CSP 2008 Competition: solvers results per benchmarks

Result page for benchmark
csp/fapp/fapp34/
normalized-fapp34-0750-9.xml

Jump to solvers results

General information on the benchmark

Namecsp/fapp/fapp34/
normalized-fapp34-0750-9.xml
MD5SUMe29b6006bf1a29842bd8623c635cae42
Bench Category2-ARY-INT (binary constraints in intension)
Best result obtained on this benchmarkSAT
Best CPU time to get the best result obtained on this benchmark29.2246
Satisfiable
(Un)Satisfiability was proved
Number of variables750
Number of constraints8639
Maximum constraint arity2
Maximum domain size998
Number of constraints which are defined in extension0
Number of constraints which are defined in intension8639
Global constraints used (with number of constraints)

Results of the different solvers on this benchmark

Solver NameTraceIDAnswerCPU timeWall clock time
Abscon 112v4 AC1085677SAT 29.2246 29.4871
Abscon 112v4 ESAC1085678SAT 29.5505 29.731
cpHydra k_101085679SAT 85.0781 85.6438
cpHydra k_401085680SAT 85.356 86.0056
Concrete + CPS4J 2008-05-301085662SAT 186.057 187.903
Concrete + CSP4J - WMC Engine 2008-05-301085661SAT 278.749 279.15
SAT4J CSP 2008-06-131085665? 0.963853 1.07519
galac M1085671? (problem) 0.437932 0.520152
galac E1085672? (problem) 0.445931 0.51942
Sugar v1.13+minisat1085667? (MO) 239.79 242.949
Sugar v1.13+picosat1085666? (MO) 456.4 461.654
casper zito1085676? (TO) 1800.02 1811.51
Minion/Tailor 2008-07-041105591? (TO) 1800.06 1811.21
bpsolver 2008-06-271085668? (TO) 1800.07 1812.21
Mistral-prime 1.3131085674? (TO) 1800.08 1807.31
Concrete + CSP4J - Tabu Engine 2008-05-301085660? (TO) 1800.1 1801.83
casper zao1085675? (TO) 1800.1 1878.25
MDG-noprobe 2008-06-271085664? (TO) 1800.1 1807.81
Mistral-option 1.3141085673? (TO) 1800.11 1814.03
MDG-probe 2008-06-271085663? (TO) 1800.11 1803.11
choco2_dwdeg 2008-06-261085670? (TO) 1800.16 1816.96
choco2_impwdeg 2008-06-261085669? (TO) 1800.23 1803.83

Additionnal information

This section presents information obtained from the best job displayed in the list (i.e. solvers whose names are not hidden).

