CSP 2008 Competition: results by benchmark

Results by benchmark for category binary constraints in intension (2-ARY-INT)

This page displays the results of the different solvers for each benchmark for category binary constraints in intension (2-ARY-INT)

REMINDER

Keep in mind that the 'Best result' columns only provide the best result given by one of the solvers. This 'Best result' may be wrong in case of an UNSATISFIABLE or OPTIMUM FOUND answer (because there's no efficient way to check these answers).

Description of a cell contents:

Cell exampleMeaning
AnswerSolver result
TT=...Total Time (TT): this is the CPU time (in seconds) used by the solver until termination. This time is only meaningful for complete solvers because incomplete solvers will always run until they time out
T1=...Time to get the best model (T1): this is the wall clock time (in seconds) ellapsed when the solver found its best model. This time is obtained from the 'o lines'. It is useful to compare both complete and incomplete solvers. It doesn't take into account the time to prove optimality of the solution.
Remember that CPU time and wall clock time are two very different notions. The CPU time represents the time during which the instructions of the solver were executed by the processor. The wall clock time represents how much time ellapsed on the clock. For a same event, the CPU time may be either smaller or greater than the wall clock time depending on the number of threads of execution and the number of processors.

Meaning of some abbreviations:

AbbreviationMeaning
TOTime Out
MOMem. Out (out of memory)

Meaning of the different colors:

ColorMeaning
textthe solver cannot handle this instance
textthe solver gave no answer
textthe solver gave a definitive answer (SAT or UNSAT)
textthe solver performed better than the other ones on that instance
textthe solver was ended by a signal
textthe solver gave an incomplete answer
textthe solver was disqualified in the category
textthe solver gave a wrong answer

For better readability, you may choose to hide some solvers:
Abscon 112v4 AC
Abscon 112v4 ESAC
bpsolver 2008-06-27
casper zao
casper zito
choco2_dwdeg 2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg 2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J 2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine 2008-05-30
cpHydra k_10
cpHydra k_40
galac E
galac M
MDG-noprobe 2008-06-27
MDG-probe 2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor 2008-07-04
Mistral-option 1.314
Mistral-prime 1.313
SAT4J CSP 2008-06-13
Sugar v1.13+minisat
Sugar v1.13+picosat

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/domino/
normalized-domino-1000-100.xml
SAT
TT=0.052

? (MO)
TT=0.897

SAT
TT=1.999

CHECKS=8219800
NODES=1000
SAT
TT=0.247

SAT
TT=2.452

CHECKS=396013
SAT
TT=0.188

CHECKS=362367
SAT
TT=1.486

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=1.33

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=4.175

CHECKS=607204
NODES=1000
SAT
TT=2.623

CHECKS=813003
NODES=0
SAT
TT=2.503

CHECKS=813003
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.067

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=0.065

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=102

SAT
TT=99.986

SAT
TT=0.052

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=0.057

ASSIGNMENTS=4
CHECKS=254
SAT
TT=1.003

SAT
TT=0.057

ASSIGNMENTS=99
CHECKS=1295
SAT
TT=0.056

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=10.788

SAT
TT=2.613

SAT
TT=4.09

csp/domino/
normalized-domino-1000-300.xml
SAT
TT=0.051

SAT
TT=4.121

CHECKS=165489000
NODES=1000
SAT
TT=4.216

CHECKS=165489000
NODES=1000
SAT
TT=0.283

SAT
TT=3.251

CHECKS=1678790
SAT
TT=0.786

CHECKS=1572070
SAT
TT=1.528

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=1.24

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=21.158

CHECKS=4560550
NODES=1000
SAT
TT=5.881

CHECKS=6111000
NODES=0
SAT
TT=5.853

CHECKS=6111000
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.068

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=622
SAT
TT=0.067

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=622
? (MO)
TT=788.1

? (MO)
TT=819.22

SAT
TT=0.051

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=622
SAT
TT=0.051

ASSIGNMENTS=2
CHECKS=632
SAT
TT=0.964

SAT
TT=0.057

ASSIGNMENTS=299
CHECKS=3895
SAT
TT=0.054

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=63.341

SAT
TT=3.985

SAT
TT=9.66

csp/domino/
normalized-domino-1000-800.xml
SAT
TT=0.052

SAT
TT=10.148

CHECKS=21070700
NODES=1000
SAT
TT=11.117

CHECKS=21070700
NODES=1000
SAT
TT=0.414

SAT
TT=4.678

CHECKS=4245970
SAT
TT=2.275

CHECKS=4216470
SAT
TT=1.22

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=1.568

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=82.357

CHECKS=34870200
NODES=1000
SAT
TT=22.054

CHECKS=40776000
NODES=0
SAT
TT=23.046

CHECKS=40776000
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.067

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=1622
SAT
TT=0.068

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=1622
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=0.056

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=1622
SAT
TT=0.057

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=1617
SAT
TT=1.05

SAT
TT=0.056

ASSIGNMENTS=799
CHECKS=10395
SAT
TT=0.052

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=417.584

SAT
TT=9.211

SAT
TT=23.433

csp/domino/
normalized-domino-100-100.xml
SAT
TT=0.009

SAT
TT=0.94

CHECKS=821805
NODES=100
SAT
TT=0.899

CHECKS=821805
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.045

SAT
TT=0.265

CHECKS=46790
SAT
TT=0.042

CHECKS=50761
SAT
TT=0.885

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=0.689

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=0.928

CHECKS=60904
NODES=100
SAT
TT=0.775

CHECKS=81303
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.699

CHECKS=81303
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=0.022

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=11.538

SAT
TT=10.498

SAT
TT=0.009

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=0.01

ASSIGNMENTS=2
CHECKS=234
SAT
TT=0.383

SAT
TT=0.013

ASSIGNMENTS=99
CHECKS=1295
SAT
TT=0.01

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=3.444

SAT
TT=0.828

SAT
TT=1.094

csp/domino/
normalized-domino-100-300.xml
SAT
TT=0.009

SAT
TT=1.066

CHECKS=16547500
NODES=100
SAT
TT=1.056

CHECKS=16547500
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.051

SAT
TT=0.356

CHECKS=148256
SAT
TT=0.119

CHECKS=146065
SAT
TT=0.677

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=0.665

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=2.498

CHECKS=457450
NODES=100
SAT
TT=1.035

CHECKS=611103
NODES=0
SAT
TT=1.041

CHECKS=611103
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=622
SAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=622
SAT
TT=73.72

SAT
TT=79.692

SAT
TT=0.01

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=622
SAT
TT=0.011

ASSIGNMENTS=2
CHECKS=27
SAT
TT=0.383

SAT
TT=0.009

ASSIGNMENTS=299
CHECKS=3895
SAT
TT=0.009

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=8.27

SAT
TT=1.053

SAT
TT=1.646

csp/domino/
normalized-domino-2000-2000.xml
SAT
TT=0.127

SAT
TT=95.796

CHECKS=256674000
NODES=2000
SAT
TT=101.963

CHECKS=256674000
NODES=2000
SAT
TT=1.312

SAT
TT=19.056

CHECKS=24541300
SAT
TT=9.623

CHECKS=13508000
SAT
TT=2.063

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=2.297

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=309.85

CHECKS=500240000
NODES=2000
SAT
TT=227.705

CHECKS=505892000
NODES=0
SAT
TT=238.123

CHECKS=505892000
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.135

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=4022
SAT
TT=0.133

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=4022
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=0.136

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=4022
SAT
TT=0.132

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=4017
SAT
TT=1.587

SAT
TT=0.142

ASSIGNMENTS=1999
CHECKS=25995
SAT
TT=0.127

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
?
TT=69.951

SAT
TT=45.803

SAT
TT=120.777

csp/domino/
normalized-domino-500-100.xml
SAT
TT=0.025

SAT
TT=1.276

CHECKS=4109800
NODES=500
SAT
TT=1.324

CHECKS=4109800
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.143

SAT
TT=1.307

CHECKS=226885
SAT
TT=0.121

CHECKS=218536
SAT
TT=1.345

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=1.212

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=2.319

CHECKS=303704
NODES=500
SAT
TT=1.649

CHECKS=406503
NODES=0
SAT
TT=1.614

CHECKS=406503
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=51.756

SAT
TT=48.275

SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=0.025

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=0.769

SAT
TT=0.028

ASSIGNMENTS=99
CHECKS=1295
SAT
TT=0.025

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=6.918

SAT
TT=1.568

SAT
TT=2.602

csp/domino/
normalized-domino-500-200.xml
SAT
TT=0.026

SAT
TT=1.683

CHECKS=26167200
NODES=500
SAT
TT=1.717

CHECKS=26167200
NODES=500
SAT
TT=0.132

SAT
TT=1.398

CHECKS=498405
SAT
TT=0.254

CHECKS=493533
SAT
TT=0.956

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=1.088

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=5.524

CHECKS=1064220
NODES=500
SAT
TT=2.247

CHECKS=1425000
NODES=0
SAT
TT=2.235

CHECKS=1425000
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=422
SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=422
SAT
TT=187.595

SAT
TT=182.769

SAT
TT=0.028

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=422
SAT
TT=0.031

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=0.893

SAT
TT=0.028

ASSIGNMENTS=199
CHECKS=2595
SAT
TT=0.026

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=16.147

SAT
TT=2.235

SAT
TT=3.959

csp/domino/
normalized-domino-500-500.xml
SAT
TT=0.027

SAT
TT=3.314

CHECKS=4138360
NODES=500
SAT
TT=3.355

CHECKS=4138360
NODES=500
SAT
TT=0.186

SAT
TT=1.926

CHECKS=1348840
SAT
TT=0.755

CHECKS=1320220
SAT
TT=1.197

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=1.04

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=26.181

CHECKS=6083640
NODES=500
SAT
TT=5.727

CHECKS=8152500
NODES=0
SAT
TT=5.784

CHECKS=8152500
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.04

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=1022
SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=1022
? (MO)
TT=1055.97

? (MO)
TT=1046.51

SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=1022
SAT
TT=0.029

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=1022
SAT
TT=0.757

SAT
TT=0.03

ASSIGNMENTS=499
CHECKS=6495
SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=86.609

SAT
TT=3.373

SAT
TT=7.977

csp/domino/
normalized-domino-800-100.xml
SAT
TT=0.042

SAT
TT=1.679

CHECKS=6575800
NODES=800
SAT
TT=1.681

CHECKS=6575800
NODES=800
SAT
TT=0.203

SAT
TT=2.099

CHECKS=337227
SAT
TT=0.15

CHECKS=306659
SAT
TT=1.329

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=1.33

ASSIGNMENTS=1
SAT
TT=3.538

CHECKS=485804
NODES=800
SAT
TT=2.145

CHECKS=650403
NODES=0
SAT
TT=2.228

CHECKS=650403
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.056

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=0.055

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=79.289

SAT
TT=78.386

SAT
TT=0.044

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=222
SAT
TT=1.106

SAT
TT=0.044

ASSIGNMENTS=99
CHECKS=1295
SAT
TT=0.044

ASSIGNMENTS=1
CHECKS=14
SAT
TT=9.478

SAT
TT=2.183

SAT
TT=3.658

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp01/
normalized-fapp01-0200-10.xml
SAT
TT=2.432

SAT
TT=10.236

CHECKS=509828
NODES=200
SAT
TT=10.31

CHECKS=603822
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=5.863

ASSIGNMENTS=155
SAT
TT=5.807

ASSIGNMENTS=155
SAT
TT=18.154

CHECKS=1045660
NODES=427
SAT
TT=14.224

CHECKS=23030900
NODES=6856
SAT
TT=12.099

CHECKS=3334850
NODES=591
SAT
TT=16.817

ASSIGNMENTS=200
CHECKS=509828
SAT
TT=17.103

ASSIGNMENTS=200
CHECKS=509828
? (problem)
TT=0.577

? (problem)
TT=0.579

SAT
TT=2.461

ASSIGNMENTS=418
CHECKS=35520
SAT
TT=91.132

ASSIGNMENTS=7543
CHECKS=1512450
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=2.432

ASSIGNMENTS=288
CHECKS=31525
SAT
TT=137.591

SAT
TT=149.969

SAT
TT=75.418

csp/fapp/fapp01/
normalized-fapp01-0200-2.xml
UNSAT
TT=9.95

UNSAT
TT=10.453

CHECKS=153025
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=9.95

CHECKS=153025
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

UNSAT
TT=22.344

CHECKS=9956950
NODES=2675
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=17.535

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=153025
UNSAT
TT=17.658

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=153025
? (problem)
TT=0.439

? (problem)
TT=0.454

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=160.765

UNSAT
TT=26.677

UNSAT
TT=54.013

csp/fapp/fapp01/
normalized-fapp01-0200-8.xml
SAT
TT=6.562

SAT
TT=10.894

CHECKS=616036
NODES=200
SAT
TT=10.701

CHECKS=1003130
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=6.788

ASSIGNMENTS=243
SAT
TT=6.654

ASSIGNMENTS=243
SAT
TT=20.63

CHECKS=5118480
NODES=2183
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=11.962

CHECKS=3760060
NODES=693
SAT
TT=17.05

ASSIGNMENTS=200
CHECKS=616036
SAT
TT=18.338

ASSIGNMENTS=200
CHECKS=616036
? (problem)
TT=0.492

SAT
TT=608.366

SAT
TT=13.894

ASSIGNMENTS=1904
CHECKS=286789
SAT
TT=90.181

ASSIGNMENTS=6362
CHECKS=1572420
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=6.562

ASSIGNMENTS=885
CHECKS=116262
SAT
TT=141.143

SAT
TT=145.2

SAT
TT=90.3

csp/fapp/fapp02/
normalized-fapp02-0250-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.994

UNSAT
TT=17.88

CHECKS=28617
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=17.834

CHECKS=28617
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.994

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=16.566

ASSIGNMENTS=157
UNSAT
TT=17.745

ASSIGNMENTS=157
UNSAT
TT=30.681

CHECKS=1811210
NODES=249
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=23.9

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=28617
UNSAT
TT=24.438

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=28617
? (problem)
TT=0.45

? (problem)
TT=0.577

UNSAT
TT=14.794

ASSIGNMENTS=169
CHECKS=100956
UNSAT
TT=122.36

ASSIGNMENTS=4369
CHECKS=1408090
UNSAT
TT=136.821

UNSAT
TT=486.704

ASSIGNMENTS=5748
CHECKS=4531650
UNSAT
TT=7.873

ASSIGNMENTS=86
CHECKS=37881
UNSAT
TT=247.085

UNSAT
TT=38.859

UNSAT
TT=79.722

csp/fapp/fapp02/
normalized-fapp02-0250-3.xml
SAT
TT=17.484

SAT
TT=18.558

CHECKS=5487510
NODES=660
SAT
TT=17.484

CHECKS=1608080
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=25.176

ASSIGNMENTS=660
CHECKS=5487510
SAT
TT=25.57

ASSIGNMENTS=660
CHECKS=5487510
? (problem)
TT=0.575

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=474.405

SAT
TT=341.373

SAT
TT=220.05

csp/fapp/fapp02/
normalized-fapp02-0250-9.xml
SAT
TT=13.973

SAT
TT=17.875

CHECKS=1020020
NODES=252
SAT
TT=19.367

CHECKS=3970030
NODES=252
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=15.183

ASSIGNMENTS=666
SAT
TT=16.591

ASSIGNMENTS=666
SAT
TT=33.716

CHECKS=6619340
NODES=1638
? (TO)
TT=1800

SAT
TT=30.103

CHECKS=48793800
NODES=8922
SAT
TT=24.477

ASSIGNMENTS=252
CHECKS=1020020
SAT
TT=25.014

ASSIGNMENTS=252
CHECKS=1020020
? (problem)
TT=0.44

? (problem)
TT=0.582

SAT
TT=42.657

ASSIGNMENTS=5513
CHECKS=1443140
SAT
TT=217.393

ASSIGNMENTS=11874
CHECKS=3201240
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=13.973

ASSIGNMENTS=1335
CHECKS=233024
SAT
TT=260.497

SAT
TT=403.726

SAT
TT=156.903

csp/fapp/fapp03/
normalized-fapp03-0300-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.197

UNSAT
TT=22.338

CHECKS=16362
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=21.979

CHECKS=11673
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.197

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=15.438

ASSIGNMENTS=3
UNSAT
TT=15.055

ASSIGNMENTS=3
UNSAT
TT=56.661

CHECKS=1059530
NODES=47
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=31.826

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=11673
UNSAT
TT=31.821

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=11673
? (problem)
TT=0.595

? (problem)
TT=0.479

UNSAT
TT=8.472

ASSIGNMENTS=23
CHECKS=33873
UNSAT
TT=229.247

ASSIGNMENTS=3885
CHECKS=1940160
UNSAT
TT=817.88

UNSAT
TT=829.438

ASSIGNMENTS=6060
CHECKS=5641460
UNSAT
TT=5.371

ASSIGNMENTS=27
CHECKS=10404
?
TT=380.23

UNSAT
TT=51.131

UNSAT
TT=135.899

csp/fapp/fapp03/
normalized-fapp03-0300-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=11.852

UNSAT
TT=22.239

CHECKS=45927
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=22.287

CHECKS=56387
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=11.852

ASSIGNMENTS=11
UNSAT
TT=12.14

ASSIGNMENTS=11
UNSAT
TT=50.136

CHECKS=839687
NODES=65
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=31.182

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=41775
UNSAT
TT=30.007

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=41775
? (problem)
TT=0.448

? (problem)
TT=0.447

UNSAT
TT=80.313

ASSIGNMENTS=971
CHECKS=1150040
UNSAT
TT=243.623

ASSIGNMENTS=4652
CHECKS=2271150
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=12.056

ASSIGNMENTS=138
CHECKS=69678
?
TT=335.06

UNSAT
TT=52.068

UNSAT
TT=128.538

csp/fapp/fapp03/
normalized-fapp03-0300-7.xml
SAT
TT=27.393

SAT
TT=27.393

CHECKS=27150600
NODES=2571
SAT
TT=30.406

CHECKS=27304700
NODES=2494
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=111.536

ASSIGNMENTS=5276
SAT
TT=110.592

ASSIGNMENTS=5276
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=35.432

ASSIGNMENTS=2475
CHECKS=26092700
SAT
TT=35.326

ASSIGNMENTS=2475
CHECKS=26080000
? (problem)
TT=0.596

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=363.381

ASSIGNMENTS=52421
CHECKS=21609700
SAT
TT=329.065

ASSIGNMENTS=10171
CHECKS=4564700
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

?
TT=744.49

SAT
TT=964.751

SAT
TT=385.458

csp/fapp/fapp04/
normalized-fapp04-0300-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=6.461

UNSAT
TT=21.836

CHECKS=130470
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=21.945

CHECKS=136039
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=12.871

ASSIGNMENTS=13
UNSAT
TT=12.866

ASSIGNMENTS=13
UNSAT
TT=51.153

CHECKS=1743780
NODES=223
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=30.801

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=114257
UNSAT
TT=30.949

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=114257
? (problem)
TT=0.449

? (problem)
TT=563.846

UNSAT
TT=7.907

ASSIGNMENTS=117
CHECKS=21951
UNSAT
TT=202.067

ASSIGNMENTS=4576
CHECKS=1303920
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=6.461

ASSIGNMENTS=54
CHECKS=15256
?
TT=972.788

UNSAT
TT=49.811

UNSAT
TT=120.045

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp04/
normalized-fapp04-0300-5.xml
SAT
TT=24.214

SAT
TT=24.681

CHECKS=7018200
NODES=303
SAT
TT=24.214

CHECKS=6630470
NODES=303
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=155.869

CHECKS=353973000
NODES=33652
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=32.051

ASSIGNMENTS=301
CHECKS=6292900
SAT
TT=32.802

ASSIGNMENTS=301
CHECKS=6291610
? (problem)
TT=0.449

? (problem)
TT=0.45

SAT
TT=1231.85

ASSIGNMENTS=114597
CHECKS=24795100
SAT
TT=1261.2

ASSIGNMENTS=53012
CHECKS=18772100
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=610.226

ASSIGNMENTS=37496
CHECKS=8916950
?
TT=711.431

SAT
TT=1099.34

SAT
TT=300.795

csp/fapp/fapp04/
normalized-fapp04-0300-6.xml
SAT
TT=25.935

SAT
TT=25.935

CHECKS=14061100
NODES=688
SAT
TT=26.226

CHECKS=12592000
NODES=571
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

SAT
TT=227.979

CHECKS=543836000
NODES=85583
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=33.1

ASSIGNMENTS=384
CHECKS=7942480
SAT
TT=33.052

ASSIGNMENTS=384
CHECKS=7956210
? (problem)
TT=0.574

? (problem)
TT=0.453

SAT
TT=1684.01

ASSIGNMENTS=195372
CHECKS=34426900
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=335.873

ASSIGNMENTS=19743
CHECKS=4100000
?
TT=555.881

SAT
TT=1282.26

SAT
TT=319.265

csp/fapp/fapp05/
normalized-fapp05-0350-1.xml
UNSAT
TT=22.35

UNSAT
TT=22.533

CHECKS=317504
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=22.35

CHECKS=316272
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

UNSAT
TT=107.749

CHECKS=109373000
NODES=9781
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=33.452

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=295425
UNSAT
TT=33.784

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=295425
? (problem)
TT=0.451

? (problem)
TT=0.426

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=60.562

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

?
TT=682.429

UNSAT
TT=81.134

UNSAT
TT=202.479

csp/fapp/fapp05/
normalized-fapp05-0350-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=22.549

UNSAT
TT=22.549

CHECKS=600118
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=22.79

CHECKS=623131
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=33.426

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=578297
UNSAT
TT=33.844

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=599784
? (problem)
TT=0.592

? (problem)
TT=0.582

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=53.71

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=341.936

UNSAT
TT=89.211

UNSAT
TT=196.394

csp/fapp/fapp05/
normalized-fapp05-0350-6.xml
UNSAT
TT=22.557

UNSAT
TT=22.693

CHECKS=635661
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=22.557

CHECKS=614079
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=33.041

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=593533
UNSAT
TT=32.864

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=614079
? (problem)
TT=0.417

? (problem)
TT=0.417

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=52.152

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

?
TT=361.521

UNSAT
TT=121.544

UNSAT
TT=188.846

csp/fapp/fapp06/
normalized-fapp06-0500-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=15.646

UNSAT
TT=23.35

CHECKS=68156
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=23.322

CHECKS=68156
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=22.752

ASSIGNMENTS=47
UNSAT
TT=22.765

ASSIGNMENTS=47
UNSAT
TT=108.225

CHECKS=2546970
NODES=185
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=37.967

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=68156
UNSAT
TT=38.232

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=68156
? (problem)
TT=0.448

? (problem)
TT=0.594

UNSAT
TT=53.138

ASSIGNMENTS=314
CHECKS=366433
UNSAT
TT=374.933

ASSIGNMENTS=4827
CHECKS=2086840
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=15.646

ASSIGNMENTS=32
CHECKS=26024
?
TT=411.282

UNSAT
TT=99.112

UNSAT
TT=249.105

csp/fapp/fapp06/
normalized-fapp06-0500-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=23.433

UNSAT
TT=23.654

CHECKS=499244
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=23.433

CHECKS=492091
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

UNSAT
TT=104.4

CHECKS=7144040
NODES=1644
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=35.828

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=491742
UNSAT
TT=36.06

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=491742
? (problem)
TT=0.448

? (problem)
TT=0.586

UNSAT
TT=382.551

ASSIGNMENTS=30706
CHECKS=2600560
UNSAT
TT=740.305

ASSIGNMENTS=33848
CHECKS=5772890
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=53.323

ASSIGNMENTS=1834
CHECKS=274363
?
TT=426.333

UNSAT
TT=102.18

UNSAT
TT=251.959

csp/fapp/fapp06/
normalized-fapp06-0500-9.xml
SAT
TT=32.804

SAT
TT=33.79

CHECKS=24646300
NODES=892
SAT
TT=32.804

CHECKS=24645600
NODES=890
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

SAT
TT=289.119

CHECKS=343325000
NODES=38162
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=45.115

ASSIGNMENTS=1174
CHECKS=27142700
SAT
TT=47.136

ASSIGNMENTS=1727
CHECKS=33099500
? (problem)
TT=0.481

? (problem)
TT=0.595

SAT
TT=509.265

ASSIGNMENTS=35955
CHECKS=6778100
SAT
TT=557.666

ASSIGNMENTS=15353
CHECKS=4523690
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

?
TT=1592.48

? (MO)
TT=99.772

SAT
TT=809.405

csp/fapp/fapp07/
normalized-fapp07-0600-6.xml
UNSAT
TT=17.54

UNSAT
TT=25.06

CHECKS=741026
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=25.553

CHECKS=748825
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=24.679

ASSIGNMENTS=99
UNSAT
TT=24.716

ASSIGNMENTS=99
UNSAT
TT=130.667

CHECKS=8361780
NODES=863
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=36.518

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=737757
UNSAT
TT=37.834

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=737415
? (problem)
TT=0.577

? (problem)
TT=0.582

UNSAT
TT=28.124

ASSIGNMENTS=270
CHECKS=90835
UNSAT
TT=399.943

ASSIGNMENTS=5979
CHECKS=3486390
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=17.54

ASSIGNMENTS=181
CHECKS=55218
?
TT=355.284

? (MO)
TT=102.38

UNSAT
TT=272.64

csp/fapp/fapp07/
normalized-fapp07-0600-7.xml
UNSAT
TT=15.721

UNSAT
TT=25.471

CHECKS=698967
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=25.135

CHECKS=696525
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=31.606

ASSIGNMENTS=151
UNSAT
TT=32.742

ASSIGNMENTS=151
UNSAT
TT=136.277

CHECKS=9689550
NODES=816
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=36.86

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=691651
UNSAT
TT=38.221

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=705735
? (problem)
TT=0.43

? (problem)
TT=0.441

UNSAT
TT=30.296

ASSIGNMENTS=402
CHECKS=110474
UNSAT
TT=436.946

ASSIGNMENTS=6170
CHECKS=3611270
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=15.721

ASSIGNMENTS=294
CHECKS=54575
?
TT=332.67

? (MO)
TT=104.1

UNSAT
TT=283.226

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp07/
normalized-fapp07-0600-8.xml
UNSAT
TT=22.167

UNSAT
TT=24.924

CHECKS=656562
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=25.294

CHECKS=657079
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=204.229

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=30.607

ASSIGNMENTS=159
UNSAT
TT=28.805

ASSIGNMENTS=159
UNSAT
TT=122.792

CHECKS=2948410
NODES=1378
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800

UNSAT
TT=36.212

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=651455
UNSAT
TT=36.292

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=656381
? (problem)
TT=0.426

? (problem)
TT=0.762

UNSAT
TT=32.833

ASSIGNMENTS=543
CHECKS=128330
UNSAT
TT=496.402

ASSIGNMENTS=12047
CHECKS=4689790
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=22.167

ASSIGNMENTS=342
CHECKS=81711
?
TT=312.55

? (MO)
TT=102.23

UNSAT
TT=273.56

csp/fapp/fapp08/
normalized-fapp08-0700-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=17.553

UNSAT
TT=24.495

CHECKS=29426
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=24.189

CHECKS=29478
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=596.502

CHECKS=3300580
UNSAT
TT=19.691

ASSIGNMENTS=9
UNSAT
TT=19.638

ASSIGNMENTS=9
UNSAT
TT=113.178

CHECKS=11002700
NODES=2723
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=38.89

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=29478
UNSAT
TT=38.591

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=29478
? (problem)
TT=0.437

? (problem)
TT=0.664

UNSAT
TT=71.447

ASSIGNMENTS=1142
CHECKS=275001
UNSAT
TT=302.917

ASSIGNMENTS=5728
CHECKS=1677000
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=17.553

ASSIGNMENTS=132
CHECKS=44225
?
TT=1325.6

UNSAT
TT=100.996

UNSAT
TT=229.632

csp/fapp/fapp08/
normalized-fapp08-0700-10.xml
SAT
TT=23.692

SAT
TT=32.441

CHECKS=20025900
NODES=703
SAT
TT=32.484

CHECKS=20025000
NODES=703
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=372.206

ASSIGNMENTS=27703
SAT
TT=383.751

ASSIGNMENTS=27703
SAT
TT=125.081

CHECKS=46338500
NODES=7813
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800

SAT
TT=42.518

ASSIGNMENTS=703
CHECKS=19766800
SAT
TT=41.478

ASSIGNMENTS=700
CHECKS=18990500
? (problem)
TT=0.439

? (problem)
TT=0.453

SAT
TT=23.692

ASSIGNMENTS=1604
CHECKS=196576
SAT
TT=490.187

ASSIGNMENTS=19704
CHECKS=4094470
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=70.675

ASSIGNMENTS=5427
CHECKS=696634
?
TT=792.959

? (MO)
TT=103.752

SAT
TT=760.074

csp/fapp/fapp08/
normalized-fapp08-0700-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=24.203

UNSAT
TT=24.203

CHECKS=588429
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=24.272

CHECKS=588429
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

UNSAT
TT=100.83

CHECKS=6031720
NODES=2625
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=37.012

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=588429
UNSAT
TT=35.402

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=578287
? (problem)
TT=0.464

? (problem)
TT=0.469

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=959.946

ASSIGNMENTS=142742
CHECKS=7471780
?
TT=789.127

UNSAT
TT=95.394

UNSAT
TT=230.149

csp/fapp/fapp09/
normalized-fapp09-0800-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=17.343

UNSAT
TT=26.583

CHECKS=190575
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=25.775

CHECKS=185955
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=554.413

ASSIGNMENTS=12976
UNSAT
TT=556.74

ASSIGNMENTS=12976
UNSAT
TT=120.03

CHECKS=4552890
NODES=548
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=39.85

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=184450
UNSAT
TT=41.474

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=186519
? (problem)
TT=0.427

? (problem)
TT=1195.52

UNSAT
TT=23.406

ASSIGNMENTS=438
CHECKS=104475
UNSAT
TT=651.388

ASSIGNMENTS=20150
CHECKS=6178930
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=17.343

ASSIGNMENTS=301
CHECKS=62649
?
TT=450.694

UNSAT
TT=83.881

UNSAT
TT=177.812

csp/fapp/fapp09/
normalized-fapp09-0800-4.xml
SAT
TT=32.3

SAT
TT=39.155

CHECKS=18880800
NODES=2522
SAT
TT=32.3

CHECKS=10874800
NODES=812
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=48.938

ASSIGNMENTS=1859
CHECKS=15146600
SAT
TT=42.654

ASSIGNMENTS=812
CHECKS=10874000
? (problem)
TT=0.445

? (problem)
TT=0.589

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

?
TT=1064.49

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

SAT
TT=792.038

csp/fapp/fapp09/
normalized-fapp09-0800-8.xml
SAT
TT=13.936

SAT
TT=31.464

CHECKS=12277900
NODES=801
SAT
TT=31.45

CHECKS=12300700
NODES=801
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

SAT
TT=167.178

CHECKS=64794500
NODES=12009
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=78.316

