T765.61
T1=12.25

<512.988MSAT (T414.1996
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT84o46=159>f=16T2r>TT=)
f=2T1=15.77
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T1=20.64

<>MSphp2881.069
csp/QCP-10br>normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml <87012341108php744728(TO)
T1=12.2TT=22.38T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

T1=12.25
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<621o4?a href="346.6896
T1=20.64

<1239.48=159>f=83514
Tr>T1=20.64

f=td>1.br>TT=)
f=2T1=15.77
<1102163 (TOPT<849.7r>TT=0">OPTIMUMT1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1732jo&idjtightnessid35idev=16&idjob=11rand-2-40-16-250-350-7br>
TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">T1=20.64
T=16&190.8296
T1=20.64

<2129T1br>T=16&946.98br>Tr>T1=20.64

<1665T=9MSAT (T155531>MSAT
T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
T0">OPTIMUMT1=6.02

TT=3600.07

T)csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
<714.398>TT=f="574T44 (TO)goo918

csp/QCP-10br>normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml<324.0691108php183T44 (TO)f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT82.0a href="2.56 (TO)csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
T1=20.64
T1=20.64
<888T841f=2
594.18br>Tr>T1=20.64

M707SA>MSAT
T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
<893.181f=2
67&.04659.9Ta.9TIMUM
f=9
TT=1038.61>
<1720n3T (TOPT<&483.77 (TO)T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

MSAT1ven">MOPT877<29
f=t1.57
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT54659.96
T1=20.64
<285.51
T=16190.579f=2goo918

Con="trace.php?ih=300 ><890.2631108php771.549f=2goo918

4ph="trace.php?ih=300 ><330.9691108php241or>TT=)
f=2T1=15.77
<1025161T1=12.2r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT2ven">MOPSAT (8ev=1">M14o351108r>T1=20.64
MSAT2ven">MOPT93.2br>T">M14o351108r>T1=20.64
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T1=12.25

<2762.631108php2042142="bench.php?ide5

<3380.41f=2
2256.8896
T1=20.64
<2017.191108php1833o3T (TO)f=9
TT=1038.61>
<3566.83f=2f=2T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT1ven">MOPT96.87">MSphp49.97br>T)csp/QCP-10/
normalized-qcp-10-67-11_ext.xml
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T1=12.25

<2171.54=159>f=2033o48br>Tr>T1=20.64

<20djob3=159php1842o351108r>T1=20.64
<747.931MSAT (T684.62 (TO)T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
<473.2r>TT=f="398.65(TO)
T1=12.2r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT2ven">MOPT75.6T (TO (T6.7
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)T=167o351108r>T1=20.64
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT1ven">MObr>TT=1659.96
T1=20.64

<630.47br>T=16468?2
T)<
f=2goo918

<610.2341108php383T=9(TO) <216.3?a href="8<2o3T (TO)
f=2T1=15.77
<335.447">MSphp287.5 (TOTO)
f=2T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT2ven">MOPT94.69br>T=16&.86659.9TT1=20.64
MSAT (TO)T=16&.73659.9TT1=20.64
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">T1=12.25
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

<909.1269629.2 (TO)T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
<739.8T6=2T1=12.2r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT2ven">MOPT91.3? href="8<.72="bench.php?ide5
MSAT (TO) T1=12.25
T1=12.25
MSA>f=t1707229 MObr>TT55=2 <441.57896T1=0.85637.35
T1=0.85
TT=f="573T99MSAT
T1=0.85TT=22.38T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

? (TO)

TT=3600.04

T=167o99f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">T1=12.25
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<537n3T (TOPT<499.9896
T1=20.64
<99.614 (TOPT<59163 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<297T87">MSphp273.3r>TT=)
f=2T1=15.77
<462T71r>TT=PT<462.66>TT=0">OPTIMUMT1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1792jo&idjtightnessid65idev=16&idjob=11rand-2-40-40-135-650-13br>
TT=3600.07

MSAT2ven">MOP62jo14 (TOPT<26.72="bench.php?ide5
MObr>TT391108php24.989 f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<39610b3=159php245.98br>Tr>T1=20.64

<411o763=159php219T75.983 <199.2=9MSAT (T160.589f=2T1=15.77
<321.3?8MSAT (T321.29 (TO)T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MObr>TT1">MOPT<23.179MSAT2ven">MOPT94.54=159>f=23757f=2MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT1ven">MObr>TT56(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<1168.589
<2746o81f=2
<118.773br>T=16&087299f=2T1=15.77
<261.17896M=61.13(TO)
T1=12.2r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT2ven">MOPT94.7
T=1639.7UM
MSAT2ven">MOPSA8.2896M39.8M
T1=12.25
T1=20.64

<1778.64=2T1=20.64

<95916<29
f=485.391108)
f=2T1=15.77
<365.643f=2f=2T1=15.77
<1213.8896T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT2ven">MOPT64.?8MSAT (T7o99f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT2br>T=167o39f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T1=12.25
T1=12.25
MObr>TTb7">MSphp127&.0UM
TT=PT<3565T=896
T1=20.64
<1232o73br>T=16&144.579f=2T1=15.77
<1956T14=2T1=12.2r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT2ven">MOPT86 (8ev=1">M16169 (TOTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT2ven">MOP625.77 (TO">M16139 (TOTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T1=12.25
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<2208773br>T=16&646o7UM
T)csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">TT==16945.9
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
<935.368br>T=16935724 (TOTO)
f=2T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT5=300 ><2257T99MSATphp17969f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
MObr>TTb3">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
MObr>TTb3=1595.61
T1=12.25
f=44ob1659.9O)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=)
f=2T1=15.77
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT1">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MObr>TT1">MO (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT3=300 ><2818T171108php24.57
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT3=300 >
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TTb (TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<61572br>TT=PT<4067969f=2goo918

<665T894=159>f=453.179f=2/td>th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT5idev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MObr>TT57">MO (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT5&idjob=1108716=159>f=1AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT5=300 ><2204.219
MObr>TTb5">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT1(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<1184.989251.149f=2goo918

<2809.4=159>f=2809.199f=2/td>th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT53dev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<2539o63 (TOPT<2539.4996
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSA>f=2603.4996
>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT3=300 ><2542.589f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT3=300 >19o92 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
T1=12.25
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
MSA>f=2603.4996
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T=161036T02(TO)
T1=12.21
T1=15.77
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT56">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MObr>TT5idev=1br>f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

T)<>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT3=300 >MSphp8T87">MSTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT3=300 >T=169">MSTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<210.72r>TT=f="57?2
T)<
f=2goo918

<359.43=159php1897229
<675o949 href="650.271br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<1124.0">MSA>f=t123.9
Tr>br>f=2T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1835ef&idjtightnessid8idev=16&idjob=11rand-2-40-80-103-800-64br>
TT=3600.07

MSAT2ven">MO3307?2
TPT<1.0UM
MSAT2ven">MOP786T849 T1=12.25
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85

<105917896M">C.47br>T)csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result"><730.668br>T=16625.25 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
<326.797MSAT (T326.7
f=2
TT=1TT=22.38T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

MOb4849T1=12.21
T1=15.77
MO2406773br>T=1622n16=159TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
T1=12.25
MObr>TTb5">MS=16264.549f=2idth=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT1">MOPT<449161T1=12.21
T1=15.77
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT1">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MObr>TT57">MO (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT3=300 ><2662.2r>TT=f="17.36659.9TT1=20.64
MSTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo918

<219T (8ev=1">M1330.2 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
<1214ob3=159php185o46=159br)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo918

<1792.891108php1569o46=159br)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
<2130.92f=2
2130.83 (TO)T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

