CSP 2006 Competition (second round): results by benchmark

Results by benchmark for category binary constraints in extension (2-ARY-EXT), subcategory random problems

This page displays the results of the different solvers for each benchmark for category binary constraints in extension (2-ARY-EXT), subcategory random problems

REMINDER

Keep in mind that the 'Best result' columns only provide the best result given by one of the solvers. This 'Best result' may be wrong in case of an UNSATISFIABLE or OPTIMUM FOUND answer (because there's no efficient way to check these answers).

Description of a cell contents:

Cell exampleMeaning
AnswerSolver result
TT=...Total Time (TT): this is the CPU time (in seconds) used by the solver until termination. This time is only meaningful for complete solvers because incomplete solvers will always run until they time out
Remember that CPU time and wall clock time are two very different notions. The CPU time represents the time during which the instructions of the solver were executed by the processor. The wall clock time represents how much time ellapsed on the clock. For a same event, the CPU time may be either smaller or greater than the wall clock time depending on the number of threads of execution and the number of processors.

Meaning of some abbreviations:

AbbreviationMeaning
TOTime Out
MOMem. Out (out of memory)

Meaning of the different colors:

ColorMeaning
textthe solver cannot handle this instance
textthe solver gave no answer
textthe solver gave a definitive answer (SAT or UNSAT)
textthe solver performed better than the other ones on that instance
textthe solver was ended by a signal
textthe solver gave an incomplete answer
textthe solver was disqualified in the category
textthe solver gave a wrong answer

For better readability, you may choose to hide some solvers:
Abscon 109 ESAC
Abscon 109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a 2006-12-13
buggy_2_5 2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s 2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo 2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC 2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC 2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat 0.3
Diarmuid-rndi 2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi 2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi 2006-12-21
galac 1
galacJ beta 1
Mistral 2006-12-04
rjw-solver 2006-12-09
rjw-solver 2007-01-21
sat4jCSP 1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED 1.7 RC BF3
sugar 0.40
Tramontane 2006-12-04
VALCSP 3.0
VALCSP 3.1

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
frb/frb30-15/
frb30-15-1-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.078

SAT
TT=0.928

CHECKS=309860
NODES=295
SAT
TT=0.933

CHECKS=288213
NODES=317
SAT
TT=0.27

SAT
TT=0.445

SAT
TT=0.449

SAT
TT=1.692

NODES=1826
SAT
TT=2.695

NODES=3790
SAT
TT=3.094

CHECKS=65028
NODES=4506
SAT
TT=5.817

SAT
TT=16.177

CHECKS=9766001
NODES=7062
SAT
TT=16.782

CHECKS=10878841
NODES=8223
SAT
TT=4.134

CHECKS=2690117
NODES=1655
SAT
TT=4.298

SAT
TT=5.825

SAT
TT=0.427

SAT
TT=1.274

CHECKS=804338
NODES=575
SAT
TT=1.268

CHECKS=804338
NODES=575
SAT
TT=13.373

SAT
TT=12.272

SAT
TT=21.709

SAT
TT=0.801

SAT
TT=0.078

CHECKS=866747
NODES=237
SAT
TT=0.077

CHECKS=866747
NODES=237
frb/frb30-15/
frb30-15-2-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.118

SAT
TT=1.121

CHECKS=1143185
NODES=1125
SAT
TT=1.529

CHECKS=3841897
NODES=3863
SAT
TT=1.587

SAT
TT=1.386

SAT
TT=1.416

SAT
TT=1.279

NODES=1028
SAT
TT=3.783

NODES=5244
SAT
TT=4.218

CHECKS=70377
NODES=6365
SAT
TT=9.82

SAT
TT=12.244

CHECKS=7274012
NODES=5043
SAT
TT=13.152

CHECKS=8281447
NODES=5869
SAT
TT=25.24

CHECKS=17379175
NODES=11191
SAT
TT=15.029

SAT
TT=8.606

SAT
TT=1.992

SAT
TT=15.415

CHECKS=10677586
NODES=7071
SAT
TT=16.404

CHECKS=10677586
NODES=7071
SAT
TT=15.709

SAT
TT=14.885

SAT
TT=36.66

SAT
TT=0.118

SAT
TT=0.385

CHECKS=10748100
NODES=2661
SAT
TT=0.384

CHECKS=10748100
NODES=2661
frb/frb30-15/
frb30-15-3-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.272

SAT
TT=1.555

CHECKS=3766806
NODES=3560
SAT
TT=1.627

CHECKS=3934074
NODES=3737
SAT
TT=1.276

SAT
TT=0.939

SAT
TT=0.937

SAT
TT=4.678

NODES=7182
SAT
TT=2.334

NODES=2737
SAT
TT=2.31

CHECKS=68639
NODES=2937
SAT
TT=0.864

SAT
TT=11.563

CHECKS=6804349
NODES=4786
SAT
TT=17.433

CHECKS=11291119
NODES=7273
SAT
TT=10.618

CHECKS=7328158
NODES=4250
SAT
TT=2.382

SAT
TT=4.061

SAT
TT=0.272

SAT
TT=13.142

CHECKS=8574413
NODES=5387
SAT
TT=12.35

CHECKS=8574413
NODES=5387
SAT
TT=4.863

SAT
TT=4.965

SAT
TT=4.37

SAT
TT=0.326

SAT
TT=0.289

CHECKS=7649740
NODES=1692
SAT
TT=0.267

CHECKS=7649740
NODES=1692
frb/frb30-15/
frb30-15-4-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.133

SAT
TT=0.888

CHECKS=380993
NODES=397
SAT
TT=0.9

CHECKS=140091
NODES=180
SAT
TT=0.584

SAT
TT=1.392

SAT
TT=1.388

SAT
TT=2.734

NODES=3475
SAT
TT=3.509

NODES=4704
SAT
TT=2.885

CHECKS=68657
NODES=4028
SAT
TT=0.585

SAT
TT=20.268

CHECKS=13236520
NODES=8891
SAT
TT=21.321

CHECKS=13229662
NODES=9126
SAT
TT=11.756

CHECKS=7912750
NODES=5021
SAT
TT=2.387

SAT
TT=3.087

SAT
TT=1.119

SAT
TT=4.827

CHECKS=3301308
NODES=2106
SAT
TT=5.324

CHECKS=3301308
NODES=2106
SAT
TT=2.674

SAT
TT=2.983

SAT
TT=13.52

SAT
TT=1.076

SAT
TT=0.133

CHECKS=2670640
NODES=618
SAT
TT=0.135

CHECKS=2670640
NODES=618
frb/frb30-15/
frb30-15-5-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.171

SAT
TT=0.966

CHECKS=745925
NODES=704
SAT
TT=0.921

CHECKS=234846
NODES=271
SAT
TT=0.602

SAT
TT=1.625

SAT
TT=1.626

SAT
TT=0.818

NODES=360
SAT
TT=1.848

NODES=1752
SAT
TT=1.695

CHECKS=68617
NODES=1828
SAT
TT=0.881

SAT
TT=19.764

CHECKS=12151779
NODES=8451
SAT
TT=11.292

CHECKS=7097865
NODES=4695
SAT
TT=32.008

CHECKS=22294226
NODES=12881
SAT
TT=2.392

SAT
TT=2.689

SAT
TT=0.345

SAT
TT=6.098

CHECKS=4102863
NODES=2475
SAT
TT=6.125

CHECKS=4102863
NODES=2475
SAT
TT=4.422

SAT
TT=4.438

SAT
TT=6.31

SAT
TT=0.328

SAT
TT=0.171

CHECKS=3974620
NODES=886
SAT
TT=0.172

CHECKS=3974620
NODES=886
frb/frb35-17/
frb35-17-1-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.754

SAT
TT=3.614

CHECKS=17504113
NODES=13393
SAT
TT=4.231

CHECKS=21099255
NODES=15974
SAT
TT=2.733

SAT
TT=2.378

SAT
TT=2.368

SAT
TT=23.543

NODES=29879
SAT
TT=8.004

NODES=9882
SAT
TT=8.468

CHECKS=106566
NODES=11399
SAT
TT=70.469

SAT
TT=63.453

CHECKS=33955353
NODES=17627
SAT
TT=69.188

CHECKS=36663307
NODES=18479
SAT
TT=107.572

CHECKS=64379955
NODES=29898
SAT
TT=18.422

SAT
TT=4.778

SAT
TT=4.102

SAT
TT=96.336

CHECKS=58908095
NODES=26027
SAT
TT=104.451

CHECKS=58908095
NODES=26027
SAT
TT=17.821

SAT
TT=17.344

SAT
TT=46.242

SAT
TT=2.854

SAT
TT=1.754

CHECKS=58823800
NODES=9427
SAT
TT=1.804

CHECKS=58823800
NODES=9427
frb/frb35-17/
frb35-17-2-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.854

SAT
TT=2.189

CHECKS=7316156
NODES=6224
SAT
TT=3.942

CHECKS=20454408
NODES=16810
SAT
TT=1.854

SAT
TT=4.309

SAT
TT=4.566

SAT
TT=0.933

NODES=341
SAT
TT=14.165

NODES=17673
SAT
TT=11.881

CHECKS=106291
NODES=17494
SAT
TT=32.052

SAT
TT=151.854

CHECKS=88177463
NODES=48370
SAT
TT=155.126

CHECKS=91734995
NODES=50441
SAT
TT=112.498

CHECKS=71755080
NODES=39218
SAT
TT=93.984

SAT
TT=106.658

SAT
TT=4.004

SAT
TT=172.285

CHECKS=97220993
NODES=52116
SAT
TT=163.518

CHECKS=97220993
NODES=52116
SAT
TT=794.608

SAT
TT=828.731

SAT
TT=223.84

SAT
TT=15.18

SAT
TT=3.152

CHECKS=97709200
NODES=19902
SAT
TT=2.871

CHECKS=97709200
NODES=19902
frb/frb35-17/
frb35-17-3-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.921

SAT
TT=1.156

CHECKS=1190544
NODES=1071
SAT
TT=1.071

CHECKS=851704
NODES=778
SAT
TT=4.42

SAT
TT=5.761

SAT
TT=5.589

SAT
TT=6.115

NODES=7178
SAT
TT=2.616

NODES=2638
SAT
TT=4.495

CHECKS=110751
NODES=5789
SAT
TT=94.209

SAT
TT=56.818

CHECKS=29095602
NODES=16856
SAT
TT=54.994

CHECKS=28054817
NODES=16784
SAT
TT=118.731

CHECKS=69998785
NODES=39851
SAT
TT=41.618

SAT
TT=46.317

SAT
TT=2.037

SAT
TT=49.004

CHECKS=25158956
NODES=15093
SAT
TT=49.579

CHECKS=25158956
NODES=15093
SAT
TT=47.247

SAT
TT=48.187

SAT
TT=56.777

SAT
TT=6.344

SAT
TT=0.921

CHECKS=26201400
NODES=6050
SAT
TT=0.849

CHECKS=26201400
NODES=6050
frb/frb35-17/
frb35-17-4-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.257

SAT
TT=2.773

CHECKS=11429769
NODES=8435
SAT
TT=3.28

CHECKS=16629386
NODES=12231
SAT
TT=0.816

SAT
TT=3.392

SAT
TT=3.628

SAT
TT=7.377

NODES=8580
SAT
TT=8.22

NODES=8708
SAT
TT=6.662

CHECKS=106730
NODES=8761
SAT
TT=51.286

SAT
TT=63.144

CHECKS=35788478
NODES=16865
SAT
TT=65.493

CHECKS=38876400
NODES=18409
SAT
TT=109.949

CHECKS=71599445
NODES=30608
SAT
TT=25.476

SAT
TT=21.133

SAT
TT=2.71

SAT
TT=52.546

CHECKS=32845717
NODES=15001
SAT
TT=57.304

CHECKS=32845717
NODES=15001
SAT
TT=19.052

SAT
TT=19.393

SAT
TT=87.39

SAT
TT=0.257

SAT
TT=1.041

CHECKS=31853600
NODES=5252
SAT
TT=1.034

CHECKS=31853600
NODES=5252
frb/frb35-17/
frb35-17-5-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.199

SAT
TT=4.748

CHECKS=25866598
NODES=20580
SAT
TT=1.91

CHECKS=5750420
NODES=4765
SAT
TT=4.654

SAT
TT=6.178

SAT
TT=6.497

SAT
TT=1.502

NODES=1187
SAT
TT=28.437

NODES=39860
SAT
TT=28.558

CHECKS=112198
NODES=41146
SAT
TT=0.199

SAT
TT=36.358

CHECKS=16924969
NODES=9736
SAT
TT=23.525

CHECKS=10296335
NODES=5856
SAT
TT=368.15

CHECKS=192346777
NODES=102811
SAT
TT=130.991

SAT
TT=53.038

SAT
TT=10.976

SAT
TT=232.35

CHECKS=121537886
NODES=65468
SAT
TT=247.564

CHECKS=121537886
NODES=65468
SAT
TT=204.618

SAT
TT=214.984

SAT
TT=99.17

SAT
TT=14.005

SAT
TT=3.481

CHECKS=117395000
NODES=24025
SAT
TT=3.68

CHECKS=117395000
NODES=24025
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
frb/frb40-19/
frb40-19-1-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.54

SAT
TT=1.54

CHECKS=3289620
NODES=2368
SAT
TT=7.485

CHECKS=45290482
NODES=31521
SAT
TT=25.756

SAT
TT=5.075

SAT
TT=4.993

SAT
TT=7.346

NODES=7182
SAT
TT=41.925

NODES=44804
SAT
TT=40.104

CHECKS=165924
NODES=46854
SAT
TT=624.146

SAT
TT=297.047

CHECKS=174492325
NODES=70318
SAT
TT=290.509

CHECKS=172464266
NODES=69465
SAT
TT=478.011

CHECKS=307377910
NODES=122098
SAT
TT=4.2

SAT
TT=182.765

SAT
TT=24.511

SAT
TT=385.977

CHECKS=221834622
NODES=87539
SAT
TT=392.903

CHECKS=221834622
NODES=87539
SAT
TT=235.742

SAT
TT=242.277

SAT
TT=376.289

SAT
TT=21.514

SAT
TT=6.443

CHECKS=214740000
NODES=33575
SAT
TT=6.404

CHECKS=214740000
NODES=33575
frb/frb40-19/
frb40-19-2-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.457

SAT
TT=1.891

CHECKS=6120720
NODES=4565
SAT
TT=1.457

CHECKS=2766955
NODES=2114
SAT
TT=94.347

SAT
TT=3.583

SAT
TT=3.704

SAT
TT=0.757

NODES=101
SAT
TT=74.232

NODES=86634
SAT
TT=76.883

CHECKS=167439
NODES=100434
SAT
TT=588.544

SAT
TT=174.599

CHECKS=105049557
NODES=44569
SAT
TT=264.477

CHECKS=153398933
NODES=62784
SAT
TT=994.755

CHECKS=623213649
NODES=259129
SAT
TT=360.164

SAT
TT=89.818

SAT
TT=5.272

SAT
TT=175.111

CHECKS=108168270
NODES=45476
SAT
TT=179.992

CHECKS=108168270
NODES=45476
SAT
TT=476.788

SAT
TT=483.793

SAT
TT=754.26

SAT
TT=35.67

SAT
TT=3.053

CHECKS=104303000
NODES=17633
SAT
TT=3.189

CHECKS=104303000
NODES=17633
frb/frb40-19/
frb40-19-3-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=8.8

SAT
TT=39.155

CHECKS=245438948
NODES=187091
SAT
TT=17.24

CHECKS=112293829
NODES=84531
SAT
TT=91.494

SAT
TT=37.03

SAT
TT=34.873

SAT
TT=18.36

NODES=21438
SAT
TT=325.524

NODES=389684
SAT
TT=278.752

CHECKS=155726
NODES=397215
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=763.742

CHECKS=430803903
NODES=207981
SAT
TT=736.933

CHECKS=425502742
NODES=205395
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=109.305

SAT
TT=1491.72

CHECKS=850466417
NODES=407210
SAT
TT=1532.3

CHECKS=850466417
NODES=407210
? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=8.8

SAT
TT=22.783

CHECKS=784834000
NODES=151379
SAT
TT=24.397

CHECKS=784834000
NODES=151379
frb/frb40-19/
frb40-19-4-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=4.489

SAT
TT=10.25

CHECKS=60547397
NODES=42902
SAT
TT=47.548

CHECKS=330176782
NODES=230902
SAT
TT=29.396

SAT
TT=19.9

SAT
TT=20.156

SAT
TT=36.741

NODES=38669
SAT
TT=187.249

NODES=219465
SAT
TT=133.333

CHECKS=167593
NODES=174501
SAT
TT=142.334

SAT
TT=920.74

CHECKS=521239312
NODES=239426
SAT
TT=1091.39

CHECKS=533080633
NODES=243750
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=1214.92

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=31.875

SAT
TT=268.996

CHECKS=142863544
NODES=65140
SAT
TT=256.702

CHECKS=142863544
NODES=65140
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

SAT
TT=735.004

SAT
TT=97.079

SAT
TT=4.489

CHECKS=143350000
NODES=25098
SAT
TT=4.484

CHECKS=143350000
NODES=25098
frb/frb40-19/
frb40-19-5-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=10.227

SAT
TT=80.426

CHECKS=504378609
NODES=372979
SAT
TT=82.37

CHECKS=556059266
NODES=414712
SAT
TT=150.636

SAT
TT=52.095

SAT
TT=55.554

SAT
TT=249.995

NODES=277916
SAT
TT=208.683

NODES=260214
SAT
TT=216.063

CHECKS=169535
NODES=290893
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=603.749

CHECKS=332382758
NODES=166295
SAT
TT=976.508

CHECKS=517078704
NODES=264205
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=153.607

SAT
TT=611.718

CHECKS=328890840
NODES=164178
SAT
TT=638.835

CHECKS=328890840
NODES=164178
SAT
TT=390.347

SAT
TT=400.568

SAT
TT=918.327

SAT
TT=114.051

SAT
TT=10.227

CHECKS=318887000
NODES=63997
SAT
TT=10.106

CHECKS=318887000
NODES=63997
frb/frb45-21/
frb45-21-1-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=6.926

SAT
TT=90.771

CHECKS=613789147
NODES=390951
SAT
TT=30.029

CHECKS=190963189
NODES=123139
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=7.047

SAT
TT=6.926

SAT
TT=119.578

NODES=106885
SAT
TT=1393.71

NODES=1472831
SAT
TT=1187.49

CHECKS=249710
NODES=1319976
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.6

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=280.78

CHECKS=8951050000
NODES=1511880
SAT
TT=273.113

CHECKS=8951050000
NODES=1511880
frb/frb45-21/
frb45-21-2-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=73.112

SAT
TT=107.296

CHECKS=715802997
NODES=460419
SAT
TT=73.112

CHECKS=516828091
NODES=331977
SAT
TT=648.942

SAT
TT=106.615

SAT
TT=112.671

SAT
TT=665.011

NODES=626636
SAT
TT=590.981

NODES=562281
SAT
TT=537.287

CHECKS=238171
NODES=618218
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=94.575

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=492.791

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

SAT
TT=74.621

SAT
TT=568.448

SAT
TT=96.424

CHECKS=3100950000
NODES=529944
SAT
TT=94.947

CHECKS=3100950000
NODES=529944
frb/frb45-21/
frb45-21-3-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=54.041

SAT
TT=156.933

CHECKS=1112593646
NODES=720577
SAT
TT=209.573

CHECKS=1399072869
NODES=908052
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=265.815

SAT
TT=249.34

? (TO)
TT=1800

SAT
TT=897.975

NODES=936248
SAT
TT=359.629

CHECKS=229486
NODES=418272
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=475.168

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=1265.82

SAT
TT=54.041

CHECKS=1721410000
NODES=303672
SAT
TT=52.553

CHECKS=1721410000
NODES=303672
frb/frb45-21/
frb45-21-4-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=2.285

SAT
TT=2.285

CHECKS=9091424
NODES=5634
SAT
TT=11.088

CHECKS=68240323
NODES=42274
SAT
TT=252.78

SAT
TT=218.68

SAT
TT=211.423

SAT
TT=7.559

NODES=6105
SAT
TT=1204.04

NODES=1175832
SAT
TT=1571.12

CHECKS=237917
NODES=1743529
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=490.251

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=543.944

SAT
TT=77.579

CHECKS=2516490000
NODES=417652
SAT
TT=77.607

CHECKS=2516490000
NODES=417652
frb/frb45-21/
frb45-21-5-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=56.871

SAT
TT=404.202

CHECKS=2854025528
NODES=1787259
SAT
TT=526.109

CHECKS=3684603661
NODES=2299428
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=245.086

SAT
TT=231.393

SAT
TT=1219.26

NODES=1160819
SAT
TT=110.882

NODES=110323
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=1596.87

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=267.515

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=56.871

SAT
TT=60.028

SAT
TT=941.31

SAT
TT=549.168

SAT
TT=118.556

CHECKS=3923610000
NODES=608646
SAT
TT=118.555

CHECKS=3923610000
NODES=608646
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
frb/frb50-23/
frb50-23-1-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=508.324

SAT
TT=508.324

CHECKS=3446439207
NODES=1997854
SAT
TT=760.972

CHECKS=5620777249
NODES=3240075
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=638.572

CHECKS=20942400000
NODES=3101720
SAT
TT=626.566

CHECKS=20942400000
NODES=3101720
frb/frb50-23/
frb50-23-2-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

frb/frb50-23/
frb50-23-3-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=582.261

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=622.836

SAT
TT=582.261

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

frb/frb50-23/
frb50-23-4-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=36.044

SAT
TT=73.287

CHECKS=536947976
NODES=311555
SAT
TT=154.219

CHECKS=1073175800
NODES=614186
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=553.798

SAT
TT=517.815

SAT
TT=1398.08

NODES=1049129
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=198.487

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=36.044

CHECKS=1160710000
NODES=192864
SAT
TT=36.039

CHECKS=1160710000
NODES=192864
frb/frb50-23/
frb50-23-5-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=328.129

SAT
TT=1546.18

CHECKS=10685475368
NODES=6040065
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=1337.59

SAT
TT=1256.38

SAT
TT=171.155

NODES=129022
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=328.129

CHECKS=10880900000
NODES=1607660
SAT
TT=318.859

CHECKS=10880900000
NODES=1607660
frb/frb53-24/
frb53-24-1-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

frb/frb53-24/
frb53-24-2-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

frb/frb53-24/
frb53-24-3-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

frb/frb53-24/
frb53-24-4-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=73.891

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=73.891

CHECKS=509726407
NODES=262196
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=182.06

NODES=126936
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=1063.8

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=454.243

CHECKS=15829500000
NODES=2005400
SAT
TT=436.845

CHECKS=15829500000
NODES=2005400
frb/frb53-24/
frb53-24-5-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
frb/frb56-25/
frb56-25-1-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

frb/frb56-25/
frb56-25-2-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

frb/frb56-25/
frb56-25-3-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

frb/frb56-25/
frb56-25-4-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

frb/frb56-25/
frb56-25-5-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

frb/frb59-26/
frb59-26-1-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

frb/frb59-26/
frb59-26-2-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

frb/frb59-26/
frb59-26-3-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

frb/frb59-26/
frb59-26-4-mgd_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

frb/frb59-26/
frb59-26-5-mgd_ext.xml
SAT
TT=413.883

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

SAT
TT=413.883

CHECKS=2438873030
NODES=1166077
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
marc/
large-80-sat_ext.xml
SAT
TT=13.394

SAT
TT=14.931

CHECKS=32216
NODES=0
SAT
TT=13.394

CHECKS=29056
NODES=80
? (conv)
TT=0.017

SAT
TT=42.608

SAT
TT=44.631

SAT
TT=44.777

NODES=0
SAT
TT=43.95

NODES=80
SAT
TT=43.555

CHECKS=6320
NODES=80
? (MO)
TT=8.617

? (problem)
TT=0.037

? (problem)
TT=0.037

? (problem)
TT=0.031

? (TO)
TT=0.027

? (problem)
TT=109.535

SAT
TT=17.884

? (problem)
TT=0.037

? (problem)
TT=0.034

SAT
TT=46.406

SAT
TT=46.041

?
TT=422.52

SAT
TT=16.009

SAT
TT=321.874

CHECKS=120426
NODES=80
SAT
TT=299.168

CHECKS=120426
NODES=80
marc/
large-80-unsat_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=11.802

UNSAT
TT=12.116

CHECKS=1176214
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=11.802

CHECKS=1078209
NODES=79
? (conv)
TT=0.017

UNSAT
TT=32.972

UNSAT
TT=32.898

UNSAT
TT=44.509

NODES=79
UNSAT
TT=47.657

NODES=63
UNSAT
TT=50.306

CHECKS=20217680
NODES=66
? (MO)
TT=6.137

? (problem)
TT=0.035

? (problem)
TT=0.036

? (problem)
TT=0.032

UNSAT
TT=1201.21

? (problem)
TT=153.86

UNSAT
TT=13.91

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (problem)
TT=0.034

UNSAT
TT=45.485

UNSAT
TT=40.359

?
TT=380.301

UNSAT
TT=13.927

UNSAT
TT=254.863

CHECKS=1392220
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=246.242

CHECKS=1392220
NODES=0
marc/
large-84-sat_ext.xml
SAT
TT=15.726

SAT
TT=15.726

CHECKS=46863
NODES=0
SAT
TT=17.41

CHECKS=43377
NODES=84
? (conv)
TT=0.017

SAT
TT=51.814

SAT
TT=52.188

SAT
TT=52.752

NODES=0
SAT
TT=52.801

NODES=84
SAT
TT=58.359

CHECKS=6972
NODES=84
? (MO)
TT=5.592

? (problem)
TT=0.036

? (problem)
TT=0.035

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (problem)
TT=193.956

? (problem)
TT=186.422

SAT
TT=21.389

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (problem)
TT=0.035

SAT
TT=54.631

SAT
TT=55.909

?
TT=42.409

SAT
TT=20.018

SAT
TT=421.716

CHECKS=120553
NODES=84
SAT
TT=433.801

CHECKS=120553
NODES=84
marc/
large-84-unsat_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=13.844

UNSAT
TT=13.844

CHECKS=1407276
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=14.249

CHECKS=1271279
NODES=83
? (conv)
TT=0.018

UNSAT
TT=37.641

UNSAT
TT=39.556

UNSAT
TT=55.122

NODES=84
UNSAT
TT=59.573

NODES=67
UNSAT
TT=55.069

CHECKS=24590244
NODES=62
? (MO)
TT=6.58

? (problem)
TT=0.034

? (problem)
TT=0.034

? (problem)
TT=0.038

? (problem)
TT=121.576

? (problem)
TT=120.558

UNSAT
TT=18.192

? (problem)
TT=0.037

? (problem)
TT=0.033

UNSAT
TT=50.251

UNSAT
TT=48.507

?
TT=406.518

UNSAT
TT=16.077

UNSAT
TT=328.207

CHECKS=1612530
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=344.073

CHECKS=1612530
NODES=0
marc/
large-88-sat_ext.xml
SAT
TT=18.772

SAT
TT=20.441

CHECKS=36616
NODES=0
SAT
TT=18.772

CHECKS=32788
NODES=88
? (conv)
TT=0.017

SAT
TT=65.523

SAT
TT=65.277

?
TT=333.067

?
TT=310.926

?
TT=307.157

? (MO)
TT=6.578

? (problem)
TT=0.035

? (problem)
TT=0.035

? (problem)
TT=0.034

? (problem)
TT=297.525

? (problem)
TT=293.562

SAT
TT=25.826

? (problem)
TT=0.038

? (problem)
TT=0.035

SAT
TT=69.749

SAT
TT=65.84

?
TT=36.54

SAT
TT=25.072

SAT
TT=571.475

CHECKS=151260
NODES=88
SAT
TT=544.715

CHECKS=151260
NODES=88
marc/
large-88-unsat_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=16.382

UNSAT
TT=16.382

CHECKS=1645295
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=16.432

CHECKS=1440713
NODES=86
? (conv)
TT=0.018

UNSAT
TT=47.698

UNSAT
TT=48.17

UNSAT
TT=97.827

NODES=90
UNSAT
TT=110.393

NODES=65
UNSAT
TT=127.905

CHECKS=29636376
NODES=65
? (MO)
TT=7.207

? (problem)
TT=0.038

? (problem)
TT=0.037

? (problem)
TT=0.032

? (problem)
TT=143.944

? (problem)
TT=135.866

UNSAT
TT=21.55

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (problem)
TT=0.036

UNSAT
TT=62.673

UNSAT
TT=57.558

?
TT=1185.08

UNSAT
TT=20.234

UNSAT
TT=442.489

CHECKS=1854940
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=432.622

CHECKS=1854940
NODES=0
marc/
large-92-sat_ext.xml
SAT
TT=22.359

SAT
TT=22.359

CHECKS=47353
NODES=0
SAT
TT=22.374

CHECKS=43167
NODES=92
? (conv)
TT=0.017

SAT
TT=64.137

SAT
TT=66.806

?
TT=295.347

?
TT=262.385

?
TT=298.095

? (MO)
TT=6.964

? (problem)
TT=0.034

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (problem)
TT=0.033

? (problem)
TT=277.651

? (problem)
TT=277.531

SAT
TT=29.325

? (problem)
TT=0.032

? (problem)
TT=0.036

SAT
TT=77.395

SAT
TT=75.243

?
TT=52.873

SAT
TT=29.637

SAT
TT=722.096

CHECKS=154582
NODES=92
SAT
TT=713.33

CHECKS=154582
NODES=92
marc/
large-92-unsat_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=17.856

UNSAT
TT=17.856

CHECKS=1918859
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=18.064

CHECKS=1705351
NODES=91
? (conv)
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=53.635