CHECKS=21014000
NODES=1674
SAT
TT=41.465

ASSIGNMENTS=802
CHECKS=12157700
SAT
TT=42.804

ASSIGNMENTS=801
CHECKS=12220200
? (problem)
TT=0.435

? (problem)
TT=0.567

SAT
TT=15.64

ASSIGNMENTS=752
CHECKS=101234
SAT
TT=364.242

ASSIGNMENTS=11623
CHECKS=2938500
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=13.936

ASSIGNMENTS=963
CHECKS=109366
?
TT=397.012

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

SAT
TT=586.213

csp/fapp/fapp10/
normalized-fapp10-0900-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.304

UNSAT
TT=26.735

CHECKS=294809
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=26.627

CHECKS=294809
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=3.304

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=150.167

ASSIGNMENTS=651
UNSAT
TT=149.17

ASSIGNMENTS=651
UNSAT
TT=152.839

CHECKS=32144200
NODES=440
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=52.773

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=293330
UNSAT
TT=51.171

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=256410
? (problem)
TT=0.439

? (problem)
TT=0.451

UNSAT
TT=177.557

ASSIGNMENTS=2088
CHECKS=491684
UNSAT
TT=592.054

ASSIGNMENTS=5422
CHECKS=2627870
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=29.405

ASSIGNMENTS=389
CHECKS=54642
?
TT=433.024

? (MO)
TT=150.14

? (MO)
TT=310.886

csp/fapp/fapp10/
normalized-fapp10-0900-10.xml
SAT
TT=52.5

SAT
TT=53.307

CHECKS=60265700
NODES=1904
SAT
TT=52.5

CHECKS=59856800
NODES=1904
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.23

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

SAT
TT=477.382

CHECKS=485069000
NODES=26005
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=58.673

ASSIGNMENTS=905
CHECKS=45853600
SAT
TT=58.811

ASSIGNMENTS=905
CHECKS=45848900
? (problem)
TT=0.44

? (problem)
TT=0.442

SAT
TT=181.421

ASSIGNMENTS=12056
CHECKS=5200560
SAT
TT=722.269

ASSIGNMENTS=10349
CHECKS=4836620
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

SAT
TT=102.871

ASSIGNMENTS=4669
CHECKS=919358
?
TT=683.331

? (MO)
TT=153.11

? (MO)
TT=339.84

csp/fapp/fapp10/
normalized-fapp10-0900-9.xml
SAT
TT=55.309

SAT
TT=67.679

CHECKS=81188700
NODES=3513
SAT
TT=55.309

CHECKS=60989000
NODES=2141
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

SAT
TT=559.3

CHECKS=572095000
NODES=40805
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=66.599

ASSIGNMENTS=1872
CHECKS=59243300
SAT
TT=66.925

ASSIGNMENTS=1872
CHECKS=59243300
? (problem)
TT=0.446

? (problem)
TT=0.647

SAT
TT=152.956

ASSIGNMENTS=5165
CHECKS=2201010
SAT
TT=1690.6

ASSIGNMENTS=128532
CHECKS=13676100
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=127.789

ASSIGNMENTS=7094
CHECKS=1087640
?
TT=350.002

? (MO)
TT=143.192

? (MO)
TT=314.53

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp11/
normalized-fapp11-1000-1.xml
UNSAT
TT=27.31

UNSAT
TT=27.31

CHECKS=1849040
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=28.086

CHECKS=1849560
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=73.245

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

UNSAT
TT=166.361

CHECKS=51643400
NODES=40
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800

UNSAT
TT=62.724

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1848430
UNSAT
TT=61.75

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1848430
? (problem)
TT=0.465

? (problem)
TT=0.617

UNSAT
TT=972.802

ASSIGNMENTS=3080
CHECKS=2271950
UNSAT
TT=673.593

ASSIGNMENTS=3412
CHECKS=2628560
UNSAT
TT=1307.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=400.487

ASSIGNMENTS=1603
CHECKS=985145
?
TT=419.901

? (MO)
TT=241.249

? (MO)
TT=403.283

csp/fapp/fapp11/
normalized-fapp11-1000-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=27.02

UNSAT
TT=27.02

CHECKS=1575160
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=27.57

CHECKS=1575160
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=335.728

ASSIGNMENTS=2471
UNSAT
TT=326.354

ASSIGNMENTS=2471
UNSAT
TT=170.873

CHECKS=62435200
NODES=193
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=59.565

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1575160
UNSAT
TT=57.745

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1574610
? (problem)
TT=0.477

? (problem)
TT=0.478

UNSAT
TT=1074.92

ASSIGNMENTS=11869
CHECKS=4164580
UNSAT
TT=713.418

ASSIGNMENTS=6147
CHECKS=2932610
UNSAT
TT=1519.42

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=172.649

ASSIGNMENTS=1228
CHECKS=580159
?
TT=582.376

? (MO)
TT=252.804

? (MO)
TT=398.339

csp/fapp/fapp11/
normalized-fapp11-1000-6.xml
UNSAT
TT=27.246

UNSAT
TT=27.955

CHECKS=1405800
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=27.246

CHECKS=1405800
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.23

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

UNSAT
TT=176.255

CHECKS=59339800
NODES=165
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=57.188

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1405100
UNSAT
TT=57.511

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1405100
? (problem)
TT=0.443

? (problem)
TT=0.478

UNSAT
TT=278.058

ASSIGNMENTS=7753
CHECKS=989157
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=1211.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=82.321

ASSIGNMENTS=1322
CHECKS=224872
?
TT=381.496

? (MO)
TT=239.755

? (MO)
TT=404.74

csp/fapp/fapp12/
normalized-fapp12-1500-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=29.357

UNSAT
TT=30.203

CHECKS=874658
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=29.357

CHECKS=874658
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.24

UNSAT
TT=231.914

CHECKS=16679400
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=240.434

CHECKS=17651900
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=278.989

CHECKS=17655400
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=85.645

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=874658
UNSAT
TT=90.468

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=874658
? (problem)
TT=0.44

? (problem)
TT=0.58

UNSAT
TT=64.884

ASSIGNMENTS=12
CHECKS=37670
UNSAT
TT=605.386

ASSIGNMENTS=1774
CHECKS=2147160
UNSAT
TT=1779.97

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=65.95

ASSIGNMENTS=12
CHECKS=37631
?
TT=709.369

?
TT=392.266

?
TT=417.99

csp/fapp/fapp12/
normalized-fapp12-1500-10.xml
SAT
TT=1072.47

SAT
TT=1072.47

CHECKS=2710230000
NODES=16896
SAT
TT=1157.62

CHECKS=2712340000
NODES=16896
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=1259.39

ASSIGNMENTS=18052
CHECKS=3099210000
SAT
TT=1275.33

ASSIGNMENTS=18799
CHECKS=3106840000
? (problem)
TT=0.594

? (problem)
TT=0.574

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=543.885

?
TT=422.086

?
TT=419.488

csp/fapp/fapp12/
normalized-fapp12-1500-9.xml
SAT
TT=203.296

SAT
TT=285.524

CHECKS=561995000
NODES=9933
SAT
TT=267.255

CHECKS=561970000
NODES=9933
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=317.161

ASSIGNMENTS=12620
CHECKS=576084000
SAT
TT=312.075

ASSIGNMENTS=12620
CHECKS=576079000
? (problem)
TT=0.454

? (problem)
TT=0.445

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

?
TT=733.303

?
TT=422.452

?
TT=420.96

csp/fapp/fapp13/
normalized-fapp13-2000-4.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.23

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (problem)
TT=0.474

? (problem)
TT=0.6

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

?
TT=310.908

?
TT=366.346

?
TT=378.384

csp/fapp/fapp13/
normalized-fapp13-2000-6.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1831.68

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.24

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (problem)
TT=0.468

? (problem)
TT=0.422

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

?
TT=1239.51

?
TT=368.87

?
TT=376.978

csp/fapp/fapp13/
normalized-fapp13-2000-9.xml
SAT
TT=53.788

SAT
TT=59.144

CHECKS=61518000
NODES=3329
SAT
TT=53.788

CHECKS=48414900
NODES=2020
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.23

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1775.88

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=75.251

ASSIGNMENTS=3331
CHECKS=61480900
SAT
TT=65.478

ASSIGNMENTS=2024
CHECKS=47763000
? (problem)
TT=0.436

? (problem)
TT=0.762

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

?
TT=1213.35

?
TT=362.158

?
TT=381.569

csp/fapp/fapp14/
normalized-fapp14-2500-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=35.704

UNSAT
TT=36.02

CHECKS=404591
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=35.704

CHECKS=404591
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

UNSAT
TT=395.794

CHECKS=606433
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=519.522

CHECKS=1637490
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=484.704

CHECKS=1560980
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=139.001

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=395664
UNSAT
TT=142.868

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=404591
? (problem)
TT=0.419

? (problem)
TT=0.413

UNSAT
TT=326.024

ASSIGNMENTS=598
CHECKS=421741
UNSAT
TT=711.483

ASSIGNMENTS=1682
CHECKS=1890210
UNSAT
TT=43.461

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=210.401

ASSIGNMENTS=335
CHECKS=208866
?
TT=420.712

?
TT=527.789

?
TT=528.564

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp14/
normalized-fapp14-2500-2.xml
UNSAT
TT=36.864

UNSAT
TT=36.864

CHECKS=2491180
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=37.132

CHECKS=2491180
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.23

UNSAT
TT=412.396

CHECKS=9720230
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=490.118

CHECKS=10197700
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=508.549

CHECKS=10193900
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=123.261

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2482640
UNSAT
TT=117.641

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2491180
? (problem)
TT=0.457

? (problem)
TT=0.582

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=692.919

ASSIGNMENTS=2523
CHECKS=1881240
UNSAT
TT=50.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

?
TT=396.977

?
TT=550.442

?
TT=489.221

csp/fapp/fapp14/
normalized-fapp14-2500-9.xml
SAT
TT=415.716

SAT
TT=511.534

CHECKS=1141320000
NODES=22541
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.24

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=1010.77

ASSIGNMENTS=47660
CHECKS=1953880000
SAT
TT=415.716

ASSIGNMENTS=14255
CHECKS=721391000
? (problem)
TT=0.453

? (problem)
TT=0.45

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

Wrong UNSAT
TT=47.336

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=372.957

?
TT=503.614

?
TT=493.271

csp/fapp/fapp15/
normalized-fapp15-3000-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=30.699

UNSAT
TT=31.476

CHECKS=213034
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=30.699

CHECKS=212940
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=48.158

ASSIGNMENTS=1008
UNSAT
TT=51.503

ASSIGNMENTS=1008
UNSAT
TT=320.189

CHECKS=12299900
NODES=179
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=66.712

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=212940
UNSAT
TT=68.555

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=212940
? (problem)
TT=0.442

? (problem)
TT=0.446

UNSAT
TT=31.577

ASSIGNMENTS=8
CHECKS=66823
UNSAT
TT=608.69

ASSIGNMENTS=6569
CHECKS=4567700
UNSAT
TT=34.071

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

UNSAT
TT=36.603

ASSIGNMENTS=8
CHECKS=66823
?
TT=309.894

?
TT=346.959

?
TT=335.57

csp/fapp/fapp15/
normalized-fapp15-3000-2.xml
UNSAT
TT=31.212

UNSAT
TT=31.212

CHECKS=1107370
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=31.309

CHECKS=1107370
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=85.662

ASSIGNMENTS=2612
UNSAT
TT=85.119

ASSIGNMENTS=2612
UNSAT
TT=441.841

CHECKS=22740100
NODES=3343
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=57.954

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1107370
UNSAT
TT=56.087

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1107370
? (problem)
TT=0.576

? (problem)
TT=0.576

UNSAT
TT=454.018

ASSIGNMENTS=10523
CHECKS=2428640
UNSAT
TT=889.156

ASSIGNMENTS=22811
CHECKS=7818960
UNSAT
TT=33.958

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=712.028

ASSIGNMENTS=12845
CHECKS=3537120
?
TT=1214.88

?
TT=572.235

?
TT=333.034

csp/fapp/fapp15/
normalized-fapp15-3000-8.xml
SAT
TT=68.918

SAT
TT=181.505

CHECKS=322191000
NODES=10241
SAT
TT=68.918

CHECKS=88376000
NODES=3497
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=91.724

ASSIGNMENTS=3497
CHECKS=88172100
SAT
TT=93.619

ASSIGNMENTS=3497
CHECKS=88237200
? (problem)
TT=0.569

? (problem)
TT=0.428

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

Wrong UNSAT
TT=34.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

?
TT=1404.61

?
TT=347.811

?
TT=361.929

csp/fapp/fapp16/
normalized-fapp16-0260-10.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.069

UNSAT
TT=21.563

CHECKS=51072
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=21.594

CHECKS=51072
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.069

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=15.949

ASSIGNMENTS=65
UNSAT
TT=15.837

ASSIGNMENTS=65
UNSAT
TT=55.52

CHECKS=2165850
NODES=59
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=32.488

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=47493
UNSAT
TT=32.58

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=47493
? (problem)
TT=0.587

? (problem)
TT=0.576

UNSAT
TT=11.632

ASSIGNMENTS=99
CHECKS=93134
UNSAT
TT=114.758

ASSIGNMENTS=3962
CHECKS=1359710
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=1241.66

ASSIGNMENTS=10476
CHECKS=5170210
UNSAT
TT=14.349

ASSIGNMENTS=384
CHECKS=119497
?
TT=422.768

UNSAT
TT=41.63

UNSAT
TT=93.829

csp/fapp/fapp16/
normalized-fapp16-0260-7.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.006

UNSAT
TT=21.359

CHECKS=49074
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=21.528

CHECKS=50858
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.006

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=14.998

ASSIGNMENTS=69
UNSAT
TT=16.024

ASSIGNMENTS=69
UNSAT
TT=54.658

CHECKS=2355760
NODES=69
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=33.038

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=50849
UNSAT
TT=33.117

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=49074
? (problem)
TT=0.584

? (problem)
TT=0.59

UNSAT
TT=23.197

ASSIGNMENTS=470
CHECKS=326090
UNSAT
TT=123.051

ASSIGNMENTS=4071
CHECKS=1365400
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=1097.03

ASSIGNMENTS=9960
CHECKS=4920140
UNSAT
TT=12.284

ASSIGNMENTS=176
CHECKS=90470
?
TT=404.459

UNSAT
TT=42.087

UNSAT
TT=92.441

csp/fapp/fapp16/
normalized-fapp16-0260-8.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.081

UNSAT
TT=21.559

CHECKS=53030
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=21.701

CHECKS=53636
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.081

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=15.848

ASSIGNMENTS=65
UNSAT
TT=14.684

ASSIGNMENTS=65
UNSAT
TT=53.528

CHECKS=2358290
NODES=69
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=32.279

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=49070
UNSAT
TT=33.866

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=49067
? (problem)
TT=0.415

? (problem)
TT=0.463

UNSAT
TT=20.728

ASSIGNMENTS=352
CHECKS=274473
UNSAT
TT=139.603

ASSIGNMENTS=3972
CHECKS=1572330
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=1092.67

ASSIGNMENTS=9960
CHECKS=4947720
UNSAT
TT=10.399

ASSIGNMENTS=96
CHECKS=76869
? (TO)
TT=1802.2

UNSAT
TT=43.937

UNSAT
TT=82.112

csp/fapp/fapp17/
normalized-fapp17-0300-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.011

UNSAT
TT=20.755

CHECKS=91335
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=20.838

CHECKS=91335
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.011

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=21.103

ASSIGNMENTS=95
UNSAT
TT=19.571

ASSIGNMENTS=95
UNSAT
TT=59.031

CHECKS=4995480
NODES=398
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=31.769

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=91335
UNSAT
TT=31.654

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=91335
? (problem)
TT=0.423

? (problem)
TT=0.439

UNSAT
TT=12.363

ASSIGNMENTS=77
CHECKS=23445
UNSAT
TT=183.765

ASSIGNMENTS=4732
CHECKS=1105530
UNSAT
TT=898.862

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=24.167

ASSIGNMENTS=338
CHECKS=94211
?
TT=419.923

UNSAT
TT=58.927

UNSAT
TT=142.304

csp/fapp/fapp17/
normalized-fapp17-0300-1.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.013

UNSAT
TT=19.249

CHECKS=91331
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=20.811

CHECKS=91331
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.013

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=21.398

ASSIGNMENTS=95
UNSAT
TT=19.652

ASSIGNMENTS=95
UNSAT
TT=57.554

CHECKS=4994020
NODES=398
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=32.007

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=91331
UNSAT
TT=34.141

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=91331
? (problem)
TT=0.455

? (problem)
TT=0.456

UNSAT
TT=12.145

ASSIGNMENTS=77
CHECKS=23445
UNSAT
TT=160.65

ASSIGNMENTS=4547
CHECKS=1040410
UNSAT
TT=917.655

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=23.858

ASSIGNMENTS=338
CHECKS=94211
?
TT=920.708

UNSAT
TT=55.407

UNSAT
TT=143.989

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp17/
normalized-fapp17-0300-4.xml
SAT
TT=1.134

SAT
TT=22.126

CHECKS=302678
NODES=300
SAT
TT=21.971

CHECKS=305981
NODES=300
SAT
TT=1.134

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=18.151

ASSIGNMENTS=272
SAT
TT=16.797

ASSIGNMENTS=272
SAT
TT=68.009

CHECKS=16731500
NODES=1799
SAT
TT=35.236

CHECKS=15266600
NODES=1357
SAT
TT=38.107

CHECKS=10937800
NODES=583
SAT
TT=34.539

ASSIGNMENTS=300
CHECKS=315911
SAT
TT=34.927

ASSIGNMENTS=300
CHECKS=315956
? (problem)
TT=0.405

? (problem)
TT=0.555

SAT
TT=12.661

ASSIGNMENTS=286
CHECKS=38159
SAT
TT=171.907

ASSIGNMENTS=4747
CHECKS=1035010
Wrong UNSAT
TT=853.934

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=10.313

ASSIGNMENTS=271
CHECKS=31361
?
TT=461.054

SAT
TT=167.822

SAT
TT=204.387

csp/fapp/fapp18/
normalized-fapp18-0350-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.973

UNSAT
TT=21.283

CHECKS=65039
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=21.308

CHECKS=65039
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.973

UNSAT
TT=38.737

CHECKS=9957
UNSAT
TT=0.373

CHECKS=9957
UNSAT
TT=11.97

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=12.87

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=58.963

CHECKS=259247
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=30.011

CHECKS=679649
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=27.881

CHECKS=679649
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=6.408

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
UNSAT
TT=6.556

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
? (problem)
TT=0.455

? (problem)
TT=0.421

UNSAT
TT=7.062

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
UNSAT
TT=6.194

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
UNSAT
TT=22.812

UNSAT
TT=6.421

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
UNSAT
TT=6.244

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
?
TT=411.35

UNSAT
TT=56.572

UNSAT
TT=140.927

csp/fapp/fapp18/
normalized-fapp18-0350-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.988

UNSAT
TT=21.48

CHECKS=63301
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=21.488

CHECKS=63150
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.988

UNSAT
TT=39.185

CHECKS=9957
UNSAT
TT=0.369

CHECKS=9957
UNSAT
TT=13.172

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=13.502

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=55.159

CHECKS=259245
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=30.882

CHECKS=679643
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=31.433

CHECKS=679643
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=5.966

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
UNSAT
TT=6.34

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
? (problem)
TT=0.585

? (problem)
TT=0.581

UNSAT
TT=6.363

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
UNSAT
TT=6.133

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
UNSAT
TT=23.456

UNSAT
TT=6.597

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
UNSAT
TT=5.691

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6154
?
TT=470.907

UNSAT
TT=55.806

UNSAT
TT=140.446

csp/fapp/fapp18/
normalized-fapp18-0350-6.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.971

UNSAT
TT=21.418

CHECKS=134009
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=21.594

CHECKS=132621
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.971

UNSAT
TT=36.352

CHECKS=10711
UNSAT
TT=0.343

CHECKS=10711
UNSAT
TT=12.978

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=13.065

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=58.935

CHECKS=683027
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=29.804

CHECKS=1075860
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=29.589

CHECKS=1075860
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=6.256

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6137
UNSAT
TT=6.273

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6137
? (problem)
TT=0.581

? (problem)
TT=0.585

UNSAT
TT=5.668

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6137
UNSAT
TT=6.991

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6137
UNSAT
TT=23.185

UNSAT
TT=6.193

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6137
UNSAT
TT=6.413

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6137
?
TT=1383.54

UNSAT
TT=64.856

UNSAT
TT=145.995

csp/fapp/fapp19/
normalized-fapp19-0350-2.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.689

UNSAT
TT=22.885

CHECKS=248605
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=23.244

CHECKS=248605
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.689

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=108.259

ASSIGNMENTS=583
UNSAT
TT=106.51

ASSIGNMENTS=583
UNSAT
TT=128.879

CHECKS=795836
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=97.596

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=152696
UNSAT
TT=95.646

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=254715
? (problem)
TT=0.441

? (problem)
TT=0.438

UNSAT
TT=324.262

ASSIGNMENTS=4437
CHECKS=707543
UNSAT
TT=684.497

ASSIGNMENTS=1893
CHECKS=869014
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=222.408

ASSIGNMENTS=549
CHECKS=274864
?
TT=0.954

? (MO)
TT=197.15

? (MO)
TT=386.272

csp/fapp/fapp19/
normalized-fapp19-0350-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.862

UNSAT
TT=23.073

CHECKS=293799
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=23.18

CHECKS=293799
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.862

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=279.07

ASSIGNMENTS=2633
UNSAT
TT=280.456

ASSIGNMENTS=2633
UNSAT
TT=128.579

CHECKS=1096120
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=243.057

CHECKS=1606350
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=247.093

CHECKS=1606350
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=87.679

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=188151
UNSAT
TT=94.098

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=188151
? (problem)
TT=0.424

? (problem)
TT=0.605

UNSAT
TT=286.537

ASSIGNMENTS=839
CHECKS=621954
UNSAT
TT=1302.46

ASSIGNMENTS=5329
CHECKS=2748710
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=222.171

ASSIGNMENTS=547
CHECKS=351327
?
TT=0.935

? (MO)
TT=212.96

? (MO)
TT=381.058

csp/fapp/fapp19/
normalized-fapp19-0350-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.728

UNSAT
TT=23.213

CHECKS=386572
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=23.148

CHECKS=386572
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.728

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=94.51

ASSIGNMENTS=298
UNSAT
TT=94.861

ASSIGNMENTS=298
UNSAT
TT=150.343

CHECKS=73714100
NODES=252
UNSAT
TT=241.099

CHECKS=4041050
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=244.381

CHECKS=4041050
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=96.684

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=249898
UNSAT
TT=91.105

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=249898
? (problem)
TT=0.584

? (problem)
TT=0.448

UNSAT
TT=87.336

ASSIGNMENTS=108
CHECKS=27049
UNSAT
TT=893.216

ASSIGNMENTS=2372
CHECKS=1473200
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=134.572

ASSIGNMENTS=334
CHECKS=106947
?
TT=0.971

? (MO)
TT=210.35

? (MO)
TT=385.14

csp/fapp/fapp20/
normalized-fapp20-0420-2.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.369

UNSAT
TT=21.615

CHECKS=60344
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=21.527

CHECKS=59798
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.369

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=44.071

ASSIGNMENTS=1829
UNSAT
TT=44.008

ASSIGNMENTS=1829
UNSAT
TT=69.526

CHECKS=4254880
NODES=663
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=35.9

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54328
UNSAT
TT=35.991

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54328
? (problem)
TT=0.432

? (problem)
TT=0.435

UNSAT
TT=107.867

ASSIGNMENTS=1987
CHECKS=581188
UNSAT
TT=193.11

ASSIGNMENTS=5371
CHECKS=1008910
UNSAT
TT=203.473

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=28.35

ASSIGNMENTS=550
CHECKS=111797
?
TT=721.253

UNSAT
TT=62.43

UNSAT
TT=146.504

csp/fapp/fapp20/
normalized-fapp20-0420-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.393

UNSAT
TT=22.038

CHECKS=67595
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=22.232

CHECKS=65881
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.393

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=27.558

ASSIGNMENTS=505
UNSAT
TT=28.19

ASSIGNMENTS=505
UNSAT
TT=118.597

CHECKS=125876000
NODES=13745
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=37.455

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=67596
UNSAT
TT=36.997

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=67596
? (problem)
TT=0.449

? (problem)
TT=0.446

UNSAT
TT=39.581

ASSIGNMENTS=950
CHECKS=223724
UNSAT
TT=194.094

ASSIGNMENTS=5360
CHECKS=1012520
UNSAT
TT=189.766

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=30.332

ASSIGNMENTS=550
CHECKS=112545
?
TT=1618.41

UNSAT
TT=70.78

UNSAT
TT=147.679

csp/fapp/fapp20/
normalized-fapp20-0420-7.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.381

UNSAT
TT=22.103

CHECKS=65375
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=22.282

CHECKS=65456
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.381

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=27.652

ASSIGNMENTS=505
UNSAT
TT=27.448

ASSIGNMENTS=505
UNSAT
TT=153.205

CHECKS=160636000
NODES=29569
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=35.674

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=65375
UNSAT
TT=35.325

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=65375
? (problem)
TT=0.577

? (problem)
TT=570.706

UNSAT
TT=38.386

ASSIGNMENTS=950
CHECKS=224836
UNSAT
TT=197.162

ASSIGNMENTS=5452
CHECKS=1036320
UNSAT
TT=201.245

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=28.013

ASSIGNMENTS=550
CHECKS=112829
?
TT=397.754

UNSAT
TT=69.452

UNSAT
TT=159.796

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp21/
normalized-fapp21-0500-5.xml
SAT
TT=21.768

SAT
TT=21.768

CHECKS=823489
NODES=500
SAT
TT=21.81

CHECKS=869253
NODES=500
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=31.783

ASSIGNMENTS=500
CHECKS=766860
SAT
TT=32.239

ASSIGNMENTS=500
CHECKS=766860
? (problem)
TT=0.567

? (problem)
TT=0.578

SAT
TT=691.923

ASSIGNMENTS=61905
CHECKS=2821430
SAT
TT=281.516

ASSIGNMENTS=29345
CHECKS=1340370
Wrong UNSAT
TT=120.356

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

?
TT=810.244

SAT
TT=288.792

SAT
TT=261.691

csp/fapp/fapp21/
normalized-fapp21-0500-6.xml
SAT
TT=21.607

SAT
TT=21.783

CHECKS=942290
NODES=500
SAT
TT=21.607

CHECKS=784456
NODES=500
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=1001.56

ASSIGNMENTS=140929
SAT
TT=1078.84

ASSIGNMENTS=140929
SAT
TT=1177.32

CHECKS=2774580000
NODES=751487
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=33.342

ASSIGNMENTS=500
CHECKS=874935
SAT
TT=33.801

ASSIGNMENTS=500
CHECKS=990034
? (problem)
TT=0.495

? (problem)
TT=0.424

SAT
TT=1256.21

ASSIGNMENTS=207460
CHECKS=8804110
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

Wrong UNSAT
TT=119.565

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

?
TT=976.221

SAT
TT=246.303

SAT
TT=265.678

csp/fapp/fapp21/
normalized-fapp21-0500-7.xml
SAT
TT=21.749

SAT
TT=21.792

CHECKS=921553
NODES=500
SAT
TT=21.749

CHECKS=919013
NODES=500
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

SAT
TT=1414.1

CHECKS=4269480000
NODES=902415
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=33.464

ASSIGNMENTS=500
CHECKS=963800
SAT
TT=32.737

ASSIGNMENTS=500
CHECKS=936460
? (problem)
TT=0.436

? (problem)
TT=0.442

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

Wrong UNSAT
TT=111.471

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=504.034

ASSIGNMENTS=58130
CHECKS=2347850
?
TT=363.875

SAT
TT=288.646

SAT
TT=278.277

csp/fapp/fapp22/
normalized-fapp22-1750-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=8.748

UNSAT
TT=30.706

CHECKS=338746
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=30.098

CHECKS=363035
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=8.748

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=125.171

ASSIGNMENTS=369
UNSAT
TT=115.127

ASSIGNMENTS=369
UNSAT
TT=277.861

CHECKS=641601
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=452.141

CHECKS=810381
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=482.188

CHECKS=820657
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=400.568

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=358632
UNSAT
TT=427.376

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=358632
? (problem)
TT=0.438

? (problem)
TT=0.61

UNSAT
TT=539.767

ASSIGNMENTS=227
CHECKS=196084
UNSAT
TT=724.406

ASSIGNMENTS=705
CHECKS=382894
UNSAT
TT=32.519

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=537.68

ASSIGNMENTS=2831
CHECKS=464931
?
TT=0.766

?
TT=742.814

?
TT=743.495

csp/fapp/fapp22/
normalized-fapp22-1750-10.xml
SAT
TT=36.294

SAT
TT=36.294

CHECKS=9267580
NODES=1750
SAT
TT=37.143

CHECKS=9269920
NODES=1750
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

SAT
TT=284.899

CHECKS=9578020
NODES=1750
SAT
TT=547.877

CHECKS=10370900
NODES=648
SAT
TT=566.175

CHECKS=16506800
NODES=637
SAT
TT=435.138

ASSIGNMENTS=1750
CHECKS=9260380
SAT
TT=428.45

ASSIGNMENTS=1750
CHECKS=9278020
? (problem)
TT=0.616

? (problem)
TT=0.464

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=1473.8

ASSIGNMENTS=191233
CHECKS=8365990
Wrong UNSAT
TT=32.969

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

?
TT=0.837

?
TT=774.726

?
TT=763.005

csp/fapp/fapp22/
normalized-fapp22-1750-6.xml
UNSAT
TT=8.738

UNSAT
TT=31.483

CHECKS=59746
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=30.624

CHECKS=59746
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=8.738

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=213.607

ASSIGNMENTS=2209
UNSAT
TT=214.049

ASSIGNMENTS=2209
UNSAT
TT=277.725

CHECKS=500339
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=466.028

CHECKS=514137
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=471.184

CHECKS=514653
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=426.269

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=41031
UNSAT
TT=427.928

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=41543
? (problem)
TT=0.45

? (problem)
TT=0.58

UNSAT
TT=779.036

ASSIGNMENTS=2489
CHECKS=1156160
UNSAT
TT=907.015

ASSIGNMENTS=2291
CHECKS=686609
UNSAT
TT=30.794

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=486.689

ASSIGNMENTS=722
CHECKS=322011
?
TT=0.811

?
TT=773.311

?
TT=808.599

csp/fapp/fapp23/
normalized-fapp23-1800-2.xml
UNSAT
TT=17.562

UNSAT
TT=35.173

CHECKS=786088
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=34.952

CHECKS=786103
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=17.562

UNSAT
TT=73.771

CHECKS=7518540
UNSAT
TT=36.681

CHECKS=927696
UNSAT
TT=55.691

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=58.451

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=754.128

CHECKS=474485
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=906.285

CHECKS=552627
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=832.556

CHECKS=552627
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=132.27

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=190727
UNSAT
TT=138.349

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=190727
? (problem)
TT=0.581