M16146=159br>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">T=1611o48br>Tr>T1=20.64
Tr>T1=20.64
T1=12.25
T1=20.64
<47.471 (TO">M16146=159br2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<65.152f=2
23.891108br2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<470161r>TT=PT<362.0UM
MO17.678">MO (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MObr>TTb (TO)PT<307.83 (TO)<>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT4&idjob=P5951391108php18T72="bench.php?ide5
MSAT4&idjob=2279.1
T=1618.57
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MObr>TTb5">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
MObr>TTb (TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MObr>TTb (TO)PT<307.83 (TO)<2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MObr>TTb7">MSphp826.43=159
T1=12.21
T1=15.77
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT51">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO17.088dev=1br>f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT2ven">MOPT86 3T (TOPT<2o351108r>T1=20.64
MSAT (TO)f=2.41108r>T1=20.64
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TTb4f=2f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo918

<195Tb 7">MSphp122o34 (TO)<2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=60o92 (TO)T1=12.21
T1=15.77
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT55">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO17.559">MO (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT5=300 >19o29 (TOTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT5=300 >f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TTb7">MS (TOTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT4&idjob=110875idev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT5&idjob=11087b (TO)PT<156.94 (TOTO)
f=2
f=2T1=15.77
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT55">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO16.98br>Tr(TO)T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

T=1622n11br>Tr>T1=20.64
Tr>T1=20.64
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo918

<2241or49T1=20.64
<467T88896f=2T1=15.77
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT51">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO17.009">MO (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT3=300 >f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT3=300 > f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT1(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<131.42r>TT==1652T849f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo918

<148.183f=2f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<893.364=2f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO17.36br>Tr(TO)T1=6.02

TT=3600.07

M5139 (TOTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T=165.3r>TT=)
f=2T1=15.77
MObr>T659.96
T1=20.64
MObr>TTb3=1595.61
T1=12.25
MSAT5&idjob=11087b59 MObr>TT139f=2T1=15.77
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT55">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO18.277">MO (TO)<)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1802ef&idjtightnessid9idev=16&idjob=11rand-2-40-180-84-9ug-76br>
TT=3600.07

MSA=159br>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT3=300 >T1=12.25
MSAT3=300 ><2639.76MSAT (T36.b6.983 MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TTbidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MObr>TTb4f=2<=16116&.73659.9TT1=20.64
MSAT5&idjob=1108714f=2<=169.271br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT55">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO17.97idev=1br>f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT5=300 >Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
MSAT5=300 >f=1.9
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
MSAT5&idjob=11087bidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT5&idjob=11087bidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<41.91
T=1638n11br>Tr>T1=20.64
MSAT204ven">MObr>TT139 f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MObr>TT11>TT=PT<3563.82(TO)
T1=12.2r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
<6br>
TT=3600.07

TT=0"width=100 class="bestresu/a> f=2/a>
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT139f=2T1=15.77
T=16418.9
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT12">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MObr>TT58dev=1br>f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<7br>
TT=3600.07

MO0.67
T=1607579
MSAT131&idjob=P5951849 MSAT131&idjob=P62jo139 MObr>TTb3=1595.61
T1=12.25
MObr>TT">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TTb3">MS>f=44o87">MSTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT 12ven">MObr>TT21 (TO">M107?2
MO0.67
T=1607579f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO5.388br>T=165.3r>TT=)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
11br>
TT=3600.07

f=>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSpb=PSA3.449
MSpb=PSA1o139f=2
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T1=20.64
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MO7.16659.96
T1=20.64
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MO8T87">MST6
T1=20.64
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT02">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
12br>
TT=3600.07

T=163.13(TO)
T1=12.2br>
T=163Tb4f=2T1=12.2br> f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT475&idjob=1108714f=2<=1649196
T1=20.64

TT=36answerass="bestresultincomplete">MO231T72="ben(TOTO)
f=2
T=160798br>Tr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
T=1610.85>TT=)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
13br>
TT=3600.07

0.64
12.
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
M13T5.983
MSAT50ven">MObr>TTb5">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TTb7">MS (TOTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MO8Tb3=1595.61
T1=12.25
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MO7.83=1595.61
T1=12.25
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT51">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MObr>TT57">MO (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<6-16br>
TT=3600.07

MSAT25=300 >T=161.97>TT=0")
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT25=300 >T0")
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT25=300 ><&idjob3">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT223idev=16&idjob6659.PT<14.7>TT=0")
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
12.11
<28.318br>T=16279f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
<23.341MSAT (T23.2996
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
<6-18br>
TT=3600.07

MSpb=PSA1ob (TO)PT<12.3r>TT=)
f=2T1=15.77
MSpb=P5817579TT=)
f=2T1=15.77
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT31&idjob=11087bidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MObr>TTb3">MS>f=20o48br>Tr>T1=20.64
MObr>TT11>TT=PT<34.68br>T> Tr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
M13T75 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<6-20br>
TT=3600.07

MO8T71598Tb4f=2 MSAT 7">MSpb=PSA3.5">MSA>f=28.891108br2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSpb=P587.62MSAT (T28.291108br2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA>f=46146=159br2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
8Tb4f=2f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
T=1610.36659.9TT1=20.64f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v3098jomax&idjcelar/scensidev=16&idjob=11scenw><6-22br>
TT=3600.07

MO7.6b59TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT22&idjob=P595169 (TO">M161811br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT22&idjob=P587.48>TT=f="17.221br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT22&idjob=&idjob3">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT139
MO7.6b59f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO5T7539f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<6-24br>
TT=3600.07

MO6o18br>T=166.149f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSpb=P5817579MSTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSpb=P5881391108php10.0UM
MSAT22&idjob=&idjo">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT26idev=16&idjob">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA>f=17.93T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2T1=15.77
MO6o18br>T=166.149f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO4.122ven">(T4.0796
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
<6-30br>
TT=3600.07

MO0.79TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT22&idjob=P593Tb3">MS>f=22ob5">MSAO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT22&idjob=PSA8.52br>T=1621.9
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<1767.71 (TO">M1767.57MSAT> MO0.79f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
<1o8749f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<6-30d> ucbr>
TT=3600.07

MO0.6319TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<124.6b19MSCHECKS=5205180idev NODES=2992 (TO )<2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<1343o139f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>Tf=2f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT1dev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<5716=159>f=4169 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<3169r>TT=PT<3.47br>T)csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result"><0.6319f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
<0.536br>T=16072396
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
<6br>
TT=3600.07

T=1614.149f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT38&idjob=1108756(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MObr>TTb4f=2<=1622o221br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MObr>TT12">MSPT<18.37br>T)csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<7_7.200_30dbr>
TT=3600.07

TT=PT<12.85>TT=)
f=2Tr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT17ven">MObr>TTb4f=2<=16267272396
T1=20.64csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
T1=12.25
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT59">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
<7_r>
TT=3600.07

TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT76&idjob=P625.39f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT76&idjob=P638n14=159>f=64.76 (TO)<)
f=2csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
MSAT57&idjob=1108757f=2f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT94&idjob=1108756(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T=16135.93T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=PT<3397.795.61
T1=12.25
th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MObr>TT1">MO (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MObr>TT55">MO (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<8br>
TT=3600.07

MObr>TTb1659.96
0.64
T=1620.54=159r>br>f=2T1=15.77
TT=f="19.03M
MObr>TTb5">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT193ven">MObr>TTb7">MS (TOTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MO7.26">MS (TOTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MO7.2.893">MS (TOTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>th=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MObr>TT02">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MObr>TT1">MO (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
<9br>
TT=3600.07

47T849f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MOPS16.98919.6>TT=)
f=2T1=15.77
MSAT94&idjob=110875idev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT94&idjob=1108757f=2f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT255&idjob=1108717f=2f=2T1=15.77
f=2T1=15.77
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=4163 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
10br>
TT=3600.07

MOPS02o63 (TOPT<18.421br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT94&idjob=110875idev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT94&idjob=1108756(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
5A8.52br>T)
f=2T1=15.77
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=4163 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v3115jomax&idjcelar/subs6idev=16&idjob=11scenw>6-sub0br>
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT6idev=161516.63 (TOPT<1.13(TO)
T1=12.2br>
MSAT6idev=161559716=159>f=0798br>Tr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MO6o492MSAT (T61br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MO10.5469 TT=f="0f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
6-sub1-24br>
TT=3600.07