UNSAT
TT=54.95

?
TT=382.528

?
TT=442.404

?
TT=426.781

? (MO)
TT=7.226

? (problem)
TT=0.034

? (problem)
TT=0.034

? (problem)
TT=0.035

? (problem)
TT=312.389

? (problem)
TT=350.259

UNSAT
TT=24.725

? (problem)
TT=0.035

? (problem)
TT=0.034

UNSAT
TT=65.889

UNSAT
TT=69.314

?
TT=37.84

UNSAT
TT=23.848

UNSAT
TT=595.023

CHECKS=2120440
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=554.758

CHECKS=2120440
NODES=0
marc/
large-96-sat_ext.xml
SAT
TT=27.436

SAT
TT=27.436

CHECKS=55143
NODES=0
SAT
TT=27.81

CHECKS=50583
NODES=96
? (conv)
TT=0.019

SAT
TT=79.646

SAT
TT=76.214

?
TT=221.385

?
TT=224.552

?
TT=257.978

? (MO)
TT=7.175

? (problem)
TT=0.036

? (problem)
TT=0.035

? (problem)
TT=0.034

? (problem)
TT=369.383

? (problem)
TT=381.216

SAT
TT=35.594

? (problem)
TT=0.036

? (problem)
TT=0.033

SAT
TT=88.633

SAT
TT=91.999

?
TT=46.11

SAT
TT=35.535

SAT
TT=925.562

CHECKS=159433
NODES=96
SAT
TT=989.084

CHECKS=159433
NODES=96
marc/
large-96-unsat_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=22.151

UNSAT
TT=22.151

CHECKS=2219519
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=22.819

CHECKS=1912760
NODES=94
? (conv)
TT=0.019

UNSAT
TT=64.663

UNSAT
TT=67.204

?
TT=297.215

?
TT=283.75

?
TT=276.517

? (MO)
TT=8.085

? (problem)
TT=0.037

? (problem)
TT=0.037

? (problem)
TT=0.036

? (problem)
TT=285.655

? (problem)
TT=311.484

UNSAT
TT=29.909

? (problem)
TT=0.035

? (problem)
TT=0.038

UNSAT
TT=99.355

UNSAT
TT=97.961

?
TT=39.73

UNSAT
TT=27.667

UNSAT
TT=727.499

CHECKS=2410260
NODES=0
UNSAT
TT=727.12

CHECKS=2410260
NODES=0
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-23/
rand-23-23-253-131-46021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=24.86

UNSAT
TT=101.002

CHECKS=664471318
NODES=506059
UNSAT
TT=105.137

CHECKS=707975132
NODES=537791
UNSAT
TT=48.463

UNSAT
TT=40.859

UNSAT
TT=41.603

UNSAT
TT=662.654

NODES=629730
UNSAT
TT=261.509

NODES=401280
UNSAT
TT=228.345

CHECKS=209198
NODES=397776
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=1458.47

CHECKS=783778269
NODES=552805
UNSAT
TT=1558.06

CHECKS=770203342
NODES=545218
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=116.395

UNSAT
TT=1604.72

CHECKS=752115205
NODES=533236
UNSAT
TT=1610.04

CHECKS=752115205
NODES=533236
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=137.153

UNSAT
TT=24.86

CHECKS=762123000
NODES=191607
UNSAT
TT=23.17

CHECKS=762123000
NODES=191607
random/rand-2-23/
rand-23-23-253-131-47021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=24.431

UNSAT
TT=97.097

CHECKS=651546326
NODES=490572
UNSAT
TT=95.632

CHECKS=632766949
NODES=478159
UNSAT
TT=45.859

UNSAT
TT=40.556

UNSAT
TT=39.117

UNSAT
TT=630.337

NODES=591855
UNSAT
TT=277.41

NODES=398958
UNSAT
TT=246.685

CHECKS=204096
NODES=393683
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=1450.59

CHECKS=740232637
NODES=518607
UNSAT
TT=1643.8

CHECKS=771846134
NODES=539918
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=110.491

UNSAT
TT=1488.32

CHECKS=732374599
NODES=513952
UNSAT
TT=1477.53

CHECKS=732374599
NODES=513952
? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=130.764

UNSAT
TT=24.431

CHECKS=749117000
NODES=186106
UNSAT
TT=22.656

CHECKS=749117000
NODES=186106
random/rand-2-23/
rand-23-23-253-131-48021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=15.971

SAT
TT=62.843

CHECKS=417178844
NODES=317237
SAT
TT=88.269

CHECKS=557724450
NODES=419676
SAT
TT=32.011

SAT
TT=15.971

SAT
TT=16.017

SAT
TT=330.758

NODES=337319
SAT
TT=62.109

NODES=92496
SAT
TT=56.24

CHECKS=203158
NODES=89596
SAT
TT=22.864

SAT
TT=303.081

CHECKS=170619178
NODES=118253
SAT
TT=103.994

CHECKS=52292305
NODES=35746
SAT
TT=773.27

CHECKS=403071536
NODES=285868
SAT
TT=430.967

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=50.311

SAT
TT=1084.6

CHECKS=537004351
NODES=375449
SAT
TT=1088.33

CHECKS=537004351
NODES=375449
? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=32.602

SAT
TT=18.199

CHECKS=550598000
NODES=135896
SAT
TT=17.861

CHECKS=550598000
NODES=135896
random/rand-2-23/
rand-23-23-253-131-49021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=2.012

SAT
TT=2.012

CHECKS=7376944
NODES=5844
SAT
TT=35.277

CHECKS=227992844
NODES=175674
SAT
TT=4.1

SAT
TT=6.628

SAT
TT=6.837

SAT
TT=163.233

NODES=168270
SAT
TT=238.787

NODES=371808
SAT
TT=163.754

CHECKS=204274
NODES=255511
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=92.559

CHECKS=48851059
NODES=34630
SAT
TT=986.929

CHECKS=483035909
NODES=338128
SAT
TT=769.925

CHECKS=402740569
NODES=279205
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=32.985

SAT
TT=115.183

CHECKS=57104512
NODES=40921
SAT
TT=114.945

CHECKS=57104512
NODES=40921
? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=35.401

SAT
TT=2.072

CHECKS=59176900
NODES=14990
SAT
TT=1.926

CHECKS=59176900
NODES=14990
random/rand-2-23/
rand-23-23-253-131-50021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=13.803

SAT
TT=90.851

CHECKS=634978159
NODES=492025
SAT
TT=59.985

CHECKS=420917965
NODES=332321
SAT
TT=50.227

SAT
TT=36.818

SAT
TT=38.488

SAT
TT=14.419

NODES=14338
SAT
TT=17.2

NODES=26910
SAT
TT=13.803

CHECKS=202050
NODES=20739
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=795.443

CHECKS=400415914
NODES=288685
SAT
TT=850.255

CHECKS=426303961
NODES=305648
SAT
TT=538.779

CHECKS=288001702
NODES=208248
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=50.642

SAT
TT=1727.25

CHECKS=791265385
NODES=569138
SAT
TT=1627.84

CHECKS=791265385
NODES=569138
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=31.294

SAT
TT=24.266

CHECKS=798235000
NODES=204563
SAT
TT=25.997

CHECKS=798235000
NODES=204563
random/rand-2-23/
rand-23-23-253-131-51021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=26.646

UNSAT
TT=101.899

CHECKS=686602124
NODES=524337
UNSAT
TT=108.77

CHECKS=715213835
NODES=546328
UNSAT
TT=52.065

UNSAT
TT=41.885

UNSAT
TT=44.604

UNSAT
TT=617.738

NODES=630633
UNSAT
TT=281.706

NODES=418143
UNSAT
TT=248.503

CHECKS=203736
NODES=412710
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=1530.77

CHECKS=796112620
NODES=567648
UNSAT
TT=1613.71

CHECKS=802076646
NODES=569445
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=112.245

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=138.204

UNSAT
TT=26.646

CHECKS=835359000
NODES=210810
UNSAT
TT=25.281

CHECKS=835359000
NODES=210810
random/rand-2-23/
rand-23-23-253-131-52021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=24.169

UNSAT
TT=92.282

CHECKS=628559294
NODES=472758
UNSAT
TT=99.401

CHECKS=687208692
NODES=515969
UNSAT
TT=47.007

UNSAT
TT=40.466

UNSAT
TT=41.304

UNSAT
TT=497.506

NODES=526802
UNSAT
TT=243.746

NODES=396159
UNSAT
TT=222.123

CHECKS=206941
NODES=381106
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=1420.05

CHECKS=723442419
NODES=507295
UNSAT
TT=1553.47

CHECKS=725586468
NODES=510671
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=105.687

UNSAT
TT=1493.36

CHECKS=725821946
NODES=509970
UNSAT
TT=1474.54

CHECKS=725821946
NODES=509970
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=135.046

UNSAT
TT=24.169

CHECKS=735585000
NODES=182201
UNSAT
TT=23.951

CHECKS=735585000
NODES=182201
random/rand-2-23/
rand-23-23-253-131-53021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=14.128

SAT
TT=51.192

CHECKS=358011256
NODES=273402
SAT
TT=83.25

CHECKS=564800774
NODES=427559
SAT
TT=27.249

SAT
TT=34.371

SAT
TT=34.512

SAT
TT=269.533

NODES=248405
SAT
TT=137.675

NODES=223174
SAT
TT=146.531

CHECKS=203928
NODES=251716
SAT
TT=598.792

SAT
TT=574.748

CHECKS=290298776
NODES=202185
SAT
TT=1156.35

CHECKS=573112693
NODES=397335
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=14.609

SAT
TT=907.845

CHECKS=422330190
NODES=295488
SAT
TT=917.335

CHECKS=422330190
NODES=295488
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

SAT
TT=1659.26

SAT
TT=70.637

SAT
TT=14.128

CHECKS=430194000
NODES=105854
SAT
TT=13.958

CHECKS=430194000
NODES=105854
random/rand-2-23/
rand-23-23-253-131-54021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=4.645

SAT
TT=14.622

CHECKS=95977087
NODES=76067
SAT
TT=12.394

CHECKS=75607897
NODES=59480
SAT
TT=32.047

SAT
TT=9.433

SAT
TT=9.474

SAT
TT=31.708

NODES=30573
SAT
TT=237.083

NODES=373220
SAT
TT=242.81

CHECKS=204930
NODES=390260
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=80.247

CHECKS=43085631
NODES=30594
SAT
TT=385.739

CHECKS=187410818
NODES=132151
SAT
TT=2.567

CHECKS=1512597
NODES=858
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=4.645

SAT
TT=1000.48

CHECKS=489122706
NODES=345569
SAT
TT=1064.56

CHECKS=489122706
NODES=345569
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800

SAT
TT=34.367

SAT
TT=15.447

CHECKS=499759000
NODES=124701
SAT
TT=16.24

CHECKS=499759000
NODES=124701
random/rand-2-23/
rand-23-23-253-131-55021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=25.031

UNSAT
TT=95.266

CHECKS=680900187
NODES=519269
UNSAT
TT=100.11

CHECKS=704845115
NODES=534420
UNSAT
TT=47.959

UNSAT
TT=39.328

UNSAT
TT=38.816

UNSAT
TT=617.721

NODES=592933
UNSAT
TT=248.638

NODES=381123
UNSAT
TT=244.892

CHECKS=211873
NODES=385783
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=1493.47

CHECKS=791280626
NODES=560604
UNSAT
TT=1623.63

CHECKS=759043314
NODES=539070
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=119.694

UNSAT
TT=1521.39

CHECKS=741708310
NODES=526836
UNSAT
TT=1626.33

CHECKS=741708310
NODES=526836
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=145.561

UNSAT
TT=25.031

CHECKS=762712000
NODES=191299
UNSAT
TT=24.787

CHECKS=762712000
NODES=191299
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-24/
rand-24-24-276-139-48021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=9.908

SAT
TT=213.073

CHECKS=1414666342
NODES=1016839
SAT
TT=147.566

CHECKS=974819716
NODES=705542
SAT
TT=18.262

SAT
TT=34.788

SAT
TT=32.662

SAT
TT=704.814

NODES=678317
SAT
TT=471.958

NODES=689898
SAT
TT=530.69

CHECKS=243248
NODES=788131
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=883.398

CHECKS=386701364
NODES=256299
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=64.614

SAT
TT=599.416

CHECKS=293501519
NODES=192693
SAT
TT=570.573

CHECKS=293501519
NODES=192693
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=13.383

SAT
TT=9.908

CHECKS=300621000
NODES=70002
SAT
TT=9.27

CHECKS=300621000
NODES=70002
random/rand-2-24/
rand-24-24-276-139-49021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=56.069

UNSAT
TT=228.635

CHECKS=1553737166
NODES=1098163
UNSAT
TT=232.767

CHECKS=1555666554
NODES=1101906
UNSAT
TT=103.935

UNSAT
TT=91.04

UNSAT
TT=90.827

UNSAT
TT=1406.77

NODES=1236388
UNSAT
TT=539.554

NODES=795674
UNSAT
TT=535.154

CHECKS=246004
NODES=802102
? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800

UNSAT
TT=254.807

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=272.434

UNSAT
TT=56.069

CHECKS=1711640000
NODES=402360
UNSAT
TT=52.279

CHECKS=1711640000
NODES=402360
random/rand-2-24/
rand-24-24-276-139-50021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=2.304

SAT
TT=147.2

CHECKS=788976565
NODES=574096
SAT
TT=138.649

CHECKS=925440958
NODES=668604
SAT
TT=12.336

SAT
TT=2.304

SAT
TT=2.399

SAT
TT=325.252

NODES=317447
SAT
TT=477.258

NODES=679748
SAT
TT=554.595

CHECKS=246233
NODES=830152
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=186.62

CHECKS=72612342
NODES=46609
SAT
TT=227.789

CHECKS=80165499
NODES=53126
SAT
TT=1288.21

CHECKS=603386892
NODES=397894
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=39.669

SAT
TT=451.905

CHECKS=188252699
NODES=127703
SAT
TT=378.4

CHECKS=188252699
NODES=127703
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=164.954

SAT
TT=4.678

CHECKS=131220000
NODES=31689
SAT
TT=4.485

CHECKS=131220000
NODES=31689
random/rand-2-24/
rand-24-24-276-139-51021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=60.286

UNSAT
TT=236.257

CHECKS=1584006012
NODES=1128656
UNSAT
TT=218.831

CHECKS=1582522674
NODES=1127737
UNSAT
TT=106.13

UNSAT
TT=91.377

UNSAT
TT=86.446

UNSAT
TT=1477.08

NODES=1295837
UNSAT
TT=589.085

NODES=866918
UNSAT
TT=531.282

CHECKS=244532
NODES=853372
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=270.003

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=287.232

UNSAT
TT=60.286

CHECKS=1847260000
NODES=435549
UNSAT
TT=59.555

CHECKS=1847260000
NODES=435549
random/rand-2-24/
rand-24-24-276-139-52021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=55.477

UNSAT
TT=215.91

CHECKS=1555434220
NODES=1109595
UNSAT
TT=243.456

CHECKS=1637246566
NODES=1166907
UNSAT
TT=110.884

UNSAT
TT=93.512

UNSAT
TT=89.107

UNSAT
TT=1455.17

NODES=1321050
UNSAT
TT=588.149

NODES=850642
UNSAT
TT=573.365

CHECKS=251214
NODES=855829
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=277.791

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=268.842

UNSAT
TT=55.477

CHECKS=1807570000
NODES=427576
UNSAT
TT=58.64

CHECKS=1807570000
NODES=427576
random/rand-2-24/
rand-24-24-276-139-53021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=59.617

UNSAT
TT=242.033

CHECKS=1706551088
NODES=1229334
UNSAT
TT=221.61

CHECKS=1599232375
NODES=1147915
UNSAT
TT=115.464

UNSAT
TT=93.693

UNSAT
TT=100.069

UNSAT
TT=1504.72

NODES=1348259
UNSAT
TT=602.223

NODES=889719
UNSAT
TT=533.233

CHECKS=245276
NODES=864550
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=273.994

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=325.582

UNSAT
TT=59.617

CHECKS=1832500000
NODES=440219
UNSAT
TT=59.522

CHECKS=1832500000
NODES=440219
random/rand-2-24/
rand-24-24-276-139-54021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=56.377

UNSAT
TT=242.176

CHECKS=1602549192
NODES=1143657
UNSAT
TT=228.278

CHECKS=1528489291
NODES=1094528
UNSAT
TT=114.651

UNSAT
TT=93.738

UNSAT
TT=88.136

UNSAT
TT=1525.12

NODES=1369953
UNSAT
TT=546.593

NODES=854078
UNSAT
TT=562.965

CHECKS=244564
NODES=855354
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=259.649

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=307.728

UNSAT
TT=56.377

CHECKS=1864660000
NODES=446788
UNSAT
TT=56.492

CHECKS=1864660000
NODES=446788
random/rand-2-24/
rand-24-24-276-139-55021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.168

SAT
TT=1.168

CHECKS=1801574
NODES=1377
SAT
TT=1.954

CHECKS=6494220
NODES=4962
SAT
TT=31.511

SAT
TT=12.801

SAT
TT=13.668

SAT
TT=5.673

NODES=5011
SAT
TT=598.072

NODES=881853
SAT
TT=555.653

CHECKS=244557
NODES=894244
SAT
TT=861.434

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=26.81

SAT
TT=944.038

CHECKS=497258443
NODES=335849
SAT
TT=1033.16

CHECKS=497258443
NODES=335849
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=279.269

SAT
TT=17.253

CHECKS=522694000
NODES=125417
SAT
TT=16.075

CHECKS=522694000
NODES=125417
random/rand-2-24/
rand-24-24-276-139-56021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=58.767

UNSAT
TT=232.713

CHECKS=1597679929
NODES=1137974
UNSAT
TT=238.808

CHECKS=1640788103
NODES=1166772
UNSAT
TT=111.903

UNSAT
TT=87.561

UNSAT
TT=93.535

UNSAT
TT=1494.96

NODES=1329646
UNSAT
TT=600.625

NODES=879635
UNSAT
TT=556.736

CHECKS=244918
NODES=834324
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=285.133

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=320.923

UNSAT
TT=58.767

CHECKS=1795260000
NODES=430122
UNSAT
TT=54.499

CHECKS=1795260000
NODES=430122
random/rand-2-24/
rand-24-24-276-139-57021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=53.806

UNSAT
TT=216.885

CHECKS=1565934214
NODES=1107913
UNSAT
TT=245.325

CHECKS=1644791796
NODES=1161685
UNSAT
TT=100.9

UNSAT
TT=90.272

UNSAT
TT=90.523

UNSAT
TT=1145.88

NODES=1110887
UNSAT
TT=559.062

NODES=864254
UNSAT
TT=517.587

CHECKS=250644
NODES=812349
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=262.678

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=313.764

UNSAT
TT=53.806

CHECKS=1755300000
NODES=412537
UNSAT
TT=56.885

CHECKS=1755300000
NODES=412537
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-25/
rand-25-25-300-147-50021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=134.869

UNSAT
TT=503.625

CHECKS=3369245681
NODES=2272965
UNSAT
TT=513.121

CHECKS=3489842688
NODES=2353737
UNSAT
TT=236.594

UNSAT
TT=218.673

UNSAT
TT=220.804

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=1250.64

NODES=1829749
UNSAT
TT=1313.81

CHECKS=295364
NODES=1850502
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=615.269

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=690.646

UNSAT
TT=134.869

CHECKS=4135990000
NODES=936880
UNSAT
TT=128.117

CHECKS=4135990000
NODES=936880
random/rand-2-25/
rand-25-25-300-147-51021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=11.738

SAT
TT=370.913

CHECKS=2450727471
NODES=1658752
SAT
TT=212.61

CHECKS=1427027943
NODES=979062
SAT
TT=21.968

SAT
TT=76.246

SAT
TT=71.552

SAT
TT=13.306

NODES=11101
SAT
TT=1115.34

NODES=1534296
SAT
TT=824.628

CHECKS=288993
NODES=1217820
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=976.171

CHECKS=420259026
NODES=261908
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=276.226

SAT
TT=879.005

CHECKS=339377582
NODES=216425
SAT
TT=813.193

CHECKS=339377582
NODES=216425
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=370.066

SAT
TT=11.738

CHECKS=350432000
NODES=79886
SAT
TT=11.601

CHECKS=350432000
NODES=79886
random/rand-2-25/
rand-25-25-300-147-52021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=32.93

SAT
TT=534.098

CHECKS=3542492925
NODES=2400357
SAT
TT=304.569

CHECKS=2123431907
NODES=1458249
SAT
TT=63.364

SAT
TT=58.12

SAT
TT=58.216

SAT
TT=906.96

NODES=798587
SAT
TT=259.793

NODES=350085
SAT
TT=424.325

CHECKS=291232
NODES=578671
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=275.489

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=575.814

SAT
TT=32.93

CHECKS=991567000
NODES=229629
SAT
TT=31.573

CHECKS=991567000
NODES=229629
random/rand-2-25/
rand-25-25-300-147-53021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=13.229

SAT
TT=51.094

CHECKS=328038770
NODES=230193
SAT
TT=122.715

CHECKS=813162621
NODES=561762
SAT
TT=134.075

SAT
TT=13.229

SAT
TT=13.521

SAT
TT=470.625

NODES=418261
SAT
TT=1059.12

NODES=1454007
SAT
TT=1115.31

CHECKS=294140
NODES=1663115
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=83.62

CHECKS=35121091
NODES=21260
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=332.012

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=213.847

SAT
TT=76.16

CHECKS=2318470000
NODES=521246
SAT
TT=75.451

CHECKS=2318470000
NODES=521246
random/rand-2-25/
rand-25-25-300-147-54021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=25.548

SAT
TT=34.208

CHECKS=234412254
NODES=166444
SAT
TT=40.121

CHECKS=260618020
NODES=183809
SAT
TT=55.617

SAT
TT=44.876

SAT
TT=45.259

SAT
TT=1120.61

NODES=947597
SAT
TT=644.336

NODES=825593
SAT
TT=428.961

CHECKS=289785
NODES=597286
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=813.695

CHECKS=339668462
NODES=212704
SAT
TT=865.474

CHECKS=340952580
NODES=214285
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=44.002

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=345.737

SAT
TT=25.548

CHECKS=822572000
NODES=186666
SAT
TT=25.118

CHECKS=822572000
NODES=186666
random/rand-2-25/
rand-25-25-300-147-55021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=132.125

UNSAT
TT=533.618

CHECKS=3581421535
NODES=2409979
UNSAT
TT=532.17

CHECKS=3579809423
NODES=2398009
UNSAT
TT=253.898

UNSAT
TT=224.316

UNSAT
TT=220.62

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=1420.21

NODES=1866654
UNSAT
TT=1298.41

CHECKS=291463
NODES=1860874
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=612.121

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=758.363

UNSAT
TT=132.125

CHECKS=4005370000
NODES=899287
UNSAT
TT=122.287

CHECKS=4005370000
NODES=899287
random/rand-2-25/
rand-25-25-300-147-56021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=42.811

SAT
TT=273.819

CHECKS=1898482255
NODES=1300295
SAT
TT=73.191

CHECKS=474116338
NODES=332703
SAT
TT=253.635

SAT
TT=42.811

SAT
TT=43.132

SAT
TT=454.81

NODES=379895
SAT
TT=1134.34

NODES=1513963
SAT
TT=181.954

CHECKS=287781
NODES=243339
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=657.716

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=250.784

SAT
TT=141.659

CHECKS=4358630000
NODES=992077
SAT
TT=135.087

CHECKS=4358630000
NODES=992077
random/rand-2-25/
rand-25-25-300-147-57021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=132.712

UNSAT
TT=521.111

CHECKS=3766952057
NODES=2515566
UNSAT
TT=527.374

CHECKS=3802175966
NODES=2544776
UNSAT
TT=256.91

UNSAT
TT=211.906

UNSAT
TT=217.122

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=1285.51

NODES=1742687
UNSAT
TT=1227.19

CHECKS=292338
NODES=1830165
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=569.468

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=730.282

UNSAT
TT=132.712

CHECKS=4056660000
NODES=907895
UNSAT
TT=122.593

CHECKS=4056660000
NODES=907895
random/rand-2-25/
rand-25-25-300-147-58021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=138.007

UNSAT
TT=554.894

CHECKS=3638906372
NODES=2448692
UNSAT
TT=539.853

CHECKS=3635581339
NODES=2444140
UNSAT
TT=257.88

UNSAT
TT=219.473

UNSAT
TT=216.984

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=1435.11

NODES=1943210
UNSAT
TT=1337.12

CHECKS=296244
NODES=1928130
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=619.047

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=712.433

UNSAT
TT=138.007

CHECKS=4212780000
NODES=952782
UNSAT
TT=128.484

CHECKS=4212780000
NODES=952782
random/rand-2-25/
rand-25-25-300-147-59021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=67.126

SAT
TT=144.139

CHECKS=1004797476
NODES=694039
SAT
TT=107.003

CHECKS=749377810
NODES=520363
SAT
TT=122.062

SAT
TT=83.757

SAT
TT=84.501

SAT
TT=15.637

NODES=13432
SAT
TT=924.12

NODES=1332557
SAT
TT=892.97

CHECKS=292979
NODES=1305477
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=553.122

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.51

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=655.159

SAT
TT=67.126

CHECKS=2032330000
NODES=457598
SAT
TT=66.411

CHECKS=2032330000
NODES=457598
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-26/
rand-26-26-325-155-52021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=337.775

UNSAT
TT=1355.64

CHECKS=9005733151
NODES=5782824
UNSAT
TT=1277.39

CHECKS=8721566284
NODES=5614387
UNSAT
TT=601.029

UNSAT
TT=509

UNSAT
TT=508.457

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=1468.95

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=1787.2

UNSAT
TT=337.775

CHECKS=10202400000
NODES=2240380
UNSAT
TT=318.67

CHECKS=10202400000
NODES=2240380
random/rand-2-26/
rand-26-26-325-155-53021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=35.019

SAT
TT=35.019

CHECKS=242178619
NODES=160905
SAT
TT=201.072

CHECKS=1331169532
NODES=870893
SAT
TT=215.028

SAT
TT=223.228

SAT
TT=209.42

SAT
TT=1151.46

NODES=913408
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=47.089

SAT
TT=1770.66

CHECKS=760876079
NODES=459137
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=856.709

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=1023.08

SAT
TT=114.818

CHECKS=3467430000
NODES=753142
SAT
TT=106.314

CHECKS=3467430000
NODES=753142
random/rand-2-26/
rand-26-26-325-155-54021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=40.429

SAT
TT=155.928

CHECKS=1022061274
NODES=684119
SAT
TT=187.911

CHECKS=1307777023
NODES=870280
SAT
TT=224.366

SAT
TT=307.981

SAT
TT=319.846

SAT
TT=785.129

NODES=638090
SAT
TT=1421.02

NODES=1921018
SAT
TT=1279.6

CHECKS=342766
NODES=1786561
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=86.666

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800

SAT
TT=40.429

SAT
TT=126.88

CHECKS=3802980000
NODES=836956
SAT
TT=116.686

CHECKS=3802980000
NODES=836956
random/rand-2-26/
rand-26-26-325-155-55021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=35.281

SAT
TT=157.415

CHECKS=1050111013
NODES=690303
SAT
TT=35.281

CHECKS=244412805
NODES=161930
SAT
TT=553.75

SAT
TT=156.317

SAT
TT=166.251

SAT
TT=1396.49

NODES=1144180
SAT
TT=772.139

NODES=1067168
SAT
TT=576.246

CHECKS=339958
NODES=750873
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=1265.5

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=247.01

SAT
TT=309.434

CHECKS=9399700000
NODES=2044320
SAT
TT=294.735

CHECKS=9399700000
NODES=2044320
random/rand-2-26/
rand-26-26-325-155-56021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=345.71

UNSAT
TT=1318.13

CHECKS=9425637831
NODES=6019711
UNSAT
TT=1463.95

CHECKS=9645085718
NODES=6189826
UNSAT
TT=653.046

UNSAT
TT=554.257

UNSAT
TT=554.953

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=1414.49

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=345.71

CHECKS=10472300000
NODES=2286260
UNSAT
TT=319.91

CHECKS=10472300000
NODES=2286260
random/rand-2-26/
rand-26-26-325-155-57021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=338.633

UNSAT
TT=1269.45

CHECKS=8768564687
NODES=5649761
UNSAT
TT=1341.12

CHECKS=9150990544
NODES=5902241
UNSAT
TT=649.235

UNSAT
TT=542.476

UNSAT
TT=529.958

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=1447.45

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=1714.26

UNSAT
TT=338.633

CHECKS=10526000000
NODES=2316910
UNSAT
TT=321.916

CHECKS=10526000000
NODES=2316910
random/rand-2-26/
rand-26-26-325-155-58021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=318.764

UNSAT
TT=1291.88

CHECKS=9176264909
NODES=5884568
UNSAT
TT=1231.94

CHECKS=8836686153
NODES=5681952
UNSAT
TT=646.577

UNSAT
TT=513.034

UNSAT
TT=510.448

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=1580.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=1785.85

UNSAT
TT=318.764

CHECKS=10339900000
NODES=2274760
UNSAT
TT=320.299

CHECKS=10339900000
NODES=2274760
random/rand-2-26/
rand-26-26-325-155-59021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=112.163

SAT
TT=466.973

CHECKS=3323605609
NODES=2180140
SAT
TT=492.535

CHECKS=3523297774
NODES=2302238
SAT
TT=221.994

SAT
TT=516.639

SAT
TT=517.463

SAT
TT=1586.28

NODES=1229305
SAT
TT=629.324

NODES=762811
SAT
TT=1010.52

CHECKS=342182
NODES=845046
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=892.549

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=826.791

SAT
TT=112.163

CHECKS=3634670000
NODES=793981
SAT
TT=119.794

CHECKS=3634670000
NODES=793981
random/rand-2-26/
rand-26-26-325-155-60021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=318.1

UNSAT
TT=1337.4

CHECKS=8587703125
NODES=5479114
UNSAT
TT=1289.82

CHECKS=8612838268
NODES=5498578
UNSAT
TT=579.042

UNSAT
TT=503.852

UNSAT
TT=503.558

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=1381.28

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=1772.32

UNSAT
TT=318.1

CHECKS=9708500000
NODES=2106620
UNSAT
TT=316.283

CHECKS=9708500000
NODES=2106620
random/rand-2-26/
rand-26-26-325-155-61021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=81.645