? (problem)
TT=0.46

UNSAT
TT=129.965

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=190727
UNSAT
TT=136.312

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=190727
UNSAT
TT=66.606

UNSAT
TT=125.19

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=190727
UNSAT
TT=130.063

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=190727
? (TO)
TT=1802.17

?
TT=509.517

?
TT=477.864

csp/fapp/fapp23/
normalized-fapp23-1800-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=17.811

UNSAT
TT=36.028

CHECKS=789237
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=36.778

CHECKS=785308
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=17.811

UNSAT
TT=70.821

CHECKS=5701440
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=56.033

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=51.334

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=730.741

CHECKS=473717
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=875

? (TO)
TT=882.95

UNSAT
TT=140.563

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=324708
UNSAT
TT=130.487

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=324708
? (problem)
TT=0.474

? (problem)
TT=0.608

UNSAT
TT=139.764

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=324708
UNSAT
TT=137.658

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=324708
UNSAT
TT=66.293

UNSAT
TT=134.018

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=324708
UNSAT
TT=140.555

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=324708
?
TT=416.965

?
TT=529.713

?
TT=512.545

csp/fapp/fapp23/
normalized-fapp23-1800-9.xml
SAT
TT=37.915

SAT
TT=37.915

CHECKS=2321360
NODES=1800
SAT
TT=38.618

CHECKS=2329420
NODES=1800
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=59.94

ASSIGNMENTS=1340
SAT
TT=59.89

ASSIGNMENTS=1340
SAT
TT=761.868

CHECKS=2372230
NODES=1800
? (TO)
TT=980.3

? (TO)
TT=952.74

SAT
TT=191.556

ASSIGNMENTS=1800
CHECKS=2326670
SAT
TT=179.606

ASSIGNMENTS=1800
CHECKS=2336430
? (problem)
TT=0.595

? (problem)
TT=0.451

SAT
TT=144.161

ASSIGNMENTS=905
CHECKS=621531
SAT
TT=145.513

ASSIGNMENTS=13058
CHECKS=2142790
Wrong UNSAT
TT=65.625

SAT
TT=169.489

ASSIGNMENTS=60573
CHECKS=13090500
SAT
TT=144.34

ASSIGNMENTS=940
CHECKS=623561
?
TT=451.994

?
TT=505.105

?
TT=531.543

csp/fapp/fapp24/
normalized-fapp24-2000-1.xml
UNSAT
TT=8.112

UNSAT
TT=24.96

CHECKS=94159
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=25.152

CHECKS=103650
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=8.112

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=47.33

ASSIGNMENTS=671
UNSAT
TT=42.964

ASSIGNMENTS=671
UNSAT
TT=343.002

CHECKS=54381600
NODES=250
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=93.669

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=82101
UNSAT
TT=91.937

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=82101
? (problem)
TT=0.459

? (problem)
TT=0.458

UNSAT
TT=354.321

ASSIGNMENTS=846
CHECKS=598265
UNSAT
TT=754.375

ASSIGNMENTS=4873
CHECKS=2510490
UNSAT
TT=1679.91

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=134.205

ASSIGNMENTS=217
CHECKS=167969
?
TT=417.218

?
TT=495.533

?
TT=467.545

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp24/
normalized-fapp24-2000-2.xml
UNSAT
TT=8.719

UNSAT
TT=25.9

CHECKS=111735
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=25.73

CHECKS=111735
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=8.719

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=47.472

ASSIGNMENTS=671
UNSAT
TT=43.067

ASSIGNMENTS=671
UNSAT
TT=286.592

CHECKS=32991100
NODES=52
UNSAT
TT=212.19

CHECKS=3103200
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=210.045

CHECKS=3103200
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=94.077

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=111735
UNSAT
TT=102.138

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=111735
? (problem)
TT=0.425

? (problem)
TT=0.585

UNSAT
TT=368.102

ASSIGNMENTS=846
CHECKS=598265
UNSAT
TT=747.201

ASSIGNMENTS=5147
CHECKS=2615680
UNSAT
TT=1714.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=138.172

ASSIGNMENTS=217
CHECKS=167969
?
TT=1467.21

?
TT=445.024

?
TT=465.473

csp/fapp/fapp24/
normalized-fapp24-2000-7.xml
SAT
TT=28.33

SAT
TT=29.043

CHECKS=2575070
NODES=2000
SAT
TT=28.33

CHECKS=2558380
NODES=2000
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=49.554

ASSIGNMENTS=4053
SAT
TT=46.636

ASSIGNMENTS=4053
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=104.063

ASSIGNMENTS=2000
CHECKS=2561810
SAT
TT=101.984

ASSIGNMENTS=2000
CHECKS=2560820
? (problem)
TT=0.57

? (problem)
TT=0.585

SAT
TT=101.11

ASSIGNMENTS=2556
CHECKS=258446
SAT
TT=631.069

ASSIGNMENTS=8488
CHECKS=2431550
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=107.598

ASSIGNMENTS=1823
CHECKS=246767
?
TT=402.076

?
TT=466.298

?
TT=478.093

csp/fapp/fapp25/
normalized-fapp25-2230-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=5.062

UNSAT
TT=24.543

CHECKS=165883
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=24.544

CHECKS=165883
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=5.062

UNSAT
TT=45.292

CHECKS=2047800
UNSAT
TT=5.273

CHECKS=630863
UNSAT
TT=34.78

ASSIGNMENTS=1
UNSAT
TT=34.055

ASSIGNMENTS=1
UNSAT
TT=167.68

CHECKS=8547990
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=107.745

CHECKS=9708830
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=114.509

CHECKS=9708830
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=56.577

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54523
UNSAT
TT=53.984

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54523
? (problem)
TT=0.583

? (problem)
TT=593.591

UNSAT
TT=54.314

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54523
UNSAT
TT=51.959

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54523
UNSAT
TT=20.957

UNSAT
TT=54.751

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54523
UNSAT
TT=54.638

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54523
?
TT=366.207

?
TT=463.682

?
TT=466.788

csp/fapp/fapp25/
normalized-fapp25-2230-2.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.998

UNSAT
TT=25.224

CHECKS=2052920
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=25.621

CHECKS=2110580
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.998

UNSAT
TT=44.331

CHECKS=216868
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=35.136

ASSIGNMENTS=48
UNSAT
TT=35.05

ASSIGNMENTS=48
UNSAT
TT=177.675

CHECKS=8665700
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=126.137

CHECKS=9660360
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=125.132

CHECKS=9660360
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=54.665

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54202
UNSAT
TT=57.469

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54202
? (problem)
TT=0.579

? (problem)
TT=0.471

UNSAT
TT=54.537

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54202
UNSAT
TT=51.008

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54202
UNSAT
TT=20.847

UNSAT
TT=51.091

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54202
UNSAT
TT=54.301

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=54202
?
TT=349.054

?
TT=457.193

?
TT=433.716

csp/fapp/fapp25/
normalized-fapp25-2230-4.xml
SAT
TT=28.939

SAT
TT=29.277

CHECKS=7810920
NODES=2230
SAT
TT=28.939

CHECKS=7802130
NODES=2230
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

SAT
TT=235.441

CHECKS=25144900
NODES=4618
SAT
TT=134.668

CHECKS=25797700
NODES=4914
SAT
TT=140.858

CHECKS=34505200
NODES=855
SAT
TT=95.523

ASSIGNMENTS=2230
CHECKS=7810180
SAT
TT=95.437

ASSIGNMENTS=2230
CHECKS=7805720
? (problem)
TT=0.413

? (problem)
TT=0.555

SAT
TT=55.985

ASSIGNMENTS=3545
CHECKS=275397
SAT
TT=71.274

ASSIGNMENTS=26109
CHECKS=1488000
Wrong UNSAT
TT=20.904

SAT
TT=465.272

ASSIGNMENTS=694510
CHECKS=45718700
SAT
TT=55.854

ASSIGNMENTS=2346
CHECKS=243533
?
TT=366.45

?
TT=466.208

?
TT=455.422

csp/fapp/fapp26/
normalized-fapp26-2300-10.xml
SAT
TT=29.892

SAT
TT=30.414

CHECKS=3766720
NODES=2300
SAT
TT=29.892

CHECKS=3769220
NODES=2300
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.23

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=94.759

ASSIGNMENTS=2300
CHECKS=3768070
SAT
TT=90.139

ASSIGNMENTS=2300
CHECKS=3765790
? (problem)
TT=0.601

? (problem)
TT=0.455

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

Wrong UNSAT
TT=26.594

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=393.935

?
TT=496.837

?
TT=468.886

csp/fapp/fapp26/
normalized-fapp26-2300-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=7.495

UNSAT
TT=26.587

CHECKS=937741
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=26.638

CHECKS=937741
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=7.495

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

UNSAT
TT=261.956

CHECKS=91372200
NODES=429
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=91.773

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=942312
UNSAT
TT=87.006

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=939296
? (problem)
TT=0.448

? (problem)
TT=0.583

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=965.585

ASSIGNMENTS=15568
CHECKS=3699280
UNSAT
TT=28.322

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=1398.76

ASSIGNMENTS=27298
CHECKS=4234850
?
TT=408.171

?
TT=486.433

?
TT=510.094

csp/fapp/fapp26/
normalized-fapp26-2300-8.xml
SAT
TT=29.51

SAT
TT=29.51

CHECKS=3539790
NODES=2300
SAT
TT=29.718

CHECKS=3539380
NODES=2300
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.25

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=93.375

ASSIGNMENTS=2300
CHECKS=3538920
SAT
TT=97.408

ASSIGNMENTS=2300
CHECKS=3535360
? (problem)
TT=0.479

? (problem)
TT=0.445

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

Wrong UNSAT
TT=24.802

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

?
TT=977.753

?
TT=479.309

?
TT=492.849

csp/fapp/fapp27/
normalized-fapp27-2550-10.xml
SAT
TT=31.712

SAT
TT=33.639

CHECKS=22271500
NODES=2550
SAT
TT=31.712

CHECKS=21932400
NODES=2550
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.23

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=60.143

ASSIGNMENTS=2550
CHECKS=22253300
SAT
TT=60.227

ASSIGNMENTS=2550
CHECKS=21987800
? (problem)
TT=461.33

? (problem)
TT=0.429

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

Wrong UNSAT
TT=11.57

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

?
TT=390.855

?
TT=420.66

?
TT=416.07

csp/fapp/fapp27/
normalized-fapp27-2550-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=22.787

UNSAT
TT=22.787

CHECKS=535609
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=22.953

CHECKS=555096
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.24

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=49.999

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=535609
UNSAT
TT=49.305

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=535609
? (problem)
TT=0.593

? (problem)
TT=0.424

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=10.636

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=229.25

ASSIGNMENTS=30980
CHECKS=1036290
?
TT=408.839

?
TT=429.206

?
TT=417.567

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp27/
normalized-fapp27-2550-7.xml
SAT
TT=32

SAT
TT=32.065

CHECKS=20475000
NODES=2551
SAT
TT=32

CHECKS=20473500
NODES=2551
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=55.632

ASSIGNMENTS=2551
CHECKS=20035700
SAT
TT=57.052

ASSIGNMENTS=2551
CHECKS=20009300
? (problem)
TT=0.469

? (problem)
TT=0.644

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

Wrong UNSAT
TT=11.269

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

?
TT=1039.28

?
TT=444.608

?
TT=402.845

csp/fapp/fapp28/
normalized-fapp28-2800-10.xml
SAT
TT=48.941

SAT
TT=50.723

CHECKS=43944400
NODES=2802
SAT
TT=48.941

CHECKS=43941100
NODES=2802
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.24

SAT
TT=286.491

CHECKS=50975500
NODES=2801
SAT
TT=460.014

CHECKS=80877800
NODES=153231
SAT
TT=436.837

CHECKS=58829700
NODES=1070
SAT
TT=518.374

ASSIGNMENTS=2802
CHECKS=43958800
SAT
TT=485.414

ASSIGNMENTS=2802
CHECKS=43953300
? (problem)
TT=0.598

? (problem)
TT=0.441

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

Wrong UNSAT
TT=29.337

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

?
TT=0.886

?
TT=1131.99

?
TT=1040.2

csp/fapp/fapp28/
normalized-fapp28-2800-5.xml
SAT
TT=44.85

SAT
TT=44.85

CHECKS=35049200
NODES=2800
SAT
TT=47.72

CHECKS=35048600
NODES=2800
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.27

SAT
TT=297.094

CHECKS=38833600
NODES=2800
SAT
TT=1410.51

CHECKS=1211510000
NODES=1803300
SAT
TT=430.371

CHECKS=45067000
NODES=691
SAT
TT=544.549

ASSIGNMENTS=2800
CHECKS=35062900
SAT
TT=527.457

ASSIGNMENTS=2800
CHECKS=35049200
? (problem)
TT=0.432

? (problem)
TT=0.568

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

Wrong UNSAT
TT=30.927

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

?
TT=0.854

?
TT=1046.79

?
TT=1044

csp/fapp/fapp28/
normalized-fapp28-2800-6.xml
SAT
TT=45.953

SAT
TT=45.953

CHECKS=36212400
NODES=2800
SAT
TT=48.489

CHECKS=36217300
NODES=2800
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.24

? (TO)
TT=1800.24

SAT
TT=293.697

CHECKS=39743100
NODES=2801
SAT
TT=613.664

CHECKS=264288000
NODES=302500
SAT
TT=427.841

CHECKS=45241900
NODES=659
SAT
TT=482.583

ASSIGNMENTS=2800
CHECKS=36222800
SAT
TT=483.318

ASSIGNMENTS=2800
CHECKS=36231600
? (problem)
TT=0.443

? (problem)
TT=0.444

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

Wrong UNSAT
TT=25.145

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

?
TT=0.932

?
TT=1028.1

?
TT=1115.1

csp/fapp/fapp29/
normalized-fapp29-2900-1.xml
UNSAT
TT=16.226

UNSAT
TT=39.921

CHECKS=1188900
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=37.981

CHECKS=1190080
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=16.226

UNSAT
TT=76.26

CHECKS=117301
UNSAT
TT=42.512

CHECKS=117301
UNSAT
TT=93.607

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=90.935

ASSIGNMENTS=0
?
TT=714.378

? (TO)
TT=952.83

? (TO)
TT=1010.3

UNSAT
TT=221.877

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=26170
UNSAT
TT=244.713

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=26170
? (problem)
TT=0.428

? (problem)
TT=0.421

UNSAT
TT=226.761

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=26170
UNSAT
TT=239.994

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=26170
UNSAT
TT=325.531

UNSAT
TT=239.708

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=26170
UNSAT
TT=223.055

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=26170
?
TT=0.912

?
TT=911.879

?
TT=795.601

csp/fapp/fapp29/
normalized-fapp29-2900-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=17.532

UNSAT
TT=40.638

CHECKS=2048040
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=40.168

CHECKS=2048040
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=17.532

UNSAT
TT=72.784

CHECKS=117297
UNSAT
TT=42.846

CHECKS=117297
UNSAT
TT=87.982

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=94.417

ASSIGNMENTS=0
?
TT=768.348

? (TO)
TT=920.09

? (TO)
TT=946.14

UNSAT
TT=293.2

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=38032
UNSAT
TT=319.38

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=38032
? (problem)
TT=0.603

? (problem)
TT=0.444

UNSAT
TT=323.441

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=38032
UNSAT
TT=315.465

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=38032
UNSAT
TT=304.592

UNSAT
TT=323.136

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=38032
UNSAT
TT=311.213

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=38032
?
TT=0.929

?
TT=788.517

?
TT=820.753

csp/fapp/fapp29/
normalized-fapp29-2900-6.xml
SAT
TT=21.955

SAT
TT=50.606

CHECKS=6359000
NODES=2900
SAT
TT=44.593

CHECKS=6358640
NODES=2900
SAT
TT=21.955

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=132.748

ASSIGNMENTS=2827
SAT
TT=132.813

ASSIGNMENTS=2827
?
TT=754.325

? (TO)
TT=951.79

? (TO)
TT=992.92

SAT
TT=498.622

ASSIGNMENTS=2900
CHECKS=6357900
SAT
TT=521.161

ASSIGNMENTS=2900
CHECKS=6362330
? (problem)
TT=0.445

? (problem)
TT=0.614

SAT
TT=452.93

ASSIGNMENTS=155
CHECKS=222572
SAT
TT=449.827

ASSIGNMENTS=154
CHECKS=219120
Wrong UNSAT
TT=285.232

SAT
TT=425.697

ASSIGNMENTS=157
CHECKS=222872
SAT
TT=446.85

ASSIGNMENTS=155
CHECKS=222444
?
TT=0.922

?
TT=837.81

?
TT=807.714

csp/fapp/fapp30/
normalized-fapp30-3000-10.xml
SAT
TT=91.177

SAT
TT=91.177

CHECKS=104858000
NODES=3000
SAT
TT=98.724

CHECKS=105023000
NODES=3000
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.28

?
TT=987.488

? (TO)
TT=1163.41

? (TO)
TT=1238.81

SAT
TT=1180.74

ASSIGNMENTS=3000
CHECKS=104798000
SAT
TT=1091.79

ASSIGNMENTS=3000
CHECKS=104799000
? (problem)
TT=0.572

? (problem)
TT=0.593

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

?
TT=0.776

?
TT=910.013

?
TT=843.061

csp/fapp/fapp30/
normalized-fapp30-3000-1.xml
UNSAT
TT=18.269

UNSAT
TT=40.692

CHECKS=47789
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=39.769

CHECKS=47789
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=18.269

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

UNSAT
TT=177.905

ASSIGNMENTS=4363
UNSAT
TT=191.342

ASSIGNMENTS=4363
?
TT=877.318

? (TO)
TT=1140.86

? (TO)
TT=1138.28

UNSAT
TT=1100.95

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=47789
UNSAT
TT=1113.73

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=47789
? (problem)
TT=0.453

? (problem)
TT=0.56

UNSAT
TT=1431.04

ASSIGNMENTS=8780
CHECKS=747186
UNSAT
TT=1692.08

ASSIGNMENTS=7497
CHECKS=823907
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

UNSAT
TT=1120.55

ASSIGNMENTS=377
CHECKS=92375
?
TT=0.832

?
TT=818.266

?
TT=869.335

csp/fapp/fapp30/
normalized-fapp30-3000-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=17.117

UNSAT
TT=41.005

CHECKS=48778
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=38.854

CHECKS=48778
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=17.117

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

?
TT=976.085

? (TO)
TT=1163.6

? (TO)
TT=1174.72

UNSAT
TT=1049.16

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=48778
UNSAT
TT=1010.52

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=48778
? (problem)
TT=0.419

? (problem)
TT=0.422

UNSAT
TT=1080.59

ASSIGNMENTS=3948
CHECKS=263741
UNSAT
TT=1377.81

ASSIGNMENTS=3571
CHECKS=417217
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=1502.04

ASSIGNMENTS=16829
CHECKS=625821
?
TT=0.808

?
TT=818.379

?
TT=827.101

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp31/
normalized-fapp31-0400-6.xml
SAT
TT=114.448

SAT
TT=114.448

CHECKS=229439000
NODES=579
SAT
TT=127.651

CHECKS=230468000
NODES=579
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=161.351

ASSIGNMENTS=579
CHECKS=228646000
SAT
TT=179.55

ASSIGNMENTS=579
CHECKS=229454000
? (problem)
TT=0.58

? (problem)
TT=0.613

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

Wrong UNSAT
TT=4.134

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=0.797

SAT
TT=617.477

SAT
TT=409.6

csp/fapp/fapp31/
normalized-fapp31-0400-7.xml
SAT
TT=152.754

SAT
TT=156.682

CHECKS=302419000
NODES=575
SAT
TT=152.754

CHECKS=302419000
NODES=575
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

SAT
TT=904.917

CHECKS=2185220000
NODES=65763
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=192.196

ASSIGNMENTS=575
CHECKS=300834000
SAT
TT=194.882

ASSIGNMENTS=575
CHECKS=301073000
? (problem)
TT=0.624

? (problem)
TT=0.577

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

Wrong UNSAT
TT=4.479

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

?
TT=0.805

SAT
TT=579.433

SAT
TT=398.674

csp/fapp/fapp31/
normalized-fapp31-0400-9.xml
SAT
TT=144.181

SAT
TT=144.181

CHECKS=306631000
NODES=568
SAT
TT=152.23

CHECKS=307282000
NODES=568
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

SAT
TT=1421.48

CHECKS=3851390000
NODES=70800
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=204.111

ASSIGNMENTS=568
CHECKS=306239000
SAT
TT=207.736

ASSIGNMENTS=568
CHECKS=306633000
? (problem)
TT=0.445

? (problem)
TT=0.44

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

Wrong UNSAT
TT=4.162

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

?
TT=0.828

SAT
TT=741.89

SAT
TT=381.123

csp/fapp/fapp32/
normalized-fapp32-0550-1.xml
UNSAT
TT=26.171

UNSAT
TT=26.171

CHECKS=1919080
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=26.53

CHECKS=1919080
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=1195.83

ASSIGNMENTS=1390
UNSAT
TT=1217.44

ASSIGNMENTS=1390
UNSAT
TT=142.982

CHECKS=3078800
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=375.427

CHECKS=2556630
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=363.848

CHECKS=3513850
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=265.908

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1919080
UNSAT
TT=255.441

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1919080
? (problem)
TT=0.573

? (problem)
TT=0.448

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=1730

ASSIGNMENTS=5424
CHECKS=2205760
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

?
TT=0.824

? (MO)
TT=562.416

? (MO)
TT=692.399

csp/fapp/fapp32/
normalized-fapp32-0550-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=26.545

? (MO)
TT=23.035

UNSAT
TT=26.545

CHECKS=1883380
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.25

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

UNSAT
TT=144.292

CHECKS=4251520
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=363.068

CHECKS=4236640
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=354.252

CHECKS=3600670
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=242.32

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1883380
UNSAT
TT=258.359

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1883380
? (problem)
TT=0.439

? (problem)
TT=0.579

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=1289.1

ASSIGNMENTS=4527
CHECKS=1489190
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=1036.62

ASSIGNMENTS=2140
CHECKS=1134710
?
TT=0.793

? (MO)
TT=531.079

? (MO)
TT=690.526

csp/fapp/fapp32/
normalized-fapp32-0550-8.xml
SAT
TT=35.15

SAT
TT=36.019

CHECKS=12106500
NODES=551
SAT
TT=35.15

CHECKS=12112700
NODES=551
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

SAT
TT=151.439

CHECKS=17679100
NODES=554
SAT
TT=457.722

CHECKS=152098000
NODES=150918
SAT
TT=388.623

CHECKS=22713700
NODES=668
SAT
TT=277.661

ASSIGNMENTS=551
CHECKS=12112700
SAT
TT=268.753

ASSIGNMENTS=551
CHECKS=12114300
? (problem)
TT=0.445

? (problem)
TT=0.436

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=1514.18

ASSIGNMENTS=2362
CHECKS=5683680
?
TT=0.783

? (MO)
TT=527.318

? (MO)
TT=694.381

csp/fapp/fapp33/
normalized-fapp33-0650-10.xml
SAT
TT=29.653

SAT
TT=30.027

CHECKS=6981000
NODES=654
SAT
TT=29.653

CHECKS=6981430
NODES=654
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.25

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=70.342

ASSIGNMENTS=654
CHECKS=6946900
SAT
TT=71.3

ASSIGNMENTS=654
CHECKS=6946900
? (problem)
TT=0.592

? (problem)
TT=0.609

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

?
TT=550.293

? (MO)
TT=200.797

? (MO)
TT=357.3

csp/fapp/fapp33/
normalized-fapp33-0650-1.xml
UNSAT
TT=24.591

UNSAT
TT=24.591

CHECKS=220301
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=24.872

CHECKS=220301
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=34.845

ASSIGNMENTS=5
UNSAT
TT=35.138

ASSIGNMENTS=5
UNSAT
TT=136.03

CHECKS=8149610
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=69.722

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=213883
UNSAT
TT=68.755

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=220301
? (problem)
TT=0.418

? (problem)
TT=0.451

UNSAT
TT=45.868

ASSIGNMENTS=18
CHECKS=26979
UNSAT
TT=608.018

ASSIGNMENTS=3194
CHECKS=1274760
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=1084.05

ASSIGNMENTS=3983
CHECKS=1627930
UNSAT
TT=44.133

ASSIGNMENTS=16
CHECKS=20734
?
TT=460.955

? (MO)
TT=200.734

? (MO)
TT=383.63

csp/fapp/fapp33/
normalized-fapp33-0650-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=24.612

UNSAT
TT=24.612

CHECKS=248366
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=24.813

CHECKS=248366
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=37.213

ASSIGNMENTS=7
UNSAT
TT=38.212

ASSIGNMENTS=7
UNSAT
TT=133.771

CHECKS=387255
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=67.906

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=241982
UNSAT
TT=69.713

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=241982
? (problem)
TT=0.451

? (problem)
TT=0.444

UNSAT
TT=45.508

ASSIGNMENTS=15
CHECKS=22813
UNSAT
TT=617.786

ASSIGNMENTS=3388
CHECKS=1405470
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=49.646

ASSIGNMENTS=19
CHECKS=26436
?
TT=491.717

? (MO)
TT=202.436

? (MO)
TT=366.05

csp/fapp/fapp34/
normalized-fapp34-0750-0.xml
UNSAT
TT=25.167

UNSAT
TT=25.25

CHECKS=1302480
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=25.167

CHECKS=1302480
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.24

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

UNSAT
TT=134.837

CHECKS=3003690
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=279.219

CHECKS=6352610
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=264.31

CHECKS=7989820
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=80.426

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1302730
UNSAT
TT=80.94

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1302730
? (problem)
TT=0.411

? (problem)
TT=0.417

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=1564.58

ASSIGNMENTS=8694
CHECKS=2552100
UNSAT
TT=348.781

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=667.905

ASSIGNMENTS=3105
CHECKS=793840
?
TT=0.882

? (MO)
TT=241.225

? (MO)
TT=440.5

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp34/
normalized-fapp34-0750-4.xml
SAT
TT=28.645

SAT
TT=28.645

CHECKS=6429710
NODES=750
SAT
TT=28.742

CHECKS=6438840
NODES=750
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.23

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

SAT
TT=165.003

CHECKS=29706100
NODES=3962
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=87.985

ASSIGNMENTS=750
CHECKS=6428720
SAT
TT=85.857

ASSIGNMENTS=750
CHECKS=6436050
? (problem)
TT=0.602

? (problem)
TT=0.615

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

Wrong UNSAT
TT=260.887

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

?
TT=0.889

? (MO)
TT=221.313

? (MO)
TT=401.417

csp/fapp/fapp34/
normalized-fapp34-0750-9.xml
SAT
TT=29.225

SAT
TT=29.225

CHECKS=8902030
NODES=750
SAT
TT=29.551

CHECKS=8895260
NODES=750
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.23

SAT
TT=186.057

CHECKS=32468800
NODES=6256
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=278.749

CHECKS=43815600
NODES=1687
SAT
TT=85.078

ASSIGNMENTS=750
CHECKS=8889800
SAT
TT=85.356

ASSIGNMENTS=750
CHECKS=8889800
? (problem)
TT=0.446

? (problem)
TT=0.438

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

?
TT=0.964

? (MO)
TT=239.79

? (MO)
TT=456.4

csp/fapp/fapp35/
normalized-fapp35-1500-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=30.412

UNSAT
TT=30.412

CHECKS=2478420
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=30.712

CHECKS=2478420
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

UNSAT
TT=203.113

CHECKS=1200720
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=412.047

CHECKS=1186700
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=391.828

CHECKS=1161650
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=259.656

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2478420
UNSAT
TT=255.162

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2478420
? (problem)
TT=0.608

? (problem)
TT=0.459

UNSAT
TT=343.365

ASSIGNMENTS=229
CHECKS=87697
UNSAT
TT=677.568

ASSIGNMENTS=616
CHECKS=421825
UNSAT
TT=21.632

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=302.701

ASSIGNMENTS=195
CHECKS=66144
?
TT=0.805

?
TT=735.109

?
TT=733.884

csp/fapp/fapp35/
normalized-fapp35-1500-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=31.037

UNSAT
TT=31.037

CHECKS=2524260
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=31.715

CHECKS=2524260
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

UNSAT
TT=211.536

CHECKS=1316600
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=413.796

CHECKS=1304870
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=399.291

CHECKS=1304870
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=264.383

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2524260
UNSAT
TT=266.303

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2524260
? (problem)
TT=0.451

? (problem)
TT=0.584

UNSAT
TT=347.358

ASSIGNMENTS=240
CHECKS=88267
UNSAT
TT=681.319

ASSIGNMENTS=661
CHECKS=428201
UNSAT
TT=25.526

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=287.93

ASSIGNMENTS=191
CHECKS=64053
?
TT=0.802

?
TT=784.025

?
TT=730.874

csp/fapp/fapp35/
normalized-fapp35-1500-9.xml
SAT
TT=57.031

SAT
TT=57.031

CHECKS=24395000
NODES=1501
SAT
TT=60.335

CHECKS=24392600
NODES=1501
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

SAT
TT=231.84

CHECKS=33922200
NODES=1876
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=286.862

ASSIGNMENTS=1501
CHECKS=24395300
SAT
TT=273.515

ASSIGNMENTS=1501
CHECKS=24395000
? (problem)
TT=0.446

? (problem)
TT=0.615

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

Wrong UNSAT
TT=21.426

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

?
TT=0.794

?
TT=764.841

?
TT=684.25

csp/fapp/fapp36/
normalized-fapp36-2000-10.xml
SAT
TT=37.094

SAT
TT=37.564

CHECKS=17354000
NODES=2000
SAT
TT=37.094

CHECKS=17360800
NODES=2000
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=120.927

ASSIGNMENTS=2000
CHECKS=17345800
SAT
TT=124.545

ASSIGNMENTS=2000
CHECKS=17345300
? (problem)
TT=0.418

? (problem)
TT=0.425

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

Wrong UNSAT
TT=19.576

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=375.224

?
TT=614.382

?
TT=585.416

csp/fapp/fapp36/
normalized-fapp36-2000-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=28.107

UNSAT
TT=28.447

CHECKS=207354
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=28.107

CHECKS=207354
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=37.464

ASSIGNMENTS=5
UNSAT
TT=36.65

ASSIGNMENTS=5
UNSAT
TT=174.756

CHECKS=4089450
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=291.136

CHECKS=17144300
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=108.585

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=207354
UNSAT
TT=119.976

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=207354
? (problem)
TT=0.435