MSCHECKS=39181600idev NODES=8058dev= r>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSpb=P581739br>T=160768br>Tr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSpb=br>TTb3=1595.61
T1=12.25
MSAT18&idjob=11087bidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
TT=f="0or1=159brbr>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
6-sub1br>
TT=3600.07

MO0.2579TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT22&idjob=P583.5">MSA>f=1.03">MSf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT22&idjob=&idjob3(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT22&idjob=&idjob5dev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MO191.0159190.795.61
T1=12.25

MO355.911>TT=PT<355.67MSAT> MO0.2579f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO1.438br>T=161.16 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
6-sub2br>
TT=3600.07

MO0or749TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT22&idjob=P588.85>TT=PT<3.3
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
MSAT22&idjob=P589.97>TT=PT<3.3
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
MSAT22&idjob=&idjobidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MO258T8259146.551br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MO271.8089128.25.983 MO0.r749f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO1.742br>T=161obidev=1rbr>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
6-sub3br>
TT=3600.07

TT=PT<3.8
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
Tr>T1=20.64
MSAT24idev=16&idjob2(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT24idev=16&idjob4dev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<2996.5">MSA>f=2995.921br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=PT<352o48br>Tr>T1=20.64
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
<2.543 (TOPT<2.14 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
6-sub4-20br>
TT=3600.07

MSAT23&idjob=PSA4.179Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
TTb5">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT23idev=161108756(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=PT<1327br>Tr>T1=20.64
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
T=160734dev=1rbr>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
6-sub4br>
TT=3600.07

MSPT<1.56AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T=161.76 (TO)<)
f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT24idev=16&idjob4dev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo918

TT=PT<458T121br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<2761.85>TT=PT<2661.59br>Tr>T1=20.64
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
<2.513 (TOPT<2.44 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
7-sub0br>
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT4idev=16P574ob (TO)PT<1.179TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<1.03">MSCHECKS=56842800idev NODES=>T13
T r>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<75T825975T64 (TOTO)
f=2
TT=f="0f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
TT=f="0o74dev=1rbr>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
7-sub1-20br>
TT=3600.07

MSCHECKS=23340700idev NODES=5800idev f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSCHECKS=43475000idev NODES=93709
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
12.03
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
6772396
T1=20.64csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
7-sub1br>
TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSpb=P583.71 (TO">M2.83">MSr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSpb=P58271590798br>Tr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSAT18&idjob=11087bidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT18&idjob=11087b6(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MS>f=22o34 (TO)<2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=f="0obidev=1r)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
PT<1.07 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v3100jomax&idjcelar/subs7idev=16&idjob=11scenw>7-sub2br>
TT=3600.07

MSpb=P572.9=159>f=0773">MSTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSpb=P585.6=159>f=079>TT=0")
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT18&idjob=11087b3">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
M128.57
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
T=161obidev=1rbr>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
7-sub3br>
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<1.2
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
TTb5">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTbidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=PT<349.94 (TOTO)
f=2
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93
7-sub4-22br>
TT=3600.07

PT<24.
Tr>br>f=2T1=15.77
MS>f=26Tb4f=2f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=idth=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
566.76 (TO)<)
f=2goo918

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
T)f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
7-sub4br>
TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2T1=15.77
TTb5">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTb1dev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T=161736o221br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MS rbr>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>f=2T1=15.77

f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=0701 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

M2.5995893">MS f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
M2.599f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MS>f=1665.26">MS rbr>f=2T1=0.85
f=2csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=0701 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSCHECKS=21170800idev NODES=521699
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo918

TT=PT<1017.b5">MSAO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo918

PT<3246.34 (TO)<)
f=2csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSCHECKS=58402400idev NODES=>696609
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT57&idjob=1607.97>TT=PT<0.589f=2T1=15.77
MSAT57&idjob=1108753">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT72&idjob=&idjob3(TO)PT<1.84 (TO)<)
f=2csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
T=160702 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

M2.56659.CHECKS=36160700idev NODES=55772&idj TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT65&idjob=11087bidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT65&idjob=11087b">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MS rbr>f=2csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
T=160702 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
PT<3.459f=2
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MS rbr>f=2csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
TT=PT<0.02 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v3438phmax&idjcnf/2-40-7.2-7.20idev=16&idjob=11cnf-2-40-8.2-810521br>
TT=3600.07

MSCHECKS=41320300idev NODES=671439
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTb5">MSPT<2.11T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2T1=15.77
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
MSPT<1.889f=2T1=15.77
MSAT113&idjob=1108753">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT113&idjob=110875">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTb5">MSPT<2.03M
f=2T1=15.77
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

T=161o59T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT230&idjob=11087b2(TO)PT<11.47br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT230&idjob=11087b6MSAT (T2.589f=2T1=15.77
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MO2.032MSAT (T0T79TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MO1624.36659. (T0T79TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MO1616Tb4f=2< (T0T79TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT225&idjob=11087b6MSAT (T4.41AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
Tr>T1=20.64
MO2.032MSAT (T1.28f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MO1.7139f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSPT<5T64 (TOTO>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MS>f=1614.95br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT265&idjob=1108719f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT258&idjob=11087b6MSAT (T3.27br>Tr>T1=20.64
MSPT<5T64 (TOTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
T=161o36 (TO)<)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

T=1607589f=2T1=15.77
f=2T1=15.77
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
Tr>T1=20.64
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85T1=20.64
MSAT227idev=16&idjob2(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT227idev=16&idjob7f=2f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT278&idjob=1108754">MS (T3.7br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
M1.95br>TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT221&idjob=1869.36659. (T9.7T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT221&idjob=1616T33659. (T9.79TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TTbidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tdev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT265&idjob=1108712">MSPT<2.121br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
T=161.459f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

T=161.32AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
PT<1.37T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT278&idjob=11087559T1=20.64
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<2.28f=2T1=15.77
f=2T1=15.77
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<2.28f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MS rbr>f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v3209efmax&idjcnf/2-40-27.2-3.20idev=16&idjob=11cnf-2-40-23.2-96030br>
TT=3600.07

PT<2.83">MSr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
TT=f="0o74dev=1rbr>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T)f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT279&idjob=1S04.899Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT279&idjob=1S08.76=159>f=1S08.72br>Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT279&idjob=1108754">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT279&idjob=1108757f=2f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MS (T18.5AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T1=20.64csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MS1rbr>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<0o65f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
PT<2.69f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTb5">MSPT<27.71 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=f="3.551br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=0773">MSTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTb5">MSPT<21.12AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
M1.95br>TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

PT<2.83">MSr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
MSr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
f=0704br>TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSPT<2.121br>f=>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
MSPT<2.121br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MS (T15.48>TT=TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<3.459f=2
MSPT<2.26dev=1rbr>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

PT<2.83">MSr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
MSAT289&idjob=1617o21907851br>f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT289&idjob=1108756">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
1768br>TTO)
f=2
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT229M1.86 (TO)<)
f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT229MS>f=1.77
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT229f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA>f=1280.26">MS rbr>f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<0o86">MS rbr>f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT25&idjob=1108753">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT25&idjob=11087bidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
MS rbr>f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v4097efmax&idjcnf/2-80-7.2-7.20idev=16&idjob=11cnf-2-80-108-3v4043br>
TT=3600.07

TT=f="0o87
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT63&idjob=110871">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MS r>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MS rbr>f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT70idev=16&idjob2(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT70idev=16&idjob2(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSPT<4.76 (TO)<)
f=2/a>
MS r)
f=2
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MS r>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT809f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT809Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT80idev=16br>Tdev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT80idev=16br>TTbidev=1br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T1=20.64csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">MS r)
f=2
PT<30.6dev=1rbr>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