SAT
TT=130.956

CHECKS=912492751
NODES=600102
SAT
TT=81.645

CHECKS=532901111
NODES=353596
SAT
TT=517.495

SAT
TT=128.827

SAT
TT=134.844

SAT
TT=1378.39

NODES=1061274
SAT
TT=1648.12

NODES=2047478
SAT
TT=1251.35

CHECKS=341031
NODES=1133978
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=141.79

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=1179.38

SAT
TT=259.427

CHECKS=8265280000
NODES=1812420
SAT
TT=266.796

CHECKS=8265280000
NODES=1812420
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-27/
rand-27-27-351-163-54021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=220.171

SAT
TT=1362.94

CHECKS=6747430171
NODES=4248045
SAT
TT=740.603

CHECKS=3698357799
NODES=2338116
SAT
TT=548.281

SAT
TT=220.171

SAT
TT=235.041

SAT
TT=996.524

NODES=734923
SAT
TT=1342.42

NODES=1628535
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=723.889

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=1459.41

SAT
TT=292.322

CHECKS=9328710000
NODES=1974470
SAT
TT=296.105

CHECKS=9328710000
NODES=1974470
random/rand-2-27/
rand-27-27-351-163-55021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=779.576

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=1259.52

UNSAT
TT=1177.97

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=779.576

CHECKS=23455500000
NODES=4881500
UNSAT
TT=767.924

CHECKS=23455500000
NODES=4881500
random/rand-2-27/
rand-27-27-351-163-56021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=4.147

SAT
TT=4.147

CHECKS=15272227
NODES=10030
SAT
TT=1110.46

CHECKS=5579664320
NODES=3488801
SAT
TT=255.986

SAT
TT=198.668

SAT
TT=186.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=744.986

CHECKS=249273441
NODES=139470
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=370.182

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=145.221

CHECKS=4367660000
NODES=899596
SAT
TT=133.627

CHECKS=4367660000
NODES=899596
random/rand-2-27/
rand-27-27-351-163-57021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=780.343

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=1313.11

UNSAT
TT=1224.99

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=780.343

CHECKS=25314900000
NODES=5370120
UNSAT
TT=832.437

CHECKS=25314900000
NODES=5370120
random/rand-2-27/
rand-27-27-351-163-58021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=822.211

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=1295.62

UNSAT
TT=1297.44

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=822.211

CHECKS=25772500000
NODES=5399300
UNSAT
TT=843.672

CHECKS=25772500000
NODES=5399300
random/rand-2-27/
rand-27-27-351-163-59021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=836.584

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=1240.91

UNSAT
TT=1245.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

UNSAT
TT=836.584

CHECKS=25515300000
NODES=5374010
UNSAT
TT=840.682

CHECKS=25515300000
NODES=5374010
random/rand-2-27/
rand-27-27-351-163-60021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=221.806

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=1603.86

CHECKS=8251906671
NODES=5089835
SAT
TT=659.718

SAT
TT=388.992

SAT
TT=364.013

SAT
TT=395.976

NODES=306178
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800

SAT
TT=1626.67

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=221.806

SAT
TT=341.455

CHECKS=10373900000
NODES=2145620
SAT
TT=341.431

CHECKS=10373900000
NODES=2145620
random/rand-2-27/
rand-27-27-351-163-61021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=873.694

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=1412.67

UNSAT
TT=1324.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=873.694

CHECKS=26575700000
NODES=5698190
UNSAT
TT=838.505

CHECKS=26575700000
NODES=5698190
random/rand-2-27/
rand-27-27-351-163-62021_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=809.946

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=1249.41

UNSAT
TT=1211.58

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=809.946

CHECKS=24664900000
NODES=5147560
UNSAT
TT=807.041

CHECKS=24664900000
NODES=5147560
random/rand-2-27/
rand-27-27-351-163-63021_ext.xml
SAT
TT=135.415

SAT
TT=135.415

CHECKS=636103776
NODES=401804
SAT
TT=834.703

CHECKS=4157663730
NODES=2599948
SAT
TT=450.96

SAT
TT=576.406

SAT
TT=539.844

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=1444.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=224.173

CHECKS=6807330000
NODES=1420480
SAT
TT=223.698

CHECKS=6807330000
NODES=1420480
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-11_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.072

SAT
TT=1.431

CHECKS=2841278
NODES=3075
SAT
TT=0.935

CHECKS=310153
NODES=393
SAT
TT=1.637

SAT
TT=0.445

SAT
TT=0.445

SAT
TT=0.811

NODES=425
SAT
TT=4.124

NODES=6042
SAT
TT=2.086

CHECKS=75537
NODES=2677
SAT
TT=1.689

SAT
TT=10.78

CHECKS=5648841
NODES=4482
SAT
TT=11.038

CHECKS=5540558
NODES=4508
SAT
TT=4.322

CHECKS=2749226
NODES=1723
SAT
TT=12.452

SAT
TT=5.25

SAT
TT=0.094

SAT
TT=0.923

CHECKS=499791
NODES=400
SAT
TT=0.926

CHECKS=499791
NODES=400
SAT
TT=2.463

SAT
TT=2.617

SAT
TT=5.064

SAT
TT=0.129

SAT
TT=0.072

CHECKS=622349
NODES=219
SAT
TT=0.069

CHECKS=622349
NODES=219
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-13_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.149

SAT
TT=0.951

CHECKS=745600
NODES=789
SAT
TT=1.183

CHECKS=1777229
NODES=1860
SAT
TT=0.423

SAT
TT=1.455

SAT
TT=1.441

SAT
TT=0.678

NODES=218
SAT
TT=1.797

NODES=2016
SAT
TT=1.631

CHECKS=67798
NODES=2040
SAT
TT=2.612

SAT
TT=12.13

CHECKS=7710959
NODES=5493
SAT
TT=13.995

CHECKS=9290837
NODES=6752
SAT
TT=6.166

CHECKS=4449254
NODES=2789
SAT
TT=3.789

SAT
TT=3.524

SAT
TT=0.727

SAT
TT=5.171

CHECKS=3676892
NODES=2466
SAT
TT=5.503

CHECKS=3676892
NODES=2466
SAT
TT=2.765

SAT
TT=3.437

SAT
TT=12.49

SAT
TT=0.472

SAT
TT=0.149

CHECKS=3771040
NODES=929
SAT
TT=0.163

CHECKS=3771040
NODES=929
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-15_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.103

SAT
TT=0.964

CHECKS=626148
NODES=720
SAT
TT=0.829

CHECKS=123717
NODES=162
SAT
TT=0.603

SAT
TT=1.359

SAT
TT=1.305

SAT
TT=0.779

NODES=351
SAT
TT=1.202

NODES=1137
SAT
TT=1.042

CHECKS=73064
NODES=782
SAT
TT=0.521

SAT
TT=0.135

CHECKS=30815
NODES=34
SAT
TT=13.573

CHECKS=7318263
NODES=5767
SAT
TT=0.949

CHECKS=635103
NODES=389
SAT
TT=2.296

SAT
TT=1.874

SAT
TT=0.72

SAT
TT=4.151

CHECKS=2391312
NODES=1816
SAT
TT=4.137

CHECKS=2391312
NODES=1816
SAT
TT=4.524

SAT
TT=4.503

SAT
TT=4.89

SAT
TT=1.408

SAT
TT=0.103

CHECKS=1704310
NODES=534
SAT
TT=0.105

CHECKS=1704310
NODES=534
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-17_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.259

SAT
TT=0.92

CHECKS=512804
NODES=572
SAT
TT=0.925

CHECKS=453793
NODES=528
SAT
TT=1.19

SAT
TT=0.659

SAT
TT=0.684

SAT
TT=3.57

NODES=5344
SAT
TT=3.078

NODES=4177
SAT
TT=2.695

CHECKS=73587
NODES=3895
SAT
TT=0.842

SAT
TT=6.786

CHECKS=4194565
NODES=3130
SAT
TT=7.142

CHECKS=3919045
NODES=3094
SAT
TT=2.539

CHECKS=1724291
NODES=1102
SAT
TT=4.541

SAT
TT=3.562

SAT
TT=0.259

SAT
TT=16.619

CHECKS=10697755
NODES=7116
SAT
TT=16.974

CHECKS=10697755
NODES=7116
SAT
TT=3.533

SAT
TT=3.367

SAT
TT=13.45

SAT
TT=0.71

SAT
TT=0.366

CHECKS=10533200
NODES=2668
SAT
TT=0.367

CHECKS=10533200
NODES=2668
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-19_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.076

SAT
TT=0.952

CHECKS=564037
NODES=596
SAT
TT=1.48

CHECKS=2898095
NODES=3122
SAT
TT=0.213

SAT
TT=1.447

SAT
TT=1.398

SAT
TT=0.91

NODES=600
SAT
TT=1.745

NODES=2193
SAT
TT=1.33

CHECKS=72466
NODES=1452
SAT
TT=1.396

SAT
TT=10.244

CHECKS=5552853
NODES=4470
SAT
TT=31.698

CHECKS=18990546
NODES=14375
SAT
TT=6.558

CHECKS=4114533
NODES=2915
SAT
TT=11.389

SAT
TT=21.84

SAT
TT=1.348

SAT
TT=1.041

CHECKS=556303
NODES=458
SAT
TT=1.044

CHECKS=556303
NODES=458
SAT
TT=12.686

SAT
TT=12.581

SAT
TT=15.65

SAT
TT=1.2

SAT
TT=0.076

CHECKS=772874
NODES=238
SAT
TT=0.076

CHECKS=772874
NODES=238
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-21_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.352

SAT
TT=0.871

CHECKS=123032
NODES=130
SAT
TT=1.023

CHECKS=779386
NODES=922
SAT
TT=1.044

SAT
TT=1.264

SAT
TT=1.336

SAT
TT=0.81

NODES=432
SAT
TT=2.029

NODES=2443
SAT
TT=3.604

CHECKS=71161
NODES=5751
SAT
TT=1.312

SAT
TT=14.142

CHECKS=8805984
NODES=6765
SAT
TT=18.446

CHECKS=11762844
NODES=9033
SAT
TT=52.858

CHECKS=35399030
NODES=25893
SAT
TT=5.793

SAT
TT=5.065

SAT
TT=1.842

SAT
TT=13.704

CHECKS=9295265
NODES=6703
SAT
TT=14.707

CHECKS=9295265
NODES=6703
SAT
TT=3.068

SAT
TT=2.888

SAT
TT=19.402

SAT
TT=0.956

SAT
TT=0.352

CHECKS=9829220
NODES=2754
SAT
TT=0.331

CHECKS=9829220
NODES=2754
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-23_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.352

SAT
TT=1.008

CHECKS=913570
NODES=1027
SAT
TT=1.16

CHECKS=1445104
NODES=1632
SAT
TT=1.093

SAT
TT=0.352

SAT
TT=0.357

SAT
TT=1.537

NODES=1868
SAT
TT=1.076

NODES=955
SAT
TT=0.653

CHECKS=70733
NODES=94
SAT
TT=0.436

SAT
TT=33.453

CHECKS=21660007
NODES=17174
SAT
TT=0.252

CHECKS=95401
NODES=96
SAT
TT=15.944

CHECKS=10175931
NODES=8198
SAT
TT=2.782

SAT
TT=4.118

SAT
TT=1.714

SAT
TT=24.847

CHECKS=15453151
NODES=12385
SAT
TT=24.981

CHECKS=15453151
NODES=12385
SAT
TT=2.651

SAT
TT=2.85

SAT
TT=28.797

SAT
TT=3.385

SAT
TT=0.562

CHECKS=16131500
NODES=4861
SAT
TT=0.564

CHECKS=16131500
NODES=4861
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-25_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.113

SAT
TT=0.855

CHECKS=336912
NODES=334
SAT
TT=0.859

CHECKS=76063
NODES=103
SAT
TT=1.191

SAT
TT=0.461

SAT
TT=0.443

SAT
TT=0.787

NODES=366
SAT
TT=2.909

NODES=3994
SAT
TT=4.196

CHECKS=71824
NODES=6603
SAT
TT=1.01

SAT
TT=31.798

CHECKS=19528863
NODES=13963
SAT
TT=30.206

CHECKS=18278494
NODES=13060
SAT
TT=23.422

CHECKS=15853932
NODES=10618
SAT
TT=10.482

SAT
TT=12.887

SAT
TT=0.616

SAT
TT=3.174

CHECKS=2015068
NODES=1321
SAT
TT=3.259

CHECKS=2015068
NODES=1321
SAT
TT=17.926

SAT
TT=17.691

SAT
TT=13.414

SAT
TT=1.649

SAT
TT=0.113

CHECKS=2069700
NODES=465
SAT
TT=0.108

CHECKS=2069700
NODES=465
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-27_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.079

SAT
TT=1.235

CHECKS=1877612
NODES=2049
SAT
TT=1.413

CHECKS=2853975
NODES=3208
SAT
TT=0.28

SAT
TT=1.005

SAT
TT=1.046

SAT
TT=3.486

NODES=5117
SAT
TT=1.93

NODES=2516
SAT
TT=2.726

CHECKS=70796
NODES=4176
SAT
TT=2.888

SAT
TT=11.07

CHECKS=6567478
NODES=5098
SAT
TT=8.171

CHECKS=4792992
NODES=3756
SAT
TT=7.26

CHECKS=5234720
NODES=3757
SAT
TT=4.071

SAT
TT=4.214

SAT
TT=0.927

SAT
TT=1.743

CHECKS=1128697
NODES=815
SAT
TT=1.783

CHECKS=1128697
NODES=815
SAT
TT=6.639

SAT
TT=6.99

SAT
TT=9.07

SAT
TT=0.987

SAT
TT=0.079

CHECKS=917823
NODES=271
SAT
TT=0.079

CHECKS=917823
NODES=271
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-29_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.34

SAT
TT=0.834

CHECKS=112135
NODES=107
SAT
TT=0.858

CHECKS=226572
NODES=271
SAT
TT=1.651

SAT
TT=1.317

SAT
TT=1.318

SAT
TT=1.698

NODES=1967
SAT
TT=4.003

NODES=5604
SAT
TT=4.737

CHECKS=75681
NODES=8022
SAT
TT=7.631

SAT
TT=33.732

CHECKS=19890246
NODES=14334
SAT
TT=30.572

CHECKS=17791424
NODES=12929
SAT
TT=49.825

CHECKS=31955219
NODES=21658
SAT
TT=4.832

SAT
TT=2.226

SAT
TT=1.074

SAT
TT=14.577

CHECKS=8657962
NODES=6271
SAT
TT=14.628

CHECKS=8657962
NODES=6271
SAT
TT=4.811

SAT
TT=4.721

SAT
TT=7.36

SAT
TT=1.114

SAT
TT=0.34

CHECKS=9316810
NODES=2385
SAT
TT=0.339

CHECKS=9316810
NODES=2385
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-31_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.478

SAT
TT=1.929

CHECKS=6358664
NODES=6414
SAT
TT=1.934

CHECKS=5580524
NODES=5792
SAT
TT=2.095

SAT
TT=0.578

SAT
TT=0.592

SAT
TT=5.238

NODES=7827
SAT
TT=4.863

NODES=7351
SAT
TT=3.89

CHECKS=72927
NODES=6323
SAT
TT=0.704

SAT
TT=33.976

CHECKS=20987507
NODES=14631
SAT
TT=34.733

CHECKS=21090609
NODES=14759
SAT
TT=2.738

CHECKS=1978317
NODES=1214
SAT
TT=4.915

SAT
TT=7.144

SAT
TT=2.352

SAT
TT=23.549

CHECKS=15075392
NODES=9926
SAT
TT=23.593

CHECKS=15075392
NODES=9926
SAT
TT=7.074

SAT
TT=7.432

SAT
TT=30.587

SAT
TT=2.412

SAT
TT=0.478

CHECKS=15265500
NODES=3855
SAT
TT=0.515

CHECKS=15265500
NODES=3855
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-33_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.099

SAT
TT=0.939

CHECKS=469541
NODES=518
SAT
TT=1.047

CHECKS=892847
NODES=1048
SAT
TT=0.875

SAT
TT=1.106

SAT
TT=1.151

SAT
TT=0.627

NODES=150
SAT
TT=3.217

NODES=4589
SAT
TT=4.225

CHECKS=75455
NODES=7228
SAT
TT=4.76

SAT
TT=17.019

CHECKS=9154875
NODES=7178
SAT
TT=16.655

CHECKS=9611396
NODES=7501
SAT
TT=50.155

CHECKS=31000053
NODES=23916
SAT
TT=2.861

SAT
TT=2.939

SAT
TT=0.099

SAT
TT=1.47

CHECKS=776535
NODES=643
SAT
TT=1.365

CHECKS=776535
NODES=643
SAT
TT=3.4

SAT
TT=3.546

SAT
TT=49.619

SAT
TT=0.749

SAT
TT=0.151

CHECKS=3076190
NODES=939
SAT
TT=0.147

CHECKS=3076190
NODES=939
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-35_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.156

SAT
TT=1.083

CHECKS=1264217
NODES=1327
SAT
TT=1.286

CHECKS=2258259
NODES=2475
SAT
TT=0.583

SAT
TT=0.5

SAT
TT=0.501

SAT
TT=0.992

NODES=675
SAT
TT=1.746

NODES=1937
SAT
TT=1.379

CHECKS=75500
NODES=1380
SAT
TT=3.736

SAT
TT=11.083

CHECKS=6648262
NODES=4719
SAT
TT=11.833

CHECKS=6625405
NODES=4861
SAT
TT=8.567

CHECKS=5608398
NODES=3640
SAT
TT=9.139

SAT
TT=9.201

SAT
TT=0.288

SAT
TT=5.147

CHECKS=3321090
NODES=2590
SAT
TT=5.563

CHECKS=3321090
NODES=2590
SAT
TT=3.134

SAT
TT=3.408

SAT
TT=35.07

SAT
TT=1.378

SAT
TT=0.156

CHECKS=3312560
NODES=1081
SAT
TT=0.158

CHECKS=3312560
NODES=1081
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-37_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.094

SAT
TT=0.847

CHECKS=71848
NODES=70
SAT
TT=0.885

CHECKS=142499
NODES=169
SAT
TT=0.388

SAT
TT=0.57

SAT
TT=0.565

SAT
TT=0.682

NODES=180
SAT
TT=0.666

NODES=170
SAT
TT=0.676

CHECKS=74016
NODES=172
SAT
TT=1.169

SAT
TT=8.881

CHECKS=5059041
NODES=3440
SAT
TT=14.844

CHECKS=8832483
NODES=6050
SAT
TT=5.663

CHECKS=3855082
NODES=2133
SAT
TT=2.24

SAT
TT=2.126

SAT
TT=0.228

SAT
TT=1.419

CHECKS=895113
NODES=546
SAT
TT=1.4

CHECKS=895113
NODES=546
SAT
TT=2.348

SAT
TT=2.43

SAT
TT=8.92

SAT
TT=0.205

SAT
TT=0.094

CHECKS=1607390
NODES=379
SAT
TT=0.093

CHECKS=1607390
NODES=379
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-39_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.219

SAT
TT=0.939

CHECKS=493776
NODES=575
SAT
TT=0.885

CHECKS=271662
NODES=353
SAT
TT=0.787

SAT
TT=1.293

SAT
TT=1.228

SAT
TT=1.315

NODES=1290
SAT
TT=3.218

NODES=4689
SAT
TT=2.913

CHECKS=72379
NODES=4196
SAT
TT=2.562

SAT
TT=17.304

CHECKS=9647520
NODES=7812
SAT
TT=13.223

CHECKS=7864688
NODES=6312
SAT
TT=6.528

CHECKS=4268016
NODES=3044
SAT
TT=2.283

SAT
TT=3.676

SAT
TT=1.524

SAT
TT=9.098

CHECKS=5277030
NODES=3949
SAT
TT=8.559

CHECKS=5277030
NODES=3949
SAT
TT=5.082

SAT
TT=5.049

SAT
TT=12.57

SAT
TT=0.226

SAT
TT=0.219

CHECKS=5349580
NODES=1475
SAT
TT=0.218

CHECKS=5349580
NODES=1475
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-41_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.558

SAT
TT=2.053

CHECKS=6855917
NODES=7484
SAT
TT=1.674

CHECKS=4300902
NODES=4889
SAT
TT=2.718

SAT
TT=1.673

SAT
TT=1.675

SAT
TT=3.122

NODES=4929
SAT
TT=6.016

NODES=9647
SAT
TT=5.015

CHECKS=75797
NODES=8481
SAT
TT=2.377

SAT
TT=39.673

CHECKS=24519788
NODES=19025
SAT
TT=34.997

CHECKS=20517486
NODES=16401
SAT
TT=18.004

CHECKS=12693343
NODES=8563
SAT
TT=3.644

SAT
TT=23.541

SAT
TT=1.101

SAT
TT=25.815

CHECKS=16000225
NODES=12880
SAT
TT=24.442

CHECKS=16000225
NODES=12880
SAT
TT=2.692

SAT
TT=2.853

SAT
TT=7.14

SAT
TT=1.292

SAT
TT=0.558

CHECKS=16024600
NODES=5278
SAT
TT=0.553

CHECKS=16024600
NODES=5278
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-43_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.12

SAT
TT=1.058

CHECKS=1004291
NODES=1144
SAT
TT=0.955

CHECKS=715941
NODES=849
SAT
TT=0.906

SAT
TT=1.482

SAT
TT=1.41

SAT
TT=3.088

NODES=4502
SAT
TT=2.567

NODES=3339
SAT
TT=3.69

CHECKS=74680
NODES=6007
SAT
TT=7.211

SAT
TT=9.217

CHECKS=4992405
NODES=3863
SAT
TT=6.556

CHECKS=3558679
NODES=2713
SAT
TT=22.471

CHECKS=14756786
NODES=9685
SAT
TT=2.138

SAT
TT=5.338

SAT
TT=0.21

SAT
TT=2.698

CHECKS=1565067
NODES=1085
SAT
TT=2.719

CHECKS=1565067
NODES=1085
SAT
TT=6.782

SAT
TT=7.067

SAT
TT=32.955

SAT
TT=0.559

SAT
TT=0.12

CHECKS=2240630
NODES=616
SAT
TT=0.119

CHECKS=2240630
NODES=616
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-45_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.167

SAT
TT=1.035

CHECKS=639653
NODES=699
SAT
TT=0.806

CHECKS=50956
NODES=78
SAT
TT=0.374

SAT
TT=1.57

SAT
TT=1.598

SAT
TT=0.579

NODES=74
SAT
TT=1.974

NODES=2134
SAT
TT=2.917

CHECKS=75643
NODES=4215
SAT
TT=1.667

SAT
TT=9.502

CHECKS=5262920
NODES=3831
SAT
TT=11.966

CHECKS=6985705
NODES=5140
SAT
TT=2.468

CHECKS=1572628
NODES=1004
SAT
TT=2.468

SAT
TT=2.514

SAT
TT=0.942

SAT
TT=5.922

CHECKS=3732745
NODES=2488
SAT
TT=6.362

CHECKS=3732745
NODES=2488
SAT
TT=3.1

SAT
TT=3.287

SAT
TT=11.676

SAT
TT=1.067

SAT
TT=0.167

CHECKS=3849680
NODES=986
SAT
TT=0.156

CHECKS=3849680
NODES=986
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-47_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.074

SAT
TT=4.023

CHECKS=18959307
NODES=21314
SAT
TT=4.867

CHECKS=22996408
NODES=25783
SAT
TT=2.574

SAT
TT=3.029

SAT
TT=3.064

SAT
TT=1.473

NODES=1442
SAT
TT=2.949

NODES=4390
SAT
TT=8.819

CHECKS=74456
NODES=16074
SAT
TT=40.513

SAT
TT=16.155

CHECKS=9133400
NODES=7138
SAT
TT=34.425

CHECKS=19617427
NODES=15524
SAT
TT=8.377

CHECKS=5291080
NODES=4062
SAT
TT=22.3

SAT
TT=3.365

SAT
TT=0.089

SAT
TT=1.711

CHECKS=979706
NODES=836
SAT
TT=1.701

CHECKS=979706
NODES=836
SAT
TT=10.599

SAT
TT=10.427

SAT
TT=15.65

SAT
TT=1.186

SAT
TT=0.074

CHECKS=778679
NODES=241
SAT
TT=0.074

CHECKS=778679
NODES=241
random/rand-2-30-15-fcd/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-fcd-49_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.145

SAT
TT=1.678

CHECKS=4441565
NODES=4865
SAT
TT=0.884

CHECKS=288271
NODES=400
SAT
TT=0.453

SAT
TT=0.642

SAT
TT=0.618

SAT
TT=1.538

NODES=1700
SAT
TT=1.931

NODES=2436
SAT
TT=3.668

CHECKS=73351
NODES=5585
SAT
TT=15.166

SAT
TT=10.997

CHECKS=6299400
NODES=4651
SAT
TT=15.483

CHECKS=8939462
NODES=6443
SAT
TT=6.48

CHECKS=4454551
NODES=2856
SAT
TT=2.694

SAT
TT=1.794

SAT
TT=1.036

SAT
TT=4.965

CHECKS=2926882
NODES=2172
SAT
TT=4.927

CHECKS=2926882
NODES=2172
SAT
TT=7.998

SAT
TT=7.647

SAT
TT=13.42

SAT
TT=1.643

SAT
TT=0.145

CHECKS=3273850
NODES=915
SAT
TT=0.143

CHECKS=3273850
NODES=915
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-11_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.759

UNSAT
TT=3.534

CHECKS=16258870
NODES=16629
UNSAT
TT=3.439

CHECKS=15536082
NODES=15809
UNSAT
TT=4.847

UNSAT
TT=2.42

UNSAT
TT=2.316

UNSAT
TT=17.279

NODES=28867
UNSAT
TT=6.213

NODES=9425
UNSAT
TT=7.344

CHECKS=75790
NODES=10704
UNSAT
TT=25.335

UNSAT
TT=49.733

CHECKS=29843897
NODES=21529
UNSAT
TT=47.533

CHECKS=26411088
NODES=19545
UNSAT
TT=165.625

CHECKS=102836791
NODES=70733
UNSAT
TT=24.143

UNSAT
TT=23.87

UNSAT
TT=2.926

UNSAT
TT=39.876

CHECKS=22916740
NODES=17155
UNSAT
TT=37.542

CHECKS=22916740
NODES=17155
UNSAT
TT=40.575

UNSAT
TT=39.304

UNSAT
TT=21.47

UNSAT
TT=3.715

UNSAT
TT=0.759

CHECKS=22317100
NODES=6385
UNSAT
TT=0.698

CHECKS=22317100
NODES=6385
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-13_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.329

UNSAT
TT=1.587

CHECKS=3480076
NODES=3537
UNSAT
TT=1.451

CHECKS=3406934
NODES=3519
UNSAT
TT=0.726

UNSAT
TT=1.832

UNSAT
TT=1.831

UNSAT
TT=3.832

NODES=5155
UNSAT
TT=2.183

NODES=2460
UNSAT
TT=1.838

CHECKS=68160
NODES=2441
UNSAT
TT=4.098

UNSAT
TT=13.25

CHECKS=8373775
NODES=5665
UNSAT
TT=12.269

CHECKS=8319493
NODES=5640
UNSAT
TT=32.22

CHECKS=23839402
NODES=14612
UNSAT
TT=3.965

UNSAT
TT=3.897

UNSAT
TT=0.77

UNSAT
TT=10.516

CHECKS=7552988
NODES=4521
UNSAT
TT=11.062

CHECKS=7552988
NODES=4521
UNSAT
TT=6.276

UNSAT
TT=6.526

UNSAT
TT=10.78

UNSAT
TT=1.225

UNSAT
TT=0.329

CHECKS=9291930
NODES=2032
UNSAT
TT=0.325

CHECKS=9291930
NODES=2032
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-15_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.774

UNSAT
TT=2.754

CHECKS=9728920
NODES=10336
UNSAT
TT=3.149

CHECKS=13003965
NODES=14001
UNSAT
TT=7.946

UNSAT
TT=2.241

UNSAT
TT=2.29

UNSAT
TT=12.426

NODES=18611
UNSAT
TT=4.112

NODES=6585
UNSAT
TT=3.98

CHECKS=73607
NODES=6643
UNSAT
TT=13.516

UNSAT
TT=34.283

CHECKS=21223350
NODES=15526
UNSAT
TT=26.465

CHECKS=16602311
NODES=12069
UNSAT
TT=143.164

CHECKS=89821435
NODES=66256
UNSAT
TT=7.541

UNSAT
TT=12.849

UNSAT
TT=2.04

UNSAT
TT=40.819

CHECKS=25637495
NODES=18689
UNSAT
TT=40.83

CHECKS=25637495
NODES=18689
UNSAT
TT=22.169

UNSAT
TT=24.511

UNSAT
TT=20.167

UNSAT
TT=2.563

UNSAT
TT=0.774

CHECKS=22745000
NODES=6382
UNSAT
TT=0.774

CHECKS=22745000
NODES=6382
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-17_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.147

SAT
TT=0.847

CHECKS=40841
NODES=30
SAT
TT=0.83

CHECKS=6830
NODES=30
SAT
TT=0.886

SAT
TT=1.4

SAT
TT=1.511

SAT
TT=0.587

NODES=36
SAT
TT=2.145

NODES=2679
SAT
TT=1.908

CHECKS=74171
NODES=2351
SAT
TT=0.835

SAT
TT=16.617

CHECKS=10553181
NODES=7443
SAT
TT=13.918

CHECKS=8824497
NODES=6265
SAT
TT=8.87

CHECKS=6035475
NODES=3656
SAT
TT=2.619

SAT
TT=2.285

SAT
TT=0.725

SAT
TT=5.921

CHECKS=3730967
NODES=2185
SAT
TT=5.297

CHECKS=3730967
NODES=2185
SAT
TT=3.418

SAT
TT=3.466

SAT
TT=5.51

SAT
TT=0.525

SAT
TT=0.147

CHECKS=3604930
NODES=850
SAT
TT=0.144

CHECKS=3604930
NODES=850
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-19_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.553

