MAX-CSP 2008 Competition: solvers results per benchmarks

Result page for benchmark
csp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-36.xml

Jump to solvers results

General information on the benchmark

Namecsp/haystacks/
normalized-haystacks-36.xml
MD5SUM87cb5ec2449d8c75ad96262506f10f50
Bench Category2-ARY-INT (binary constraints in intension)
Best result obtained on this benchmarkMSAT TO
Best Number of falsified constraints1
Best CPU time to get the best result obtained on this benchmark3600.03
Satisfiable
(Un)Satisfiability was proved
Number of variables1296
Number of constraints22715
Maximum constraint arity2
Maximum domain size36
Number of constraints which are defined in extension0
Number of constraints which are defined in intension22715
Global constraints used (with number of constraints)

Results of the different solvers on this benchmark

Solver NameTraceIDAnswerNumber of falsified constraintsCPU timeWall clock time
Concrete + CSP4J - MCRW Engine 2008-05-301112353MSAT (TO)1 3600.03 3627.92
AbsconMax 112 pc-d1112356MSAT (TO)2 1727.45 4000.1
AbsconMax 112 pc-w1112355MSAT (TO)2 1752.62 4000.11
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-301112354MSAT (TO)2 3600.04 3618.42
Sugar++ v1.13+minisat-inc1112357? 207.488 215.863
Sugar v1.13+minisat1112358? 221.702 260.966

Additionnal information

This section presents information obtained from the best job displayed in the list (i.e. solvers whose names are not hidden).