? (problem)
TT=0.496

UNSAT
TT=89.366

ASSIGNMENTS=17
CHECKS=30812
UNSAT
TT=630.425

ASSIGNMENTS=3383
CHECKS=928660
UNSAT
TT=19.133

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=94.624

ASSIGNMENTS=32
CHECKS=37244
?
TT=956.804

?
TT=585.986

?
TT=573.289

csp/fapp/fapp36/
normalized-fapp36-2000-6.xml
UNSAT
TT=27.624

UNSAT
TT=27.624

CHECKS=238659
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=28.216

CHECKS=238659
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.33

? (TO)
TT=1800.24

UNSAT
TT=174.048

CHECKS=562760
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=328.866

CHECKS=22787100
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=117.808

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=238659
UNSAT
TT=112.278

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=238659
? (problem)
TT=0.46

? (problem)
TT=0.608

UNSAT
TT=443.232

ASSIGNMENTS=2958
CHECKS=577185
UNSAT
TT=844.615

ASSIGNMENTS=6423
CHECKS=1531920
UNSAT
TT=18.756

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=300.343

ASSIGNMENTS=1979
CHECKS=333547
?
TT=663.424

?
TT=588.021

?
TT=564.982

csp/fapp/fapp37/
normalized-fapp37-2250-1.xml
UNSAT
TT=41.15

UNSAT
TT=41.15

CHECKS=786436
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=41.313

CHECKS=786436
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (problem)
TT=112.465

? (problem)
TT=113.737

?
TT=367.849

? (TO)
TT=627.61

? (TO)
TT=633.44

UNSAT
TT=757.197

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=786436
UNSAT
TT=812.561

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=786436
? (problem)
TT=0.582

? (problem)
TT=0.571

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=57.955

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

?
TT=0.877

?
TT=1149.87

?
TT=1032.15

csp/fapp/fapp37/
normalized-fapp37-2250-2.xml
UNSAT
TT=40.887

UNSAT
TT=40.887

CHECKS=2118760
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=42.066

CHECKS=2118760
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (problem)
TT=106.672

? (problem)
TT=112.78

?
TT=354.792

? (TO)
TT=623.6

? (TO)
TT=623.68

UNSAT
TT=810.812

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2118760
UNSAT
TT=848.84

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2118760
? (problem)
TT=0.612

? (problem)
TT=0.452

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=69.247

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

?
TT=0.893

?
TT=1030.02

?
TT=1008.11

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/fapp/fapp37/
normalized-fapp37-2250-5.xml
SAT
TT=55.601

SAT
TT=56.291

CHECKS=25166200
NODES=2250
SAT
TT=55.601

CHECKS=25166200
NODES=2250
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (problem)
TT=105.752

? (problem)
TT=112.517

?
TT=356.214

? (TO)
TT=639.96

? (TO)
TT=620.82

SAT
TT=749.923

ASSIGNMENTS=2250
CHECKS=25166900
SAT
TT=823.952

ASSIGNMENTS=2250
CHECKS=25166900
? (problem)
TT=0.444

? (problem)
TT=0.626

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

Wrong UNSAT
TT=68.303

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

?
TT=0.873

?
TT=1078.06

?
TT=1005.04

csp/fapp/fapp38/
normalized-fapp38-2500-3.xml
SAT
TT=66.206

SAT
TT=66.206

CHECKS=38549700
NODES=2501
SAT
TT=71.951

CHECKS=38554200
NODES=2501
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (problem)
TT=92.479

? (problem)
TT=91.332

?
TT=790.689

? (TO)
TT=1065.71

? (TO)
TT=1029.53

SAT
TT=711.004

ASSIGNMENTS=2501
CHECKS=38540000
SAT
TT=753.005

ASSIGNMENTS=2501
CHECKS=38541700
? (problem)
TT=0.572

? (problem)
TT=0.624

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

?
TT=0.82

?
TT=658.63

?
TT=747.462

csp/fapp/fapp38/
normalized-fapp38-2500-6.xml
SAT
TT=70.038

SAT
TT=70.038

CHECKS=45327900
NODES=2505
? (MO)
TT=34.824

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (problem)
TT=86.399

? (problem)
TT=89.067

?
TT=797.293

? (TO)
TT=1080.63

? (TO)
TT=1046.45

SAT
TT=709.557

ASSIGNMENTS=2505
CHECKS=45314300
SAT
TT=694.741

ASSIGNMENTS=2505
CHECKS=45302200
? (problem)
TT=0.585

? (problem)
TT=0.602

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

?
TT=0.794

?
TT=701.589

?
TT=717.556

csp/fapp/fapp38/
normalized-fapp38-2500-9.xml
SAT
TT=75.16

SAT
TT=78.65

CHECKS=60950000
NODES=4587
SAT
TT=75.16

CHECKS=60940400
NODES=4587
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (problem)
TT=85.237

? (problem)
TT=89.252

?
TT=878.564

? (TO)
TT=1047.53

? (TO)
TT=1051.27

SAT
TT=671.41

ASSIGNMENTS=4587
CHECKS=60942100
SAT
TT=679.306

ASSIGNMENTS=4587
CHECKS=60942100
? (problem)
TT=0.448

? (problem)
TT=0.624

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

?
TT=0.768

?
TT=715.233

?
TT=672.465

csp/fapp/fapp39/
normalized-fapp39-2750-5.xml
SAT
TT=1265

SAT
TT=1355.76

CHECKS=2545130000
NODES=3810
SAT
TT=1426.19

CHECKS=2544800000
NODES=3810
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=1295.94

ASSIGNMENTS=3810
CHECKS=2540110000
SAT
TT=1265

ASSIGNMENTS=3810
CHECKS=2540100000
? (problem)
TT=0.428

? (problem)
TT=0.421

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

Wrong UNSAT
TT=25.894

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

?
TT=0.776

?
TT=664.648

?
TT=647.761

csp/fapp/fapp39/
normalized-fapp39-2750-6.xml
SAT
TT=1499.85

SAT
TT=1661.98

CHECKS=3090810000
NODES=4101
SAT
TT=1738.17

CHECKS=3090650000
NODES=4101
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.24

? (TO)
TT=1800.28

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=1499.85

ASSIGNMENTS=4101
CHECKS=3080200000
SAT
TT=1579.99

ASSIGNMENTS=4101
CHECKS=3080430000
? (problem)
TT=0.47

? (problem)
TT=0.601

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

Wrong UNSAT
TT=24.912

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

?
TT=0.816

?
TT=643.626

?
TT=650.326

csp/fapp/fapp39/
normalized-fapp39-2750-9.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (problem)
TT=0.552

? (problem)
TT=0.45

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=24.914

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

?
TT=0.803

?
TT=622.692

?
TT=646.443

csp/fapp/fapp40/
normalized-fapp40-3000-2.xml
UNSAT
TT=43.006

UNSAT
TT=44.349

CHECKS=4768650
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=43.006

CHECKS=4768650
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (problem)
TT=83.419

? (problem)
TT=77.724

?
TT=664.799

? (TO)
TT=843.74

? (TO)
TT=844.28

UNSAT
TT=692.994

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4768650
UNSAT
TT=686.689

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4768650
? (problem)
TT=0.458

? (problem)
TT=0.451

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=56.632

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

?
TT=0.812

?
TT=650.389

?
TT=655.208

csp/fapp/fapp40/
normalized-fapp40-3000-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=44.642

UNSAT
TT=44.642

CHECKS=4570620
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=44.88

CHECKS=4570620
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (problem)
TT=89.69

? (problem)
TT=84.367

?
TT=572.058

? (TO)
TT=866.23

? (TO)
TT=854.51

UNSAT
TT=645.201

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4570620
UNSAT
TT=625.197

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4570620
? (problem)
TT=0.422

? (problem)
TT=0.422

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=60.008

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

?
TT=0.815

?
TT=640.526

?
TT=611.91

csp/fapp/fapp40/
normalized-fapp40-3000-7.xml
SAT
TT=72.287

SAT
TT=78.214

CHECKS=61172000
NODES=3004
SAT
TT=72.287

CHECKS=61181600
NODES=3004
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (problem)
TT=83.158

? (problem)
TT=76.663

?
TT=587.281

? (TO)
TT=887.26

? (TO)
TT=825.86

SAT
TT=651.993

ASSIGNMENTS=3004
CHECKS=61192800
SAT
TT=684.029

ASSIGNMENTS=3004
CHECKS=61181600
? (problem)
TT=0.451

? (problem)
TT=0.458

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

Wrong UNSAT
TT=56.881

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

?
TT=0.839

?
TT=694.72

?
TT=612.659

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/
hos/
normalized-abb313GPIA-10.xml
SAT
TT=2.59

SAT
TT=25.714

CHECKS=3719600
NODES=10698
SAT
TT=31.269

CHECKS=3809820
NODES=9861
SAT
TT=10.871

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

SAT
TT=136.865

ASSIGNMENTS=1508
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=2.59

ASSIGNMENTS=1575
CHECKS=331753
SAT
TT=2.752

ASSIGNMENTS=1575
CHECKS=331753
SAT
TT=68.61

SAT
TT=59.885

SAT
TT=2.636

ASSIGNMENTS=1279
CHECKS=163978
SAT
TT=6.002

ASSIGNMENTS=45060
CHECKS=4140570
SAT
TT=24.594

SAT
TT=4.22

ASSIGNMENTS=13694
CHECKS=1809400
SAT
TT=2.811

ASSIGNMENTS=3634
CHECKS=876273
SAT
TT=27.322

SAT
TT=22.223

SAT
TT=27.426

csp/graphColoring/
hos/
normalized-abb313GPIA-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=2.494

UNSAT
TT=20.153

CHECKS=20
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=20.854

CHECKS=20
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=11.089

UNSAT
TT=58.284

CHECKS=56794500
UNSAT
TT=67.999

CHECKS=64664100
UNSAT
TT=30.083

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=27.748

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=2.568

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=131
UNSAT
TT=2.494

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=131
UNSAT
TT=36.349

UNSAT
TT=34.794

UNSAT
TT=2.704

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=131
UNSAT
TT=2.67

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=131
UNSAT
TT=12.79

UNSAT
TT=2.667

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=131
UNSAT
TT=2.704

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=131
UNSAT
TT=12.359

UNSAT
TT=13.946

UNSAT
TT=19.494

csp/graphColoring/
hos/
normalized-abb313GPIA-9.xml
SAT
TT=10.017

SAT
TT=175.8

CHECKS=131529000
NODES=118319
SAT
TT=87.897

CHECKS=50651400
NODES=50781
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=18.536

ASSIGNMENTS=24318
CHECKS=21062600
SAT
TT=423.965

ASSIGNMENTS=281036
CHECKS=357749000
SAT
TT=60.529

SAT
TT=63.612

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=24.958

ASSIGNMENTS=43593
CHECKS=36664200
SAT
TT=10.017

ASSIGNMENTS=24318
CHECKS=21062600
SAT
TT=140.23

SAT
TT=63.989

SAT
TT=41.402

csp/graphColoring/
hos/
normalized-ash331GPIA-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.168

UNSAT
TT=1.886

CHECKS=23837
NODES=55
UNSAT
TT=2.396

CHECKS=112493
NODES=55
UNSAT
TT=0.704

UNSAT
TT=0.351

CHECKS=195694
UNSAT
TT=0.196

CHECKS=182727
UNSAT
TT=2.621

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.874

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=6.212

CHECKS=25457
NODES=152
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.184

ASSIGNMENTS=11
CHECKS=6101
UNSAT
TT=0.195

ASSIGNMENTS=11
CHECKS=6101
UNSAT
TT=2.606

UNSAT
TT=2.386

UNSAT
TT=0.168

ASSIGNMENTS=11
CHECKS=7299
UNSAT
TT=0.307

ASSIGNMENTS=5497
CHECKS=340507
UNSAT
TT=1.277

UNSAT
TT=0.226

ASSIGNMENTS=1047
CHECKS=44765
UNSAT
TT=0.182

ASSIGNMENTS=11
CHECKS=6096
UNSAT
TT=4.913

UNSAT
TT=1.774

UNSAT
TT=2.006

csp/graphColoring/
hos/
normalized-ash608GPIA-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.351

UNSAT
TT=3.071

CHECKS=19241
NODES=79
UNSAT
TT=3.432

CHECKS=165182
NODES=61
UNSAT
TT=1.402

UNSAT
TT=0.74

CHECKS=366537
UNSAT
TT=0.423

CHECKS=357806
UNSAT
TT=4.149

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=4.408

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=18.02

CHECKS=3894
NODES=39
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.363

ASSIGNMENTS=16
CHECKS=10188
UNSAT
TT=0.379

ASSIGNMENTS=16
CHECKS=10188
UNSAT
TT=4.872

UNSAT
TT=4.258

UNSAT
TT=0.366

ASSIGNMENTS=23
CHECKS=13269
UNSAT
TT=0.573

ASSIGNMENTS=7132
CHECKS=412913
UNSAT
TT=2.056

UNSAT
TT=0.476

ASSIGNMENTS=1790
CHECKS=86445
UNSAT
TT=0.351

ASSIGNMENTS=13
CHECKS=9814
UNSAT
TT=6.12

UNSAT
TT=2.743

UNSAT
TT=2.862

csp/graphColoring/
hos/
normalized-ash608GPIA-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.376

SAT
TT=3.889

CHECKS=86128
NODES=2026
SAT
TT=4.374

CHECKS=165943
NODES=2539
SAT
TT=1.513

SAT
TT=14.787

CHECKS=6234660
SAT
TT=31.851

CHECKS=11470200
SAT
TT=4.741

ASSIGNMENTS=587
SAT
TT=4.17

ASSIGNMENTS=587
SAT
TT=19

CHECKS=35340
NODES=1817
SAT
TT=23.143

CHECKS=8627770
NODES=151282
SAT
TT=18.218

CHECKS=5191100
NODES=1021
SAT
TT=0.399

ASSIGNMENTS=643
CHECKS=26934
SAT
TT=0.393

ASSIGNMENTS=643
CHECKS=26934
SAT
TT=7.271

SAT
TT=7.807

SAT
TT=0.392

ASSIGNMENTS=815
CHECKS=42341
SAT
TT=0.773

ASSIGNMENTS=25001
CHECKS=846190
SAT
TT=2.588

SAT
TT=0.572

ASSIGNMENTS=3930
CHECKS=84551
SAT
TT=0.376

ASSIGNMENTS=516
CHECKS=18434
SAT
TT=6.079

SAT
TT=3.105

SAT
TT=3.275

csp/graphColoring/
hos/
normalized-ash958GPIA-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.626

UNSAT
TT=4.202

CHECKS=33075
NODES=83
UNSAT
TT=5.528

CHECKS=271921
NODES=81
UNSAT
TT=2.873

UNSAT
TT=1.234

CHECKS=553776
UNSAT
TT=0.649

CHECKS=550158
UNSAT
TT=6.536

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=6.556

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=48.619

CHECKS=3639
NODES=39
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.655

ASSIGNMENTS=12
CHECKS=14563
UNSAT
TT=0.643

ASSIGNMENTS=12
CHECKS=14563
UNSAT
TT=7.421

UNSAT
TT=7.322

UNSAT
TT=0.634

ASSIGNMENTS=14
CHECKS=17227
UNSAT
TT=0.961

ASSIGNMENTS=8696
CHECKS=448022
UNSAT
TT=2.845

UNSAT
TT=0.864

ASSIGNMENTS=2831
CHECKS=132361
UNSAT
TT=0.626

ASSIGNMENTS=11
CHECKS=14581
UNSAT
TT=6.034

UNSAT
TT=3.614

UNSAT
TT=4.069

csp/graphColoring/
hos/
normalized-ash958GPIA-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.627

SAT
TT=5.186

CHECKS=102365
NODES=2610
SAT
TT=6.432

CHECKS=254765
NODES=4400
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=37.361

CHECKS=27292400
SAT
TT=63.878

CHECKS=46472800
SAT
TT=6.372

ASSIGNMENTS=912
SAT
TT=6.647

ASSIGNMENTS=912
SAT
TT=58.957

CHECKS=87107
NODES=4737
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=51.293

CHECKS=12322300
NODES=1486
SAT
TT=0.702

ASSIGNMENTS=847
CHECKS=28923
SAT
TT=0.69

ASSIGNMENTS=847
CHECKS=28923
SAT
TT=13.111

SAT
TT=13.71

SAT
TT=0.627

ASSIGNMENTS=844
CHECKS=28921
SAT
TT=1.381

ASSIGNMENTS=33488
CHECKS=1018380
SAT
TT=3.204

SAT
TT=1.244

ASSIGNMENTS=6202
CHECKS=151569
SAT
TT=0.696

ASSIGNMENTS=1173
CHECKS=50276
SAT
TT=6.805

SAT
TT=4.206

SAT
TT=4.249

csp/graphColoring/
hos/
normalized-will199GPIA-6.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.759

UNSAT
TT=4.044

CHECKS=1956360
NODES=2165
UNSAT
TT=3.956

CHECKS=1986750
NODES=2194
UNSAT
TT=1.074

UNSAT
TT=340.343

CHECKS=1333920000
UNSAT
TT=236.395

CHECKS=951878000
UNSAT
TT=41.737

ASSIGNMENTS=4286
UNSAT
TT=890.97

ASSIGNMENTS=126781
UNSAT
TT=22.412

CHECKS=167965
NODES=2642
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.935

ASSIGNMENTS=2051
CHECKS=868277
UNSAT
TT=0.889

ASSIGNMENTS=2051
CHECKS=868277
UNSAT
TT=4.429

UNSAT
TT=4.574

UNSAT
TT=0.766

ASSIGNMENTS=1929
CHECKS=790256
UNSAT
TT=2.158

ASSIGNMENTS=18133
CHECKS=2532790
UNSAT
TT=2.119

UNSAT
TT=1.535

ASSIGNMENTS=5588
CHECKS=906046
UNSAT
TT=0.759

ASSIGNMENTS=1705
CHECKS=685214
UNSAT
TT=7.462

UNSAT
TT=2.486

UNSAT
TT=3.35

csp/graphColoring/
hos/
normalized-will199GPIA-7.xml
SAT
TT=0.312

SAT
TT=2.974

CHECKS=40402
NODES=701
SAT
TT=2.672

CHECKS=40625
NODES=0
SAT
TT=1.118

SAT
TT=2.574

CHECKS=487215
SAT
TT=2.989

CHECKS=588728
SAT
TT=12.674

ASSIGNMENTS=984
SAT
TT=14.375

ASSIGNMENTS=976
SAT
TT=22.206

CHECKS=126263
NODES=4895
SAT
TT=13.838

CHECKS=340498
NODES=780
SAT
TT=13.45

CHECKS=2725440
NODES=522
SAT
TT=0.321

ASSIGNMENTS=683
CHECKS=14345
SAT
TT=0.322

ASSIGNMENTS=683
CHECKS=14345
SAT
TT=7.02

SAT
TT=6.417

SAT
TT=0.312

ASSIGNMENTS=684
CHECKS=14345
SAT
TT=0.639

ASSIGNMENTS=33788
CHECKS=713417
SAT
TT=1.957

SAT
TT=0.514

ASSIGNMENTS=5269
CHECKS=108421
SAT
TT=0.312

ASSIGNMENTS=713
CHECKS=15018
SAT
TT=6.026

SAT
TT=2.873

SAT
TT=3.781

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-1-fullins-3-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.007

UNSAT
TT=0.745

CHECKS=833
NODES=16
UNSAT
TT=0.763

CHECKS=1268
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.035

UNSAT
TT=0.016

CHECKS=1110
UNSAT
TT=0.011

CHECKS=1147
UNSAT
TT=0.589

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.587

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.776

CHECKS=1317
NODES=35
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.022

ASSIGNMENTS=13
CHECKS=643
UNSAT
TT=0.02

ASSIGNMENTS=13
CHECKS=643
UNSAT
TT=0.828

UNSAT
TT=0.643

UNSAT
TT=0.007

ASSIGNMENTS=21
CHECKS=869
UNSAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=138
CHECKS=4665
UNSAT
TT=0.342

UNSAT
TT=0.008

ASSIGNMENTS=85
CHECKS=1677
UNSAT
TT=0.01

ASSIGNMENTS=13
CHECKS=589
UNSAT
TT=1.07

UNSAT
TT=0.647

UNSAT
TT=0.616

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-1-fullins-4-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.04

UNSAT
TT=1.316

CHECKS=120965
NODES=633
UNSAT
TT=1.371

CHECKS=116994
NODES=592
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=23.019

CHECKS=92881000
UNSAT
TT=32.259

CHECKS=137883000
UNSAT
TT=2.069

ASSIGNMENTS=5230
UNSAT
TT=2.066

ASSIGNMENTS=5230
UNSAT
TT=1.297

CHECKS=22568
NODES=288
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.059

ASSIGNMENTS=576
CHECKS=61201
UNSAT
TT=0.06

ASSIGNMENTS=576
CHECKS=61201
UNSAT
TT=1.249

UNSAT
TT=1.158

UNSAT
TT=0.051

ASSIGNMENTS=708
CHECKS=73647
UNSAT
TT=0.161

ASSIGNMENTS=6348
CHECKS=377846
UNSAT
TT=0.645

UNSAT
TT=0.047

ASSIGNMENTS=663
CHECKS=46423
UNSAT
TT=0.04

ASSIGNMENTS=408
CHECKS=41512
UNSAT
TT=2.507

UNSAT
TT=1.127

UNSAT
TT=1.267

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-1-fullins-4-5.xml
SAT
TT=0.026

SAT
TT=1.03

CHECKS=2507
NODES=93
SAT
TT=1.083

CHECKS=2888
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.097

SAT
TT=0.056

CHECKS=25112
SAT
TT=0.032

CHECKS=24990
SAT
TT=1.354

ASSIGNMENTS=85
SAT
TT=1.222

ASSIGNMENTS=85
SAT
TT=1.22

CHECKS=2304
NODES=93
SAT
TT=1.234

CHECKS=17191
NODES=55
SAT
TT=1.131

CHECKS=39673
NODES=50
SAT
TT=0.04

ASSIGNMENTS=89
CHECKS=1186
SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=89
CHECKS=1186
SAT
TT=1.818

SAT
TT=1.653

SAT
TT=0.026

ASSIGNMENTS=89
CHECKS=1186
SAT
TT=0.03

ASSIGNMENTS=289
CHECKS=5983
SAT
TT=0.683

SAT
TT=0.028

ASSIGNMENTS=425
CHECKS=5837
SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=89
CHECKS=1186
SAT
TT=2.073

SAT
TT=1.313

SAT
TT=1.287

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-1-fullins-5-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.216

UNSAT
TT=2.747

CHECKS=637358
NODES=905
UNSAT
TT=2.748

CHECKS=636092
NODES=855
UNSAT
TT=1791.97

UNSAT
TT=24.376

CHECKS=73561400
UNSAT
TT=35.185

CHECKS=101037000
UNSAT
TT=7.8

ASSIGNMENTS=13367
UNSAT
TT=8.265

ASSIGNMENTS=13367
UNSAT
TT=4.175

CHECKS=81811
NODES=374
? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.244

ASSIGNMENTS=698
CHECKS=303026
UNSAT
TT=0.22

ASSIGNMENTS=698
CHECKS=303026
UNSAT
TT=2.432

UNSAT
TT=2.217

UNSAT
TT=0.249

ASSIGNMENTS=831
CHECKS=390146
UNSAT
TT=0.738

ASSIGNMENTS=8514
CHECKS=1846020
UNSAT
TT=1.401

UNSAT
TT=0.216

ASSIGNMENTS=1280
CHECKS=171305
UNSAT
TT=0.216

ASSIGNMENTS=534
CHECKS=255367
UNSAT
TT=4.695

UNSAT
TT=2.048

UNSAT
TT=2.412

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-1-fullins-5-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=6.824

UNSAT
TT=50.374

CHECKS=68552800
NODES=101774
UNSAT
TT=49.262

CHECKS=67665600
NODES=97543
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=109.699

CHECKS=560659000
UNSAT
TT=170.522

CHECKS=846559000
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=99.27

CHECKS=10204700
NODES=58405
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=15.732

ASSIGNMENTS=82916
CHECKS=26386700
UNSAT
TT=125.776

ASSIGNMENTS=288001
CHECKS=193361000
UNSAT
TT=6.223

UNSAT
TT=83.274

UNSAT
TT=10.079

ASSIGNMENTS=88990
CHECKS=29536200
UNSAT
TT=8.186

ASSIGNMENTS=91597
CHECKS=25891800
UNSAT
TT=8.008

UNSAT
TT=20.177

ASSIGNMENTS=150361
CHECKS=48389500
UNSAT
TT=9.216

ASSIGNMENTS=82916
CHECKS=26386700
UNSAT
TT=44.507

UNSAT
TT=6.824

UNSAT
TT=11.715

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-2-fullins-3-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.014

UNSAT
TT=0.86

CHECKS=11365
NODES=142
UNSAT
TT=0.872

CHECKS=12245
NODES=103
UNSAT
TT=0.05

UNSAT
TT=3.434

CHECKS=10505200
UNSAT
TT=5.035

CHECKS=15135900
UNSAT
TT=0.785

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.737

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.802

CHECKS=2970
NODES=85
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.025

ASSIGNMENTS=94
CHECKS=3392
UNSAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=94
CHECKS=3392
UNSAT
TT=0.801

UNSAT
TT=0.822

UNSAT
TT=0.014

ASSIGNMENTS=85
CHECKS=3182
UNSAT
TT=0.05

ASSIGNMENTS=4980
CHECKS=83092
UNSAT
TT=0.437

UNSAT
TT=0.014

ASSIGNMENTS=243
CHECKS=3343
UNSAT
TT=0.015

ASSIGNMENTS=80
CHECKS=2673
UNSAT
TT=1.528

UNSAT
TT=0.77

UNSAT
TT=0.809

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-2-fullins-3-5.xml
SAT
TT=0.012

SAT
TT=0.815

CHECKS=1040
NODES=52
SAT
TT=0.804

CHECKS=1108
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.048

SAT
TT=0.023

CHECKS=6001
SAT
TT=0.017

CHECKS=7174
SAT
TT=0.824

ASSIGNMENTS=47
SAT
TT=0.832

ASSIGNMENTS=45
SAT
TT=0.834

CHECKS=997
NODES=60
SAT
TT=0.834

CHECKS=5587
NODES=31
SAT
TT=0.794

CHECKS=12237
NODES=39
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=51
CHECKS=421
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=51
CHECKS=421
SAT
TT=1.446

SAT
TT=1.351

SAT
TT=0.014

ASSIGNMENTS=51
CHECKS=421
SAT
TT=0.014

ASSIGNMENTS=114
CHECKS=1000
SAT
TT=0.464

SAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=173
CHECKS=1221
SAT
TT=0.013

ASSIGNMENTS=51
CHECKS=422
SAT
TT=1.54

SAT
TT=0.779

SAT
TT=0.814

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-2-fullins-4-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.2

UNSAT
TT=2.439

CHECKS=1432930
NODES=4870
UNSAT
TT=2.625

CHECKS=1401560
NODES=4849
UNSAT
TT=1675.38

UNSAT
TT=23.474

CHECKS=46417100
UNSAT
TT=36.25

CHECKS=79762200
UNSAT
TT=1.827

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.701

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=3.578

CHECKS=253936
NODES=2987
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.41

ASSIGNMENTS=6332
CHECKS=647669
UNSAT
TT=0.38

ASSIGNMENTS=6332
CHECKS=647669
UNSAT
TT=1.665

UNSAT
TT=1.745

UNSAT
TT=0.407

ASSIGNMENTS=6496
CHECKS=712633
UNSAT
TT=0.357

ASSIGNMENTS=13926
CHECKS=678825
UNSAT
TT=1.227

UNSAT
TT=0.429

ASSIGNMENTS=5476
CHECKS=496036
UNSAT
TT=0.2

ASSIGNMENTS=2843
CHECKS=293774
UNSAT
TT=3.963

UNSAT
TT=1.4

UNSAT
TT=1.69

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-3-fullins-4-6.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.512

UNSAT
TT=18.457

CHECKS=23804800
NODES=57810
UNSAT
TT=17.731

CHECKS=22803600
NODES=52291
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=47.194

CHECKS=142004000
UNSAT
TT=79.496

CHECKS=268827000
UNSAT
TT=2.467

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.703

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=32.908

CHECKS=2419870
NODES=22627
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=9.439

ASSIGNMENTS=20560
CHECKS=2792950
UNSAT
TT=46.106

ASSIGNMENTS=143192
CHECKS=59155700
UNSAT
TT=4.065

UNSAT
TT=4.979

UNSAT
TT=5.532

ASSIGNMENTS=81976
CHECKS=10659600
UNSAT
TT=1.512

ASSIGNMENTS=39242
CHECKS=2873570
UNSAT
TT=5.154

UNSAT
TT=5.364

ASSIGNMENTS=29349
CHECKS=3659660
UNSAT
TT=1.658

ASSIGNMENTS=20560
CHECKS=2792950
UNSAT
TT=13.518

UNSAT
TT=2.924

UNSAT
TT=4.541

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-4-fullins-4-7.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.805

UNSAT
TT=265.184

CHECKS=381224000
NODES=673036
UNSAT
TT=271.061

CHECKS=359940000
NODES=689260
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=381.117

CHECKS=1634120000
UNSAT
TT=108.711

CHECKS=487468000
UNSAT
TT=3.805

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=4.37

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=946.645

CHECKS=38503000
NODES=315133
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=33.018

ASSIGNMENTS=238621
CHECKS=40566800
UNSAT
TT=626.875

ASSIGNMENTS=1765370
CHECKS=949945000
UNSAT
TT=39.539

UNSAT
TT=129.559

UNSAT
TT=76.564

ASSIGNMENTS=815476
CHECKS=125775000
UNSAT
TT=16.575

ASSIGNMENTS=203362
CHECKS=27257600
UNSAT
TT=46.306

UNSAT
TT=67.578

ASSIGNMENTS=377943
CHECKS=52401600
UNSAT
TT=24.974

ASSIGNMENTS=238621
CHECKS=40566800
UNSAT
TT=254.554

UNSAT
TT=13.969

UNSAT
TT=13.908

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-4-fullins-5-6.xml
UNSAT
TT=5.557

UNSAT
TT=124.83

CHECKS=54092900
NODES=13286
UNSAT
TT=139.001

CHECKS=46355600
NODES=11129
UNSAT
TT=27.117

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=36.623

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=37.152

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=140.339

ASSIGNMENTS=16723
CHECKS=77108300
UNSAT
TT=141.5

ASSIGNMENTS=16723
CHECKS=77108300
UNSAT
TT=82.186

UNSAT
TT=72.036

UNSAT
TT=14.866

ASSIGNMENTS=9625
CHECKS=6792920
UNSAT
TT=21.256

ASSIGNMENTS=71836
CHECKS=11812700
UNSAT
TT=18.597

UNSAT
TT=59.843

ASSIGNMENTS=56528
CHECKS=23803100
UNSAT
TT=5.557

ASSIGNMENTS=3376
CHECKS=2320690
UNSAT
TT=20.321

UNSAT
TT=16.369

UNSAT
TT=24.646

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-5-fullins-3-6.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.034

UNSAT
TT=1.07

CHECKS=24
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.06

CHECKS=24
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.131

UNSAT
TT=0.117

CHECKS=203031
UNSAT
TT=0.087

CHECKS=204281
UNSAT
TT=1.209

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.15

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.817

CHECKS=26653
NODES=856
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.046

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.048

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=1.309

UNSAT
TT=1.355

UNSAT
TT=0.035

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.034

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.729

UNSAT
TT=0.034

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=2.767

UNSAT
TT=1.194

UNSAT
TT=1.279

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
full-insertion/
normalized-5-fullins-4-8.xml
UNSAT
TT=5.788