UNSAT
TT=3.224

CHECKS=13141010
NODES=13147
UNSAT
TT=3.188

CHECKS=12993716
NODES=12862
UNSAT
TT=2.888

UNSAT
TT=2.178

UNSAT
TT=2.095

UNSAT
TT=9.302

NODES=15110
UNSAT
TT=5.234

NODES=8339
UNSAT
TT=5.483

CHECKS=74109
NODES=9421
UNSAT
TT=16.972

UNSAT
TT=33.729

CHECKS=21064362
NODES=15411
UNSAT
TT=31.186

CHECKS=17941774
NODES=13096
UNSAT
TT=154.349

CHECKS=94265209
NODES=66849
UNSAT
TT=16.573

UNSAT
TT=21.012

UNSAT
TT=2.449

UNSAT
TT=25.365

CHECKS=16525500
NODES=12063
UNSAT
TT=25.75

CHECKS=16525500
NODES=12063
UNSAT
TT=32.651

UNSAT
TT=30.915

UNSAT
TT=26.379

UNSAT
TT=3.017

UNSAT
TT=0.553

CHECKS=17082100
NODES=4721
UNSAT
TT=0.584

CHECKS=17082100
NODES=4721
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-1_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.138

SAT
TT=2.811

CHECKS=10465335
NODES=10150
SAT
TT=1.52

CHECKS=2531551
NODES=2586
SAT
TT=0.138

SAT
TT=1.966

SAT
TT=2.019

SAT
TT=1.778

NODES=1811
SAT
TT=1.757

NODES=1723
SAT
TT=1.552

CHECKS=73004
NODES=1748
SAT
TT=6.209

SAT
TT=12.959

CHECKS=7105473
NODES=5289
SAT
TT=6.712

CHECKS=3599070
NODES=2744
SAT
TT=0.884

CHECKS=573510
NODES=347
SAT
TT=7.649

SAT
TT=6.324

SAT
TT=0.308

SAT
TT=8.41

CHECKS=5246466
NODES=3398
SAT
TT=8.753

CHECKS=5246466
NODES=3398
SAT
TT=2.005

SAT
TT=2.179

SAT
TT=7.98

SAT
TT=1.06

SAT
TT=0.24

CHECKS=6129640
NODES=1532
SAT
TT=0.236

CHECKS=6129640
NODES=1532
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-21_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.258

SAT
TT=2.874

CHECKS=11171868
NODES=11955
SAT
TT=2.804

CHECKS=9918371
NODES=10556
SAT
TT=1.849

SAT
TT=1.354

SAT
TT=1.356

SAT
TT=8.142

NODES=12803
SAT
TT=2.801

NODES=3913
SAT
TT=2.356

CHECKS=71792
NODES=3470
SAT
TT=0.363

SAT
TT=27.496

CHECKS=16710972
NODES=12367
SAT
TT=15.724

CHECKS=9343913
NODES=6970
SAT
TT=13.815

CHECKS=9469052
NODES=6544
SAT
TT=5.025

SAT
TT=3.183

SAT
TT=1.687

SAT
TT=9.417

CHECKS=6350453
NODES=4530
SAT
TT=9.981

CHECKS=6350453
NODES=4530
SAT
TT=6.052

SAT
TT=5.946

SAT
TT=8.27

SAT
TT=1.119

SAT
TT=0.258

CHECKS=6734850
NODES=1847
SAT
TT=0.238

CHECKS=6734850
NODES=1847
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-23_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.601

SAT
TT=2.284

CHECKS=7865426
NODES=8739
SAT
TT=1.52

CHECKS=3510381
NODES=3936
SAT
TT=2.846

SAT
TT=2.66

SAT
TT=2.552

SAT
TT=1.7

NODES=2038
SAT
TT=3.247

NODES=5055
SAT
TT=4.025

CHECKS=71836
NODES=7007
SAT
TT=9.589

SAT
TT=33.55

CHECKS=21850820
NODES=16847
SAT
TT=29.855

CHECKS=18071260
NODES=13974
SAT
TT=126.462

CHECKS=85090582
NODES=64139
SAT
TT=3.573

SAT
TT=3.226

SAT
TT=1.481

SAT
TT=25.591

CHECKS=17100936
NODES=12967
SAT
TT=27.504

CHECKS=17100936
NODES=12967
SAT
TT=38.092

SAT
TT=37.972

SAT
TT=31.14

SAT
TT=2.025

SAT
TT=0.601

CHECKS=18300900
NODES=5239
SAT
TT=0.628

CHECKS=18300900
NODES=5239
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-25_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.227

SAT
TT=3.53

CHECKS=15506812
NODES=15902
SAT
TT=3.338

CHECKS=14924311
NODES=15285
SAT
TT=0.227

SAT
TT=1.555

SAT
TT=1.645

SAT
TT=13.935

NODES=24011
SAT
TT=5.035

NODES=7984
SAT
TT=5.616

CHECKS=71848
NODES=9157
SAT
TT=8.863

SAT
TT=37.902

CHECKS=23943475
NODES=17515
SAT
TT=33.988

CHECKS=22446039
NODES=16293
SAT
TT=5.943

CHECKS=3967591
NODES=2741
SAT
TT=2.76

SAT
TT=4.307

SAT
TT=2.227

SAT
TT=10.212

CHECKS=6263334
NODES=4400
SAT
TT=9.523

CHECKS=6263334
NODES=4400
SAT
TT=41.656

SAT
TT=39.824

SAT
TT=18.23

SAT
TT=2.881

SAT
TT=0.261

CHECKS=6635540
NODES=1679
SAT
TT=0.256

CHECKS=6635540
NODES=1679
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-27_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.384

UNSAT
TT=2.367

CHECKS=7949885
NODES=7793
UNSAT
TT=2.235

CHECKS=7853456
NODES=7842
UNSAT
TT=1.205

UNSAT
TT=1.969

UNSAT
TT=1.867

UNSAT
TT=5.661

NODES=8856
UNSAT
TT=4.073

NODES=5387
UNSAT
TT=4.289

CHECKS=71514
NODES=5771
UNSAT
TT=7.354

UNSAT
TT=22.887

CHECKS=15183999
NODES=10246
UNSAT
TT=22.475

CHECKS=14184758
NODES=9390
UNSAT
TT=73.415

CHECKS=49656080
NODES=31473
UNSAT
TT=8.319

UNSAT
TT=10.137

UNSAT
TT=1.398

UNSAT
TT=15.797

CHECKS=11091239
NODES=7029
UNSAT
TT=15.365

CHECKS=11091239
NODES=7029
UNSAT
TT=14.932

UNSAT
TT=15.114

UNSAT
TT=23.389

UNSAT
TT=2.204

UNSAT
TT=0.384

CHECKS=11157200
NODES=2706
UNSAT
TT=0.391

CHECKS=11157200
NODES=2706
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-29_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.81

UNSAT
TT=3.008

CHECKS=13228831
NODES=13785
UNSAT
TT=3.301

CHECKS=13663201
NODES=13999
UNSAT
TT=2.256

UNSAT
TT=2.436

UNSAT
TT=2.417

UNSAT
TT=12.055

NODES=18799
UNSAT
TT=5.006

NODES=7671
UNSAT
TT=5.283

CHECKS=75906
NODES=8359
UNSAT
TT=23.94

UNSAT
TT=33.555

CHECKS=19075279
NODES=13891
UNSAT
TT=34.805

CHECKS=20667405
NODES=14882
UNSAT
TT=165.614

CHECKS=101491435
NODES=70615
UNSAT
TT=11.294

UNSAT
TT=14.91

UNSAT
TT=2.114

UNSAT
TT=40.072

CHECKS=23774878
NODES=17349
UNSAT
TT=37.82

CHECKS=23774878
NODES=17349
UNSAT
TT=27.449

UNSAT
TT=25.308

UNSAT
TT=42.84

UNSAT
TT=2.727

UNSAT
TT=0.81

CHECKS=23467700
NODES=6542
UNSAT
TT=0.802

CHECKS=23467700
NODES=6542
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-31_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.696

UNSAT
TT=3.309

CHECKS=14364986
NODES=14210
UNSAT
TT=3.204

CHECKS=13191923
NODES=13191
UNSAT
TT=2.72

UNSAT
TT=2.411

UNSAT
TT=2.42

UNSAT
TT=10.813

NODES=18094
UNSAT
TT=5.129

NODES=8229
UNSAT
TT=5.083

CHECKS=72582
NODES=8256
UNSAT
TT=16.045

UNSAT
TT=39.834

CHECKS=26381723
NODES=18108
UNSAT
TT=42.748

CHECKS=26517711
NODES=18110
UNSAT
TT=159.246

CHECKS=104934568
NODES=69767
UNSAT
TT=13.647

UNSAT
TT=29.179

UNSAT
TT=2.368

UNSAT
TT=30.248

CHECKS=20232038
NODES=13297
UNSAT
TT=30.915

CHECKS=20232038
NODES=13297
UNSAT
TT=55.874

UNSAT
TT=62.521

UNSAT
TT=27.553

UNSAT
TT=3.503

UNSAT
TT=0.696

CHECKS=21309700
NODES=5193
UNSAT
TT=0.696

CHECKS=21309700
NODES=5193
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-33_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=1.753

UNSAT
TT=6.245

CHECKS=29681778
NODES=32086
UNSAT
TT=5.74

CHECKS=29985566
NODES=32206
UNSAT
TT=10.253

UNSAT
TT=3.034

UNSAT
TT=2.995

UNSAT
TT=25.413

NODES=41021
UNSAT
TT=11.007

NODES=19472
UNSAT
TT=12.132

CHECKS=76293
NODES=22204
UNSAT
TT=80.13

UNSAT
TT=76.271

CHECKS=44187747
NODES=34221
UNSAT
TT=63.825

CHECKS=38242003
NODES=29675
UNSAT
TT=263.749

CHECKS=162135746
NODES=122990
UNSAT
TT=55.177

UNSAT
TT=112.157

UNSAT
TT=4.489

UNSAT
TT=98.234

CHECKS=60212837
NODES=45254
UNSAT
TT=102.292

CHECKS=60212837
NODES=45254
UNSAT
TT=479.48

UNSAT
TT=406.321

UNSAT
TT=110.644

UNSAT
TT=6.231

UNSAT
TT=1.753

CHECKS=57260500
NODES=16553
UNSAT
TT=1.855

CHECKS=57260500
NODES=16553
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-35_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.531

UNSAT
TT=3.315

CHECKS=14377123
NODES=15101
UNSAT
TT=3.173

CHECKS=11819072
NODES=12690
UNSAT
TT=1.864

UNSAT
TT=2.237

UNSAT
TT=2.384

UNSAT
TT=11.247

NODES=17635
UNSAT
TT=5.522

NODES=8823
UNSAT
TT=4.332

CHECKS=75586
NODES=6904
UNSAT
TT=14.954

UNSAT
TT=27.32

CHECKS=17373166
NODES=13055
UNSAT
TT=29.469

CHECKS=18335833
NODES=13580
UNSAT
TT=155.504

CHECKS=103306822
NODES=73100
UNSAT
TT=11.577

UNSAT
TT=12.347

UNSAT
TT=1.934

UNSAT
TT=25.659

CHECKS=15498160
NODES=11503
UNSAT
TT=25.765

CHECKS=15498160
NODES=11503
UNSAT
TT=19.894

UNSAT
TT=20.175

UNSAT
TT=27.06

UNSAT
TT=3.27

UNSAT
TT=0.531

CHECKS=14997400
NODES=4627
UNSAT
TT=0.521

CHECKS=14997400
NODES=4627
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-37_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.146

SAT
TT=1.054

CHECKS=537886
NODES=518
SAT
TT=1.106

CHECKS=1087037
NODES=1132
SAT
TT=0.829

SAT
TT=0.385

SAT
TT=0.403

SAT
TT=1.659

NODES=1535
SAT
TT=1.012

NODES=651
SAT
TT=1.358

CHECKS=77085
NODES=1232
SAT
TT=0.152

SAT
TT=12.332

CHECKS=7239841
NODES=4423
SAT
TT=12.811

CHECKS=7327654
NODES=4529
SAT
TT=0.67

CHECKS=444429
NODES=244
SAT
TT=2.705

SAT
TT=2.3

SAT
TT=0.178

SAT
TT=5.78

CHECKS=3618654
NODES=2044
SAT
TT=5.717

CHECKS=3618654
NODES=2044
SAT
TT=2.53

SAT
TT=2.729

SAT
TT=5.68

SAT
TT=0.441

SAT
TT=0.146

CHECKS=3778420
NODES=925
SAT
TT=0.156

CHECKS=3778420
NODES=925
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-39_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.179

SAT
TT=1.033

CHECKS=942633
NODES=1050
SAT
TT=0.976

CHECKS=465788
NODES=543
SAT
TT=0.279

SAT
TT=1.213

SAT
TT=1.284

SAT
TT=0.781

NODES=358
SAT
TT=2.571

NODES=3341
SAT
TT=1.703

CHECKS=72168
NODES=1961
SAT
TT=1.13

SAT
TT=7.668

CHECKS=4451565
NODES=3520
SAT
TT=11.289

CHECKS=6053743
NODES=4861
SAT
TT=10.453

CHECKS=7002328
NODES=4957
SAT
TT=7.722

SAT
TT=5.313

SAT
TT=0.53

SAT
TT=7.155

CHECKS=4365638
NODES=3401
SAT
TT=7.533

CHECKS=4365638
NODES=3401
SAT
TT=8.623

SAT
TT=8.538

SAT
TT=17.12

SAT
TT=0.464

SAT
TT=0.179

CHECKS=4269700
NODES=1259
SAT
TT=0.189

CHECKS=4269700
NODES=1259
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-3_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.593

UNSAT
TT=2.184

CHECKS=8159027
NODES=7856
UNSAT
TT=2.27

CHECKS=8948501
NODES=8464
UNSAT
TT=1.445

UNSAT
TT=2.03

UNSAT
TT=1.956

UNSAT
TT=8.033

NODES=12938
UNSAT
TT=3.236

NODES=4415
UNSAT
TT=3.281

CHECKS=73298
NODES=4737
UNSAT
TT=8.971

UNSAT
TT=26.077

CHECKS=16827139
NODES=11115
UNSAT
TT=25.113

CHECKS=15050780
NODES=10254
UNSAT
TT=75.704

CHECKS=50058856
NODES=31116
UNSAT
TT=6.075

UNSAT
TT=7.573

UNSAT
TT=1.422

UNSAT
TT=28.723

CHECKS=17893102
NODES=10890
UNSAT
TT=28.86

CHECKS=17893102
NODES=10890
UNSAT
TT=13.976

UNSAT
TT=13.935

UNSAT
TT=18.758

UNSAT
TT=2.066

UNSAT
TT=0.593

CHECKS=17375500
NODES=3873
UNSAT
TT=0.578

CHECKS=17375500
NODES=3873
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-41_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.159

SAT
TT=1.619

CHECKS=3316416
NODES=3839
SAT
TT=1.669

CHECKS=4498336
NODES=5037
SAT
TT=0.922

SAT
TT=1.842

SAT
TT=1.779

SAT
TT=3.461

NODES=5338
SAT
TT=4.128

NODES=6447
SAT
TT=1.6

CHECKS=73798
NODES=1832
SAT
TT=27.167

SAT
TT=16.221

CHECKS=9668351
NODES=7552
SAT
TT=13.96

CHECKS=8230510
NODES=6512
SAT
TT=9.697

CHECKS=6566420
NODES=4367
SAT
TT=3.921

SAT
TT=7.881

SAT
TT=0.159

SAT
TT=7.94

CHECKS=4797790
NODES=4017
SAT
TT=7.579

CHECKS=4797790
NODES=4017
SAT
TT=6.611

SAT
TT=6.708

SAT
TT=29.16

SAT
TT=0.528

SAT
TT=0.225

CHECKS=5613970
NODES=1828
SAT
TT=0.227

CHECKS=5613970
NODES=1828
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-43_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.172

SAT
TT=1.531

CHECKS=2892489
NODES=3140
SAT
TT=1.332

CHECKS=2194296
NODES=2424
SAT
TT=0.371

SAT
TT=0.817

SAT
TT=0.853

SAT
TT=5.949

NODES=9268
SAT
TT=4.256

NODES=6426
SAT
TT=1.222

CHECKS=73383
NODES=1170
SAT
TT=3.298

SAT
TT=15.271

CHECKS=9001641
NODES=6608
SAT
TT=20.422

CHECKS=11919935
NODES=8824
SAT
TT=19.876

CHECKS=13083743
NODES=8929
SAT
TT=2.684

SAT
TT=5.831

SAT
TT=0.225

SAT
TT=5.682

CHECKS=3318644
NODES=2292
SAT
TT=5.614

CHECKS=3318644
NODES=2292
SAT
TT=15.56

SAT
TT=16.494

SAT
TT=56.17

SAT
TT=2.777

SAT
TT=0.172

CHECKS=3835540
NODES=1126
SAT
TT=0.169

CHECKS=3835540
NODES=1126
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-45_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.134

SAT
TT=0.962

CHECKS=525364
NODES=519
SAT
TT=1.783

CHECKS=4659959
NODES=4669
SAT
TT=0.134

SAT
TT=0.304

SAT
TT=0.284

SAT
TT=1.109

NODES=885
SAT
TT=2.348

NODES=2799
SAT
TT=2.401

CHECKS=74872
NODES=3319
SAT
TT=1.839

SAT
TT=9.765

CHECKS=5277735
NODES=3991
SAT
TT=13.015

CHECKS=7056134
NODES=5291
SAT
TT=4.591

CHECKS=2949669
NODES=1859
SAT
TT=2.38

SAT
TT=2.048

SAT
TT=0.328

SAT
TT=6.326

CHECKS=3748300
NODES=2415
SAT
TT=5.95

CHECKS=3748300
NODES=2415
SAT
TT=2.555

SAT
TT=2.342

SAT
TT=5.64

SAT
TT=0.739

SAT
TT=0.183

CHECKS=4312020
NODES=1117
SAT
TT=0.182

CHECKS=4312020
NODES=1117
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-47_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.56

SAT
TT=1.399

CHECKS=2545447
NODES=3091
SAT
TT=1.001

CHECKS=808247
NODES=978
SAT
TT=2.494

SAT
TT=1.399

SAT
TT=1.437

SAT
TT=4.692

NODES=6932
SAT
TT=12.885

NODES=21992
SAT
TT=13.161

CHECKS=75921
NODES=25598
SAT
TT=68.799

SAT
TT=34.212

CHECKS=19381661
NODES=15480
SAT
TT=32.393

CHECKS=18552091
NODES=15024
SAT
TT=85.906

CHECKS=56361321
NODES=44193
SAT
TT=36.421

SAT
TT=57.267

SAT
TT=3.453

SAT
TT=25.477

CHECKS=14874461
NODES=11957
SAT
TT=25.42

CHECKS=14874461
NODES=11957
SAT
TT=233.684

SAT
TT=282.395

SAT
TT=64.452

SAT
TT=2.152

SAT
TT=0.56

CHECKS=15448200
NODES=4544
SAT
TT=0.547

CHECKS=15448200
NODES=4544
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-49_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.782

UNSAT
TT=3.169

CHECKS=12364826
NODES=13588
UNSAT
TT=2.988

CHECKS=12340121
NODES=13680
UNSAT
TT=3.221

UNSAT
TT=2.377

UNSAT
TT=2.445

UNSAT
TT=11.433

NODES=19783
UNSAT
TT=6.337

NODES=10425
UNSAT
TT=6.128

CHECKS=74595
NODES=10109
UNSAT
TT=37.719

UNSAT
TT=34.146

CHECKS=22022611
NODES=16856
UNSAT
TT=39.779

CHECKS=25403189
NODES=19143
UNSAT
TT=156.592

CHECKS=98842321
NODES=70049
UNSAT
TT=13.299

UNSAT
TT=20.686

UNSAT
TT=2.528

UNSAT
TT=41.965

CHECKS=25734743
NODES=18186
UNSAT
TT=39.625

CHECKS=25734743
NODES=18186
UNSAT
TT=39.505

UNSAT
TT=40.194

UNSAT
TT=36.896

UNSAT
TT=3.287

UNSAT
TT=0.782

CHECKS=25032000
NODES=6803
UNSAT
TT=0.824

CHECKS=25032000
NODES=6803
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-6_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=0.374

UNSAT
TT=2.29

CHECKS=8473202
NODES=8066
UNSAT
TT=1.977

CHECKS=6944704
NODES=6742
UNSAT
TT=1.882

UNSAT
TT=1.926

UNSAT
TT=1.944

UNSAT
TT=7.445

NODES=12067
UNSAT
TT=3.269

NODES=4671
UNSAT
TT=3.307

CHECKS=73918
NODES=4672
UNSAT
TT=10.661

UNSAT
TT=20.237

CHECKS=12893614
NODES=8602
UNSAT
TT=24.954

CHECKS=14716061
NODES=9802
UNSAT
TT=76.498

CHECKS=50685076
NODES=31838
UNSAT
TT=5.849

UNSAT
TT=6.286

UNSAT
TT=1.183

UNSAT
TT=16.731

CHECKS=10637402
NODES=6888
UNSAT
TT=16.356

CHECKS=10637402
NODES=6888
UNSAT
TT=10.63

UNSAT
TT=10.828

UNSAT
TT=27.89

UNSAT
TT=1.925

UNSAT
TT=0.374

CHECKS=10859900
NODES=2569
UNSAT
TT=0.348

CHECKS=10859900
NODES=2569
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-7_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.287

SAT
TT=0.936

CHECKS=445864
NODES=522
SAT
TT=1.017

CHECKS=938178
NODES=1114
SAT
TT=3.851

SAT
TT=1.169

SAT
TT=1.248

SAT
TT=8.537

NODES=14344
SAT
TT=3.357

NODES=5200
SAT
TT=5.027

CHECKS=74705
NODES=8490
SAT
TT=10.017

SAT
TT=24.964

CHECKS=14399873
NODES=10872
SAT
TT=22.842

CHECKS=13031493
NODES=9838
SAT
TT=67.165

CHECKS=43855691
NODES=30752
SAT
TT=2.738

SAT
TT=19.542

SAT
TT=3.081

SAT
TT=14.606

CHECKS=8702283
NODES=6506
SAT
TT=14.718

CHECKS=8702283
NODES=6506
SAT
TT=25.357

SAT
TT=26.223

SAT
TT=24.68

SAT
TT=0.379

SAT
TT=0.287

CHECKS=8100750
NODES=2328
SAT
TT=0.302

CHECKS=8100750
NODES=2328
random/rand-2-30-15/
rand-2-30-15-306-230-9_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.362

SAT
TT=3.495

CHECKS=13772609
NODES=14941
SAT
TT=2.669

CHECKS=9843265
NODES=10633
SAT
TT=1.937

SAT
TT=0.551

SAT
TT=0.55

SAT
TT=5.14

NODES=8248
SAT
TT=2.517

NODES=3665
SAT
TT=2.423

CHECKS=74442
NODES=3597
SAT
TT=1.444

SAT
TT=34.058

CHECKS=20098911
NODES=15646
SAT
TT=19.893

CHECKS=11109027
NODES=8932
SAT
TT=71.23

CHECKS=43410012
NODES=32544
SAT
TT=14.597

SAT
TT=15.135

SAT
TT=2.374

SAT
TT=16.578

CHECKS=9328057
NODES=7247
SAT
TT=15.538

CHECKS=9328057
NODES=7247
SAT
TT=8.656

SAT
TT=8.231

SAT
TT=18.38

SAT
TT=0.511

SAT
TT=0.362

CHECKS=9438690
NODES=2792
SAT
TT=0.358

CHECKS=9438690
NODES=2792
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-11_ext.xml
SAT
TT=27.015

SAT
TT=94.297

CHECKS=632576895
NODES=468967
SAT
TT=95.601

CHECKS=595486628
NODES=442486
SAT
TT=229.294

SAT
TT=93.046

SAT
TT=93.644

SAT
TT=356.376

NODES=399936
SAT
TT=630.898

NODES=731588
SAT
TT=582.66

CHECKS=178308
NODES=759561
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=36.374

SAT
TT=1739.27

CHECKS=907812872
NODES=439424
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.58

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=77.419

SAT
TT=27.015

CHECKS=860978000
NODES=165328
SAT
TT=26.65

CHECKS=860978000
NODES=165328
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-13_ext.xml
SAT
TT=14.202

SAT
TT=24.496

CHECKS=148307866
NODES=104766
SAT
TT=21.238

CHECKS=132053360
NODES=93178
SAT
TT=17.821

SAT
TT=23.091

SAT
TT=21.727

SAT
TT=100.951

NODES=103775
SAT
TT=137.96

NODES=150406
SAT
TT=88.695

CHECKS=181902
NODES=116061
SAT
TT=295.536

SAT
TT=1005.36

CHECKS=479970648
NODES=208179
SAT
TT=196.937

CHECKS=94758785
NODES=43629
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=657.812

SAT
TT=355.438

SAT
TT=23.702

SAT
TT=975.627

CHECKS=475546485
NODES=205534
SAT
TT=944.553

CHECKS=475546485
NODES=205534
? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=989.201

SAT
TT=23.686

SAT
TT=14.202

CHECKS=474743000
NODES=80749
SAT
TT=14.167

CHECKS=474743000
NODES=80749
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-15_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.784

SAT
TT=5.869

CHECKS=35061907
NODES=23125
SAT
TT=5.16

CHECKS=26835900
NODES=18560
SAT
TT=31.893

SAT
TT=7.347

SAT
TT=6.934

SAT
TT=46.475

NODES=49389
SAT
TT=60.363

NODES=61731
SAT
TT=69.348

CHECKS=173525
NODES=85254
SAT
TT=16.488

SAT
TT=48.654

CHECKS=24427842
NODES=11161
SAT
TT=327.545

CHECKS=177446096
NODES=69027
SAT
TT=720.412

CHECKS=413310865
NODES=164307
SAT
TT=36.582

SAT
TT=240.26

SAT
TT=1.309

SAT
TT=30.052

CHECKS=15479465
NODES=6895
SAT
TT=31.133

CHECKS=15479465
NODES=6895
SAT
TT=167.526

SAT
TT=173.9

SAT
TT=56.04

SAT
TT=32.195

SAT
TT=0.784

CHECKS=21750900
NODES=4008
SAT
TT=0.789

CHECKS=21750900
NODES=4008
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-17_ext.xml
SAT
TT=54.076

SAT
TT=201.918

CHECKS=1257764808
NODES=946712
SAT
TT=110.58

CHECKS=674932527
NODES=514357
SAT
TT=105.833

SAT
TT=56.234

SAT
TT=58.951

SAT
TT=896.822

NODES=960526
SAT
TT=596.921

NODES=731173
SAT
TT=383.181

CHECKS=182553
NODES=523952
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=1249.83

CHECKS=639273039
NODES=310067
SAT
TT=1077.22

CHECKS=634878398
NODES=299468
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=74.249

SAT
TT=128.949

SAT
TT=217.431

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=63.811

SAT
TT=54.076

CHECKS=1900790000
NODES=361813
SAT
TT=57.218

CHECKS=1900790000
NODES=361813
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-19_ext.xml
SAT
TT=2.178

SAT
TT=2.178

CHECKS=7056188
NODES=5287
SAT
TT=21.875

CHECKS=131514524
NODES=95762
SAT
TT=92.348

SAT
TT=49.357

SAT
TT=49.43

SAT
TT=7.926

NODES=7729
SAT
TT=87.772

NODES=98963
SAT
TT=192.966

CHECKS=176138
NODES=244667
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=1703.4

CHECKS=895684442
NODES=431970
SAT
TT=215.433

CHECKS=112101828
NODES=52960
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=81.538

SAT
TT=803.683

CHECKS=392194544
NODES=190374
SAT
TT=862.692

CHECKS=392194544
NODES=190374
SAT
TT=1748.77

SAT
TT=1743.61

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=147.588

SAT
TT=10.518

CHECKS=361704000
NODES=69367
SAT
TT=11.297

CHECKS=361704000
NODES=69367
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-21_ext.xml
SAT
TT=14.49

SAT
TT=100.628

CHECKS=663544064
NODES=519584
SAT
TT=17.87

CHECKS=113430019
NODES=89261
SAT
TT=812.279

SAT
TT=14.49

SAT
TT=14.525

SAT
TT=958.493

NODES=1108244
SAT
TT=304.161

NODES=380791
SAT
TT=286.887

CHECKS=173817
NODES=404932
SAT
TT=873.626

SAT
TT=13.361

CHECKS=6319346
NODES=3172
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=1398.08

CHECKS=716979709
NODES=367616
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=214.178

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=124.962

SAT
TT=33.752

CHECKS=1146170000
NODES=248856
SAT
TT=33.5

CHECKS=1146170000
NODES=248856
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-23_ext.xml
SAT
TT=2.6

SAT
TT=25.403

CHECKS=164297085
NODES=121499
SAT
TT=69.528

CHECKS=437537601
NODES=318058
SAT
TT=122.248

SAT
TT=23.588

SAT
TT=23.482

SAT
TT=189.303

NODES=203318
SAT
TT=284.308

NODES=305576
SAT
TT=243.527

CHECKS=174408
NODES=298073
SAT
TT=1531.79

SAT
TT=1454.99

CHECKS=701754633
NODES=330394
SAT
TT=1534.58

CHECKS=694248313
NODES=328771
SAT
TT=640.494

CHECKS=324715908
NODES=158860
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=6.838

SAT
TT=291.656

CHECKS=134292168
NODES=65800
SAT
TT=297.697

CHECKS=134292168
NODES=65800
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=1760.86

SAT
TT=95.568

SAT
TT=2.6

CHECKS=79148100
NODES=16401
SAT
TT=2.586

CHECKS=79148100
NODES=16401
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-25_ext.xml
SAT
TT=10.229

SAT
TT=10.229

CHECKS=56099442
NODES=42650
SAT
TT=10.614

CHECKS=65171841
NODES=48978
SAT
TT=116.234

SAT
TT=52.739

SAT
TT=56.157

SAT
TT=70.496

NODES=74384
SAT
TT=35.633

NODES=41956
SAT
TT=41.468

CHECKS=177846
NODES=53855
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=636.362

CHECKS=310160422
NODES=151914
SAT
TT=689.156

CHECKS=306864687
NODES=150298
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=924.713

SAT
TT=722.864

SAT
TT=87.77

SAT
TT=1015.58

CHECKS=493646543
NODES=241084
SAT
TT=1078.03

CHECKS=493646543
NODES=241084
? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.54