Number of falsified constraints: 1
Solution found:
17 25 22 20 2 21 13 4 8 17 20 4 22 23 17 4 2 31 28 30 1 32 5 19 11 1 30 5 34 26 4 0 4 29 29 35 35 23 17 31 7 35 30 33 31 2 10 26 11 18 12 21
12 33 24 27 4 31 30 3 35 12 13 7 13 18 1 32 11 33 23 16 20 28 10 30 4 21 8 33 20 21 13 33 19 25 3 6 5 8 8 10 14 21 34 30 25 11 26 5 26 21 33
17 27 10 16 0 21 24 29 25 32 17 29 32 11 2 34 4 24 28 9 34 19 7 16 13 6 27 23 35 2 24 26 14 30 30 3 12 9 14 15 7 16 18 5 20 29 18 30 31 34
30 8 22 11 23 23 21 35 19 9 3 28 34 24 27 3 29 33 11 30 20 30 17 27 13 30 21 19 10 21 18 32 29 26 14 12 34 19 3 34 21 32 0 9 0 7 17 11 15 8
13 32 3 6 30 7 11 19 2 10 34 20 16 8 30 28 14 2 5 3 35 10 12 2 0 28 22 10 0 5 13 19 14 35 34 28 35 14 27 0 33 20 10 14 4 14 28 20 11 13 9 16
0 19 26 16 10 17 33 26 35 2 24 30 33 20 23 26 31 10 9 25 24 26 12 16 18 24 4 1 33 9 6 22 23 14 1 22 13 2 17 15 34 33 16 14 26 14 14 7 3 16
25 24 0 3 16 22 2 11 12 29 9 34 0 2 2 17 18 0 15 9 5 21 7 5 33 32 29 17 24 7 32 24 16 5 2 1 22 29 27 34 9 6 11 27 33 4 4 5 26 28 4 0 3 12 8
8 24 35 5 1 0 8 7 18 32 32 26 19 14 1 24 18 17 3 10 28 6 11 9 23 21 5 18 9 7 15 20 12 14 20 13 31 17 20 28 26 10 9 1 8 17 19 28 14 15 3 15 1
31 6 15 18 17 33 11 21 19 33 8 1 32 6 1 31 22 21 3 14 22 19 32 30 19 24 16 31 9 2 20 5 31 25 13 2 17 26 14 21 2 12 7 13 13 9 32 35 8 22 13
10 9 6 6 10 33 35 29 28 20 17 23 30 27 2 7 24 25 4 18 0 10 9 10 18 15 35 12 16 8 20 21 16 9 6 12 26 34 32 9 21 35 29 8 1 4 22 29 6 0 28 10
33 35 13 20 2 20 3 9 24 22 1 8 19 2 4 30 28 15 14 35 25 32 29 14 26 15 13 28 24 27 15 32 35 22 16 6 17 28 21 1 25 32 14 15 16 22 14 3 10 26
13 27 34 16 11 0 32 17 22 29 17 5 1 16 8 25 19 15 2 10 25 8 15 13 8 25 18 7 26 12 28 21 6 7 18 30 30 12 24 25 32 16 0 33 11 29 35 34 6 30 22
34 28 28 24 15 11 15 28 34 1 19 33 10 29 8 23 12 7 25 15 3 9 26 16 4 22 20 19 4 9 4 12 31 28 6 19 0 18 4 13 9 30 8 15 29 25 30 8 25 19 21 29
22 22 5 12 34 26 25 7 0 23 13 24 15 14 29 28 21 35 35 24 33 28 18 19 34 18 24 29 5 6 25 20 6 11 33 6 35 27 16 21 34 0 22 5 17 26 15 33 24 7
27 11 16 31 15 33 21 26 18 6 23 32 2 4 33 6 22 17 15 15 25 9 27 4 22 18 29 22 0 32 33 34 11 14 27 3 22 6 30 2 1 10 4 1 10 25 4 13 0 6 1 34 1
14 14 33 27 6 18 24 31 2 31 32 26 6 7 5 34 1 28 16 25 10 13 34 23 17 15 9 32 23 25 18 13 13 30 3 33 4 35 21 10 16 18 5 19 35 11 27 31 5 3 16
7 16 19 24 20 27 23 12 23 19 14 26 28 25 15 34 4 0 16 1 8 35 3 19 31 0 29 14 2 7 30 14 2 18 22 22 14 4 35 25 3 16 20 22 15 14 26 27 2 5 18 0
26 5 7 23 24 27 33 22 3 26 20 13 28 16 1 11 10 8 12 29 23 28 7 21 25 27 26 7 23 20 26 12 8 34 23 15 33 2 17 23 17 31 29 31 22 29 3 10 28 28
23 10 29 6 20 17 19 4 5 11 18 20 21 2 5 10 12 2 28 27 11 15 9 3 31 27 24 27 31 7 32 12 32 30 21 31 31 18 11 5 0 15 14 25 31 6 35 35 25 35 30
19 28 27 7 5 1 21 33 29 33 24 34 17 15 15 17 31 19 5 20 1 6 25 4 30 32 24 7 1 7 24 12 32 35 34 13 7 32 12 30 35 27 33 32 8 16 23 11 31 3 3
18 24 9 30 33 2 0 6 10 35 7 8 16 34 21 29 21 27 31 11 3 18 1 20 23 35 9 13 26 27 33 1 8 10 7 27 17 10 2 12 13 22 24 23 6 27 24 13 14 6 20 3
20 14 18 12 21 2 34 27 21 20 34 8 19 13 31 4 7 8 23 5 31 10 7 15 5 25 5 22 13 23 1 25 8 5 12 18 17 4 27 23 0 2 6 5 25 19 29 18 13 9 15 19 3
31 26 20 34 6 7 19 29 3 1 1 12 14 33 26 10 14 4 3 0 0 23 31 9 10 1 32 22 9 20 22 12 17 16 32 8 35 12 2 25 29 24 11 20 29 0 12 30 32 11 18 8
9 29 13 15 9 17 31 18 5 30 4 13 30 29 23 23 13 15 23 4 32 8 3 12 27 0 32 26 7 24 10 29 31 25 2 26 11 11 12 20 5 35 3 22 11 26 9 27 0 28 0 23
1 31 9 8 0 28 11 35 3 27 26 6 27 5 21 20 19 24 11 11 7 9 17 17 12 4 17 28 25 18 21 11 8 18 4 23 1 22 19 19 6 34 31 12 32 19 1 21 16 28 25 16
23 3 34 16 6 34 30 31