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=5.788

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=6.777

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=293.366

ASSIGNMENTS=1991740
CHECKS=444586000
UNSAT
TT=1040.29

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=498.749

ASSIGNMENTS=3694330
CHECKS=777646000
UNSAT
TT=224.536

ASSIGNMENTS=1639780
CHECKS=313210000
UNSAT
TT=792.3

UNSAT
TT=836.233

ASSIGNMENTS=2870200
CHECKS=571275000
UNSAT
TT=293.091

ASSIGNMENTS=1991740
CHECKS=444586000
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=119.27

UNSAT
TT=101.963

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-1-insertions-4-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=1.007

CHECKS=16660
NODES=185
UNSAT
TT=0.936

CHECKS=16999
NODES=152
UNSAT
TT=0.057

UNSAT
TT=0.041

CHECKS=64110
UNSAT
TT=0.028

CHECKS=66031
UNSAT
TT=0.937

ASSIGNMENTS=43
UNSAT
TT=0.973

ASSIGNMENTS=43
UNSAT
TT=0.915

CHECKS=21151
NODES=464
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.031

ASSIGNMENTS=189
CHECKS=14993
UNSAT
TT=0.029

ASSIGNMENTS=189
CHECKS=14993
UNSAT
TT=1.045

UNSAT
TT=0.863

UNSAT
TT=0.019

ASSIGNMENTS=162
CHECKS=11959
UNSAT
TT=0.118

ASSIGNMENTS=3908
CHECKS=276704
UNSAT
TT=0.481

UNSAT
TT=0.022

ASSIGNMENTS=366
CHECKS=23758
UNSAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=191
CHECKS=15173
UNSAT
TT=1.627

UNSAT
TT=0.884

UNSAT
TT=0.834

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-1-insertions-6-6.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.23

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-2-insertions-3-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.062

UNSAT
TT=1.063

CHECKS=153378
NODES=3478
UNSAT
TT=1.093

CHECKS=141439
NODES=3400
UNSAT
TT=0.09

UNSAT
TT=0.113

CHECKS=390216
UNSAT
TT=0.107

CHECKS=390321
UNSAT
TT=1.079

ASSIGNMENTS=6116
UNSAT
TT=1.152

ASSIGNMENTS=6116
UNSAT
TT=1.171

CHECKS=233902
NODES=16015
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.104

ASSIGNMENTS=9381
CHECKS=172090
UNSAT
TT=0.103

ASSIGNMENTS=9381
CHECKS=172090
UNSAT
TT=0.806

UNSAT
TT=0.668

UNSAT
TT=0.062

ASSIGNMENTS=7042
CHECKS=130640
UNSAT
TT=0.097

ASSIGNMENTS=12401
CHECKS=211332
UNSAT
TT=0.379

UNSAT
TT=0.139

ASSIGNMENTS=14313
CHECKS=256554
UNSAT
TT=0.183

ASSIGNMENTS=23130
CHECKS=415299
UNSAT
TT=1.434

UNSAT
TT=0.663

UNSAT
TT=0.649

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-2-insertions-4-4.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-2-insertions-5-4.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-2-insertions-5-5.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-3-insertions-4-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=2.162

UNSAT
TT=87.828

CHECKS=80326800
NODES=491185
UNSAT
TT=97.186

CHECKS=87911800
NODES=555376
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=97.167

CHECKS=325546000
UNSAT
TT=70.778

CHECKS=267595000
UNSAT
TT=397.974

ASSIGNMENTS=2829360
UNSAT
TT=410.596

ASSIGNMENTS=2829360
UNSAT
TT=826.3

CHECKS=131907000
NODES=2167910
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=47.645

ASSIGNMENTS=903274
CHECKS=89515700
UNSAT
TT=72.74

ASSIGNMENTS=568854
CHECKS=70144600
UNSAT
TT=1.885

UNSAT
TT=1.838

UNSAT
TT=24.399

ASSIGNMENTS=561669
CHECKS=61886200
UNSAT
TT=38.392

ASSIGNMENTS=878133
CHECKS=94444800
UNSAT
TT=16.92

UNSAT
TT=110.263

ASSIGNMENTS=1686090
CHECKS=183161000
UNSAT
TT=37.246

ASSIGNMENTS=903274
CHECKS=89515700
UNSAT
TT=5.316

UNSAT
TT=2.226

UNSAT
TT=2.162

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-3-insertions-5-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=7.584

UNSAT
TT=680.088

CHECKS=514149000
NODES=489423
UNSAT
TT=674.555

CHECKS=531502000
NODES=519565
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=1515.67

ASSIGNMENTS=1842280
UNSAT
TT=1563.25

ASSIGNMENTS=1842280
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=390.65

ASSIGNMENTS=373453
CHECKS=372979000
UNSAT
TT=392.338

ASSIGNMENTS=373453
CHECKS=372979000
UNSAT
TT=7.727

UNSAT
TT=6.055

UNSAT
TT=334.641

ASSIGNMENTS=1071840
CHECKS=920981000
UNSAT
TT=303.571

ASSIGNMENTS=977387
CHECKS=860103000
UNSAT
TT=28.217

UNSAT
TT=724.315

ASSIGNMENTS=1667420
CHECKS=1141660000
UNSAT
TT=1016.9

ASSIGNMENTS=3460460
CHECKS=2626730000
UNSAT
TT=15.055

UNSAT
TT=7.764

UNSAT
TT=7.584

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-3-insertions-5-4.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-3-insertions-5-5.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-3-insertions-5-6.xml
SAT
TT=0.496

SAT
TT=463.239

CHECKS=55154
NODES=1406
SAT
TT=4.389

CHECKS=56232
NODES=0
SAT
TT=2.001

SAT
TT=2.612

CHECKS=414394
SAT
TT=2.182

CHECKS=433124
SAT
TT=5.583

ASSIGNMENTS=1402
SAT
TT=5.852

ASSIGNMENTS=1402
SAT
TT=29.981

CHECKS=45834
NODES=1406
SAT
TT=30.187

CHECKS=315370
NODES=632
SAT
TT=30.574

CHECKS=4967900
NODES=641
SAT
TT=0.515

ASSIGNMENTS=1401
CHECKS=19390
SAT
TT=0.541

ASSIGNMENTS=1401
CHECKS=19390
SAT
TT=10.443

SAT
TT=10.317

SAT
TT=0.512

ASSIGNMENTS=1401
CHECKS=19390
SAT
TT=0.496

ASSIGNMENTS=1294
CHECKS=19493
SAT
TT=2.508

SAT
TT=0.517

ASSIGNMENTS=1405
CHECKS=19390
SAT
TT=0.509

ASSIGNMENTS=1403
CHECKS=19390
SAT
TT=6.348

SAT
TT=3.222

SAT
TT=4.248

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-4-insertions-3-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.011

SAT
TT=0.949

CHECKS=704
NODES=79
SAT
TT=0.835

CHECKS=709
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.05

SAT
TT=0.02

CHECKS=3814
SAT
TT=0.013

CHECKS=3578
SAT
TT=0.866

ASSIGNMENTS=77
SAT
TT=0.872

ASSIGNMENTS=77
SAT
TT=0.797

CHECKS=535
NODES=79
SAT
TT=0.909

CHECKS=3248
NODES=26
SAT
TT=0.807

CHECKS=6420
NODES=29
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=78
CHECKS=312
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=78
CHECKS=312
SAT
TT=1.308

SAT
TT=1.348

SAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=78
CHECKS=312
SAT
TT=0.014

ASSIGNMENTS=71
CHECKS=312
SAT
TT=0.5

SAT
TT=0.011

ASSIGNMENTS=78
CHECKS=312
SAT
TT=0.011

ASSIGNMENTS=74
CHECKS=312
SAT
TT=1.349

SAT
TT=0.887

SAT
TT=0.798

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-4-insertions-4-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=6.636

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=1225.24

CHECKS=3594070000
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=4.231

UNSAT
TT=5.595

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=23.951

UNSAT
TT=8.632

UNSAT
TT=6.636

csp/graphColoring/insertion/
k-insertion/
normalized-4-insertions-4-4.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15a-05.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.314

UNSAT
TT=2.661

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.555

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.134

UNSAT
TT=25.918

CHECKS=34156500
UNSAT
TT=36.788

CHECKS=39259800
UNSAT
TT=3.934

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=3.614

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=21.035

CHECKS=21708
NODES=211
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.33

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=10
UNSAT
TT=0.332

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=10
UNSAT
TT=4.2

UNSAT
TT=3.956

UNSAT
TT=0.314

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=10
UNSAT
TT=0.315

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=10
UNSAT
TT=2.169

UNSAT
TT=0.321

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=10
UNSAT
TT=0.32

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=10
UNSAT
TT=6.612

UNSAT
TT=2.819

UNSAT
TT=3.834

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15a-08.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.312

UNSAT
TT=2.553

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.542

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.049

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=4.143

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=3.868

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=236.73

CHECKS=4130360
NODES=46131
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.328

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.327

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=17.977

UNSAT
TT=6.557

UNSAT
TT=0.315

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.316

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=7.704

UNSAT
TT=0.317

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.312

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=24.809

UNSAT
TT=3.298

UNSAT
TT=5.357

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15a-12.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.306

UNSAT
TT=2.727

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.656

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.119

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=4.238

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=4.089

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.328

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.324

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.308

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.306

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.32

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.317

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=145.005

UNSAT
TT=567.476

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15b-08.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.308

UNSAT
TT=2.697

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.676

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.112

UNSAT
TT=194.313

CHECKS=684387000
UNSAT
TT=240.242

CHECKS=828221000
UNSAT
TT=3.876

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=3.765

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=226.578

CHECKS=4117500
NODES=45844
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.333

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.327

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=11.872

UNSAT
TT=8.851

UNSAT
TT=0.308

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.314

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=6.177

UNSAT
TT=0.319

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.308

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=25.096

UNSAT
TT=3.372

UNSAT
TT=6.764

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15b-10.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.297

UNSAT
TT=2.779

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.735

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.123

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=3.902

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=3.9

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.333

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.33

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=1620.39

UNSAT
TT=0.312

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.311

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=649.968

UNSAT
TT=0.297

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.299

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.16

UNSAT
TT=5.457

UNSAT
TT=20.72

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15b-13.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.311

UNSAT
TT=2.782

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.714

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=3.626

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=3.876

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.33

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.325

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.312

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.311

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.314

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.314

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.2

UNSAT
TT=1142.45

UNSAT
TT=774.114

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15b-15.xml
SAT
TT=0.403

SAT
TT=5.126

CHECKS=2084990
NODES=5524
SAT
TT=5.954

CHECKS=2210610
NODES=5524
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=750.06

ASSIGNMENTS=205124
SAT
TT=44.738

ASSIGNMENTS=444
SAT
TT=348.445

CHECKS=10833300
NODES=78081
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=8.158

ASSIGNMENTS=1566
CHECKS=96860
SAT
TT=13.156

ASSIGNMENTS=5524
CHECKS=2084990
SAT
TT=9.806

SAT
TT=10.1

SAT
TT=381.306

ASSIGNMENTS=6254950
CHECKS=496383000
SAT
TT=3.351

ASSIGNMENTS=38652
CHECKS=4879250
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=1.206

ASSIGNMENTS=9851
CHECKS=593617
SAT
TT=0.403

ASSIGNMENTS=1566
CHECKS=96860
SAT
TT=48.452

SAT
TT=5.724

SAT
TT=8.717

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15c-13.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.66

UNSAT
TT=4.476

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.393

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.25

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=7.255

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.439

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.683

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.686

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.666

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.667

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=0.662

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.66

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.19

UNSAT
TT=791.751

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15c-14.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.619

UNSAT
TT=4.554

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.635

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.274

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=7.237

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.467

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=0.681

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.702

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.679

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.677

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.619

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.619

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15d-05.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.672

UNSAT
TT=3.99

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.235

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.108

UNSAT
TT=39.808

CHECKS=47279600
UNSAT
TT=57.519

CHECKS=67760200
UNSAT
TT=6.55

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=6.54

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=105.925

CHECKS=39518
NODES=188
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.688

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=22
UNSAT
TT=0.706

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=22
UNSAT
TT=7.664

UNSAT
TT=6.78

UNSAT
TT=0.672

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=22
UNSAT
TT=0.686

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=22
UNSAT
TT=3.196

UNSAT
TT=0.689

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=22
UNSAT
TT=0.686

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=22
UNSAT
TT=7.909

UNSAT
TT=4.464

UNSAT
TT=5.946

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15d-08.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.621

UNSAT
TT=4.157

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.386

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.296

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=6.821

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=6.653

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=739.144

CHECKS=9879990
NODES=46934
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.689

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.694

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=16.076

UNSAT
TT=9.211

UNSAT
TT=0.669

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.621

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=10.99

UNSAT
TT=0.639

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.633

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=40.663

UNSAT
TT=4.343

UNSAT
TT=6.672

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15d-10.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.617

UNSAT
TT=4.086

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.082

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.303

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=6.583

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.7

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.636

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.693

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.649

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.65

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=512.533

UNSAT
TT=0.617

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.657

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
? (TO)
TT=1800.15

UNSAT
TT=9.328

UNSAT
TT=36.006

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-15/
normalized-lei450-15d-12.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.669

UNSAT
TT=4.115

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.499

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.291

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=7.442

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.199

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.674

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.674

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.669

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.67

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.675

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.67

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=224.067

UNSAT
TT=943.358

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-25/
normalized-lei450-25a-15.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.313

UNSAT
TT=2.851

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.806

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.048

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=3.666

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=3.771

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.339

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.329

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.314

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.316

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=0.317

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.313

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-25/
normalized-lei450-25a-23.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.295

UNSAT
TT=2.79

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.78

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=3.893

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=4.148

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.329

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.331

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.295

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.302

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.322

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.32

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-25/
normalized-lei450-25a-25.xml
SAT
TT=0.301

SAT
TT=2.936

CHECKS=144881
NODES=450
SAT
TT=2.918

CHECKS=143472
NODES=0
SAT
TT=1.168

SAT
TT=1.016

CHECKS=439497
SAT
TT=0.668

CHECKS=393052
SAT
TT=65.242

ASSIGNMENTS=414
SAT
TT=70.142

ASSIGNMENTS=3071
SAT
TT=26.373

CHECKS=199116
NODES=2299
SAT
TT=20.855

CHECKS=1775620
NODES=648
SAT
TT=20.295

CHECKS=2703950
NODES=307
SAT
TT=0.314

ASSIGNMENTS=435
CHECKS=17098
SAT
TT=0.337

ASSIGNMENTS=435
CHECKS=17098
SAT
TT=16.282

SAT
TT=12.075

SAT
TT=0.301

ASSIGNMENTS=435
CHECKS=17098
SAT
TT=0.327

ASSIGNMENTS=1622
CHECKS=47395
SAT
TT=1.877

SAT
TT=0.752

ASSIGNMENTS=11160
CHECKS=367967
SAT
TT=0.302

ASSIGNMENTS=435
CHECKS=17105
SAT
TT=16.202

SAT
TT=3.907

SAT
TT=7.944

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-25/
normalized-lei450-25b-15.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.286

UNSAT
TT=2.568

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.562

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.142

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=4.006

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=3.993

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.33

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.331

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.29

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.286

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.311

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.314

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-25/
normalized-lei450-25b-24.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.299

UNSAT
TT=2.928

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.621

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=4.027

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=4.084

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.325

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.326

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.299

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.299

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=0.319

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.317

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-25/
normalized-lei450-25c-05.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.642

UNSAT
TT=4.111

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.299

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.204

UNSAT
TT=49.492

CHECKS=54184900
UNSAT
TT=73.163

CHECKS=78958400
UNSAT
TT=6.673

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.203

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=111.814

CHECKS=39907
NODES=182
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.711

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.704

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=7.976

UNSAT
TT=6.396

UNSAT
TT=0.644

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.645

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=3.234

UNSAT
TT=0.702

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.642

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=7.79

UNSAT
TT=4.608

UNSAT
TT=5.675

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-25/
normalized-lei450-25c-25.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (MO)
TT=553.3

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-25/
normalized-lei450-25d-05.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.684

UNSAT
TT=4.397

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.477

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.329

UNSAT
TT=32.525

CHECKS=43789100
UNSAT
TT=44.602

CHECKS=60098000
UNSAT
TT=7.099

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.732

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=126.812

CHECKS=37803
NODES=163
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.684

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.716

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=8.137

UNSAT
TT=6.422

UNSAT
TT=0.708

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.703

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=3.277

UNSAT
TT=0.706

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.695

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=7.244

UNSAT
TT=4.24

UNSAT
TT=5.884

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-25/
normalized-lei450-25d-20.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.65

UNSAT
TT=4.481

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.53

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.363

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=7.736

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.234

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.702

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.699

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.65

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.658

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.682

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.68

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-5/
normalized-lei450-05a-04.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.215

UNSAT
TT=2.078

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.159

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.806

UNSAT
TT=1.542

CHECKS=1569850
UNSAT
TT=1.758

CHECKS=2139220
UNSAT
TT=2.953

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.923

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=9.337

CHECKS=12651
NODES=111
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.223

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.236

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=2.884

UNSAT
TT=3.09

UNSAT
TT=0.226

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.223

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=1.416

UNSAT
TT=0.215

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.222

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=5.772

UNSAT
TT=2.115

UNSAT
TT=2.665

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-5/
normalized-lei450-05a-05.xml
SAT
TT=0.422

SAT
TT=2.526

CHECKS=110856
NODES=595
SAT
TT=2.792

CHECKS=184794
NODES=581
SAT
TT=1.277

SAT
TT=447.955

CHECKS=1509280000
SAT
TT=289.562

CHECKS=519536000
SAT
TT=6.731

ASSIGNMENTS=13
SAT
TT=7.595

ASSIGNMENTS=18
SAT
TT=11.364

CHECKS=190382
NODES=1194
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=42.839

CHECKS=148395000
NODES=56525
SAT
TT=0.45

ASSIGNMENTS=483
CHECKS=294439
SAT
TT=0.439

ASSIGNMENTS=483
CHECKS=294439
SAT
TT=4.922

SAT
TT=5.029

SAT
TT=0.453

ASSIGNMENTS=540
CHECKS=364576
SAT
TT=2.018

ASSIGNMENTS=4532
CHECKS=2867310
SAT
TT=1.912

SAT
TT=0.818

ASSIGNMENTS=2417
CHECKS=743654
SAT
TT=0.422

ASSIGNMENTS=511
CHECKS=303715
SAT
TT=7.226

SAT
TT=2.756

SAT
TT=3.099

csp/graphColoring/leighton/
leighton-5/
normalized-lei450-05b-05.xml
SAT
TT=0.292

SAT
TT=4.458

CHECKS=1869350
NODES=4044
SAT
TT=3.606

CHECKS=1023800
NODES=2253
SAT
TT=0.823

SAT
TT=318.981

CHECKS=1181030000
SAT
TT=99.2

CHECKS=230641000
SAT
TT=9.09

ASSIGNMENTS=332
SAT
TT=9.79

ASSIGNMENTS=279
SAT
TT=13.024

CHECKS=220506
NODES=1414
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=0.342

ASSIGNMENTS=207
CHECKS=180188
SAT
TT=0.36

ASSIGNMENTS=207
CHECKS=180188
SAT
TT=4.695

SAT
TT=4.644

SAT
TT=0.292

ASSIGNMENTS=219
CHECKS=139115
SAT
TT=3.416

ASSIGNMENTS=7971
CHECKS=5214960
SAT
TT=1.988

SAT
TT=0.509

ASSIGNMENTS=1843
CHECKS=360458
SAT
TT=0.303

ASSIGNMENTS=170
CHECKS=130299
SAT
TT=7.76

SAT
TT=2.439

SAT
TT=3.498

csp/graphColoring/
mug/
normalized-mug100-1-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.784

UNSAT
TT=1.851

CHECKS=425372
NODES=17420
UNSAT
TT=1.361

CHECKS=191679
NODES=8068
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=105.087

CHECKS=227798000
UNSAT
TT=98.215

CHECKS=250633000
? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=16.455

ASSIGNMENTS=189705
CHECKS=4917310
UNSAT
TT=16.802

ASSIGNMENTS=189705
CHECKS=4917310
UNSAT
TT=1.157

UNSAT
TT=0.83

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=1.505

UNSAT
TT=0.784

UNSAT
TT=0.8

csp/graphColoring/
mug/
normalized-mug100-1-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.012

SAT
TT=0.84

CHECKS=853
NODES=100
SAT
TT=0.867

CHECKS=904
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.049

SAT
TT=0.021

CHECKS=4024
SAT
TT=0.015

CHECKS=3890
SAT
TT=0.816

ASSIGNMENTS=87
SAT
TT=0.783

ASSIGNMENTS=87
SAT
TT=0.764

CHECKS=577
NODES=100
SAT
TT=0.795

CHECKS=3448
NODES=34
SAT
TT=0.796

CHECKS=7804
NODES=38
SAT
TT=0.025

ASSIGNMENTS=88
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=88
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=1.325

SAT
TT=1.661

SAT
TT=0.014

ASSIGNMENTS=88
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=0.013

ASSIGNMENTS=92
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=0.456

SAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=87
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=0.013

ASSIGNMENTS=92
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=1.453

SAT
TT=0.795

SAT
TT=0.801

csp/graphColoring/
mug/
normalized-mug100-25-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.853

UNSAT
TT=1.169

CHECKS=123868
NODES=5383
UNSAT
TT=1.601

CHECKS=370077
NODES=14905
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=83.273

CHECKS=194949000
UNSAT
TT=82.412

CHECKS=222694000
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=8.717

ASSIGNMENTS=17178
CHECKS=361474
UNSAT
TT=8.683

ASSIGNMENTS=17178
CHECKS=361474
UNSAT
TT=0.824

UNSAT
TT=0.959

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=1.573

UNSAT
TT=0.853

UNSAT
TT=0.88

csp/graphColoring/
mug/
normalized-mug100-25-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.011

SAT
TT=0.886

CHECKS=857
NODES=100
SAT
TT=0.816

CHECKS=916
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.052

SAT
TT=0.023

CHECKS=4026
SAT
TT=0.015

CHECKS=3821
SAT
TT=0.821

ASSIGNMENTS=90
SAT
TT=0.786

ASSIGNMENTS=90
SAT
TT=0.763

CHECKS=577
NODES=100
SAT
TT=0.801

CHECKS=3516
NODES=39
SAT
TT=0.821

CHECKS=7800
NODES=37
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=95
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=95
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=1.319

SAT
TT=1.316

SAT
TT=0.011

ASSIGNMENTS=95
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=88
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=0.452

SAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=93
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=0.011

ASSIGNMENTS=87
CHECKS=332
SAT
TT=1.454

SAT
TT=0.903

SAT
TT=0.848

csp/graphColoring/
mug/
normalized-mug88-1-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.717

UNSAT
TT=1.35

CHECKS=238723
NODES=10640
UNSAT
TT=1.484

CHECKS=214798
NODES=9870
UNSAT
TT=1539.12

UNSAT
TT=82.676

CHECKS=199592000
UNSAT
TT=89.994

CHECKS=238785000
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=10.836

ASSIGNMENTS=77382
CHECKS=1850830
UNSAT
TT=11.644

ASSIGNMENTS=77382
CHECKS=1850830
UNSAT
TT=0.796

UNSAT
TT=0.97

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=1.545

UNSAT
TT=0.717

UNSAT
TT=0.784

csp/graphColoring/
mug/
normalized-mug88-1-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.009

SAT
TT=0.835

CHECKS=743
NODES=88
SAT
TT=0.896

CHECKS=784
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.045

SAT
TT=0.019

CHECKS=3285
SAT
TT=0.013

CHECKS=3366
SAT
TT=0.727

ASSIGNMENTS=77
SAT
TT=0.739

ASSIGNMENTS=77
SAT
TT=0.712

CHECKS=508
NODES=88
SAT
TT=0.714

CHECKS=2984
NODES=27
SAT
TT=0.718

CHECKS=6118
NODES=31
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=77
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=77
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=1.192

SAT
TT=1.201

SAT
TT=0.009

ASSIGNMENTS=77
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=80
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=0.421

SAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=77
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=0.01

ASSIGNMENTS=80
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=1.35

SAT
TT=0.721

SAT
TT=0.716

csp/graphColoring/
mug/
normalized-mug88-25-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.855

UNSAT
TT=1.149

CHECKS=64756
NODES=2934
UNSAT
TT=1.283

CHECKS=180888
NODES=7119
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=7.906

CHECKS=27554400
UNSAT
TT=11.032

CHECKS=37505600
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800

UNSAT
TT=9.63

ASSIGNMENTS=34731
CHECKS=780235
UNSAT
TT=10.2

ASSIGNMENTS=34731
CHECKS=780235
UNSAT
TT=0.803

UNSAT
TT=0.938

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=1.481

UNSAT
TT=0.857

UNSAT
TT=0.855

csp/graphColoring/
mug/
normalized-mug88-25-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.01

SAT
TT=0.857

CHECKS=763
NODES=88
SAT
TT=0.804

CHECKS=816
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.049

SAT
TT=0.019

CHECKS=3304
SAT
TT=0.014

CHECKS=3414
SAT
TT=0.724

ASSIGNMENTS=74
SAT
TT=0.787

ASSIGNMENTS=74
SAT
TT=0.735

CHECKS=501
NODES=88
SAT
TT=0.757

CHECKS=3068
NODES=33
SAT
TT=0.755

CHECKS=7102
NODES=39
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=78
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=78
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=1.431

SAT
TT=1.94

SAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=78
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=75
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=0.417

SAT
TT=0.011

ASSIGNMENTS=76
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=0.01

ASSIGNMENTS=81
CHECKS=292
SAT
TT=1.425

SAT
TT=0.777

SAT
TT=0.732

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel3-3.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.007

UNSAT
TT=0.69

CHECKS=276
NODES=9
UNSAT
TT=0.664

CHECKS=721
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.027

UNSAT
TT=0.01

CHECKS=660
UNSAT
TT=0.007

CHECKS=1052
UNSAT
TT=0.55

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.479

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.469

CHECKS=422
NODES=35
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.019

ASSIGNMENTS=20
CHECKS=265
UNSAT
TT=0.02

ASSIGNMENTS=20
CHECKS=265
UNSAT
TT=0.737

UNSAT
TT=0.542

UNSAT
TT=0.007

ASSIGNMENTS=18
CHECKS=255
UNSAT
TT=0.007

ASSIGNMENTS=34
CHECKS=488
UNSAT
TT=0.289

UNSAT
TT=0.008

ASSIGNMENTS=48
CHECKS=487
UNSAT
TT=0.007

ASSIGNMENTS=30
CHECKS=392
UNSAT
TT=0.854

UNSAT
TT=0.496

UNSAT
TT=0.506

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel3-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.006

SAT
TT=0.736

CHECKS=104
NODES=11
SAT
TT=0.675

CHECKS=101
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.027

SAT
TT=0.008

CHECKS=656
SAT
TT=0.008

CHECKS=600
SAT
TT=0.476

ASSIGNMENTS=9
SAT
TT=0.52

ASSIGNMENTS=9
SAT
TT=0.461

CHECKS=67
NODES=11
SAT
TT=0.469

CHECKS=412
NODES=3
SAT
TT=0.448

CHECKS=476
NODES=4
SAT
TT=0.018

ASSIGNMENTS=10
CHECKS=40
SAT
TT=0.018

ASSIGNMENTS=10
CHECKS=40
SAT
TT=0.872

SAT
TT=0.881

SAT
TT=0.006

ASSIGNMENTS=10
CHECKS=40
SAT
TT=0.007

ASSIGNMENTS=10
CHECKS=40
SAT
TT=0.282

SAT
TT=0.007

ASSIGNMENTS=10
CHECKS=40
SAT
TT=0.007

ASSIGNMENTS=10
CHECKS=40
SAT
TT=0.911

SAT
TT=0.507

SAT
TT=0.504

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel4-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.026

UNSAT
TT=0.872

CHECKS=29912
NODES=544
UNSAT
TT=0.859

CHECKS=30322
NODES=578
UNSAT
TT=0.053

UNSAT
TT=0.028

CHECKS=70057
UNSAT
TT=0.026

CHECKS=69976
UNSAT
TT=0.636

ASSIGNMENTS=149
UNSAT
TT=0.644

ASSIGNMENTS=149
UNSAT
TT=0.753

CHECKS=39010
NODES=2638
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=1918
CHECKS=44836
UNSAT
TT=0.036

ASSIGNMENTS=1918
CHECKS=44836
UNSAT
TT=0.695

UNSAT
TT=0.703

UNSAT
TT=0.026

ASSIGNMENTS=1998
CHECKS=46161
UNSAT
TT=0.044

ASSIGNMENTS=5397
CHECKS=99440
UNSAT
TT=0.363

UNSAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=3187
CHECKS=71019
UNSAT
TT=0.04

ASSIGNMENTS=3792
CHECKS=85111
UNSAT
TT=1.523

UNSAT
TT=0.704

UNSAT
TT=0.68

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel4-5.xml
SAT
TT=0.007

SAT
TT=0.747

CHECKS=390
NODES=23
SAT
TT=0.715

CHECKS=380
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.035

SAT
TT=0.014

CHECKS=2261
SAT
TT=0.009

CHECKS=1850
SAT
TT=0.626

ASSIGNMENTS=21
SAT
TT=0.571

ASSIGNMENTS=21
SAT
TT=0.688

CHECKS=276
NODES=23
SAT
TT=0.601

CHECKS=1757
NODES=6
SAT
TT=0.609

CHECKS=2142
NODES=7
SAT
TT=0.02

ASSIGNMENTS=22
CHECKS=142
SAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=22
CHECKS=142
SAT
TT=1.166

SAT
TT=1.019

SAT
TT=0.007

ASSIGNMENTS=22
CHECKS=142
SAT
TT=0.008

ASSIGNMENTS=22
CHECKS=142
SAT
TT=0.35

SAT
TT=0.007

ASSIGNMENTS=22
CHECKS=142
SAT
TT=0.009

ASSIGNMENTS=22
CHECKS=142
SAT
TT=1.063

SAT
TT=0.614

SAT
TT=0.659

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel5-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.046

UNSAT
TT=0.942

CHECKS=53921
NODES=442
UNSAT
TT=0.993

CHECKS=64809
NODES=527
UNSAT
TT=0.102

UNSAT
TT=0.079

CHECKS=274748
UNSAT
TT=0.074

CHECKS=271591
UNSAT
TT=0.844

ASSIGNMENTS=122
UNSAT
TT=1.108

ASSIGNMENTS=122
UNSAT
TT=1.143

CHECKS=90367
NODES=2704
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.061

ASSIGNMENTS=1387
CHECKS=92249
UNSAT
TT=0.059

ASSIGNMENTS=1387
CHECKS=92249
UNSAT
TT=0.933

UNSAT
TT=0.907

UNSAT
TT=0.046

ASSIGNMENTS=1295
CHECKS=88720
UNSAT
TT=0.102

ASSIGNMENTS=5225
CHECKS=238316
UNSAT
TT=0.485

UNSAT
TT=0.099

ASSIGNMENTS=3305
CHECKS=208915
UNSAT
TT=0.059

ASSIGNMENTS=2208
CHECKS=143390
UNSAT
TT=2.211

UNSAT
TT=0.944

UNSAT
TT=0.989

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel5-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=25.039