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=81.922

SAT
TT=13.237

CHECKS=417602000
NODES=84067
SAT
TT=13.062

CHECKS=417602000
NODES=84067
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-27_ext.xml
SAT
TT=4.37

SAT
TT=20.006

CHECKS=122097872
NODES=87055
SAT
TT=17.276

CHECKS=110535120
NODES=78296
SAT
TT=153.233

SAT
TT=4.595

SAT
TT=4.37

SAT
TT=101.957

NODES=107713
SAT
TT=201.136

NODES=237074
SAT
TT=186.522

CHECKS=180255
NODES=242547
SAT
TT=1130.92

SAT
TT=1054.03

CHECKS=516671374
NODES=251005
SAT
TT=1110.47

CHECKS=530691235
NODES=257664
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=414.52

SAT
TT=72.043

SAT
TT=1410.45

CHECKS=733462980
NODES=355617
SAT
TT=1391.94

CHECKS=733462980
NODES=355617
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=991.733

SAT
TT=84.53

SAT
TT=22.087

CHECKS=756417000
NODES=143029
SAT
TT=21.998

CHECKS=756417000
NODES=143029
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-29_ext.xml
SAT
TT=4.648

SAT
TT=4.648

CHECKS=22837804
NODES=16752
SAT
TT=23.825

CHECKS=146818252
NODES=104867
SAT
TT=134.106

SAT
TT=19.633

SAT
TT=19.525

SAT
TT=319.075

NODES=345860
SAT
TT=123.84

NODES=146427
SAT
TT=177.427

CHECKS=173905
NODES=158251
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=214.611

CHECKS=112379526
NODES=49693
SAT
TT=210.626

CHECKS=113555002
NODES=50461
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=340.067

SAT
TT=422.093

SAT
TT=55.849

SAT
TT=1087.26

CHECKS=524230273
NODES=226084
SAT
TT=1092.55

CHECKS=524230273
NODES=226084
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

SAT
TT=245.61

SAT
TT=87.568

SAT
TT=14.766

CHECKS=498492000
NODES=85800
SAT
TT=14.77

CHECKS=498492000
NODES=85800
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-31_ext.xml
SAT
TT=6.609

SAT
TT=26.81

CHECKS=170595974
NODES=128962
SAT
TT=44.024

CHECKS=272927342
NODES=207071
SAT
TT=12.068

SAT
TT=50.823

SAT
TT=47.29

SAT
TT=168.091

NODES=188096
SAT
TT=40.837

NODES=50245
SAT
TT=89.87

CHECKS=171075
NODES=87460
SAT
TT=45.715

SAT
TT=210.728

CHECKS=113584204
NODES=56579
SAT
TT=214.663

CHECKS=111200538
NODES=55870
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=1349.89

SAT
TT=21.299

SAT
TT=424.152

CHECKS=224851374
NODES=109209
SAT
TT=447.269

CHECKS=224851374
NODES=109209
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=63.32

SAT
TT=6.609

CHECKS=213435000
NODES=41723
SAT
TT=6.215

CHECKS=213435000
NODES=41723
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-33_ext.xml
SAT
TT=32.448

SAT
TT=378.594

CHECKS=2362099420
NODES=1832823
SAT
TT=365.688

CHECKS=2422920425
NODES=1885246
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=34.205

SAT
TT=32.448

SAT
TT=386.11

NODES=442530
SAT
TT=159.147

NODES=201044
SAT
TT=937.265

CHECKS=172465
NODES=1246157
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=1068.45

CHECKS=540632987
NODES=282072
SAT
TT=352.191

CHECKS=172565826
NODES=87182
SAT
TT=1755.12

CHECKS=851958019
NODES=449887
SAT
TT=315.202

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=339.049

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=59.426

SAT
TT=70.357

CHECKS=2253600000
NODES=464246
SAT
TT=70.394

CHECKS=2253600000
NODES=464246
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-35_ext.xml
SAT
TT=54.136

SAT
TT=173.057

CHECKS=1046911372
NODES=823526
SAT
TT=99.705

CHECKS=664135759
NODES=524674
SAT
TT=871.5

SAT
TT=78.687

SAT
TT=80.051

SAT
TT=182.182

NODES=199070
SAT
TT=119.945

NODES=140362
SAT
TT=374.201

CHECKS=178929
NODES=480198
SAT
TT=1258.72

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=92.23

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

SAT
TT=518.634

SAT
TT=84.441

SAT
TT=54.136

CHECKS=1712780000
NODES=370694
SAT
TT=49.781

CHECKS=1712780000
NODES=370694
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-37_ext.xml
SAT
TT=19.31

SAT
TT=54.15

CHECKS=347123494
NODES=270266
SAT
TT=19.31

CHECKS=120915614
NODES=96348
SAT
TT=302.998

SAT
TT=31.424

SAT
TT=30.803

SAT
TT=46.135

NODES=51937
SAT
TT=462.564

NODES=533253
SAT
TT=348.647

CHECKS=174851
NODES=454076
SAT
TT=1629.71

SAT
TT=376.995

CHECKS=180830798
NODES=90370
SAT
TT=462.334

CHECKS=218439990
NODES=109229
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=88.252

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=234.705

SAT
TT=45.003

CHECKS=1414080000
NODES=295463
SAT
TT=44.409

CHECKS=1414080000
NODES=295463
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-39_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.586

SAT
TT=1.586

CHECKS=3409965
NODES=2333
SAT
TT=2.419

CHECKS=10039213
NODES=6850
SAT
TT=32.53

SAT
TT=14.767

SAT
TT=14.888

SAT
TT=2.773

NODES=1998
SAT
TT=106.938

NODES=114073
SAT
TT=90.682

CHECKS=187594
NODES=102868
SAT
TT=657.009

SAT
TT=747.752

CHECKS=350594310
NODES=145836
SAT
TT=573.452

CHECKS=352693768
NODES=147451
SAT
TT=842.56

CHECKS=395452977
NODES=158210
SAT
TT=134.218

SAT
TT=2.689

SAT
TT=54.165

SAT
TT=566.256

CHECKS=350225127
NODES=145855
SAT
TT=623.524

CHECKS=350225127
NODES=145855
SAT
TT=1263.35

SAT
TT=1235.53

SAT
TT=98.88

SAT
TT=28.749

SAT
TT=9.552

CHECKS=343045000
NODES=59457
SAT
TT=10.098

CHECKS=343045000
NODES=59457
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-41_ext.xml
SAT
TT=15.795

SAT
TT=55.424

CHECKS=371184799
NODES=256959
SAT
TT=20.139

CHECKS=123478444
NODES=86265
SAT
TT=139.515

SAT
TT=16.838

SAT
TT=15.795

SAT
TT=106.182

NODES=115503
SAT
TT=71.479

NODES=75840
SAT
TT=75.596

CHECKS=177303
NODES=90708
SAT
TT=156.049

SAT
TT=1041.77

CHECKS=531633881
NODES=245577
SAT
TT=1114.54

CHECKS=526888559
NODES=243135
SAT
TT=90.265

CHECKS=50576236
NODES=22088
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=516.923

SAT
TT=87.165

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=476.484

SAT
TT=486.243

SAT
TT=1504.64

SAT
TT=39.617

SAT
TT=28.495

CHECKS=938038000
NODES=181325
SAT
TT=26.552

CHECKS=938038000
NODES=181325
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-43_ext.xml
SAT
TT=30.719

SAT
TT=83.82

CHECKS=516143492
NODES=388035
SAT
TT=149.906

CHECKS=947595102
NODES=706391
SAT
TT=751.356

SAT
TT=92.342

SAT
TT=98.313

SAT
TT=738.252

NODES=826284
SAT
TT=725.716

NODES=861344
SAT
TT=774.159

CHECKS=178114
NODES=1057394
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=314.243

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=327.405

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.75

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=136.456

SAT
TT=30.719

CHECKS=1061480000
NODES=213606
SAT
TT=30.628

CHECKS=1061480000
NODES=213606
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-45_ext.xml
SAT
TT=5.683

SAT
TT=35.137

CHECKS=224234327
NODES=167770
SAT
TT=5.683

CHECKS=32164042
NODES=23489
SAT
TT=181.154

SAT
TT=27.098

SAT
TT=26.95

SAT
TT=97.103

NODES=101399
SAT
TT=167.283

NODES=196291
SAT
TT=167.111

CHECKS=182777
NODES=214928
SAT
TT=117.694

SAT
TT=1109.34

CHECKS=515568738
NODES=261045
SAT
TT=130.036

CHECKS=52001369
NODES=27519
SAT
TT=105.371

CHECKS=51756179
NODES=23642
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=180.231

SAT
TT=944.769

CHECKS=488566949
NODES=231852
SAT
TT=1008.49

CHECKS=488566949
NODES=231852
? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=40.055

SAT
TT=9.889

CHECKS=314312000
NODES=60931
SAT
TT=9.825

CHECKS=314312000
NODES=60931
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-47_ext.xml
SAT
TT=62.002

SAT
TT=229.165

CHECKS=1489822477
NODES=1104163
SAT
TT=243.374

CHECKS=1525088587
NODES=1125784
SAT
TT=266.534

SAT
TT=86.02

SAT
TT=85.516

SAT
TT=40.527

NODES=42505
SAT
TT=404.985

NODES=518026
SAT
TT=533.183

CHECKS=184569
NODES=728103
SAT
TT=1082.24

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=101.145

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=565.913

SAT
TT=62.002

CHECKS=1996370000
NODES=405974
SAT
TT=59.298

CHECKS=1996370000
NODES=405974
random/rand-2-40-19-fcd/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-fcd-49_ext.xml
SAT
TT=2.332

SAT
TT=19.912

CHECKS=125401063
NODES=96225
SAT
TT=14.209

CHECKS=80162547
NODES=62783
SAT
TT=7.859

SAT
TT=48.838

SAT
TT=52.02

SAT
TT=707.28

NODES=821055
SAT
TT=503

NODES=646976
SAT
TT=445.596

CHECKS=186663
NODES=610044
SAT
TT=729.785

SAT
TT=148.556

CHECKS=64301622
NODES=35429
SAT
TT=159.328

CHECKS=62652487
NODES=34511
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=2.989

SAT
TT=106.196

CHECKS=57933582
NODES=32619
SAT
TT=123.454

CHECKS=57933582
NODES=32619
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=1660.63

SAT
TT=71.004

SAT
TT=2.332

CHECKS=68445000
NODES=15655
SAT
TT=2.3

CHECKS=68445000
NODES=15655
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-11_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=81.693

UNSAT
TT=270.083

CHECKS=1685665617
NODES=1238090
UNSAT
TT=279.873

CHECKS=1881116508
NODES=1371491
UNSAT
TT=468.471

UNSAT
TT=146.502

UNSAT
TT=156.821

UNSAT
TT=1513.46

NODES=1777853
UNSAT
TT=631.972

NODES=781142
UNSAT
TT=742.628

CHECKS=176678
NODES=975243
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=325.558

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.84

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=442.87

UNSAT
TT=81.693

CHECKS=2808250000
NODES=556541
UNSAT
TT=81.737

CHECKS=2808250000
NODES=556541
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-13_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=22.895

UNSAT
TT=76.95

CHECKS=496232509
NODES=335360
UNSAT
TT=68.696

CHECKS=478900487
NODES=327656
UNSAT
TT=125.841

UNSAT
TT=44.819

UNSAT
TT=42.058

UNSAT
TT=426.336

NODES=426101
UNSAT
TT=192.304

NODES=213015
UNSAT
TT=185.432

CHECKS=183600
NODES=220916
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=1442.9

CHECKS=713251144
NODES=327878
UNSAT
TT=1332.56

CHECKS=714682686
NODES=328301
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=94.725

UNSAT
TT=1656.94

CHECKS=847682884
NODES=367115
UNSAT
TT=1615.41

CHECKS=847682884
NODES=367115
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=125.078

UNSAT
TT=22.895

CHECKS=808893000
NODES=138520
UNSAT
TT=24.051

CHECKS=808893000
NODES=138520
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-15_ext.xml
SAT
TT=3.797

SAT
TT=8.913

CHECKS=57623674
NODES=37451
SAT
TT=3.797

CHECKS=20669527
NODES=13830
SAT
TT=3.856

SAT
TT=15.891

SAT
TT=14.978

SAT
TT=32.018

NODES=36122
SAT
TT=113.948

NODES=112881
SAT
TT=56.679

CHECKS=173502
NODES=72663
SAT
TT=1042.09

SAT
TT=799.431

CHECKS=433541560
NODES=179998
SAT
TT=97.596

CHECKS=52078924
NODES=22356
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=794.276

SAT
TT=1449.75

SAT
TT=37.593

SAT
TT=838.558

CHECKS=428013040
NODES=176915
SAT
TT=852.867

CHECKS=428013040
NODES=176915
SAT
TT=306.696

SAT
TT=305.067

SAT
TT=21.49

SAT
TT=40.589

SAT
TT=12.534

CHECKS=431137000
NODES=69090
SAT
TT=12.574

CHECKS=431137000
NODES=69090
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-17_ext.xml
SAT
TT=8.208

SAT
TT=69.543

CHECKS=427618641
NODES=320664
SAT
TT=8.208

CHECKS=46275172
NODES=35157
SAT
TT=236.888

SAT
TT=29.439

SAT
TT=29.639

SAT
TT=258.228

NODES=270509
SAT
TT=357.897

NODES=442204
SAT
TT=198.387

CHECKS=184082
NODES=266369
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=921.745

CHECKS=462731028
NODES=215642
SAT
TT=863.329

CHECKS=459093816
NODES=213705
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=116.145

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800

SAT
TT=188.5

SAT
TT=32.909

CHECKS=1118070000
NODES=191018
SAT
TT=32.744

CHECKS=1118070000
NODES=191018
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-19_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=36.32

UNSAT
TT=123.621

CHECKS=786503385
NODES=549961
UNSAT
TT=119.529

CHECKS=814838312
NODES=568065
UNSAT
TT=288.395

UNSAT
TT=69.012

UNSAT
TT=65.007

UNSAT
TT=746.12

NODES=802852
UNSAT
TT=314.714

NODES=339170
UNSAT
TT=294.684

CHECKS=176541
NODES=369896
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=148.721

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=178.104

UNSAT
TT=36.32

CHECKS=1154330000
NODES=217269
UNSAT
TT=35.785

CHECKS=1154330000
NODES=217269
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-1_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=28.147

UNSAT
TT=82.964

CHECKS=567557577
NODES=396626
UNSAT
TT=82.202

CHECKS=576195353
NODES=400431
UNSAT
TT=279.047

UNSAT
TT=62.043

UNSAT
TT=58.596

UNSAT
TT=945.114

NODES=782576
UNSAT
TT=243.85

NODES=254956
UNSAT
TT=232.395

CHECKS=182445
NODES=279233
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=0.028

UNSAT
TT=109.378

UNSAT
TT=1752.85

CHECKS=1017313398
NODES=459653
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.63

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

UNSAT
TT=1766.73

UNSAT
TT=157.836

UNSAT
TT=28.147

CHECKS=935683000
NODES=169049
UNSAT
TT=27.911

CHECKS=935683000
NODES=169049
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-21_ext.xml
SAT
TT=37.253

SAT
TT=97.913

CHECKS=586900352
NODES=462706
SAT
TT=38.511

CHECKS=228326931
NODES=183575
SAT
TT=521.055

SAT
TT=127.277

SAT
TT=119.245

SAT
TT=190.05

NODES=214539
SAT
TT=254.095

NODES=311267
SAT
TT=452.494

CHECKS=172366
NODES=647046
SAT
TT=1386.83

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=124.397

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=208.437

SAT
TT=37.253

CHECKS=1176600000
NODES=260347
SAT
TT=36.823

CHECKS=1176600000
NODES=260347
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-23_ext.xml
SAT
TT=10.098

SAT
TT=13.521

CHECKS=77208957
NODES=55339
SAT
TT=34.425

CHECKS=231377112
NODES=164016
SAT
TT=69.653

SAT
TT=10.098

SAT
TT=10.211

SAT
TT=486.363

NODES=554770
SAT
TT=139.548

NODES=156544
SAT
TT=223.99

CHECKS=173569
NODES=267086
SAT
TT=169.81

SAT
TT=994.601

CHECKS=508363988
NODES=233891
SAT
TT=1079.09

CHECKS=508459251
NODES=233765
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=572.472

SAT
TT=492.971

SAT
TT=113.932

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=386.896

SAT
TT=399.648

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=55.856

SAT
TT=31.058

CHECKS=1025080000
NODES=180961
SAT
TT=30.912

CHECKS=1025080000
NODES=180961
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-25_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=41.501

UNSAT
TT=138.093

CHECKS=862691004
NODES=608392
UNSAT
TT=148.017

CHECKS=955109046
NODES=672649
UNSAT
TT=336.913

UNSAT
TT=80.468

UNSAT
TT=75.098

UNSAT
TT=772.02

NODES=836781
UNSAT
TT=367.812

NODES=391501
UNSAT
TT=319.053

CHECKS=177335
NODES=419233
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=175.851

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.5

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=189.761

UNSAT
TT=41.501

CHECKS=1345170000
NODES=256676
UNSAT
TT=41.31

CHECKS=1345170000
NODES=256676
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-27_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=21.91

UNSAT
TT=61.421

CHECKS=407838029
NODES=275956
UNSAT
TT=64.59

CHECKS=411636816
NODES=278904
UNSAT
TT=217.826

UNSAT
TT=41.647

UNSAT
TT=42.61

UNSAT
TT=489.99

NODES=512479
UNSAT
TT=182.672

NODES=205523
UNSAT
TT=167.008

CHECKS=178073
NODES=208942
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=1337.33

CHECKS=652715125
NODES=306327
UNSAT
TT=1418.6

CHECKS=643522927
NODES=302785
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=87.158

UNSAT
TT=1451

CHECKS=682268266
NODES=319523
UNSAT
TT=1453.81

CHECKS=682268266
NODES=319523
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=112.858

UNSAT
TT=21.91

CHECKS=701594000
NODES=127171
UNSAT
TT=21.803

CHECKS=701594000
NODES=127171
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-29_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=15.692

UNSAT
TT=43.531

CHECKS=297493035
NODES=201833
UNSAT
TT=45.497

CHECKS=291636592
NODES=198540
UNSAT
TT=133.185

UNSAT
TT=27.082

UNSAT
TT=26.759

UNSAT
TT=314.241

NODES=363530
UNSAT
TT=125.056

NODES=128720
UNSAT
TT=114.151

CHECKS=172659
NODES=135750
UNSAT
TT=1396.1

UNSAT
TT=891.893

CHECKS=504794105
NODES=212056
UNSAT
TT=951.397

CHECKS=505533456
NODES=212573
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=943.167

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=60.046

UNSAT
TT=1107.17

CHECKS=532357648
NODES=223350
UNSAT
TT=1017.58

CHECKS=532357648
NODES=223350
? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=1795.09

UNSAT
TT=69.755

UNSAT
TT=15.692

CHECKS=523276000
NODES=85303
UNSAT
TT=15.194

CHECKS=523276000
NODES=85303
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-31_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.864

SAT
TT=31.186

CHECKS=188205637
NODES=139656
SAT
TT=46.413

CHECKS=303858548
NODES=227582
SAT
TT=0.864

SAT
TT=35.076

SAT
TT=37.541

SAT
TT=342.688

NODES=399133
SAT
TT=82.835

NODES=94103
SAT
TT=83.158

CHECKS=170429
NODES=104753
SAT
TT=1712.27

SAT
TT=155.488

CHECKS=83673616
NODES=40575
SAT
TT=97.783

CHECKS=51711810
NODES=24856
SAT
TT=780.933

CHECKS=423755191
NODES=208830
SAT
TT=255.063

SAT
TT=1252.33

SAT
TT=31.509

SAT
TT=722.98

CHECKS=348897154
NODES=161018
SAT
TT=701.861

CHECKS=348897154
NODES=161018
? (TO)
TT=1800.52

? (TO)
TT=1800.71

SAT
TT=1521.77

SAT
TT=14.819

SAT
TT=10.878

CHECKS=350977000
NODES=64255
SAT
TT=10.672

CHECKS=350977000
NODES=64255
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-33_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=148.225

UNSAT
TT=411.682

CHECKS=2728993272
NODES=2086270
UNSAT
TT=434.814

CHECKS=2745934907
NODES=2112798
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=239.68

UNSAT
TT=239.954

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=1200.07

NODES=1373535
UNSAT
TT=1049.68

CHECKS=173665
NODES=1479267
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=589.85

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=625.842

UNSAT
TT=148.225

CHECKS=4775300000
NODES=977797
UNSAT
TT=142.043

CHECKS=4775300000
NODES=977797
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-35_ext.xml
SAT
TT=23.531

SAT
TT=139.722

CHECKS=926278292
NODES=722375
SAT
TT=45.968

CHECKS=278468133
NODES=223323
SAT
TT=674.271

SAT
TT=61.268

SAT
TT=61.82

SAT
TT=75.425

NODES=86512
SAT
TT=523.503

NODES=643599
SAT
TT=416.858

CHECKS=179542
NODES=544623
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=1418.63

CHECKS=726829844
NODES=375000
SAT
TT=1490.41

CHECKS=735768305
NODES=377590
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=223.699

SAT
TT=1297.46

CHECKS=710894124
NODES=367578
SAT
TT=1383.33

CHECKS=710894124
NODES=367578
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=305.502

SAT
TT=23.531

CHECKS=750935000
NODES=162605
SAT
TT=23.487

CHECKS=750935000
NODES=162605
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-37_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=83.27

UNSAT
TT=314.332

CHECKS=1946987218
NODES=1461042
UNSAT
TT=305.646

CHECKS=1911952266
NODES=1438524
UNSAT
TT=655.245

UNSAT
TT=142.696

UNSAT
TT=134.679

UNSAT
TT=1781.1

NODES=1970053
UNSAT
TT=719.859

NODES=877191
UNSAT
TT=742.296

CHECKS=175653
NODES=1039034
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=392.74

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=400.837

UNSAT
TT=83.27

CHECKS=2634620000
NODES=557397
UNSAT
TT=82.772

CHECKS=2634620000
NODES=557397
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-39_ext.xml
SAT
TT=8.716

SAT
TT=24.166

CHECKS=163130678
NODES=106270
SAT
TT=21.799

CHECKS=150204849
NODES=99005
SAT
TT=25.203

SAT
TT=16.879

SAT
TT=16.869

SAT
TT=40.969

NODES=42095
SAT
TT=15.725

NODES=14849
SAT
TT=12.819

CHECKS=185255
NODES=13572
SAT
TT=105.557

SAT
TT=583.598

CHECKS=287466952
NODES=117891
SAT
TT=607.888

CHECKS=337553096
NODES=133906
SAT
TT=1637.17

CHECKS=838881795
NODES=326870
SAT
TT=165.254

SAT
TT=360.82

SAT
TT=8.716

SAT
TT=579.285

CHECKS=336691626
NODES=133587
SAT
TT=604.317

CHECKS=336691626
NODES=133587
SAT
TT=1538.76

SAT
TT=1549.73

SAT
TT=152.56

SAT
TT=25.93

SAT
TT=10.073

CHECKS=350749000
NODES=54653
SAT
TT=10.161

CHECKS=350749000
NODES=54653
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-3_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=44.238

UNSAT
TT=156.658

CHECKS=1048557079
NODES=701425
UNSAT
TT=129.111

CHECKS=901722206
NODES=610489
UNSAT
TT=284.374

UNSAT
TT=66.02

UNSAT
TT=62.049

UNSAT
TT=772.224

NODES=853018
UNSAT
TT=383.986

NODES=430576
UNSAT
TT=343.912

CHECKS=178995
NODES=424908
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=204.468

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

UNSAT
TT=267.436

UNSAT
TT=44.238

CHECKS=1501180000
NODES=246778
UNSAT
TT=42.557

CHECKS=1501180000
NODES=246778
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-41_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=30.718

UNSAT
TT=100.378

CHECKS=689206796
NODES=465240
UNSAT
TT=124.494

CHECKS=806582929
NODES=538273
UNSAT
TT=367.574

UNSAT
TT=53.151

UNSAT
TT=51.011

UNSAT
TT=571.261

NODES=606464
UNSAT
TT=237.48

NODES=282828
UNSAT
TT=235.671

CHECKS=177571
NODES=289170
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

UNSAT
TT=143.665

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=173.194

UNSAT
TT=30.718

CHECKS=1010840000
NODES=186342
UNSAT
TT=30.578

CHECKS=1010840000
NODES=186342
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-43_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=90.651

UNSAT
TT=311.807

CHECKS=2101744036
NODES=1535269
UNSAT
TT=355.111

CHECKS=2327609636
NODES=1692213
UNSAT
TT=747.571

UNSAT
TT=162.007

UNSAT
TT=174.427

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=869.937

NODES=1106615
UNSAT
TT=818.918

CHECKS=178982
NODES=1050528
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

UNSAT
TT=367.294

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.66

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

UNSAT
TT=457.526

UNSAT
TT=90.651

CHECKS=2939110000
NODES=601618
UNSAT
TT=90.312

CHECKS=2939110000
NODES=601618
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-45_ext.xml
SAT
TT=13.724

SAT
TT=64.193

CHECKS=403162453
NODES=299827
SAT
TT=71.926

CHECKS=444370623
NODES=326786
SAT
TT=265.996

SAT
TT=50.837

SAT
TT=51.734

SAT
TT=214.741

NODES=225103
SAT
TT=605.269

NODES=675236
SAT
TT=209.139

CHECKS=183745
NODES=280278
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=441.298

CHECKS=215549476
NODES=106849
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=163.129

SAT
TT=1055.75

CHECKS=501138605
NODES=239090
SAT
TT=973.572

CHECKS=501138605
NODES=239090
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.55

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=332.152

SAT
TT=13.724

CHECKS=459736000
NODES=88601
SAT
TT=14.549

CHECKS=459736000
NODES=88601
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-47_ext.xml
SAT
TT=24.838

SAT
TT=53.883

CHECKS=322891431
NODES=242639
SAT
TT=38.669

CHECKS=255575389
NODES=192514
SAT
TT=579.109

SAT
TT=26.269

SAT
TT=24.838

SAT
TT=105.585

NODES=113146
SAT
TT=604.666

NODES=712171
SAT
TT=533.44

CHECKS=182780
NODES=717625
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=137.71

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

SAT
TT=1321.41

SAT
TT=1268.87

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=359.746

SAT
TT=36.782

CHECKS=1204100000
NODES=228533
SAT
TT=34.813

CHECKS=1204100000
NODES=228533
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-49_ext.xml
SAT
TT=40.087

SAT
TT=228.26

CHECKS=1434466780
NODES=1086944
SAT
TT=212.71

CHECKS=1421763725
NODES=1078878
SAT
TT=165.045

SAT
TT=174.428

SAT
TT=163.144

SAT
TT=348.484

NODES=378181
SAT
TT=46.041

NODES=52100
SAT
TT=45.889

CHECKS=182408
NODES=56456
SAT
TT=563.63

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=1139.2

CHECKS=511102299
NODES=272997
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=106.324

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.56

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=307.824

SAT
TT=40.087

CHECKS=1232450000
NODES=286929
SAT
TT=38.881

CHECKS=1232450000
NODES=286929
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-5_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=66.415

UNSAT
TT=251.427

CHECKS=1540686439
NODES=1117687
UNSAT
TT=225.652

CHECKS=1521246115
NODES=1096362
UNSAT
TT=360.918

UNSAT
TT=117.294

UNSAT
TT=121.773

UNSAT
TT=1201.18

NODES=1384785
UNSAT
TT=600.315

NODES=741963
UNSAT
TT=580.665

CHECKS=175887
NODES=813812
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=237.446

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.56

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

UNSAT
TT=343.162

UNSAT
TT=66.415

CHECKS=2134640000
NODES=437659
UNSAT
TT=65.721

CHECKS=2134640000
NODES=437659
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-7_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=101.315

UNSAT
TT=403.932

CHECKS=2477981985
NODES=1937455
UNSAT
TT=379.2

CHECKS=2454505480
NODES=1914574
UNSAT
TT=588.845

UNSAT
TT=237.011

UNSAT
TT=222.366

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=951.525

NODES=1182920
UNSAT
TT=990.828

CHECKS=173582
NODES=1306306
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=387.366

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

UNSAT
TT=488.675

UNSAT
TT=101.315

CHECKS=3302030000
NODES=718151
UNSAT
TT=103.239

CHECKS=3302030000
NODES=718151
random/rand-2-40-19/
rand-2-40-19-443-230-9_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=63.954

UNSAT
TT=181.347

CHECKS=1226164643
NODES=882161
UNSAT
TT=193.667

CHECKS=1225260478
NODES=880664
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=112.201

UNSAT
TT=109.439

UNSAT
TT=1170.99

NODES=1234992
UNSAT
TT=433.668

NODES=515134
UNSAT
TT=416.641

CHECKS=179142
NODES=544089
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=194.905

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.65

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

UNSAT
TT=268.674

UNSAT
TT=63.954

CHECKS=2092670000
NODES=386609
UNSAT
TT=63.122

CHECKS=2092670000
NODES=386609
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-11_ext.xml
SAT
TT=222.955

SAT
TT=222.955

CHECKS=1559117243
NODES=940192
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-13_ext.xml
SAT
TT=639.645

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

SAT
TT=1325.75

CHECKS=8485695134
NODES=5394062
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=639.645

SAT
TT=683.312

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=1579.39

CHECKS=50658100000
NODES=9588380
SAT
TT=1506.02

CHECKS=50658100000
NODES=9588380
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-15_ext.xml
SAT
TT=468.835

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

SAT
TT=468.835

CHECKS=3054840526
NODES=1922021
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=698.148

CHECKS=21951700000
NODES=4043510
SAT
TT=642.672

CHECKS=21951700000
NODES=4043510
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-17_ext.xml
SAT
TT=408.058

SAT
TT=1326.16

CHECKS=9305168526
NODES=5952688
SAT
TT=1559.1

CHECKS=10861441116
NODES=6942988
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=428.389