Tbr>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">TT=f="7739br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT81&idjob=1635.519f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT81&idjob=1108756">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT113&idjob=11087529f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<25713(TO)r>T1=20.64csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">TT=f="36.67dev= r)
f=2
MSPT<27.35br>TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSPT<7.091br>f=>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSPT<7739br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<7.091br>f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<668713(TO)r>T1=20.64> TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=36.0
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=36.0
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T1=20.64
MSPT<3.821br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>f=121.311br>f=T1=20.64> PT<12375396
T1=20.64f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MO1648.26">MSPT<11.08T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MO16317b29f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<125077
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT206659.=1611087149TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=8.52br>Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<8.62br>Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT226659.=161108712">MSPT<2419.66br>Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

f=>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MS>f=1.7AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MS>f=1.54dev=1rbr>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MS (T7.2br>Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MS r)
f=2
0 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT221&idjob=11087119f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T">MSPT<7737AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT306659.=1611087119TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T=164272396
T1=20.64f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v3220ssmax&idjcnf/2-80-77.2-2.20idev=16&idjob=11cnf-2-80-75.2-895349br>
TT=3600.07

MSPT<3.821br>f=>TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<3.87">MSr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
TPT<3.821br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT355&idjob=1108712">MSPT<10.849
f=2
0 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT2389f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT (TO>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
MSAT272&idjob=1108">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
MSAT272&idjob=1108758>MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT4069f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT354659.=1611087159f=2
0 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT276659.=1611087119TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

MSAT (TO>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<22.26">MS rbr>f=2/a>
MSAT272&idjob=1108752">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT360&idjob=&idjob3(TO)PT<9737AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT386659.=161108719">MSPT<11.17
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT275&idjob=11087119TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA>f=17.471br>TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
MSAT (TO))
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
PT<8.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT324&idjob=11087119TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi49b6MSAT NODESi119
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi4701&idj NODESi69
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi4776MSAT NODESi9&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi4851&idj NODESi12">MS f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

PT<2.61>MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi5131&idj NODESi169
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi4711&idj NODESi89
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi5591&idj NODESi289
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi5546MSAT NODESi27">MS f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
MSPT<2713(TO)r>T1=20.64csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=5.93

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi6081&idj NODESi42&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi5931&idj NODESi369
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>f=2.58>MSAf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0704br>TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

0758>MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<2.61>MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi7866&idj NODESi83&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi5321&idj NODESi269
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<27471br>TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0704br>TTO)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v4503efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

TT=f="0o67(TO)CHECKSi5&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<2.59T (TCHECKSi5&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi21071&idj NODESi448&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi40686MSAT NODESi903&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo
MSPT<27271br>TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=2
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

0758>MSACHECKSi5&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<2.68T (TCHECKSi5&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi19636&idj NODESi449&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi6951&idj NODESi689
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>f=2.42 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4489efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

PT<2.78T (TCHECKSi5&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=f="0o67(TO)CHECKSi5&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi86076MSAT NODESi2133&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi196851&idj NODESi48369
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<27471br>TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=2
0704br>TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4601efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

T=163.24">MS rbr>f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">MS rbr>f=2100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
MSA>f=17.071br>TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<27071br>TO>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSPT<7.94 (TO)<)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<27071br>TO2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0.0
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4538efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MS>f=1.53AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=1.67AT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSPT<1.389f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MS (T1.311br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TO2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

TT=f="8.2br>Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT18idev=161108756(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT399MSA (T1.111br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=5.54dev=1r2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4555efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MST (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MST (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT209MSA (T2062.6dev=f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TO2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
22.95br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT43&idjob=110875idev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=0704br>TTO)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v4350ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=1.589)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
MSPT<1755br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT399f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT51&idjob=1108713(TO)PT<91.449TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

18.57 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>18.78T (TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSPT<1.129TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4298ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSPT<7.88>TT=TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA (T8.299f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT57&idjob=1108754">MST (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT57&idjob=1108756">MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA (T1.26T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA (T13.22f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT57&idjob=1108751dev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT57&idjob=1108758">MST (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA (T1.25br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
55.859)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
PT<2.0
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4321efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSAT60idev=161597.73">MSPT<21.39br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT60idev=161583.59T (TPT<21.36br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT99idev=161108755dev= (T1.271br>TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=0783T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO))
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4451efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSPT<1.54dev=1r2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TO2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MSPT<2.0
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4375efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=5.13T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MST (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO))
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=0704br>TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT (TO))
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=0704br>TTO)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v4420efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=5.311br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT (TO))
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
0704br>TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

0758>MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi7324">MS NODESi159
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi7224">MS NODESi119
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85T=163.38>MSAf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>f=2.59 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5553efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

0761>MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.850758>MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi7694">MS NODESi17&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi71099
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.850762T (TCHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi7674MSAT NODESi21&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi70599
TT=1637.35
T1=0.853.41dev=f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0701TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5489efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

0758>MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<2.63>MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi215499
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi280199
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi161699
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi411699
MS f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85T=163.38>MSAf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5507efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi294399
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi22424">MS NODESi2919
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85T=163.42>MSAf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>f=2.66dev=f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSPT<1.8796
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5592efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSPT<1707">MSr>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT7&idjob=1108758">MST (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT7&idjob=1108752>MSAT (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
MSA>f=S01.01dev=f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT6idev=161108755dev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TO2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>f=27.33T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
PT<2.06br>TTO)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v5323efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT57&idjob=11087539f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=0707br>Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=5.25br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
T>f=5.21br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT57&idjob=1108752T (TPT<1768
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT57&idjob=1108759">MSPT<1772T (T1r2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5305efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSAT31&idjob=1S05.019TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<9.7 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MST (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSPT<1.39 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=1.57br>Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<349.25br>TTOf=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSA (T17.92T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=16718
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MST (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=1.57br>Tf=2
TT=1r>TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSPT<1759 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<349.25br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5245efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

0784
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
078
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MST (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSPT<1773T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSPT<17511br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
MSPT<1708 (TOf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

T=163.259)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
ob=114.264=159>f=295.35br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
ob=07897T (TPT<0o06br>Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5474efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MST (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA (T1.631br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TO2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TObr>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MS (T17.36br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=27159TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5470efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
1.9 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
T>f=69.17TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

237159TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MS (TOf=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<1758br>TTO)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v5191efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSPT<0784
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MS (TOf=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MS (TOf=>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA (T17.411br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT112&idjob=110875idev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
MSAT112&idjob=1108">MS (TOf=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=85.97(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5384efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA (T12.38>MSAf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MS (TOf=>f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSA (T5.7896
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5376efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSPT<37701TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">37.01dev=f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<2842772T (T1r2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT194idev=161603.64=159>f=12.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT194idev=161607.411br>>f=12.46br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
MSA (T368772T (T1r2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5350efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
07051br>f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">f=27.139f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
PT<27.21br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/td>0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
07051br>f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5816efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi6620&idj NODESi171br> f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi6125br>T NODESi111br> f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TO2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.389TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi6555br>T NODESi15&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi5945br>T NODESi71br> f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<17511br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
07051br>f=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v5782efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<0757&idjCHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi6000br>T NODESi111br> f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi6110br>T NODESi9&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<1759 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<0o68>MSACHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi34075br>T NODESi446br>T f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi46715br>T NODESi633T (T f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v6002efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<0o68>MSACHECKSi2319270&idj NODESi26=11087 f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT19f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<17441br>TO2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.52T (T1r2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
MSPT<07051br>f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<0o63T (TCHECKSi106173T (T NODESi198idev f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.850778>MSACHECKSi1337200br>T NODESi15111br> f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85br>0f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5890efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSA>f=2719(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=37051br>f=2
TT=1r>TT=1998.71
T1=1>
MSA (T1.78 (TOf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSA>f=0.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.850772
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<3297.24
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1753.47dev=1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0TT=1r>TT=1998.71
T1=1>
07051br>f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5884efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