UNSAT
TT=25.039

CHECKS=34788100
NODES=397254
UNSAT
TT=29.904

CHECKS=39853800
NODES=458975
UNSAT
TT=655.767

UNSAT
TT=99.347

CHECKS=454619000
UNSAT
TT=96.833

CHECKS=451476000
UNSAT
TT=46.066

ASSIGNMENTS=574723
UNSAT
TT=46.541

ASSIGNMENTS=574723
UNSAT
TT=387.389

CHECKS=96524000
NODES=4328700
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=102.481

ASSIGNMENTS=1786190
CHECKS=163939000
UNSAT
TT=102.791

ASSIGNMENTS=1786190
CHECKS=163939000
UNSAT
TT=186.452

UNSAT
TT=216.136

UNSAT
TT=33.677

ASSIGNMENTS=2237490
CHECKS=96805700
UNSAT
TT=31

ASSIGNMENTS=2014660
CHECKS=88679500
UNSAT
TT=99.477

UNSAT
TT=31.59

ASSIGNMENTS=1908840
CHECKS=72511500
UNSAT
TT=67.804

ASSIGNMENTS=4817280
CHECKS=213097000
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=56.015

UNSAT
TT=232.688

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel5-6.xml
SAT
TT=0.012

SAT
TT=0.85

CHECKS=1356
NODES=47
SAT
TT=0.9

CHECKS=1353
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.053

SAT
TT=0.029

CHECKS=7632
SAT
TT=0.017

CHECKS=7809
SAT
TT=0.806

ASSIGNMENTS=45
SAT
TT=0.812

ASSIGNMENTS=45
SAT
TT=1.075

CHECKS=1047
NODES=47
SAT
TT=0.84

CHECKS=7480
NODES=21
SAT
TT=0.879

CHECKS=10296
NODES=17
SAT
TT=0.025

ASSIGNMENTS=46
CHECKS=472
SAT
TT=0.028

ASSIGNMENTS=46
CHECKS=472
SAT
TT=1.417

SAT
TT=1.31

SAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=46
CHECKS=472
SAT
TT=0.014

ASSIGNMENTS=46
CHECKS=472
SAT
TT=0.461

SAT
TT=0.014

ASSIGNMENTS=46
CHECKS=472
SAT
TT=0.014

ASSIGNMENTS=46
CHECKS=472
SAT
TT=1.656

SAT
TT=0.818

SAT
TT=0.826

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel6-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.097

UNSAT
TT=1.291

CHECKS=161372
NODES=583
UNSAT
TT=1.353

CHECKS=179166
NODES=606
UNSAT
TT=0.42

UNSAT
TT=0.836

CHECKS=3349740
UNSAT
TT=1.169

CHECKS=5272040
UNSAT
TT=1.341

ASSIGNMENTS=384
UNSAT
TT=1.34

ASSIGNMENTS=384
UNSAT
TT=2.764

CHECKS=248880
NODES=3412
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.116

ASSIGNMENTS=1152
CHECKS=193635
UNSAT
TT=0.112

ASSIGNMENTS=1152
CHECKS=193635
UNSAT
TT=1.367

UNSAT
TT=1.518

UNSAT
TT=0.097

ASSIGNMENTS=1318
CHECKS=214314
UNSAT
TT=0.264

ASSIGNMENTS=5872
CHECKS=641014
UNSAT
TT=1.107

UNSAT
TT=0.214

ASSIGNMENTS=2838
CHECKS=443103
UNSAT
TT=0.126

ASSIGNMENTS=1767
CHECKS=286561
UNSAT
TT=6

UNSAT
TT=1.46

UNSAT
TT=1.812

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel6-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=26.269

UNSAT
TT=38.679

CHECKS=54230100
NODES=219820
UNSAT
TT=40.458

CHECKS=56468200
NODES=229679
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=454.804

CHECKS=2164930000
UNSAT
TT=471.947

CHECKS=2071190000
UNSAT
TT=48.066

ASSIGNMENTS=242956
UNSAT
TT=45.642

ASSIGNMENTS=242956
UNSAT
TT=972.593

CHECKS=160487000
NODES=3047840
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=72.602

ASSIGNMENTS=1410710
CHECKS=193561000
UNSAT
TT=140.936

ASSIGNMENTS=934415
CHECKS=222544000
UNSAT
TT=679.873

UNSAT
TT=538.734

UNSAT
TT=28.471

ASSIGNMENTS=633487
CHECKS=84302100
UNSAT
TT=26.269

ASSIGNMENTS=591023
CHECKS=77526400
UNSAT
TT=76.085

UNSAT
TT=77.7

ASSIGNMENTS=1631870
CHECKS=196656000
UNSAT
TT=65.203

ASSIGNMENTS=1410710
CHECKS=193561000
? (TO)
TT=1800.16

UNSAT
TT=139.635

UNSAT
TT=425.14

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel6-6.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel7-4.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.252

UNSAT
TT=2.233

CHECKS=495812
NODES=804
UNSAT
TT=2.072

CHECKS=425206
NODES=703
UNSAT
TT=1.654

UNSAT
TT=5.612

CHECKS=20398800
UNSAT
TT=8.906

CHECKS=31411900
UNSAT
TT=2.396

ASSIGNMENTS=607
UNSAT
TT=2.597

ASSIGNMENTS=607
UNSAT
TT=7.046

CHECKS=434406
NODES=2951
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800

UNSAT
TT=0.295

ASSIGNMENTS=1428
CHECKS=647886
UNSAT
TT=0.314

ASSIGNMENTS=1428
CHECKS=647886
UNSAT
TT=1.861

UNSAT
TT=2.063

UNSAT
TT=0.252

ASSIGNMENTS=1281
CHECKS=559705
UNSAT
TT=0.759

ASSIGNMENTS=7199
CHECKS=2187140
UNSAT
TT=1.129

UNSAT
TT=0.517

ASSIGNMENTS=3050
CHECKS=1268800
UNSAT
TT=0.299

ASSIGNMENTS=1475
CHECKS=632049
UNSAT
TT=5.266

UNSAT
TT=2.033

UNSAT
TT=2.43

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel7-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=41.969

UNSAT
TT=69.367

CHECKS=96661500
NODES=163338
UNSAT
TT=80.057

CHECKS=99896700
NODES=172079
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=130.077

ASSIGNMENTS=290172
UNSAT
TT=143.436

ASSIGNMENTS=290172
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=95.503

ASSIGNMENTS=803507
CHECKS=276100000
UNSAT
TT=289.205

ASSIGNMENTS=780141
CHECKS=405808000
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=1120.16

UNSAT
TT=41.969

ASSIGNMENTS=383099
CHECKS=130085000
UNSAT
TT=43.306

ASSIGNMENTS=404567
CHECKS=134256000
UNSAT
TT=166.228

UNSAT
TT=228.431

ASSIGNMENTS=1847260
CHECKS=620943000
UNSAT
TT=83.017

ASSIGNMENTS=803507
CHECKS=276100000
? (TO)
TT=1800.17

UNSAT
TT=365.613

UNSAT
TT=811.677

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel7-6.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel7-7.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

csp/graphColoring/
myciel/
normalized-myciel7-8.xml
SAT
TT=0.087

SAT
TT=1.825

CHECKS=15124
NODES=191
SAT
TT=1.483

CHECKS=15654
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.317

SAT
TT=0.228

CHECKS=154093
SAT
TT=0.116

CHECKS=148235
SAT
TT=2.032

ASSIGNMENTS=186
SAT
TT=2.121

ASSIGNMENTS=186
SAT
TT=2.843

CHECKS=13175
NODES=191
SAT
TT=2.791

CHECKS=115048
NODES=130
SAT
TT=2.822

CHECKS=327112
NODES=116
SAT
TT=0.103

ASSIGNMENTS=187
CHECKS=4720
SAT
TT=0.097

ASSIGNMENTS=187
CHECKS=4720
SAT
TT=3.148

SAT
TT=3.042

SAT
TT=0.087

ASSIGNMENTS=187
CHECKS=4720
SAT
TT=0.092

ASSIGNMENTS=187
CHECKS=4720
SAT
TT=1.041

SAT
TT=0.091

ASSIGNMENTS=190
CHECKS=4720
SAT
TT=0.087

ASSIGNMENTS=187
CHECKS=4720
SAT
TT=3.9

SAT
TT=1.77

SAT
TT=1.796

csp/graphColoring/
register/fpsol/
normalized-fpsol2-i-1-55.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.404

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=1.536

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=5.182

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=5.113

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.462

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.434

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (MO)
TT=1013.88

UNSAT
TT=0.404

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.442

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=0.436

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.436

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

csp/graphColoring/
register/fpsol/
normalized-fpsol2-i-2-10.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.311

UNSAT
TT=3.945

CHECKS=20
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=3.931

CHECKS=20
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.198

UNSAT
TT=12.426

CHECKS=27253100
UNSAT
TT=18.294

CHECKS=36397800
UNSAT
TT=3.972

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=3.738

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.348

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.35

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.329

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.33

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=1262.95

UNSAT
TT=0.311

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.317

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

UNSAT
TT=6.531

UNSAT
TT=26.194

csp/graphColoring/
register/fpsol/
normalized-fpsol2-i-2-15.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.329

UNSAT
TT=4.184

CHECKS=60
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.049

CHECKS=60
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.199

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=4.092

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=4.273

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.348

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.347

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.34

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.333

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.332

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.329

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

csp/graphColoring/
register/fpsol/
normalized-fpsol2-i-2-27.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.31

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=4.328

CHECKS=541039
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.209

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=3.759

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=4.29

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.342

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.345

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.334

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.332

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.31

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.313

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800

csp/graphColoring/
register/fpsol/
normalized-fpsol2-i-3-27.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.308

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

UNSAT
TT=4.455

CHECKS=540007
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.199

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=3.828

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=4.329

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.35

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.349

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.325

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.324

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.309

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.308

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/
register/inithx/
normalized-inithx-i-1-10.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.67

UNSAT
TT=11.482

CHECKS=20
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=11.032

CHECKS=20
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.585

UNSAT
TT=2.767

CHECKS=55250
UNSAT
TT=1.984

CHECKS=55250
UNSAT
TT=6.89

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.658

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.749

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.753

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.67

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.672

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=795.334

UNSAT
TT=0.729

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.679

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.15

UNSAT
TT=10.421

UNSAT
TT=38.23

csp/graphColoring/
register/inithx/
normalized-inithx-i-1-45.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.722

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=7.126

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.129

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800

UNSAT
TT=0.734

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.734

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (MO)
TT=1719.15

UNSAT
TT=0.733

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.732

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.722

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.752

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
?
TT=481.099

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

csp/graphColoring/
register/inithx/
normalized-inithx-i-2-15.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.5

UNSAT
TT=8.297

CHECKS=30
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=7.754

CHECKS=30
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.811

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=5.388

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=5.389

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.565

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
UNSAT
TT=0.566

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.5

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
UNSAT
TT=0.535

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.545

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
UNSAT
TT=0.567

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

csp/graphColoring/
register/inithx/
normalized-inithx-i-2-20.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.511

UNSAT
TT=8.287

CHECKS=40
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=7.589

CHECKS=40
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.845

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=5.451

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=5.72

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.521

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.521

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.535

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.537

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.53

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.511

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

csp/graphColoring/
register/inithx/
normalized-inithx-i-2-31.xml
SAT
TT=0.547

SAT
TT=9.356

CHECKS=373091
NODES=645
SAT
TT=8.148

CHECKS=365150
NODES=0
SAT
TT=2.015

SAT
TT=3.001

CHECKS=1773630
SAT
TT=2.428

CHECKS=1740680
SAT
TT=10.84

ASSIGNMENTS=615
SAT
TT=12.82

ASSIGNMENTS=615
SAT
TT=66.4

CHECKS=280233
NODES=645
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=74.178

CHECKS=68345400
NODES=5466
SAT
TT=0.564

ASSIGNMENTS=644
CHECKS=28196
SAT
TT=0.569

ASSIGNMENTS=644
CHECKS=28196
SAT
TT=33.08

SAT
TT=22.615

SAT
TT=0.565

ASSIGNMENTS=644
CHECKS=28196
SAT
TT=0.562

ASSIGNMENTS=644
CHECKS=28289
SAT
TT=3.121

SAT
TT=0.642

ASSIGNMENTS=1356
CHECKS=145724
SAT
TT=0.547

ASSIGNMENTS=644
CHECKS=28196
SAT
TT=23.921

SAT
TT=6.249

SAT
TT=14.673

csp/graphColoring/
register/inithx/
normalized-inithx-i-3-20.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.513

UNSAT
TT=7.517

CHECKS=40
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=7.516

CHECKS=40
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.945

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=5.755

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=5.46

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.553

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.551

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.548

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.552

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.513

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.537

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

csp/graphColoring/
register/inithx/
normalized-inithx-i-3-28.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.5

UNSAT
TT=151.806

CHECKS=198485000
NODES=9861
UNSAT
TT=164.989

CHECKS=198894000
NODES=9861
UNSAT
TT=1.959

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=5.721

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=5.994

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.555

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.555

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.542

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.534

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.502

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.5

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

csp/graphColoring/
register/inithx/
normalized-inithx-i-3-30.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.499

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=5.585

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=5.499

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.526

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=19
UNSAT
TT=0.525

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=19
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.536

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=19
UNSAT
TT=0.499

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=19
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.551

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=19
UNSAT
TT=0.553

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=19
? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

csp/graphColoring/
register/mulsol/
normalized-mulsol-i-1-05.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.142

UNSAT
TT=1.983

CHECKS=10
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.063

CHECKS=10
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.51

UNSAT
TT=0.362

CHECKS=3998
UNSAT
TT=0.194

CHECKS=3998
UNSAT
TT=2.4

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.441

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=4.962

CHECKS=23870
NODES=144
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.157

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.156

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=2.406

UNSAT
TT=2.25

UNSAT
TT=0.143

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.142

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=1.463

UNSAT
TT=0.145

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.146

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=5.228

UNSAT
TT=2.05

UNSAT
TT=2.155

csp/graphColoring/
register/mulsol/
normalized-mulsol-i-1-25.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.133

UNSAT
TT=2.185

CHECKS=50
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.065

CHECKS=50
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.517

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=2.503

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.492

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.154

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.153

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.141

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.146

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.133

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.134

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/
register/mulsol/
normalized-mulsol-i-1-49.xml
SAT
TT=0.148

SAT
TT=2.258

CHECKS=176336
NODES=197
SAT
TT=2.294

CHECKS=156715
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.491

SAT
TT=0.464

CHECKS=350054
SAT
TT=0.299

CHECKS=395865
SAT
TT=3.601

ASSIGNMENTS=147
SAT
TT=3.581

ASSIGNMENTS=147
SAT
TT=7.226

CHECKS=139292
NODES=197
SAT
TT=945.29

CHECKS=6929180000
NODES=1961250
SAT
TT=6.673

CHECKS=10990800
NODES=1366
SAT
TT=0.159

ASSIGNMENTS=194
CHECKS=8147
SAT
TT=0.16

ASSIGNMENTS=194
CHECKS=8147
SAT
TT=17.127

SAT
TT=12.083

SAT
TT=0.149

ASSIGNMENTS=194
CHECKS=8147
SAT
TT=0.148

ASSIGNMENTS=194
CHECKS=8172
SAT
TT=1.445

SAT
TT=0.149

ASSIGNMENTS=193
CHECKS=8174
SAT
TT=0.149

ASSIGNMENTS=194
CHECKS=8147
SAT
TT=16.898

SAT
TT=3.45

SAT
TT=6.75

csp/graphColoring/
register/mulsol/
normalized-mulsol-i-2-05.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.143

UNSAT
TT=1.918

CHECKS=10
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.08

CHECKS=10
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.513

UNSAT
TT=0.358

CHECKS=3914
UNSAT
TT=0.194

CHECKS=3914
UNSAT
TT=2.433

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.591

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=5.325

CHECKS=24912
NODES=144
? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.152

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.159

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=2.371

UNSAT
TT=2.397

UNSAT
TT=0.143

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.143

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=1.264

UNSAT
TT=0.144

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.144

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=5.25

UNSAT
TT=1.803

UNSAT
TT=2.513

csp/graphColoring/
register/mulsol/
normalized-mulsol-i-2-20.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.142

UNSAT
TT=1.916

CHECKS=40
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.918

CHECKS=40
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.516

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=2.258

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.645

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.152

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.152

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.143

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.143

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.142

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.143

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

csp/graphColoring/
register/mulsol/
normalized-mulsol-i-3-30.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.132

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=2.414

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.695

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.147

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
UNSAT
TT=0.147

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.132

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
UNSAT
TT=0.145

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.143

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
UNSAT
TT=0.142

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
? (TO)
TT=1800.24

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

csp/graphColoring/
register/mulsol/
normalized-mulsol-i-4-29.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.131

UNSAT
TT=1.957

CHECKS=58
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.953

CHECKS=58
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.514

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=2.406

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.58

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.154

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=9
UNSAT
TT=0.156

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=9
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.147

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=9
UNSAT
TT=0.148

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=9
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

UNSAT
TT=0.131

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=9
UNSAT
TT=0.144

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=9
? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

csp/graphColoring/
register/mulsol/
normalized-mulsol-i-4-30.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.144

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=2.286

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.642

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.156

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
UNSAT
TT=0.159

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.146

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
UNSAT
TT=0.146

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.144

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
UNSAT
TT=0.145

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=7
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

csp/graphColoring/
register/mulsol/
normalized-mulsol-i-5-10.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.137

UNSAT
TT=1.962

CHECKS=20
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.154

CHECKS=20
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.525

UNSAT
TT=1.197

CHECKS=2915630
UNSAT
TT=1.406

CHECKS=4182160
UNSAT
TT=2.576

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.247

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.158

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.159

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=599.726

UNSAT
TT=0.145

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.145

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=584.386

UNSAT
TT=0.137

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.146

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=7.199

UNSAT
TT=11.879

csp/graphColoring/
register/zeroin/
normalized-zeroin-i-1-45.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.151

UNSAT
TT=2.111

CHECKS=90
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.234

CHECKS=90
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=2.465

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.703

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.163

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.163

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (MO)
TT=1491.88

UNSAT
TT=0.151

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.151

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.153

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.151

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

csp/graphColoring/
register/zeroin/
normalized-zeroin-i-2-28.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.129

UNSAT
TT=2.018

CHECKS=56
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.057

CHECKS=56
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=2.073

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.302

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.143

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=12
UNSAT
TT=0.145

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=12
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.13

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=12
UNSAT
TT=0.129

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=12
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.131

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=12
UNSAT
TT=0.13

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=12
? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

csp/graphColoring/
register/zeroin/
normalized-zeroin-i-2-30.xml
SAT
TT=0.134

SAT
TT=2.1

CHECKS=88469
NODES=211
SAT
TT=2.184

CHECKS=80672
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.442

SAT
TT=0.418

CHECKS=342900
SAT
TT=0.266

CHECKS=364654
SAT
TT=3.089

ASSIGNMENTS=180
SAT
TT=3.405

ASSIGNMENTS=181
SAT
TT=5.408

CHECKS=66237
NODES=211
? (TO)
TT=1800

SAT
TT=5.947

CHECKS=8384530
NODES=1681
SAT
TT=0.145

ASSIGNMENTS=209
CHECKS=7365
SAT
TT=0.145

ASSIGNMENTS=209
CHECKS=7365
SAT
TT=8.523

SAT
TT=7.132

SAT
TT=0.136

ASSIGNMENTS=209
CHECKS=7365
SAT
TT=0.137

ASSIGNMENTS=208
CHECKS=7440
SAT
TT=1.237

SAT
TT=0.166

ASSIGNMENTS=1478
CHECKS=42809
SAT
TT=0.134

ASSIGNMENTS=209
CHECKS=7365
SAT
TT=12.88

SAT
TT=2.639

SAT
TT=4.418

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/
school/
normalized-school1-13.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.862

UNSAT
TT=4.596

CHECKS=98
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=4.963

CHECKS=98
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.543

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=9.372

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=9.631

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.91

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
UNSAT
TT=0.916

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.88

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
UNSAT
TT=0.879

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.867

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
UNSAT
TT=0.862

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=770.38

csp/graphColoring/
school/
normalized-school1-14.xml
SAT
TT=1.275

SAT
TT=5.576

CHECKS=135370
NODES=394
SAT
TT=6.366

CHECKS=240254
NODES=0
SAT
TT=2.546

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=13.139

ASSIGNMENTS=42
SAT
TT=60.937

ASSIGNMENTS=36
SAT
TT=213.252

CHECKS=1252360
NODES=4342
SAT
TT=213.082

CHECKS=250656000
NODES=154749
SAT
TT=162.371

CHECKS=11939600
NODES=770
SAT
TT=1.322

ASSIGNMENTS=49
CHECKS=162052
SAT
TT=1.322

ASSIGNMENTS=49
CHECKS=162052
SAT
TT=20.137

SAT
TT=14.993

SAT
TT=1.349

ASSIGNMENTS=49
CHECKS=162052
SAT
TT=54.496

ASSIGNMENTS=6839
CHECKS=19371800
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=12.362

ASSIGNMENTS=2412
CHECKS=4713990
SAT
TT=1.275

ASSIGNMENTS=49
CHECKS=162052
SAT
TT=14.605

SAT
TT=5.897

SAT
TT=11.224

csp/graphColoring/
school/
normalized-school1-15.xml
SAT
TT=1.291

SAT
TT=5.604

CHECKS=151940
NODES=392
SAT
TT=5.734

CHECKS=192716
NODES=0
SAT
TT=2.573

SAT
TT=18.06

CHECKS=19456000
SAT
TT=24.727

CHECKS=30608900
SAT
TT=401.352

ASSIGNMENTS=1288
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

SAT
TT=161.971

CHECKS=375977
NODES=1210
SAT
TT=141.767

CHECKS=2547270
NODES=861
SAT
TT=145.389

CHECKS=12491400
NODES=854
SAT
TT=1.35

ASSIGNMENTS=82
CHECKS=176794
SAT
TT=1.348

ASSIGNMENTS=82
CHECKS=176794
SAT
TT=22.093

SAT
TT=15.605

SAT
TT=1.291

ASSIGNMENTS=82
CHECKS=176794
SAT
TT=52.895

ASSIGNMENTS=8627
CHECKS=18924100
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=21.335

ASSIGNMENTS=5858
CHECKS=8747820
SAT
TT=1.322

ASSIGNMENTS=82
CHECKS=176794
SAT
TT=22.34

SAT
TT=6.388

SAT
TT=9.828

csp/graphColoring/
school/
normalized-school1-16.xml
SAT
TT=0.81

SAT
TT=5.447

CHECKS=167334
NODES=388
SAT
TT=8.327

CHECKS=585034
NODES=388
SAT
TT=2.593

SAT
TT=19.81

CHECKS=24507200
SAT
TT=21.7

CHECKS=27787400
SAT
TT=1688.24

ASSIGNMENTS=3800
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=453.869

CHECKS=5659770
NODES=14077
SAT
TT=159.304

CHECKS=2599340
NODES=803
SAT
TT=148.596

CHECKS=12386700
NODES=947
SAT
TT=0.824

ASSIGNMENTS=88
CHECKS=39026
SAT
TT=0.831

ASSIGNMENTS=88
CHECKS=39026
SAT
TT=23.469

SAT
TT=15.134

SAT
TT=0.817

ASSIGNMENTS=88
CHECKS=39026
SAT
TT=64.986

ASSIGNMENTS=603120
CHECKS=111908000
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=1.26

ASSIGNMENTS=6362
CHECKS=749587
SAT
TT=0.81

ASSIGNMENTS=87
CHECKS=39026
SAT
TT=15.865

SAT
TT=6.581

SAT
TT=10.344

csp/graphColoring/
school/
normalized-school1-nsh-12.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.728

UNSAT
TT=4.054

CHECKS=24
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=3.947

CHECKS=24
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.938

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=7.467

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.556

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.741

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.754

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.735

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.728

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.749

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.744

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.87

UNSAT
TT=322.882

UNSAT
TT=250.583

csp/graphColoring/
school/
normalized-school1-nsh-13.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.695

UNSAT
TT=4.025

CHECKS=26
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=3.765

CHECKS=26
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=7.536

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=6.726

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.751

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.744

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800

UNSAT
TT=0.695

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.742

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.743

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.737

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.18

UNSAT
TT=453.034

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

csp/graphColoring/
school/
normalized-school1-nsh-14.xml
SAT
TT=1.011

SAT
TT=15.463

CHECKS=10629900
NODES=3196
SAT
TT=5.142

CHECKS=211503
NODES=0
SAT
TT=1793.84

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=18.083

ASSIGNMENTS=60
SAT
TT=67.647

ASSIGNMENTS=39
SAT
TT=91.319

CHECKS=639822
NODES=2013
SAT
TT=1322.25

CHECKS=5553030000
NODES=4202190
SAT
TT=73.332

CHECKS=8221210
NODES=794
SAT
TT=1.059

ASSIGNMENTS=50
CHECKS=129183
SAT
TT=1.068

ASSIGNMENTS=50
CHECKS=129183
SAT
TT=15.706

SAT
TT=12.538

SAT
TT=1.011

ASSIGNMENTS=50
CHECKS=129183
SAT
TT=42.58

ASSIGNMENTS=6251
CHECKS=14470000
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=12.777

ASSIGNMENTS=4754
CHECKS=5415860
SAT
TT=1.07

ASSIGNMENTS=50
CHECKS=129183
SAT
TT=13.176

SAT
TT=6.238

SAT
TT=8.39

csp/graphColoring/
school/
normalized-school1-nsh-15.xml
SAT
TT=1.072

SAT
TT=5.302

CHECKS=451754
NODES=510
SAT
TT=6.984

CHECKS=816486
NODES=510
SAT
TT=27.003

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=396.32

ASSIGNMENTS=1489
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

SAT
TT=92.386

CHECKS=571967
NODES=2306
SAT
TT=120.719

CHECKS=225342000
NODES=153214
SAT
TT=73.808

CHECKS=8942680
NODES=963
SAT
TT=1.11

ASSIGNMENTS=97
CHECKS=157057
SAT
TT=1.095

ASSIGNMENTS=97
CHECKS=157057
SAT
TT=16.923

SAT
TT=12.815

SAT
TT=1.086

ASSIGNMENTS=97
CHECKS=157057
SAT
TT=36.852

ASSIGNMENTS=8745
CHECKS=13517100
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=14.345

ASSIGNMENTS=5358
CHECKS=5432380
SAT
TT=1.072

ASSIGNMENTS=98
CHECKS=156767
SAT
TT=16.38

SAT
TT=5.118

SAT
TT=8.881

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/book/
normalized-anna-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.023

UNSAT
TT=0.985

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.012

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.094

UNSAT
TT=0.058

CHECKS=77211
UNSAT
TT=0.04

CHECKS=78412
UNSAT
TT=1.149

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.163

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.22

CHECKS=10700
NODES=207
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
UNSAT
TT=0.035

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
UNSAT
TT=1.121

UNSAT
TT=1.097

UNSAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
UNSAT
TT=0.026

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
UNSAT
TT=0.676

UNSAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
UNSAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=14
UNSAT
TT=2.372

UNSAT
TT=1.243

UNSAT
TT=1.245

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/book/
normalized-anna-9.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.023

UNSAT
TT=1.065

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.975

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1500.87

UNSAT
TT=471.789

CHECKS=1719900000
UNSAT
TT=463.632

CHECKS=1704970000
UNSAT
TT=1.015

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.038

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=145.856

CHECKS=22651200
NODES=402628
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.035

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.035

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=291.473

UNSAT
TT=21.715

UNSAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.025

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=7.534

UNSAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=74.711

UNSAT
TT=1.879

UNSAT
TT=3.555

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/
sgb/book/
normalized-david-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=0.924

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.989

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.079

UNSAT
TT=0.039

CHECKS=420
UNSAT
TT=0.02

CHECKS=420
UNSAT
TT=0.897

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.921

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.162

CHECKS=11038
NODES=170
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=0.032

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.032

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=1.092

UNSAT
TT=1.005

UNSAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.627

UNSAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.019

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=2.129

UNSAT
TT=1.141

UNSAT
TT=1.303

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/book/
normalized-david-8.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=0.9

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.977

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.748

UNSAT
TT=0.045

CHECKS=49829
UNSAT
TT=0.029

CHECKS=50665
UNSAT
TT=1

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.956

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=12.187

CHECKS=2285510
NODES=46404
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.034

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.032

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=5.919

UNSAT
TT=2.483

UNSAT
TT=0.019

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=1.425

UNSAT
TT=0.019

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.02

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=6.303

UNSAT
TT=1.293

UNSAT
TT=1.647

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/book/
normalized-homer-12.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.074

UNSAT
TT=1310.15

CHECKS=2489650000
NODES=4037900
UNSAT
TT=1279.2

CHECKS=2489670000
NODES=4037900
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=1.916

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.628

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.091

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.094

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.082

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.077

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.074

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.074

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=89.42

UNSAT
TT=165.118

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/book/
normalized-huck-10.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.015

UNSAT
TT=0.966

CHECKS=40043
NODES=94
UNSAT
TT=0.918

CHECKS=8025
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1796.74

UNSAT
TT=0.038

CHECKS=38942
UNSAT
TT=0.026

CHECKS=38733
UNSAT
TT=0.816

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.822

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=491.328

CHECKS=87762900
NODES=3973090
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.028

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=56.95

UNSAT
TT=0.017

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.015

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=61.378

UNSAT
TT=0.015

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.017

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=525.532

UNSAT
TT=2.532

UNSAT
TT=11.818

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/book/
normalized-jean-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.015

UNSAT
TT=0.902

CHECKS=10
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.824

CHECKS=10
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.053

UNSAT
TT=0.026

CHECKS=265
UNSAT
TT=0.015

CHECKS=265
UNSAT
TT=0.748

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.757

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.873

CHECKS=3864
NODES=175
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.028

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.025

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=1.112

UNSAT
TT=0.836

UNSAT
TT=0.015

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.015

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.509

UNSAT
TT=0.015

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.015

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=1.771

UNSAT
TT=0.818

UNSAT
TT=0.84

csp/graphColoring/sgb/games/
normalized-games120-8.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.026

UNSAT
TT=0.989

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.022

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.107

UNSAT
TT=71.205

CHECKS=217260000
UNSAT
TT=79.359

CHECKS=255602000
UNSAT
TT=1.024

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.072

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=8.988

CHECKS=525431
NODES=46397
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.041

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=5.874

UNSAT
TT=3.856

UNSAT
TT=0.029

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.029

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=4.243

UNSAT
TT=0.03

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=0.026

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=4
UNSAT
TT=4.486

UNSAT
TT=1.605

UNSAT
TT=1.563

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/miles/
normalized-miles1000-40.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.112