SAT
TT=408.058

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=1701.03

SAT
TT=594.221

CHECKS=18742500000
NODES=3222370
SAT
TT=581.475

CHECKS=18742500000
NODES=3222370
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-19_ext.xml
SAT
TT=522.947

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=643.891

SAT
TT=689.236

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=1421.71

SAT
TT=1407.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=732.859

SAT
TT=522.947

CHECKS=16273500000
NODES=2965810
SAT
TT=474.57

CHECKS=16273500000
NODES=2965810
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-21_ext.xml
SAT
TT=845.181

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

SAT
TT=920.403

SAT
TT=845.181

SAT
TT=899.016

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=1358.34

CHECKS=47828100000
NODES=7135380
SAT
TT=1437.53

CHECKS=47828100000
NODES=7135380
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-23_ext.xml
SAT
TT=2.536

SAT
TT=2.536

CHECKS=10153281
NODES=6554
SAT
TT=295.195

CHECKS=1946467607
NODES=1204962
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=75.128

SAT
TT=80.119

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=1007.19

CHECKS=32313800000
NODES=5422250
SAT
TT=992.237

CHECKS=32313800000
NODES=5422250
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-25_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-27_ext.xml
SAT
TT=511.767

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=511.767

SAT
TT=513.529

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.58

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-29_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1166.76

SAT
TT=1579.7

CHECKS=10057451549
NODES=6238367
SAT
TT=1166.76

CHECKS=8187481087
NODES=5076299
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

SAT
TT=1349.48

SAT
TT=1283.3

SAT
TT=245.123

NODES=197541
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=1189.59

CHECKS=39723200000
NODES=7508550
SAT
TT=1267.74

CHECKS=39723200000
NODES=7508550
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-31_ext.xml
SAT
TT=196.206

SAT
TT=196.206

CHECKS=1399949621
NODES=822579
SAT
TT=679.658

CHECKS=4608631011
NODES=2731527
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=1159.57

SAT
TT=1241.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=983.361

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.56

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=212.36

CHECKS=7094220000
NODES=1139870
SAT
TT=213.087

CHECKS=7094220000
NODES=1139870
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-33_ext.xml
SAT
TT=389.804

SAT
TT=1382.22

CHECKS=9960552631
NODES=5888388
SAT
TT=389.804

CHECKS=2595711036
NODES=1537471
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=442.397

SAT
TT=472.105

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=783.735

CHECKS=25323400000
NODES=4161090
SAT
TT=747.266

CHECKS=25323400000
NODES=4161090
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-35_ext.xml
SAT
TT=330.783

SAT
TT=743.444

CHECKS=4905020155
NODES=2979562
SAT
TT=330.783

CHECKS=2359597418
NODES=1402022
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=795.741

SAT
TT=799.707

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.56

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-37_ext.xml
SAT
TT=477.599

SAT
TT=477.599

CHECKS=3260384086
NODES=1997401
SAT
TT=676.876

CHECKS=4739119516
NODES=2900247
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.55

? (TO)
TT=1800.64

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-39_ext.xml
SAT
TT=114.517

SAT
TT=114.517

CHECKS=745514391
NODES=442915
? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=1369.4

SAT
TT=1462.65

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=1496.78

NODES=1373334
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=1531.35

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=299.484

CHECKS=10259500000
NODES=1702660
SAT
TT=297.376

CHECKS=10259500000
NODES=1702660
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-41_ext.xml
SAT
TT=167.635

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

SAT
TT=394.314

CHECKS=2593680866
NODES=1611602
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=1622.51

SAT
TT=1690.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=809.899

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.58

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=167.635

CHECKS=5552370000
NODES=1108730
SAT
TT=165.706

CHECKS=5552370000
NODES=1108730
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-43_ext.xml
SAT
TT=222.449

SAT
TT=242.28

CHECKS=1588213368
NODES=934085
SAT
TT=222.449

CHECKS=1565728893
NODES=935186
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.62

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-45_ext.xml
SAT
TT=68.775

SAT
TT=841.733

CHECKS=5451351129
NODES=3260742
SAT
TT=396.648

CHECKS=2806955628
NODES=1719545
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=68.775

SAT
TT=69.62

SAT
TT=1614.73

NODES=1410930
SAT
TT=1384.77

NODES=1261422
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=1442.89

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=277.52

CHECKS=9348540000
NODES=1599140
SAT
TT=285.587

CHECKS=9348540000
NODES=1599140
random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-47_ext.xml
SAT
TT=76.456

SAT
TT=76.456

CHECKS=473734824
NODES=320167
SAT
TT=300.986

CHECKS=1938949376
NODES=1270628
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=1664.49

SAT
TT=1535.82

SAT
TT=929.374

NODES=792611
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

random/rand-2-50-23-fcd/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-fcd-49_ext.xml
SAT
TT=489.567

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

SAT
TT=1565.74

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=489.567

CHECKS=363609
NODES=460289
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-10_ext.xml
SAT
TT=376.074

SAT
TT=1445.31

CHECKS=9817823554
NODES=6522095
SAT
TT=902.971

CHECKS=4541294022
NODES=2954073
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=377.407

SAT
TT=376.074

SAT
TT=768.686

NODES=699439
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=880.949

SAT
TT=624.102

CHECKS=21030800000
NODES=4054740
SAT
TT=657.977

CHECKS=21030800000
NODES=4054740
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-11_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.64

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-12_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-13_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.47

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-14_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1044.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=1044.05

CHECKS=34979400000
NODES=6160800
SAT
TT=1099.29

CHECKS=34979400000
NODES=6160800
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-15_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-16_ext.xml
SAT
TT=354.635

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=354.635

SAT
TT=381.497

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=1135.12

CHECKS=37577000000
NODES=6149130
SAT
TT=1085.44

CHECKS=37577000000
NODES=6149130
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-17_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1073.51

SAT
TT=1073.51

CHECKS=7489081724
NODES=4527913
SAT
TT=1792.66

CHECKS=11790234745
NODES=7131750
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=1147.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=1600.64

CHECKS=52112800000
NODES=8761670
SAT
TT=1536.11

CHECKS=52112800000
NODES=8761670
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-18_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-19_ext.xml
SAT
TT=255.586

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

SAT
TT=255.586

CHECKS=1756254328
NODES=1087419
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.6

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=1045.81

CHECKS=33497900000
NODES=5754670
SAT
TT=1034.49

CHECKS=33497900000
NODES=5754670
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-1_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1776.7

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=1776.7

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-20_ext.xml
SAT
TT=192.44

SAT
TT=420.005

CHECKS=3038737884
NODES=1803886
SAT
TT=887.073

CHECKS=5997688607
NODES=3605977
? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=192.44

SAT
TT=206.815

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=359.465

CHECKS=11923900000
NODES=1955720
SAT
TT=332.88

CHECKS=11923900000
NODES=1955720
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-21_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1298.57

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

SAT
TT=1607.24

SAT
TT=1712.83

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=1298.57

CHECKS=45344000000
NODES=6922360
SAT
TT=1372.75

CHECKS=45344000000
NODES=6922360
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-22_ext.xml
SAT
TT=141.697

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=869.883

SAT
TT=873.925

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=1145.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=141.697

CHECKS=4459680000
NODES=831752
SAT
TT=139.912

CHECKS=4459680000
NODES=831752
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-23_ext.xml
SAT
TT=129.765

SAT
TT=490.513

CHECKS=3489519939
NODES=2119569
SAT
TT=500.604

CHECKS=3347495509
NODES=2061144
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=242.441

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.61

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=129.765

CHECKS=4435940000
NODES=739299
SAT
TT=135.842

CHECKS=4435940000
NODES=739299
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-24_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-25_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1077.61

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=1459.45

NODES=1401411
SAT
TT=1077.61

CHECKS=363670
NODES=1089385
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-26_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1737.96

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=1737.96

SAT
TT=1738.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-27_ext.xml
SAT
TT=714.584

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=714.584

CHECKS=23577000000
NODES=4691380
SAT
TT=755.227

CHECKS=23577000000
NODES=4691380
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-28_ext.xml
SAT
TT=34.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=34.228

SAT
TT=34.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-29_ext.xml
SAT
TT=70.963

SAT
TT=70.963

CHECKS=475381175
NODES=303283
? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=131.825

SAT
TT=123.127

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=732.517

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.59

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=167.191

CHECKS=5745780000
NODES=1009170
SAT
TT=178.638

CHECKS=5745780000
NODES=1009170
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-2_ext.xml
SAT
TT=385.944

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=932.626

SAT
TT=930.794

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=385.944

CHECKS=12851600000
NODES=1887140
SAT
TT=363.75

CHECKS=12851600000
NODES=1887140
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-30_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-31_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.56

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-32_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-33_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1304.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

SAT
TT=1383.4

CHECKS=9867902868
NODES=5849897
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=1304.16

CHECKS=42190700000
NODES=6958390
SAT
TT=1291.26

CHECKS=42190700000
NODES=6958390
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-34_ext.xml
SAT
TT=195.182

SAT
TT=1732.17

CHECKS=11129118467
NODES=7112610
SAT
TT=195.182

CHECKS=1335280719
NODES=866976
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=370.541

SAT
TT=369.994

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-35_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-36_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-37_ext.xml
SAT
TT=74.297

SAT
TT=777.829

CHECKS=5406844162
NODES=3283954
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=79.189

SAT
TT=74.297

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-38_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1481.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=1481.2

CHECKS=47642200000
NODES=7960070
SAT
TT=1422.51

CHECKS=47642200000
NODES=7960070
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-39_ext.xml
SAT
TT=362.121

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

SAT
TT=1528.42

CHECKS=10776208870
NODES=6658242
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=1341.08

SAT
TT=1333.3

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=362.121

CHECKS=11597200000
NODES=2093800
SAT
TT=338.374

CHECKS=11597200000
NODES=2093800
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-3_ext.xml
SAT
TT=240.868

SAT
TT=240.868

CHECKS=1558019976
NODES=981761
SAT
TT=1207.57

CHECKS=5413295919
NODES=3415515
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=299.217

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-40_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1513.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.2

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=1513.18

CHECKS=52388900000
NODES=8957720
SAT
TT=1520.03

CHECKS=52388900000
NODES=8957720
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-41_ext.xml
SAT
TT=529.552

SAT
TT=1492.67

CHECKS=10269984948
NODES=6546448
SAT
TT=807.094

CHECKS=5537901306
NODES=3548020
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.61

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=529.552

CHECKS=16779700000
NODES=3114270
SAT
TT=519.167

CHECKS=16779700000
NODES=3114270
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-42_ext.xml
SAT
TT=681.298

SAT
TT=1201.87

CHECKS=7967714328
NODES=4825502
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=681.298

SAT
TT=726.381

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-43_ext.xml
SAT
TT=35.285

SAT
TT=1277.44

CHECKS=8755088250
NODES=5369590
SAT
TT=614.942

CHECKS=4328373748
NODES=2622267
SAT
TT=619.823

SAT
TT=53.224

SAT
TT=53.247

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=1200.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.3

? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=35.285

CHECKS=1121080000
NODES=189192
SAT
TT=35.119

CHECKS=1121080000
NODES=189192
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-44_ext.xml
SAT
TT=224.611

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

SAT
TT=341.596

SAT
TT=224.611

SAT
TT=225.98

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-45_ext.xml
SAT
TT=22.815

SAT
TT=22.815

CHECKS=142857244
NODES=92726
SAT
TT=974.66

CHECKS=6862462120
NODES=4182508
? (TO)
TT=1800.1

SAT
TT=1104.62

SAT
TT=1104.16

SAT
TT=398.418

NODES=326339
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.56

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

SAT
TT=1171.98

CHECKS=40011700000
NODES=6805440
SAT
TT=1179.48

CHECKS=40011700000
NODES=6805440
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-46_ext.xml
SAT
TT=874.67

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

SAT
TT=1544.08

CHECKS=10862142214
NODES=7019298
? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=1268.48

SAT
TT=1267.66

SAT
TT=177.753

NODES=143363
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=874.67

CHECKS=27898200000
NODES=5002010
SAT
TT=865.1

CHECKS=27898200000
NODES=5002010
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-47_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1009.15

SAT
TT=1009.15

CHECKS=6811257930
NODES=4594407
SAT
TT=1622.36

CHECKS=11023246404
NODES=7210102
? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-48_ext.xml
SAT
TT=211.765

SAT
TT=1683.76

CHECKS=12035354105
NODES=6311691
? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

SAT
TT=938.187

SAT
TT=875.73

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.22

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=211.765

CHECKS=7206030000
NODES=1001880
SAT
TT=196.47

CHECKS=7206030000
NODES=1001880
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-49_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.55

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-4_ext.xml
SAT
TT=419.269

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.62

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=419.269

CHECKS=13582700000
NODES=2231500
SAT
TT=400.893

CHECKS=13582700000
NODES=2231500
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-50_ext.xml
SAT
TT=184.732

SAT
TT=463.493

CHECKS=3061502354
NODES=1852654
SAT
TT=560.31

CHECKS=3986034545
NODES=2439144
? (TO)
TT=1800.03

SAT
TT=185.669

SAT
TT=184.732

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

SAT
TT=1765.91

CHECKS=60918900000
NODES=11207900
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-5_ext.xml
SAT
TT=491.785

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

SAT
TT=515.356

SAT
TT=514.814

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=998.511

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.19

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=491.785

CHECKS=16336500000
NODES=2845680
SAT
TT=509.203

CHECKS=16336500000
NODES=2845680
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-6_ext.xml



? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-7_ext.xml
SAT
TT=243.616

SAT
TT=243.616

CHECKS=1746638556
NODES=1023904
SAT
TT=375.128

CHECKS=2665429111
NODES=1538331
? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.01

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.15

? (TO)
TT=1800.18

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-8_ext.xml
SAT
TT=726.759

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=774.14

SAT
TT=776.536

? (TO)
TT=1800

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.12

? (TO)
TT=1800.03

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=1471.29

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.6

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

SAT
TT=1399.63

SAT
TT=726.759

CHECKS=23003500000
NODES=4297810
SAT
TT=723.637

CHECKS=23003500000
NODES=4297810
random/rand-2-50-23/
rand-2-50-23-587-230-9_ext.xml
SAT
TT=740.976

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

? (TO)
TT=1800.04

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.02

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.08

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

? (TO)
TT=1800.05

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

? (TO)
TT=1800.1

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=740.976

CHECKS=25652400000
NODES=4588030
SAT
TT=751.938

CHECKS=25652400000
NODES=4588030
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-0_ext.xml
SAT
TT=2.337

SAT
TT=4.399

CHECKS=10132138
NODES=15308
SAT
TT=3.355

CHECKS=7738981
NODES=11832
SAT
TT=13.45

SAT
TT=2.451

SAT
TT=2.337

SAT
TT=20.014

NODES=16237
SAT
TT=14.868

NODES=13960
SAT
TT=9.992

CHECKS=86818
NODES=10961
SAT
TT=12.706

SAT
TT=202.438

CHECKS=93768929
NODES=60130
SAT
TT=175.37

CHECKS=84153643
NODES=53992
SAT
TT=179.329

CHECKS=86669367
NODES=58484
SAT
TT=4.027

SAT
TT=8.353

SAT
TT=12.857

SAT
TT=186.315

CHECKS=91046842
NODES=61478
SAT
TT=184.568

CHECKS=91046842
NODES=61478
SAT
TT=142.102

SAT
TT=139.892

SAT
TT=16.64

SAT
TT=3.736

SAT
TT=2.958

CHECKS=92195900
NODES=31384
SAT
TT=2.915

CHECKS=92195900
NODES=31384
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-11_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.401

SAT
TT=2.802

CHECKS=5096327
NODES=7666
SAT
TT=1.401

CHECKS=834443
NODES=1408
SAT
TT=9.05

SAT
TT=1.957

SAT
TT=1.935

SAT
TT=11.499

NODES=8407
SAT
TT=29.182

NODES=29791
SAT
TT=18.439

CHECKS=87567
NODES=20704
SAT
TT=8.585

SAT
TT=172.516

CHECKS=78368752
NODES=48439
SAT
TT=208.103

CHECKS=93746797
NODES=58080
SAT
TT=114.072

CHECKS=55760938
NODES=35371
SAT
TT=4.59

SAT
TT=2.72

SAT
TT=2.953

SAT
TT=198.138

CHECKS=95953597
NODES=62735
SAT
TT=194.513

CHECKS=95953597
NODES=62735
SAT
TT=61.161

SAT
TT=62.562

SAT
TT=1.72

SAT
TT=3.095

SAT
TT=3.04

CHECKS=93606700
NODES=31656
SAT
TT=2.894

CHECKS=93606700
NODES=31656
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-13_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.391

UNSAT
TT=13.06

CHECKS=36869981
NODES=51875
UNSAT
TT=13.475

CHECKS=39493712
NODES=55718
UNSAT
TT=10.809

UNSAT
TT=11.606

UNSAT
TT=11.704

UNSAT
TT=94.197

NODES=72656
UNSAT
TT=35.986

NODES=35701
UNSAT
TT=28.326

CHECKS=86389
NODES=30291
UNSAT
TT=23.259

UNSAT
TT=216.246

CHECKS=105047266
NODES=61708
UNSAT
TT=219.897

CHECKS=103564291
NODES=62523
UNSAT
TT=801.284

CHECKS=399337321
NODES=245253
UNSAT
TT=47.431

UNSAT
TT=250.057

UNSAT
TT=13.09

UNSAT
TT=215.159

CHECKS=104516503
NODES=64231
UNSAT
TT=214.114

CHECKS=104516503
NODES=64231
UNSAT
TT=499.185

UNSAT
TT=495.912

UNSAT
TT=23.65

UNSAT
TT=18.94

UNSAT
TT=3.391

CHECKS=108681000
NODES=33887
UNSAT
TT=3.383

CHECKS=108681000
NODES=33887
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-15_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.389

SAT
TT=10.885

CHECKS=33539559
NODES=49829
SAT
TT=10.408

CHECKS=29564154
NODES=43830
SAT
TT=3.736

SAT
TT=6.1

SAT
TT=5.72

SAT
TT=4.436

NODES=2897
SAT
TT=26.061

NODES=27702
SAT
TT=25.259

CHECKS=87911
NODES=26567
SAT
TT=20.012

SAT
TT=251.472

CHECKS=117902134
NODES=76637
SAT
TT=253.526

CHECKS=116760459
NODES=75174
SAT
TT=390.802

CHECKS=191190811
NODES=122688
SAT
TT=4.675

SAT
TT=136.516

SAT
TT=11.245

SAT
TT=85.563

CHECKS=37904289
NODES=24601
SAT
TT=82.956

CHECKS=37904289
NODES=24601
SAT
TT=23.773

SAT
TT=22.088

SAT
TT=6.69

SAT
TT=4.199

SAT
TT=1.389

CHECKS=42583900
NODES=14197
SAT
TT=1.273

CHECKS=42583900
NODES=14197
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-17_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=5.169

UNSAT
TT=21.417

CHECKS=63340371
NODES=93125
UNSAT
TT=20.914

CHECKS=67498836
NODES=99716
UNSAT
TT=16.421

UNSAT
TT=14.364

UNSAT
TT=14.926

UNSAT
TT=139.749

NODES=107247
UNSAT
TT=55.536

NODES=53680
UNSAT
TT=53.588

CHECKS=87187
NODES=60927
UNSAT
TT=48.779

UNSAT
TT=323.528

CHECKS=149539320
NODES=94589
UNSAT
TT=306.428

CHECKS=142295520
NODES=91012
UNSAT
TT=1290.75

CHECKS=624424576
NODES=410197
UNSAT
TT=112.78

UNSAT
TT=527.517

UNSAT
TT=19.444

UNSAT
TT=333.81

CHECKS=149385247
NODES=97850
UNSAT
TT=336.718

CHECKS=149385247
NODES=97850
UNSAT
TT=1412.11

UNSAT
TT=1440.3

UNSAT
TT=48.35

UNSAT
TT=23.501

UNSAT
TT=5.169

CHECKS=161310000
NODES=53745
UNSAT
TT=5.087

CHECKS=161310000
NODES=53745
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-19_ext.xml
SAT
TT=2.376

SAT
TT=11.231

CHECKS=31735358
NODES=45098
SAT
TT=10.929

CHECKS=31512046
NODES=45168
SAT
TT=7.801

SAT
TT=6.257

SAT
TT=6.456

SAT
TT=46.684

NODES=38575
SAT
TT=13.699

NODES=12348
SAT
TT=26.154

CHECKS=87082
NODES=29996
SAT
TT=12.128

? (conv)
TT=0

? (conv)
TT=0

? (conv)
TT=0

SAT
TT=33.222

SAT
TT=61.958

SAT
TT=4.841

? (conv)
TT=0

? (conv)
TT=0

SAT
TT=34.432

SAT
TT=33.455

SAT
TT=20.48

SAT
TT=4.511

SAT
TT=2.376

CHECKS=75128200
NODES=23413
SAT
TT=2.319

CHECKS=75128200
NODES=23413
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-1_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.421

UNSAT
TT=18.123

CHECKS=52499096
NODES=75603
UNSAT
TT=16.165

CHECKS=47521739
NODES=69133
UNSAT
TT=11.13

UNSAT
TT=11.179

UNSAT
TT=11.856

UNSAT
TT=95.62

NODES=72352
UNSAT
TT=44.496

NODES=41890
UNSAT
TT=35.938

CHECKS=88719
NODES=41082
UNSAT
TT=30.185

UNSAT
TT=304.897

CHECKS=141902522
NODES=85567
UNSAT
TT=268.047

CHECKS=128855353
NODES=78072
UNSAT
TT=1108.18

CHECKS=510360248
NODES=317762
UNSAT
TT=56.697

UNSAT
TT=302.761

UNSAT
TT=12.194

UNSAT
TT=220.75

CHECKS=101191665
NODES=63158
UNSAT
TT=211.933

CHECKS=101191665
NODES=63158
UNSAT
TT=994.845

UNSAT
TT=951.538

UNSAT
TT=25.58

UNSAT
TT=19.641

UNSAT
TT=3.421

CHECKS=108994000
NODES=34510
UNSAT
TT=3.423

CHECKS=108994000
NODES=34510
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-21_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.628

UNSAT
TT=22.426

CHECKS=66653428
NODES=99137
UNSAT
TT=21.17

CHECKS=66078961
NODES=97939
UNSAT
TT=16.198

UNSAT
TT=12.696

UNSAT
TT=12.992

UNSAT
TT=117.251

NODES=93687
UNSAT
TT=45.315

NODES=48719
UNSAT
TT=42.51

CHECKS=88980
NODES=48295
UNSAT
TT=35.131

UNSAT
TT=277.856

CHECKS=136038223
NODES=88666
UNSAT
TT=321.918

CHECKS=150188985
NODES=98664
UNSAT
TT=1282.16

CHECKS=638406850
NODES=428442
UNSAT
TT=134.898

UNSAT
TT=324.474

UNSAT
TT=19.545

UNSAT
TT=301.004

CHECKS=139600114
NODES=92899
UNSAT
TT=306.327

CHECKS=139600114
NODES=92899
UNSAT
TT=1593.49

UNSAT
TT=1564.39

UNSAT
TT=38.3

UNSAT
TT=27.629

UNSAT
TT=4.628

CHECKS=145034000
NODES=50246
UNSAT
TT=4.584

CHECKS=145034000
NODES=50246
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-23_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.304

SAT
TT=2.195

CHECKS=3547239
NODES=5436
SAT
TT=1.509

CHECKS=1299788
NODES=2081
SAT
TT=4.285

SAT
TT=1.927

SAT
TT=2.042

SAT
TT=8.672

NODES=6933
SAT
TT=8.847

NODES=8600
SAT
TT=22.566

CHECKS=87740
NODES=23931
SAT
TT=5.225

SAT
TT=95.539

CHECKS=42978332
NODES=26940
SAT
TT=114.024

CHECKS=53334477
NODES=32779
SAT
TT=115.487

CHECKS=48739278
NODES=31981
SAT
TT=26.775

SAT
TT=15.47

SAT
TT=6.135

SAT
TT=88.53

CHECKS=39465715
NODES=26999
SAT
TT=80.87

CHECKS=39465715
NODES=26999
SAT
TT=35.228

SAT
TT=36.506

SAT
TT=2.454

SAT
TT=15.351

SAT
TT=1.304

CHECKS=39834300
NODES=13930
SAT
TT=1.266

CHECKS=39834300
NODES=13930
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-25_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.051

SAT
TT=1.074

CHECKS=345661
NODES=581
SAT
TT=3.143

CHECKS=6989290
NODES=11255
SAT
TT=3.41

SAT
TT=2.034

SAT
TT=1.966

SAT
TT=8.797

NODES=6752
SAT
TT=20.994

NODES=22217
SAT
TT=28.408

CHECKS=87561
NODES=33219
SAT
TT=16.287

SAT
TT=72.442

CHECKS=32279174
NODES=21273
SAT
TT=94.978

CHECKS=45537424
NODES=28489
SAT
TT=250.864

CHECKS=122415925
NODES=82111
SAT
TT=15.065

SAT
TT=146.004

SAT
TT=2.406

SAT
TT=64.198

CHECKS=29636955
NODES=20691
SAT
TT=64.813

CHECKS=29636955
NODES=20691
? (TO)
TT=1800.16

? (TO)
TT=1800.06

SAT
TT=7.31

SAT
TT=2.425

SAT
TT=1.051

CHECKS=34147100
NODES=12308
SAT
TT=1.115

CHECKS=34147100
NODES=12308
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-27_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.909

SAT
TT=2.392

CHECKS=4214489
NODES=6339
SAT
TT=3.648

CHECKS=7933180
NODES=12024
SAT
TT=3.568

SAT
TT=3.954

SAT
TT=4.178

SAT
TT=26.395

NODES=19867
SAT
TT=43.687

NODES=42142
SAT
TT=11.846

CHECKS=86573
NODES=12456
SAT
TT=14.075

SAT
TT=219.156

CHECKS=100651974
NODES=63753
SAT
TT=225.978

CHECKS=100964306
NODES=64360
SAT
TT=351.521

CHECKS=167768085
NODES=107658
SAT
TT=4.989

SAT
TT=100.429

SAT
TT=11.947

SAT
TT=61.142

CHECKS=26158827
NODES=16653
SAT
TT=58.894

CHECKS=26158827
NODES=16653
SAT
TT=204.928

SAT
TT=215.655

SAT
TT=17.24

SAT
TT=9.996

SAT
TT=0.909

CHECKS=29913800
NODES=9452
SAT
TT=0.896

CHECKS=29913800
NODES=9452
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-29_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.545

SAT
TT=2.315

CHECKS=3628391
NODES=5834
SAT
TT=20.229

CHECKS=65634322
NODES=99959
SAT
TT=9.3

SAT
TT=1.61

SAT
TT=1.545

SAT
TT=138.517

NODES=114539
SAT
TT=13.749

NODES=13611
SAT
TT=59.238

CHECKS=87596
NODES=66888
SAT
TT=2.763

SAT
TT=116.095

CHECKS=53547256
NODES=33576
SAT
TT=62.742

CHECKS=29416991
NODES=19057
SAT
TT=283.311

CHECKS=131533741
NODES=89962
SAT
TT=16.574

SAT
TT=220.963

SAT
TT=13.337

SAT
TT=208.355

CHECKS=95657776
NODES=64279
SAT
TT=207.007

CHECKS=95657776
NODES=64279
SAT
TT=507.808

SAT
TT=521.455

SAT
TT=43.39

SAT
TT=25.024

SAT
TT=3.075

CHECKS=97842000
NODES=33601
SAT
TT=3.101

CHECKS=97842000
NODES=33601
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-31_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.288

UNSAT
TT=20.003

CHECKS=59739575
NODES=86693
UNSAT
TT=20.944

CHECKS=63877756
NODES=93064
UNSAT
TT=13.948

UNSAT
TT=15.103

UNSAT
TT=14.167

UNSAT
TT=110.122

NODES=95226
UNSAT
TT=58.29

NODES=55442
UNSAT
TT=49.713

CHECKS=88476
NODES=57411
UNSAT
TT=47.229

UNSAT
TT=282.846

CHECKS=139395566
NODES=88428
UNSAT
TT=302.085

CHECKS=137179445
NODES=88760
UNSAT
TT=1334.21

CHECKS=644459458
NODES=420187
UNSAT
TT=102.51

UNSAT
TT=642.271

UNSAT
TT=18.408

UNSAT
TT=261.484

CHECKS=120986216
NODES=78339
UNSAT
TT=265.387

CHECKS=120986216
NODES=78339
UNSAT
TT=1409.16

UNSAT
TT=1516.1

UNSAT
TT=37.304

UNSAT
TT=27.198

UNSAT
TT=4.288

CHECKS=133938000
NODES=44847
UNSAT
TT=4.231

CHECKS=133938000
NODES=44847
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-33_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.061

UNSAT
TT=16.848

CHECKS=52326554
NODES=75557
UNSAT
TT=14.054

CHECKS=44393897
NODES=63450
UNSAT
TT=13.228

UNSAT
TT=14.745

UNSAT
TT=13.805

UNSAT
TT=94.474

NODES=72456
UNSAT
TT=43.43

NODES=47434
UNSAT
TT=40.191

CHECKS=87843
NODES=46023
UNSAT
TT=38.063

UNSAT
TT=245.619

CHECKS=113567110
NODES=71131
UNSAT
TT=272.278

CHECKS=130543859
NODES=81803
UNSAT
TT=1008.23

CHECKS=504529510
NODES=320318
UNSAT
TT=90.521

UNSAT
TT=541.867

UNSAT
TT=15.095

UNSAT
TT=248.133

CHECKS=120547663
NODES=76018
UNSAT
TT=255.85

CHECKS=120547663
NODES=76018
UNSAT
TT=948.977

UNSAT
TT=931.579

UNSAT
TT=26.57

UNSAT
TT=20.951

UNSAT
TT=4.061

CHECKS=129729000
NODES=41935
UNSAT
TT=4.17

CHECKS=129729000
NODES=41935
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-35_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.929