Solution found:
-2518 -2558 -3092 -3312 -3352 -3132 -2554 -2478 2992 -2758 -2624 2586 -2590 -2758 -3036 -2616 -3044 2566 -3190 -2616 -2584 -2568 2570 -2518
-3044 -2564 3250 -3352 -2626 2616 -2828 2752 -2580 -2848 -3150 -2478 -3108 3302 -3096 3292 -2780 -2792 -2994 -3074 -2788 -2610 3290 -2736
-2580 -2788 -2518 -3190 -2892 -3150 -2604 3004 -2798 -2518 -2584 -2518 -2568 2576 2356 2784 -2828 -2478 -3150 -2828 -2558 3038 2916 -3260
-2608 -2518 -3312 -2594 -3190 -3004 -2624 -3150 -2758 -2814 -3124 -2436 -2828 2610 -3174 -3042 3186 -2852 -2828 -2478 2696 -2576 -2478 -2788
-3004 -3102 -3052 -2566 -3352 -2932 -3312 -3106 3002 -3044 -3004 -2982 -3150 -2758 -2562 -2558 -2356 2624 3056 -3004 -2828 -2518 3144 -2478
-2422 3032 -3256 -3296 -3038 3312 2992 -2610 -3044 -2602 -3102 -2558 -3312 -3150 -2606 3146 -2774 -3012 -2616 -3076 -2606 3144 -3004 3040
-2706 -2518 -2604 -2758 -2546 -3352 -2478 -3004 -3190 -2758 2976 -2828 -2578 -2586 -2478 -3020 -2618 3150 -3150 -3134 3164 -2568 -2598 -2828
-2478 -2620 -3190 -3150 -2518 -2618 -2540 2908 -3110 -2514 -2604 -2584 -2782 -2710 -2728 -3150 -2590 -3060 -2518 -2478 -2788 -3148 -2478
2576 2984 -2786 -2378 -3352 -2626 2980 -2992 3150 -3150 2626 -3142 -2558 -3044 -2356 -2518 -3274 2680 -2952 -3190 3352 -2612 -2518 -3314
-2608 -2518 -3190 -2798 -2558 2832 -2942 -2786 -2678 -2604 -2578 2630 -2396 -3150 -2478 -2558 -3190 -3066 -2854 2928 -2798 -2744 -2540 -2976
2822 -2828 -2828 2588 -2558 3210 3226 -3142 -2564 2618 3210 -3142 -2518 2480 -2478 -2478 -2616 -3102 -2396 -2736 -3004 -2936 -2828 -3190
-2624 -2584 -3256 -2566 -3312 -2652 -2788 -2602 -3352 -2788 2356 3058 -2518 -2356 3000 -3142 -2788 -2586 -2518 3024 -3146 -3044 -3352 -2518
2914 -3300 2854 -2768 -3190 -2736 -3332 -3036 -3002 -2396 -2518 3166 -3020 -3102 -2626 -2828 3214 2696 -2632 -3150 -3004 -3044 -3004 -3136
-2630 -3190 2554 2586 3190 -3190 -2582 -2982 -3270 -3004 2396 -3312 2592 -3190 -2356 -2876 -3096 -3286 2792 -2676 -3004 -2514 2592 3120
-2640 3170 3148 -3078 -2758 -2558 -2558 -3150 -3142 -3160 -2746 -2396 -2750 -2826 3312 -2930 -2758 -2478 -2566 -3150 -2404 -3150 3190 -2978
3142 -3230 2356 -3106 -2624 -2584 -2798 -2628 -3004 -3280 -2518 -2630 -2518 3352 -2616 2356 -2952 2950 -3190 -2586 -2626 -2632 -2594 -3216
3342 2822 -3190 2788 -2628 -2798 -2676 -2832 -3312 -2518 -2610 -2658 -2536 -3146 -3322 -3106 2588 -3038 2650 -2578 -2828 -2826 -3352 -2718
-2356 -2622 -2710 -2798 3040 -2382 -2788 -3042 -2518 -3282 -3150 -3326 -3044 -2508 -2576 2628 -2578 -3004 -2626 -3004 -2518 -2938 -3104 2564
2992 -2634 -2788 2950 -2558 -2558 -2558 2734 -3044 -2558 2788 2590 -3150 -2866 -2478 2414 -3004 -2624 2942 -2798 2954 -2788 -3150 2396 -3044
-2828 -3076 -2798 -2576 -3312 -3190 2588 -3312 2670 -3330 -3110 -2588 -2776 -2578 -2788 -2518 -3148 -2478 -2606 -2798 2600 -2952 -2996 2990
3190 -2518 -3352 -2396 2924 -2580 -3016 -2644 -2562 -2586 2788 2812 3026 -2586 -3056 -3150 -3150 -3004 -2894 -2630 -2490 2964 -2884 -2720
-2604 2828 -2758 -2518 -2758 -2518 3312 -3312 3282 2610 -3036 -2356 2948 -2518 -2758 3170 -2798 -2808 -3150 -2620 -3004 -2798 3110 -2954
-3044 -3108 -3290 2716 -2584 -2404 -3002 -2828 -2518 -3190 -2758 2634 -2790 2396 -2758 -2518 -3150 -3312 -3146 -2608 -2562 -3150 -2518 -3190
-2518 -2530 -3352 3002 -2788 2564 -2758 -2570 -2828 -3150 -2518 2520 -2396 -2626 -2618 -2798 2820 2478 -2558 3042 -2518 -3146 -2554 2518
-2558 -2514 -2576 2586 -2618 -3080 -3044 -3110 -2606 -2518 -2576 -2990 -2558 -3240 -2444 3020 -2450 2396 -2518 -2620 -2514 -2518 -3142 -2566
-3150 -3312 -2634 -3096 3042 -2994 -2478 -2788 -2890 -3060 -2626 -2782 -2788 -2558 2478 -2924 -2748 -2518 2548 -2478 -2478 -2620 -3004 -2594
-2604 -3104 -2518 -2828 2582 -2798 -3202 -3102 2554 -2754 -2364 -2626 -3242 -2788 -2518 -2518 2974 2670 -3102 -3150 -2628 -2570 -2518 2580
-2758 -2828 -2478 -2580 -3044 -2602 3060 -2588 -3142 -2562 -2758 -2826 -3190 2964 -2580 -3150 -2626 -2590 3242 -3044 -2518 -3078 -3352 2866
-2788 2396 -2750 -2602 -3044 3188 2798 -2620 -2586 -3106 -3352 -2558 -3044 -2954 2822 -2374 2792 2732 -2788 -2772 -2606 -3190 -3044 -2616
-2794 -3174 -2500 2790 3034 2500 -2788 3014 -2490 -3142 3126 -3102 -3102 -2558 2624 -2478 -2622 -2576 -3018 -2478 -3186 -3078 -3190 -2618
2418 -3044 -2798 -2828 -2518 3020 -2564 -3352 -3312 2888 2356 -2716 -2586 -2620 -2782 2906 -2570 -2798 -3352 2396 -3190 -2518 -2478 -2584
-2468 -3102 -2586 -2518 -2478 -2478