T>f=0.77(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0TT=1r>TT=1998.71
T1=1>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">1.26br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
1.28br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<2.29dev=1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA (T14o54=159br2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5727efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

TPT<26.92
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>f=25712dev=1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>5772T (T1r2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<1723TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.3br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">MSPT<1723TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<7.139f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2
f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v6074efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
1.26br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
1.22T (T1r2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>587589f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

T>f=1.36br>TTO)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
1.19 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
8.7TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<22.94br>TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v6044efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSPT<07611br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
MSPT<3.45 (TOf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">>f=1.429TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT110&idjob=3108757(TO)PT<1739 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT116&idjob=110871T (TPT<1.56br>Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=5773T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5648ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
f=1.52T (T1r2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAPT<14.44 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA (T12.94=159br
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
8.8br>Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5702efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">MSAT100&idjob=1580.79(TO)PT<17669TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT100&idjob=2102.46br>TPT<1785 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT100&idjob=1108756(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT100&idjob=11087559MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT1191087ob=1108758918.89dev=1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5692efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSPT<5717dev=f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=57159TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

bTT1808712">MSPT<0777(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
bTT1578714=159>f=0.78 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
bTT3108752(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85bTT31087519MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
bTT6.5979f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
bTT6.989(TO)PT<1767T (TO)
f=2
f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v5857efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=0o64
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT136&idjob=11087539MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
br>32.6br>Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT129&idjob=1596o54=159PT<7.21
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT129&idjob=2668712">MSPT<7732T (T1r2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT129&idjob=1108754dev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5954efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSAT167&idjob=1765.819Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT167&idjob=1552.8490797(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=0.78 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=0.76 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5927efmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">MSA>f=0.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>f=2.26br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2.45 (TOf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=0.56br>TCHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0.58br>TCHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi4869br>T NODESi12&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi4389br>T NODESi5&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.33T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4725ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSPT<0o58br>TCHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>f=0.48br>TCHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSCHECKSi4599br>T NODESi9&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSCHECKSi4449br>T NODESi6&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=27159TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<0o58br>TCHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<0o58br>TCHECKSi0&idj NODESi0&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi4944 (TO NODESi13&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi4359br>T NODESi8&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.149TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4889ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0o64
CHECKSi539451&idj NODESi756&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2719dev=1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=0o63
CHECKSi1468629
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TCHECKSi495167&idj NODESi747&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=27159TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0TT=1r>TT=1998.71
T1=1>
TTO)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v4878ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=0o64
CHECKSi828515&idj NODESi1458&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKSi7253490&idj NODESi11033&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<2.29dev=1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2T (T1r2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
br>0f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0o8br>TCHECKSi77745000&idj NODESi101893&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<78.08
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5153ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

TCHECKSi7772960&idj NODESi10846&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=88757(TO)<=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>f=0.65
CHECKSi15131300&idj NODESi18459&idj f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
<=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4989ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSA>f=0.78 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT13&idjob=1108759dev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">1738>MSAf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4994ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=0.78 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">br>0.659f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2T1=0.85
MSA>f=1.28br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<0o58br>Tbr>TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">MSPT<0o58br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>f=0.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
17321br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA>b=11087059MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<1738>MSAf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4799ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSAT70>MSA>b=11087059f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT30&idjob=1592.53=159>f=0.67(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSAT30&idjob=1585.39dev= (T0.78 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSA>b=1108709(TO)PT<1721br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
TTO)
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v4852ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

bTT1564.489f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">bTT15707349TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>b=11087059TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>b=11087119TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSA>b=11087119TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4827ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSPT<0o74=159br>TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<0o74=159br2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=0.78 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<1.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<2.76 (TOf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<0o859f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=0.73T (TO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>f=0.04br>TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5040jomax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSAT73&idjob=1587o629
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
MSAT73&idjob=1598738>MSA>f=1758 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>b=11087119TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=0o64
br2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
f=0o64
br2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1717dev=TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5102ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

MSPT<0o74=159br2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
0o74=159br2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSA>f=0.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MS>f=0.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v5099ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0o82
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<0o56 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MS (T0.59br>Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.851639.289TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v4931ssmax&idjkb
TT=3600.07

f=0o58 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSPT<0o58br>Tbr2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MS>f=0.68
f=>TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">MS>f=0.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MS>f=0.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MS>f=1.97dev=TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TTO)
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4250ssmax&idjmax&liqueidev=16&idjob=11brock-200-4br>
TT=3600.07

MSTT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSA>b=1662.819)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4196efmax&idjmax&liqueidev=16&idjob=11brock-800-1br>
TT=3600.07

=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSAT7859f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
MSAT784&idjob=1677.86(TO)PT<1677.77(TO)<>2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=6757(TO)<=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4226efmax&idjmax&liqueidev=16&idjob=11c-fat200-2br>
TT=3600.07

MSA>b=1662.82dev=PT<33.7(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSA>b=1665.311br>PT<1665.25(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSA>b=1108719MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>b=1108755(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<2.56
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<13.4
f==2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=1698758 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=4.819TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSA>b=1108719MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">MS
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<13.4
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<22.321br>f=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4222efmax&idjmax&liqueidev=16&idjob=11c-fat500-2br>
TT=3600.07

MS>f=6713
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<11.3f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<157559TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<30.659f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v4223ssmax&idjmax&liqueidev=16&idjob=11ham08-g-10-2br>
TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSf=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSPT<18=8.61(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSA>b=11087019MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4198ssmax&idjmax&liqueidev=16&idjob=11johnson-1br>-4br>
TT=3600.07

TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=9.22">MSO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=41.9">MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=18.03
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
-4br>
TT=3600.07

MSPT<34o88
f=
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4224ssmax&idjmax&liqueidev=16&idjob=11johnson-8r>-4br>
TT=3600.07

f=4.16 f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<0
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

18.22">MSO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1/a>
MSA>b=1665.971br>PT<1665.94
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>b=11087559MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=58.77(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4241ssmax&idjmax&liqueidev=16&idjob=11p-hat>T10-2br>
TT=3600.07

f==2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSTT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4249ssmax&idjmax&liqueidev=16&idjob=11p-hat5td-3br>
TT=3600.07

MSf=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSA<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT130&idjob=1632.59(TO)PT<1.68
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT130&idjob=1646.05">MSPT<1.59br>Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSAT130&idjob=1108752dev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<23.96
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v4206efmax&idjmax&liqueidev=16&idjob=11san-400-0.7-3br>
TT=3600.07

MSA>b=1660.79dev=PT<1660.74
f==2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSPT<1.76 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=/a>
MSA>b=1660.79dev=PT<1660.74
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>b=1108759dev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA>b=1108756(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=41.97(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT159&idjob=1108754(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2302ssmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth><-340-2br>
TT=3600.07

MSf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
PT<0757">MSf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.321br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MS>f=1.48
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<-340-5br>
TT=3600.07

MSf=>TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MS>f=0.62
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<0757">MSf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
5.24">MSf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">PT<4.659f=2T1=0.85
MSPT<0
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2325efmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth><-360-4br>
TT=3600.07

MSf=>TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>b=1613.89(TO)PT<0o78
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>b=1618.61
PT<0.77(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSAT151>MSA>b=11087019MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT151>MSA>b=11087069MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MSA>b=1108759(TO)PT<5.48">MSf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=14.71
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<-370-5br>
TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
MS>f=0.76T (TO))
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
MSf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<0
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2384efmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth><-390-8br>
TT=3600.07

MSf=>TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<0.62
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=3.26=159f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
PT<48712(TO)<=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<1.56
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<-400-10br>
TT=3600.07

MS>f=0.55">MSf=>TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2.359f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
5.06=159f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
MS>f=8.3f=2T1=0.85
MS>f=21.379TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2338efmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth><-400-2br>
TT=3600.07