UNSAT
TT=13.516

CHECKS=42058294
NODES=59580
UNSAT
TT=13.058

CHECKS=37651974
NODES=52938
UNSAT
TT=12.724

UNSAT
TT=10.497

UNSAT
TT=10.704

UNSAT
TT=65.382

NODES=49641
UNSAT
TT=37.276

NODES=34951
UNSAT
TT=34.397

CHECKS=88978
NODES=36342
UNSAT
TT=27.329

UNSAT
TT=264.126

CHECKS=119463866
NODES=69660
UNSAT
TT=264.602

CHECKS=118499016
NODES=68969
UNSAT
TT=1102.17

CHECKS=512564990
NODES=309825
UNSAT
TT=61.306

UNSAT
TT=246.177

UNSAT
TT=14.202

UNSAT
TT=261.095

CHECKS=127482250
NODES=76683
UNSAT
TT=271.909

CHECKS=127482250
NODES=76683
UNSAT
TT=680.094

UNSAT
TT=670.615

UNSAT
TT=35.53

UNSAT
TT=18.594

UNSAT
TT=3.929

CHECKS=126236000
NODES=38338
UNSAT
TT=3.889

CHECKS=126236000
NODES=38338
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-37_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.653

UNSAT
TT=15.601

CHECKS=49429947
NODES=70766
UNSAT
TT=15.363

CHECKS=46050328
NODES=66237
UNSAT
TT=11.662

UNSAT
TT=12.867

UNSAT
TT=12.99

UNSAT
TT=95.758

NODES=71157
UNSAT
TT=33.791

NODES=37500
UNSAT
TT=34.571

CHECKS=87504
NODES=40057
UNSAT
TT=26.739

UNSAT
TT=260.723

CHECKS=118036312
NODES=73403
UNSAT
TT=268.771

CHECKS=121156710
NODES=75182
UNSAT
TT=1042.79

CHECKS=499037204
NODES=322235
UNSAT
TT=51.887

UNSAT
TT=239.629

UNSAT
TT=15.181

UNSAT
TT=221.663

CHECKS=106919541
NODES=67965
UNSAT
TT=220.588

CHECKS=106919541
NODES=67965
UNSAT
TT=1126.18

UNSAT
TT=1098.54

UNSAT
TT=21.299

UNSAT
TT=26.177

UNSAT
TT=3.653

CHECKS=114855000
NODES=37649
UNSAT
TT=3.638

CHECKS=114855000
NODES=37649
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-39_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.12

SAT
TT=1.993

CHECKS=3129801
NODES=4908
SAT
TT=10.479

CHECKS=31324011
NODES=47691
SAT
TT=4.381

SAT
TT=3.96

SAT
TT=4.061

SAT
TT=17.464

NODES=13570
SAT
TT=39.346

NODES=38444
SAT
TT=37.845

CHECKS=89308
NODES=42900
SAT
TT=23.082

SAT
TT=246.937

CHECKS=111543827
NODES=71590
SAT
TT=246.946

CHECKS=117517241
NODES=75357
SAT
TT=180.539

CHECKS=90535247
NODES=59693
SAT
TT=4.984

SAT
TT=6.704

SAT
TT=7.816

SAT
TT=69.29

CHECKS=32159491
NODES=20947
SAT
TT=74.43

CHECKS=32159491
NODES=20947
SAT
TT=484.276

SAT
TT=515.953

SAT
TT=24.87

SAT
TT=12.8

SAT
TT=1.12

CHECKS=34192900
NODES=11386
SAT
TT=1.088

CHECKS=34192900
NODES=11386
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-3_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.772

UNSAT
TT=18.057

CHECKS=53559010
NODES=76874
UNSAT
TT=16.325

CHECKS=48891083
NODES=70017
UNSAT
TT=10.731

UNSAT
TT=14.966

UNSAT
TT=15.067

UNSAT
TT=92.465

NODES=77162
UNSAT
TT=38.995

NODES=43252
UNSAT
TT=36.575

CHECKS=87805
NODES=40042
UNSAT
TT=28.307

UNSAT
TT=274.402

CHECKS=129838667
NODES=79258
UNSAT
TT=259.881

CHECKS=118817260
NODES=72598
UNSAT
TT=1043.61

CHECKS=505188367
NODES=318700
UNSAT
TT=80.791

UNSAT
TT=246.753

UNSAT
TT=14.054

UNSAT
TT=256.065

CHECKS=116603426
NODES=72764
UNSAT
TT=259.807

CHECKS=116603426
NODES=72764
UNSAT
TT=832.106

UNSAT
TT=877.963

UNSAT
TT=29.433

UNSAT
TT=25.556

UNSAT
TT=3.772

CHECKS=119856000
NODES=38002
UNSAT
TT=3.771

CHECKS=119856000
NODES=38002
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-41_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.09

SAT
TT=15.839

CHECKS=48721571
NODES=76158
SAT
TT=4.098

CHECKS=9467261
NODES=15311
SAT
TT=0.459

SAT
TT=11.07

SAT
TT=11.683

SAT
TT=12.431

NODES=9941
SAT
TT=11.816

NODES=12861
SAT
TT=51.167

CHECKS=86911
NODES=60740
SAT
TT=17.314

SAT
TT=41.278

CHECKS=18591548
NODES=11185
SAT
TT=32.444

CHECKS=13939623
NODES=8525
SAT
TT=63.881

CHECKS=30760609
NODES=21262
SAT
TT=11.329

SAT
TT=195.168

SAT
TT=0.366

SAT
TT=8.419

CHECKS=3349760
NODES=2555
SAT
TT=8.648

CHECKS=3349760
NODES=2555
SAT
TT=510.104

SAT
TT=509.927

SAT
TT=18.896

SAT
TT=1.396

SAT
TT=0.09

CHECKS=1790540
NODES=735
SAT
TT=0.085

CHECKS=1790540
NODES=735
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-43_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.158

UNSAT
TT=14.065

CHECKS=40967030
NODES=57139
UNSAT
TT=11.813

CHECKS=36876805
NODES=51584
UNSAT
TT=9.214

UNSAT
TT=10.344

UNSAT
TT=10.067

UNSAT
TT=84.181

NODES=68519
UNSAT
TT=30.604

NODES=32879
UNSAT
TT=29.141

CHECKS=87059
NODES=30661
UNSAT
TT=23.907

UNSAT
TT=226.006

CHECKS=110008884
NODES=64714
UNSAT
TT=251.407

CHECKS=121596328
NODES=70881
UNSAT
TT=802.657

CHECKS=393527408
NODES=236905
UNSAT
TT=47.357

UNSAT
TT=214.15

UNSAT
TT=12.351

UNSAT
TT=195.29

CHECKS=92476506
NODES=55798
UNSAT
TT=202.702

CHECKS=92476506
NODES=55798
UNSAT
TT=625.375

UNSAT
TT=633.476

UNSAT
TT=28.05

UNSAT
TT=16.758

UNSAT
TT=3.158

CHECKS=100466000
NODES=30640
UNSAT
TT=3.127

CHECKS=100466000
NODES=30640
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-45_ext.xml
SAT
TT=4.48

SAT
TT=9.145

CHECKS=27022481
NODES=41041
SAT
TT=11.888

CHECKS=34432932
NODES=51927
SAT
TT=13.674

SAT
TT=5.794

SAT
TT=6.159

SAT
TT=82.946

NODES=65050
SAT
TT=35.722

NODES=37630
SAT
TT=30.298

CHECKS=87935
NODES=33151
SAT
TT=32.82

SAT
TT=153.22

CHECKS=75210888
NODES=48590
SAT
TT=168.688

CHECKS=80157313
NODES=51060
SAT
TT=242.591

CHECKS=116684821
NODES=77691
SAT
TT=17.78

SAT
TT=40.5

SAT
TT=17.924

SAT
TT=297.453

CHECKS=134862115
NODES=90685
SAT
TT=281.231

CHECKS=134862115
NODES=90685
SAT
TT=62.183

SAT
TT=62.809

SAT
TT=20.58

SAT
TT=14.823

SAT
TT=4.48

CHECKS=141895000
NODES=48660
SAT
TT=4.484

CHECKS=141895000
NODES=48660
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-47_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.933

UNSAT
TT=16.056

CHECKS=47087819
NODES=67896
UNSAT
TT=14.222

CHECKS=44751461
NODES=64841
UNSAT
TT=11.509

UNSAT
TT=10.198

UNSAT
TT=10.739

UNSAT
TT=89.587

NODES=75003
UNSAT
TT=40.847

NODES=42266
UNSAT
TT=38.579

CHECKS=88733
NODES=41080
UNSAT
TT=38.936

UNSAT
TT=230.934

CHECKS=108489982
NODES=68347
UNSAT
TT=250.776

CHECKS=122993559
NODES=76274
UNSAT
TT=1065.88

CHECKS=493953522
NODES=313138
UNSAT
TT=99.26

UNSAT
TT=342.791

UNSAT
TT=16.937

UNSAT
TT=243.215

CHECKS=117884958
NODES=74207
UNSAT
TT=238.911

CHECKS=117884958
NODES=74207
UNSAT
TT=1065.37

UNSAT
TT=1136.74

UNSAT
TT=26.2

UNSAT
TT=22.103

UNSAT
TT=3.933

CHECKS=125565000
NODES=40306
UNSAT
TT=3.955

CHECKS=125565000
NODES=40306
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-49_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.553

UNSAT
TT=18.522

CHECKS=54333846
NODES=76315
UNSAT
TT=16.035

CHECKS=51510094
NODES=72840
UNSAT
TT=14.393

UNSAT
TT=12.553

UNSAT
TT=11.867

UNSAT
TT=96.797

NODES=73275
UNSAT
TT=36.947

NODES=34449
UNSAT
TT=33.817

CHECKS=87778
NODES=35501
UNSAT
TT=31.696

UNSAT
TT=270.107

CHECKS=124099309
NODES=74225
UNSAT
TT=256.927

CHECKS=123013831
NODES=73845
UNSAT
TT=1037.69

CHECKS=516222002
NODES=318552
UNSAT
TT=49.963

UNSAT
TT=340.368

UNSAT
TT=16.706

UNSAT
TT=285.329

CHECKS=136263442
NODES=84576
UNSAT
TT=298.951

CHECKS=136263442
NODES=84576
UNSAT
TT=1154.87

UNSAT
TT=1134.02

UNSAT
TT=26.398

UNSAT
TT=19.323

UNSAT
TT=4.553

CHECKS=142904000
NODES=44475
UNSAT
TT=4.467

CHECKS=142904000
NODES=44475
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-51_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.478

UNSAT
TT=15

CHECKS=46929260
NODES=68109
UNSAT
TT=15.553

CHECKS=49713897
NODES=71645
UNSAT
TT=13.578

UNSAT
TT=14.705

UNSAT
TT=15.515

UNSAT
TT=107.281

NODES=83351
UNSAT
TT=36.326

NODES=39960
UNSAT
TT=39.502

CHECKS=87388
NODES=45399
UNSAT
TT=39.228

UNSAT
TT=239.861

CHECKS=112540896
NODES=71367
UNSAT
TT=250.932

CHECKS=117284606
NODES=74603
UNSAT
TT=1295.79

CHECKS=610811624
NODES=393713
UNSAT
TT=73.842

UNSAT
TT=353.616

UNSAT
TT=18.521

UNSAT
TT=293.258

CHECKS=134212124
NODES=86994
UNSAT
TT=289.809

CHECKS=134212124
NODES=86994
UNSAT
TT=789.437

UNSAT
TT=802.056

UNSAT
TT=30.86

UNSAT
TT=23.295

UNSAT
TT=4.478

CHECKS=140409000
NODES=46881
UNSAT
TT=4.128

CHECKS=140409000
NODES=46881
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-53_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.044

UNSAT
TT=14.006

CHECKS=40042669
NODES=56993
UNSAT
TT=12.976

CHECKS=37935454
NODES=54452
UNSAT
TT=11.902

UNSAT
TT=12.708

UNSAT
TT=12.701

UNSAT
TT=100.524

NODES=80964
UNSAT
TT=31.283

NODES=32189
UNSAT
TT=37.162

CHECKS=87567
NODES=40854
UNSAT
TT=40.656

UNSAT
TT=247.756

CHECKS=114359307
NODES=69222
UNSAT
TT=224.954

CHECKS=106529934
NODES=65146
UNSAT
TT=1118.85

CHECKS=513885226
NODES=320048
UNSAT
TT=79.637

UNSAT
TT=265.643

UNSAT
TT=16.887

UNSAT
TT=256.788

CHECKS=122114495
NODES=75095
UNSAT
TT=259.497

CHECKS=122114495
NODES=75095
UNSAT
TT=1019.69

UNSAT
TT=935.176

UNSAT
TT=34.01

UNSAT
TT=21.282

UNSAT
TT=4.044

CHECKS=128563000
NODES=39795
UNSAT
TT=3.975

CHECKS=128563000
NODES=39795
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-55_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.679

UNSAT
TT=19.772

CHECKS=64239231
NODES=93012
UNSAT
TT=18.658

CHECKS=58982436
NODES=85046
UNSAT
TT=11.85

UNSAT
TT=14.543

UNSAT
TT=14.056

UNSAT
TT=109.205

NODES=92172
UNSAT
TT=44.681

NODES=41535
UNSAT
TT=38.773

CHECKS=89147
NODES=44612
UNSAT
TT=43.319

UNSAT
TT=293.624

CHECKS=140026039
NODES=86930
UNSAT
TT=287.277

CHECKS=139536023
NODES=86730
UNSAT
TT=1389.59

CHECKS=629173058
NODES=401891
UNSAT
TT=69.73

UNSAT
TT=319.55

UNSAT
TT=15.252

UNSAT
TT=239.559

CHECKS=114519974
NODES=72787
UNSAT
TT=245.594

CHECKS=114519974
NODES=72787
UNSAT
TT=1303.55

UNSAT
TT=1348.91

UNSAT
TT=36.71

UNSAT
TT=22.905

UNSAT
TT=3.679

CHECKS=122438000
NODES=40232
UNSAT
TT=3.868

CHECKS=122438000
NODES=40232
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-57_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=2.628

UNSAT
TT=12.183

CHECKS=36617876
NODES=49533
UNSAT
TT=8.963

CHECKS=27067175
NODES=37003
UNSAT
TT=7.231

UNSAT
TT=8.35

UNSAT
TT=8.049

UNSAT
TT=60.841

NODES=48785
UNSAT
TT=23.967

NODES=24799
UNSAT
TT=24.486

CHECKS=87873
NODES=27567
UNSAT
TT=28.892

UNSAT
TT=196.058

CHECKS=88924520
NODES=49685
UNSAT
TT=184.307

CHECKS=88590197
NODES=49216
UNSAT
TT=803.294

CHECKS=395598715
NODES=226819
UNSAT
TT=34.227

UNSAT
TT=168.619

UNSAT
TT=9.49

UNSAT
TT=160.114

CHECKS=78376272
NODES=44440
UNSAT
TT=164.704

CHECKS=78376272
NODES=44440
UNSAT
TT=462.623

UNSAT
TT=477.01

UNSAT
TT=18.77

UNSAT
TT=13.21

UNSAT
TT=2.628

CHECKS=83938600
NODES=23571
UNSAT
TT=2.616

CHECKS=83938600
NODES=23571
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-59_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.322

SAT
TT=8.468

CHECKS=22878648
NODES=33266
SAT
TT=5.216

CHECKS=12995433
NODES=18931
SAT
TT=3.782

SAT
TT=7.92

SAT
TT=8.293

SAT
TT=5.766

NODES=4000
SAT
TT=20.574

NODES=22189
SAT
TT=26.243

CHECKS=87346
NODES=27226
SAT
TT=9.142

SAT
TT=118.267

CHECKS=52935296
NODES=31665
SAT
TT=121.47

CHECKS=55788023
NODES=33159
SAT
TT=26.753

CHECKS=12247518
NODES=7503
SAT
TT=26.542

SAT
TT=18.029

SAT
TT=12.24

SAT
TT=81.106

CHECKS=39152965
NODES=24543
SAT
TT=83.773

CHECKS=39152965
NODES=24543
SAT
TT=51.503

SAT
TT=55.831

SAT
TT=16.73

SAT
TT=5.888

SAT
TT=1.322

CHECKS=40366900
NODES=12766
SAT
TT=1.287

CHECKS=40366900
NODES=12766
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-5_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.326

SAT
TT=1.006

CHECKS=30607
NODES=44
SAT
TT=0.885

CHECKS=8507
NODES=44
SAT
TT=1.086

SAT
TT=2.12

SAT
TT=2.003

SAT
TT=2.381

NODES=1294
SAT
TT=23.784

NODES=21895
SAT
TT=9.091

CHECKS=87720
NODES=9021
SAT
TT=3.449

SAT
TT=43.782

CHECKS=18634895
NODES=10054
SAT
TT=118.033

CHECKS=52380922
NODES=31610
SAT
TT=194.038

CHECKS=97348846
NODES=60544
SAT
TT=9.66

SAT
TT=27.584

SAT
TT=1.881

SAT
TT=20.566

CHECKS=8995275
NODES=5652
SAT
TT=22.584

CHECKS=8995275
NODES=5652
SAT
TT=18.029

SAT
TT=20.03

SAT
TT=13.5

SAT
TT=0.326

SAT
TT=0.334

CHECKS=9534270
NODES=2983
SAT
TT=0.331

CHECKS=9534270
NODES=2983
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-61_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.138

SAT
TT=1.004

CHECKS=136553
NODES=226
SAT
TT=1.001

CHECKS=148496
NODES=276
SAT
TT=6.022

SAT
TT=1.729

SAT
TT=1.613

SAT
TT=0.978

NODES=280
SAT
TT=29.916

NODES=33893
SAT
TT=34.999

CHECKS=87576
NODES=38101
SAT
TT=0.138

SAT
TT=181.172

CHECKS=79741678
NODES=50426
SAT
TT=113.165

CHECKS=50729200
NODES=32085
SAT
TT=355.848

CHECKS=163977260
NODES=107038
SAT
TT=45.503

SAT
TT=9.364

SAT
TT=5.738

SAT
TT=133.066

CHECKS=58626345
NODES=37741
SAT
TT=118.01

CHECKS=58626345
NODES=37741
SAT
TT=9.669

SAT
TT=10.296

SAT
TT=8.52

SAT
TT=3.885

SAT
TT=2.01

CHECKS=63575600
NODES=20535
SAT
TT=2.003

CHECKS=63575600
NODES=20535
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-63_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.779

SAT
TT=4.622

CHECKS=10640088
NODES=16450
SAT
TT=3.403

CHECKS=7974334
NODES=12271
SAT
TT=8.106

SAT
TT=7.523

SAT
TT=7.114

SAT
TT=41.558

NODES=32347
SAT
TT=42.829

NODES=46071
SAT
TT=33.506

CHECKS=88999
NODES=37479
SAT
TT=1.779

SAT
TT=188.985

CHECKS=86075933
NODES=55166
SAT
TT=197.811

CHECKS=88669237
NODES=57343
SAT
TT=337.3

CHECKS=159074722
NODES=105237
SAT
TT=2.632

SAT
TT=314.675

SAT
TT=22.669

SAT
TT=154.806

CHECKS=72617076
NODES=47165
SAT
TT=147.596

CHECKS=72617076
NODES=47165
SAT
TT=33.417

SAT
TT=32.264

SAT
TT=8.98

SAT
TT=13.879

SAT
TT=2.512

CHECKS=77746200
NODES=25735
SAT
TT=2.422

CHECKS=77746200
NODES=25735
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-65_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=5.572

UNSAT
TT=19.502

CHECKS=61884814
NODES=90720
UNSAT
TT=20.091

CHECKS=64839331
NODES=94851
UNSAT
TT=17.429

UNSAT
TT=15.054

UNSAT
TT=15.077

UNSAT
TT=138.938

NODES=112944
UNSAT
TT=58.622

NODES=55274
UNSAT
TT=45.854

CHECKS=88562
NODES=52138
UNSAT
TT=49.629

UNSAT
TT=318.204

CHECKS=147282426
NODES=94092
UNSAT
TT=326.363

CHECKS=148940174
NODES=95652
UNSAT
TT=1302.22

CHECKS=640027323
NODES=414596
UNSAT
TT=119.787

UNSAT
TT=623.636

UNSAT
TT=21.107

UNSAT
TT=329.407

CHECKS=165243468
NODES=106389
UNSAT
TT=336.498

CHECKS=165243468
NODES=106389
? (TO)
TT=1800.51

? (TO)
TT=1800.45

UNSAT
TT=41.976

UNSAT
TT=25.024

UNSAT
TT=5.572

CHECKS=177984000
NODES=58946
UNSAT
TT=5.233

CHECKS=177984000
NODES=58946
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-67_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.429

SAT
TT=0.967

CHECKS=111750
NODES=179
SAT
TT=1.121

CHECKS=520848
NODES=931
SAT
TT=5.338

SAT
TT=0.429

SAT
TT=0.433

SAT
TT=1.142

NODES=518
SAT
TT=12.576

NODES=13757
SAT
TT=14.969

CHECKS=87648
NODES=15499
SAT
TT=2.078

SAT
TT=76.794

CHECKS=36361774
NODES=22196
SAT
TT=46.802

CHECKS=19945750
NODES=11135
SAT
TT=39.092

CHECKS=18518201
NODES=11689
SAT
TT=4.899

SAT
TT=37.28

SAT
TT=3.533

SAT
TT=131.536

CHECKS=58832319
NODES=37776
SAT
TT=139.178

CHECKS=58832319
NODES=37776
SAT
TT=11.52

SAT
TT=10.957

SAT
TT=3.2

SAT
TT=4.004

SAT
TT=1.909

CHECKS=59719600
NODES=19522
SAT
TT=1.91

CHECKS=59719600
NODES=19522
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-69_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.421

UNSAT
TT=16.949

CHECKS=49455817
NODES=70676
UNSAT
TT=18.161

CHECKS=57642070
NODES=83162
UNSAT
TT=13.073

UNSAT
TT=12.594

UNSAT
TT=11.772

UNSAT
TT=98.929

NODES=81675
UNSAT
TT=44.735

NODES=41421
UNSAT
TT=38.499

CHECKS=87707
NODES=44267
UNSAT
TT=36.502

UNSAT
TT=248.909

CHECKS=123180882
NODES=75812
UNSAT
TT=281.105

CHECKS=128996823
NODES=79143
UNSAT
TT=1091.39

CHECKS=517988986
NODES=325114
UNSAT
TT=79.393

UNSAT
TT=382.472

UNSAT
TT=15.095

UNSAT
TT=281.732

CHECKS=135697674
NODES=84499
UNSAT
TT=282.57

CHECKS=135697674
NODES=84499
UNSAT
TT=1331.27

UNSAT
TT=1325.03

UNSAT
TT=40.604

UNSAT
TT=24.967

UNSAT
TT=4.421

CHECKS=140475000
NODES=44887
UNSAT
TT=4.42

CHECKS=140475000
NODES=44887
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-71_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.456

SAT
TT=7.019

CHECKS=18538714
NODES=27155
SAT
TT=6.788

CHECKS=17844142
NODES=26390
SAT
TT=4.496

SAT
TT=8.501

SAT
TT=8.092

SAT
TT=29.709

NODES=23315
SAT
TT=30.49

NODES=30570
SAT
TT=26.886

CHECKS=87804
NODES=29082
SAT
TT=16.457

SAT
TT=119.067

CHECKS=55268469
NODES=33470
SAT
TT=92.11

CHECKS=41316126
NODES=24585
SAT
TT=101.92

CHECKS=48269510
NODES=28946
SAT
TT=34.774

SAT
TT=33.894

SAT
TT=4.005

SAT
TT=94.585

CHECKS=43490391
NODES=27354
SAT
TT=94.151

CHECKS=43490391
NODES=27354
SAT
TT=28.275

SAT
TT=27.982

SAT
TT=12.714

SAT
TT=14.192

SAT
TT=1.456

CHECKS=45746600
NODES=14823
SAT
TT=1.466

CHECKS=45746600
NODES=14823
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-73_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.554

UNSAT
TT=22.151

CHECKS=66378667
NODES=96464
UNSAT
TT=20.744

CHECKS=62444179
NODES=90908
UNSAT
TT=13.845

UNSAT
TT=15.648

UNSAT
TT=15.585

UNSAT
TT=143.863

NODES=109183
UNSAT
TT=56.829

NODES=53657
UNSAT
TT=47.75

CHECKS=88111
NODES=55050
UNSAT
TT=52.723

UNSAT
TT=348.623

CHECKS=159819036
NODES=102601
UNSAT
TT=376.894

CHECKS=171081189
NODES=109365
UNSAT
TT=1363.53

CHECKS=637910528
NODES=419961
UNSAT
TT=78.749

UNSAT
TT=815.802

UNSAT
TT=19.192

UNSAT
TT=288.912

CHECKS=132084743
NODES=87614
UNSAT
TT=282.49

CHECKS=132084743
NODES=87614
? (TO)
TT=1800.17

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

UNSAT
TT=39.85

UNSAT
TT=31.383

UNSAT
TT=4.554

CHECKS=142668000
NODES=48345
UNSAT
TT=4.528

CHECKS=142668000
NODES=48345
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-75_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.68

SAT
TT=1.79

CHECKS=2503459
NODES=3982
SAT
TT=1.197

CHECKS=335184
NODES=599
SAT
TT=2.013

SAT
TT=1.676

SAT
TT=1.687

SAT
TT=29.47

NODES=23466
SAT
TT=11.336

NODES=11809
SAT
TT=14.54

CHECKS=88117
NODES=16106
SAT
TT=5.086

SAT
TT=46.007

CHECKS=19747513
NODES=10900
SAT
TT=67.135

CHECKS=28749582
NODES=16267
SAT
TT=6.812

CHECKS=2843134
NODES=1654
SAT
TT=10.618

SAT
TT=9.979

SAT
TT=2.028

SAT
TT=42.087

CHECKS=18745124
NODES=12137
SAT
TT=39.199

CHECKS=18745124
NODES=12137
SAT
TT=20.406

SAT
TT=19.44

SAT
TT=2.19

SAT
TT=3.74

SAT
TT=0.68

CHECKS=20299700
NODES=6717
SAT
TT=0.673

CHECKS=20299700
NODES=6717
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-77_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.976

SAT
TT=1.021

CHECKS=234543
NODES=394
SAT
TT=0.976

CHECKS=111708
NODES=205
SAT
TT=5.646

SAT
TT=5.709

SAT
TT=5.407

SAT
TT=2.387

NODES=1402
SAT
TT=4.678

NODES=4263
SAT
TT=4.6

CHECKS=85987
NODES=4327
SAT
TT=5.939

SAT
TT=88.755

CHECKS=40153379
NODES=25394
SAT
TT=158.885

CHECKS=72949958
NODES=45670
SAT
TT=38.715

CHECKS=18540719
NODES=12375
SAT
TT=12.733

SAT
TT=41.688

SAT
TT=1.763

SAT
TT=105.282

CHECKS=47775131
NODES=31917
SAT
TT=108.807

CHECKS=47775131
NODES=31917
SAT
TT=5.651

SAT
TT=6.036

SAT
TT=3.25

SAT
TT=1.119

SAT
TT=1.651

CHECKS=51669200
NODES=17645
SAT
TT=1.648

CHECKS=51669200
NODES=17645
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-79_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.159

UNSAT
TT=20.509

CHECKS=62714728
NODES=93104
UNSAT
TT=18.537

CHECKS=59649688
NODES=88099
UNSAT
TT=12.808

UNSAT
TT=15.227

UNSAT
TT=14.331

UNSAT
TT=96.905

NODES=84189
UNSAT
TT=44.089

NODES=45565
UNSAT
TT=43.207

CHECKS=87435
NODES=47351
UNSAT
TT=41.816

UNSAT
TT=269.391

CHECKS=122501594
NODES=79048
UNSAT
TT=279.871

CHECKS=127105628
NODES=81709
UNSAT
TT=1366.57

CHECKS=630492197
NODES=415063
UNSAT
TT=96.24

UNSAT
TT=428.038

UNSAT
TT=16.077

UNSAT
TT=277.353

CHECKS=125209595
NODES=82715
UNSAT
TT=257.368

CHECKS=125209595
NODES=82715
UNSAT
TT=1338.17

UNSAT
TT=1381.14

UNSAT
TT=29.088

UNSAT
TT=24.176

UNSAT
TT=4.159

CHECKS=129102000
NODES=43346
UNSAT
TT=4.066

CHECKS=129102000
NODES=43346
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-7_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.989

SAT
TT=1.005

CHECKS=143303
NODES=225
SAT
TT=1.055

CHECKS=158982
NODES=295
SAT
TT=2.258

SAT
TT=9.214

SAT
TT=9.428

SAT
TT=1.982

NODES=961
SAT
TT=24.745

NODES=25409
SAT
TT=22.071

CHECKS=87662
NODES=24482
SAT
TT=5.929

SAT
TT=112.529

CHECKS=49290625
NODES=28983
SAT
TT=91.779

CHECKS=40329746
NODES=24066
SAT
TT=84.464

CHECKS=42362893
NODES=25602
SAT
TT=16.476

SAT
TT=22.87

SAT
TT=9.61

SAT
TT=66.203

CHECKS=29338666
NODES=18098
SAT
TT=66.402

CHECKS=29338666
NODES=18098
SAT
TT=34.997

SAT
TT=37.784

SAT
TT=10.384

SAT
TT=5.826

SAT
TT=0.989

CHECKS=32646900
NODES=10430
SAT
TT=1.043

CHECKS=32646900
NODES=10430
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
tightness/tightness0.1/
rand-2-40-8-753-100-9_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.172

UNSAT
TT=14.978

CHECKS=43032439
NODES=61962
UNSAT
TT=16.489

CHECKS=49561999
NODES=71499
UNSAT
TT=14.378

UNSAT
TT=11.217

UNSAT
TT=11.842

UNSAT
TT=75.004

NODES=62914
UNSAT
TT=31.345

NODES=32153
UNSAT
TT=28.394

CHECKS=87381
NODES=31734
UNSAT
TT=31.473

UNSAT
TT=291.356

CHECKS=132119131
NODES=80579
UNSAT
TT=262.091

CHECKS=120966417
NODES=74118
UNSAT
TT=1046.39

CHECKS=506238953
NODES=313856
UNSAT
TT=68.895

UNSAT
TT=235.735

UNSAT
TT=12.816

UNSAT
TT=267.083

CHECKS=124387458
NODES=78832
UNSAT
TT=255.134

CHECKS=124387458
NODES=78832
UNSAT
TT=622.556

UNSAT
TT=596.026

UNSAT
TT=24.32

UNSAT
TT=21.547

UNSAT
TT=4.172

CHECKS=129946000
NODES=41798
UNSAT
TT=4.069

CHECKS=129946000
NODES=41798
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-11_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.883