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=2.229

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.407

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=0.126

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.133

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (MO)
TT=1612.27

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.112

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.113

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=0.126

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.127

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/miles/
normalized-miles1500-30.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.198

UNSAT
TT=2.214

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.112

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.653

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=3.01

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.697

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.215

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.211

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.2

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.2

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.2

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.198

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/miles/
normalized-miles1500-72.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.182

UNSAT
TT=2.128

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=2.135

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=2.993

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=3.104

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.204

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
UNSAT
TT=0.199

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
? (MO)
TT=956.69

? (MO)
TT=488.64

UNSAT
TT=0.182

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
UNSAT
TT=0.187

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.199

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
UNSAT
TT=0.198

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=5
? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/miles/
normalized-miles1500-73.xml
SAT
TT=0.189

SAT
TT=2.357

CHECKS=350364
NODES=128
SAT
TT=2.31

CHECKS=335666
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.622

SAT
TT=0.626

CHECKS=682749
SAT
TT=0.47

CHECKS=742486
SAT
TT=4.018

ASSIGNMENTS=56
SAT
TT=3.911

ASSIGNMENTS=56
SAT
TT=15.513

CHECKS=502271
NODES=848
SAT
TT=8.563

CHECKS=3523770
NODES=288
SAT
TT=11.322

CHECKS=12696400
NODES=955
SAT
TT=0.222

ASSIGNMENTS=127
CHECKS=10476
SAT
TT=0.217

ASSIGNMENTS=127
CHECKS=10476
SAT
TT=46.209

SAT
TT=17.949

SAT
TT=0.203

ASSIGNMENTS=127
CHECKS=10476
SAT
TT=0.202

ASSIGNMENTS=126
CHECKS=10476
SAT
TT=1.401

SAT
TT=0.695

ASSIGNMENTS=12194
CHECKS=685702
SAT
TT=0.189

ASSIGNMENTS=127
CHECKS=10475
SAT
TT=72.818

SAT
TT=4.551

SAT
TT=11.586

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/
sgb/miles/
normalized-miles500-10.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.046

UNSAT
TT=1.182

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.19

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.171

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=1708.98

CHECKS=8019910000
UNSAT
TT=1.539

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.284

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.059

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=11
UNSAT
TT=0.059

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=11
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=179.749

UNSAT
TT=0.046

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=11
UNSAT
TT=0.047

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=11
UNSAT
TT=103.186

UNSAT
TT=0.047

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=11
UNSAT
TT=0.048

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=11
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

UNSAT
TT=6.868

UNSAT
TT=7.457

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/miles/
normalized-miles500-15.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.045

UNSAT
TT=1.204

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.209

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.172

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=1.354

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.529

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.059

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.058

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=0.045

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.047

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=0.045

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.048

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/miles/
normalized-miles500-19.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.044

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=1.284

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.292

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.058

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6
UNSAT
TT=0.057

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.044

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6
UNSAT
TT=0.045

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.047

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6
UNSAT
TT=0.048

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=6
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/miles/
normalized-miles750-15.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.075

UNSAT
TT=1.336

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.358

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.285

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=1.651

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.966

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.086

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.085

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=0.08

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.081

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=0.075

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
UNSAT
TT=0.077

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=3
? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/miles/
normalized-miles750-29.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.074

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=1.913

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.715

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=0.092

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.091

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.074

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.074

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=0.081

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
UNSAT
TT=0.082

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=2
? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/miles/
normalized-miles750-31.xml
SAT
TT=0.08

SAT
TT=1.615

CHECKS=49632
NODES=128
SAT
TT=1.496

CHECKS=49299
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.294

SAT
TT=11.6

CHECKS=56627200
SAT
TT=17.111

CHECKS=86464500
SAT
TT=2.289

ASSIGNMENTS=93
SAT
TT=2.143

ASSIGNMENTS=93
SAT
TT=3.571

CHECKS=71743
NODES=761
SAT
TT=3.162

CHECKS=2529390
NODES=1525
SAT
TT=2.74

CHECKS=1839400
NODES=449
SAT
TT=0.097

ASSIGNMENTS=122
CHECKS=4443
SAT
TT=0.095

ASSIGNMENTS=122
CHECKS=4443
SAT
TT=6.362

SAT
TT=5.398

SAT
TT=0.081

ASSIGNMENTS=122
CHECKS=4443
SAT
TT=0.096

ASSIGNMENTS=986
CHECKS=20827
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=0.195

ASSIGNMENTS=4572
CHECKS=122022
SAT
TT=0.08

ASSIGNMENTS=122
CHECKS=4443
SAT
TT=13.487

SAT
TT=2.029

SAT
TT=3.2

csp/graphColoring/sgb/miles/
normalized-miles750-5.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.079

UNSAT
TT=1.422

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.388

CHECKS=0
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.288

UNSAT
TT=0.187

CHECKS=165603
UNSAT
TT=0.119

CHECKS=321911
UNSAT
TT=1.824

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.774

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.531

CHECKS=6650
NODES=177
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.093

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.092

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=1.821

UNSAT
TT=1.695

UNSAT
TT=0.079

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.08

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.999

UNSAT
TT=0.08

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.079

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=4.055

UNSAT
TT=1.859

UNSAT
TT=2.036

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/queen/
normalized-queen12-12-11.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.095

UNSAT
TT=1.487

CHECKS=22
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.501

CHECKS=22
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.349

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=1.993

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.995

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.108

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.106

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800

UNSAT
TT=0.097

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.095

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=0.098

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.095

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.16

UNSAT
TT=14.58

UNSAT
TT=11.473

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/queen/
normalized-queen12-12-14.xml
SAT
TT=0.933

SAT
TT=11.095

CHECKS=11316300
NODES=57864
SAT
TT=3.649

CHECKS=2120150
NODES=10938
SAT
TT=55.645

SAT
TT=154.714

CHECKS=773226000
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=110.288

ASSIGNMENTS=44105
SAT
TT=58.191

ASSIGNMENTS=19702
SAT
TT=205.791

CHECKS=14143100
NODES=235468
SAT
TT=3.249

CHECKS=354296
NODES=402
SAT
TT=3.097

CHECKS=1304330
NODES=723
SAT
TT=8.236

ASSIGNMENTS=18697
CHECKS=2180330
SAT
TT=170.448

ASSIGNMENTS=1183720
CHECKS=229036000
SAT
TT=13.117

SAT
TT=104.096

SAT
TT=9.722

ASSIGNMENTS=224516
CHECKS=28313200
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

SAT
TT=8.248

ASSIGNMENTS=134597
CHECKS=20559400
SAT
TT=0.933

ASSIGNMENTS=18697
CHECKS=2180330
SAT
TT=318.771

SAT
TT=4.296

SAT
TT=18.875

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/queen/
normalized-queen15-15-15.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/graphColoring/
sgb/queen/
normalized-queen8-12-10.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.051

UNSAT
TT=1.183

CHECKS=39
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=1.187

CHECKS=39
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.195

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=1.366

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.667

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1723.99

CHECKS=208480000
NODES=3957090
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=0.063

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.062

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=105.644

UNSAT
TT=0.052

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.053

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=169.906

UNSAT
TT=0.052

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
UNSAT
TT=0.051

ASSIGNMENTS=0
CHECKS=1
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

UNSAT
TT=6.037

UNSAT
TT=6.162

csp/graphColoring/
sgb/queen/
normalized-queen8-12-12.xml
SAT
TT=0.055

SAT
TT=1.633

CHECKS=137462
NODES=1126
SAT
TT=1.517

CHECKS=60950
NODES=381
SAT
TT=0.199

SAT
TT=12.677

CHECKS=59749000
SAT
TT=17.781

CHECKS=86672000
SAT
TT=4.378

ASSIGNMENTS=442
SAT
TT=3.867

ASSIGNMENTS=216
SAT
TT=3.927

CHECKS=210328
NODES=4735
SAT
TT=2.047

CHECKS=168024
NODES=294
SAT
TT=1.885

CHECKS=235212
NODES=159
SAT
TT=0.068

ASSIGNMENTS=142
CHECKS=11878
SAT
TT=0.07

ASSIGNMENTS=142
CHECKS=11878
SAT
TT=3.126

SAT
TT=2.829

SAT
TT=0.055

ASSIGNMENTS=109
CHECKS=8748
SAT
TT=0.217

ASSIGNMENTS=8173
CHECKS=284561
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=0.097

ASSIGNMENTS=1686
CHECKS=64223
SAT
TT=0.076

ASSIGNMENTS=644
CHECKS=54793
SAT
TT=4.109

SAT
TT=1.566

SAT
TT=1.665

csp/graphColoring/sgb/queen/
normalized-queen8-8-9.xml
SAT
TT=0.945

SAT
TT=6.942

CHECKS=7271100
NODES=47953
SAT
TT=19.133

CHECKS=23097800
NODES=153835
SAT
TT=1.142

SAT
TT=18.018

CHECKS=87082500
SAT
TT=17.548

CHECKS=84234100
SAT
TT=43.731

ASSIGNMENTS=29099
SAT
TT=2.509

ASSIGNMENTS=366
SAT
TT=20.799

CHECKS=3301950
NODES=75147
SAT
TT=1.394

CHECKS=265219
NODES=1167
SAT
TT=2

CHECKS=6091950
NODES=8222
SAT
TT=13.614

ASSIGNMENTS=47433
CHECKS=7006570
SAT
TT=13.746

ASSIGNMENTS=47433
CHECKS=7006570
SAT
TT=23.637

SAT
TT=43.667

SAT
TT=364.165

ASSIGNMENTS=7729060
CHECKS=774419000
SAT
TT=1.778

ASSIGNMENTS=36783
CHECKS=3795950
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=3.717

ASSIGNMENTS=72578
CHECKS=7359090
SAT
TT=0.945

ASSIGNMENTS=19063
CHECKS=1970120
SAT
TT=57.955

SAT
TT=92.648

SAT
TT=3.746

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-05.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.008

UNSAT
TT=0.726

CHECKS=643
NODES=22
UNSAT
TT=0.75

CHECKS=599
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.034

UNSAT
TT=2.443

CHECKS=3959920
UNSAT
TT=5.118

CHECKS=10436200
UNSAT
TT=0.755

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=0.734

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=8.26

CHECKS=4136230
NODES=291029
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=116
CHECKS=3395
UNSAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=116
CHECKS=3395
UNSAT
TT=0.946

UNSAT
TT=0.727

UNSAT
TT=0.008

ASSIGNMENTS=25
CHECKS=992
UNSAT
TT=0.018

ASSIGNMENTS=593
CHECKS=13494
UNSAT
TT=40.869

UNSAT
TT=0.012

ASSIGNMENTS=168
CHECKS=4148
UNSAT
TT=0.009

ASSIGNMENTS=67
CHECKS=2098
UNSAT
TT=1.174

UNSAT
TT=0.626

UNSAT
TT=0.626

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-08.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.068

UNSAT
TT=1.152

CHECKS=14842
NODES=228
UNSAT
TT=1.073

CHECKS=11920
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=0.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=1.265

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.47

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=0.707

ASSIGNMENTS=8136
CHECKS=979305
UNSAT
TT=0.7

ASSIGNMENTS=8136
CHECKS=979305
UNSAT
TT=1.479

UNSAT
TT=1.238

UNSAT
TT=0.171

ASSIGNMENTS=1864
CHECKS=226773
UNSAT
TT=0.359

ASSIGNMENTS=7467
CHECKS=490913
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=0.462

ASSIGNMENTS=4265
CHECKS=520719
UNSAT
TT=0.068

ASSIGNMENTS=641
CHECKS=77490
UNSAT
TT=3.267

UNSAT
TT=1.532

UNSAT
TT=1.595

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-10.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.236

UNSAT
TT=1.425

CHECKS=264202
NODES=2381
UNSAT
TT=1.085

CHECKS=13661
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=8.325

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=1.791

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1.861

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=8.616

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=7.408

ASSIGNMENTS=1965
CHECKS=309611
UNSAT
TT=85.589

UNSAT
TT=162.938

UNSAT
TT=5.558

ASSIGNMENTS=44199
CHECKS=7929500
UNSAT
TT=5.771

ASSIGNMENTS=53286
CHECKS=8357500
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=61.827

ASSIGNMENTS=294993
CHECKS=66933400
UNSAT
TT=0.236

ASSIGNMENTS=1965
CHECKS=309611
UNSAT
TT=70.84

UNSAT
TT=3.075

UNSAT
TT=13.409

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-11.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.221

UNSAT
TT=2.868

CHECKS=1423860
NODES=10110
UNSAT
TT=1.221

CHECKS=15578
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=82.683

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=2.006

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.326

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=9.417

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=8.657

ASSIGNMENTS=10883
CHECKS=2129330
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=52.487

ASSIGNMENTS=357213
CHECKS=74332800
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=1.601

ASSIGNMENTS=10883
CHECKS=2129330
UNSAT
TT=1722.22

UNSAT
TT=11.672

UNSAT
TT=81.18

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-12.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.399

UNSAT
TT=5.091

CHECKS=3259090
NODES=21500
UNSAT
TT=1.399

CHECKS=21535
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=2.193

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=2.355

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=9.377

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=11.22

ASSIGNMENTS=18116
CHECKS=4177240
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=607.708

ASSIGNMENTS=3351570
CHECKS=779363000
UNSAT
TT=491.989

ASSIGNMENTS=2758640
CHECKS=641731000
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=3.512

ASSIGNMENTS=18116
CHECKS=4177240
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

UNSAT
TT=48.373

UNSAT
TT=271.214

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-15.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.935

UNSAT
TT=1428.17

CHECKS=1485810000
NODES=6657340
UNSAT
TT=1.935

CHECKS=66002
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=3.568

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=4.414

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=11.092

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=15.438

ASSIGNMENTS=28686
CHECKS=8513550
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=7.82

ASSIGNMENTS=28686
CHECKS=8513550
? (TO)
TT=1801.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-16.xml
UNSAT
TT=2.343

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

UNSAT
TT=2.343

CHECKS=114052
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=4.181

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=6.574

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=11.73

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=25.783

ASSIGNMENTS=58043
CHECKS=18972200
? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=18.253

ASSIGNMENTS=58043
CHECKS=18972200
? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-20.xml
UNSAT
TT=5.291

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=5.291

CHECKS=533629
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=8.396

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=8.179

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=16.988

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=1246.92

ASSIGNMENTS=1612090
CHECKS=927161000
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=59.336

ASSIGNMENTS=106711
CHECKS=36221900
UNSAT
TT=1129.61

ASSIGNMENTS=1612090
CHECKS=927161000
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-29.xml
UNSAT
TT=32.486

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

UNSAT
TT=33.389

CHECKS=2444860
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=32.486

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=33.811

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (MO)
TT=1637.31

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-30.xml
UNSAT
TT=33.602

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=33.602

CHECKS=2076730
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=37.308

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=33.771

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (MO)
TT=1297.68

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-35.xml
UNSAT
TT=64.511

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=68.248

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=64.511

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (MO)
TT=1200.16

? (MO)
TT=821.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-36.xml
UNSAT
TT=54.709

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

UNSAT
TT=54.709

CHECKS=3017070
NODES=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=71.09

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=78.083

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (MO)
TT=1200.06

? (MO)
TT=1150.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (exit code)
TT=1125.36

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-43.xml
UNSAT
TT=145.621

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=145.621

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=181.6

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (MO)
TT=1399.32

? (MO)
TT=1143.88

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (exit code)
TT=157.168

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

?
TT=216.778

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-45.xml
UNSAT
TT=346.213

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=346.213

ASSIGNMENTS=0
UNSAT
TT=361.143

ASSIGNMENTS=0
? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (MO)
TT=1373.71

? (MO)
TT=1049.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (exit code)
TT=205.771

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

?
TT=787.547

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-48.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (MO)
TT=1436.19

? (MO)
TT=1025.43

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (exit code)
TT=363.877

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

?
TT=586.121

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-54.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (MO)
TT=1489.49

? (MO)
TT=409.51

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (exit code)
TT=621.692

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

?
TT=205.855

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

csp/jobShop-e0ddr1/
normalized-e0ddr1-10-by-5-10.xml
SAT
TT=0.071

SAT
TT=2.13

CHECKS=2161970
NODES=1472
SAT
TT=2.016

CHECKS=1071380
NODES=523
SAT
TT=0.09

SAT
TT=23.583

CHECKS=54863000
SAT
TT=34.537

CHECKS=75404300
SAT
TT=1.368

ASSIGNMENTS=80
SAT
TT=1.724

ASSIGNMENTS=80
SAT
TT=1.394

CHECKS=0
NODES=51
SAT
TT=17.175

CHECKS=192326000
NODES=157539
SAT
TT=1.637

CHECKS=9190790
NODES=5254
SAT
TT=0.256

ASSIGNMENTS=1109
CHECKS=1808670
SAT
TT=0.257

ASSIGNMENTS=1109
CHECKS=1808670
SAT
TT=480.631

SAT
TT=33.895

SAT
TT=0.345

ASSIGNMENTS=1770
CHECKS=2556840
SAT
TT=0.073

ASSIGNMENTS=858
CHECKS=388319
SAT
TT=0.735

SAT
TT=0.199

ASSIGNMENTS=1629
CHECKS=1166960
SAT
TT=0.071

ASSIGNMENTS=405
CHECKS=364951
SAT
TT=33.062

SAT
TT=1.056

SAT
TT=1.548

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/jobShop-e0ddr1/
normalized-e0ddr1-10-by-5-1.xml
SAT
TT=0.04

SAT
TT=1.916

CHECKS=800721
NODES=537
SAT
TT=1.922

CHECKS=308967
NODES=84
SAT
TT=0.089

SAT
TT=17.473

CHECKS=40952800
SAT
TT=18.261

CHECKS=47069000
SAT
TT=1.361

ASSIGNMENTS=71
SAT
TT=1.451

ASSIGNMENTS=71
SAT
TT=1.283

CHECKS=0
NODES=224
SAT
TT=50.803

CHECKS=572198000
NODES=482337
SAT
TT=1.123

CHECKS=368461
NODES=76
SAT
TT=0.117

ASSIGNMENTS=592
CHECKS=656739
SAT
TT=0.116

ASSIGNMENTS=592
CHECKS=656739
SAT
TT=397.674

SAT
TT=23.088

SAT
TT=0.107

ASSIGNMENTS=768
CHECKS=642394
SAT
TT=0.111

ASSIGNMENTS=1512
CHECKS=667826
SAT
TT=0.729

SAT
TT=0.062

ASSIGNMENTS=574
CHECKS=254308
SAT
TT=0.04

ASSIGNMENTS=109
CHECKS=136278
SAT
TT=13.89

SAT
TT=1.102

SAT
TT=1.428

csp/jobShop-e0ddr1/
normalized-e0ddr1-10-by-5-2.xml
SAT
TT=0.022

SAT
TT=1.954

CHECKS=214299
NODES=122
SAT
TT=1.775

CHECKS=149112
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.085

SAT
TT=18.561

CHECKS=50904200
SAT
TT=17.468

CHECKS=49716500
SAT
TT=1.406

ASSIGNMENTS=94
SAT
TT=1.335

ASSIGNMENTS=94
SAT
TT=1.295

CHECKS=0
NODES=93
SAT
TT=16.01

CHECKS=183593000
NODES=152233
SAT
TT=0.966

CHECKS=415127
NODES=76
SAT
TT=0.05

ASSIGNMENTS=278
CHECKS=103472
SAT
TT=0.048

ASSIGNMENTS=278
CHECKS=103472
SAT
TT=460.467

SAT
TT=24.576

SAT
TT=0.048

ASSIGNMENTS=602
CHECKS=213659
SAT
TT=0.04

ASSIGNMENTS=315
CHECKS=147814
SAT
TT=0.733

SAT
TT=0.022

ASSIGNMENTS=68
CHECKS=18956
SAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=102
CHECKS=33530
SAT
TT=11.033

SAT
TT=1.094

SAT
TT=1.362

csp/jobShop-e0ddr1/
normalized-e0ddr1-10-by-5-3.xml
SAT
TT=0.048

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

SAT
TT=0.085

SAT
TT=46.991

CHECKS=104102000
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=1.661

ASSIGNMENTS=78
SAT
TT=1.44

ASSIGNMENTS=78
SAT
TT=7.664

CHECKS=0
NODES=46978
SAT
TT=16.75

CHECKS=198037000
NODES=166163
SAT
TT=3.645

CHECKS=36341900
NODES=21036
SAT
TT=8.89

ASSIGNMENTS=78
SAT
TT=7.154

ASSIGNMENTS=243
CHECKS=256362
SAT
TT=511.733

SAT
TT=43.776

SAT
TT=26.031

ASSIGNMENTS=162078
CHECKS=205884000
SAT
TT=0.048

ASSIGNMENTS=533
CHECKS=187006
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=0.058

ASSIGNMENTS=603
CHECKS=202779
SAT
TT=0.054

ASSIGNMENTS=243
CHECKS=256362
SAT
TT=101.047

SAT
TT=1.012

SAT
TT=1.4

csp/jobShop-e0ddr1/
normalized-e0ddr1-10-by-5-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.021

SAT
TT=1.81

CHECKS=370352
NODES=215
SAT
TT=1.719

CHECKS=60534
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.086

SAT
TT=11.555

CHECKS=33484100
SAT
TT=23.971

CHECKS=62311600
SAT
TT=1.531

ASSIGNMENTS=84
SAT
TT=1.565

ASSIGNMENTS=84
SAT
TT=1.287

CHECKS=0
NODES=144
SAT
TT=6.551

CHECKS=64047300
NODES=53959
SAT
TT=1.004

CHECKS=959150
NODES=478
SAT
TT=0.294

ASSIGNMENTS=1124
CHECKS=2269000
SAT
TT=0.295

ASSIGNMENTS=1124
CHECKS=2269000
SAT
TT=361.781

SAT
TT=25.582

SAT
TT=0.339

ASSIGNMENTS=1562
CHECKS=2748610
SAT
TT=0.068

ASSIGNMENTS=808
CHECKS=381872
SAT
TT=278.94

SAT
TT=0.034

ASSIGNMENTS=241
CHECKS=76621
SAT
TT=0.021

ASSIGNMENTS=47
CHECKS=13160
SAT
TT=9.996

SAT
TT=0.981

SAT
TT=1.564

csp/jobShop-e0ddr1/
normalized-e0ddr1-10-by-5-5.xml
SAT
TT=0.022

SAT
TT=1.873

CHECKS=217212
NODES=131
SAT
TT=1.779

CHECKS=59168
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.089

SAT
TT=12.363

CHECKS=28161500
SAT
TT=18.061

CHECKS=42792800
SAT
TT=1.331

ASSIGNMENTS=90
SAT
TT=1.441

ASSIGNMENTS=90
SAT
TT=1.376

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.494

CHECKS=6252450
NODES=4874
SAT
TT=0.948

CHECKS=498468
NODES=165
SAT
TT=0.034

ASSIGNMENTS=82
CHECKS=24868
SAT
TT=0.035

ASSIGNMENTS=82
CHECKS=24868
SAT
TT=369.898

SAT
TT=25.411

SAT
TT=0.022

ASSIGNMENTS=84
CHECKS=29880
SAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=134
CHECKS=38333
SAT
TT=0.867

SAT
TT=0.035

ASSIGNMENTS=257
CHECKS=78520
SAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=69
CHECKS=23514
SAT
TT=10.634

SAT
TT=1.096

SAT
TT=1.534

csp/jobShop-e0ddr1/
normalized-e0ddr1-10-by-5-6.xml
SAT
TT=0.024

SAT
TT=1.854

CHECKS=74689
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.882

CHECKS=67056
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.093

SAT
TT=0.411

CHECKS=9948
SAT
TT=0.025

CHECKS=11088
SAT
TT=1.402

ASSIGNMENTS=97
SAT
TT=1.311

ASSIGNMENTS=97
SAT
TT=1.574

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.324

CHECKS=2893570
NODES=2065
SAT
TT=1.014

CHECKS=379891
NODES=53
SAT
TT=0.04

ASSIGNMENTS=107
CHECKS=46400
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=107
CHECKS=46400
SAT
TT=326.105

SAT
TT=24.763

SAT
TT=0.026

ASSIGNMENTS=106
CHECKS=45160
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=60
CHECKS=17712
SAT
TT=0.869

SAT
TT=0.034

ASSIGNMENTS=312
CHECKS=77931
SAT
TT=0.033

ASSIGNMENTS=151
CHECKS=66370
SAT
TT=11.252

SAT
TT=1.026

SAT
TT=1.507

csp/jobShop-e0ddr1/
normalized-e0ddr1-10-by-5-7.xml
SAT
TT=0.036

SAT
TT=1.856

CHECKS=221884
NODES=134
SAT
TT=1.764

CHECKS=90807
NODES=0
SAT
TT=892.633

SAT
TT=0.432

CHECKS=11521
SAT
TT=0.025

CHECKS=11490
SAT
TT=1.364

ASSIGNMENTS=78
SAT
TT=1.455

ASSIGNMENTS=78
SAT
TT=1.306

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.227

CHECKS=2732830
NODES=2015
SAT
TT=1.14

CHECKS=2733380
NODES=1552
SAT
TT=1.102

ASSIGNMENTS=5457
CHECKS=8306140
SAT
TT=1.012

ASSIGNMENTS=5457
CHECKS=8306140
SAT
TT=507.081

SAT
TT=23.812

SAT
TT=1.069

ASSIGNMENTS=5449
CHECKS=8336000
SAT
TT=0.055

ASSIGNMENTS=591
CHECKS=247544
SAT
TT=0.736

SAT
TT=0.036

ASSIGNMENTS=267
CHECKS=86154
SAT
TT=0.066

ASSIGNMENTS=405
CHECKS=335762
SAT
TT=11.036

SAT
TT=1.149

SAT
TT=1.627

csp/jobShop-e0ddr1/
normalized-e0ddr1-10-by-5-8.xml
SAT
TT=0.042

SAT
TT=2.11

CHECKS=911704
NODES=524
SAT
TT=1.941

CHECKS=526002
NODES=167
SAT
TT=0.083

SAT
TT=23.731

CHECKS=50989800
SAT
TT=34.618

CHECKS=77524700
SAT
TT=1.347

ASSIGNMENTS=75
SAT
TT=1.359

ASSIGNMENTS=75
SAT
TT=1.273

CHECKS=0
NODES=98
SAT
TT=14.155

CHECKS=171275000
NODES=144154
SAT
TT=1.363

CHECKS=5646380
NODES=3338
SAT
TT=0.213

ASSIGNMENTS=968
CHECKS=1408010
SAT
TT=0.214

ASSIGNMENTS=968
CHECKS=1408010
SAT
TT=391.208

SAT
TT=23.506

SAT
TT=0.119

ASSIGNMENTS=1165
CHECKS=826614
SAT
TT=0.151

ASSIGNMENTS=2191
CHECKS=1059170
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=0.043

ASSIGNMENTS=386
CHECKS=118237
SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=196
CHECKS=169534
SAT
TT=22.407

SAT
TT=1.142

SAT
TT=1.37

csp/jobShop-e0ddr1/
normalized-e0ddr1-10-by-5-9.xml
SAT
TT=0.024

SAT
TT=1.963

CHECKS=68293
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.826

CHECKS=100238
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.088

SAT
TT=0.43

CHECKS=9015
SAT
TT=0.027

CHECKS=15480
SAT
TT=1.474

ASSIGNMENTS=82
SAT
TT=1.366

ASSIGNMENTS=82
SAT
TT=1.371

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.047

CHECKS=503160
NODES=155
SAT
TT=1.015

CHECKS=357657
NODES=28
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=80
CHECKS=29728
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=80
CHECKS=29728
SAT
TT=376.645

SAT
TT=24.355

SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=88
CHECKS=34690
SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=114
CHECKS=44617
SAT
TT=0.728

SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=465
CHECKS=113488
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=74
CHECKS=21156
SAT
TT=12.301

SAT
TT=1.07

SAT
TT=1.527

csp/jobShop-e0ddr2/
normalized-e0ddr2-10-by-5-10.xml
SAT
TT=0.03

SAT
TT=1.988

CHECKS=80049
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.962

CHECKS=78774
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.087

SAT
TT=0.448

CHECKS=123601
SAT
TT=0.072

CHECKS=123347
SAT
TT=1.402

ASSIGNMENTS=119
SAT
TT=1.319

ASSIGNMENTS=119
SAT
TT=1.507

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=2.369

CHECKS=16008800
NODES=11365
SAT
TT=1.101

CHECKS=1401440
NODES=632
SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=131
CHECKS=60017
SAT
TT=0.041

ASSIGNMENTS=131
CHECKS=60017
SAT
TT=606.856

SAT
TT=33.463

SAT
TT=0.03

ASSIGNMENTS=131
CHECKS=60017
SAT
TT=0.065

ASSIGNMENTS=664
CHECKS=324080
SAT
TT=0.696

SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=447
CHECKS=102740
SAT
TT=0.104

ASSIGNMENTS=598
CHECKS=729398
SAT
TT=12.943

SAT
TT=1.051

SAT
TT=1.605

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/jobShop-e0ddr2/
normalized-e0ddr2-10-by-5-1.xml
SAT
TT=0.042

SAT
TT=2.258

CHECKS=383132
NODES=157
SAT
TT=2.056

CHECKS=393670
NODES=74
SAT
TT=581.235

SAT
TT=25.607

CHECKS=53621400
SAT
TT=35.523

CHECKS=78798500
SAT
TT=1.445

ASSIGNMENTS=79
SAT
TT=1.456

ASSIGNMENTS=79
SAT
TT=1.518

CHECKS=0
NODES=147
SAT
TT=649.692

CHECKS=8266180000
NODES=6301700
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=0.057

ASSIGNMENTS=333
CHECKS=180816
SAT
TT=0.058

ASSIGNMENTS=333
CHECKS=180816
SAT
TT=588.304

SAT
TT=79.168

SAT
TT=0.05

ASSIGNMENTS=455
CHECKS=225497
SAT
TT=0.549

ASSIGNMENTS=7576
CHECKS=4406720
SAT
TT=1207.63

SAT
TT=1.876

ASSIGNMENTS=9623
CHECKS=14270000
SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=194
CHECKS=161857
SAT
TT=12.14

SAT
TT=1.145

SAT
TT=1.618

csp/jobShop-e0ddr2/
normalized-e0ddr2-10-by-5-2.xml
SAT
TT=0.531

SAT
TT=2.324

CHECKS=1225870
NODES=510
SAT
TT=2.073

CHECKS=912247
NODES=213
SAT
TT=913.923

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=1.564

ASSIGNMENTS=124
SAT
TT=1.568

ASSIGNMENTS=124
SAT
TT=2.338

CHECKS=0
NODES=7566
SAT
TT=470.696

CHECKS=5821060000
NODES=4477470
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=0.964