MSf=>TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0.67(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
MSf=aSf=>TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2.94
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<4.13
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=>
3.95
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
<-400-5br>
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<0769T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
PT<16.99f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v251=5.max&idjmax&utjmax&uth4
TT=3600.07

MSA>b=1628754dev=>f=0.67(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
MSA>b=1621.67(TO)>f=0.79(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
MSAT161&idjob=1108757(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSAT161&idjob=1108753(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
PT<3.16TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=38o559f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
PT<4.56
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

PT<0.69(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA>b=11087019f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2544efmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth4
TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=6.521br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

PT<0768T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<0.77(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<8768T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v254=5.max&idjmax&utjmax&uth4
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.88T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
6.6TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=0.67(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSAT246dev=>b=110875896.55
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
MSO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v25055.max&idjmax&utjmax&uth4
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<0768T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<0.89(TO)O)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

PT<0.77(TO)<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=0.88T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>b=1101.839f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
MSA>b=1130.91(TO)PT<470.33">MSf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2268ssmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth5
TT=3600.07

f=0.67(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=3717(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
MSA<>)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=804o77(TO)f=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSA>b=1632.74">MSPT<0768T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>b=1621.939TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSA>b=1108753dev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA>b=1108753dev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=24=159f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
MSA>b=1508.98dev=>f=364757">MSf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
MSA>b=1550.34(TO)PT<854.94
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v2252efmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth5
TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
MSf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
PT<655o43(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=1.379f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=1403.27(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2227ssmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth5
TT=3600.07

MSPT<0.68T (TO)>TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
MSPT<82.74
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<673.38(TO)O)
f=2
f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSAT244>MSA>b=16287739TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
MSAT244>MSA>b=1623756(TO)PT<07991br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2203ssmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth5
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=)
f=2
TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<4.27
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=3252.02
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2432efmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth6
TT=3600.07

f=0.76(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=61.5
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

MSPT<0768T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0.69T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2.44">MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
3.6TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1>
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2461efmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth6
TT=3600.07

MSA>b=1622.54(TO)PT<1758 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
MSA>b=1618.56">MSPT<0794">MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSA>b=1108708dev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSA>b=1108708dev=1br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<129o96TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0778T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v2467ssmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth6
TT=3600.07

f=0.88T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSO)
f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=7717(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
726.359f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
MSTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=0.72
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2T1=0.85
PT<835.51
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2454ssmax&idjmax&utjmax&uth6
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=3757dev=1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02

TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
PT<0.97(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=4715T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
1098.59(TO)f=2T1=0.85
PT<125.521br>f=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v3058ssmax&idjpijpi-20-10-20-t6TT=3600.07

lass=NODES=44=11087 f=2T1=0.85lass=NODES=5014=159 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0o03(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

0o48T (TCHECKS3146588>lass=NODES=2459(TO) f=2T1=0.85lass=NODES=4929=159 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.09
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v3047ssmax&idjpijpi-20-10-20-t6TT=3600.07

0o48T (TCHECKS3233786>lass=NODES=44=7(TO) f=2T1=0.85lass=NODES=9766=159 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.09
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0o03(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=0.69T (TCHECKS32907330>lass=NODES=42469(TO) f=2T1=0.85MSPT<0767(TO)CHECKS3673737>lass=NODES=10798dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=1.09
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0o03(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v3019efmax&idjpijpi-20-10-20-t6TT=3600.07

f=0.58T (TCHECKS323729=159 NODES=41(TO) f=2T1=0.85f=0.58T (TCHECKS3234569
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<1.23(TO)<=br>f=2T1=0.85f=1.321br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0o03(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=0.58T (TCHECKS3393576>lass=NODES=61639
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.25T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0o03(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v3034ssmax&idjpijpi-20-10-20-t6TT=3600.07

f=2T1=0.85lass=NODES=7030lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.21br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0o03(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

0o49T (TCHECKS354322dev==NODES=80dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=0.47T (TCHECKS344975T (T=NODES=589
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1998.71
T1=1goo
f=1.379f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2868ssmax&idjpijpi-20-10-20-t7TT=3600.07

f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
lass=NODES=86620lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<11.82(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

MSAT5&idjob=1598.36dev=>f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=0.58T (TCHECKS313417600lass=NODES=18607lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=47179f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0o03(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2821ssmax&idjpijpi-20-10-20-t7TT=3600.07

f=0.58T (TCHECKS31581730>lass=NODES=22277(TO) f=2T1=0.85lass=NODES=50201lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=77679f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

MSPT<0748T (TCHECKS37227840>lass=NODES=98027T (T f=2T1=0.85lass=NODES=36582dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2801ssmax&idjpijpi-20-10-20-t7TT=3600.07

f=0778T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0.58T (TCHECKS33106930>lass=NODES=43912dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0o04">MSTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

lass=NODES=82232(TO) f=2T1=0.85f=0.88T (TCHECKS35034460>lass=NODES=76630lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=4765dev=1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0o03(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2845efmax&idjpijpi-20-10-20-t7TT=3600.07

lass=NODES=92593T (T f=2T1=0.85lass=NODES=95661dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0o03(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSPT<0749T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=4746
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=5748T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<0703(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v2707efmax&idjpijpi-30-10-25-t48idev=16&idjob=11pi-30-10-197-52-22br>TT=3600.07

TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=5.59(TO)f=2T1=0.85f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=2.69T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=3734">MSTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=2T1=0.85lass=NODES=54397lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=9.19
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.711br>f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2699efmax&idjpijpi-30-10-25-t48idev=16&idjob=11pi-30-10-197-52-36br>TT=3600.07

TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
0o69T (TCHECKS34471210>lass=NODES=432839
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=772
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=5703(TO)<=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=1.88T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=4734">MSTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=0.88T (TCHECKS3104141>lass=NODES=787lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<1.66
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.51
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2688efmax&idjpijpi-30-10-25-t48idev=16&idjob=11pi-30-10-197-52-61br>TT=3600.07

f=2.18T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85lass=NODES=286639
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<11.47
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1.58 (TOf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=3759(TO)CHECKS319355700>lass=NODES=175188dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=3726T (TCHECKS31005660>lass=NODES=9726=159 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=12.1
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=77069f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<1.279f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2763efmax&idjpijpi-30-10-25-t48idev=16&idjob=11pi-30-10-197-52-88br>TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85lass=NODES=34323T (T 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=471
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=1.21br>f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<2.59(TO)f=2T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1.369f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2934efmax&idjpijpi-30-10-25-t58idev=16&idjob=11pi-30-10-197-42-15br>TT=3600.07

f=0773T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.83T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<2.25T (Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=2.03T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1017b02
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=2.38 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=15.51
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v2902efmax&idjpijpi-30-10-25-t58idev=16&idjob=11pi-30-10-197-42-18br>TT=3600.07

f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=22.5 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=18b12T (Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

MSPT<0768(TO)f=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
f=0.67 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1127.59(TO)f=2T1=0.85f=2372.98(TO)1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=4.03T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=11.44(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2887ssmax&idjpijpi-30-10-25-t58idev=16&idjob=11pi-30-10-197-42-3br>TT=3600.07

f=0.67 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=0.83T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2907749T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
PT<2573.84TT=1637.35
T1=0.851777
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2.45T (Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<0768(TO)f=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2102.1
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSPT<11.08(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2892efmax&idjpijpi-30-10-25-t58idev=16&idjob=11pi-30-10-197-42-66br>TT=3600.07

MSPT<6.52(TO)f=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">MSPT<5795TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1605.63
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=10.79dev=f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=15o04">MSTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=3.74T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
f=3765dev=1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1930.97(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=66.12dev=f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
110.31(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2598efmax&idjpijpi-40-10-08-t6TT=3600.07

f=1726T (TCHECKS36746490>lass=NODES=65246dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=1.369lass=NODES=42960lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.45T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.48T (TO)2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.12T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
1.67 (TOf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2601ssmax&idjpijpi-40-10-08-t6TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85CHECKS33715120>lass=NODES=39970lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.3
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<2.52T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1.85T (Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
MSPT<0785T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.92
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.11
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v2658efmax&idjpijpi-40-10-08-t6TT=3600.07