UNSAT
TT=18.724

CHECKS=85002721
NODES=94340
UNSAT
TT=20.029

CHECKS=90492051
NODES=100119
UNSAT
TT=13.642

UNSAT
TT=11.346

UNSAT
TT=12.057

UNSAT
TT=96.411

NODES=124449
UNSAT
TT=47.578

NODES=64081
UNSAT
TT=44.713

CHECKS=82256
NODES=63573
UNSAT
TT=93.629

UNSAT
TT=314.948

CHECKS=152306784
NODES=106322
UNSAT
TT=317.311

CHECKS=150747281
NODES=105189
UNSAT
TT=1531.94

CHECKS=722846137
NODES=497110
UNSAT
TT=163.272

UNSAT
TT=555.635

UNSAT
TT=18.119

UNSAT
TT=275.54

CHECKS=140106507
NODES=98201
UNSAT
TT=271.735

CHECKS=140106507
NODES=98201
UNSAT
TT=1457.94

UNSAT
TT=1414.66

UNSAT
TT=61.13

UNSAT
TT=27.308

UNSAT
TT=4.883

CHECKS=150237000
NODES=47887
UNSAT
TT=4.879

CHECKS=150237000
NODES=47887
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-13_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=5.857

UNSAT
TT=26.381

CHECKS=118299738
NODES=139620
UNSAT
TT=21.595

CHECKS=95688881
NODES=114625
UNSAT
TT=23.619

UNSAT
TT=14.574

UNSAT
TT=14.271

UNSAT
TT=128.895

NODES=165248
UNSAT
TT=61.508

NODES=83763
UNSAT
TT=54.509

CHECKS=80966
NODES=82779
UNSAT
TT=165.871

UNSAT
TT=438.926

CHECKS=209318830
NODES=155741
UNSAT
TT=358.122

CHECKS=177687747
NODES=133138
? (TO)
TT=1800.04

UNSAT
TT=402.157

UNSAT
TT=657.051

UNSAT
TT=22.436

UNSAT
TT=377.656

CHECKS=190920001
NODES=141398
UNSAT
TT=373.31

CHECKS=190920001
NODES=141398
UNSAT
TT=1584.1

UNSAT
TT=1647.8

UNSAT
TT=77.74

UNSAT
TT=38.425

UNSAT
TT=5.857

CHECKS=177731000
NODES=61668
UNSAT
TT=5.804

CHECKS=177731000
NODES=61668
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-15_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.78

SAT
TT=2.227

CHECKS=5558368
NODES=6930
SAT
TT=8.348

CHECKS=36192020
NODES=44785
SAT
TT=5.966

SAT
TT=9.909

SAT
TT=10.278

SAT
TT=16.986

NODES=21430
SAT
TT=56.733

NODES=83856
SAT
TT=56.171

CHECKS=82630
NODES=84982
SAT
TT=113.545

SAT
TT=145.908

CHECKS=68785901
NODES=49607
SAT
TT=134.471

CHECKS=62759925
NODES=45228
SAT
TT=288.27

CHECKS=141332705
NODES=102657
SAT
TT=6.154

SAT
TT=779.164

SAT
TT=26.614

SAT
TT=110.669

CHECKS=55688989
NODES=40984
SAT
TT=110.247

CHECKS=55688989
NODES=40984
SAT
TT=955.296

SAT
TT=974.468

SAT
TT=78.488

SAT
TT=34.523

SAT
TT=1.78

CHECKS=52887200
NODES=17929
SAT
TT=1.762

CHECKS=52887200
NODES=17929
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-17_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.433

SAT
TT=2.995

CHECKS=9442209
NODES=11503
SAT
TT=12.259

CHECKS=57025230
NODES=67784
SAT
TT=0.433

SAT
TT=3.775

SAT
TT=4.018

SAT
TT=43.47

NODES=59645
SAT
TT=11.392

NODES=15375
SAT
TT=10.89

CHECKS=81288
NODES=15273
SAT
TT=112.419

SAT
TT=42.884

CHECKS=21404670
NODES=15450
SAT
TT=23.315

CHECKS=11049274
NODES=7553
SAT
TT=844.186

CHECKS=413391507
NODES=296153
SAT
TT=65.359

SAT
TT=185.946

SAT
TT=0.73

SAT
TT=8.941

CHECKS=4592674
NODES=3414
SAT
TT=8.924

CHECKS=4592674
NODES=3414
SAT
TT=93.193

SAT
TT=96.432

SAT
TT=10.49

SAT
TT=27.433

SAT
TT=0.591

CHECKS=16897800
NODES=5764
SAT
TT=0.585

CHECKS=16897800
NODES=5764
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-19_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.355

UNSAT
TT=15.42

CHECKS=74856158
NODES=78955
UNSAT
TT=15.757

CHECKS=71066726
NODES=75176
UNSAT
TT=8.478

UNSAT
TT=9.961

UNSAT
TT=9.729

UNSAT
TT=62.357

NODES=84183
UNSAT
TT=32.071

NODES=43085
UNSAT
TT=32.265

CHECKS=81961
NODES=43583
UNSAT
TT=81.04

UNSAT
TT=268.454

CHECKS=126609746
NODES=82007
UNSAT
TT=258.993

CHECKS=122844273
NODES=80085
UNSAT
TT=1211.55

CHECKS=589162317
NODES=384065
UNSAT
TT=125.641

UNSAT
TT=346.71

UNSAT
TT=13.281

UNSAT
TT=216.31

CHECKS=104251866
NODES=69497
UNSAT
TT=217.862

CHECKS=104251866
NODES=69497
UNSAT
TT=908.828

UNSAT
TT=936.231

UNSAT
TT=50.092

UNSAT
TT=16.406

UNSAT
TT=3.355

CHECKS=104449000
NODES=30848
UNSAT
TT=3.381

CHECKS=104449000
NODES=30848
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-1_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.837

UNSAT
TT=15.312

CHECKS=67055664
NODES=73735
UNSAT
TT=13.831

CHECKS=61283040
NODES=67840
UNSAT
TT=10.86

UNSAT
TT=11.036

UNSAT
TT=11.16

UNSAT
TT=64.948

NODES=79221
UNSAT
TT=31.417

NODES=43148
UNSAT
TT=32.523

CHECKS=80515
NODES=43733
UNSAT
TT=73.916

UNSAT
TT=208.232

CHECKS=107955859
NODES=71780
UNSAT
TT=229.248

CHECKS=108079234
NODES=71904
UNSAT
TT=1193.6

CHECKS=586385485
NODES=382435
UNSAT
TT=101.232

UNSAT
TT=230.06

UNSAT
TT=15.391

UNSAT
TT=230.443

CHECKS=116494192
NODES=76829
UNSAT
TT=243.746

CHECKS=116494192
NODES=76829
UNSAT
TT=596.907

UNSAT
TT=569.828

UNSAT
TT=35.479

UNSAT
TT=23.523

UNSAT
TT=3.837

CHECKS=120192000
NODES=35364
UNSAT
TT=3.868

CHECKS=120192000
NODES=35364
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-21_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.386

SAT
TT=4.299

CHECKS=15883831
NODES=19970
SAT
TT=4.548

CHECKS=15696716
NODES=20109
SAT
TT=1.441

SAT
TT=2.135

SAT
TT=2.278

SAT
TT=14.066

NODES=17862
SAT
TT=31.493

NODES=46088
SAT
TT=33.247

CHECKS=81232
NODES=50012
SAT
TT=0.386

SAT
TT=219.509

CHECKS=103435152
NODES=80144
SAT
TT=208.897

CHECKS=97484901
NODES=76562
SAT
TT=698.897

CHECKS=356722734
NODES=272847
SAT
TT=62.707

SAT
TT=632.374

SAT
TT=0.87

SAT
TT=29.816

CHECKS=13953083
NODES=11205
SAT
TT=29.635

CHECKS=13953083
NODES=11205
SAT
TT=490.991

SAT
TT=487.752

SAT
TT=2.733

SAT
TT=1.808

SAT
TT=0.528

CHECKS=14865800
NODES=5348
SAT
TT=0.525

CHECKS=14865800
NODES=5348
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-23_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.391

SAT
TT=3.397

CHECKS=10868740
NODES=13347
SAT
TT=1.337

CHECKS=1480419
NODES=1892
SAT
TT=0.953

SAT
TT=3.211

SAT
TT=3.413

SAT
TT=10.501

NODES=13052
SAT
TT=22.233

NODES=30796
SAT
TT=45.356

CHECKS=81017
NODES=66851
SAT
TT=13.904

SAT
TT=43.6

CHECKS=21171401
NODES=16344
SAT
TT=59.117

CHECKS=27064644
NODES=20464
SAT
TT=92.854

CHECKS=45835265
NODES=33637
SAT
TT=3.852

SAT
TT=5.668

SAT
TT=1.363

SAT
TT=20.83

CHECKS=9954770
NODES=7927
SAT
TT=20.967

CHECKS=9954770
NODES=7927
SAT
TT=216.737

SAT
TT=212.967

SAT
TT=53.36

SAT
TT=8.239

SAT
TT=0.391

CHECKS=11427300
NODES=4282
SAT
TT=0.415

CHECKS=11427300
NODES=4282
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-25_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=5.076

UNSAT
TT=22.048

CHECKS=98139088
NODES=111832
UNSAT
TT=23.991

CHECKS=116552605
NODES=132635
UNSAT
TT=14.653

UNSAT
TT=11.931

UNSAT
TT=11.899

UNSAT
TT=105.121

NODES=130479
UNSAT
TT=48.489

NODES=69213
UNSAT
TT=53.755

CHECKS=81068
NODES=73314
UNSAT
TT=141.615

UNSAT
TT=327.166

CHECKS=169594711
NODES=120606
UNSAT
TT=386.094

CHECKS=180696611
NODES=127464
UNSAT
TT=1711.29

CHECKS=914865504
NODES=640080
UNSAT
TT=170.286

UNSAT
TT=656.156

UNSAT
TT=21.541

UNSAT
TT=349.038

CHECKS=165213616
NODES=118191
UNSAT
TT=333.405

CHECKS=165213616
NODES=118191
UNSAT
TT=1753.78

UNSAT
TT=1685.57

UNSAT
TT=79.1

UNSAT
TT=31.44

UNSAT
TT=5.076

CHECKS=163380000
NODES=52293
UNSAT
TT=5.306

CHECKS=163380000
NODES=52293
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-27_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.886

SAT
TT=1.518

CHECKS=2468984
NODES=2907
SAT
TT=0.888

CHECKS=197786
NODES=269
SAT
TT=4.792

SAT
TT=1.687

SAT
TT=1.703

SAT
TT=2.023

NODES=1856
SAT
TT=2.906

NODES=2981
SAT
TT=8.015

CHECKS=80941
NODES=9872
SAT
TT=11.27

SAT
TT=78.356

CHECKS=38147700
NODES=25063
SAT
TT=82.116

CHECKS=38142616
NODES=25082
SAT
TT=71.954

CHECKS=35076245
NODES=23223
SAT
TT=15.569

SAT
TT=16.92

SAT
TT=6.73

SAT
TT=92.188

CHECKS=42814146
NODES=30235
SAT
TT=85.246

CHECKS=42814146
NODES=30235
SAT
TT=23.733

SAT
TT=22.094

SAT
TT=2.38

SAT
TT=0.886

SAT
TT=1.034

CHECKS=30888100
NODES=9332
SAT
TT=1.034

CHECKS=30888100
NODES=9332
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-29_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=6.293

UNSAT
TT=25.847

CHECKS=116912029
NODES=136384
UNSAT
TT=25.532

CHECKS=122949712
NODES=142602
UNSAT
TT=17.836

UNSAT
TT=13.616

UNSAT
TT=12.805

UNSAT
TT=145.293

NODES=186727
UNSAT
TT=55.86

NODES=80779
UNSAT
TT=55.677

CHECKS=81149
NODES=82616
UNSAT
TT=157.403

UNSAT
TT=402.302

CHECKS=209983675
NODES=148949
UNSAT
TT=391.933

CHECKS=201398853
NODES=144891
? (TO)
TT=1800.12

UNSAT
TT=195.403

UNSAT
TT=695.57

UNSAT
TT=22.844

UNSAT
TT=414.756

CHECKS=197148766
NODES=142828
UNSAT
TT=399.145

CHECKS=197148766
NODES=142828
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.13

UNSAT
TT=84.821

UNSAT
TT=31.651

UNSAT
TT=6.293

CHECKS=190138000
NODES=64330
UNSAT
TT=6.209

CHECKS=190138000
NODES=64330
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-31_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.594

SAT
TT=9.548

CHECKS=38958195
NODES=48559
SAT
TT=2.497

CHECKS=6634443
NODES=8612
SAT
TT=1.594

SAT
TT=7.973

SAT
TT=8.545

SAT
TT=18.438

NODES=23690
SAT
TT=21.602

NODES=28944
SAT
TT=31.015

CHECKS=80946
NODES=42649
SAT
TT=24.469

SAT
TT=68.794

CHECKS=35291044
NODES=27185
SAT
TT=79.729

CHECKS=39122266
NODES=29481
SAT
TT=79.573

CHECKS=39097007
NODES=28892
SAT
TT=17.281

SAT
TT=28.483

SAT
TT=7.741

SAT
TT=36.939

CHECKS=17165586
NODES=12976
SAT
TT=37.317

CHECKS=17165586
NODES=12976
SAT
TT=248.898

SAT
TT=238.748

SAT
TT=78.35

SAT
TT=12.076

SAT
TT=1.944

CHECKS=57649100
NODES=20925
SAT
TT=1.945

CHECKS=57649100
NODES=20925
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-33_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.182

SAT
TT=1.182

CHECKS=958727
NODES=1281
SAT
TT=1.718

CHECKS=3759819
NODES=4644
SAT
TT=3.468

SAT
TT=3.098

SAT
TT=3.08

SAT
TT=32.04

NODES=40769
SAT
TT=25.454

NODES=36753
SAT
TT=22.136

CHECKS=80935
NODES=30902
SAT
TT=127.567

SAT
TT=82.463

CHECKS=38828328
NODES=27941
SAT
TT=108.425

CHECKS=48639430
NODES=37262
SAT
TT=151.639

CHECKS=75678803
NODES=56666
SAT
TT=51.132

SAT
TT=181.879

SAT
TT=4.07

SAT
TT=74.73

CHECKS=35124937
NODES=28007
SAT
TT=75.593

CHECKS=35124937
NODES=28007
? (TO)
TT=1800.21

? (TO)
TT=1800.09

SAT
TT=34.315

SAT
TT=8.384

SAT
TT=1.22

CHECKS=35724200
NODES=12947
SAT
TT=1.136

CHECKS=35724200
NODES=12947
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-35_ext.xml
SAT
TT=1.912

SAT
TT=2.345

CHECKS=5908051
NODES=7496
SAT
TT=1.912

CHECKS=4595157
NODES=5792
SAT
TT=7.181

SAT
TT=5.351

SAT
TT=5.398

SAT
TT=10.632

NODES=14078
SAT
TT=36.957

NODES=57153
SAT
TT=71.238

CHECKS=82451
NODES=104685
SAT
TT=140.308

SAT
TT=432.106

CHECKS=220382994
NODES=166044
SAT
TT=143.765

CHECKS=66209043
NODES=48697
SAT
TT=805.339

CHECKS=380805971
NODES=284159
SAT
TT=327.171

SAT
TT=1002.68

SAT
TT=10.744

SAT
TT=161.28

CHECKS=73688891
NODES=57016
SAT
TT=147.786

CHECKS=73688891
NODES=57016
SAT
TT=90.951

SAT
TT=92.715

SAT
TT=144.04

SAT
TT=23.923

SAT
TT=2.99

CHECKS=89861500
NODES=30672
SAT
TT=2.981

CHECKS=89861500
NODES=30672
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-37_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=6.638

UNSAT
TT=27.826

CHECKS=125183192
NODES=145941
UNSAT
TT=25.436

CHECKS=113011273
NODES=133319
UNSAT
TT=27.667

UNSAT
TT=15.079

UNSAT
TT=15.127

UNSAT
TT=113.282

NODES=154556
UNSAT
TT=67.902

NODES=90956
UNSAT
TT=63.028

CHECKS=80862
NODES=95145
UNSAT
TT=163.277

UNSAT
TT=366.812

CHECKS=180013041
NODES=132399
UNSAT
TT=348.899

CHECKS=176029929
NODES=129896
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

UNSAT
TT=278.981

UNSAT
TT=879.314

UNSAT
TT=24.506

UNSAT
TT=430.846

CHECKS=203634517
NODES=148146
UNSAT
TT=405.774

CHECKS=203634517
NODES=148146
? (TO)
TT=1800.11

? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=76.07

UNSAT
TT=30.712

UNSAT
TT=6.638

CHECKS=204800000
NODES=68718
UNSAT
TT=6.682

CHECKS=204800000
NODES=68718
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-39_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=6.687

UNSAT
TT=29.431

CHECKS=131525064
NODES=153353
UNSAT
TT=28.099

CHECKS=126645932
NODES=147623
UNSAT
TT=19.346

UNSAT
TT=17.432

UNSAT
TT=17.356

UNSAT
TT=147.624

NODES=186882
UNSAT
TT=53.356

NODES=77566
UNSAT
TT=56.391

CHECKS=82004
NODES=82439
UNSAT
TT=177.103

UNSAT
TT=448.095

CHECKS=211895455
NODES=156726
UNSAT
TT=425.736

CHECKS=211308786
NODES=156258
? (TO)
TT=1800.07

UNSAT
TT=286.211

UNSAT
TT=844.687

UNSAT
TT=25.449

UNSAT
TT=412.984

CHECKS=206892825
NODES=153810
UNSAT
TT=426.695

CHECKS=206892825
NODES=153810
? (TO)
TT=1800.09

? (TO)
TT=1800.14

UNSAT
TT=76.933

UNSAT
TT=40.902

UNSAT
TT=6.687

CHECKS=203180000
NODES=68757
UNSAT
TT=6.667

CHECKS=203180000
NODES=68757
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-3_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.378

UNSAT
TT=15.529

CHECKS=73376228
NODES=84279
UNSAT
TT=16.469

CHECKS=72740185
NODES=83423
UNSAT
TT=14.095

UNSAT
TT=10.502

UNSAT
TT=9.86

UNSAT
TT=84.874

NODES=107424
UNSAT
TT=40.544

NODES=61989
UNSAT
TT=44.615

CHECKS=80402
NODES=61176
UNSAT
TT=72.473

UNSAT
TT=283.225

CHECKS=142289183
NODES=101549
UNSAT
TT=274.737

CHECKS=136527556
NODES=96306
UNSAT
TT=1537.25

CHECKS=698976873
NODES=498345
UNSAT
TT=113.37

UNSAT
TT=346.789

UNSAT
TT=17.202

UNSAT
TT=276.813

CHECKS=135781514
NODES=96921
UNSAT
TT=274.236

CHECKS=135781514
NODES=96921
UNSAT
TT=790.827

UNSAT
TT=773.511

UNSAT
TT=46.05

UNSAT
TT=26.078

UNSAT
TT=4.378

CHECKS=133138000
NODES=43297
UNSAT
TT=4.342

CHECKS=133138000
NODES=43297
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-41_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.677

UNSAT
TT=17.886

CHECKS=86051241
NODES=94931
UNSAT
TT=20.992

CHECKS=96555340
NODES=105048
UNSAT
TT=16.453

UNSAT
TT=10.522

UNSAT
TT=10.475

UNSAT
TT=92.142

NODES=128275
UNSAT
TT=42.152

NODES=63369
UNSAT
TT=48.585

CHECKS=81832
NODES=70496
UNSAT
TT=96.367

UNSAT
TT=288.044

CHECKS=150421048
NODES=101017
UNSAT
TT=283.477

CHECKS=144599868
NODES=96569
UNSAT
TT=1549.43

CHECKS=720730847
NODES=489668
UNSAT
TT=112.615

UNSAT
TT=509.704

UNSAT
TT=20.028

UNSAT
TT=283.35

CHECKS=143365376
NODES=97133
UNSAT
TT=287.11

CHECKS=143365376
NODES=97133
UNSAT
TT=1260.9

UNSAT
TT=1315.06

UNSAT
TT=50.47

UNSAT
TT=27.883

UNSAT
TT=4.677

CHECKS=143788000
NODES=44319
UNSAT
TT=4.595

CHECKS=143788000
NODES=44319
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-43_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.817

SAT
TT=6.655

CHECKS=26229040
NODES=30989
SAT
TT=0.817

CHECKS=13463
NODES=44
SAT
TT=4.83

SAT
TT=3.948

SAT
TT=4.005

SAT
TT=0.648

NODES=70
SAT
TT=31.573

NODES=44382
SAT
TT=44.281

CHECKS=81581
NODES=62196
SAT
TT=66.03

SAT
TT=226.424

CHECKS=109670889
NODES=78414
SAT
TT=221.438

CHECKS=105433466
NODES=75745
SAT
TT=953.177

CHECKS=484912187
NODES=347149
SAT
TT=7.187

SAT
TT=115.616

SAT
TT=4.937

SAT
TT=127.762

CHECKS=60931144
NODES=45614
SAT
TT=127.269

CHECKS=60931144
NODES=45614
SAT
TT=11.762

SAT
TT=11.901

SAT
TT=18.7

SAT
TT=5.74

SAT
TT=2.077

CHECKS=62213100
NODES=21913
SAT
TT=2.075

CHECKS=62213100
NODES=21913
Bench nameBest results
on this
instance
Abscon
109 ESAC
Abscon
109 AC
BPrologCSPSolver70a
2006-12-13
buggy_2_5
2007-01-08
buggy_2_5_s
2007-01-08
CSP4J - Combo
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2006-12-19
CSP4J - MAC
2007-01-16
CSPtoSAT+minisat
0.3
Diarmuid-rndi
2006-12-21
Diarmuid-rndi
2007-01-22
Diarmuid-wtdi
2006-12-21
galac
1
galacJ
beta 1
Mistral
2006-12-04
rjw-solver
2006-12-09
rjw-solver
2007-01-21
sat4jCSP
1.7 RC BF3
SAT4JCSP-CACHED
1.7 RC BF3
sugar
0.40
Tramontane
2006-12-04
VALCSP
3.0
VALCSP
3.1
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-45_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=3.46

UNSAT
TT=13.432

CHECKS=64342223
NODES=68681
UNSAT
TT=14.374

CHECKS=63094242
NODES=67875
UNSAT
TT=12.526

UNSAT
TT=8.521

UNSAT
TT=8.241

UNSAT
TT=66.188

NODES=82874
UNSAT
TT=31.1

NODES=42706
UNSAT
TT=33.257

CHECKS=81958
NODES=46354
UNSAT
TT=95.317

UNSAT
TT=255.809

CHECKS=120851990
NODES=79036
UNSAT
TT=242.157

CHECKS=118587487
NODES=77355
UNSAT
TT=1162.72

CHECKS=570590246
NODES=374687
UNSAT
TT=83.083

UNSAT
TT=329.422

UNSAT
TT=14.037

UNSAT
TT=221.132

CHECKS=107841718
NODES=72854
UNSAT
TT=229.061

CHECKS=107841718
NODES=72854
UNSAT
TT=921.549

UNSAT
TT=887.599

UNSAT
TT=63.443

UNSAT
TT=19.677

UNSAT
TT=3.46

CHECKS=106392000
NODES=31350
UNSAT
TT=3.388

CHECKS=106392000
NODES=31350
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-47_ext.xml
UNSAT
TT=4.628

UNSAT
TT=19.717

CHECKS=87307138
NODES=98768
UNSAT
TT=18.573

CHECKS=87809517
NODES=98693
UNSAT
TT=11.73

UNSAT
TT=10.458

UNSAT
TT=10.466

UNSAT
TT=95.62

NODES=120391
UNSAT
TT=42.956

NODES=61134
UNSAT
TT=38.716

CHECKS=82796
NODES=57269
UNSAT
TT=79.915

UNSAT
TT=291.111

CHECKS=150669110
NODES=103245
UNSAT
TT=297.874

CHECKS=148898531
NODES=101902
UNSAT
TT=1438.03

CHECKS=709361143
NODES=491275
UNSAT
TT=158.406

UNSAT
TT=402.046

UNSAT
TT=22.692

UNSAT
TT=290.889

CHECKS=139532326
NODES=98746
UNSAT
TT=292.53

CHECKS=139532326
NODES=98746
UNSAT
TT=1062.74

UNSAT
TT=1109.7

UNSAT
TT=50.49

UNSAT
TT=26.879

UNSAT
TT=4.628

CHECKS=143346000
NODES=45300
UNSAT
TT=4.62

CHECKS=143346000
NODES=45300
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-49_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.081

SAT
TT=3.137

CHECKS=10842254
NODES=13120
SAT
TT=2.265

CHECKS=5405356
NODES=6741
SAT
TT=0.357

SAT
TT=5.611

SAT
TT=5.67

SAT
TT=2.555

NODES=2655
SAT
TT=43.409

NODES=60930
SAT
TT=42.562

CHECKS=81794
NODES=58876
SAT
TT=119.476

SAT
TT=33.754

CHECKS=14962845
NODES=10188
SAT
TT=47.756

CHECKS=21054615
NODES=15220
SAT
TT=0.366

CHECKS=141003
NODES=123
SAT
TT=78.777

SAT
TT=27.48

SAT
TT=0.081

SAT
TT=0.375

CHECKS=141003
NODES=123
SAT
TT=0.374

CHECKS=141003
NODES=123
SAT
TT=22.946

SAT
TT=23.645

SAT
TT=6.959

SAT
TT=3.365

SAT
TT=0.503

CHECKS=14113800
NODES=5103
SAT
TT=0.509

CHECKS=14113800
NODES=5103
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-51_ext.xml
SAT
TT=2.22

SAT
TT=3.447

CHECKS=11963223
NODES=13896
SAT
TT=2.22

CHECKS=6232929
NODES=7239
SAT
TT=9.24

SAT
TT=6.391

SAT
TT=6.326

SAT
TT=11.357

NODES=13657
SAT
TT=28.055

NODES=42264
SAT
TT=7.415

CHECKS=80555
NODES=9235
SAT
TT=121.136

SAT
TT=286.387

CHECKS=145358175
NODES=99992
SAT
TT=290.311

CHECKS=146073437
NODES=101203
SAT
TT=333.263

CHECKS=176529161
NODES=119410
SAT
TT=23.01

SAT
TT=380.221

SAT
TT=4.082

SAT
TT=210.074

CHECKS=99975075
NODES=69175
SAT
TT=207.831

CHECKS=99975075
NODES=69175
SAT
TT=1165.68

SAT
TT=1160.26

SAT
TT=21.643

SAT
TT=11.934

SAT
TT=3.285

CHECKS=101245000
NODES=31050
SAT
TT=3.289

CHECKS=101245000
NODES=31050
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-53_ext.xml
SAT
TT=4.567

SAT
TT=5.109

CHECKS=18525061
NODES=22656
SAT
TT=7.565

CHECKS=31233335
NODES=38360
SAT
TT=14.276

SAT
TT=13.487

SAT
TT=12.676

SAT
TT=17.462

NODES=21928
SAT
TT=51.821

NODES=80282
SAT
TT=41.112

CHECKS=81764
NODES=60303
SAT
TT=81.21

SAT
TT=315.667

CHECKS=162503426
NODES=121289
SAT
TT=106.102

CHECKS=48657958
NODES=37356
SAT
TT=988.11

CHECKS=464504444
NODES=347235
SAT
TT=164.193

SAT
TT=486.797

SAT
TT=19.787

SAT
TT=306.954

CHECKS=146683287
NODES=109974
SAT
TT=286.357

CHECKS=146683287
NODES=109974
SAT
TT=14.067

SAT
TT=13.975

SAT
TT=21.023

SAT
TT=19.956

SAT
TT=4.567

CHECKS=138156000
NODES=48102
SAT
TT=4.534

CHECKS=138156000
NODES=48102
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-55_ext.xml
SAT
TT=3.223

SAT
TT=8.856

CHECKS=40107791
NODES=44888
SAT
TT=9.973

CHECKS=45310853
NODES=50563
SAT
TT=9.04

SAT
TT=6.018

SAT
TT=5.685

SAT
TT=31.985

NODES=39909
SAT
TT=22.673

NODES=28648
SAT
TT=23.179

CHECKS=80976
NODES=31130
SAT
TT=73.557

SAT
TT=209.954

CHECKS=102492280
NODES=67505
SAT
TT=217.876

CHECKS=102815320
NODES=68162
SAT
TT=2.928

CHECKS=1527755
NODES=931
SAT
TT=37.576

SAT
TT=97.17

SAT
TT=10.28

SAT
TT=200.777

CHECKS=96092043
NODES=64069
SAT
TT=202.772

CHECKS=96092043
NODES=64069
SAT
TT=83.699

SAT
TT=80.229

SAT
TT=6.02

SAT
TT=15.346

SAT
TT=3.223

CHECKS=98006800
NODES=29468
SAT
TT=3.16

CHECKS=98006800
NODES=29468
tightness/tightness0.2/
rand-2-40-11-414-200-57_ext.xml
SAT
TT=0.449

SAT
TT=18.615

CHECKS=83206082
NODES=100428
SAT
TT=15.654

CHECKS=71992196
NODES=85757
SAT
TT=1.094

SAT
TT=4.084

SAT
TT=3.826

SAT
TT=59.044

NODES=82262
SAT
TT=69.121

NODES=104588
SAT
TT=17.026

CHECKS=80879
NODES=23230
SAT
TT=11.717

SAT
TT=300.724

CHECKS=146075396
NODES=111556
SAT
TT=287.56

CHECKS=1420400