ASSIGNMENTS=4676
CHECKS=7693550
SAT
TT=0.902

ASSIGNMENTS=4676
CHECKS=7693550
SAT
TT=760.781

SAT
TT=143.742

SAT
TT=0.855

ASSIGNMENTS=4481
CHECKS=7567780
SAT
TT=9.294

ASSIGNMENTS=46248
CHECKS=75939100
SAT
TT=969.822

SAT
TT=4.511

ASSIGNMENTS=21955
CHECKS=34145900
SAT
TT=0.531

ASSIGNMENTS=2658
CHECKS=4139960
SAT
TT=462.925

SAT
TT=1.14

SAT
TT=1.53

csp/jobShop-e0ddr2/
normalized-e0ddr2-10-by-5-3.xml
SAT
TT=0.027

SAT
TT=2.151

CHECKS=376894
NODES=132
SAT
TT=2.231

CHECKS=502465
NODES=119
SAT
TT=0.09

SAT
TT=36.938

CHECKS=85497800
SAT
TT=41.013

CHECKS=102981000
SAT
TT=1.312

ASSIGNMENTS=106
SAT
TT=1.531

ASSIGNMENTS=106
SAT
TT=1.642

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=278.599

CHECKS=3618530000
NODES=2705990
SAT
TT=1.21

CHECKS=834162
NODES=306
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=116
CHECKS=43828
SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=116
CHECKS=43828
SAT
TT=657.615

SAT
TT=43.189

SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=116
CHECKS=43828
SAT
TT=0.254

ASSIGNMENTS=3457
CHECKS=1757560
SAT
TT=0.741

SAT
TT=0.049

ASSIGNMENTS=535
CHECKS=162875
SAT
TT=0.192

ASSIGNMENTS=867
CHECKS=1412520
SAT
TT=12.439

SAT
TT=1.118

SAT
TT=1.538

csp/jobShop-e0ddr2/
normalized-e0ddr2-10-by-5-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.039

SAT
TT=2.045

CHECKS=93785
NODES=59
SAT
TT=2.05

CHECKS=213236
NODES=0
SAT
TT=917.112

SAT
TT=11.89

CHECKS=27986800
SAT
TT=17.53

CHECKS=43080200
SAT
TT=1.315

ASSIGNMENTS=96
SAT
TT=1.316

ASSIGNMENTS=96
SAT
TT=1.581

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.382

CHECKS=4480230
NODES=3042
SAT
TT=0.988

CHECKS=716294
NODES=240
SAT
TT=0.041

ASSIGNMENTS=157
CHECKS=61183
SAT
TT=0.044

ASSIGNMENTS=157
CHECKS=61183
SAT
TT=654.893

SAT
TT=56.34

SAT
TT=0.062

ASSIGNMENTS=271
CHECKS=301022
SAT
TT=0.049

ASSIGNMENTS=441
CHECKS=226645
SAT
TT=0.795

SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=430
CHECKS=85956
SAT
TT=0.053

ASSIGNMENTS=356
CHECKS=223583
SAT
TT=13.18

SAT
TT=1.35

SAT
TT=1.75

csp/jobShop-e0ddr2/
normalized-e0ddr2-10-by-5-5.xml
SAT
TT=0.027

SAT
TT=2.132

CHECKS=93659
NODES=55
SAT
TT=2.113

CHECKS=158355
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.09

SAT
TT=5.305

CHECKS=12314800
SAT
TT=6.83

CHECKS=16518700
SAT
TT=1.431

ASSIGNMENTS=126
SAT
TT=1.574

ASSIGNMENTS=126
SAT
TT=1.666

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=18.288

CHECKS=211533000
NODES=154694
SAT
TT=0.961

CHECKS=623887
NODES=133
SAT
TT=0.041

ASSIGNMENTS=129
CHECKS=47583
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=129
CHECKS=47583
SAT
TT=621.616

SAT
TT=32.056

SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=140
CHECKS=52025
SAT
TT=0.101

ASSIGNMENTS=1481
CHECKS=649009
SAT
TT=0.804

SAT
TT=0.058

ASSIGNMENTS=770
CHECKS=206938
SAT
TT=0.214

ASSIGNMENTS=1135
CHECKS=1526920
SAT
TT=13.228

SAT
TT=1.133

SAT
TT=1.632

csp/jobShop-e0ddr2/
normalized-e0ddr2-10-by-5-6.xml
SAT
TT=0.024

SAT
TT=2.148

CHECKS=77662
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.983

CHECKS=83706
NODES=0
SAT
TT=6.963

SAT
TT=0.439

CHECKS=11661
SAT
TT=0.026

CHECKS=11820
SAT
TT=1.666

ASSIGNMENTS=116
SAT
TT=1.473

ASSIGNMENTS=116
SAT
TT=1.495

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=81.684

CHECKS=1032650000
NODES=752558
SAT
TT=0.983

CHECKS=817493
NODES=285
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=98
CHECKS=28390
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=98
CHECKS=28390
SAT
TT=527.972

SAT
TT=44.227

SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=101
CHECKS=28205
SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=132
CHECKS=49420
SAT
TT=0.737

SAT
TT=0.041

ASSIGNMENTS=453
CHECKS=104408
SAT
TT=0.106

ASSIGNMENTS=580
CHECKS=666959
SAT
TT=14.06

SAT
TT=1.048

SAT
TT=1.611

csp/jobShop-e0ddr2/
normalized-e0ddr2-10-by-5-7.xml
SAT
TT=0.033

SAT
TT=2.192

CHECKS=164227
NODES=78
SAT
TT=2.105

CHECKS=131660
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.088

SAT
TT=22.191

CHECKS=50858900
SAT
TT=34.553

CHECKS=78611000
SAT
TT=1.416

ASSIGNMENTS=94
SAT
TT=1.424

ASSIGNMENTS=94
SAT
TT=1.461

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=31.752

CHECKS=408507000
NODES=303278
SAT
TT=1.261

CHECKS=1448290
NODES=765
SAT
TT=0.044

ASSIGNMENTS=123
CHECKS=67668
SAT
TT=0.043

ASSIGNMENTS=123
CHECKS=67668
SAT
TT=562.881

SAT
TT=33.077

SAT
TT=0.033

ASSIGNMENTS=136
CHECKS=92360
SAT
TT=0.09

ASSIGNMENTS=989
CHECKS=524401
SAT
TT=0.886

SAT
TT=0.035

ASSIGNMENTS=356
CHECKS=79279
SAT
TT=0.068

ASSIGNMENTS=396
CHECKS=405967
SAT
TT=17.694

SAT
TT=1.052

SAT
TT=1.891

csp/jobShop-e0ddr2/
normalized-e0ddr2-10-by-5-8.xml
SAT
TT=0.031

SAT
TT=2.048

CHECKS=76584
NODES=50
SAT
TT=2.03

CHECKS=275722
NODES=50
SAT
TT=0.091

SAT
TT=23.927

CHECKS=55631500
SAT
TT=22.552

CHECKS=55360200
SAT
TT=1.342

ASSIGNMENTS=105
SAT
TT=1.357

ASSIGNMENTS=105
SAT
TT=1.66

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=427.733

CHECKS=5018690000
NODES=3748410
SAT
TT=1.902

CHECKS=12604700
NODES=7104
SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=105
CHECKS=47856
SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=105
CHECKS=47856
SAT
TT=582.756

SAT
TT=57

SAT
TT=0.031

ASSIGNMENTS=132
CHECKS=63974
SAT
TT=0.246

ASSIGNMENTS=3354
CHECKS=1722590
SAT
TT=0.86

SAT
TT=0.06

ASSIGNMENTS=677
CHECKS=224229
SAT
TT=0.154

ASSIGNMENTS=933
CHECKS=1045000
SAT
TT=13.504

SAT
TT=1.093

SAT
TT=1.574

csp/jobShop-e0ddr2/
normalized-e0ddr2-10-by-5-9.xml
SAT
TT=0.067

SAT
TT=2.438

CHECKS=1733440
NODES=721
SAT
TT=41.146

CHECKS=482244000
NODES=177039
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=0.54

CHECKS=236579
SAT
TT=0.137

CHECKS=253143
SAT
TT=1.457

ASSIGNMENTS=78
SAT
TT=1.482

ASSIGNMENTS=78
SAT
TT=1.467

CHECKS=0
NODES=345
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=0.122

ASSIGNMENTS=632
CHECKS=699534
SAT
TT=0.124

ASSIGNMENTS=632
CHECKS=699534
SAT
TT=709.368

SAT
TT=713.885

SAT
TT=0.121

ASSIGNMENTS=823
CHECKS=744498
SAT
TT=0.838

ASSIGNMENTS=9003
CHECKS=6963660
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=0.529

ASSIGNMENTS=3595
CHECKS=3765360
SAT
TT=0.067

ASSIGNMENTS=391
CHECKS=357091
SAT
TT=25.635

SAT
TT=1.05

SAT
TT=1.594

csp/jobShop-enddr1/
normalized-enddr1-10-by-5-10.xml
SAT
TT=0.024

SAT
TT=2.147

CHECKS=679272
NODES=414
SAT
TT=1.894

CHECKS=93882
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.089

SAT
TT=14.493

CHECKS=36727600
SAT
TT=17.543

CHECKS=48194800
SAT
TT=1.319

ASSIGNMENTS=100
SAT
TT=1.303

ASSIGNMENTS=100
SAT
TT=1.426

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=18.483

CHECKS=232760000
NODES=182333
SAT
TT=1.027

CHECKS=350650
NODES=34
SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=167
CHECKS=59974
SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=167
CHECKS=59974
SAT
TT=603.964

SAT
TT=26.163

SAT
TT=0.032

ASSIGNMENTS=219
CHECKS=71708
SAT
TT=0.034

ASSIGNMENTS=191
CHECKS=100464
SAT
TT=0.691

SAT
TT=0.034

ASSIGNMENTS=280
CHECKS=74362
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=90
CHECKS=24993
SAT
TT=13.711

SAT
TT=1.111

SAT
TT=1.539

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/jobShop-enddr1/
normalized-enddr1-10-by-5-1.xml
SAT
TT=0.03

SAT
TT=1.825

CHECKS=144023
NODES=87
SAT
TT=1.928

CHECKS=68382
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.084

SAT
TT=0.437

CHECKS=8796
SAT
TT=0.022

CHECKS=9422
SAT
TT=1.372

ASSIGNMENTS=77
SAT
TT=1.283

ASSIGNMENTS=77
SAT
TT=1.314

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.105

CHECKS=1503470
NODES=1002
SAT
TT=1.085

CHECKS=481897
NODES=111
SAT
TT=0.054

ASSIGNMENTS=166
CHECKS=179465
SAT
TT=0.058

ASSIGNMENTS=166
CHECKS=179465
SAT
TT=377.76

SAT
TT=25.298

SAT
TT=0.054

ASSIGNMENTS=220
CHECKS=243769
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=298
CHECKS=123190
SAT
TT=0.869

SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=263
CHECKS=83667
SAT
TT=0.03

ASSIGNMENTS=149
CHECKS=82904
SAT
TT=11.971

SAT
TT=1.127

SAT
TT=1.452

csp/jobShop-enddr1/
normalized-enddr1-10-by-5-2.xml
SAT
TT=0

SAT
TT=1.881

CHECKS=131380
NODES=84
SAT
TT=2.008

CHECKS=62890
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0

SAT
TT=0.437

CHECKS=10791
SAT
TT=0.026

CHECKS=10601
SAT
TT=1.274

ASSIGNMENTS=95
SAT
TT=1.273

ASSIGNMENTS=95
SAT
TT=1.43

CHECKS=0
NODES=94
SAT
TT=1.175

CHECKS=1810900
NODES=1182
SAT
TT=1.024

CHECKS=326576
NODES=27
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=108
CHECKS=28882
SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=108
CHECKS=28882
SAT
TT=411.026

SAT
TT=25.559

SAT
TT=0.028

ASSIGNMENTS=199
CHECKS=48432
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=43
CHECKS=16466
SAT
TT=0.73

SAT
TT=0.032

ASSIGNMENTS=184
CHECKS=52105
SAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=53
CHECKS=16474
SAT
TT=12.816

SAT
TT=1.102

SAT
TT=1.662

csp/jobShop-enddr1/
normalized-enddr1-10-by-5-3.xml
SAT
TT=0.031

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=1.806

CHECKS=66359
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.09

SAT
TT=0.434

CHECKS=11141
SAT
TT=0.026

CHECKS=12881
SAT
TT=1.444

ASSIGNMENTS=87
SAT
TT=1.311

ASSIGNMENTS=87
SAT
TT=1.321

CHECKS=0
NODES=97
SAT
TT=1.773

CHECKS=9037550
NODES=7058
SAT
TT=0.973

CHECKS=686835
NODES=259
SAT
TT=8.259

ASSIGNMENTS=87
SAT
TT=7.81

ASSIGNMENTS=164
CHECKS=86177
SAT
TT=483.819

SAT
TT=25.174

SAT
TT=1.71

ASSIGNMENTS=8523
CHECKS=13610000
SAT
TT=0.088

ASSIGNMENTS=962
CHECKS=506449
SAT
TT=35.638

SAT
TT=0.031

ASSIGNMENTS=186
CHECKS=54720
SAT
TT=0.031

ASSIGNMENTS=164
CHECKS=86177
SAT
TT=11.333

SAT
TT=1.153

SAT
TT=1.501

csp/jobShop-enddr1/
normalized-enddr1-10-by-5-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.027

SAT
TT=1.965

CHECKS=85445
NODES=57
SAT
TT=1.8

CHECKS=64707
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.092

SAT
TT=0.443

CHECKS=10703
SAT
TT=0.027

CHECKS=12864
SAT
TT=1.338

ASSIGNMENTS=81
SAT
TT=1.557

ASSIGNMENTS=81
SAT
TT=1.481

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=15.838

CHECKS=186854000
NODES=152096
SAT
TT=1.046

CHECKS=389426
NODES=72
SAT
TT=0.206

ASSIGNMENTS=955
CHECKS=1515000
SAT
TT=0.221

ASSIGNMENTS=955
CHECKS=1515000
SAT
TT=388.541

SAT
TT=26.866

SAT
TT=0.165

ASSIGNMENTS=650
CHECKS=1129810
SAT
TT=0.041

ASSIGNMENTS=322
CHECKS=142474
SAT
TT=0.729

SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=340
CHECKS=87647
SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=150
CHECKS=41618
SAT
TT=10.735

SAT
TT=1.115

SAT
TT=1.614

csp/jobShop-enddr1/
normalized-enddr1-10-by-5-5.xml
SAT
TT=0.024

SAT
TT=1.906

CHECKS=79234
NODES=51
SAT
TT=1.876

CHECKS=59842
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.09

SAT
TT=0.441

CHECKS=9769
SAT
TT=0.024

CHECKS=9900
SAT
TT=1.348

ASSIGNMENTS=94
SAT
TT=1.423

ASSIGNMENTS=94
SAT
TT=1.443

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.766

CHECKS=10323700
NODES=7713
SAT
TT=0.949

CHECKS=423380
NODES=39
SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=86
CHECKS=33633
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=86
CHECKS=33633
SAT
TT=440.105

SAT
TT=26.97

SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=94
CHECKS=41578
SAT
TT=0.03

ASSIGNMENTS=146
CHECKS=67156
SAT
TT=0.855

SAT
TT=0.03

ASSIGNMENTS=201
CHECKS=50793
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=75
CHECKS=22087
SAT
TT=11.456

SAT
TT=1.221

SAT
TT=1.517

csp/jobShop-enddr1/
normalized-enddr1-10-by-5-6.xml
SAT
TT=0.022

SAT
TT=1.961

CHECKS=77545
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.949

CHECKS=68813
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.083

SAT
TT=0.431

CHECKS=10968
SAT
TT=0.023

CHECKS=10193
SAT
TT=1.289

ASSIGNMENTS=116
SAT
TT=1.281

ASSIGNMENTS=116
SAT
TT=1.362

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=70.947

CHECKS=797549000
NODES=600199
SAT
TT=0.945

CHECKS=384802
NODES=44
SAT
TT=0.036

ASSIGNMENTS=97
CHECKS=27194
SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=97
CHECKS=27194
SAT
TT=421.396

SAT
TT=26.967

SAT
TT=0.022

ASSIGNMENTS=97
CHECKS=27194
SAT
TT=0.031

ASSIGNMENTS=148
CHECKS=63930
SAT
TT=0.858

SAT
TT=0.029

ASSIGNMENTS=152
CHECKS=42558
SAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=61
CHECKS=17397
SAT
TT=13.231

SAT
TT=0.994

SAT
TT=1.723

csp/jobShop-enddr1/
normalized-enddr1-10-by-5-7.xml
SAT
TT=0.028

SAT
TT=2.034

CHECKS=152019
NODES=90
SAT
TT=1.876

CHECKS=63656
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.092

SAT
TT=0.407

CHECKS=12158
SAT
TT=0.026

CHECKS=12443
SAT
TT=1.456

ASSIGNMENTS=77
SAT
TT=1.328

ASSIGNMENTS=77
SAT
TT=1.568

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.05

CHECKS=1580390
NODES=967
SAT
TT=1.2

CHECKS=375343
NODES=49
SAT
TT=6.973

ASSIGNMENTS=99
CHECKS=52744
SAT
TT=7.271

ASSIGNMENTS=99
CHECKS=52744
SAT
TT=558.023

SAT
TT=26.516

SAT
TT=3.264

ASSIGNMENTS=16349
CHECKS=26298700
SAT
TT=0.033

ASSIGNMENTS=185
CHECKS=77480
SAT
TT=0.679

SAT
TT=0.036

ASSIGNMENTS=325
CHECKS=95015
SAT
TT=0.028

ASSIGNMENTS=99
CHECKS=52744
SAT
TT=11.566

SAT
TT=1.086

SAT
TT=1.48

csp/jobShop-enddr1/
normalized-enddr1-10-by-5-8.xml
SAT
TT=0.024

SAT
TT=1.882

CHECKS=204209
NODES=118
SAT
TT=1.938

CHECKS=104052
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.09

SAT
TT=0.405

CHECKS=10999
SAT
TT=0.023

CHECKS=10863
SAT
TT=1.303

ASSIGNMENTS=85
SAT
TT=1.307

ASSIGNMENTS=85
SAT
TT=1.329

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.178

CHECKS=2214530
NODES=1505
SAT
TT=1.063

CHECKS=593851
NODES=208
SAT
TT=0.035

ASSIGNMENTS=78
CHECKS=33618
SAT
TT=0.036

ASSIGNMENTS=78
CHECKS=33618
SAT
TT=270.916

SAT
TT=28.701

SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=78
CHECKS=33618
SAT
TT=0.029

ASSIGNMENTS=118
CHECKS=62743
SAT
TT=0.743

SAT
TT=0.041

ASSIGNMENTS=473
CHECKS=124309
SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=162
CHECKS=179824
SAT
TT=12.762

SAT
TT=1.085

SAT
TT=1.882

csp/jobShop-enddr1/
normalized-enddr1-10-by-5-9.xml
SAT
TT=0.024

SAT
TT=1.989

CHECKS=81706
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.917

CHECKS=64427
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.083

SAT
TT=0.437

CHECKS=10299
SAT
TT=0.026

CHECKS=9902
SAT
TT=1.278

ASSIGNMENTS=92
SAT
TT=1.355

ASSIGNMENTS=92
SAT
TT=1.456

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=16.433

CHECKS=200890000
NODES=150046
SAT
TT=1.014

CHECKS=458713
NODES=68
SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=84
CHECKS=27265
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=84
CHECKS=27265
SAT
TT=423.176

SAT
TT=27.056

SAT
TT=0.026

ASSIGNMENTS=84
CHECKS=27265
SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=128
CHECKS=46576
SAT
TT=0.74

SAT
TT=0.033

ASSIGNMENTS=214
CHECKS=53725
SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=53
CHECKS=18305
SAT
TT=12.967

SAT
TT=0.989

SAT
TT=1.551

csp/jobShop-enddr2/
normalized-enddr2-10-by-5-10.xml
SAT
TT=0.039

SAT
TT=2.273

CHECKS=100807
NODES=50
SAT
TT=2.176

CHECKS=82498
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.085

SAT
TT=0.445

CHECKS=10310
SAT
TT=0.028

CHECKS=14589
SAT
TT=1.45

ASSIGNMENTS=115
SAT
TT=1.423

ASSIGNMENTS=115
SAT
TT=1.482

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.092

CHECKS=2158980
NODES=1194
SAT
TT=1.064

CHECKS=615114
NODES=134
SAT
TT=0.049

ASSIGNMENTS=234
CHECKS=137475
SAT
TT=0.055

ASSIGNMENTS=234
CHECKS=137475
SAT
TT=633.551

SAT
TT=34.979

SAT
TT=0.059

ASSIGNMENTS=392
CHECKS=271692
SAT
TT=0.064

ASSIGNMENTS=928
CHECKS=358946
SAT
TT=0.69

SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=495
CHECKS=91888
SAT
TT=0.044

ASSIGNMENTS=172
CHECKS=164309
SAT
TT=15.575

SAT
TT=1.01

SAT
TT=1.706

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon 112v4
AC
Abscon 112v4
ESAC
bpsolver
2008-06-27
casper
zao
casper
zito
choco2_dwdeg
2008-06-26
choco2_impwdeg
2008-06-26
Concrete + CPS4J
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine
2008-05-30
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine
2008-05-30
cpHydra
k_10
cpHydra
k_40
galac
E
galac
M
MDG-noprobe
2008-06-27
MDG-probe
2008-06-27
Minion/Tailor
2008-07-04
Mistral-option
1.314
Mistral-prime
1.313
SAT4J CSP
2008-06-13
Sugar
v1.13+minisat
Sugar
v1.13+picosat
csp/jobShop-enddr2/
normalized-enddr2-10-by-5-1.xml
SAT
TT=0.03

SAT
TT=2.224

CHECKS=95363
NODES=50
SAT
TT=2.183

CHECKS=140590
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.09

SAT
TT=8.42

CHECKS=19342100
SAT
TT=13.657

CHECKS=33436400
SAT
TT=1.483

ASSIGNMENTS=93
SAT
TT=1.695

ASSIGNMENTS=93
SAT
TT=1.605

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=9.687

CHECKS=113123000
NODES=82225
SAT
TT=1.104

CHECKS=1307380
NODES=626
SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=93
CHECKS=36141
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=93
CHECKS=36141
SAT
TT=737.009

SAT
TT=44.035

SAT
TT=0.03

ASSIGNMENTS=110
CHECKS=54206
SAT
TT=0.206

ASSIGNMENTS=2876
CHECKS=1426260
SAT
TT=0.8

SAT
TT=0.105

ASSIGNMENTS=1075
CHECKS=543240
SAT
TT=0.039

ASSIGNMENTS=164
CHECKS=140498
SAT
TT=13.359

SAT
TT=1.296

SAT
TT=1.574

csp/jobShop-enddr2/
normalized-enddr2-10-by-5-2.xml
SAT
TT=0.023

SAT
TT=2.346

CHECKS=798936
NODES=240
SAT
TT=2.226

CHECKS=728669
NODES=156
SAT
TT=0.096

SAT
TT=22.321

CHECKS=49229000
SAT
TT=34.63

CHECKS=72253000
SAT
TT=1.431

ASSIGNMENTS=72
SAT
TT=1.356

ASSIGNMENTS=72
SAT
TT=1.464

CHECKS=0
NODES=144
SAT
TT=184.002

CHECKS=2251530000
NODES=1653180
SAT
TT=1.254

CHECKS=4357310
NODES=2469
SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=124
CHECKS=28824
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=124
CHECKS=28824
SAT
TT=671.782

SAT
TT=35.436

SAT
TT=0.023

ASSIGNMENTS=124
CHECKS=28824
SAT
TT=0.17

ASSIGNMENTS=2297
CHECKS=1281430
SAT
TT=0.71

SAT
TT=0.342

ASSIGNMENTS=2620
CHECKS=2245800
SAT
TT=0.043

ASSIGNMENTS=187
CHECKS=167385
SAT
TT=25.344

SAT
TT=1.113

SAT
TT=1.675

csp/jobShop-enddr2/
normalized-enddr2-10-by-5-3.xml
SAT
TT=0.029

SAT
TT=2.219

CHECKS=89982
NODES=50
SAT
TT=2.154

CHECKS=395901
NODES=80
SAT
TT=0.093

SAT
TT=11.925

CHECKS=27448300
SAT
TT=20.47

CHECKS=48462300
SAT
TT=1.334

ASSIGNMENTS=120
SAT
TT=1.339

ASSIGNMENTS=120
SAT
TT=1.537

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=80.993

CHECKS=1072350000
NODES=760045
SAT
TT=1.017

CHECKS=1245070
NODES=526
SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=131
CHECKS=61207
SAT
TT=0.043

ASSIGNMENTS=131
CHECKS=61207
SAT
TT=632.646

SAT
TT=34.879

SAT
TT=0.029

ASSIGNMENTS=140
CHECKS=65870
SAT
TT=0.056

ASSIGNMENTS=446
CHECKS=263949
SAT
TT=0.747

SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=360
CHECKS=90437
SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=170
CHECKS=175452
SAT
TT=15.11

SAT
TT=1.062

SAT
TT=1.703

csp/jobShop-enddr2/
normalized-enddr2-10-by-5-4.xml
SAT
TT=0.024

SAT
TT=2.146

CHECKS=93451
NODES=51
SAT
TT=2.159

CHECKS=82534
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.09

SAT
TT=0.449

CHECKS=12461
SAT
TT=0.025

CHECKS=12742
SAT
TT=1.297

ASSIGNMENTS=112
SAT
TT=1.421

ASSIGNMENTS=112
SAT
TT=1.73

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=3.939

CHECKS=40174100
NODES=28376
SAT
TT=1.015

CHECKS=494330
NODES=91
SAT
TT=0.036

ASSIGNMENTS=117
CHECKS=31966
SAT
TT=0.036

ASSIGNMENTS=117
CHECKS=31966
SAT
TT=699.853

SAT
TT=34.419

SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=117
CHECKS=31966
SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=125
CHECKS=40061
SAT
TT=0.785

SAT
TT=0.033

ASSIGNMENTS=269
CHECKS=51686
SAT
TT=0.025

ASSIGNMENTS=58
CHECKS=28193
SAT
TT=14.635

SAT
TT=1.276

SAT
TT=1.728

csp/jobShop-enddr2/
normalized-enddr2-10-by-5-5.xml
SAT
TT=0.029

SAT
TT=2.263

CHECKS=90914
NODES=50
SAT
TT=2.529

CHECKS=83784
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.091

SAT
TT=0.436

CHECKS=11537
SAT
TT=0.024

CHECKS=12428
SAT
TT=1.335

ASSIGNMENTS=119
SAT
TT=1.467

ASSIGNMENTS=119
SAT
TT=1.568

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.051

CHECKS=1553080
NODES=795
SAT
TT=0.997

CHECKS=616552
NODES=114
SAT
TT=0.04

ASSIGNMENTS=131
CHECKS=50569
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=131
CHECKS=50569
SAT
TT=848.889

SAT
TT=35.682

SAT
TT=0.029

ASSIGNMENTS=136
CHECKS=52257
SAT
TT=0.054

ASSIGNMENTS=533
CHECKS=257896
SAT
TT=0.737

SAT
TT=0.031

ASSIGNMENTS=274
CHECKS=51676
SAT
TT=0.032

ASSIGNMENTS=133
CHECKS=81058
SAT
TT=14.093

SAT
TT=1.094

SAT
TT=1.6

csp/jobShop-ewddr2/
normalized-ewddr2-10-by-5-10.xml
SAT
TT=0.024

SAT
TT=2.284

CHECKS=94847
NODES=50
SAT
TT=2.21

CHECKS=86949
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.091

SAT
TT=0.442

CHECKS=8350
SAT
TT=0.025

CHECKS=12213
SAT
TT=1.427

ASSIGNMENTS=111
SAT
TT=1.329

ASSIGNMENTS=111
SAT
TT=1.511

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=17.227

CHECKS=212752000
NODES=150035
SAT
TT=0.978

CHECKS=594420
NODES=47
SAT
TT=0.044

ASSIGNMENTS=169
CHECKS=62594
SAT
TT=0.042

ASSIGNMENTS=169
CHECKS=62594
SAT
TT=731.896

SAT
TT=35.951

SAT
TT=0.028

ASSIGNMENTS=198
CHECKS=72856
SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=166
CHECKS=44820
SAT
TT=0.674

SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=117
CHECKS=28418
SAT
TT=0.025

ASSIGNMENTS=112
CHECKS=43785
SAT
TT=14.985

SAT
TT=1.122

SAT
TT=1.589

csp/jobShop-ewddr2/
normalized-ewddr2-10-by-5-1.xml
SAT
TT=0.027

SAT
TT=2.202

CHECKS=106942
NODES=50
SAT
TT=2.168

CHECKS=158061
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.084

SAT
TT=0.436

CHECKS=12768
SAT
TT=0.026

CHECKS=11873
SAT
TT=1.313

ASSIGNMENTS=107
SAT
TT=1.549

ASSIGNMENTS=107
SAT
TT=1.477

CHECKS=0
NODES=50
SAT
TT=1.16

CHECKS=2003870
NODES=1056
SAT
TT=1.069

CHECKS=1629790
NODES=746
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=100
CHECKS=32817
SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=100
CHECKS=32817
SAT
TT=999.851

SAT
TT=37.766

SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=126
CHECKS=43158
SAT
TT=0.035

ASSIGNMENTS=244
CHECKS=107883
SAT
TT=0.679

SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=414
CHECKS=89668
SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=150
CHECKS=138506
SAT
TT=15.839

SAT
TT=1.133

SAT
TT=1.59

csp/jobShop-ewddr2/
normalized-ewddr2-10-by-5-2.xml
SAT
TT=0.024

SAT
TT=2.203

CHECKS=92868
NODES=50
SAT
TT=2.145

CHECKS=79179
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.085

SAT
TT=0.448

CHECKS=16800
SAT
TT=0.028

CHECKS=17879
SAT
TT=1.371

ASSIGNMENTS=109
SAT
TT=1.45

ASSIGNMENTS=109
SAT
TT=1.444

CHECKS=0
NODES=51
SAT
TT=55.831

CHECKS=667799000
NODES=471122
SAT
TT=1.154

CHECKS=1730920
NODES=846
SAT
TT=0.037

ASSIGNMENTS=129
CHECKS=26301
SAT
TT=0.038

ASSIGNMENTS=129
CHECKS=26301
SAT
TT=694.12

SAT
TT=34.608

SAT
TT=0.024

ASSIGNMENTS=129
CHECKS=26301
SAT
TT=0.183

ASSIGNMENTS=2323
CHECKS=1212270
SAT
TT=0.686

SAT
TT=0.027

ASSIGNMENTS=129
CHECKS=28861
SAT
TT=0.092

ASSIGNMENTS=456
CHECKS=564012
SAT
TT=15.203

SAT
TT=1.126

SAT
TT=1.596

csp/jobShop-ewddr2/
normalized-ewddr2-10-by-5-3.xml
SAT
TT=0.031

SAT
TT=2.322

CHECKS=227152
NODES=91
SAT
TT=2.277

CHECKS=163750
NODES=0
SAT
TT=0.091

SAT
TT=0.446

CHECKS=12876
SAT
TT=0.025

CHECKS=10434
SAT
TT=1.329