21728(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<217079lass=NODES=61907lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=3712
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=3742T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1.28 (TOf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=0.55T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=0o61T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.83
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=3719
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2612efmax&idjpijpi-40-10-08-t6TT=3600.07

lass=NODES=2960lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=30742T (TCHECKS3239389lass=NODES=211
=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<2.25T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<0o06">MSTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

1.16
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85lass=NODES=42970lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=3.13
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.17T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1.279f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4146ssmax&idjplanningidev=16&idjob=11depot01cc_extbr>TT=3600.07

0o67 (TOCHECKS31591
=NODES=0lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
0o67 (TOCHECKS31591
=NODES=0lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSPT<6.28(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=375T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

=NODES=7lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=0o63 (TOCHECKS3148620>lass=NODES=2212
=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.869f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.03T (TTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4122ssmax&idjplanningidev=16&idjob=11driverlog04cc_extbr>TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.82T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=14.17TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=1667754
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=10.21
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
PT<2.05dev=1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=108754(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4141efmax&idjplanningidev=16&idjob=11driverlog08cc_extbr>TT=3600.07

MSPT<54.789TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=54.649TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=1.279TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=10.77TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=1686.6
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=14.73T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=1.21
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v4180efmax&idjplanningidev=16&idjob=11driverlog09_extbr>TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=0.78 (TOCHECKS315374(TO)=NODES=11
=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=0.58 (TOCHECKS31717860>lass=NODES=13078(TO)=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=6o79 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=4.28(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.03T (TTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4186efmax&idjplanningidev=16&idjob=11mprime03cc_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=0.68 (TOCHECKS315374(TO)=NODES=11
=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=0.78 (TOCHECKS32046120>lass=NODES=19561
=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=100 class="bestresultincomplete">f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=6o32
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

0o67 (TOCHECKS315374(TO)=NODES=11
=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=0.68 (TOCHECKS31402540>lass=NODES=10640lass=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=37469f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.02T (TTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4160efmax&idjplanningidev=16&idjob=11mprime04ac_extbr>TT=3600.07

PT<2.55T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=4.83
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=2.73T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<2.57T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=4.74(TO)<=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4125efmax&idjplanningidev=16&idjob=11rovers02ac_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=1.16
CHECKS32631780>lass=NODES=2202
=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.29
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=1717 (TOCHECKS3168943>lass=NODES=99(TO)=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
PT<1.379lass=NODES=3008(TO)=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
f=0TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.32T (TTT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4163efmax&idjplanningidev=16&idjob=11zenoss=vel04ac_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=8.47(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0 class="bestresultincomplete">
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=157079lass=NODES=25376dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=16.221br>CHECKS35137960>lass=NODES=25536(TO)=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=196739 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=302758(TO)<=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=49.969f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=58.62(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v2166efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=td widthLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-100-18-15_extbr>TT=3600.07

TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">
>f=0.65dev=1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1440.52T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=32759f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
5.95T (Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=0o77T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
08(TO)PT<1027599f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=52742T (Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2142efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=td widthLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-100-18-25_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=1.021br>CHECKS33449470>lass=NODES=22841
=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">f=0.98(TO)CHECKS34101090>lass=NODES=20423(TO)=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=71o61T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=453.49">MSf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=87.73dev=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=47.48T (Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

>f=0.87T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=106.49">MSf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=246.25T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85>f=80.02T (TTT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=26.47(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2141efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=td widthLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-100-18-36_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=1.56
CHECKS34375970>lass=NODES=28000
=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">PT<1.38lass=NODES=13724T (T=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=167769">MSf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<38.869f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=31711(TO)<=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=18o59 (TOCHECKS33978560>lass=NODES=26131
=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">lass=NODES=19974T (T=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<933o67 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<147.59f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=79.4(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2140efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=td widthLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-100-18-46_extbr>TT=3600.07

f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0o77T (Tf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=150.94
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=315.95T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.51
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85P161108758(TO)PT<624.51
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=514.24T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v1914efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=td widthTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-15-10-100-93-1_extbr>TT=3600.07

TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10intd width=100 class="result">f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85P161108759(TO)PT<227.09
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=489.8T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=6.71(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
P161108758(TO)PT<283.74
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
P161108712(TO)PT<603o63 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.999f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1905efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=td widthTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-15-10-100-93-23_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0.57(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=514.7(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85P161108756dev=>f=463.28(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1.869f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=4.55(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=0.51
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=329
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=406.03T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=3.26(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v1897efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=td widthTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-15-10-100-93-47_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=0.63 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85161108713(TO)PT<295o79 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85P16110871(TO)PT<507o63 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
2.369f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2.82dev=f=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=0.58 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
P161108711(TO)PT<399.12
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=876.65dev=1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=11713(TO)f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=22.28(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v1904efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=td widthTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-15-10-100-93-8_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=0.56(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85>f=0.77(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85P161108712(TO)PT<335o79 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=451.26(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2.76(TO)<=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

>f=0.87T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=0o85T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=3.83
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.869f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=1.95(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2116efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=denshLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-30-10-25-48-15_extbr>TT=3600.07

PT<0757(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=3.32
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=27079f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2.63dev=f=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=1.14(TO)TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1718(TO)TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=2o67 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=4.049f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2.87(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2126efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=denshLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-30-10-25-48-32_extbr>TT=3600.07

0o55T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85=1621.663 (TOPT<21.51
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85=1624.2021br>PT<24.03T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85=164.944(TO)>f=1.58 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
=165.618dev=>f=5.5T (Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

CHECKS31056040>lass=NODES=9982dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
lass=NODES=28004T (T=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.852.32
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85>f=2.23T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=0o08 (TOf=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v2128efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=denshLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-30-10-25-48-39_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=0.53
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0.56(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.98TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<1.9T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85lass=NODES=572999f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85MSTT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
PT<1.17(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2130efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=denshLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-30-10-25-48-44_extbr>TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=4.379lass=NODES=65492T (T=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=16.23T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0o>9
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=0.06(TO)<=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

>f=0.87T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=0.54T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85P161108758(TO)PT<20.35
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85P161108759(TO)PT<0o73 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>fbr>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v1853efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=denshTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-25-87-21_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=0.81
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85>f=0.87T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85161108713(TO)PT<0.83
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85161108759(TO)PT<0o89T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85
fbr>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
PT<1.51(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=0767(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85P161108713(TO)PT<58.9
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85P161108713(TO)PT<0769">MSf=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">fbr>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
f=0.98TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v1867efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=denshTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-25-87-36_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0.9
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<10.34T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>fbr>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
=165.989dev=>f=4.93(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=1716(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1718(TO)TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85161108758(TO)PT<0o72
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1213.74
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.09(TO)>fbr>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v1882efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=denshTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-25-87-44_extbr>TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.39(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85161108756dev=PT<0o84T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
161108711(TO)>f=1.96(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=7751(TO)<=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
PT<0o86(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85P161108712dev=PT<1.02
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85161108758(TO)PT<1.43
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2757
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1848efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=denshTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-25-87-9_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=0o5T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.850o55T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85161108758(TO)PT<0o85T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
161108713(TO)PT<0.83
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1.78 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
>f=2.77dev=f=br>f=2f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

0o98 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85=161455.7(TO)>f=0o83(TO)CHECKS38213140>lass=NODES=84244T (T=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85=166.022dev=>f=4.29
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85=1617.054T (T>f=15.5dev=1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85=161.244(TO)>f=27079f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
=164.456dev=PT<4.35
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2032efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=sparshLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-40-10-13-60-24_extbr>TT=3600.07

0o98 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=9
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=5.21
1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
2.85T (Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=13.95(TO)f=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=4.84
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2082efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=sparshLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-60-10-8-60-1_extbr>TT=3600.07

>f=3.95(TO)CHECKS35854110lass=NODES=7659dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS31596210lass=NODES=1267(TO)=f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=77529f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=6.47 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1.379f=2TT=1607.22
T1=>
PT<10.94(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2054efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=sparshLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-70-10-7-60-1_extbr>TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85>f=10.43
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<41.58 (TOf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=10.34T (Tf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=11.17(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85=166147688dev=>f=589.2
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85=16183.963 (TOPT<136.06(TO)<=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85=16620.308dev=>f=594.76(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
=16564.24
>f=564.13(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v2002efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=sparshLooseidev=16&idjob=11v&id-80-10-6-60-8_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=7741(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=774(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=257.73
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<118.28(TO)<=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=0o88 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0o88 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85161108759(TO)PT<369.49
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.8516110871(TO)>f=502.6(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0o03(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v1955efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=sparshTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-21-85-20_extbr>TT=3600.07

TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0o68 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1046.62
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<1781.03T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<1.57(TO)<=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=1.47(TO)f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2497o85T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">PT<0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
0o03(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
>
Sugar++
v1982efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=sparshTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-21-85-27_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1606.21
1=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
>f=1.26(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=0757
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.850o66
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<555.48
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v1976efmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=sparshTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-21-85-35_extbr>TT=3600.07

0o58 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0o88 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<1194
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

0o58 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=646.69
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=927.14
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=0.04(TO)f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v1991ssmax&idjrandomMaxCSPidev=sparshTightidev=16&idjob=11v&id-25-10-21-85-48_extbr>TT=3600.07

>f=0o68 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0o63 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.8516110871(TO)>f=174.23T (TTT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=970o>9
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f=1785T (Tf=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

>f=14.7
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=13.84T (Tf=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=275
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85161108713(TO)PT<1.97
f=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">1685.917(TO)>f=5.66(TO)<=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
165.771(TO)>f=5o72
f=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v4255efmax&idjspot5idev=16&idjob=11spot5-8_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0o63 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<0(TO)>f2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

=1617.379(TO)PT<0o87(TO)CHECKS373
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS3196116dev==NODES=285T (T 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS31046951br>=NODES=138
1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=9.82
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<0.42dev=f=2
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v6098efmax&idjwarehousesidev=16&idjob=11cap103_extbr>TT=3600.07

=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
=1617.339(TO)>f=0o88 (TOCHECKS373
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS3196116dev==NODES=285T (T 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS31046951br>=NODES=138
1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=36.26(TO)f=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=0o79(TO)CHECKS373
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS3196116dev==NODES=285T (T 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS31046951br>=NODES=138
1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=34.65(TO)f=2
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=9.82
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<0.42dev=f=2
TT=1r>f=2
>
Sugar++
v6108efmax&idjwarehousesidev=16&idjob=11cap113_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=1.07(TO)CHECKS3148idev=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS34730729 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS3331410lass=NODES=1329f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
PT<342.48
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
PT<0.99(TO)CHECKS3148idev=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS34730729 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS3331410lass=NODES=1329f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
TT=1br>TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=31.379f=2TT=1607.22
T1=csp/QCP-10td width=100 class="result">f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<1.57(TO)<=2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v6117efmax&idjwarehousesidev=16&idjob=11cap44_extbr>TT=3600.07

f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS399709
=NODES=216dev==1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS356264(TO)=NODES=133dev==1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=5.81
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

PT<0.77dev=CHECKS346idev=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS399709
=NODES=216dev==1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS356264(TO)=NODES=133dev==1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
>f=14.13
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85PT<5.71 (TOf=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v6131efmax&idjwarehousesidev=16&idjob=11cap91_extbr>TT=3600.07

=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS3196116dev==NODES=285T (T 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS31046951br>=NODES=138
1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=35.9
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
f2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

0o91(TO)CHECKS373
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS3196116dev==NODES=285T (T 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS31046951br>=NODES=138
1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=35.8
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=9757
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<0.42dev=f=2
TT=1r>f=2
>
Sugar++
v6082efmax&idjwarehousesidev=16&idjob=11cap93_extbr>TT=3600.07

=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
=161.0369CHECKS3196116dev==NODES=285T (T 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
CHECKS31046951br>=NODES=138
1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=35.49
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=0(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
PT<0.41(TO)>f2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

f=15.46 (TOCHECKS31000300
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
d width=100 class="bestresultcomplete">=16233o419(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
d width=100 class="bestresultcomplete">=16226.0191br>
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2708(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=1r>f=2
T=5.983
T1=5.73
? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar++
v6084efmax&idjwarehousesidev=16&idjob=11capmo4_extbr>TT=3600.07

=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
f=15.17(TO)CHECKS31000300
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
d width=100 class="bestresultcomplete">=16226.156(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
d width=100 class="bestresultcomplete">=16230o6741br>
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
14.74(TO)>f2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=.02
TT=3600.07

PT<15.229=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=goo
=NODES=0dev= 1=br>f=2TT=1607.22
T1=
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
d width=100 class="bestresultcomplete">=16235.292

f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
d width=100 class="bestresultcomplete">=16208.7541br>
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2.18(TO)>f2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
14.74(TO)>f2
TT=1r>f=2
TT=6.201
T1=ef="solver.php?idev=16&idsolver=367">Sugar++
v6101efmax&idjwarehousesidev=16&idjob=11capmp2_extbr>TT=3600.07

PT<1879.69
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=1342.75
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
d width=100 class="bestresultcomplete">=16881.067(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
d width=100 class="bestresultcomplete">=16464.7261br>
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=28.9
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
TT=3600.07

3518.12
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.851918.02
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
d width=100 class="bestresultcomplete">=16436.861(TO)
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
d width=100 class="bestresultcomplete">=16445.1231br>
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85f=27.73
f=2
TT=1637.35
T1=0.85
<"940ef2
T=5.983
T1=5.="trace.php?idev=16&idjob=1108766">? (TO)

TT=3600.04

? (TO)

TT=3600.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
AbsconMax 112
pc-d
AbsconMax 112
pc-w
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Sugar
v1.13+minisatT=dr>
Number of times the sver.p is able to give the csp/ known answerbr>TTT=drdjogn="center">1>TTT=drdjogn="center">169< >TTT=drdjogn="center">1=11 >TTT=drdjogn="center">961 >TTT=drdjogn="center">2471 >TTT=drdjogn="center">2351 >TTT=drdjogn="center">4=11 >TTT=drdjogn="center">TTT=r>T=dr>Number of times the sver.p is able to give the csp/ known answer from an TTT=drdjogn="center">4251 >TTT=drdjogn="center">4271 >TTT=drdjogn="center">51TTT=drdjogn="center">4771 >TTT=drdjogn="center">2591 >TTT=drdjogn="center">2501 >TTT=drdjogn="center">4=11 >TTT=drdjogn="center">TTT=r>T=dr>Number of times the sver.p is the csp/ sver.p from a id width sver.p point of view (i.e.rcsp/ known answer andrcsp/ TT time)1 >TTT=drdjogn="center">211 >TTT=drdjogn="center">291 >TTT=drdjogn="center">371 >TTT=drdjogn="center">231 >TTT=drdjogn="center">311 >TTT=drdjogn="center">301 >TTT=drdjogn="center">3831 >TTT=drdjogn="center">TTT=r>T=dr>Number of times the sver.p is the csp/ sver.p from an TTT=drdjogn="center">109< >TTT=drdjogn="center">1=51 >TTT=drdjogn="center">TTT=drdjogn="center">TTT=drdjogn="center">14br>TTT=drdjogn="center">1>1 >TTT=drdjogn="center">258a >TTT=drdjogn="center">TTT/table=22